Free Essay

The Wisdom Paradox

In: Psychology

Submitted By blaine
Words 3619
Pages 15
“The Wisdom Paradox” (Goldberg, 2005) is a fascinating book about the biology of cognitive wisdom, including its unique costs and benefits. This book provides a thorough explanation of how people in later stages of life successfully undertake major cognitive tasks, as well as how this aptitude can be maximized. With vigorous and life-long mental activity in novel tasks learning new information, an aging person can gain wisdom and minimize clinical brain injury.
Wisdom has intellectual, practical, moral, and spiritual facets. It can be defined as extensive pattern recognition of new information or situations as accurately being in some way similar to familiar information or situations, thus leading to successful problem-solving and reasoning abilities. There are many types of wisdom, including genetic, phylum wisdom, species or cultural wisdom, group wisdom, and individual wisdom. The wisdom of the phylum, which is contained in the amygdala, includes genetically-programmed, innate fears and survival mechanisms that have existed in all species for millions of years through evolution. This type of wisdom uses sensory and motor regions of the cortex, as well as subcortical regions of the brain.
Cultural wisdom is expressed as language and other symbolic systems passed down through the generations for thousands of years. Language is made up of a self-organizing, complex neural network widely spread throughout various regions of the cortex that are not pre-wired. Group wisdom includes certain remarkable talents or expertise shared by a group of people, which also come from self-organization of the association areas of the cortex. Lastly, individual wisdom is expressed by a person’s unique cognitive templates and pattern recognition devices that also are not hardwired in the brain. This type of wisdom is the main topic of this book.
There are three main stages of brain development. The first stage includes the learning of basic information and skills, as well as the forming of one’s identity. During this stage, many different neural processes are taking place, including the development, migration, and interconnections of neurons, as well as the myelination of axons. The second, more mature stage of brain development is distinguished by a more stable brain with developed templates from learning a great deal of new information that is now familiar. In this stage, individuals can contribute their knowledge and skills to the world with less current need for learning new information. People who are cognitively successful in this stage are likely talented or even genius in specific domains from gaining an abundance of knowledge regarding that domain.
The final stage of aging comes with at least some deterioration and reduction in brain tissue with less neuronal connectivity, myelination, and blood and oxygen supply. This is particularly the case in the right hemisphere, where damage occurs earlier on with greater atrophy. Subsequently, older individuals have decreased senses, processing speed, working memory, mental inhibition and flexibility. Selective and divided attention, as well as semantic and episodic memory, are also weakened with age. Neuroerosion and dementia develop gradually over these later years, and the brain regions that developed last are also the first to atrophy. Thus, the association areas of the cortex and prefrontal cortex are remarkably vulnerable to deterioration and dementia. The hippocampi are also susceptible to Alzheimer’s dementia with age. Despite all of these losses, for some people who have had a lifetime of learning new information, mental activity may continue to be successful in this stage. Aging comes with the privileged opportunity for competence and wisdom, which allow for incredibly successful cognition.
There are important cerebral hemispheric differences in the mammalian brain that have existed for millions of years. Although some left-handed people have an inverse hemispheric differentiation, the right hemisphere typically engages in more integrative functions making long-distance neural connections, while the left hemisphere consists of more local connections. While the right hemisphere is used for problem-solving in novel, unfamiliar situations, the left hemisphere is implicated in pattern recognition of familiar verbal and non-verbal information using preexisting cognitive templates. Thus, throughout the lifespan, information that was once dealt with in the right hemisphere transfers to the left hemisphere after it is learned and becomes familiar to the person.
Younger people rely on their problem-solving abilities to learn and understand new things, relying more on the right hemisphere. As individuals age and gain more experiences, they acquire more and more cognitive templates, or interconnected constellations of neurons, relying more and more on the left hemisphere. These templates have been shown to be the most valuable cognitive machinery, allowing people to continue to be cognitively proficient in new and familiar situations even in the face of brain corrosion or dementia, possibly for years. Thus, the more new information that a person learns and encodes, the more that cognitive templates are able to be at his/her disposal to recognize, understand, and solve or deal with familiar and new situations and problems. Expertise, competence, and most notably wisdom are all attained through a significantly large amount of cognitive templates and extensive pattern recognition devices. They are the rewards of aging.
