Accounting Case Study

In: Business and Management

Submitted By jayduff101
Words 670
Pages 3
John Duffy
Dr. Shahid
ACC 302-03
March 14, 2011
Chapter 18 Case
Discussion Questions, Part 1.
1. When judging whether MiniScribe’s revenue recognition practices were consistent with GAAP, Reggie Lewis should have reviewed Section 605 of the Accounting Standards Codification concerning everything surrounding revenue recognition. More specifically ASC 605-25-1 states that, “The recognition of revenue of an entity during a period involves consideration of the following two factors, being realized or realizable and being earned.” In terms of revenue realization, FASB Concepts Statement No. 5 states that, “revenue is realized when products, merchandise or other assets are exchanged for cash or claims to cash.”
In MiniScribe’s case, by booking sales when goods are shipped to the warehouses rather then when they were shipped to customers to increase sales, they were not following the Accounting Standards Codifications guidelines of reporting revenues when earned. Based on these documents Reggie, and not his superior, is right to question the practices of MiniScribe in their effort to increase sales.
2. Reggie is in an extremely tough position. While his superior’s main goals are to increase sales, Reggie should realize as a worker in the company that the goal should be to increase sales ethically and by the rule book. Although his superiors may not want to hear it, Reggie should tell them about their faulty practices in reporting revenue. Although his boss may see this as a lack of enthusiasm to increase sales on Reggie’s part, if his boss is a decent and somewhat ethical businessman as he should be, he will realize that Reggie is only trying to help the company. If Reggie does not say anything, the company will continue their unethical practices and while they may continue to see sales increases in the couple years, in the long run not accounting by the rule…...

Similar Documents

Cost Accounting Case Study

..., variance costs, variance analysis, separating fixed costs from variable costs, all of this at the cost center level, to achieve a high level of cost control and accuracy.” Cheney (2005) states that, “where a typical U.S. company might have one Overhead (OH) measure per department, a GPK structure typically involves a half dozen or more measures per resource cost center.” GPK White (2004) states that GPK has been widely U.S.ed in German manufacturing and services companies for over forty years and that any technique this durable and successfully U.S.ed by a major indU.S.trial nation should be understood. According to Sharman and Vikas (2004), management accounting and controllership practices in German speaking countries are more developed than in the rest of the world. The German system, GPK, can be loosely translated as, “ Flexible Analytic Cost Planning and Accounting.” The system is also referred as, “Flexible Standard Costing.” As Buys (2007) states, standard costing , as it applies to manufacturing in the U.S., , U.S.ually includes direct material, direct labor, and allocated manufacturing overhead costs which include plant facilities, manufacturing related personnel, and depreciation of factory machinery. Many companies in the U.S. allocate overhead costs to products with the intention of recovering all costs. This is not the case with the GPK. GPK is more closely related to marginal costing, with many aspects of Activity Based Costing. Offenbacker (2004) describes...

Words: 3637 - Pages: 15

Accounting Case Study

...Date: October 6, 2011 To: ABC Management From: Shafiq Lalani, Advisor Subject: ABC acquisition of patent, land, building and equipment In response to your request to provide advice on how to account for the acquisition of a patent, land, building and equipment please find below an extensive report. Please note that this report is in accordance with Accounting Standards for Private Enterprises (ASPE) and as the advisor my recommendations will be based on my unbiased and independent understanding of these standards. The primary users of this information will be ABC management who have the objective of understanding their balance sheet post acquisitions to determine whether a request to increase their line of credit is viable. The secondary users include ABC silent investors, who have a financial stake in the business and want to ensure that the company has line of sight to profitability. Also, the bank that provides funds to ABC Company may also be a user of this report to assess the financial health of the firm and determine whether providing more loans to the institutions is warranted. Although this company is privately owned and is not legally subject to using any of the prescribed accounting standards laid out by the Canadian government, I would still recommend the usage of Accounting Standards for Private Enterprises (ASPE) given this company is interested in obtaining external loans from financial institutions that would likely require the use of ASPE. This...

