Free Essay

Addressing International and Legal Ethics

In: Business and Management

Submitted By dshinett
Words 1622
Pages 7
Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Paper
De’Shawn Shinette, Sr. University of Phoenix
BUS 415: Business Law
James Zaccaria
March 16, 2008

Introduction Any solid relationship should begin with a period of introduction, or courtship. The same can be said when a global negotiation venture with a prospective foreign nation business partner has started. The need to know about the culture, background, structure, and goals of the parties involved is important (Negotiation Leadership, 2008). It might be wise to spend the money to hire an experienced consultant, or professional third party to look into the potential partner’s past. In this report two companies (CadMex and Gentura) are attempting a business venture. Before they can move forward a few issues need to be addressed in a memo. Initially an explanation why Gentura might be in breach of contract with CadMex will be given. Next, a discussion of what remedies are available will to be conducted. From there, a recommendation will be made on how the Gentura situation will be handled. An analysis for selecting the proper forum and venue for dispute resolution will be included. Finally, an analysis of the situation from an ethical standpoint will be done in order to support ones recommendation. I. Breach of Contract Breach of a contract between two parties can bring about severe legal issues. Substantial performance occurs when there has been a minor breach of contract (Bereznicki-Korol, Clarke & Yates, 2005). In other words, when a party to a contract renders performance that deviates only slightly from complete performance; a minor breach occurs. In the case with the two companies stated above, an explanation as to why Gentura would be in breach of its contract must be given. Given the fact that Candore is in the midst of a viral epidemic, the company is forced to subsidize ViroBlax which a drug used to treat the epidemic. In turn, this was a minor breach of the original contract. Since Gentura is unable to meet the demand CadMex had to negotiate for sublicensing with local pharmaceutical companies in order to meet the demand for ViroBlax. Though this was a minor breach; both companies needed to come together in order fight the epidemic. II. Remedies When a contract is breached, alternatives to settling the dispute between two parties should be available. Settling of a dispute is considered a remedy. In the case with CadMex and Gentura a few remedies were available to amend the situation. CadMex could take legal action against Gentura but that would have a severe impact on business relations with the two companies which isn’t needed at this time (University of Phoenix, 2007). Another remedy would be for CadMex to take no legal action, but claim compensation from Gentura. This is a good idea however; it would hit CadMex financially a pose a strain on its resources (University of Phoenix, 2007). Finally, CadMex could take no legal action and obtain marketing rights of another drug that Gentura makes. Getting worldwide marketing rights for another is a good idea. CadMex would be able to recoup its losses from the drug ViroBlax (University of Phoenix, 2007). All options are good and bad in one way or another. Moving forward, a recommendation on the situation will be given.
III. Recommendation Complete performance of a contract is what should be done when two parties inter into a business venture. A recommendation must be made to settle the issue with both companies. A few remedies were provided above for them to work out their problems. The first was to sue Gentura but doing so would damage the business relationship between the two companies. The second remedy was to take no legal action and claim compensation from Gentura. However, doing so would be costly to CadMex. Finally, CadMex could take no legal action and obtain marketing rights for Gentura’s manufacturing of another drug. Recommendation to choose this option is a good idea because it helps CadMex get back a great deal if not all the money which it lost in this situation. Again, the original contract may have been breached but room for maneuvering is available for both parties to maintain their business agreement and make money.
IV. Forum and Venue Selecting the proper forum and venue is essential when negotiating a contract in international business. CadMex had a few different approaches to consider when negotiating a contract with Gentura. Under the Choice-of-Law clause CadMex could choose Contracts for International Sale of Goods (CSIG). This would be a fine choice but Candore isn’t a signatory of the United Nations Convention on Contracts for International Sale of Goods. This means that CSIG wouldn’t be able to bind Gentura legally to its contract with CadMex. If CadMex chose to go with Candorean Regulations for Technology Import Contracts (CRTIC), doing so would be good because the CRTIC explicitly states the criteria which a foreign company must fulfill for technology transfer to a Candorean company (University of Phoenix, 2007). Along with choosing a good law to abide by CadMex must look at which forum it will use in order to settle disputes. Considering international arbitration which is binding would be a good choice because reaching an agreement out of court is much quicker and less expensive. The agreement also must be legal binding instead of nonbinding simply because if it were nonbinding, that would defeat the purpose of the forum in the first place. Choosing local laws is another option. The problem here is that since Candore is new to international trade, its courts have no experience in settling international disputes involving trade agreements. The last option would be to go through U.S. Courts. This would be good but when one considers a country with an unstable political system, CadMex may be unable to enforce this option if the government of Candore intervenes. Choosing international arbitration which is binding would be best for CadMex.
V. Ethical Implications Business Ethics is the application of general ethical ideas to business behavior (Ethics in Business, 2008). A business should not try to make up its own definition of right and wrong, these values are already greatly instilled in business culture. Looking at CadMex and Gentura’s situation from an ethical standpoint is important. Considering that Candore had an epidemic which CadMex had the means to work out; the company could have stuck to its original contract and took Gentura to court for breaching its contract. This would bring about an ethical dilemma. Though both companies are legally bound to their contract with one another, the local company’s government must allow compulsory licensing for generic versions of a drug which is needed to treat an epidemic in the country. If CadMex ignores this situation and pursues legal action for breach of contract, ethically this is wrong. The company knows that it could do something to help but would rather not. Morally this is wrong. Never will it be considered wrong to help someone in need. In this case, CadMex did the right thing ethically by allowing Gentura to go outside of their contract in order to help the Candorean people. Renegotiating the contract between the two companies enabled Gentura to help its people and maintain good business relations with CadMex. The same can be said about CadMex. CadMex was able to obtain marketing rights for Gentura’s manufacturing of another drug; recouping the money which was initially lost in the beginning of this situation.

