Free Essay

A Streetcar Named Desire- the Conflict Between Stanley and Blanche

In:

Submitted By oscarfulffycat
Words 1843
Pages 8
The nature of Stanley and Blanche’s conflict is mainly verbal (conflict is about power struggle, who has control over the other characters) Williams presents this through their verbal interactions, his use of language shows their animosity.The conflict is one in which Stanley is constantly squaring up to Blanche as if to see who has the upper hand. The conflict began with Stanley’s suspicions of Blanche when he heard of the demise of Belle Reve. Williams parallels his use of negative language with Blanche’s impressions of Stanley; with Blanche appearing to pull Mitch away from Stanley and by changing who appears have most control over Stella. Williams demonstrates the theme of conflict through verbal and physical interactions as well symbolism as shown below. The first sign of the conflict between Stanley and Blanche is at the very beginning in Act One Scene Two. Blanche has revealed to Stella that their childhood home ‘Belle Reve,’ has been lost, what she doesn’t explain is the nature of how it was lost. When Stella explains to Stanley he begins to grow suspicious of Blanche, thinking that she has sold ‘Belle Reve,’ swindling Stella of her share of the money and through her, swindled him. He begins to rummage through her stuff, looking through her clothing when Blanche appears. Blanche starts off with flirtatiously asking Stanley to do up the buttons on her dress and begins “fishing for a compliment” from Stanley. All this does is rile him up and make him more suspicious of how sincere a person she really is. When she begins to insult his intelligence he begins to react with a cutting quickness that Blanche throws back at him with more flirtation. When he begins to look through her dead husbands letters “ripping the ribbon off to examine them” it is more than Blanche can bear saying “Now that you’ve [Stanley] touched them I’ll burn them!” This first fight helps us to understand the conflict of the play as a whole as it gives the audience an insight as to how Blanche views Stanley as lesser than him and how Stanley resents Blanche for her actions in this scene.

The dramatist has been clever in ‘The Poker’ scene as he has presented the situation of the escalating conflict Stanley is facing first through verbal abuse to the inhabitants of the room, then when Stanley notices this has little effect he becomes physically violent. Stanley has already been losing his hand, his pride is wounded and because his friends are having fun and joking with each other rather than pitying him and his poor hand, he becomes agitated that they are ignoring him, so he begins to create minor arguments with the minor characters. When Stella and Blanche come in, Stella’s attention is mainly on Blanche rather than Stanley, further upsetting him so he begins to order them to be quiet. Mitch then leaves the game to talk to Blanche, undermining his dominant position in his group that one of his friends should choose her company over his, especially when his friend and his wife start dancing with the enemy to music on the radio. As verbal threats are not working in removing attention from Blanche he goes into a physical mode. He “stalks fiercely” to the “small white radio and snatches it off the table… he tosses the instrument out the window.” This physicality is shocking to the audience as throughout the play so far he has been a verbal antagonist, adding drama to the scene. When Stella tries to fight back he feels this is the perfect opportunity to show Blanche who is boss in this household and hits Stella.The dramatist presents this in a physical format for two reasons. One is because Stanley can see that verbal warnings haven't worked on Blanche to gain his control over her so he gives her a physical message by hitting Stella, a woman he does have control over. The second reason is because it will be more shocking to the audience, here is a man who is hitting a woman, its a dramatic shift from the verbal to the physical. This also enhances the understanding of the theme of conflict in the play.

Scene IV is a key moment in the play as it is the moment Blanche truly reveals what she thinks of Stanley- while Stanley listens. After Stanley hits Stella, Blanche feels anxious that Stella should leave and tries to convince Stella that he’s no good for her. “He acts like an animal, has an animals habits! Eats like one, moves like one, talks like one!” As Stanley hears all this his pride is stung, he begins to form an idea of Blanche and the desire to remove her influence over Stella drives him to form a cruel plan to get rid of her. When he enters and Stella rushes over to greet him, he knows he has won part of the battle, Stella trusts him over Blanche and this proves to him that he is loved more. This scene enhances the understanding of the play as a whole as it shows us what drives Stanley to bring Blanche’s downfall in a cruel manner whereas previously, in Scene two, it only shows the beginning of his dislike towards Blanche.