Words: 1023 - Pages: 5

Case Study Pa504 Government and Non-Profit Accounting

... international market and increasing our sales without compromising our excellent customer service. To be able to achieve this goal, I definitely need to focus in training and development of the company’s employees, both current and newly hired ones. I am optimistic about this project and I will do my best to make it work. However, I feel that accounting department alone cannot achieve this goal thus I certainly need to coordinate with Human Resource Department to be successful in this project. II. Narrative description of the organizational problem that I would like to research and resolve While maintaining a profitable business is one of our company’s goals yet we need not to sacrifice the quality service that we vowed to our clients. We are set to have “An award winning international cargo division, a full-pledged destination management and leisure division, an international ground handler and an international airline flying and catering to the luxurious convenience of our patrons through the best effort and service of our flight and ground crew. For excellence and for outstanding services Emirates has received more than 400 awards all over the globe” (http://www.emirates247.com /look-back-2010-onto-2the-most-popular-stories-of-2010)and the biggest challenge for me is to combine the goal of giving excellence service and setting our sales and standard as high as possible. Beyond having great profitable projects, I need to maintain and have a more efficient, productive......

Words: 1182 - Pages: 5

Managerial Accounting Case Study 2

...Case Study 2 number of seats 90 average load factor 70% Average full passenger fare $160 Average variable cost per passenger $70 Fixed operating cost per month $3,150,000 formulas and computations for Case Study 2 Answers a) What is the break-even point in passengers and revenues per month? Passengers 35,000 Revenue $5,600,000 Calculations contribution margin per passenger =passenger fare $160 - variable cost per passenger $70 $90 Contribution margin per unit is the difference between the selling price per unit and the variable cost per unit break-even point in units (tickets sold) = Fixed costs $3,150,000 / Contribution margin per unit $90 35,000 break-even point in dollars = Fixed costs $3,150,000 / Contribution margin ratio .5625 $5,600,000 Contribution margin ratio = unit contribution margin $90/ unit selling price $160 0.5625 Contribution margin ratio is the portion of a unit's selling price that exceeds total unit variable cost. b) What is the break-even point in number of passenger train cars per month? Passenger train cars 556 Average number of passengers per car = seats 90 x average seats filled (load factor) 70% 63 Number of cars needed to transport passengers per month = total...

Words: 1415 - Pages: 6

Accounting Case Study

...John Duffy Dr. Shahid ACC 302-03 March 14, 2011 Chapter 18 Case Discussion Questions, Part 1. 1. When judging whether MiniScribe’s revenue recognition practices were consistent with GAAP, Reggie Lewis should have reviewed Section 605 of the Accounting Standards Codification concerning everything surrounding revenue recognition. More specifically ASC 605-25-1 states that, “The recognition of revenue of an entity during a period involves consideration of the following two factors, being realized or realizable and being earned.” In terms of revenue realization, FASB Concepts Statement No. 5 states that, “revenue is realized when products, merchandise or other assets are exchanged for cash or claims to cash.” In MiniScribe’s case, by booking sales when goods are shipped to the warehouses rather then when they were shipped to customers to increase sales, they were not following the Accounting Standards Codifications guidelines of reporting revenues when earned. Based on these documents Reggie, and not his superior, is right to question the practices of MiniScribe in their effort to increase sales. 2. Reggie is in an extremely tough position. While his superior’s main goals are to increase sales, Reggie should realize as a worker in the company that the goal should be to increase sales ethically and by the rule book. Although his superiors may not want to hear it, Reggie should tell them about their faulty practices in reporting revenue. Although his boss may see...

Words: 670 - Pages: 3

Accounting 505 Case Study 1

...Case Study 1 Springfield Express is a luxury passenger carrier in Texas. All seats are first class, and the following data are available: Number of seats per passenger train car 90 Average load factor (percentage of seats filled) 70% Average full passenger fare $ 160 Average variable cost per passenger $ 70 Fixed operating cost per month $3,150,000 Formula : Revenue = Units Sold * Unit price Contribution Margin = Revenue – All Variable Cost Contribution Margin Ratio = Contribution Margin/Selling Price Break Even Points in Units = (Total Fixed Costs + Target Profit )/Contribution Margin Break Even Points in Sales = (Total Fixed Costs + Target Profit )/Contribution Margin Ratio Margin of Safety = Revenue - Break Even Points in Sales Degree of Operating Leverage = Contribution Margin/Net Income Net Income = Revenue – Total Variable Cost – Total Fixed Cost Unit Product Cost using Absorption Cost = (Total Variable Cost + Total Fixed Cost)/# of units a. Contribution margin per passenger =? Contribution margin ratio =? Break-even point in passengers = Fixed costs/Contribution Margin = Passengers =? Break-even point in dollars = Fixed Costs/Contribution Margin Ratio...