The other main distinction between the two cerebral hemispheres, particularly the amygdala and prefrontal cortex, is emotion. The right hemisphere is more involved in negative emotions, and the left hemisphere is implicated in positive emotions. This difference has been supported through many different neuropsychological studies. Moreover, this hemispheric differentiation is strongly interrelated with the cognition hemispheric differences. That is, being familiar with something and recognizing it is useful and good to know is highly associated with positive emotions. On the other hand, being unfamiliar with something and not knowing how to deal with it is significantly correlated with negative emotions. As people age, the emotional balance shifts to favor more positive emotions and peacefulness, which is consistent with the fact that the left hemisphere is more active in older individuals.
The frontal lobes of the brain, particularly the prefrontal cortex, have important roles in individual wisdom. Like the right hemisphere, they are involved in novel situations and problem-solving. They are responsible for the complex executive functioning tasks of planning, decision-making, and carrying out the decisions. Thus, memories of the analysis and solving of problems are stored here. The prefrontal cortex is also indirectly involved in empathy, ethical and moral decision-making, and impulse control in terms of aiding the understanding of cause or effect of behaviors. Other frontal lobe functions include mental flexibility and gatekeeping of perceived information. With all of these roles, it makes sense that the frontal lobes are of utmost importance in novel problem-solving tasks. Wisdom comes with dedicated use of these prefrontal lobes, particularly the left pattern recognition lobe. Interestingly, the frontal lobes are last to develop in the brain and thus more vulnerable to wear and tear from aging. However, with increased use of these functions through many new experiences in novel problem-solving, more generic problem-solving memories will be lastingly stored. This significantly protects against clinical impairments of such brain damage.
Wisdom and its pattern recognition devices are strongly related to generic memories, or memories for patterns. These memories are processed and then stored in the various areas of the neocortex in which they also are perceived via intricate neural connectivity depending upon their relations to already-learned information. When new memories are formed, there are subsequent changes in the networks of neurons based on the incorporation of the new experience and mental activity.
Vying for limited space in permanent storage in the cortex, memories become long-term when similar experiences and perceptions are reactivated frequently enough. Memories also are more likely to endure when the amygdala becomes involved in their formation because genetics or previous experience has deemed such memories as emotionally meaningful. In such long-term storage, bioelectrical, biochemical, and structural changes in the neural network are lasting and resilient. Thus, these long-term, ingrained memories are highly protected from cognitive deterioration and dementia. This makes sense given that the most recent memories added to the neural network are the first to be lost and the last to return, as the longer-lasting memories are more permanent. Also, memories for facts, especially those that are more specific and personal, are more likely to be lost than generic memories and memories for skills. Generic, abstract patterns/memories are most likely to be reactivated and thus persist and are protected from brain damage. They contain general and essential information about many different experiences, such that even those not yet encountered can be identified.
Two primary generic memories are language and higher-level perception. It is important to note, however, that long-term memory traces take years to develop through a slow, gradual process. The more that a person learns and stores novel information in the cortex, the more likely that at least some of this information is going to overlap with and reinforce pre-existing memories, aiding the long-term storage of these memories. Although the hippocampi are crucial for the initial formation of long-term memories, a dementing process, which will likely damage the hippocampi, may not impact these ingrained long-term memory traces.
Throughout the lifespan, with increased novel experiences and mental exertion, undifferentiated stem cells will develop into new neurons that will travel to and connect with the relevant areas of the cortex. This will in turn protect these regions from clinical impairment of damage and demenia, possibly for many years if these neural networks are extensive enough. If these connections of neurons are strong enough, even activation of a small neural group will keep the entire network perpetually activated. In addition, these brain-exercising individuals are able to do more mentally challenging tasks more efficiently using less brain resources with a less needed blood and oxygen supply. This large cognitive reserve, which will be explained in more detail later on, is very helpful for older individuals because blood supply problems are likely to come with age.
The aging brain is more likely to be protected from deterioration and dementia when intense mental exercise has occurred from a young age, just as the body is more likely to be protected when vigorous physical exercise has occurred from a young age. This is because more numerous and generic pattern-recognizing devices have been able to be formed from the many life-time opportunities to learn new information. Thus, aging is the price paid for accruing wisdom patterns. An important note is that aging does not necessarily lead to wisdom. Wisdom is the priceless reward achieved through strong mental efforts and resulting significant neural connectivity and patterns.