Conclusion When conducting business internationally, both companies need to be mindful of the details that go into the contract which they are pursuing. In examining the case with CadMex and Gentura, both parties entered a contract with one another. A memorandum needed to be prepared explaining in detail why Gentura would be in breach of its contract with CadMex. Entering into a contract the two companies were later faced with an epidemic which meant that Gentura would have a slight breach in the contract. Since they were faced with this issue, both companies needed to explore what remedies were available to amend the situations which they were faced with. After renegotiating the contract, Gentura was able to sublicense the manufacture of ViroMax which was a drug used to treat the epidemic. From there in the agreement CadMex would be able to obtain marketing rights to a drug later manufactured by Gentura from which a recommendation was made to choose this option. Selecting the Candorean Regulations for Technology Import Contracts (CRTIC) along with international arbitration which is binding would be a good advantage for its forum and venue because CRTIC explicitly states the criteria which a foreign company must fulfill for technology transfer to a Candorean company. Another benefit would be that reaching an agreement out of court is much quicker and less expensive. The ethical implication of this situation is that if CadMex opted to pursue legal action against Gentura instead of helping the Candorean people, this would portray CadMex as immoral and heartless; damaging the business relationship with Gentura. Though breaching a contract can potentially hurt the parties involved, maintaining an open mind and remaining flexible helps in working out potential problems.

References
Negotiation Leadership. (2008). The Solid Building Blocks of an International Agreement. Retrieved March 15, 2008, from http://www.negotiations.com/articles/international- business/
Bereznicki-Korol, T., Clarke, T. & Yates, R. (2005). Business Law in Canada (7th ed.). Toronto, Canada: Pearson.
University of Phoenix. (2007). Addressing International and Ethical Issues Simulation. Retrieved March 16, 2008, from University of Phoenix, Week Four, Resource. BUS415-Business Law Course Web site: https://mycampus.phoenix.edu/secure/resource/resource.asp
Ethics in Business. (2008). Business Ethics. Retrieved March 16, 2008, from

