Free Essay

Affect Theory

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By marksalute
Words 1802
Pages 8
ESSAY #1 – Politics of Affect

Affect theory has recently become a burgeoning field of study. In the most basic of definitions, affect is the visceral force that is around the body, something that is not consciously known, yet it can influence our movements, thoughts, and the way one relates to other people and objects. Many theorist from a wide variety of academic disciplines have contributed to the field of affect studies. This essay will look at selected works of Nigel Thrift, Deborah Gould, and Ruth Leys to show how they have contributed to the development of affect studies. The essay will also aim to show how they might differ or agree on certain concepts within affect theory amongst other prominent affect theorist.

Nigel Thrift is a leading academic in the field of human geography and has made significant contributions to the field of affect. His article, Intensities of Feelings: Towards a Spatial Politics of Affect, attempts to show that the politics of affect are central to the life of cities, given that cities are inhuman or trans-human entities and that politics is understood as a process of community without unity (Thrift, 2004, p. 57). For Thrift, affect is an object or subject of manipulation, and it is closely tied to power and how it operates, affective life and emotional life is the setting for operation of power. He states “…it is so crucial to address affect now: in at least one guise the discovery of new means of practising affect is also the discovery of a whole new means of manipulation by the powerful (Thrift, 2004, p.58). This shows that for Thrift, affect and power share a complex relationship, one which can bring about a new way of exploitation, and since affect is at such a visceral state it can potentially go unchecked. Thrift, early in his article, highlights one of the problems in writing about affect theory, he writes that there is “no stable definition of affect” (Thrift, 2004, p. 59). Thrift is able to define affect by using the work of other prominent scholars. He uses the theoretical frameworks, and critiques of prominent scholars of affect such as Jack Katz, Eve Sedgwick, Silvan Tomkins, Spinoza, Gillian Deluze, and Brian Massumi, this allows him to narrow down his definition of affect to four different approaches. Thrift’s definition of affect is not based on individualized emotions, such as happiness, or fear. He states “it is extremely important to note that none of these approaches could be described as based on a notion of human individuals coming together in community. Rather, inline with my earlier work, each cleaves to an ‘inhuman’ or ‘trans-human’ framework in which individuals are generally understood of effects of the events to which their body parts (broadly understood) respond and in which they participate” (Thrift, 2004, p.60). For Thrift affect is a form of thinking, one that is indirect and non-reflective. This is how he is able to explain the affective experience of cities, it’s a transcendence of affect from one body to another. An example could be the way cities are designed, even simple paintings on a brick wall, or Christmas reefs on city lights all produce a certain affect on people. Another affect theorist who has developed affect theory in cultural and political thought is Deborah Gould.

Deborah Gould, is an associate professor in the sociology department of University of California Santa Cruz. She writes about affect in relation to social activist movements in her article entitled “Why Emotion”. Gould’s take on affect is similar to Thrifts, its based upon a non visceral state, something that can’t be consciously quantified. Gould draws on the work of affect theorist Brian Massumi, much like Thrift, to explain affect. They both agree that affect is based on a bodily experience. She states “To get a better idea of affect, consider how we often experience our feelings as opaque to ourselves, as something that we do not quite have language for, something that we can fully grasp, something that escapes us but is nevertheless in play, generated through interaction with the world, and affecting our embodied beings and subsequent actions. I call that bodily, sensory, inarticulate, non-conscious experience affect” (Gould, 2009, p.20). One thing that Gould does explicitly is draw a difference between affect and emotion, she states “The distinction I am drawing here between affect and emotion is not a temporal one, where, for example first you have affect and then a fixed emotion in its place. Affect is always in play, even if not actualized” (Gould, 2009, p.21). Gould’s article looks at the ACT UP (Aids Coalition to Unleash Power) social movement, her aim is to try and understand the origins of the movement, its meteoric rise, development and eventual decline. On a broader level it looks at social movements in general and how affect and emotion play a role. She argues that emotion and rationality can coincide, this was something that traditional collective behaviour literature failed to do, instead it took a rationalist approach. Gould states “Scholars in the emotional turn challenge the rationalist assumption of the dominant paradigms without returning to the worst aspects of the collective behaviour literature”, she goes on to say “A focus on emotion and feeling, then, need not, and should not, negate the rationality of protestors or political nature of social movements” (Gould, 2009, p. 17). Gould is able to show how affect and social movements are connected by outlining three insights that an affective ontology provides. First she argues that using affect when looking at social movements gives more insight into human motivation, something that “rationalist ontology or more cognitive renderings tend to obscure or misunderstand” (Gould, 2009, p.25). Second, affect shows how social reproduction and social change are important, for example it is in affective states that people generate attachment to leaders. Affect helps in understanding political inaction, something scholars often overlook (Gould, 2009, p.26). And thirdly, affect gives meaning in the context of social movements. Gould argues it is the affective sensations that start social movements, the non-conscious inkling to act that turns into a movement (Gould, 2009, p.28). Gould’s contributions to affect theory and social movements furthers the discussion in a political sense, it shows how people organize politically to incite change from a visceral force because they inherently know something is not right.