Williams presents Stanley’s next moves in a verbal format, as this creates tension in the play as it is unknown when Stanley will become physical next. In Scene VIII, Blanche is meant to be celebrating her birthday, which in Stanley’s eyes show that he is losing his dominant place in his house to Blanche as it is a day for celebrating her. While Blanche and Stella are having a conversation he grows more and more agitated, becoming more sullen by the moment. Stella comments on how disgusting his fingers are, even throwing Blanches’ previous animal comments in his face, which elicits both verbal and minor physical actions. Williams has presented it in both verbal and physical as it shows how much of a loose cannon Stanley is at this moment, creating fear for both Stella and Blanche as he may harm them. By throwing plates and creating a mess he is asserting his place as the alpha male and by shouting at the two women, he is reminding them of their place. Later in the scene Stanley is about to leave but before he does he gives Blanche a birthday “gift”. His presentation of the ticket back to Lorel is a cruelly calculated move on Williams part, Stanley leaving the house at that moment shows that he can leave then return again while Blanche has a one way ticket out of the door. He does this to again assert his position in the household and try to control Blanche in some manner. This further adds to the conflict of the play, showing Stanley is slowly winning the battle over Blanche.

In scene X, the physical conflict between Stanley and Blanche is once again shown, used in a manner that allows Stanley to finally gain control over Blanche. The conflict starts much like any other with use of verbal sparring to create tension to a crueller extent. Blanche has retreated into her fantasy world and Stanley goes along with it for a time, allowing her to feel as though she has control over the situation to make her demise a more dramatic feature to the audience. In this scene Williams uses minor character s outside the apartment to foreshadow Stanley’s actions. “A prostitute rolls a drunkard. He pursues her along the walk, overtakes her and there is a struggle.” much the same thing is happening to Blanche and Stanley; he returns home drunk and her colourful background plants the idea that he can just take what he wants and it will be acceptable. The stage directions of the drunkard- he pursues her- is what Stanley does here; he lets Blanche create a fanatical reality for herself to protect herself. The final stage direction “overtakes her and there is a struggle” is exactly what happens between Stanley and Blanche. He destroys her with his words, finding holes in her plot and she has to struggle to retain the imaginative story she has created. Williams uses this Shakespearean technique of having the minor characters mirroring the main characters this way to show how the plot will play out to the audience, to create a terrible knowledge of what is about to happen. The stage directions here help enhance our understanding of the play as it shows that it was always going to come down to Stanley defeating Blanche and it was only a matter of time before he took her.

The final act of conflict between Stanley and Blanche occurs after a time lapse, where Blanche has told Stella of her rape but rather than being pitied, she is being sent away to an asylum. This shows how Stanley has finally established his position of Alpha against Blanche, proving to her that he is the one with the most control over Stella and amongst his friends. A final act of conflict is a symbolic move on Stanley’s part. At one point Blanche had placed a paper lantern over a lightbulb in the kitchen, partly to hide the light but it is also a symbolic gesture of her trying to take over Stanley’s position in the house as the dominant character. While Blanche is in a state of confusion about her leaving and her vain attempts to escape, Stanley sees an opportunity to make an example of her to everyone in the house. “You want the lantern?” is a question Stanley asks, its his way of saying “You want my place here?” The stage actions Williams uses “He… seizes the paper lantern, tearing it from the light bulb,” shows how easily Stanley has destroyed her, especially when Blanches’ reaction is one of horror and pain. The dramatist has done this to show how dominant Stanley is now that he has destroyed Blanche, to show the audience and characters in the play that he has won and to warn off any challengers to his place. When Blanche is finally taken away and Stella is crying out for her whilst trying to look after her newly born baby, Stanley sees it as him losing attention so he places himself in front of her, removes the child and shows her who her attention is meant to be on. This enhances our understanding of the play as it highlights how much control Stanley now has, yet still has the paranoia about him that this attention may slip at any point.

