Free Essay

12 Angry Men Essay

In: English and Literature

Submitted By cdnic97
Words 1491
Pages 6
The Final Verdict of 12 Angry Men On the average, about five parents are killed by their biological children in the United States every week. Matricide and patricide are both very rare events when considered in terms of the thousands of individuals arrested every year for murder. Killings of mothers and fathers each constitute about 1 percent of all homicides in the United States in which the victim-offender relationship is known. Did he do it? If he didn't, who did? Why would a young man kill his beloved father with a switchblade knife? Attention gentleman of this trial by jury, I am here to present and address to you a murder/homicide case that has previously already been put on trial with a different jury, in which it involves a teenage boy of about eighteen years old, who was accused for the killing and murder of his father by stabbing him to death. It is now our job to begin deliberations in the first-degree murder trial of an 18-year-old accused in the stabbing death of his father, where a guilty verdict means an automatic death sentence. With this intention, I will be sure to diminish all fraudulent pieces of evidence in this case and do whatever I can to prevent the result of a hung jury in this trial as we are dealing with the innocence of a young boy and his ultimate life fate. The boy on trial in Reginald Rose’s play 12 Angry Men is not guilty because, the self-acclaimed woman whose testimony as a witness seemed to be false and misleading as pertaining to the lack of truthfulness, the self-acclaimed elderly man whose testimony as a witness seemed to have an inaccurate estimated time range and period in which he witnessed and heard the boy murder his father in the same apartment building that he lived in, and the boy was a good knife-fighter so he would have stabbed upward into his father’s chest instead of downward into his father’s chest. First and foremost, the teenage boy who was on trial for the accusation and suspected murder of his father is not guilty because the woman who testified as a witness, gave a testimony that definitely seemed misleading and insufficient as the likelihood of the events that occurred in her story seemed impossible under the circumstances provided. The killing was witnessed under difficult circumstances in which it was night, and a train was passing by. The fact that she claimed to witness the murder through the windows of a passing el train late at night is completely ridiculous and obscured. The interesting part of the woman’s testimony is she swore to say that she did not wear glasses but during the testimony she had noticeable marks on her nose and such marks can only be made by glasses. People who own eye-glasses do not wear them to bed and the woman was in bed when she witnessed the killing, so she was not wearing her glasses at the time she witnessed the killing . Without her glasses she wouldn’t have seen anything, especially across to another building and through an El train that was moving relatively fast to see through when moving.. The killing was witnessed only very briefly and the lights went out immediately. Considering this, juror eight provides very valid insight that can contradict the testimony of the woman by saying, “ She testified that the murder/ took place the instant she looked out, and that the lights/ went out a split second later. She couldn’t have had time to/ put on her glasses then, Now perhaps this woman honestly/ thought she saw the boy kill his father. I say that/ she only saw a blur.” (Rose,60-61) In a like manner, another reason the boy is not guilty of the murder of his father is because the elderly man who testified as a witness and lives in the same apartment building as the boy and the father, honestly claims he heard and witnessed the murder occur in a specific short amount of time period that just seemed to be inaccurate under the circumstances. The old man said he heard the boy yell, “I’m going to kill you!” then a body hitting the ground. He rushed to the door and saw the boy running