http://www.ethicsinbusiness.net/about/
dr

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Law421 Week 2

...Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Summary Donna Bass LAW/421 January 18, 2016 Andrew McAdams Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Summary When operating a business internationally, there are legal and ethical issues that must be taken into account. The simulation shows that to be successful; a company must understand the issues involved in legal disputes, the practical considerations of taking legal action, what factors can work against the company, and what to do when customs and laws conflict. The issues that can arise when trying to resolve legal disputes in an international transaction can be cultural, ethical, political, and differences in power structures. Before taking legal action, arbitration should be considered as it is less expensive and the outcome would likely be more beneficial that dealing with a foreign court system (University of Phoenix, n.d.). Before taking legal action against a foreign business partner, there are practical considerations to take into account. The cost of legal fees and the chance of winning a court battle against this partner in a court of their country should be considered. Another is the damage that a lawsuit could have on the company's reputation. This action could hurt their chances of obtaining future international partners. Factors that could work against the granting of the sublicensing agreements by CadMex include the fact that the Canadian government and legislators would work to prevent......

Words: 402 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

International Legal & Ethical Issues

...Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues LAW/421 December 18, 2013 Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues International legal and ethical issues are extremely important to know how to deal with when you are going to join into or do business in any other country other than the U.S. In this stimulation of CadMex Pharma and Gentura, they are facing several international contracts, transactions, ethical issues and sublicensing agreements. CadMes Pharma is a pharmaceutical company in the U.S. who offer quick manufacturing techniques and has dealt with global issues often. Gentra is a biotech company in the country of Canodre which have the licensing rights to a hypothetical anti diabetic drug. CadMex Pharma’s goal is to grow financially by being able to distribute and supply this medicine for Gentra in the U.S. All countries have their own set of laws and ethics that are required to be followed, unless you have a contract in place with the company or country that you are involved in business. * What are the issues involved in resolving legal disputes in international transactions? Making a choice on which way to handle these transactions are vital, when dealing with international disputes. One choice is the Contracts for International Sale of Goods. This is not very effective because Canodre changed status and became part of the WTO. When one of the parties is not a signatory of this program, then the other party is more likely to use......

Words: 842 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Law and Corporate

...Law, Ethics, and Corporate Governance – LEG 500 | 201003 | Prerequisite: None | Quarter | Winter 2010 | Meeting Days/Time | Online course | Instructor | Dr. C. Phil Campos, MBA, JD | Instructor Phone | 214-202-8044 | Instructor E-mail | canuto.campos@strayer.edu | Instructor Office Hours/Location | 6pm – 7pm EST | Academic Office Phone NumberStrayer Online Technical SupportEcollege HelpDesk | 1-877-540-1733“As a student, you should choose 1 then 3 for academic issues from the automated menu.”1-877-642-2999“Used for problems entering the class”1-866-448-6703 or 1-303-873-0005“Used for problems once in the class” | INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIAL | Kubasek, N. K., Brennan, B. A., & Browne, N. (2009).  The legal environment of business: A critical thinking approach (5th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson-Prentice Hall.Ferrell, O. C., Fraedrich, J., & Ferrell, L. (2010).  Business ethics: Ethical decision making and cases (7th ed.). Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company/South-Western/Cengage Learning.PLEASE READ SYLLABUS PART II in the Course Home tab, it contains important University policies.GETTING TECHNICAL HELPTechnical questions regarding eCollege or classroom issues should be referred to helpdesk@strayeronline.net. Or you may phone the helpdesk at 1(866)448-6703.If the question regards a Strayer system, technical support can be reached at 1(877) 642-2999. Any technical inquiries sent to the instructor will, as a matter of course, be forwarded to the......

