Free Essay

An Unorthodox

In: English and Literature

Submitted By gbp623
Words 1129
Pages 5
An Unorthodox Protagonist
In Antigone, a drama written by the ancient Greek playwright Sophocles, the question of who the protagonist of the play is may be easily confused. It is a highly disputed topic concerning exactly which character plays the role of the protagonist, Antigone or Creon. In order to decide which character possesses the merits to be considered the true protagonist, one has to consider: what is the definition of protagonist? Is it simply the title character, or the most relatable or sympathetic character, or are there other qualifications? Greek tradition holds a variation of the definition that has stumped critics and has divided them over which character is best suited for the leading role. The self-realization and recognition of one’s mistakes is also one of the credentials, and with further examination, Creon emerges as being best suited for the role of the protagonist.
We derive our definition of a Greek tragedy from Aristotle, who originated that definition on the basis of plays from his time, such as Antigone. Greek tradition defines the dramatic protagonist as one who is regarded as extraordinary, and is brought from happiness to agony. “The character’s stature is important because it makes his or her fall all the more terrifying” (Meyer 1423). From this basic definition, Aristotle went on to include that the protagonist is the main character that possesses a tragic flaw, and later realizes his or her own faults and mistakes. Aristotle used “hamartia” as the term for these weaknesses (Meyer 1424).
Based on these definitions, Antigone and Creon both have the potential to be qualified as protagonist. They both battle forcefully for something that they believe strongly in. In Antigone's case, she fights for the honorable burial of her brother. She does this because she considers the laws of the gods to be greater than the edict laid down by her uncle Creon. In the case of Creon, the king of Thebes, he fights for adherence to his laws. Creon's battle is not traditionally a conflict that would make him a sympathetic character, nor is the audience lead to feel all that much empathy for him, but he sticks to his own morals just as Antigone remains devoted to her own.
Both Antigone and Creon seem unwilling to concede or compromise with each other, staying dedicated to their position. Creon also seems especially unwilling to concede based on the fact that his opponent is female. “Therefore we must defend the men who live by law, never let some woman triumph over us. Better to fall from power, if fall we must, at the hands of a man – never be rated inferior to a woman, never.” (Sophocles 1488)
After this, when arguing with Haemon, he calls him a “woman’s accomplice”, and a “woman’s slave.” He advises Haemon to “never lose your sense of judgment over a woman” (Sophocles 1487). It is his unwillingness to admit that he could be wrong that leads to his ultimate downfall. The king is upset that his son would take the side of a traitor over him, even though she is his son’s fiancée. He sees his son’s defense of Antigone as unmanly, and as a sign of weakness. He says that it would be better to fall at the hands of a man. “Never be rated inferior to a woman, never” (Sophocles 1488). Haemon is trying to convince his father that his ruling is unjust. Creon just can’t get over him taking a woman’s side. The more the two argue the more it appears that Creon’s stubbornness is cemented by his sexist mindset.
Antigone and Creon both prove themselves to be extremely stubborn and prideful in their own actions. In this, Antigone fulfills the first sense of the word protagonist. The entire play is titled after her name. The plot is focused around her and on her beliefs and the actions she takes to satisfy them. Although, she may possess a tragic flaw that would ultimately make her the undisputed protagonist, her unwavering and defiance of Creon to the very end puts this into question. In keeping with the fight, Antigone decides to kill herself before Creon has the chance, and it is this stubborn quality that most antagonists share: to fight against the protagonist and defy them to the bitter end. She does not take responsibility for her mistakes, and never finds herself to be in the wrong, and it is this lack of epiphany that makes Creon bested suited to be the protagonist.
Although the title of the play is Antigone's name, Creon shows characteristics of a protagonist more so than Antigone herself. When paired with the basic definition, Creon executes the role of protagonist when he recognizes his own faults and tries to mend them. He then accepts responsibility for his actions.
“And the guilt is all mine –
Can never be fixed on another man,
No escape for me. I killed you,
I, god help me, I admit it all.” (Sophocles 1504)
Antigone does not do this. Creon’s intense pride prevents him from relenting in the fight with Antigone until he sentences her to death, against the advice of the town and his own son. By enforcing this punishment, Creon is later make aware that he made mistakes. Creon used this information to recognize his errors, and he attempted to go right his wrongs. He first went to give Polynices a proper burial and then went to the cave to release Antigone from her sentence, but when he arrived, his efforts were too late. He found Antigone dead in her cell. By trying to fix his mistakes, Creon showed characteristics of a protagonist.
Antigone and Creon both fulfill the basic definition of protagonist, but it is the final acceptance of blame that sets the two apart. They both possess the stubborn characteristic of leading characters, but Antigone is stubborn and defiant to the end, while Creon is later devastated and takes responsibility. When taking the second half of the definition of protagonist into consideration, Creon is a more suitable candidate for the central character. He not only plays an important role in the plot, but he also realizes his mistakes and tries to fix them. Unlike Creon, Antigone never recognizes her faults, and she fights Creon to her death, with her very death also being a form of rebelliousness against him, which is a quality that is usually found in the antagonist. Based on these features, Creon shows himself to be an unorthodox contender for title of protagonist.

