Premium Essay

Affirmative Action Effectiveness

Submitted By
Words 1056
Pages 5
The query of whether organizations should utilize affirmative action plans to hire individuals is critical, because equal hiring practices require affirmative action plans. In this paper, I argue that within the current public perceptions or misinterpretations of affirmative action, and the question of what should be considered equal hiring policies, there is no simple answer to this controversial issue. Due to the weaknesses of the arguments against affirmative action plans, I will argue that employers should utilize affirmative action plans more often, given that it provides results in terms of higher diversity in the workplace.
Before I begin, I need to define what I mean when I reference these terms. An organization will be regarded as …show more content…
Firstly, affirmative action is effective in increasing diversity in the workplace and its benefits override the imperfections associated with it. Affirmative action allows for more individuals to join professional organizations that they otherwise would not have been able to join due to ethnic barriers or due to a lack of diversity in that professional organization. Morally speaking, diversity is favorable because it allows organizations to receive different perspectives from a variety of professionals, not just from one social group. Without allowing different perspectives organizations are at a disadvantage because including people from only one social group, tends to favor the same outcomes. The same opinions from one social group do not always provide the best outcomes because people of different social groups will provide a broader range of perspectives due to ethnic backgrounds and experiences different from the prominent social group in the workplace. Second, placing labels on minorities serves to highlight the achievement of these individuals in relation to the culture they are part of. It is nearly impossible to avoid placing labels on people when trying to bring about some change, which allows them to advance their position in society hence, when seeking promotions or employment in an organization. If labels do …show more content…
However, affirmative action need not be considered harmful to beneficiaries. Beneficiaries receive an advantage from the affirmative action plans which leads non beneficiaries to believe that they are not able to advance their self-interests. Non-beneficiaries argue for their own self-interests, in realizing that they do not receive any advantages from the policy. According to a study of sixty white students, who were told that whites were harmed by affirmative action, they were more likely to endorse the harmful to beneficiaries’ objective. This proves the harms to beneficiaries’ objection weak, because non-beneficiaries only perceive the harm once they realize they don’t receive any benefits but harms from the policy. The lack of support for the policy arises from a feeling of threat the non-beneficiaries sense as they are seeking jobs in the same organizations as those receiving advantages from the policy. This response also fails, because it need not consider the results of diversity the policy it brings to the table. The objection, only aims at trying to highlight the negative outcome of the policy put in place. It fails to consider that this policy merely highlights these individual’s achievements when compared to others who possess the same cultural background. Those claiming the harms to beneficiaries objection fail to understand that these individuals are “non-White” and would not be able

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

The Effects of Equal Employment Opportunity and Affirmative Action in Women Sports

...EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY AND AFFIRMATIVE ACTION IN WOMEN SPORTS March, 2007 TABLE OF CONTENTS Title Page i Table of Contents …..……………………………………………………………………2 Section I. Introduction 3 Section II. Review of Literature 4 Equal Employment Opportunity Laws 4 Affirmative Action 6 Effects of EEO and AA on Women Sports 7 Effects on EEO and AA on women playing sports 7 Effects of EEO and AA on women coaching sports 9 Effects of EEO and AA on women in administration………………...11 Section III. Summary and Conclusions 14 References ............... 17 INTRODUCTION Women in sports have indeed come a long way. Years ago it was socially unacceptable for women to do anything other than cook and clean. Men dominated the work place and the sports industry. But eventually women got fed up with being treated less significant than their male counterparts and began protesting. Not until the mid-1950s and early 1960s did nondiscriminatory employment become a strong social concern (Bohlander & Snell, 2004). While women were just beginning to make a name for themselves, the government began regulating Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) by passing a series of laws, in an attempt to correct social problems of interest to particular groups of workers, including women. EEO laws have made a major impact on women in all industries, but especially on women in sports. While EEO laws focused on non-discrimination, affirmative action went beyond providing equal...

Words: 4585 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Creating and Affirmative Action Plan

...Creating an Affirmative Action Plan An affirmative action plain is a formal plan created by employers to address the disparity of minorities and women in the employer’s workforce. Affirmative action plans are also implemented by organizations to meet a requirement for doing business with the federal government. An employer may also look to implement a plan to rectify past discriminatory practices. This paper will examine several of the key factors that are needed in creating an effective affirmative action plan. Before any deficiencies can be addressed a job group analysis needs to be conducted. This analysis is used to show each job classification and if it is held by a woman or minority. The objective of the analysis is to show the availability of women and minorities for a particular category. The data retrieved from the analysis will be used by the organization to identify where the underrepresentation is occurring. The data from the analysis can be compared with census data to gain a better understanding of the area’s demographic and the organization’s workforce makeup in relationship to the area’s demographic. Once a class is identified as being underrepresented steps can be taken to fill vacancies in that classification with individuals from the protected classes. An affirmative action program is justified if an employer can show a disproportion in a job classification that has previously been segregated (Eisaguirre, 1999, p. 84). Recruiting practices must be examined...

