Premium Essay

A Stranger Among Us

In: Historical Events

Submitted By jn221994
Words 648
Pages 3
A Stranger Among Us A Stranger Among Us is a movie that displays many aspects of ethnicity, and how many different groups of people interact and adapt to each other’s difference. There is a murder and a detective named Emily Eden has to place herself into a Jewish community to help solve this murder. In the film there is several groups displayed and many different perspectives, along with an ethnic neighborhood and lots of learning about the Hasidic culture, and Detective Eden made some crucial mistakes in unraveling the murder. Also, this is a movie that is beneficial to everyone in our class. The groups in the film are not only ethnic groups but also groups involving occupations. There are two main ethnic groups that interact in the movie, Caucasian American and those of the ethnic neighborhood of Hasidim; who have a hard time getting along at first, but eventually work out their differences. The two groups involving occupations are the police, and either the mafia or the mob – these two groups are key because the police help solve the case, and the mob is wrongly accused and killed because of the case. The perspective present in the film I believe is an outsider’s perspective, someone who does not know much about the Hasidic culture. This includes the audience watching the film because they are able to get a feel for how the Hasidim live, but also this includes the police characters in the movie; Eden’s life is changed by her experience in the film, and Levine and other police officers make fun of the Hasidim for their strict sexual lifestyle, wrongly saying that “they do it through a sheet.” The urban ethnic neighborhood of the Hasidim is filled with the Hebrew language. The newspapers, restaurants, and all signs are in Hebrew, along with Hebrew being spoken regularly. All of the Hasidim are constantly dressed in the same clothes that they would wear to…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay


...Living With Strangers Sometimes it can be a leap in the dark to move from a small city to a big city. You start somewhere new; an unknown place filled with new experiences, challenges and strangers. It can be overwhelming at first, and it might as well take some time to grow accustomed to the new culture and what the city has to offer. The situation can especially be difficult to someone who comes from a city, where one is used to live in closely encircling. As an example of this kind of situation is Siri Hustvedt’s essay ‘Living with Strangers’, which is written in 2002 Hustvedt describes in her essay her move from rural Minnesota to New York City in 1978 and how suddenly norms and rules change for her. In Minnesota it is the custom to greet everyone you meet on the road, even though you do not know the person. If you pass someone in silence, you will be considered as discourteous and it can lead to accusations of snobbery. This is the worst and rudest possible thing you can do and it gets compared as a sin in the egalitarian state. A good place to start is the title of the essay ‘Living With Strangers’, because it sums up the thesis in the text and Hustvedt’s point with the text. The title refers to a major problem in every city - whether it is a big or small one, and it is because the society that we live in now has changed and is still changing. The late modern society is characterized by the fact, that we no longer are bound by old traditions and habits. We are......

Words: 949 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Essay on Living with Strangers

...Essay “Living with Strangers” Minnesota and New York are two thoroughly diverse cities, but still there are exceptions of this belief - they both, like every other city in the world, have their own tacit norms and proprieties. Cultures and societies have through time build ethics, which people outside the given group or civilization won’t understand. It can be everything from simply greeting each other, from rural Minnesota where “hi” slip of people’s tongues like honey to New York where its normal to live side by side with strangers, and addressing others on the street will make you seem ridiculous. This huge culture gap is what inspired Siri Hustvedt to write her anecdote “Living with Strangers”. The text is an essay, which is characterized by several things. It’s a non-fictional text, which means its about something real, and relates to this in an unbiased way. It is a very subjective style, written from a personal point of view, where the writer used own experience and reflections: “When I moved to New York in 1978, I quickly discovered what it meant to live among hordes of strangers…”. You can tell the text is personal by the fact that “I” is used a lot. The way of writing will seem very convincing to the ready. Hustvedt uses the ethos argument and therefore seems truthful and upstanding as a writer about this particular topic. The title represents the main topic quite well, as it refers to a very common paradox in urban societies - we have been to the moon...