Words: 748 - Pages: 3

Accounting Case

...After reading the case, we need to figure out three questions, which are a. FFC’s determination of whether the respective markets for the instruments were active or inactive and whether there was a significant decease in the volume and level of activity for the instruments. b. The valuation technique used by FFC c. The classification in the fair value hierarchy for each input into the fair value measurement and how these classifications affects classification in the fair value hierarchy of the entire instrument. We will answer these questions by each instrument separately: First, Collateralized Debt Obligation (CDO) Before September30th, 2010, FFC was in an active market, and it determined the fair value of the CDO by using a market-based valuation technique that relies on inputs such as quotes prices for similar CDO securities and requires only insignificant adjustments. After that, there was a significant decrease in the volume and level of activities and the CDO’s market was not active. Besides, significant adjustments are required to determine fair value as of the measurement date given the lack of recent and relevant transactions. The valuation techniques FFC used for CDO is income approach, because this way could maximize the use of relevant observable input and minimize the use of unobservable inputs. There are two factors FFC mainly considered in the fair value measurement. Frist, FFC considered the implied rate of return on September 30, 2010...

Words: 470 - Pages: 2

Case Study Accounting Research

...Grace Lau  December 18, 2014   Page 2    Conclusions and Recommendation Based on our research and facts provided to us, the consulting bill of WesternGraphics and staff salaries should be expensed as either incurred or when the first time the marketing project starts (FASB ASC 720-35-25). You could capitalize the costs incurred only if the costs qualify as direct response advertising. According to FASB ASC 340-20, direct response advertising costs are intended “to elicit sales to customers who should be shown to have responded specifically to the advertising and that result in probable future benefits”. Although there might be future benefits resulting from marketing strategy, the company didn't create any tangible or intangible asset. The slogan created by WesternGraphics has been rejected and no asset has been created on the company books. In our opinion, the consulting fees and staff salary didn't create an asset either. Since the company operates in a highly competitive industry, it’s uncertain whether the company will derive future benefits from marketing strategy. The asset is unidentified and generally such costs should be expensed. Although the company created the game (an asset), the consulting fees and staff salaries incurred do not qualify as production costs to be capitalized. According to FASB 985-2025, only costs “of producing product masters incurred subsequent to establishing technological feasibility shall be capitalized. Those costs include coding and......

Words: 342 - Pages: 2

Accounting Case Study

...Accounting Case Study Names Institutional Affiliation DR CASH A/C CR DATE 2014 | DESCRIPTION | AMOUNT | | DATE 2014 | DESCRIPTION | AMOUNT | 30/10/14 | Balance brought down | $305 | | 15/11/14 | Account payable | $50 | 08/11/2014 | receivable | $250 | | 16/11/14 | Account payable | $600 | | | | | 24/11/14 | Salary to assistant | $800 | 10/11/14 | Unearned revenue | $625 | | 24/11/14 | dividends | $500 | 18/11/14 | Unearned revenue | $50 | | 24/11/14 | Photo/supplies | $1250 | 24/11/14 | receivable | $3000 | | 30/11/14 | salaries | $56 | 30/11/14 | advertising | $50 | | | balance | $ | | TOTALS | $4280 | | | TOTALS | $4280 | Balance/down $1024 DR SALARY A/C CR DATE 2014 | DESCRIPTION | AMOUNT | | DATE 2014 | DESCRIPTION | AMOUNT | 24/11/14 | cash | $800 | | 30/11/14 | balance | $856 | 30/11/14 | cash | $56 | | | | | | TOTALS | $856 | | | TOTALS | $856 | Balance/down $856 DR DIVIDENDS A/C CR DATE 2014 | DESCRIPTION | AMOUNT | | DATE 2014 | DESCRIPTION | AMOUNT | 30/11/14 | Balance | $500 | | 24/11/14 | Balance/down | $500...