Exercising one’s brain at a later age through rigorous cognitive augmentation exercises also can be remarkably protective. These demanding mental exercises can increase local and far-flung connections and can even supersede any potential damage from aging and dementia. In fact, in order to keep the mental acuity one has worked hard to achieve when younger, it is important to continue facing new mental challenges throughout life even when an older adult. Goldberg describes one such cognitive exercise program, which primarily focuses on an individual’s cognitive weaknesses to strengthen the neural connections in those brain regions, which likely are lacking in extensive neural networks. This program was found to have significant beneficial cognitive effects such as increased memory, focus, attention, and executive functions. These regular cognitive exercises also have therapeutic effects including a sense of empowerment and self-confidence, as well as less anxiety. Artistic activities are also very helpful in enhancing one’s mental power. All older individuals can benefit from such activities, from people living with dementia to gifted people with no current cognitive impairments who want to prevent cognitive decline.
Alzheimer’s dementia, as well as other dementias, has diverse symptom presentations, which can start with memory impairments due to injured hippocampi. It can also start with other impairments in language, spatial abilities, or executive functions from damaged frontal lobes. This variability in cognitive impairments is attributable to different people exercising different parts of their brain more than others. An increase in activity in these specific brain regions by learning new information will thus increase the development of neurons and connections in those areas. These areas that are stimulated more often, as well as their associated functions, are more protected from decay and impairment. This cognitive protection of impairment is especially significant in the prefrontal cortex and the hippocampi, where Alzheimer’s dementia first strikes. The diversity of dementia symptoms demonstrates a complex interaction between biology and behavior.
Another example of the important interaction between biology and behavior is that an even more diverse reaction to Alzheimer’s dementia is having no clinical impairment despite biological signs of the disease. This presentation occurs in those who take part in continual mental exercise of learning new things throughout their lifetime, developing an abundance of neurons and connections. Thus, those who are predisposed to developing a dementia or those in earlier stages of progressive dementia can actually limit or altogether avoid cognitive and behavioral symptoms of damage through what they choose to do with their brains (Goldberg, 2005).
This is the concept of cognitive reserve, in which biological disease of the brain is not related to the actual clinical symptoms of such pathology (Stern, 2002). Again, there is a strong interaction between genetics and the environment and behavior. A person’s cognitive reserve capacity allows for protection of the brain through the efficient usage of appropriate neural networks. This maximizes brain functioning or the compensating usage of other redundant neural networks for compensation of brain damage, optimizing resiliency and mental functioning. This can occur in those with and without brain pathology, such that a person with a high reserve capacity can perform despite brain damage or extreme task difficulty, respectively (Stern, 2002).
Each person has an individualized cognitive reserve capacity based on his/her unique neural processing (Stern et al., 2003). This capacity partly comes from prior mental activities in gaining new knowledge and experiences, including educational and occupational experiences and leisure activities (Le Carret et al., 2003). Cognitive reserve also is based on one’s genetic predisposition to such cognitive domains as intelligence, memory, and language (Lee, 2003), as individuals are pre-wired with a minimum and maximum aptitude for a skill, and their specific brain use and behaviors in that skill dictate their exact ability levels (Goldberg, 2005). Cognitive reserve also depends on one’s prior brain damage (Stern, 2002). Once the capacity of damage is filled, clinical neurological signs will develop. Likewise, with increased damage, there is increased severity of the clinical symptoms (Stern, 2002). Those with larger cognitive reserve capacities will therefore experience less brain impairments (Lee, 2003). With consistent learning of new information and taking on challenging, novel mental tasks, the brain likely will have enough cognitive reserve from abundant neural connections and pattern-recognition devices to excel and be cognitively efficient despite genetic brain deterioration (Goldberg, 2005).
Although there has been much research on the construct of cognitive reserve, additional research is still needed to better understand its functions and relations between the various underlying factors. It would be useful to design a study that sheds more light on cognitive reserve while also validating Goldberg’s (2005) cognitive enhancement program in helping older individuals build a greater cognitive reserve and protect against dementia symptoms. The proposed study would utilize a controlled experimental design. There will be 2,000 participants in the study who are 60 to 89 years of age. Participants in the study will be matched according to their educational level, occupational status, socio-economic-status, gender, and age. A wide range of educational levels from high school non-graduates to post-doctoral graduates, with individuals of all age ranges represented in each educational level will be included. Participants will be assessed for pre-existing organic dementia pathology. Those deemed demented will be excluded from the study. Additionally, those with cognitive symptoms from a history of brain trauma, as well as those who were deaf, blind, or chronically mentally ill, will be excluded from the study due to possible confounding neurological effects or erroneous outcomes from these conditions.