Words: 5313 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

International Legal and Ethical Issues

...International Legal and Ethical Issues Lori Hall LAW/421 December 18, 2012 Corey Frost International Legal and Ethical Issues When one company decides to take legal action against a foreign business partner in another company it is important to not only have an understanding of their local laws but also cultural differences, customs, and language barriers. All of these items could present possible barriers to resolving legal disputes associated with international transactions. Any company doing business abroad must be mindful of the pitfalls of international business, ensuring that the contract entered into is legally enforceable, the contract must protect the company’s interests in the foreign country against all eventualities, knowing that possible disagreements and disputes are common in the international trade arena. This paper will outline the legal, ethical, and cultural issues of doing business abroad. Issues Involved In Resolving Legal Disputes First, business contracts must clearly specify which laws will govern the business decisions that will be made, whether it is American law, local country laws, or popular international convention. One should note that international laws are broad terms establishing a series of customs that countries and businesses agree to adhere to when dealing with each other and that international laws are binding; however, largely based on reciprocal behavior rather than legal sanctions (Melvin, 2011). Some issues involved......

Words: 990 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Simulation Summary

...Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Simulation Summary LAW/421: Contemporary Business Law University of Phoenix Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Simulation Summary In January 2007, CadMex, who is a leader in global pharmaceuticals, developed techniques for the quick manufactuing of medical agents. Gentura, an established biotechnology company developed an agent called ProPrez, which is an anti-diabetic agent. Gentura is located in Candore, which is a dictatorship. CadMex decided to go into business with Gentura that would give them global marketing right to ProPez. The contract needs to have measures in place to protect CadMex interest concerning property rights and potential dispute. Some of the issues involved in resolving legal actions against a foreign business are the legal system may want to finish the case quickly rather than with quality so may not analyze all the evidence. Another issue may be the difference between the two countries laws. No written documents may also be another issue if contracts are done over the phone. An example is Some practical considerations of taking legal action against a foreign business based in another country are whether the have patent law and trademark laws. Factors that could work against CadMex decision to grant sublicensing agreements are lack of patent rights and did not go through the proper court process in Candore. When the local customs and laws......

Words: 411 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues

...Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues LAW/421 Contemporary Business Law Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues With the increasing globalization of business, organizations are finding themselves in an global environment full of legal and ethical challenges. In some international environments, the very legitimacy of a company doing business in a specific country can be a challenge. International transactions and dispute resolution require both an understanding of the law and sensitivity to foreign culture, formal and information power structures and decision-making approaches. This paper will ethical and legal issues involved in resolving legal disputes in international transactions. From an ethical point of view, an organization seeking to expand globally should first consider whether they should conduct business in countries after researching the specific country’s sociopolitical environment. Corrupt public officials, participating in racial or gender discrimination, polluting the environment or violate the human rights of their citizens through slave or child labor or inhuman working conditions (Trevino & Nelson, 2011) is considered corporate culture in some countries. For example, Foxconn is a multinational electronics contractor for major American, European, and Japanese electronic companies who has been involved in several controversies relating to how it manages employees in China. It is claimed that Foxconn uses underage workers......

Words: 653 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Business Ethics and Corporate Strategy

...Business Ethics and Corporate Strategy Ethical Issue Paper Travis G. Stoufer Business Ethics-BUS 323 Janet Evelyn-Dorsey January 29, 2010 Abstract A paper presented on the growing issues of business ethics and the decisions consumers and producers make when moral and ethical responsibilities are in question. Paper presents tools for consideration for tomorrow’s leaders and gives a general overview of strategies corporations take to limit legal responsibility in ethical matters that include; hiring of undocumented workers, strategies such as breach and pay, document retention, and rewriting policy on employees instead of treating them with dignity and respect. The paper discusses the viewpoint of ethical responsibilities with primary stakeholders in mind. The primary stakeholders for consideration in this paper would be employees, consumers, managers, and CEO’s. This paper argues corporate strategies such as breach and pay, document retention, and hiring of undocumented workers is unethical. Corporate strategies of this sort are unethical and consumers should align the purchases of goods and services with companies that participate in corporate social responsibility. BUSINESS ETHICS AND CORPORATE STRATEGY Table of Contents Abstract……………………………………………………………………………………ii Table of......