Words: 944 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Hospitality in the Iliad and Odyssey

...The Gods of Hospitality in Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey In Homer’s the Iliad and the Odyssey, much is made of hospitality as a recurring theme. In Ancient Greece the gods demand it. The nature and extent to which society today follows in that tradition has changed in form only, but not in substance. Food, shelter and protection of strangers from cultural norms of today, as the people of Ancient Greece were more inclined to take in strangers worn weary by travel. In the Iliad, the reader sees that in times of war, hospitality is provided to even the enemy. Housing strangers in one’s home was very common then, as many weary travelers trod by foot or sailed by boat to reach far-off destinations, making stops along the way. Moreover, since the Greeks believed the gods walked the earth amongst them, then turning down a travelers request, could mean rejecting a god masked from view. The Greeks took no chances in this regard; and with only a few exceptions, Homer’s literary characters comply with this religious doctrine and cultural norm. Hospitality in Ancient Greece, as portrayed by Homer, accounts, in part, for their longstanding world dominance and aligns itself in many ways with the Christianity enjoyed by many peace-loving nations of today. The guest-host relationship in both The Iliad and The Odyssey remain constant, the differences between the two dependent only on the differing circumstances posed by each tale (Biggs, Joseph, Schrodt & Dustan, n.d.) Today,......

Words: 3496 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Living with Strangers

...“Living With Strangers” Many people think that urban life in big cities means a happy life, with no worries and just pure happiness. But what is happiness? And what makes us think that urban life is pure happiness? In the essay “Living With Strangers” by Siri Hustvedt, we hear about a woman's move from the countryside of Minnesota, to the Big Apple in New York City. Her move is described with many comparisons with her previous life and experiences, and a lot of humor, which underlines her situation and her attitude to urban life. In the following essay I am going to analyze and comment on Siri Hustvedt’s essay “Living With Strangers”. Part of my essay will focus on the genre, the attitude to urban living and the contrasts between Siri’s life in Minnesota and her new life in New York City. As said, the essay is based on Siri Hustvedt’s own life and experiences. Siri Hustvedt grew up in Minnesota, where everybody knows and greets each other. Now she lives in New York City where nobody seems to care about each other, and where greeting strangers would be “impractical and unsound”. This is a big change for her, and she uses an overwhelming amount of detailed descriptions to describe her situation in the Big Apple. She uses many personal experiences and examples, which characterizes the essay genre. Furthermore, she is very reflective, descriptive, subjective and very personal in her way of writing the essay. “It didn’t take long for me to absorb the unwritten code of......

Words: 1138 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Siri Hustvedt Living with Strangers

...B ‘Living With Strangers’ An enforced closeness that exclusively belongs to boyfriends and family is something you cannot run from when being on the sidewalk in New York City. So is this the definition of the so-called living with strangers? Siri Hustvedt is an American author who in 2002 wrote the personal essay ‘Living With Strangers’. She simply raises the pros and cons of living together in the big city of New York – in a very non-simplistic way. With personal experiences and thoughts throughout the whole essay, she holds on to the reader’s attention from the very first line. I will mainly focus on the choice of genre, together with the linguistic instruments that Siri Hustvedt uses in her essay. There are a lot of basics that feature the characteristics of a personal essay. The personal essay is often focused on a belief or an insight about life. It combines elements as the narrative’s former experiences or relationships and raises questions about open answers. Only this genre permits Siri to be subjective on a topic where the essay still has a professional level of seriousness, while the intimate connection between sender and receiver creates a certain sense of ethos that helps Siri convincing her audience. This genre also gives Hustvedt the space to express her experiences in a way to convince us of her impression of “Living With Strangers”. Although, there is not a precise view being shared as the personal essay’s main argument: Instead it is more a meticulous......