Another author that has contributed to affect theory is Ruth Leys, a professor of humanities at John Hopkins University. Her article, The Turn to Affect: A Critique, is just that, a critique of affect. To understand her arguments about affect it is important to discuss, The Autonomy of Affect, an article by Brian Massumi. Ruth Leys contribution to affect comes by critically engaging prominent affect theorist such as Nigel Thrift and Brian Massumi. Although she discusses both authors amongst others in her critique, she focuses mainly on Massumi and his presumption that affect and cognition are separate. Brian Massumi, in his article describes affect as autonomous, he states “affect is autonomous to the degree to which it escapes confinement in the particular body whose vitality, or potential for interaction, it is” (Massumi, 1995, p.96). For Massumi, affect is what we know and feel from our interpretations, the feelings that we get are separate and incongruent. Massumi’s interpretation of affect is inline with what both Nigel Thrift and Deborah Gould purport, that emotion and affect are separate, and so is the mind and body. Massumi, citing a study in which brain waves were measured to reaction time, reasons with an idea known as the missing half second. This is basically brain activity that is going on without actually being aware of it. This is occurring at a visceral, affective state. Massumi states, “the half second is missed not because it is empty, but because it is overfull, in excess of the actually performed action and of its ascribed meaning”, he goes on to state “It should be noted in particular that during the mysterious half second, what we think of as ‘higher’ functions, such as volition, are apparently being performed by autonomic, bodily reactions occurring in the brain but outside consciousness, and between brain and finger, but prior to action and expression (Massumi, 1995, p.90). This could very well be an example of what affect is, this is how Massumi argues that emotion and affect are separate, and it also draws a distinction between the body and the mind. It is with these assumptions that Ruth Leys engages critically, she debates the separation between emotion and affect as well as the mind and body. Leys states “they suggest that the affects must be viewed as independent of, and in an important sense prior to, ideology – that is, prior to intentions, meanings, reasons, and beliefs— because they are nonsignifying, autonomic processes that take place below the threshold of conscious awareness and meaning” (Leys, 2011, p.437). Leys here shows the view of theorists like Massumi and Thrift, she refutes this line of thinking by stating “the claim that affect is a formless, unstructured, nonsignifying force or ‘intensity’ that escapes the categories of the psychologists suggests that Tomkins’s or Ekman’s or Damasio’s talk about the existence of six or seven or eight or nine structured, evolved categories of innate emotions is incompatible with the views of writers such as Massumi who espouse Spinozist-Deleuzean ideas about affect” (Leys, 2011, p.442). Here Leys looks at another viewpoint, the Tomkins-Ekman paradigm which she claims is incompatible with affect theorists. According to Leys the fundamental distinctions that affect are based on are not sustainable when you revisit the experiments that separate the mind and body. Leys is much more interested in the cultural aspects of affect.

In conclusion, affect theory offers a new way of thinking, or bringing back an older less popular way of thinking. Affect, according to authors like Thrift, Gould, and Massumi is at odds with Cartesian dualism, the prominent western way of thought. Theorists such as Thrift, Gould, and Massumi all develop affect theory in cultural and political thought by showing how affect, although visceral and non–conscious, has an effect on outcomes. The critique by Ruth Leys also aids to the development of affect theory, because it questions certain premises which the theory is based on.