Words: 785 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Affirmative Action

...Though affirmative action may have been valuable in the beginning, it has long since outlived any usefulness it may have had. That it ever had any usefulness is questionable, based on comparisons between overall black populations socioeconomic standing today and that of the mid-1960’s. Today, it is little more than a scapegoat behind which inferior performance can hid very well, and that scapegoat’s upkeep has become far too extravagant in today’s society. “We didn’t land on Plymouth Rock my brothers and sisters--Plymouth Rock landed on us,” Malcolm X’s observation is brought out by the facts of America history. Snatched from their native land transported thousands of miles--in a nightmare of disease and death and sold into slavery blacks were reduced into the legal status of farm animals. Even after emancipation, blacks were segregated from whites--in some states by law, in social practice almost everywhere. American apartheid continued for another century. In 1954 the Supreme Court declared state compelled segregation in schools unconstitutional, and it followed up that decisions with others that struck down many other forms of official segregation. Still discrimination survived, and in most southern states blacks were either discouraged or prohibited from excersizing their rights to vote. Not until the 1960’s was compulsory segregation finally and effectively challenged. Between 1964 and 1968 congress passed the most sweeping legislation since the end of...

Words: 3048 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Racial Diversity

...Different people with different backgrounds can offer fresh perspectives, ideas, and solutions; also diverse workforce is more resilient and flexible which can help ensure organizational survival. Input from diverse work groups can enhance rational decision making and therefore efficiency. Efforts like Equal Employment Opportunities (EEO) and the affirmative action, EEO prohibits discrimination based on race, color, ethnicity, religion and gender in employment. The affirmative action was meant to compensate for past discrimination, but now diversity is very important to the organization because of the direct correlation with the organizational effectiveness. It is a critical for an organization to enable their employees express rather than suppress their identities and roles they have outside of work.  Save Race-Related Jokes for Later If the joke you want to tell at work includes a rabbi, a priest or a black guy, save it for home. Many jokes about race, religion and culture involve stereotypes. Accordingly, the work place isn’t the best place to share them. Even racial banter between colleagues from the same background can be off putting to others. Some people disapprove of racial humor, no matter the source of it. So, consider telling race-based jokes to be inappropriate behavior at work. Keep Stereotypes to Yourself Stereotypes about racial groups abound. While working, it’s necessary to check your race-based assumptions at the door. Say you think all Latinos are good at a...

Words: 1056 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Management

...HR Recruitment and Hiring Campaign The core objective of undertaking recruitment and selection is to ensure that an organization has a reliable workforce with requisite skills and talents that befit the open positions (Armstrong & Armstrong, 2011). Recruitment, therefore, is searching or attracting a sufficient number of candidates who will then be subjected to interviews and tests. Selection, on the other hand, is a process of rejection; it involves scrutinization of the numerous numbers of candidates who had applied for the open position (Dessler, 2004). Through the selection process, the interviewing team ensures that the best candidate of all is hired to fill the vacant position (Noe, 2006).In this paper, therefore, I have developed a comprehensive recruitment and hiring plan for New York police department. Essential Elements of the Job The open positions entail recruitment and hiring of most competent and qualified police officers. There is a need to restore the police image and reputation among the members of the public. The new recruits will serve to enhance security and at the same time not infringe on the public interest. The officers will also participate in public sensitization and awareness programs to create mutual understanding with the community. Mutual understanding and cooperation between the police and the community is critical for the promotion of security programs as this region is cosmopolitan. The newly recruited officers...

Words: 1229 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Debate

...Affirmative action is a practice that is intended to promote opportunities for the “protected class” which includes minorities, woman, and people with disabilities or any disadvantaged group for that matter. With affirmative action in place people of this protected class are given an even playing field in terms of hiring, promotion, as well as compensation. Historically, affirmative action is only known to have protected African Americans and woman; however that is not the case. Affirmative action protects a variety of people and without this statute many people included in this protected class would be unfairly discriminated against. There are many reasons why affirmative action should continue to be a part of workplace such as: • Fosters diversity. • Educates our workforce on diversity. • Equips employees to achieve their highest contribution to the mission. • Challenges employees to make their maximum contribution to the mission. • Encourages employees to offer differing views and suggestions toward achieving organizational goals. • Respects and appreciates individual differences. • Provides equitable treatment and opportunities. • Creates and maintains an inclusive approach to all systems, policies, and practices (i.e., promotions, performance ratings, awards, training, assignments, and access to services). • Facilitates culture change to support wider diversity. People who are opposed to affirmative action often argue that it gives an unfair advantage to...

