Premium Essay

A Review of the Positivist and Interpretive Paradigms

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By manfredwu
Words 7379
Pages 30
A review of the positivist and interpretive paradigms and discussion on how they are both related to the proposed study 'Chinese culture on learning and the use of meta-cognitive language-learning strategies at an institute of vocational education in Hong Kong'.

By
Manfred Wu

"I certify that this work is entirely my own and has not been accepted as part of a submission to another degree course"

_________________________

Word Length: 5,964 Abstract
This paper begins with a review of the positivist and interpretive paradigms. After the description of a proposed study on Chinese values on learning and use of meta-cognitive language-learning strategies (MCLLS), how the study emerges from the two paradigms is discussed. Discussions show that the aims of the study of gathering descriptive data and exploring relationships between the two variables as well as the use of survey method are more pertained to the positivist paradigm as it shares features with the paradigm including a high degree of control over responses, use of statistics both for descriptive and for determining relationships and researchers being detached by adopting the role of an objective and passive informant. Other aims of generating insights on the two selected concepts, collecting information from respondents' frame of reference, focusing on the whole institutional setting and the use of semi-structured interview are more pertained to the interpretive paradigm. It is because the design focuses on the subjective meanings of respondents, the reasons for observable behaviours, and finally the researcher being involved by taking the role of active collaborators. However, as the study is limited to a particular setting, it does not share the aims of generalization and discovering universal laws of the positivist paradigm. Similarly, the interview part focuses on…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Classicist and Positivist Criminology

...Compare and contrast classicist and positivist criminology. Classical Criminology was developed in late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. One of the finding fathers of this approach was the Italian philosopher Cesare Baccaria. In 1764, Baccaria published his work On Crime and Punishment in which he protested against often cruel and harsh punishments, based upon the infliction of pain and suffering and appears to propose introduction of new legal system which will be reasonably fair and transparent. Classical criminology suggested that all humans are rational beings and their actions can be understood as “freewill” and crime can be regarded as an irrational judgement. Classicism assumes that people weigh up the cost and benefits of their crimes before they commit them. The focus of classical criminology was based only on the offence not on the individual, all people were treated as alike, judging seriousness of a crime was based on the act alone, and not on intentions or other factors which may influence the individual to commit the crime, for example; first-time offenders were treated the same as serial recidivist. Positivism was emerged in the early nineteenth century. However, it is widely assumed that scientific criminology began when Italian physician Cesare Lombroso published his work The Criminal Man in 1876. Lombroso studied the body shapes of executed criminals, he believed that particular bodily differences, for example skull size could identify and......

Words: 573 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Classical V Positivist

...CLASSICAL V. POSITIVIST CRIMINOLOGY There are two schools of thoughts when dealing with criminology, they are; classical and positivist criminology. The two meaning entirely the opposite, classical criminology is based on committing crimes by “free will” while positivist criminology deals with committing crime due to the impact of one’s’ environment. Cesare Beccaria helped make the present day Judicial System what it is; his thought process was in the beliefs of the classical theory. The Classical criminology theory is established on the thought process that committing a crime is a “choice” that individuals make on their own. It is only human nature to know the difference of right from wrong; the classical view depicts that one “knowingly” decides to do wrong not caring the consequences. This is where Cesare Beccaria comes into play, he decided that “do the crime, pay the time”, he felt that one’s punishment should be as just and fair pertaining to the crime itself; this is why all punishments have certain mandatory sentences imposed on them. Beccaria however, did not believe in capital punishment, he felt has though that it is not man’s job to inflict death upon another. Casare Lombroso is commended on creating this type of criminology notated as positivist; he unlike Beccaria did believe in capital punishment, and disagreed with Beccaria's perceptions on punishments being fit for the type of crime committed, and stated that instead, the punishments......

Words: 784 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Three Paradigms of Cold War

...Three (Possible) Paradigms* The Cold War is not what it once was. Not only has the conflict itself been written about in the past tense for more than a decade, but historians’ certainties about the character of the conflict have also begun to blur. The concerns brought on by trends of the past decade – such trifles as globalization, weapons proliferation, and ethnic warfare – have made even old strategy buffs question the degree to which the Cold War ought to be put at the center of the history of the late twentieth century. In this article I will try to show how some people within our field are attempting to meet such queries by reconceptualizing the Cold War as part of contemporary international history. My emphasis will be on issues connecting the Cold War – defined as a political conflict between two power blocs – and some areas of investigation that in my opinion hold much promise for reformulating our views of that conflict, blithely summed up as ideology, technology, and the Third World. I have called this lecture “Three (Possible) Paradigms” not just to avoid making too presumptuous an impression on the audience but also to indicate that my use of the term “paradigm” is slightly different from the one most people have taken over from Thomas Kuhn’s work on scientific revolutions. In the history of science, a paradigm has come to mean a comprehensive explanation, a kind of scientific “level” that sustains existing theory until overtaken by a new and different paradigm. In the......