To conclude, the nature of the conflict between Stanley and Blanche has many variables; at times it is symbolic, other physical but more often than not it is a verbal conflict that shows the audience how Stanley deals with anyone who invades or threatens his authority over his wife and friends. Williams uses these techniques to create drama in the piece, adding tension and creating a more shocking climax.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

A Conflict as a Poker Game

...paper A Conflict as a Poker Game In the early twentieth century, women were still dependent on men. It was difficult for a woman to have a job and be financially independent. In addition, at this time, women had to keep their virginity to have a chance to get married. A Streetcar Named Desire by Tennessee Williams is placed in the picturesque French Quarter in New Orleans. The play starts when Blanche DuBois comes in New Orleans to visit her sister Stella after she lost the family plantation Belle-Reve because of money problems. She then meets her brother-in-law Stanley Kowalski, a World War II veteran. As soon as they meet each other, a mistrustful rivalry starts between them. A Streetcar Named Desire depicts the conflict between two opposing views as a poker game between Blanche and Stanley for control. From the beginning of the play, Williams starts distinguishing Stanley and Blanche by their mentalities. In fact, Blanche has the Old South mentality. She grew up in a plantation where she learnt how to behave as an aristocrat whereas her brother-in-law is an industrial and a Polish immigrant representing the New South. Blanche is described as delicate and fragile whereas Stanley is rude and violent. Blanche lives in a world of illusion. She acts as a queen and wants the men to treat her like it. Unlike Blanche, Stanley lives in a rude world, a world where if a person are strong enough physically and mentally, he or she can succeed. In addition, Williams opposes Stanley and...

Words: 2039 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Censorship In A Streetcar Named Desire Essay

...Censorship in A Streetcar Named Desire Author of A Streetcar Named Desire - Tennessee Williams - stated that his plays are “Pleas for the understanding of delicate people”. A Streetcar Named Desire explores dysfunctional relationships and conflicts that arise in the breakdown. The 1930’s production code forced Kazan - director of A Streetcar Named Desire - to change the original text. The censors of the Breen Office forced Kazan to omit the film’s raw and candid portrayal of human behavior and relationships. Because the Breen Office controlled of the film industry, it definitely took away the audience’s understanding of the characters and their relationships especially in Stella’s descending of the staircase, dialogue between Blanche and Stella,...

Words: 729 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Streetcar Named Desire

...A Streetcar Named Desire Choose a play in which a central concern is clarified by the contrast between two characters.Discuss how the dramatist’s presentation of the contrast between the two characters adds to your understanding of this central concern. | * The theme of appearance versus reality is clarified by the differences between Blanche and Stanley. * Blanche represents illusion/false appearance – she tries to hide her past, her age. * Stanley represents reality – he is very honest and upfront about the type of person he is, he has no secrets. * They conflict throughout and finally Stanley crushes Blanche’s illusions (by revealing her secrets, confronting her about her lies and raping her) * Reveals the message of the theme – reality will win over illusion, you cannot live a lie. | Choose from a play a scene in which tension builds to a climax.Explain how the dramatist creates and develops this tension, and discuss the extent to which the scene has thematic as well as dramatic significance. | * Scene 10 (the rape scene) builds to a climax with tension being created through the conflict between Blanche and Stanley and the stage directions. * Blanche acts increasingly hysterical and irrational. * Stanley snaps after she calls him a swine and cruelly crushes her illusions, telling her she’s a liar. He becomes threatening and violent and eventually rapes her. * The menacing stage directions (sound, lighting, the streets of New Orleans) add to...