There will be a control and an experimental group in the proposed study. The experimental group will take part in the cognitive exercise program, which will last two years. The control group will not take part in the cognitive enhancement program during the course of the study. However, they will be on a wait-list, in which they are given the opportunity to participate in the program once the study is completed. This cognitive exercise program, which will be completed for one hour three times per week, will entail an individual completing a circuit of multiple validated computer exercises. This cognitive circuit training will strengthen multiple cognitive domains with the help of a personal trainer. The program is described in more detail by Goldberg (2005). The limitation of this program being used in the study is that there is an increased likelihood of participants dropping out (or passing away) when the time commitment is two years of intensive training. However, these older individuals also likely have a strong motivation to complete the training, as it could help protect them from brain impairment.
A neuropsychological battery administered and interpreted by a licensed psychologist, who is blind to the experimental conditions, will be used to measure the continuous dependent variables of cognitive functioning. Memory will be tested with the Wechsler Memory Scale, Third Edition (Wechsler, 1997b). Other cognitive functions, including verbal comprehension and expression, processing speed, perceptual-organizational abilities, and working memory and attention abilities will be assessed using the co-normed Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale, Third Edition (Wechsler, 1997a). These variables were shown to be significantly related to cognitive reserve (Lee, 2003). Interference with social and daily life also will be evaluated based on the Bristol Activities of Daily Living Scale, a reliable, validated measure of activities of daily living intended to assess for dementia (Bucks, Ashworth, Wilcock, & Siegfried, 1996). The limitation of the pre- and post-use of these cognitive tests is the strong possibility of practice effects of these tests. This could limit the sensitivity of noticing the differences in cognitive abilities after potentially greater cognitive reserve or potential clinical manifestations of dementia.
The other main dependent variable will be the neuro-imaging results from a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) procedure to determine the amount of white matter in the brain. White matter decline will be an indicator of brain neurodegeneration and progressive dementia. The dependent cognitive and neuro-imaging measures will be given right before the program begins, as well as two years after the installation of the program. Each individual’s pre-test score will be compared with the post-test score, and the individual’s cognitive test score will be compared to the MRI white matter quantity. Statistical procedures will show whether significant differences exist between the experimental group and the control group in their differential clinical manifestations of dementia. Clinical symptoms of progressing dementia will be defined in this study as memory loss and loss of the other aforementioned cognitive functions from pre- to post-test. Those individuals in the experimental group who had a loss of white matter from pre- to post-test will still have higher scores in the measures of cognitive functions compared to those in the control group with similar white matter loss.
Although many studies have investigated the protective value of earlier life experiences (e.g., see Stern, 2002 for a review; Le Carret et al., 2003), this study would investigate the protective effects of increased cognitive exercises and abilities, which are developed later in life, on the onset of Alzheimer’s dementia symptoms. The primary hypothesis is that those aged individuals with more cognitive training and ability will develop fewer and less severe symptoms of Alzheimer’s dementia. These results will be observed regardless of their actual neurodegerative loss of white matter. This hypothesis infers that those with such experiences of continual brain activation will have more cognitive reserve to protect against the clinical expression of dementia, even if they begin the rigorous mental exertion later in life, as described by Goldberg (2005). If the hypothesis is supported, then the concept of cognitive reserve could be expanded to include influences by later-life experiences. Older individuals could actually seek out novel and challenging cognitive experiences that could increase their reserve capacity. They could find solace in knowing that it is not too late to exercise their brains and be protected from symptoms of dementia. References
Bucks, R. S., Ashworth, D. L., Wilcock, G. K., Siegfried, K. (1996). Assessment of activities of daily living of dementia: Development of the Bristol Activities of Daily Living Scale. Age Ageing, 25, 113-120.
Goldberg, E. (2005). The Wisdom Paradox. Penguin Group: New York.
Le Carret, N., Lafont, S., Letenneur, L., Dartigues, J., Mayo, W., & Fabrigoule, C.
(2003). The effect of education on cognitive performances and its implication for the constitution of the cognitive reserve. Developmental Neuropsychology, 23, 317-337.
Lee, J. H. (2003). Genetic evidence for cognitive reserve: Variations in memory and related cognitive functions. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 25, 594-613.
Stern, Y. (2002). What is cognitive reserve? Theory and research application of the reserve concept. Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 8, 448-460.
Stern, Y., Zarahn, E., Hilton, H. J., Flynn, J., DeLaPaz, R., & Rakitin, B.
(2003). Exploring the neural basis of cognitive reserve. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 25, 691-701.
Wechsler, D. (1997). WAIS-III: Administration and scoring manual. San Antonio, TX:
The Psychological Corporation.
Wechsler, D. (1997). Wechsler memory scale (3rd ed.). San Antonio, TX: The
Psychological Corporation.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Sears Human Resources Strategy Essays

