Premium Essay

A Critical Review of ‘the Fall and Rise of Strategic Planning’

In: Business and Management

Submitted By selene816
Words 2580
Pages 11
A Critical Review of ‘The Fall and Rise of Strategic Planning’
The arrival of strategic planning had attracted general attention because it implanted in managers’ minds a kind of imperative about the process that was rational and future-oriented (Mintzberg et al, 1998). Nevertheless, Whittington (2001:4) observed,
“the plan is bound to get forgotten as circumstances change”. The purpose of this essay is to critically review ‘The Fall and Rise of Strategic Planning’. Firstly, the position of this article in the wider debate will be given followed by its theoretical underpinnings and its main strengths and weaknesses respectively. A conclusion will be drawn on the article’s contribution to the field of business strategy.

The article’s position falls in between Whittington’s classical and processual approaches. On one hand, Mintzberg challenged the traditional classical planning and progressed towards the processual approach through identifying three fundamental fallacies. Firstly, classicalists held conventional wisdom that the world was sufficiently stable that today’s planning could forecast and fit market changes
(Whittington, 2001). However, Mintzberg (1994:110) took the fresh view that the prediction of discontinuities was “virtually impossible” through questioning Ansoff’s
“extraordinary statement”. Hogarth and Makridakis (1981) strengthened that longterm prediction was notoriously imprecise. If Wilbur Wight had anticipated the prevalence of airplanes nowadays, he would not have said “not within a thousand years will man ever fly” in 1901 (Coffey, 1983 cited in Whittington, 2001). Therefore,
Mintzberg favoured the processual approach that strategic planning should be evolving to adapt to complexities in an unpredictable world (Burnes, 1996).

Secondly, the classical school believed that strategies are best created at one remove from the...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Lean Supply Management

...mind that one of the premises of MBP is that learning from the planning and implementation process is as important as the plan itself. Focusing only on financial objectives limits the organization from making critical changes. The concept of strategic learning suggests that the companies that are the most successful in the broadest terms have mastered strategic thinking versus strategic planning.[5] To appropriately define a balanced mix of financial and nonfinancial measures, the use of a Balanced Scorecard[6] is recommended. The Harvard Business Review describes the methods and advantages by which the balanced measures can be selected. These balanced objectives support the overarching goals arising from the MBP process. Using an MPB tool called a goals and action (G&A) matrix,[7] SCM and manufacturing operations managers can clearly articulate their objectives with reference to the overarching goals. The G&A matrix also allows the alignment of potentially conflicting objectives. For example, an SCM objective may be to reduce inbound transportation costs while a manufacturing objective may be to improve inventory turns or increase delivery frequency; the SCM goal would pursue decreased delivery frequency while the manufacturing goal would pursue increased delivery frequency. The development of the G&A goals, and the supportive reviews of the activity progress highlight such conflicts. Formatting the strategic intent, highest-level objectives, and second-level (functional......

Words: 481 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Craftin Strategy Review

...A critical review of ‘Crafting Strategy’ by Henry Mintzberg Strategy is a topic that receives a considerable amount of focus in both business schools and industry throughout the world (Knight and Mueller, 2004). A key debate in the field strategy is how exactly strategy is formulated. In ‘Crafting Strategy’ Mintzberg (1987) examines the distinctions between planning strategy and crafting strategy. This literature review will discuss Mintzberg’s argument and approach in the wider debate of strategy, followed by an analysis of the articles strengths and weaknesses. The position of the article in the wider debate about processes of strategy Whittington (2001) categorised strategy in to four principle approaches; Classical, evolutionary, processual and systematic. Mintzberg challenged traditional classical planning on a number of levels; Classicalist believed that the world was stable enough that strategist could accurately forecast through a rational process of deliberate calculation and analysis and that they are best created by senior management away from the operating environment (Whittington, 2001). Prescriptive strategic management literature indicates there is “a correlation between organizational performance and strategic planning, although empirical evidence is less than conclusive in this respect (Glaister and Falshaw, 1999; McKiernan and Morris, 1994; Pearce II et al., 1987; Rigby, 2001),” (Gunn and Williams, 2007, p206). Mintzberg believes that the term......