down the stairs. He said it took about 15 seconds to make it from the time he heard the body hit the floor until the boy ran down the stairs. The man was in his room, he was an old man and when he walked he would scrape his foot on the ground, so he didn’t walk very fast. Juror eight pointed all of this out and then did an experiment. He walked the same distance from the man’s room to the front door while dragging his foot. It took about forty seconds to make the distance while dragging his foot. Since there was a twenty-four to twenty-five second time differential between the old man’s testimony and the reenactment or demonstration performed by juror eight, it makes much more logical sense that it took longer than fifteen seconds for the old man to get out of bed and see the murderer running down the stairs. Notably, Juror eleven emphasises on the fact of the matter of the importance of the time difference in which the old man says he heard and witnessed the murder: “ He may have been a little bit/ off on the speed that the old cripple moved at-but twenty/ -four seconds off...well, now, you know.” (Rose,42) Not to mention, the woman said the murder happened as the last car of an El train roared by the room. How could the man hear him yell at his father then hear a body falling on the ground if the el train, which makes a tremendous amount of noise, was going by at the exact same time? In other words, the woman across the street saw the stabbing through the last two cars of the El train. The shout was heard one second before the stabbing and the El train takes ten to twelve seconds to pass a given point, such as the old man's window. So, the El train was going by at the time of the shout. The El train is really loud when it goes by and the window to the old man's apartment was open. That being the case, the old man would have heard the shout against the background of the really loud El train. We can't be certain of what we hear when there is other, loud, noises in the background. Therefore, the old man certainly couldn’t have heard the boy shout. Lastly, the boy is not guilty of stabbing his father to death because the boy was good with handling a switchblade and he would most likely have stabbed his father in the chest using a down and up technique rather than an up and down technique, which was evident in his father’s wounds from the knife being jabbed four inches deep into his chest. The boy was considered a highly-skilled knife-fighter and he admitted to buying a switchblade on the night of the murder, the same model found in his father’s dead body. However, the boy says he lost the blade on the same night before the murder. An experienced knife wielder would hold the knife under hand, not over-hand, which is what the evidence of the killing appeared to be. He would have stabbed his father with the knife from down and up, not up and down. For example, Juror five explains the proper use of a switchblade: “ Anyone who’s ever used a switch knife would never/ have stabbed downward. You don’t handle a switch knife/ that way. You use it under handed.” (Rose,56) To which Juror eight agrees by replying, “ Then he couldn’t have made the kind of wound that/ killed his father.” (Rose,56) In essence of this murder case, I have full confidence and hereby dignity to believe the boy is not guilty because of the proof beyond reasonable doubt and the thoroughly examined logical evidence that can prove the boy to be innocent. The witnesses and evidences are not conclusive enough to call him guilty, but rather enough to proclaim the boy truly innocent. The woman wasn’t wearing her glasses, the old man couldn’t make it to the door in time and wouldn’t have been able to hear the boy say or do anything to his father at the time under the difficult circumstances, and the way the killer stabbed the victim was unrealistic compared to the boy’s capabilities. Although I am usually gentle in my own manner, I am also prepared to be assertive in the search for truth and innocence in the process of determination for the young boy’s life.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