Words: 1461 - Pages: 6

Accounting Case Study

...ACCOUNTING 320B INTERMEDIATE ACCOUNTING II SYLLABUS - Fall 2014 Instructor: Dr. N.J. Kim, CPA Office: ST 612 Office Hours: TR 8:35 – 9:40 am & R 4:00 – 6:00 pm Phone: (323) 343-2840 Email: nkim2@calstatela.edu Instructional Web site: http://instructional1.calstatela.edu/nkim2/ Connect URL: http://connect.mcgraw-hill.com/class/sec-3 Textbook: Intermediate Accounting, 7th Edition, Spiceland, Sepe and Nelson, McGraw-Hill, ISBN-9780078025327 (Hard copy, Volume II, or e-book with CONNECT available) Course Objectives and Description: Intermediate Accounting is designed to acquaint the student with current accounting theories and practices. In this second part of intermediate accounting, we will learn accounting for fixed assets, intangibles, long-term liabilities, investments, and stockholders’ equity. Statement of cash flows and accounting issues related with accounting changes and error correction are also covered in this class. Prerequisite: ACCT 320A or equivalent with a grade C or better Grading: Points are distributed as follows. Accounting majors must earn a grade of “C” or better in each accounting class taken to graduate. Midterms 100 250-300 A Final 130 210-249 B Participation & Attendance 10 180-209 C Comprehensive test 20 150-179 D Homework 40 Below 150 F Total 300 points A modified curve may be applied at the end of the quarter if necessary...

Words: 547 - Pages: 3

Accounting Case

...ACCT 4400 Case Set 1 Case Set 1 covers Ethics and Professionalism in Auditing, and consists of the following cases: Case 1-1: Accounting Scandal Case 1-2: Audit Dilemma Case 1-3: Independence Case 1-1: Accounting Scandal This case focuses on the Diamond Foods accounting scandal. To complete this assignment, you should first conduct research using the Internet to better understand Diamond Foods and its fraud. Second, answer the following questions. Questions: 1. What was the motivation for the Diamond Foods scandal? Be specific, simply stating “greed” is insufficient. 2. (a) In general, what is a conflict of interest? (b) What role did the board of directors at Diamond Foods play in creating conflicts of interest at the company? (c) How should an auditor have responded to the conflicts of interest at Diamond Foods? 3. (a) What are momentum payments? (b) What was the role of momentum payments in the Diamond Foods scandal? 4. How did Diamond Foods fund its aggressive growth strategy of multiple acquisitions during a short period of time? Case 1-2: Audit Dilemma Assume that you have just started as a staff auditor at a large accounting firm. For your first audit, you are assigned to E&K books, a public company. Your firm has been auditing this client for several years, and has always given E&K clean opinions. A senior, Ella, will lead fieldwork on the E&K audit. You are glad to be working with Ella...

Words: 923 - Pages: 4

Accounting Case

...Acquisition of Legal Subsidiary in Bankruptcy Parent Co. (Parent) is a nonpublic company with two wholly owned subsidiaries, Poor Son Co. (Poor Son), a nonpublic company, and Rich Grandson Co. (Rich Grandson), a public entity registered with the SEC. Rich Grandson was transferred to Parent by Poor Son in 2006. Parent, Poor Son, and Rich Grandson each prepare stand-alone financial statements in accordance with U.S. GAAP. This case addresses the accounting by Parent and Poor Son and does not address any accounting associated with Rich Grandson. Bankruptcy In January 2007, Poor Son filed a voluntary petition for reorganization under Chapter 11 of the U.S. bankruptcy code because of its inability to meet obligations as they became due. Specifically, Poor Son incurred significant levels of bank debt in prior years, and because of deteriorating business conditions, was no longer able to support that level of debt. Parent concluded that as a result of the bankruptcy, it lost control of Poor Son and deconsolidated Poor Son from its financial statements. Parent cited the following to support a loss of control: • The bankruptcy court imposed a corporate governance stipulation under which Parent lost its ability to unilaterally remove and replace three out of the five members comprising Poor Son’s board of directors. • In 2008, Poor Son filed an action against Parent seeking to void the transfer of Rich Grandson as a fraudulent transfer, and seeking the return of its interest...