Words: 2227 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Comparison of Streetcar Named Desire the Play and the Movie

...Janet Ng Professor Faunce WRT 102 7 March 2012 Textual Analysis of A Streetcar Named Desire Based on Tennessee William’s A Streetcar Named Desire, Elia Kazan creates an award winning movie that helps readers visualize Stanley’s primal masculinity, the inner torments of the Kowalski women and the clash of the other characters’ problems which create a chaotic mess. Using stage directions in the play, William hints that Blanche is not who she appears to be while the movie subtly sheds light on Blanche’s strange little habits that suggests a bigger issue. The movie also censors many of the main themes in Williams’ play but makes up for it by having its actors flawlessly portray the characters’ emotions, allowing the readers to see the conflict at its full magnitude. Both the movie and the play sympathize with the powerless women by underlining the important theme of women’s dependence on men. Blanche is an insecure, miserable older woman who masks herself as a rich, upper class lady. She continues to shy from reality and seduce men as she cannot comprehend that her reliance on men will ultimately lead to her downfall. “Now run along, now, quickly! It would be nice to keep you, but I’ve got to be good-and keep my hands off children.” (Williams, pg 99) This isn’t the first time that Blanche has put moves on a kid as made evident when she states “I’ve got to be good and keep my hands off children.” She clearly hasn’t learned her lesson after losing her job. The scene is even more...

Words: 1838 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

A Street Car Named Desire

... The character of Blanche Dubois in the story of A Streetcar Named Desire is considered a tragic protagonist for the various conflicts she is suffering both internally and externally. It is mainly her self-delusion that ultimately leads to her destruction and the reason she is committed to an insane asylum. From the very beginning of the play we can tell that Blanche is being standoffish and not revealing everything. For instance, Blanche tells her sister in scene one that she’s simply taking a leave of absence from her job as a schoolteacher. In reality Blanche has been fired from her position and was basically run out of the town she is from because of her scandalous behavior. Blanche has been lying to so many people for so long, she can no longer can see the delineation between fantasy and reality. Blanche’s husband’s death at his own hands causes her a great deal of anxiety and guilt. We realize she is most haunted by that scene of her husband’s suicide, and that the memory is present by the sound of the polka music and then the sound of a gunshot. The death of all her older relatives and the loss of the family mansion Belle Reve contribute further to her mental instability. The struggle between Blanche and her brother in law Stanley Kowalski are a major focal point of A Streetcar Named Desire; almost immediately after meeting Blanche, Stanly has formed an opinion of her and doesn’t hold back from letting it be known how he feels about her. Stanley is a workingman, he...

Words: 961 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Ds Sda Dsd Asf Asfasf Safasf

...of Blanche tragic life Abstract : As one of the most important play writers of America after the World War Ⅱ, Tennessee Williams won lots of theatrical awards for his masterpiece A Streetcar Named Desire. As a result, Blanche, the heroine in the play, had been the focus point of the critics. This thesis tries to analyze profoundly the cause of the tragedy of Blanche from several aspects .As Williams T concluded, ‘The heroine Blanche was struggling between reality and fantasy, finally, her spirit was broken drastically under the beat of ruthless reality. She was the typical weak woman and victim in the patriarchal society. Her tragedy shows that the woman can’t escape the control of the typical patriarchal society in any case of resistances.’(Williams, 2).Some of William’s points will be elaborated in this paper which includes four parts. Chapter one serves as an “introduction”, which gives a general review of main characters in the novel. Chapter two, “Character of Blanche” ,Blanche’s being trapped by the conventionality; Blanche’s illusion about men; Blanche’s illusion about herself; her husband’s suicide; Stanley’s rude behavior and sense of dominance; Stella’s betrayal; Mitch’s desertion and the cold realistic world. In conclusion, it is the Blanche’s illusion about men ,herself and cruelty of Stanley that mainly causes her tragedy. Keywords: tragedy conventionality illusion 1.Introduction 1.1 Review of the protagonist In Tennessee Williams' "A Streetcar Named...