Words: 919 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Joan Didion on Going Home

...November 29th, 2013 Strangers and how we perceive them. I was appalled by the sight of a young girl, malnourished, dirty, in torn cloths crying and begging for money on Ahmedabad Street in India. Just as I reached for my purse to give her some money, my host, Dr. Dalal pushed me aside, gestured me inside our parked car, locked the doors and exclaimed “I should have warned you! Haven’t you seen the movie “Slumdog Millionaire?” I was left shaking, words cannot describe the horror I felt for not helping out a poor desolate child. How could this helpless child be a victim of an organized crime of self-made beggars? To answer this question would be an essay in itself, however, I describe this, as one of many etched incidences in my life to illustrate that I misrecognized the beggar and was influenced by someone else’s preconceived stereotype image of “other, a stranger described as a beggar” that was different then us. The notion of “other and misrecognition” is described in Toni Morrison’s essay “Strangers” (1998) when she explores this concept by depicting a stranger as an image of a bizarre fisherwomen dressed in men’s clothing; while Brent Staples portrays his own image as a stranger and depicts how he is perceived as a threat to others in his essay “Black Men and Public Space” (1986). Although both Morrison and Staples offer differing accounts of their experiences and feelings, they both share the same vision, the correlation between “how we see strangers” versus “how......

Words: 1525 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Jane Jacobs and Streets

...forth. Jane Jacobs suggests that solution for sidewalk and city safety. In her book she states that “public peace…is not kept primarily by the police. It is kept primarily by an intricate, almost unconscious, network of voluntary controls and standards among the people themselves” (Jacobs 32). In short, Jacobs says that the people themselves take charge of their own safety. The more people there, the more sets of eyes there are. The more eyes there are patrolling the streets the safer they will be. As I have observed on Broad Street and Main Street in Lansdale, more people start coming out and about during noon time. As more people come out there are more eyes to “watch the sidewalks in sufficient numbers” (Jacobs 35). Jacobs’ solution to sidewalk safety is to add more sets of eyes to watch over the pedestrians and other citizens. But how should the people be enticed to come out and keep watch? Jacobs lists and explains a few solutions to draw the populace out and make use of the sidewalks. She says “the basic requisite for such surveillance is a substantial quantity of stores and other public places sprinkled along the sidewalks of a district; enterprises and public places that are used by evening and night must be among them especially. Stores, bars and restaurants as the chief examples, work in server different and complex ways to abet sidewalk safety (Jacobs 36). I have discovered that on Broad Street and Main Street there are several of the bars and restaurants......

Words: 1610 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Are Our Children Too Sheltered

...taught about the danger of strangers. They learn at an early age that they should not talk to strangers. This practice is known as “Stranger Danger.” This fear of strangers has stemmed into parents wanting to have more control over their children, and trying to avoid having bad things happen to them. Naturally, no parent wants to see harm come to their children. As a result of being overprotected, children are becoming more and more sheltered. Children are often reliant on their parents until a much older age than what used to be considered the norm. In this paper, I will examine how “Stranger Danger” and its effects on childrens’ independence can be researched. I will examine the methods of research available. By examining the available types of research, I will further explore the types that best pertain to finding the answers to my question of whether or not “Stranger Danger” has caused us to shelter our children too much. Research Methods Existing Sources The first method of research is the use of existing sources. Many sources of information exist. The internet is a very useful tool in finding information that pertains to this theory. When using Google to search for the term “Stranger Danger,” one is presented with a wide array of choices. I chose to look for credible websites that could provide relevant information. The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children issued a press release stating their view on “Stranger Danger”. Nancy McBride,......

Words: 1411 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Living with Strangers

...Living with strangers Living with Strangers is an essay written by Siri Hustvedt, and in it she discusses the difference between life in the big city and life in the countryside. More precisely, she discusses the difference in social rules and her opinion on it. Siri begins by briefly describing to the reader how one was expected to behave where she grew up. Whenever you encountered someone on the road, whether you knew them or not, you should always greet them. If you didn’t, you would be considered both rude and a snob, which was pretty much the worst thing you could be in that part of rural Minnesota. When Siri moved to New York City in 1978 and she was met by a world vastly different from what she knew, and quickly learned that the social code of conduct was quite different as well. Greeting everyone you meet simply isn’t practical in downtown New York, as you are confronted with hordes of people every time you leave the apartment. On the subway, you are forced into such close contact with strangers that you can smell their hair oil, perfume and sweat, a level of intimacy reserved for lovers and family in rural Minnesota. Another phenomenon of big city life, or coping technique as she calls it, is that whenever something odd happens in the public space, you simply pretend it isn’t happening. She presents several examples of strange people doing strange things, and every single spectator simply minding their own business. To give any kind of response is viewed......