Bibliography Deborah B. Gould, “Why Emotion,” in Moving Politics: Emotion and Act-Up’s Fight Against Aids. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2009, pp. 1-48. Brian Massumi, “The Autonomy of Affect,” Cultural Critique 31 (Fall 1995), pp. 83-109.

Ruth Leys, The Turn to Affect: A Critique, Critical Inquiry, 37:3, pp. 434-72.

Nigel Thrift, “Intensities of Feeling: Toward a Spatial Politics of Affect,” Geografiska Annaler 86B (2004), pp. 57-78.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Mary Jane

...become one of America’s hottest topics and is very controversial. To figure this out, you would need to know some of the affects that it has, such as driving, schoolwork, medical purposes, the brain, and why it is so harmful. Marijuana has been a big topic of discussion in the U.S. today, but what is so harmful about it that is keeping it illegal. To get a full understanding of what affects this drug has on you, it is nice to have a little background information on it. Marijuana is the flowers, stems, and seeds that come of a plant called Cannabis sativa. The main chemical, delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol or TCH is what gives the affect of being high. It can be smoked, drank or eaten. The affect that it gives you is called a high. It can little to harmful affects on the body and can get deadly if it is abused.(National Institute on Drug Abuse) The affects that it has on the body can include increase heart rate, irritation it the lungs, respiratory problems, social life, and how your brain works. At first, your heart rate will speed up from anywhere to 20-100%. After it can also affect how hard it is to breathe. This can cause a lot of chest pain and even some illnesses. It can mess up your vision, concentration and physical activities. It is proven that it can cause similar affects to tobacco smokers.(National Institute on Drug Abuse) Marijuana has many affects on the brain that can include, panic attacks, delusions, hallucinations, and angry. This is only naming a few symptoms...

Words: 1093 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Organizational Management 501

...Paper Management and Organizational Behavior 501 Introduction I know whenever I have a bad day at work I am not in a very good mood when I get home. I think most people cannot help but carry some of their mood from work home with them. And things at home can affect your mood at work, particularly if it is negative. In this paper I will discuss what I believe job satisfaction spillover is and whether it is a positive or negative. I will also analyze the results of the study conducted in the required reading article and discuss the conclusions that came from the study. Discussion To me, job satisfaction spillover is basically letting what happens at work affect your home life and what happens at home, affect your work. So if you have a bad day at work, you are most likely going to be in a bad mood when you first get home. Of course some people are able to separate their work and personal lives, but I believe no matter how hard you try, they will affect each other to some degree. If you are having problems with your family at home, most of the time it is hard to not think about it when you are at work. This is going to affect your work. I think being unhappy at home has a greater affect on work, than does being happy at work has on home life. If you truly enjoyed your job and felt satisfied, you feel good about your situation. This would probably put you in a good mood when you left work and went home. But if you did not like what you did for work...

Words: 1326 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Life Factors and Life Events in Health and Social Care P2

...LIFE FACTORS AND LIFE EVENTS PASS 2 For this assignment I will be explaining the potential effects of five different life factors on the development of an individual. I will also be looking at unpredictable and predictable life events and how they could have an effect on the development of that person. Potential life factors, unpredictable and predictable life events could include: Employment Income Housing Environment Education Culture Gender Relationships Marriage Parenthood Birth of a child Starting work Retirement Divorce Serious illness or injury Redundancy and unemployment Bereavement Abuse HOUSING Having good housing will have a positive affect on growth and development. Your home is a place where you should feel safe a secure so by having good housing conditions and if you live in a nice peaceful area this will make you feel safe and allow you to decorate and stamp your own personality on your home. You will want people to come around to your house because you will have a sense of pride about home which will enable you to keep in contact with your friends and family. Where you live is also important, for younger people living in a urban area will give them access to more social activities and facilities which is important for their own self-esteem and growth and will allow them to make more friends and feel wanted by society. Rural life is often quieter which will suit families with younger...