Words: 4562 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

What Does The Paper Lantern Symbolize Blanche Dubois

...Tennessee Williams utilizes the symbol of the paper lantern to underline the differing characters of Blanche and Stanley who stand in contrast concerning their attitudes towards light. As to why she bought the lantern Blanche states, "I can't stand a naked light bulb, any more than I can a rude remark or vulgar action" (Williams 60). With negative word choice of 'rude', 'vulgar' and 'naked', she emphasizes her distaste of being exposed in the light and into reality. The paper lantern that Blanche brings into their home symbolizes her desire to cover up anything and make it appear tantalizing. Her life mirrors that of the lightbulb and the lantern, as she hides her faults and insecurities and reinvents herself. While the lantern solidifies Blanche as a symbol of illusion, it is the interaction between Stanley and the lantern that solidifies the theme of illusion and reality....

Words: 580 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Class In Ralph Ellison's The Invisible Man

...time conflicts took place regarding race and society. These Issues of race, class and gender roles are due to inability to accept and embrace the new social order. In many of these texts read this semester involved issues of race and the way people in the south responded to it. In Ralph Ellison’s The Invisible Man, the issue of race affects the story’s unnamed main character. The main character was invisible to the white higher class white men. The narrator’s skills were...

Words: 1170 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Overshadowing Deception

...revealed. When reading through a book or play, many people do not delve beyond the surface, focusing only on prominent characteristics and dominant traits throughout the book. However, it is possible to find the deception behind each personality within a book if one analyzes the character's beyond their superficial facade. Since the beginning of time, humans have always stumbled on a boarder between appearance and reality, using deception to mask weaknesses and obscure the harsh eye of society. By examining A Street Car Named Desire by Tennessee Williams, Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing, and The Unabridged Journals Of Sylvia Plath by Sylvia Plath the deception humans use in order to appear stronger in society are revealed. In the play, A Streetcar Named Desire by Tennessee Williams, there is a dominant theme of deception portrayed by the three main characters in the play. Stella Kowalski, Stanley Kowalski, and Blanche DuBois all have simple personalities that are extremely skewed by the end of the book. Stella states "I'm not in anything I want to get out of," (Williams, 74). This gives Blanche a huge reality check, because someone she adores has accepted such an average life, and has given up in her pursue for perfection, even if most of it is imaginary. This deception also plays a huge role in Much Ado About Nothing by Shakespeare, through a continuos series of twists throughout the book and hidden motifs, that cannot be seen by the reader until the characters themselves accept...

Words: 1010 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Understanding

...that conflict is inevitable when pride is at stake." A Streetcar Named Desire is based on betrayal, happiness, and drama. The quote explains about Blanche and Stanley's pride of the difference between fantasy vs. reality. Blanche Dubois, is Stella's older sister. She is a high school English teacher in Laurel, Mississippi and is also in her 30s. She left her town and went to her sister's house in New Orleans. She hoped she can start a new life and leave her past at Laurel. Stella is married to a man name Stanley Kowalski, who is kind to his friends, loves Stella a lot, but dislikes Blanche. Throughout the play he is always nasty to her and tries to destroy Blanche's mental emotions. The theme of the play is fantasy vs. reality. Stanley shows it throughout the play. Stanley shows how powerful and shows pride. In Scene 4, Blanche tells Stella that they must talk. Blanche tells Stella that she doesn't like the way that Stanley treats her and he is not a gentleman. She refers Stanley to animalistic man, and calls him common. He overheard the conversation, this made him upset and hurt. When Blanche first came to New Orleans there seemed tension already with Blanche and Stanley. Stanley enjoys keeping his roles in his home, shows that he is the man of the house. He likes spending time with his friends and his love for Stella is very important to him. Ever since Blanche has came to the Kowalski's house, Stella has been paying more attention to Blanche more than Stanley. He feels...