Words: 837 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Reaction Journal for “Navigation My Eerie Landscape Alone”.

...people from outside who are so afraid of doing the wrong things that they prefer to do nothing at all. The Author tells us that a few years ago all his life was completely changed. He had battled glaucoma for 20 years, but one day after lunch he recognized that his eyes had hemorrhaged. Jim Bobryk describes how different vision in his eyes helped him as "a navigator in this eerie landscape". Except his feelings, the Author writes about reaction of people of different ages from the street when they seen the human as wielding his stick. Also, the article is about how the Author builds relationship with his friends in new situations. The article "Navigation My Eerie Landscape Alone" involves an important topic because strangers do not really know how to keep balance of not to offend blind people. From my experience, I had the same questions: “Will my friendliness be misconstrued by the disabled as pity? Will an offer of help sound patronizing?” If I do not know the human personal, I will never know his reaction and I will prefer to “do nothing rather than take the risk of offending the blind.” Of course, if I will see that such people need help or if they are in a dangerous situation, I will not wait one second to help them. The problem is some of these people do not want to feel that they are different and they often become upset very quickly. Strangers often try to be tactful and do not want to hurt the feelings of a blind person. When I think about my reaction in the......

Words: 491 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Stories of the Companions

... One day.. . let his friend `Ammaar Ibn Yaasir tell us what happened on that day: I met Suhaib lbn Sinaan in front of the door of Daar Al-Arqam when the Prophet (PBUH) was there. I asked, "What do you want?" He answered, "And what do you want?" I said, "I want to meet Muhammad (PBUH) to hear what he is saying." He said, "I want the same." We both entered and met the Prophet (PBUH), who invited us to embrace Islam, and we converted. We stayed as we were till evening. Secretly he went out. Thereupon, Suhaib got to know his path to Daar Al- Arqam. He got to know his path to guidance and light, but also to difficult sacrifice and great redemption. Entering through that wooden door, which separated Daar Al-Arqam and what was inside from the outer world, was not just crossing a threshold, but crossing of a whole world of limitations. An old world, with all that represented it - religion, manners, customs and life - crossing it towards a new world with all that represented it - religion, manners, customs, and life. Crossing the threshold of Daar Al-Arqam, a threshold not wider than one foot, meant, in reality, to cross an ocean of terror, wide and expanding. Stepping over such an obstacle, such a threshold, meant the beginning of an era full of great responsibilities. As for the poor, the stranger, the enslaved, stepping over Daar Al-Arqam's threshold meant exceptional, extraordinary sacrifices. Suhaib, our hero, was a stranger; Ammar Ibn Yaasir, his friend whom he met in front of...

Words: 553 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Living with Strangers

...hopeless to make someone notice you and send a smile your way, because while you acknowledge people they don’t acknowledge you. They’ve all grown accustomed to the oblivion that comes with big city life, or rather the feigned state of oblivion. We may all get drawn to it thanks to numerous movies and TV series romanticising it, but in fact adjusting to the big city, where things are getting lively, is somewhat of an acquired taste. This is some of the things that Siri Hustvedt emphasises in the essay “Living With Strangers”. Siri Hustvedt begins her essay with writing about the “culture shock” she is met by when she first moves to New York City. In her hometown in rural Minnesota it was a custom to greet everyone that you walked past even if you didn’t know the person. The most important part of the greeting when passing by someone was to actually speak the word “hi”. “When I moved to New York City in 1978, I quickly discovered what it meant to live among hordes of strangers and how impractical and unsound it would be to greet all of them.” (p. 1, l. 6-8). You will quickly realise that you need to adapt to the new environment and follow the rules that people in the vicinity live by. Another thing that Siri Hustvedt emphasises is a law that she learns is the way to get through the hell that is public transportation in New York City. “The simple law, one nearly every New Yorker subscribes to whenever possible, is: PRETEND IT ISN’T HAPPENING.” (l.19-20). She explains that is......