Words: 2298 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Student

...Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights-Introduction, practical relevance and critical analysis Xiaoxiao Ding Master in International Business and Sustainability ABSTRACT: due to the increasingly significant influence of the transnational corporations in industrial and commercial fields in modern society, especially in the spheres of environment and labor protection, more and more cases raised involving their infringements of the international human rights laws. On June 16, 2011, the United Nations Human Rights Council endorsed Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, providing guidance for the implementation of the United Nations " Protect, Respect and Remedy" Framework. In the form of " Soft Law", these principles specify what business enterprises should do to respect human rights and how to prevent the violations on human rights. This paper identifies the main idea of these principles, gives relevant practical references and analyzes these principles with a critical perspective. Contents 1. Introduction .............................................................................. 2 2. The development and content of UN Guiding Principles......... 3 2.1 Historical development of UN Guiding Principles ........................ 3 2.2 The main idea of the UN Guiding Principles ................................. 4 2.3 The legal framework of the UN Guiding Principles ...................... 5 3. Practical relevance of the UN Guiding Principles......

Words: 5077 - Pages: 21

Free Essay

International and Legal Issues

...International Legal and Ethical Issues In an attempt to address legal and ethical issues domestically and internationally we will use the simulation and readings to discuss the questions from week two’s team project. Whether the company is a domestic company or foreign country there are legal, ethical and cultural issues that must be addressed. When addressing issues that arise when handling international legal disputes it is important to choose where and how the dispute will be settled. Each business or party involved in a legal dispute will presumably favor settling disputes within their own country. Disputes settled on homeland soil risk other countries perceiving the court’s decision as partial and unfair and therefore may attempt an appeal process and possibly bring negative attention to the country resulting in the withdrawal of interest from other foreign investors. When businesses enter into agreements with other businesses in foreign countries the contract should be clearly defined providing a plan that both parties agree upon. Laws and customs should adhere within the country in which the business or legal action is taking place. Imports and exports are examples of this because each country has different import and export tariffs and laws which should be followed in order to avoid repercussions from the government. In the simulation, CadMex, a large pharmaceutical company is entering into a contract to license with Gentura to market the Propez. Gentura......

Words: 444 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Law/421 Version 1/ Homework-Aid

...point you are making. Discuss the functions and role of law in your past or present job or industry. What is the most important Constitutional provision to business law? Properly cite at least two references from two different sources. Format your paper consistent with APA guidelines. Day 7 11 Individual Bio Post your bio in the body of a message in the chat room. Week Two: Torts Participation Participate in class discussion and respond to weekly discussion questions. DQs due days 2, 4 and 5 7 Individual Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Simulation Summary Complete the Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues simulation located on the student website. Write a 350-word summary. In your paper, answer the following questions: • What are the issues involved in resolving legal disputes in international transactions? • What are some practical considerations of taking legal action against a foreign business partner based in another country? • What factors could work against CadMex's decision to grant sublicensing agreements? • When the local customs and laws conflict with the customs and laws...

Words: 761 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Legal Issues

...Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues CadMex is a global pharmaceutical with over 85 years in the business. They are based in Tampa Florida. They have the ambitions to take their business to a country in South East Asia called Candore. The company the CadMex wants to business is called Gentura. They are well established biotechnology company. This company has over 25 years experienced into their business. This paper will highlight the many situations or challenges an organization faces while conduction business abroad. Other items that will be highlighted in this paper are: the issues involved in resolving legal disputes in international transactions. Also some practical considerations of taking legal action against a foreign business partner based in another country. Last, it will highlight how companies should resolve domestic and international issues differently. There are some issues that arise during resolving legal disputes in international transactions. The first issue to consider is the laws that govern the country. If the country is run by a borderline dictator such as President Arahi Gwendoz that took over Candore in a bloodless coup, the rule might be very difficult to understand. If there are no rules such the Constitution of the United States, there will be a lot of room for a variety of interpretations. Last, “International law has traditionally been defined in very broad terms and not limited...