Words: 2691 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

The Effects of Study Habit on the Academic Performance

...THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND Introduction Individuals are really different; thousands would love to study at night before going to bed, while thousand others will love to study at dawn. Late night is normally quiet and you are unlikely to be disturbed by anyone. Besides you have longer hours to review all your notes and works unlike the dawn when you will have to race against time. A thorough review at night will help you remember the whole thing you have learnt while the hesitant studying at the dawn is highly prone to forgetting. This is true for a particular group of people. This is entirely against the theory of “Early to bed and early to rise makes a man healthy wealthy and wise”. Waking up the whole night to study for exams is sure to affect your health. Late night study is less productive as the mind loses concentration late at night. Lack of sleep affects your daily life. It weakens the strength of the students and you can lose focus during the examination. It will also lead to serious memory impairment, thus making no use of the hard work and study. Research has suggested that sleep and good memory are bed fellows. Burning midnight oil harms more than it serves. The researchers say that at least a good night sleep within 30 hours is needed to remember a new task later. Science has also said that teen brains work most effectively at night. However, the scientists concluded that a good night's sleep, which includes both slow-wave and REM (Rapid eye movement) sleep...

Words: 548 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Research

...Name: Ryan Chistopher M. Reynado Yr. and Section: BSGE – 2C Problem no. 1: Failing Grades Title of Study | Author | Data/Result/Theories | Date Publish | Website | 1.Why Do Students Have Failing Grades? | So Yeon Ann (F) | There is no one reason that will explain why students is having a failing grades. According to studies of some experts, there are many reasons why students failed, lack of personal direction, pressure from parents or peers, laziness, ect. The most common is lack of direction because many students don’t set or know their goal in life. This will lead to laziness in their studies. To prevent these failures,  students need to be identified by their abilities in order to pursue a certain career. This will make them realize their potentials and set a goal in their lives, within their abilities. Maybe one day,we, students, will succed in what we want to achieve. | August 25, 2011 | http://social.eli.ubc.ca/2011/08/25/ why-do-students-have-failing-grades/ | 2.Reasons Students Get Poor Grades | Ron Kurtus(F) | There are number of possible reason why students get failed or poor grades. External factors, subject is too difficult to understand, techer is hard to understand, and problems at home. Some other reason is they don’t do their homework or they are too idiot to get off in their class. If the subject is the problem, better seek help. Let the teacher know that you are having a problem on the subject. If your problem is the techer, because of his attitude or...

Words: 653 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Wal-Mart Effect Book Report

...positively and negatively. The Wal-Mart Effect is an economic theory by Charles Fishman that explores the positive and negative impacts that affects consumers’ everyday from around the world because of Wal-Mart’s practices. He describes these effects as including the suburbanization of the local shopping experience, the driving down of local prices for all everyday necessities, the draining of the viability of the traditional local shopping areas, a continual downward pressure on local wages, the consolidation of consumer product companies aiming to match Wal-Mart's scale, a continual downward pressure on inflation, and a new and continual cost scrutiny at a wide ranges of businesses enabling them to survive on thinner profit margins. Questions: 1. Do you agree or disagree with the economic theory the book presents? Why? Since the book has many different theories, and many of them vary in scope such as international to local, there are some points the book makes that I don’t agree with. However, most of the ideas presented in the book introduce many new economic concepts to me, and I find very interesting. It explains how a small grocery store in America can potentially affect a local shopper in Chile. Most of the ideas presented in the book associate with international connections and some that The Wal-Mart Effect alludes to are very intellectual that I certainly agree with. 2. How does this theory affect your everyday life? Apart from just being an international chain...