...and disappear, leaving no trace of its ever having been tried. The managerial response to this paradox, based on conventional wisdom, is to try some other technique on the assumption that it is better or more correct than the previous approach. Over the years, the management bromides have included management by objectives, quality circles, total quality management, re-engineering, and now the learning organization and systems thinking. But all these implemented as techniques produce the same results: short term gains followed by long term disillusionment and dissolution. What is going on here? Could conventional management wisdom be wrong? Richard Farson thinks so, and I think he’s right. Farson’s unconventional approach to leadership operates from a different set of assumptions than the traditional rational model. In his view, human behavior and its organizational manifestation are replete with complexities and paradoxes. Because of this, approaches that simplify behavior and offer a series of prescriptive steps to success are doomed to ultimate failure because they do not comprehend the absurdity of the situation. Some Definitions A paradox is a seeming absurdity. The natural human inclination when confronted with a paradox is to seek to resolve it. Farson’s approach is to embrace the absurdity and to seek to understand the truth contained therein. By embracing paradox, one sees the organization and its members for what they are: complex,...

Words: 1883 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Innate Knowledge

...knowledge; implying that knowledge is already in you. I believe this statement is to be true and I argue in favor on Plato’s works in relation to the same thinking. In his work, Plato claims that innate knowledge is not earned but instead implies that knowledge is already in you from birth. Plato argues that all wisdom is recollection; he believed that individuals did not learn new things, but rather recall or recollect old information meaning it was learned prior to mortality. This dialog has a dramatic significance. He considered memory to be a method for breaking down and debating data and thought intellectual humility was vital. It can be seen how Socrates brings down Meno’s confidence when he thought that he knew what virtue was. By carefully questioning, Socrates makes Meno doubt: “Socrates, I used to be told, before I knew you, that you were always doubting yourself and making others doubt.” (Cottingham, Innate Knowledge, page 3)....

Words: 665 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Catch 22 Archetype Essay

...content of Joseph Heller’s Catch 22 coincides highly with the typical characteristics of postmodern literature. Catch 22 contains the anti-hero archetype, unusual narrative techniques such as fragmentation, paradox, and unreliable narrator, as well as strong connections to WWII, which was a precursor to the postmodern era and a common topic of postmodern...

Words: 701 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Nomic

...Nomic is a game created in 1982 by philosopher Peter Suber in which the rules of the game include mechanisms for the players to change those rules, usually beginning through a system of democratic voting.[1] Nomic is a game in which changing the rules is a move. In that respect it differs from almost every other game. The primary activity of Nomic is proposing changes in the rules, debating the wisdom of changing them in that way, voting on the changes, deciding what can and cannot be done afterwards, and doing it. Even this core of the game, of course, can be changed. —Peter Suber, the creator of Nomic, The Paradox of Self-Amendment, Appendix 3, p. 362. Nomic actually refers to a large number of games based on the initial ruleset laid out by Peter Suber in his book The Paradox of Self-Amendment. (The ruleset was actually first published in Douglas Hofstadter's column Metamagical Themas in Scientific American in June 1982.[2] The column discussed Suber's then-upcoming book, which was published some years later.) The game is in some ways modeled on modern government systems, and demonstrates that in any such system where rule-changes are possible, a situation may arise in which the resulting laws are contradictory or insufficient to determine what is in fact legal. Because the game models (and exposes conceptual questions about) a legal system and the problems of legal interpretation, it is named after νόμος (nomos), Greek for "law". While the victory condition in Suber's initial...