12 Angry Men Essay

...In Reginald Rose’s play ’12 Angry Men’ the jurors not only let their prejudices affect their opinions they have towards the accused, but also their opinions of each other. Jurors three, ten and four show strong prejudice against the accused purely as he is from the slums and claim that he is guilty on this point alone, whereas juror five is more reluctant to think badly of the boy as he also grew up in the slums. Many of the juror’s prejudices against people from the slums make juror five too nervous to initially speak or express his opinion and his opinion is not taken as seriously because he is seen to be just trying to defend the accused as they both grew up in the slums. Many of the jurors also do not take juror nine seriously and do not believe he will have any valuable points to make purely because he is an elderly man. Conflict is started when juror seven changes his vote. As he originally stated that he wanted to get out of the jury as soon as possible to watch the ball game the other jurors have the preconception that anything he does will be a strategic move so that he can leave, rather than doing what is best for the case. Throughout the play juror three makes comments about his son and towards the end it becomes clear that he was being prejudiced towards the accused purely because it reminded him of his son, who he does not get along with....

Words: 1349 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

12 Angry Men: an Illustration of Concepts of Organisational Behaviour

...12 Angry Men: An Illustration of Concepts of Organisational Behaviour Introduction In 1957 Sidney Lumet’s 12 Angry Men was published (Lumet, 1957). Now, 55 years later, the movie’s teachings still hold most of their truths. The events shown in the movie can be scientifically explained using concepts of organisational behaviour. Although some of these concepts did not even exist by the time the movie was made, the movie still is an excellent case to study and illustrate them. The reason for this is the isolation of the movie’s characters. All events in the movie are triggered by the characters only. There are no external influences nor is there the possibility for the characters to leave the scene. This essay will apply concepts of organizational behaviour to events of the movie. Particular attention will be paid to the concepts of perception, attribution biases, decision making, leadership and group dynamics. In order to do so, the essay will move along the plot of the movie and apply concepts where there are fit. None the less for the purpose of referencing a brief introduction to the movie and its characters is given here: The plot of 12 Angry Men describes the events that take place as a jury has come to a unanimous decision. The defendant is accused of homicide. If the jury decides upon a verdict of ‘guilty’ the judge will inevitably sentence the accused to death penalty. In the beginning all jurors but juror no. 8 are willing to verdict ‘guilty’ without debating....

Words: 2175 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

12 Angry Men

...2B 12 Angry Men Evidence Essay There is a lot to debate about murder cases.there is an especially large amount of evidence to debate in the play “12 Angry Men”. The evidence provided for the trial was easily disproven by the jury members thus proving the defendant innocent. The old man’s testimony proved the defendant innocent. He claimed to have heard the boy yell “I’m going to kill you” and then saw the boy running off seconds later. During this time a train was passing by, and because of the man’s age he needed a cane to walk. This proves he couldn’t of heard the boy yelling and he couldn’t of walked fast enough to see him run off. The old woman’s testimony was more doubtful than untrue. She claimed she had seen the boy murder his father from her bedroom window. The problem is the fact that she needs bifocals to see clearly, and the train was passing between their apartments during the time of the murder. She wouldn’t of been able to see clearly enough to identify the murderer . This rules in favor of the boy’s innocence. The knife wound was also suspicious. The wound was created by a downward stab to the chest. This probably would’ve been insignificant if the defendant didn’t have knife fighting experience. In a knife fight the contenders would of being stabbing upward in hopes of driving the knife in deep. This makes it less possible that he would’ve stabbed downward....

Words: 292 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

12 Angry Men

...12 Angry Men Writing Assignment Final Exam Project Due: ________________________________________ (EDMODO) You will see a lot of psychological phenomena exhibited in the movie 12 Angry Men. Many of these phenomena are listed in the boxes on the next page. Your task for this assignment is to watch the movie, take note of these various psychological phenomena, and then write a cohesive 2-3 page paper discussing these themes. In writing your paper you must pick at least 5 separate incidences from the movie. For each incidence, describe how it relates to psychological phenomenon. Be sure to use concepts from across all of psychology. Do NOT, for example, just pick examples from social psychology (such as conformity and stereotyping); use examples from cognition, memory, sensation, and perception, etc. as well. In order to construct a cohesive essay, you should structure your discussion of the 4 incidences around a central area. That is, your paper needs to be more than just a loose collection of summary points. Consider how you can tie all the incidences together around a central psychological idea. * Behavior is determined by multiple causes: For any complex human behavior, multiple reasons exist as to why that behavior was done. For example, consider your study behavior. It is determined by intelligence, memory and attentional constraints, and social factors....

Words: 717 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Road Age

...Name: Graeme Standing Candidate #: 002351 015 Subject: Psychology – Extended Essay Word Count : 3993 School: Collège du Léman Date: February 2007© Graeme Standing (graemestanding@hotmail.com) Contents Introduction ............................................................................................................................................1 Is Road Rage Just a Media Invention?..................................................................................................... 1 What is Road Rage? ................................................................................................................................2 Stress and Anger .....................................................................................................................................2 Are Some People More Susceptible to Road Rage?...

Words: 4955 - Pages: 20

Free Essay

Matts Home

...The other lesson that was learned in 12 Angry Men was that when members don’t agree on the goal of their group, progress is hindered and conflict persists. This was shown throughout the movie...

Words: 1331 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

English

...Read the following speech by the Nurse to Juliet in Scene ii: There's no trust, No faith, no honesty in men; all perjured, All forsworn, all naught, all dissemblers. Which of the following is the best paraphrase of this...