Words: 1543 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Case Study

...1. Identify the firm’s existing vision, mission, objectives, and strategies: Vision “To be the worldwide leader in sharing delicious tastes and creating joyful memories.” Mission “To touch and enhance lives through the joy that is Krispy Kreme. “ Objectives 1. Reduce the investment required to produce a given level of sales and reduce operating costs by operating smaller satellite stores instead of larger, more expensive factory stores. 2. Achieve greater production efficiencies by centralizing doughnut production to minimize the burden of fixed costs. 3. Achieve greater consistency of product quality through a reduction in the number of doughnut-making locations. 4. Enable store employees to focus on achieving excellence in customer satisfaction and in-shop consumer experience. 5. Stimulate an increase in on-premises sales of doughnuts and complementary products by increasing the number of retail distribution points to provide customers more convenient access to the company’s products. Strategies 1. Open up new (or convert traditional factory stores to) "hot shops" that provide a hot doughnut experience for customers throughout the day, instead of the traditional experience of having the hottest, freshest doughnuts available only at certain times of the day---these "hot shops" would be added to the traditional fresh shops and kiosks as the primary methods for market......

Words: 2264 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Strategic Planning

...Final Project Running Head: FINAL PROJECT Strategic planning helps educational organizations plan a path for the achievement of its goals. The planning process should begin with an internal review of the organizations current operations and identifying what areas are in need of improvement. Once the internal review is complete, additional planning involves identifying the results the organization wants to achieve and establishing the next steps necessary to reach the intended goals. These goals or factors can range from: finances, public relations, policy development, personnel recruitment or overall strategic planning in light of student performance. This strategic plan will focus on the financial aspects of an organizations plan. Establishing and implementing effective financial policies are fundamental in an educational organizations success. One essential component of a strategic plan is the establishment of financial policies and procedures. Financial policies are the rules that govern the financial decisions making process of an organization. Educational organizations adopt these policies and follow them to guide them when making financial decisions. Upon adoption of the organizations financial policies, the organizations financial decisions making process is simplified, because the institutions governing body has already developed the financial policies needed to make important decisions. Many times financial policies result from "past experiences." These......

Words: 1138 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Geo Politics

...significant oil and gas reservoirs are located. Pricing policies entice development of alternative sources. Over a period of 20 years, the energy structure of the Americas becomes the most diversified in the world. Innovation tied to alternative sources of energy boosts development rates in the hemisphere. Democracies become gradually more stable, as the development approach touches the daily lives of the many who now have a stake in stability and growth. Ethanol, compressed natural gas, hydroelectric power, nuclear and solar energy, reduce oil consumption and the speed of the oil depletion curve. The world economy finds some bumpy roads but rebounds strongly thereafter to enter a three-decade long growth path. Since the world witnessed the rise of the...

Words: 1572 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Mankins Strategy to Performance

...HARVARD BUSINESS REVIEW Companies typically realize only about 60% of their strategies' potential value because of defects and breakdowns in planning and execution. By strictly following seven simple rules, you can get a lot more than that. TURNING GREAT STRATEGY INTO GREAT PERFORMANCE by Michael C. Mankins and Richard Steele hree years ago, the leadership team at a major man- ufacturer spent months developing a new strategy for its European business. Over the prior half-decade, six new competitors had entered the market, each deploying the latest in low-cost manufacturing technology and slashing prices to gain market share. The performance of the European unit - once the crown jewel of the company's portfolio-had deteriorated to the point that top management was seriously considering divesting it. To turn around the operation, the unit's leadership team had recommended a hold new "solutions strategy"-one that would leverage the business's installed base to fuel growth in after-market services and equipment financing. The financial forecasts were exciting-the strategy promised to restore the business's industry-leading returns and growth. Impressed, top management quickly approved JULY-AUGUST 2005 65 » THE HIGH-PERFORMANCE ORGANIZATION Chemical, 3M, and Roche, to name a few-develop realistic plans that are solidly grounded in the underlying economics of their markets and then use the plans to drive execution. Their disciplined planning and execution......

Words: 5641 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

H & M in Fast Fashion: Continued Success

...Q9: “No matter how many reforms are passed there will always be someone who cheat and steals on a grand scale in the misguided belief that risks are outweighed by the potential gains” Reference: Corporate governance –The new focus of interest.[ Editorial].( 1993, January). Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 1-3. Jordan, C. (2012). Cadbury Twenty Years On. Villanova Law Review Stiles, P. and Taylor, B. (1993) ‘Maxwell-The failure of corporate governance’, Corporate governance-an international review, 1(1), pp. 314-327 Boyd, C.: 1996, ‘Ethics and corporate governance: The issues raised by the Cadbury report in the United Kingdom,’ Journal of business Ethics 15(2), 167-183 Parkinson, J. and Kelly, G. (1999) the combined code on corporate governance, Political Quarterly, 70, 1, 101-7 Lutz, S., Eberle, D. and Lautter, D. (2011) ‘Varieties of private self-regulation in European capitalism: corporate governance codes in the UK and Germany’, Socio-economic review 9(2): 315-38 Thomas, C. W. (2002, April). The rise and fall of Enron. Journal of accountancy, 103(4), 41-48 Davis, S., Lukomnik, J. and Pitt-Watson, D. (2010) Corporate governance in the wake of financial crises Mintz, S. (2012). Whistleblowing and bystander apathy. Available at (Accessed 24 February 2015) Fitzergaland, D. J. (2013) Whistleblowing Cohan, J. A. (2002), ‘I Didn’t Know and I was Only Doing My Job. Has......