Words: 1214 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Miss

...Assessing the Environment & Managing Interdependence, Social Responsibility, Ethics and Sustainability 30/09/2014 Dr Nick Papageorgiadis The notion of a firm with a unique national identity is quickly fading. A Bermuda-incorporated, Paris-headquartered firm, listed on the NYSE with US style investor protections and disclosure rules, a chief information officer in Bangalore, a chief finance officer in Brussels and a chief operating officer in Beijing may not sound nearly so fanciful in the near future. Desai, M. A. (2009). The decentering of the global firm. The World Economy, 32(9), 1271-1290. What is International Management? The process of developing strategies, designing and operating systems, and working with people around the world to ensure sustained competitive advantage The Global Manager’s Role Contents Assessing the Environment: • • • Understand the global business environment and how it affects the strategic and operational decisions which managers must make. Critically assess the developments, advantages, and disadvantages of globalization. Develop an appreciation for the ways in which political, economic, legal, and technological factors and changes impact the opportunities that companies face. Appreciate the complexities involved in the corporation’s obligations toward its various constituencies around the world. Understand the changing perceptions and demands of corporations doing business in other countries, in particular the......

Words: 2916 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Simulation Summary

...Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Simulation Summary 1. What are the issues involved in resolving legal disputes in international transactions? The issues involved in resolving legal disputes in international transactions include but are not limited to the signing of contracts designed to protect both parties, choice of clause, which forum to use when settling a dispute and if arbitration, if used, will be binding or nonbinding. Something else to think about when resolving legal disputes in international transactions would be to gauge when the government stands in the legal proceedings and to find out if the particular countries government can overrule any decisions made by the companies. Other issues would include the political situation, dominant international laws and cultural issues that would influence the achievement or disappointment of the business venture. 2. What are some practical considerations of taking legal action against a foreign business partner based in another country? Some practical considerations of taking legal action against a foreign business partner based in another country include looking out for the best interest of the company your represent as well as future business ventures with the company or country you are in business with. One would also have to take into consideration economic, legal, and ethical associations. The economy of the country that you are contracted with may have ulterior motives in the business......

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Cross Culture

...more likely to succeed when they act with integrity and (b) increased awareness by company directors of the need to seek expert advice to help them align and incorporate high ethical standards with business strategy and integrate them across all operational functions. In recent years, the general public have become both better informed and more concerned about business ethics at home and in developing countries. As a result governments have been called on to legislate, and business leaders to innovate, to ensure that high ethical standards are put at the heart of business and industry. The field of integrity management aims to address: 1. The demand for companies to respond to increasing awareness of ethical misconduct and resulting expectations for transparency and accountability; 2. The requirement for companies to comply with a stricter legal framework and avoid prosecution for unethical behaviour; and, 3. The desire for executives to make their enterprises leaders in responsible and sustainable development. Contents * 1 Increased public awareness and expectations * 2 More stringent legal requirements * 3 Role of consultancies * 4 References * 5 External links | Increased public awareness and expectations Media attention given to ethical lapses means that companies are increasingly being held responsible for unethical behaviour including corruption, labour issues and the poor working conditions in their own...

Words: 1551 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Creating an Effective Code of Ethics for Widget Tech Inc.

...Creating an Effective Code of Ethics for Widget Tech Inc. 11/23/2009 David G. Montague | Summary Widget Tech Inc. is in need of update the company’s current code of ethics due to growth of the company and the changing workforce. Research has been conducted to revise the current policy and address topics that were previously overlooked. Widget Tech Inc. is a company that stresses both corporate and personal integrity. We not only comply with laws and applicable regulations; but we also strive to conduct our affairs according to the highest ethical standards. Employees are expected to be honest and forthright in dealings with managers, subordinates and with one another, as well as with clients, suppliers, government agencies and their employees, business partners and the general public. Widget Tech employees must maintain the highest level of personal integrity and encourage it in others; they must not lie, cheat, steal or do anything that would bring dishonor upon themselves or the company (SRA International, Inc. 2009). Review of Widget Tech Inc. Code of Ethics Table of Contents Summary……………………………………………………………………………………..………..2 Introduction……………………………………………………………………………….………..…3 How to Create a Code of Ethics………………………………………………..……....…3 Components of a Code of......

Words: 1367 - Pages: 6