Words: 770 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Character Analysis: A Streetcar Named Desire

...Aia Kattaya Dr. Duni English 1011 2 November, 2015 Who am I? A conflict can be characterized as a condition of resistance between two strengths and is fundamental to the human experience. There are a myriad of factors which can catalyze conflict between individuals, groups, men, the environment, and within one’s Self. Inner conflicts can be brought by a struggle with the encompassing conditions or others. Internal conflict is related to the questions you ask yourself about right compared to wrong, or good compared to bad. These conflicts are usually a result of a two-headed issue happening in your life and can be something exceptionally straightforward or extremely complex in nature. Everyone is experiencing internal conflict now and again....

Words: 1886 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Blanche Dubois In A Streetcar Named Desire

...In A Streetcar Named Desire, Tennessee Williams suggests in many ways that Blanche Dubois represent the faded grandeur of the American Past. Blanche acts as if she is still living in the old South where everything seems prim and proper, but she has yet to realize that things have changed. She is used to her old life in Belle Reve, which in French means “beautiful dream”, but has difficulty fitting in her new life in New Orleans. Blanche's life in Laurel Represents the past and moving to live in New Orleans shows the New South. Blanche is deeply attached to Laurel and Belle Reve and has lived there her whole life, she lived a much wealthier life there and hates to see how her sister Stella is living in New Orleans. Blanche is stuck in the past...

Words: 814 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Nothing

...was inevitably a loss of attention to the treatment of women by their own sisters in feminism. By the 1940s, women had made social, economic and political strides by gaining access to higher education, working in predominantly male sectors, and by voting and lobbying for gender equality legislation. This allowed women to compete in the same spheres as men, resulting in a blurring of the once distinct boundaries between the male and female worlds. This intersection of the sexes had two effects: first, because women were no longer confined to domestic work, they had less incentives to remain in dominantly female circles; second, because women could operate in the male world as individuals, they had to learn to mirror male patterns of dominance or portray the traditional role of women. These combined effects resulted in the breakdown of sisterhood as women distanced themselves from female bonds in order to gain power in the male world. This fall of sisterhood is evident in literature, which I will convey through an analysis of three selections: A Streetcar Named Desire, a play by Tennessee Williams; “Recitatif,” a short story by Toni Morrison; and “Everyday Use,” a short story by Alice Walker. First, I will...

Words: 1739 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Streetcar Named Desire Illusion Vs Reality Essay

...comprehend as truth that results in chasing numerous negative things that ended up in destruction. In the play, A Streetcar Named Desire by Tennessee Williams explores the idea that when an individual seeks to reconcile the conflict between illusion and reality, it makes an individual weak since, an Illusion has affected their mind and brain so effectively, that they prefer to live in an illusion and believe in their false perception, which results in becoming insane at the end. Blanche DuBois, a desperate and psychotic lady, who was...

Words: 826 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

A Streetcar Named Desire

...Stanley Kowalski is a distinguished character in the play A Streetcar Named Desire, he is Stella’s husband, (a women which is from an upper class family) however he comes from a very different and less elegant background, than both Stella and Blanche (Stella’s older sister). We can tell this from the first impression Blanche give ‘Where were you? In bed with your Polack!’ this shows the clear lack of respect that Blanche has not only towards Stanley but towards Polish people and people of a lower class, we know that Blanche shows no guilt in what she has just said as she said it in such a shocking and shameful gesture, she is also clearly referring to him as a ‘lower class working man’. In Scene 1, Stanley is shown as having ‘animal joy’ and being a ‘richly feathered male bird’ this shows his superiority and this is also shown in most of his conversations that he has with his friends and wife, Stanley is typically the dominant speaker, he refuses to accept that someone tells him that his actions are wrong and he shows this throughout the play when he uses Stella’s upper class status against her by mentioning his ‘Napoleonic code’ meaning that everything that his wife owns, or partly owns is his. This shows that his character is very dominant and has an aggressive side to him. Stanley’s ‘animal joy’ can also show us that he has animalistic qualities for example when in scene three (the poker scene), Stanley and Blanche have a disagreement about the radio playing out loud, Blanche...

Words: 2260 - Pages: 10