Words: 956 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Barrack Gold Corporation

...macroenviroment of forces that shape opportunities and pose threats to a company such as Barrick. Jobber and Ellis-Chadwick (2013) further imply that it is these actors and forces that affect the mining company’s capability to operate effectively in providing products and services to its customers. Its external environment is characterized by elements that do not have an immediate impact on its performance albeit their impact being felt over the long term. There are those that can influence the company marketing activities without management being able to control them hence the need to continuously monitor them or risk going out of business (Wilson, 2006). The framework that best discusses these elements is the PESTLE Analysis as it provides the strategic planning and environmental analysis that can be useful for Barrick to improve performance and ensure its long term existence as a going concern (Sanderson and Luffman, 2007). Note that though the acronym PESTLE can infer to the order the analysis is conducted, it is important for Barrick to identify which variables are most important for an opportunity and threat analysis. Political, Legal and Economical Though Political, Legal and Economic factors are autonomous discussed in literature,...

Words: 3030 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Term Paper

...Amazon Strategy Analysis The strategic planning processes. Amazon and other large enterprises to build your organization with a view - from the view of the company’s mission, goals and objectives are developed. Many times during the life of an organization is necessary for the organization to redefine the objectives of the organization on the basis of profitability, customer concerns, and the internal, external and international challenges. • Value Chain • Resource Based View • Financial Analysis Using an Analysis of the Value Chain Amazon Amazon has developed an analysis of the value chain of its Competitive Advantage “own internal operationally better assess how you can add value and sustain competitive advantage have used the value chain model of Michael Porter,"Create and maintain superior performance. " Example of a Strategic Plan Model - Amazon Internal Analysis Tools, Strategic Planning, Strategic Planning Models Primary activities and support activities Primary activities are those needed to produce a product or service to the end customers. These activities generally include: • Inbound Logistics: receiving goods from suppliers, and store and move the good • Operations: Manufacturing or assembly of the product • Outbound Logistics: The shipment of goods to wholesalers, retailers or directly to the final customer • Marketing and Sales: Marketing involves customer needs understanding,......

Words: 1384 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Mintzberg’s Ten Strategy Formulation Process Comparedd

...1.0 Introduction: Strategic management is a continuous activity that appraises and controls the industries and the business in which the company is involved; evaluates its rivals and sets organizational purpose and strategies to address with all existing and potential competitors; and then reevaluates each strategy after a definite time period to determine how it has been applied and whether it has thrived or needs replacement by a new strategy to meet changed environments, new rivals or new political, economical social, technological environment. Strategic management is very important and broader area than any specific functional management area. It determines whether an organization excels, survives, or dies. It is very essential because it leads all the functional arenas of the business. It is generally believed that businesses, which develop formal strategic management systems, have a greater possibility of success than those, which do not. (Jauch and Glueck,1988,) Strategic management helps organizations predict future problems and opportunities. It endows with crystal-clear vision, mission, objectives, and strategies that guide organization into the secured future. Strategic management is a stream of decisions and actions. (Jauch and Glueck,1988). It is a procedure by which top-level management decides and does for the success of the company. It helps to determine the best possible strategy so that company could win the game in competitive business......

Words: 5438 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Business Management

...can't find enough good people, the cause, in our view, is most likely to be deep-rooted and centred on a misalignment between the strategic goals of the business and the efforts of the company's talent acquisition professionals. In this article, we'll outline the approach we took at Pfizer and offer some ideas that you can take away and implement right away. But before we do that, let's first look at why this misalignment between people and business goals happens. The root causes are not that complicated and usually centre on two things: first, the people who find and hire employees don't sit in the same meetings as those who set the direction of the overall business and its main operating units. Getting a seat at those senior-level forums, and the credibility to contribute on an equal footing as a genuine 'business partner', is more difficult than you might think. This is usually because the perception of HR, where talent acquisition resides, is that of a lower-level, tactical support function. We have both worked with a varied, diverse mix of business leaders. Depending on which one you spoke to, they viewed talent acquisition as either strategic, operational or perhaps somewhere in between. But only if the role is seen as strategically important will HR stand a chance of showing how it helps leaders meet the manpower elements of their strategic plans,...