Words: 1407 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay


...‘Walter Mitty’ in each of us? Do we fear what people would think of us; how they would laugh behind our backs; or is it simply the pre-conceived notion that “Nobody would understand”? Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to real world! A world where one feels lost among 6.8 billion faces; and finds solace when he just whiles away hours staring at the ceiling fan, ‘pretending’ to sleep. In the real world, things couldn’t get more ‘realistic’ than this… Or could they? “Life is a long-long road and we are but travelers.” And like good travelers who are faithful to their voyage, we must journey on; in search of a niche where we would ‘fit in’, a niche that is symbolic of our ‘selves’. Why aren’t we told to enrich our voyage with experiences as enthralling as the adventures of Alice in Wonderland? Perhaps that is the reason why we fade into a world of our own every now and then. Because the outside world has nothing to offer (or so it may seem…), we seek our “Some place far away…” within ourselves… There’s a difference between loneliness and solitude… The strangest thing is that in spite of having encountered both these emotions, none of us have the acumen of explaining the difference between the two. What we do not realize is that in this ‘space’ that we have created, there is no solitude… only loneliness; void and hollow loneliness. Why is it that people whom we’ve known forever seem like complete strangers; and then someday when we come across a complete stranger, we feel that we’ve......

Words: 690 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Applicable Ccm Concepts and Theories from the Terminal

...culture and it can be seen as a “weak culture”. From weak culture to strong culture, Navorski was inevitably discriminated by local people when he went to US. Gupta, the airport cleaner, is guilty for killing a policeman in India, though this, he broke his words and didn’t give Navorski vouchers that he promised to give on Tuesday. As a result, Navorski could only eat a few snacks. Gupta also suspected he was from CIA to investigate him and only after post-test machine ensured he was not dangerous was Gupta willing to play card with Navorski. Ordinary people treated him like this, let alone some airport officials. Frank always excluded Navorski, giving him small space to sleep, finding someone to replace his job of arranging shopping carts found by himself. Because of difference in language, behavior and culture, Navorsiki was treated unequally by American’s Ethnocentrism. 3. Culture shock Kalervo Oberg describes culture shock as the anxiety generated by entering a new culture environment from a familiar culture. Culture shock escalate people’s attitude towards new culture. Simmel argues that strange feeling among groups in different culture is mutual, while people in new culture is strange to a stranger from another culture and the stranger is also strange to local people. Instinctive reaction to potential danger from a stranger is distrust and rejection. For example: When asking surrounding people for help on using the calling card, Navorski was refused by all the......

Words: 1088 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Service Strategy

...relationships btw providers and customers gonna experience 4 steps from strangers to acquaintance to friends to partners. Today, I’m goona follow this structure to analyses and let u guys know how translink building relationships with customers. Even that I know probably half of the people doesn’t into translink at all. As a division of department of transport and main roads, it's a public transport system that service in queensland and aim to provide a single integrated transport network accessible to everyone. Vision: making travel easy; purpose: lead, plan, specify and provide mass transit for the people in south east queensland. Customers as strangers Strangers are those customers who have not yet had any transaction( interaction ) with a firm and may not even be aware of the firm. Take me as an example, I remembered the first time that set my foot on Brisbane was around 2 years ago, at that time, I have no idea about translink. My homestay dad and housemate told me that I need to buy a go card to take public transportation, which is easy and convenient. My housemate took me had the first experience by public transportation from my place to uni. And she told me I need to learn how to take bus. Believe it or not, at that time, I thought what?! I’m not 3 years old, of course I know how to take it. But it turns out, I do need to learn. I saw my housemate hail to the bus when it comes. And the bus driver say good day to us. It was such a surprise to me, coz in my hometown......

Words: 1450 - Pages: 6