Words: 790 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Bus 302, Management Concepts, Chap 12-13

...backgrounds have the same opportunities, companies should ____.Answer | | | | | Selected Answer: |    survey employees about their perceptions and satisfaction | Correct Answer: |    survey employees about their perceptions and satisfaction | | | | |  Question 4 3 out of 3 points | | | In a recent meeting, San Mateo County Supervisors voted unanimously to conduct a(n) ____, which would provide an accounting of how well the makeup of local boards and commissions reflects the racial, gender, cultural, geographic, and ethnic diversity of the county.Answer | | | | | Selected Answer: |    diversity audit | Correct Answer: |    diversity audit | | | | |  Question 5 0 out of 3 points | | | Affirmative action programs are typically designed to ____.Answer | | | | | Selected Answer: |    create homogeneous...

Words: 1241 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Diversity

...INTRODUCTION Becoming a diverse organization makes good business sense for both for profit and not for profit companies. Creating a diverse workforce provides tremendous opportunities for organizations and individuals to tap into the ideas, creativity and potential contributions inherent in a diverse work force. The composition of America’s workforce is changing. According to the census Bureau, nonwhite will represent more than one-third of the U. S. population by the year 2010 and close to half of the U. S. population by the ear 2050. By the year 2005, the ethnic minority share of the workforce will reach 28 percent. It is also projected that the Hispanic-American population will be the largest minority group in the U. S. by the year 2010. In order for companies to fully and aggressively compete in the marketplace, they will need to consider these statistics and work towards attracting, recruiting, developing and retaining a diverse workforce. This will be critical if they are to survive. They will also need to recognize that the market they cater to is becoming more diverse. Diverse groups are a growing percentage of the buying power in the United States. In order to maintain competitive advantage in the sector they serve, organizations will need to truly understand its customers, clients, members and employees and will need to create an organizational climate that is welcoming to all. The Birth of the Diversity Movement The “Diversity”...

Words: 2841 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Human Resource Management

...recruitment of its employees, to the management of all works, and the problem solving issues that are directly affecting the organizations’ employees. Employees are an asset to an organization, and HRM is responsible for providing them with opportunities to learn and acknowledge their achievements especially in an organization with diverse employees. On the other hand, they take care of employees’ well-being and safety, so as to make them productive and driven. Armstrong (2009) describes human resource management (HRM) as a strategic approach for the development and well-being of employees in an organization. Their main concern is to ensure that the organization benefits from its people, therefore, they aim to increase the organizational effectiveness and...

Words: 4305 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Employee Selection

...EMPLOYEE SELECTION with AFFIRMATIVE ACTION Helen Tewolde May 7, 2007 HRM 6622 Dr. Robert Sauer INTRODUCTION Selection is the process of choosing individuals who have relevant qualifications to file existing or projected job openings (Bohlander & Snell (2007). There are different criteria, themes and laws that are critical for employee selection research and practices. Employee selection is an ongoing process in today’s workplace. In most organizations the managers and human resources specialists are involved in the selection decision. Selection criteria used to evaluate employees consist of categories, education, experience, physical characteristics and personal characteristics. These criteria’s should be stated directly in the job description, which can allow potential candidates to see what is required of the position.  Another aspect of employee selection is job analysis. Job analysis is able to obtain information about the jobs and determine what type of individuals to match to the positions. There are many major developments with comparing between a person’s attributes and targeted occupational requirements. Interviewers who participate in selection should maintain a close liaison with the other departments so they can become familiar with the jobs and skills needed to perform them. It is very imperative that all Human Resources Management Department abide by the rules, regulations, and laws...

Words: 3015 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Wal-Mart, an Organizational Analysis

...Wal-Mart, an Organizational Analysis Kenneth Russell Strayer University Dr. Mary Tranquillo Bus. 310 November 6, 2012 Wal-Mart, an Organizational Analysis Introduction I will thoroughly discuss in detail the operation of Wal-Mart, the company’s strategies, legal concerns and various challenges the company faces. In addition, I will address any current (or anticipated) human resource issues concerning the expanding into the international market and make recommendations on how the organization can leverage its human resources to come out on top in a highly competitive market. Wal-Mart, an Organizational Analysis Describe the nature of the organization, its size, and any specific human resource challenges it faces. One of the most recognized retail chains around the world, Wal-Mart is an American public multinational corporation running chains of large discount and warehouse stores. Considered the largest public corporation when ranked by revenue, Wal-Mart boasts a staggering 2 million employees worldwide with approximately 1.4 million in the United States. (Wal-Mart, 2012). Wal-Mart is known for their brand of low prices and high volume which dominates the retail market. Wal-Mart’s mission statement and slogan sums it up in one simple phrase: “We save people money, so they can live better”. Wal-Mart’s idea and strategy is targeted at offering consumers a variety of name brand goods at competitive prices. Wal-Mart has over 10, 300 retail stores in 27 countries...