Words: 631 - Pages: 3

Accounting Case

...Case 3.1: While in Napal, McCoy describes his experiences with Sadhu on the mountainside as a breakdown of ethics on the corporate and individual level; in this comparison the hiking party would be the institution and Sadhu the individual. With that said typically speaking individuals within a firm may find their needs overwhelmed and under recognized as the specific interests of the firm itself are at the fore front. Again this correlates to the treatment of Sadhu by the hikers on the trip. With respect to the Ethical Dissonance Model the incident in question can be classified as low ranking concerning the corporate and individual ethics model. In short each hiker justified their actions as doing what they could to assist Sadhu, but in essence each hiker passed the safety and responsibility of Sadhu to the next hiker, rather than ensuring the gentlemen’s wellbeing through until the end. It became apparent that each hiker was concerned about their own self-interests rather than the interests and wellbeing of Sadhu.            McCoy reached stage two in Kohlberg’s Stages of Moral Development. He wanted to satisfy his own needs of fulfilling his dream of completing this hike and making it to the holy shrines. He felt that his responsibilities with the Sadhu were complete after he helped to get him clothed and checked that he was still alive, so he continued on his hike. Stephen made it to stage 3, fairness to others. He felt that he had an obligation to make sure that...

Words: 655 - Pages: 3

Accounting Case

...Tax Research Problem 1 Team 5 Ji Kim, Amy Li, Catherine Yuan Facts (Phrase the problem in the textbook) The § 351 transaction discussed here can be presented as below. Issues 1. Should M recognize gain on the contribution of the land? If so, how much? 2. Should X recognize gain on the contribution? If so, how much? 3. What is X’s basis in the land contributed by M? Conclusion Due to the contribution, M should recognize a total gain of $43,000, of which $30,000 is attributable to the contribution of the land. X recognizes no gain or loss. The gain recognized by M increases X’s basis in the land to $55,000. Analysis Internal Revenue Code (I.R.C.) § 362(a) states that if property was acquired by a corporation in connection with a transaction to which § 351 applies, the basis shall be the same as it would be in the hands of the transferor, increased in the amount of gain recognized to the transferor on such transfer. In this case, M’s basis in the land is $25,000. Therefore the gain recognized by M on this transaction needs to be determined. Although no gain or loss is recognized in a § 351 transfer [I.R.C. § 351(a)], I.R.C. § 351(b) requires that the transferor recognize gain to the extent that other property (“boot”) is received. In M’s case, he received boot, which is cash, of $50,000. This is the maximum amount of gain he can recognize on this transaction. However, M transferred multiple assets. This complicated the computation for gain recognized...

Words: 530 - Pages: 3

Accounting 504 Week 5 Case Study

...Case Study ACCT504 Acct Fin: Managerial Use Analysis Devry University Carmeshia Motes Professor Melinda Howerton February 7th, 2016 Situation A. In evaluating the internal control over inventory for the Williams Oil Services Company, an auditor learns that the warehouse receiving clerk is responsible for ordering parts for supply inventory use in drilling services, counts the inventory when received at the dock, records the receipts into the inventory ledger, and takes the annual inventory, No supervisor reviews the receiving clerk’s work. Missing Internal Control Characteristic: The important missing factor is that same person is responsible for conducting all the activities of inventory. He or She is responsible for ordering parts, counting the inventory, recording inventory ledger and taking up of annual stock. Problem of the Firm: The firm does not have any internal control mechanism to cross check the authenticity of documents and physical inventory of stores. All the duties are being performed by same person, there is no segregation of duties which could prevent or decrease the errors and willful fraud. Proposed Solution: Segregation of duties is one of the methods of internal which helps in preventing and reducing the occurrence of frauds and errors. It is done by segregating the duties in a department and by ensuring that no single person is having control on all the transactions. There are four general categories of duties: authorization, custody...

Words: 949 - Pages: 4