Words: 391 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

How to Pee

...How to PEE (literature, writer’s choice, D.O.S, Gatsby.....) Things to consider: Language Device – Alliteration, Simile, Personification, Antithesis, Epigram, Paradox, Juxtaposition, Metaphor, Rhetorical Question, Dramatic Irony, Hyperbole, Onomatopoeia E.g of Antithesis: • "Love is an ideal thing, marriage a real thing." (Goethe) • "Everybody doesn't like something, but nobody doesn't like Sara Lee." (advertising slogan) • "Hillary has soldiered on, damned if she does, damned if she doesn't, like most powerful women, expected to be tough as nails and warm as toast at the same time." (Anna Quindlen, "Say Goodbye to the Virago." Newsweek, June 16, 2003) • "It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair, we had everything before us, we had nothing before us, we were all going direct to Heaven, we were all going direct the other way." (Charles Dickens, A Tale of Two Cities) • "I would rather be ashes than dust! I would rather that my spark should burn out in a brilliant blaze than it should be stifled by dryrot. I would rather be a superb meteor, every atom of me in magnificent glow, than a sleepy and permanent planet. The proper function of man is to live, not to exist. I shall not waste my days in trying to prolong them. I shall use...

Words: 263 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Syllibus

...|[pic] |Course Syllabus | | |College of Social Sciences | | |PSY/220 Version 4 | | |Positive Psychology | Copyright © 2012, 2009. 2007 by University of Phoenix. All rights reserved. Course Description How much control does a person have over his or her thoughts, feelings, and behaviors? What does it mean to be “free”? PSY/220 offers students a contemporary and relevant approach to the study of psychology and the opportunity to learn more about themselves in the process. In this course, students evaluate, understand, and build on their psychological strengths and those of others. Policies Faculty and students/learners will be held responsible for understanding and adhering to all policies contained within the following two documents: • University policies: You must be logged into the student website to view this document. • Instructor policies: This document is posted in the Course Materials forum. University policies are subject to change. Be sure to read the policies...

Words: 2243 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

English Guru

...How Sir Francis Bacon’s essays philosophical? Francis Bacon, (1561-1626) the most influential and resourceful English writer, is a practically wise man. His essays are store-house of wordy wisdom and practicality. We find a touch of reality and practicality in his views towards truth studies, love, friendship etc. Now we are going to discuss his views. Bacon is very much frank in expressing his view towards truth in the essay “Of Truth”. Truth, according to Bacon, lacks the charm of variety which, falsehood has. Truth gives more pleasure only when a lie is added to it.  He believes that, falsehood is a source of temporary enjoyment as it gives the people a strange kind of pleasure. So the essayist says: “…a mixture of a lie doth ever add pleasure” To Bacon, a liar is brave towards god but cowards towards men. A liar does not have courage to tell the truth to the people but he shows courage to tell a lie disobeying god. As the essayist comments:  “For a lie faces God, and shrinks from man.” This is indeed a paradox. It means that a man does not fear god when he tells a lie. Bacon’s attitude towards study is completely practical. He emphasizes the function of studies. To him, reading improves the natural abilities of man. Through reading a person becomes a full man and by discussion he becomes a ready man. Then he needs writing to which makes a learner’s idea clear and accurate. As Bacon says: “Reading maketh a full man; conference a ready man; and writing an exact man...

Words: 677 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Final

...Terrance Fulton Professor Fleshman Introduction to Philosophy – Autumn Quarter 24 October 2015 Midterm Exam Nietzsche, Genealogy of Morals, Second Essay, Aphorism 12, P. 77 Nietzsche’s Genealogy of Morals sought to locate the origin of human morals and thoughts. However, his text is most effective at criticizing the morals and thoughts of humans. Most important is his criticism towards the human thought of origin and utility. Nietzsche’s work seeks to inform that the utility of an object is a consequence, not a cause, of any origin. What came first, the chicken or the egg? This is a question that is debated by everyone from Harvard scholars to biology experts to children in the school yard. The answer is unclear. Nietzsche asks a question that is quite similar: which came first, the eye or sight? The answer may seem obvious, the eye had to be made before sight could have happened. Nietzsche would agree. However, he would not agree that the eye was made for seeing. Instead he would say that the eye existed and then sight evolved from the already present organ. This statement is the basis of Nietzsche’s argument in the Genealogy: origin is not equal to essence. It Nietzsche’s belief that the origin of something is not related to its purpose/utility or vice-versa. This is the point that he is making in the provided passage. The text states, “…the utility of [anything]…means nothing regarding its origin” (p.77). This statement is put into effect through various ways in...