Words: 8015 - Pages: 33

Free Essay

The Interpretive Community

...My interpretive community In each and every community have come to encompass a number of aspects of human being as unique or individual personalized by their society. This has led to condemnations of human cloning from the unique side as a human being for a different perspective in life. The culture of India refers to the customs, beliefs, traditions, languages, ceremonies, arts, values and their different life style. For example, when you are standing inside the subway counter like: There are communities of Christians, Muslims at my left hand side; and communities of Hindu, Jain, Sikh at my right hand side! But when I put them together in SUB, it becomes our delicious and beautiful "INDIA"! Indians by nature believes in faith and religion. I grew up in Indian culture as per my parents. So I am the only solid concern and can tell that this community has their own different believes. Being Hinduism, I believe in karma and all mighty. I strongly believe in this statement “God doesn’t give you the people you want, he gives you the people you need. To help you, to hurt you, to leave you, to love you and to make you the person you were meant to be.” I have a faith in all mighty gods since I was little. There was a time that I feel and saw from my real eyes. One day, my mom was trying to cross to road and suddenly one car passed by her with rear wheel on her one feet. She realize after that car passed but her feet was absolutely fine and nothing happened. She......

Words: 865 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Paradigm

...CELL PHONE PARADIGM SHIFT Brandon McNutt Cell phones can provide many services that computers also provide. We can send content to another phone number with a push of a button (texting). These devices in this modern day, allow us to access the mobile web. Mobile phones connect to a wireless communications network through radio waves or through a satellite transmission. The device allows you to write letters without evening touching a piece of paper or a pen/pencil, also known as e-mail. A cell phones option to text someone can have a huge impact on the English language. Phrases abbreviations like ‘oh my gosh’ (OMG) and “laugh out loud’ (LOL) have been added to the dictionary. Texting has gone as far as picture and video messaging. This led to sexting where two or more people exchange sexually explicit material via text message. This application allows us to communicate without having to communicate socially. This device has evolved so much that we no longer have to communicate with each other socially or have to interact with other peers. We can be at a social gathering and be texting someone across the room. Why? Is it faster? Or is it because, it can be much easier to communicate with a person via mobile device. Americans ages 18-29 can average about 88 text messages a day. The numbers vary as the age increases. The postal system that we used to use to communicate to other people isn’t as affective as it used to be. Instead of sending a person a......

Words: 436 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Paradigm Shift

...book interesting because it was not a conventional science book. Yes, it talked a lot about science but the paradigm shift that Kuhn wrote about got my interest. The ‘scientific revolutions’ were true and believable and somehow, I agree with them. Science, or normal science as Thomas Kuhn put it, is the process of gathering facts to build hypotheses that explain different phenomena in the world. It is a ‘research firmly based upon one or more past scientific achievements, achievements that some particular community acknowledges for a time as supplying the foundation for its further practice.’ And this is the science that almost everybody knows. This is the science I know. I couldn’t care less what those new achievements are. I just watch the Discovery Channel and surf the internet and they would tell me what is new and how things happen in just one click. In this book, I could almost feel how scientists burn their time for research, proving theories and the like. How happy they must be once their research is successful and becomes basis for explaining how things work. Some even have become legends in their discoveries. I could never imagine myself doing the things they do. It’s a good thing that most of everything nowadays have already been researched about and explained by the geniuses of old times. These smart ones must have also been repulsed by the paradigm shift that Thomas Kuhn introduced. Well, I believe that they know about this shift but Kuhn putting......

Words: 927 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Paradigm

...faced to “revolutionary change” as paradigm shift. He describe it as a borderline or limitation we have set to our norm that affects how we view new ideas or change in the workplace or invention. He mentioned that great scientists and inventors of the past misread the sign of new ideas, because their old paradigm (system of rules that set limits on new ideas) could not reimagine the possibility of that idea to come true with the known resources. Barker express that one have to be able to look beyond their present paradigm to see what changes could occurs in society. People such as Einstein, Darwin and Copernicus (the Earth revolves around the Sun and not the other way around) saw adjusted to the new paradigm. 2. I believe this video is an exact example of the struggles managers of various levels and skills face today and of previous times. When in a managerial position, one is expected to be a team player than Mr. /Miss Do It Yourself (DIY). According to the textbook, one of the major challenges managers face especially new managers is changing from their old paradigm role to the new paradigm role they play in the company. One specific struggle is going from a personal identity (as the textbook described) to general specialist. Before the managerial position, you’ll be an independent entity, you having the feeling that you are capable of doing every task alone with minimal dependency on others (co-workers or supervisors). However, this paradigm normally does not make a......