Words: 2110 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

During the Time of Samuel, Why Did the People of Israel Desire a King?

...Essay 2 During the time of the judges, the land was full of corruption and sin. There was no king or legal authority in Israel and the people acted on what they thought was right and wrong. “In those days there was no king in Israel: every man did that which was right in his own eyes” (Judges 21:25). Samuel was Israel’s spiritual leader (priest), a prophet, and the last and most effective of the judges. God used Samuel to assist in the change of Israel’s government from a system of judges to kings. Samuel judged Israel until his death, saved them from the Philistines, and led them back to God. However, when Samuel grew old, he started appointing his sons as judges but they were corrupt (1 Samuel 8:1). All of the elders of Israel got together and concluded that a change in government was necessary so they went to Samuel and demanded a king. The people of Israel desired a king for several reasons: 1) Samuel was old and his sons were not fit to lead; 2) They hoped that having a king would unite the 12 tribes into one nation and one army because each tribe had their own leader and their own territory; and 3) The people wanted to be like the other nations (1 Samuel 8:4-5). Samuel was disappointed at the people’s request for a king because it showed that they rejected God as their leader and that they rejected him as their judge....

Words: 1016 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Sexuality in Colonial Massachusetts

...Hull notes, “theirs was a special place, not altogether enviable—for in this land of saints and sinners, they were viewed as both saintlier and more sinful than men.” Not only did society expect and desire women to act morally, but society also feared women for their supposed tendencies to act corruptly. Carol F. Karlsen accurately differentiates between these two identities by naming these women either “handmaidens of the devil” or “handmaidens of the Lord.” This distinction demonstrates the binary opposition of women’s place in society that existed in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. By identifying these two opposing personalities, women became the means of controlling sexuality in colonial Massachusetts. This paper illuminates the notion of sexuality in colonial Massachusetts by pointing out the derivation of this paradoxical relationship as well as demonstrating how citizens differentiated between “saints and sinners.” Section I relates the origins of this duality by...

Words: 3470 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Essay

...(Ecclesiastes 2:12-14a NIV). The first thing that he acknowledges, is that the “wise” man is able to perceive and examine life. Because of this light, the “wise” man is able to live a more fertile life. On the other hand, the foolish man perceives...

Words: 950 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The Deconstruction of Waiting for Go Dot

...“Waiting for Godot”, a classic of modern theatre, is a tragicomedy in two acts which tells the story of two men, Vladimir and Estragon, who are waiting to meet a man named Godot. By using deconstructive literary criticism, the play can be analyzed threw the following binary oppositions: passive/active hopelessness/hope, forgetfulness/remembrance and staying/going. Vladimir and Estragon are in a constant state of waiting for Godot: “Nothing to be done. / I'm beginning to come round to that opinion."(Waiting for Godot). Although they are being passive they try to occupy themselves while waiting for Godot. Derrida states that in binary oppositions there is a unspoken hierarchy in which the first term functions as superior to the second term which is considered inferior: “ Derrida’s procedure is to invert the hierarchy in which the first term functions as privileged and superior and the second term as derivative and inferior. By showing that the primary term can be made out to be derivative from or a special case of the secondary term” By reversing the first term with the second a greater meaning can obtained. Although Vladimir and Estragon as in a passive state of waiting they attempt to keep active in order to pass the time. This shows that being active is valued over being passive: “ What about trying them. / I’ve tried everything/ No I mean the boots/ Would that be a good thing? / It’d pass the time. I assure you, it’d...