Words: 1511 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Diversity

...global world emphasis continues to progress towards workforce diversity as the forefront of effective organizational strategies. This has contributed to the expansion of the definition of diversity. We no longer define diversity by race and gender, lifestyles, personality, education, and geographic origin.” Diversity now includes everyone.” Diversity and affirmative action are sometimes confused with each other, though there are significant differences between the two. The term affirmative action involves regulations and laws that regulate hiring and promoting of employees without regard to their race, color or national origin and later expanded to include inequalities and discrimination against such groups such as women, ethnic minorities, the disabled and veterans. However, diversity is a broader concept. It can be defined as understanding, valuing and respecting the human qualities, characteristics and beliefs of individuals or groups that are different, such as ones ethnic or and racial background, cognitive and physical abilities, socioeconomic status, religion and other different states of being. Affirmative action and diversity are separate points, yet both are aimed at stimulating the inclusion of people from different human qualities in the workforce (Larsen, 2011). Cultural diversity is when differences in race, ethnicity, language, nationality, traditions, and sexual orientation are represented within a workplace. A workplace is said to be culturally diverse if...

Words: 888 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Affirmative Action

...AFFIRMATIVE ACTION   What is affirmative action?               As your advisors, paid handsomely to represent the issue of Affirmative Action in the United States to you, we have gathered and analyzed the core considerations surrounding the issue. We see that there are immense difficulties in reconciling opposing moral views, and that empirical data does not reveal an obvious truth.  But there can be much gained in way of a better understanding of the issue in spite of these obstacles if we can take a holistic approach to the problem. Affirmative action is a two-pronged effort that includes “the right of all persons to be accorded full and equal consideration on the basis of merit” (K.U Medical School) and, concurrently, a policy of actively “hiring and promoting qualified individuals in protected groups such as minorities, disabled veterans, Vietnam-era veterans and women” (U. of South Dakota). It was created to focus on education and jobs, and the policies were put in place to take active measures, under the framework of non-discrimination, to ensure that disadvantaged groups that had prevalently suffered discrimination have the same opportunities as whites. The U.S. Department of Labor describes affirmative action as the “ban[ing of] discrimination and requir[ing of] contractors and subcontractors to take… action to ensure that all individuals have an equal opportunity for employment, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, national origin, disability or status as...

Words: 4179 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Questionaire for Hrm

...Managing Diversity To address diversity issues, consider these questions: what policies, practices, and ways of thinking and within our organizational culture have differential impact on different groups? What organizational changes should be made to meet the needs of a diverse workforce as well as to maximize the potential of all workers, so that San Francisco can be well positioned for the demands of the 21st century? Most people believe in the golden rule: treat others as you want to be treated. The implicit assumption is that how you want to be treated is how others want to be treated. But when you look at this proverb through a diversity perspective, you begin to ask the question: what does respect look like; does it look the same for everyone? Does it mean saying hello in the morning, or leaving someone alone, or making eye contact when you speak? It depends on the individual. We may share similar values, such as respect or need for recognition, but how we show those values through behavior may be different for different groups or individuals. How do we know what different groups or individuals need? Perhaps instead of using the golden rule, we could use the platinum rule which states: "treat others asthey want to be treated." Moving our frame of reference from what may be our default view ("our way is the best way") to a diversity-sensitive perspective ("let's take the best of a variety of ways") will help us to manage more effectively in a diverse work environment. ...

Words: 1033 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Notes

...v=hmhGzTEGa70) > Exceptions due to merit, seniority Effectiveness of Equal Pay Act Difference was 60 cents on the dollar Currently 80 cents on the dollar Women’s wages have plateaued despite more education, more hours Some argue gap due to “Women’s choices” Civil Rights Act Most comprehensive piece of legislation in terms of diversity (gender, race, religion, ethnicity) Impacts employers of more than 15 employees working 20+ hours a week, unions, employment agencies Constructive Discharge Making the work environment so unpleasant than an employee is forced to quit. Disparate Treatment When an applicant or employee is treated differently because of their membership in a protected class (Intentional discrimination) > Women have poor math skills > People with Hispanic last names don’t speak English Disparate Impact Occurs when an apparently neutral, evenly applied policy or practice has a negative effect on the employment of people belonging to a protected class (Unintentional discrimination) Must demonstrate statistical evidence for lawsuit Examples > Education requirements > Height, weight requirements Bona Fide Occupational Qualifications In a limited number of cases, discrimination on the basis of sex, religion, and age is not illegal Affirmative Action Whereas Civil Rights Act is passive (prohibits discrimination), Affirmative Action Programs require action Affirmative action applies to employment and education of minorities in government...

Words: 434 - Pages: 2