Words: 608 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Paradigm Shift

...Paradigm Shift ITT Technical Institute A paradigm shift is the term used by Thomas Kuhn in his book “The Structure of Scientific Revolutions” written in 1962 to describe a change in basic assumptions within the ruling theory of science. It is in contrast of his idea of what normal science was. What is a paradigm? A paradigm is perception, values and practices shared by a particular group and how that group organizes itself. That would make a paradigm shift a change in how things are seen and viewed and how they will change the way that particular group reacts with the shift. A technological example of a technological paradigm shift could be a personal computer and how it has evolved and changed society. Keep in mind throughout this paper my shift is based on the personal computer and not to be confused with the first computer invented. A personal computer can be defined by its size and capabilities that allow it to be more convenient for the end user. The first personal computer that was commercially available was the Programma 101. It was produced by an Italian company named Olivetti. It was invented by an engineer named, Pier Giorgio Perotto at a cost of $3200 in 1965. It allowed users to access applications such as word processing, data management, financial matters, and computer games. The term personal computer is described as a machine that used a microprocessor to execute applications. However, computers didn’t evolve to meet the standards of society until the...

Words: 952 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Interpretive Journey Paper

...INTERPRETIVE JOURNEY PAPER ACTS 6:1-7 Wilbert Early, Jr. L23076350 Inductive Bible Study, BIBL 350 Dr. Ramon Moran Liberty University, 12 December 2013 INTRODUCTION The purpose of this research paper is to provide an Interpretive Journey into the New Testament text, Acts 6:1-7. The author, Luke, penned; In those days when the number of disciples was increasing, the Hellenistic Jews among them complained against the Hebraic Jews because their widows were being overlooked in the daily distribution of food. 2 So the Twelve gathered all the disciples together and said, “It would not be right for us to neglect the ministry of the word of God in order to wait on tables. 3 Brothers and sisters, choose seven men from among you who are known to be full of the Spirit and wisdom. We will turn this responsibility over to them 4 and will give our attention to prayer and the ministry of the word.” 5 This proposal pleased the whole group. They chose Stephen, a man full of faith and of the Holy Spirit; also Philip, Procorus, Nicanor, Timon, Parmenas, and Nicolas from Antioch, a convert to Judaism. 6 They presented these men to the apostles, who prayed and laid their hands on them. 7 So the word of God spread. The number of disciples in Jerusalem increased rapidly, and a large number of priests became obedient to the faith (Acts 6:1-7, NIV). I will use the five-step process of the basic Interpretive Journey in......

Words: 1651 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Paradigm Shifts

...Paradigm Shifts A paradigm shift is a shift in world view which occurs whenever there is a period of stagnation and presents a radical new idea, such as the transition from steam to combustion engines. If paradigm shifts occur at an exponential rate, change approaches infinite, and is expected to reach a singularity where after that point; nothing can be known which NASA has categorized it as an impending event, estimated for 2035. As paradigm shifts occur exponentially, so will the symptoms of the Dark Age be exacerbated including the five beneficent pillars. The meanings of words exponentially vary causing lexical complexity to decay along with the ability to discern reality until it is virtual due to semantic shifts. The severity of higher education may soon become nil as nanotechnology will allow scanning of the brain thus, all thoughts, memories and knowledge can be transferred, recreated or stored for another human. Science and technology won’t help us master reality but instead further enslave the population due to greater dependences on things like nanotechnology to fight disease. Since that is power, governments will ignore needs and possibilities to focus on the prior, and no opposition will exist as semantic shifts further confuse population and government between mechanism and purpose. Finally, the individual must constantly adapt to growing environments due to paradigm shifts, and therefore causes greater inauthenticity which leads to greater ironic detachment.......

Words: 268 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Interpretive Journey Instructions

...Interpretive Journey Paper Instructions On Monday of Module/Week 8, you will submit a paper that will demonstrate an understanding of the interpretive journey through detailed work in each of the 5 major sections of this method of Bible study. This paper will reflect a personal and independent study of a selected passage of Scripture. As such, bibliographic resources are limited to course tools (Strong’s Exhaustive Concordance and The Zondervan Illustrated Bible Dictionary) and similar resources. In order to complete this assignment you will first select 1 of these 3 passages: A. Deuteronomy 22:8 B. Acts 6:1–7 C. 1 Peter 5:6–7 Once you have selected a passage, you will then take the verse through the interpretive journey process. Your answer must engage each of the following steps. Step 1: Grasp the text in their town. Summarize the original situation and the meaning of the text for the biblical audience. Step 2: Measure the width of the river to cross. What are the differences between the biblical situation and our situation? Step 3: Cross the Principlizing Bridge. List the theological principle(s) communicated by the passage. Step 4: Consult the biblical map. How does the theological principle fit with the rest of the Bible? Step 5: Grasp the text in our town. How should individual Christians today live out the theological principle? This assignment must be 2–3 pages in length and use current Turabian format. While the amount of material will......