Words: 382 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Factors Affecting Business Management and Office Administration Students’ Behavior in Shifting from One Course to Another

...Chapter 1 1 INTRODUCTION Background of the Study Shifting of course is a way of college students to change their chosen program to another that may have been caused by many incompatibility to compete in that specific program. Choosing a course is difficult. A lot of factors are to be considered. Choosing to pursue it or not is more difficult. Even the brightest student fails in class sometimes. On the other hand, it is unhealthy to force a student into something that he is not happy with. It will only result todisappointments and regrets in the future. The first year is adeciding period for most students as to whether they will pursue their respective degrees or shift to another. It is the year when students begin to question the significance of their subjects to their courses. If the course does not meet the demands of students it may cause failure or boredom that makes them shift.True dedication to studies cannot be easily disrupted by unpromising class performance. Although the choice of what course to pursue is often based on practical reasons, there are students who are driven by a “true calling.” These are students who are truly passionate with what they are taking up now. They cannot be easily disheartened by unsatisfactory quiz and exam results.Grades can serve as a basis when choosing between shifting and staying. However, passion is the ultimate determinant in finalizing one’s decision. ...

Words: 1971 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Kindred Todd

...MGMB 223: Organizational Theory: Group Assignment. You are required to study a particular company. The requirements of the chosen company are: 1. It must have been established more than 20 years. 2. It must be a company that employs more than 10k employees 3. It must be a global company (doing businesses in multiple regions) 4. Diverse workforce. Your assignment is due 8th April 2016 You ought to be able to discuss the company’s establishment in your assignment. Here are some questions that could be your guideline for this assignment. 1. Historical background of the company. 2. Describe the way the company has grown and developed over the years since its establishment. 3. What are the company’s goals and objectives (short and long term?) 3. What does the company do? What kind of services and products that it produces? 4. Who are their stakeholders? Categorized and explain. 5. Prepare and explain the organizational design. In your opinion, what can be done with regards to the company’s design in order to make it more competitive and more dynamic? 6. Explain the line of authority and what kind of structure does the company adapt. Why it use this structure? 7. Describe the company’s general and specific environments/how do the environment affect its operations? 8. Describe briefly the company’s working culture and how it affects the way it operates? 9. Explain the company’s major competitive advantages. How does the company utilize its competitive advantages to maintain...

Words: 286 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Article 4

..."Perception and Peak Performance." The New York Times. 28 Mar. 2012. Web. 01 Apr. 2012. | |. | |One paragraph BRIEF summary of the article: | |This article is basically talking about how our perception affects our performance in different sports like soccer, basketball, or golf. | |Psychology professor (as well as March Madness basketball fan) Jessica Witt conducted a research on how our perception affects our performance| |and confidence while playing sports. To test her hypothesis she used golf and tested different people’s performance by creating illusions to | |make the size of the ball look either bigger or smaller. Her tests concluded that the people who imagined a bigger hole did better than the | |people who imagined it smaller, as the illusions enhanced their performance psychologically. The article proceeds to elucidate further on the | |subject as well as provide counter arguments to Witt’s theory. | |Identifying the Knowledge Issue(s): |Key quotes from the article: | |Main Knowledge Issue:...

Words: 1013 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Part 2 Chapter 1 Research About the Factors Affecting Student's Study Habits

... organize your life around your achievement. Covey (2004) illustrated a highly effective system of time management that can benefit anybody. This system is primarily based on the theory that most of us are driven by a consuming sense of urgency. But through this system, Covey is instructing us to divide all our priorities into the following four quadrants: Figure 1. Stephen Covey's Time Management Quadrant 1: Important and Urgent – Items in this category are integral to your life and require your immediate attention. Quadrant 2: Important but Not Urgent – Items in this category are integral to your life but do not require your immediate attention right now. Quadrant 3: Not Important but Urgent – Items in this category are not integral to your life, but they do require your immediate attention. Quadrant 4: Not Important and Not Urgent – Items in this category are not integral to your life and do not need to happen at any particular time (or not at all, for that matter), yet doing them consumes your time and energy. Dependent Variable * Grades * Interest Independent Variable * Subject * Teacher * Time * Mind set (Pessimism vs. Optimism) Figure 2. Paradigm of the Study This concept shows some factors that can affect the performance...