Words: 1636 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Gift Love

...It is my opinion that over the centuries, spiritual and moral thinkers have prescribed ways of living that lead to greater happiness over the course of a lifetime, and the best of them from Socrates to Buddha, from Jesus to Maimonides, have powerfully lived out what they taught. The goal of a good life, they have all agreed, is a deep happiness consistent with simplicity, integrity, and a profound generosity. The great thinkers have never thought of happiness as primarily rooted in the hedonic indulgence of the senses, but rather they have described a sense of well-being and satisfaction that comes from a higher purpose pursued over time. Opinion has differed as to how happy we can expect to become in this mixed up world, and as to what goals and purposes in life really deliver on happiness. I wish to say that I have not always been a happy person, despite my ability to seem to make those around me happy. The key spiritual secret of any happier and healthier life is the deeper kindness that can be captured with the term "Gift-love," a term borrowed from C.S. Lewis. We are all too often obsessed in life with what Lewis termed "Need-love," loving and seeking the things we need, from good food to a decent coat for the winter. We certainly all need and seek to be loved, for if we do not receive love we will not be able to give it away. Yet even when we pursue the things we need, it is often not just for ourselves, but for the nearest and dearest who depend on us. This points...

Words: 1534 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

The Paratox

...Leading Ideas: Revisiting the Abilene Paradox: Is Management of Agreement Still an Issue? | |by Kathryn J. Deiss, ARL Office of Leadership and Management Services Program Manager In 1974, Professor Jerry Harvey of George Washington University developed a parable from a real-life experience to describe the issues surrounding how individuals reach agreement, or, more specifically, believe they have reached agreement. Twenty-five years later the lessons and insights his parable generates are still valid and provocative for organizations and the individuals who work together in those organizations. The Parable of the Abilene Paradox1 Four adults are sitting on a porch in 104-degree heat in the small town of Coleman, Texas, some 53 miles from Abilene. They are engaging in as little motion as possible, drinking lemonade, watching the fan spin lazily, and occasionally playing the odd game of dominoes. The characters are a married couple and the wife’s parents. At some point, the wife’s father suggests they drive to Abilene to eat at a cafeteria there. The son-in-law thinks this is a crazy idea but doesn’t see any need to upset the apple cart, so he goes along with it, as do the two women. They get in their unair-conditioned Buick and drive through a dust storm to Abilene. They eat a mediocre lunch at the cafeteria and return to Coleman exhausted, hot, and generally unhappy with the experience. It is not until they return home that it is revealed that none of them really wanted...

Words: 2054 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Enow

...Common Literary Techniques 1. Imagery: It is the use of figurative language to create visual representations of actions, objects and ideas in our mind in such a way that they appeal to our physical senses. For example: * The room was dark and gloomy. -The words “dark” and “gloomy” are visual images. * The river was roaring in the mountains. – The word “roaring” appeals to our sense of hearing. 2. Simile and Metaphor: Both compare two distinct objects and draws similarity between them. The difference is that Simile uses “as” or “like” and Metaphor does not. For example: * “My love is like a red red rose” (Simile) * He is an old fox very cunning. (Metaphor) 3. Hyperbole: It is deliberate exaggeration of actions and ideas for the sake of emphasis. For example: * Your bag weighs a ton! * I have got a million issues to look after! 4. Personification: It gives a thing, an idea or an animal human qualities. For example: * The flowers are dancing beside the lake. * Have you see my new car? She is a real beauty! 5. Alliteration: It refers to the same consonant sounds in words coming together. For example: * Better butter always makes the batter better. * She sells seashells at seashore. 6. Allegory: It is a literary technique in which an abstract idea is given a form of characters, actions or events. For example: * “Animal Farm”, written by George Orwell, is an example allegory using the actions of animals on a farm to represent the overthrow of the last...