Words: 3856 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Hrm Business a modern company Skills, Competencies and Knowledge Human resource management’s role is one of the important components of the organization. There are some skills can help the manager grow into more effective. Two of the most important skills an employer's selection and recruitment.Recruiting good staff is the first basic skills of a recruiter.It is in the process of selecting a group of highly qualified candidates for recruitment office’s worker(Gold, 2007). He also decided selection as a progress of choosing people from a group of applicants who have the highest chance to succeed in the jobs. Recently, the staff is a critical component in the development of an organization The case below discussed that Jack is a smart person and donate a vast amount of knownlegde or the experience to the organization. But , everybody’s review about Jack’s attitude...

Words: 2262 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Requirments of Business Managements Systems

...and implement effective performance measurement and management system in order to asses, control, and finally improve organizational performance. Unfortunately, still a lot of companies today use financial and accounting-based calculations as the ultimate measures of company performance although exclusively financial approach to performance is not sufficient any longer. The aim of the paper is to figure out the requirements that should be fulfilled by modern performance management systems. Thus, in the first part of the article the short review of contemporary approach to performance management was described, in the following part different opinions and discussions from the relevant academic literature were depicted and finally the comprehensive set of ten requirements was proposed. 2 Contemporary Approach to Performance Management In 1965 R. N. Anthony published his seminal work titled “Planning and Control Systems”, in which he introduced the concept of management control. His classic definition of management control was “the process by * Bartłomiej Nita, Ph.D. – Assistant Professor; Department of Managerial Accounting and Accounting for Management, Institute of Accounting, Faculty of Management, Computer Science and Finance, Wrocław University of Economics, ul. Komandorska 118/120, 53-345 Wrocław, Poland; <>....

Words: 5336 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Asahi Case Study

...STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT TEXAS EXECUTIVE MBA PROGRAM FALL 2011 Professor David B. Jemison CBA 3.232 Telephone 471-8757 Texts: Porter, Michael E. Competitive Strategy. (New York: Free Press, l998). Course Description Perspective and Themes This course is about the creation and maintenance of a long-term vision for the organization. This means that it is concerned with both the determination of strategic direction and the management of the strategic process. As such, it deals with the analytical, behavioral, and creative aspects of business simultaneously. The course is organized around six themes in strategic management: the role of the general manager, the components of business strategy, corporate strategy development, divisional-level strategy development, managing strategic change, and the development of general managers. Our perspective in this course is that of the leader whose responsibility is the long-term health of the entire firm or a major division. The key tasks involved in general management include the detection of and adaptation to environmental change; the procurement and allocation of resources; the integration of activities across subparts of the organizations; and, at the most senior levels, the determination of purpose and the setting of corporate direction. General managers, from our perspective, are managers who are in the position to make strategic decisions for the firm. Note that such...

Words: 11018 - Pages: 45

Premium Essay


...NAPIER UNIVERSITY BUSINESS SCHOOL SOE09101 – STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT IN A GLOBAL CONTEXT ASSESSMENT A – October 2014 MARKING CRITERIA MATRIC NO___40182413_____WORD COUNT_____2536__________ | Fail | Fair | Good | Very Good | Excellent | PRESENTATION [15%] Selection of Material Balance of answer and Use of References | | | | | | CONTENT [35%] Appropriate content covering core material which may draw from: * Nature of traditional/strategic planning approach; * Benefits/Problems associated with formalised strategic decision-making/emergent strategy * The role of uncertain and dynamic environment. | | | | | | ARGUMENT [25%] Development/evaluation of the proposition in terms of the question set | | | | | | SYNTHESIS/CONCLUSIONS [25%] Highlighting key issues, reaching logical conclusions supported by evidence from the literature | | | | | | In modern conditions of the relations of the developed market of the organization shall pursue more various policy to look for various methods of its implementation so that it could be arranged in time in case of new market conditions to look for new ideas of development. If it demands to be to strategic policy based on the long-term program which mentions all spheres of the organization. However, in unstable, often changeable, dynamic and uncertain conditions of market economy the organization shall adapt to such environment very quickly. The purpose of......

Words: 2781 - Pages: 12