Words: 841 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Whaaat

...truly wonderful resource” (Kristian David Olson). Though some would look at music as a small footnote in the progression of humanity, it is in fact a much greater force; for some, it defines their very existence. The fact is, music is a driving force in society; it has been present since the dawn of man. The average person spends several hours a day listening to music, whether they see it as a main activity or just as something to take up space in the background. It is not surprising, then, that music has a great effect on how humans think and act, possibly even affecting intelligence. Several studies have been conducted on this theory; though some results are questionable, the consensus view seems to be that music has the capacity for both positive and negative effects. As a background activity, listening to music has been shown to positively affect mood, productivity, and even intelligence. As stated on the Reverse Spins website: “simply listening to music in the background while doing an arduous task can make it seem much easier, or in some cases […] ease the strain of an activity” (Olson). Whether it is merely a distraction from the stress of a situation or genuinely lifts the mood of the listener, music has been shown in several studies to increase productivity in this manner. In both cases, the listener often finishes the activity in a shorter period of time and with less residual stress. If implemented into the classroom or workplace, this effect could improve test scores...

Words: 412 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Ldr 531 Week 4 Conflict Resolution Storybooks

...with Todd why he felt the need to shelter the team from the bad news. According to Middaugh 2013 “We are all more receptive to communication or signals delivered in a positive manner rather than negatively” (Middaugh, J. D. p 262). Todd has the personality to act positively in any given situation. Hence, Todd has used filtering to sound positive. As the manager, after understanding he cares for others emotions, the recommendation would be to be more straightforward with the bad news so that the team can actually do something about the company’s social media performance and help increase future results. In this situation, an email or telling Todd to focus on the point via email may make his even more nervous to express any news and can affect his ability to communicate the right message to team. Firstly, seeing his nervous physical gestures it would be proper to meet Todd personally, make him...

Words: 907 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Excel Spread Sheet Everest University

...According to Miller (2014) “there is generally a direct relationship between price and quantity supplied; as the price rises, the quantity supplied rises”(p. 58). How this concept affects me and my family is that we are victims of the market place. My family and myself cannot rely on prices remaining constant so we may end up having to pay more at times because of the laws of supply and which way that pendulum may be swinging at any given time. In short, because there has been more of a demand for something and therefore more is being supplied, I may even have to do without it because I choose not to buy it due to a price increase. 2.) According to Miller (2014) “another factor is ceteris paribus, conditions of supply; they include the prices of resources (inputs) used to produce the product, technology and productivity, taxes and subsidies, producers’ price expectations, and the number of firms in the industry” (p. 62. How this affects me and my family is let’s say that I was going to buy a refrigerator, the cost of products to produce refrigerators has risen, this will increase the cost of the refrigerator in the long run, at that point it would be best to wait it out and buy when the price evens out again. Another way that this theory affects the economy and my family is that if timber were to increase in price, it would raise the price of resources used to produce homes which in turn increases the price of homes ...

Words: 1447 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Animal a

...likely to happen in real life. * It was done in a lab therefore it lacks ecological validity. It is within an artificial setting * P may not be emotionally aroused as they watch a video because it is not the same as real life * P also may not feel any sense of responsibility as they would have felt in real life. * Because P’s took part in all the studies they might have shown demand characteristics. * Small sample size limits generalizability | Effects of age on eyewitness testimony. Aim: conducted an experiment to see if age affects recall ability (1993). Method: He got a young woman to stop people in the street and chat to them for 15 seconds and then 2 minutes later they were asked to recall the characteristics of the woman. They conducted this on 651 participants (P’s). The results showed that all age groups performed similarly, but younger people were more confident in their recall, and so concluded that age doesn’t affect EWT....

Words: 792 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The Effects of Social Factors in the Academic Performance of the Bbte Students College of Education

...will be left behind on what to do inside the institution. These rules and culture cannot be found only in books. It can be also found and learned through interaction with the co-learners and the teachers because there are times that the rules are changing based on the time, place, and people. But there are still some students who tend to explore more on the campus by joining the said social activities. The negative side of their participation in these activities is that they have a tendency to give more time than to study and do other academic activities. There are times that students are much focused on the activities of the social factors they are into. The question now is how does these students and the social factor they are into affects their studies and how do they manage and balance their time in order for them to have an equilibrium between the two variables. II. BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY...

Words: 1630 - Pages: 7