Words: 333 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Paradigms

...Three Paradigms Grand Canyon University Theoretical Foundations in Advanced Practice Nursing NUR 502 Lori Rubio November 22, 2014 Three Paradigms Maslow’s human needs theory is described in stages. The stages are 1) physiological 2) safety 3) love and belonging needs 4) self esteem needs 5) self actualization needs 6) self transcendence needs. Human needs theory has the goal of attaining the sixth need of self-transcendence needs. In Maslow’s theory the goals happen in incremental steps for the individual to move onto the next step. The unitary model explains things as all part of an ever changing universal energy system. In this theory the person is looked at, as a whole not just parts. This is a holistic view on nursing. In this theory nursing exists to serve individuals and the care depends on the amount of knowledge that each nurse brings with them to the care that they give. Rodgers’ theory is defined as “an art and science that is humanistic and humanitarian. It is directed toward the unitary human being and is concerned with the nature and direction of human development. The goal of the nurses is to participate in the process of change.”(Gill, 2014, para. 1) In Kings general systems frameworks the interactive process is described as nursing focus is the care of the human being. Human beings are constantly interacting with their environment and people have certain abilities. Some of these abilities are: able to set goals, think, feel, choose,......

Words: 399 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Nursing Paradigms

...strive to establish its own unique body of knowledge and to maintain its professional boundaries. The four metaparadigms of nursing are person, environment, health, and nursing. The paradigms are then broken into two entities; the totality paradigm and the simultaneity paradigm. The totality paradigm, the person is in constant interaction with the environment to accomplish goals and maintain balance. In the totality paradigm the focus is on health promotion, care and cure of the sick, and prevention of illness. The simultaneity paradigm, the person is viewed very differently. In the simultaneity paradigm, the focus is on the quality of life from a person’s perspective. Designation of illness by societal norms is not a significant factor. Human beings are defined as individuals who are capable of conscious and organized thought who have inherent physiological and psychosocial needs. These individuals are not predefined but get defined in the course of living a life, where the mind, body, and spirit are integrated as one. This concept is based on Parse's nursing theory. Parse’s theory views patients as taking an active and continuous role in their development, being free to select the means of achieving a particular way of living. In the areas I manage it is a fine line between the two paradigms. As we encourage patient participation in their treatment it is often met with resistance. For example, a patient 2 days post-op has orders to ambulate 2 times per shift to prevent......

Words: 1346 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Programing Paradigm

...Programming paradigm is a fundamental style of computer programming , a way of building the structure and elements of computer programs. There are six main programming paradigms: 1. imperative programming, imperative programming, which is based on procedural languages, literate programming ,which structures programs as a human-centered web, as in a hypertext essay –documentation is integral to the program, and the program is structured following the logic of prose exposition, rather than compiler convenience. 2. declarative programming, declarative programming paradigms were developed. In these languages the computer is told what the problem is, not how to solve the problem – the program is structured as a collection of properties to find in the expected result, not as a procedure to follow. Given a database or a set of rules, the computer tries to find a solution matching all the desired properties. The archetypical example of a declarative language is the fourth generation language SQL, as well as the family of functional languages and logic programming 3. functional programming , Functional programming is a subset of declarative programming. Programs written using this paradigm use functions, blocks of code intended to behave like mathematical functions. Functional languages discourage changes in the value of variables through assignment , making a great deal of use of recursion instead. 4. object-oriented programming , object-oriented......

Words: 393 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Paradigm

...Paradigm Operational Opposite paradigm Operational An educational leader promotes the success of every student. Educational leaders use data to monitor the progress of every student in their schools. Educational leaders do not promote the success of every student. Many students including minority and special education students continue to be left behind in the educational system. A positive school culture and a good instructional program are the key to student learning and staff professional development. Students learn best in a positive school culture with teachers who are nurturing and supportive. A positive school culture and a good instructional program do not always guarantee that students will learn and staff members will develop professionally. Many schools have a staff of highly qualified professionals with a positive school culture but students continue to lag behind due to their socioeconomic status. Motivating and rewarding students and staff members are fundamental to student learning and their success at school. Students learn best and staff members work better when they are provided with positive feedback and incentives. Motivating and rewarding students and staff members are not always fundamental to student learning and their success at school. The federal government has allocated a great deal of money and programs to motivate students to learn and encourage school districts to hire the best candidates yet the United States still lag......

Words: 512 - Pages: 3