Words: 2032 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Globalization

...one must face throughout the journey of life. The use of this symbolic language allows the major themes of sacrificial love in the face of hardship and death to be easily identified throughout the story. ” A Worn Path” passes far beyond it’s time capsule and remarkable fusion a number of different elements which incorporate myths, legend, and religious undertones which provide the story with a universally understanding of life and the struggles and accomplishments individuals must face on this journey called life (Moberly, 2005). Throughout the short story, titled, “A Worn Path”, the author invokes language symbolism to create a storyline that captures the reader’s imagination and creates a simplistic approach to revealing the true paradox. In the booked titled, “Journey into Literature”, symbol is defined as something that has a literal identity, but also stands for something else-something that is widely understood and has been developed over a long period...

Words: 905 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Leadership

...beginning of time, God has chosen specific men and women to stand up and lead His people – Adam, Noah, Abraham, Joseph, But biblical leadership is more than these – it is influencing others for Christ. It may take many different forms - visible and invisible; loud and quiet; verbal and nonverbal – but ultimately it is using the means and opportunities you have been given to show Christ to those around you, and encourage them to follow Him. Biblical leadership is not for anyone though. It requires wisdom: to know when to speak, and when to let others do the talking; to know the right words to say, and how to say them; and to have the right balance of encouragement and rebuke. It requires courage, for it is not an easy thing to stand up for what is right and godly when others are doing wrong. It requires integrity and righteousness in one’s own life, because for one’s message to have validity, his life must show it. Biblical leadership is somewhat of a paradox. It involves speaking out, living differently, and standing up, yet also humility, meekness, and gentleness. People can very easily see right through a person who sets himself up in arrogance as their leader due to education, sophistication, or charisma, and he loses all credibility and following. But in my opinion, it is those who do not actively seek the role of leader who in fact become leaders, because they lead biblically – with love,...

Words: 419 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Apology

...argument Socrates gives at his trial in Athens. Socrates is giving his defense of not in favor of believing in the gods and corrupting the youth. In making his defense, Socrates will respond to two kinds of accusations. The first one is referred to as the older or more ancient accusation and the second one is the current charge being made by Meletus, and other civilians who are currently at the trial. They accused him of being a sophist, someone that provides wisdom for a fee. Socrates advises the jurors that the statement is false; he enlightens others for the sole purpose to make everyone aware of their lack of knowledge. Socrates informs the jurors how he achieved this reputation. He claims that his childhood friend, Chaerophon, went to an Oracle of Delphi and inquired if there was someone wiser than Socrates and the oracle said “there is no man wiser” (561). Socrates couldn't accept Wu 2 the Oracle's words since he knows for a fact that he doesn't own this wisdom. Socrates then went on a mission to decipher the paradox and to clarify the meaning of the Oracles words by interrogating others that were wise. By questioning others, this earned him a reputation of being a "busybody" and caused many people to dislike him. Socrates opening move was to call on...

Words: 1912 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

General Management

...Assignment of General Management on the Abilene Paradox: The Management of Agreement Joseph NGENZI MPAM/3020/11 This Term Paper is Submitted in partial fulfillment of UNIT MBA 603 grades of the School of Business and Public Management for the award of Master of Public Administration and Management. Mt. Kenya University July, 2011 INTRODUCTION Four adults are sitting on a porch in 104-degree heat in the small town of Coleman, Texas, some 53 miles from Abilene. They are engaging in as little motion as possible, drinking lemonade, watching the fan spin lazily, and occasionally playing the odd game of dominoes. The characters are a married couple and the wife’s parents. At some point, the wife’s father suggests they drive to Abilene to eat at a cafeteria there. The son in-law thinks this is a crazy idea but doesn’t see any need to upset the apple cart, so he goes along with it, as do the two women. They get in their unaired-conditioned Buick and drive through a dust storm to Abilene. They eat a mediocre lunch at the cafeteria and return to Coleman exhausted, hot, and generally unhappy with the experience. It is not until they return home that it is revealed that none of them really wanted to go to Abilene–they were just going along because they thought the others were eager to go. Naturally, everyone sees this miss in communication as someone else’s problem. Dr. Harvey used this wonderfully simple parable to illustrate what he believes is a major symptom of organizational...

Words: 3711 - Pages: 15