Words: 1146 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Dude

...special features, which is why it should eventually occupy the place of the VCR in American households. Introduction I’d like to start things out by taking a survey. How many of you remember having a CD player in your house fifteen years ago? Not very many of you, I see. Of course, we all have CD players now. It took a little over a decade and some major price drops, but eventually we all threw out our old vinyl and cassettes and opted for the excellent sound quality and convenience of CDs. Just as the CD took the place of cassettes, many people believe the DVD, or digital versatile disc, will soon take the place of VHS tapes. Many of you may not even know what a DVD is, so before I go any further, let me show you what one looks like. (Take out DVD disc) It’s the same size as a CD, but it has two sides. Just like a VHS tape, it plays movies directly on your television. DVD video players were originally released in early 1997, and their first year sales were twice that of CD players, which is strong evidence that the DVD is here to stay. Why is the DVD so popular, and what makes it better than VHS? There are three main reasons: sound quality, picture quality, and special features exclusive to DVD. (Transition: Let’s start with the sound quality of DVD) Body I. The sound quality of DVD is far superior than that of VHS. A. DVD discs utilize digital technology, which is the same technology used by compact discs. 1. This means that you will...

Words: 1143 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Race, Gender, & Leadership: What Impact Does Race and Gender Have on Leadership Advancement for Women and Women of Color?

...Early on, while studies have been conducted on men and leadership, women – particularly women of color – were excluded completely from this research until the 1970’s and 1980’s (Chemers, 1997). It’s critical to address the current scarcity of leaders – given the complex challenges of the workplace and the upcoming demographic changes within the workforce once the Baby Boomers retire. Promoting more women to leadership positions can assist in closing this gap (Harris, Moran & Moran, 2004; Treverton & Bikson, 2003). While women are typically in lower level managerial positions, research, however has shown that women are more than capable...

Words: 2998 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Maya Angelou

...Morgan Peoples English IV CP Blankenship 3/21/14 Maya Angelou Known as one of the most influential voices of our time, Dr. Maya Angelou is a global renaissance woman, a celebrated poet, novelist, educator and holds many other titles. She has proven the point that sex and race cannot hinder dreams and goals. In this paper, Dr. Maya Angelou’s failures as well as successes will be recognized and discussed. Born on April 4th, 1928, in St. Louis, Missouri, Dr. Angelou was raised in St. Louis and Stamps, Arkansas. Maya Angelou's former name was Marguerite Ann Johnson. Maya got the nickname from her older brother Bailey, who had a speech issue and could not pronounce Marguerite (Longly, 2013). He started calling her Maya because he read a book on Mayan indians, and the name stuck. In Stamps, Dr. Angelou experienced the brutality of racial discrimination, but she also absorbed the unshakable faith and values of traditional African-American family, community, and culture (Angelou, 2012). Growing up in Stamps, AK, Angelou learned what it was like to be a black girl in a world whose boundaries were set by whites (Longly, 2013). As a child, she always dreamed of waking to find her "nappy black hair" metamorphosed to a long blond bob because she felt life was better for a white girl than for a black girl (Franks, n.d.). Despite the odds, her grandmother instilled pride in Angelou with religion as an important element in their home. Maya Angelou contributed to black......

Words: 2403 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Theo104 Does the Bible Have Authority

...THEO104: Module Seven Reflection Essay Title Page 1 THEO104: Module Seven Reflection Essay Michelle A. Woycitzky Liberty University THEO104: Module Seven Reflection Essay 2 I. Introduction To define yourself as a Christian is to believe in God, Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit, and the text of the Holy Bible. Many believers think that this is all it takes to be welcomed into Heaven and enjoy the afterlife in peaceful bliss with their maker. Much of what has been learned in this class these past two months has given me the opportunity to explore Christianity beyond face value, as it should be explored. The true model Christian delves into the inner workings of the scripture and promotes the promises made by God when one lives their life as a messenger of that scripture. Education is the only way to make a person aware of what it truly means to be a Christian. In reflecting on the concepts learned in this class, a series of questions were presented, three chosen, then answered on the basis of what I have learned. The first question I chose was, Does the Bible have authority? Through the Doctrine of the Bible and arguments that the Bible is the Word of God, this question will be answered along with the information in Towns book. Secondly, I chose, Why are personal testimonies important in sharing the gospel?...

Words: 1655 - Pages: 7