Works Cited

Meyer, Michael. The Bedford Introduction to Literature. 8th ed. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2008. 1423-1425. Print.
Sophocles. “Antigone”. Trans. Robert Fagles. The Bedford Introduction to Literature.
Ed. Michael Meyer. 8th ed. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2008. 1469-1505. Print.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Unorthodox

...Match the following with their corresponding units (s2 represents s-squared): Velocity | Answer 1 | Moment of Inertia | Answer 2 | Energy | Answer 3 | Acceleration | Answer 4 | Force | Answer 5 | Torque | Answer 6 | Charge | Answer 7 | Question 2 Not complete Marked out of 1.00 Flag question Question text If a car is travelling at 100 miles/h between two cities that are 100 miles apart from each other - how long with the car take to reach one city from the other: Select one: a. 1 hour b. 96.56 seconds c. 68 seconds d. Cannot calculate Question 3 Not complete Marked out of 1.00 Flag question Question text If an object with mass 10 Kg is moving at a velocity of 50 m/s west and collides with a stationary object with mass 10 Kg - after the collision the the first object comes to a complete stop (0 m/s) and the second object will move west at a velocity of ... Select one: a. 50 m/s b. 100 m/s c. 25 m/s d. 0 m/s - come to a stop Question 4 Not complete Marked out of 1.00 Flag question Question text F = ma implies Select one or more: a. Force field is equal to magnetism and amplitude b. Force needed to move a mass 'm' to an acceleration of 'a' is calculated by the product of m and a. c. Falling speed is equal to mass time amplitude d. If a force of F is applied to a mass m, the mass will experience a acceleration Question 5 Not complete Marked out of 1.00 Flag question Question text What is the magnitude of force...

Words: 1657 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Unorthodox In Brave New World

...“But I don't want comfort. I want God, I want poetry, I want real danger, I want freedom, I want goodness. I want sin” (Huxley 240). Brave New World is a novel about a dystopian society that uses power, drugs, and conditioning to control its population. Embryos are genetically modified so that they fit into a certain social caste, and the lower caste embryos are put through the Bokanovsky’s Process to make thousands of identical twins. Citizens of the society are deprived of basic human feelings, such as, love, passion, and freedom. Within the novel, unorthodox characters are introduced seeking a purpose in life. One of those characters is John the Savage. Throughout Aldous Huxley’s, Brave New World, John the Savage proves that he is physically,...

Words: 915 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Handmaid's Tale Unorthodox Quotes

...appearance deceives many. This quote by Phaedrus is a good representation of some of the characters in this book. They may seem like they are orthodox but deep down they could be trying to overrule the government and it’s rules. In the book, The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood, many characters follow the “rules” but there are also many characters that are rule breakers. They are expected to follow all of the regulations, and if they do not follow them then they will get punished. Offred, Moira, and the Commander all show that they are unorthodox in this novel. The first character that symbolizes unorthodoxy is Offred. “As long as we do this, butter our skin to keep it soft, we can believe that we will some day get out, that we will be touched again, in love or desire” (Atwood 96-97). Offred spends most of her time daydreaming about how her life used to be and all of the freedoms she once took for granted. These thoughts she continuously has shows unorthodox because they are to do with escaping Gilead somehow. “And it would be so flaunting, such a sneer at the Aunts, so sinful, so free. Freedom, like everything else, is relative” (Atwood 231). This is...

Words: 810 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

When Unorthodox Religions Become Inhumane or Unjust

...When unorthodox religions or cult practices become inhumane or unjust Introduction This research project examines when unorthodox religions or cult practices either becomes or perceived as inhumane or unjust by specifically focusing on unorthodox religions during a twenty year period between the 1950’s through the 1970’s. The research focuses on five different unorthodox religions: The People’s Temple, founded by Jim Jones, Heaven’s Gate, founded by Marshall Applewhite and Bonnie Nettles, Scientology, founded by L. Ron Hubbard, Children of God, founded by David Berg, and Branch Davidians, founded by David Koresh. Langone, M. D. (1995). These five unorthodox religions or cults may have had or have different doctrines and practices, but research shows that they may all share the common trait of being inhumane or unjust. Rationale/Thesis Statement In the International Cultic Studies Association article, by Dole and Eichel (1985), a survey was conducted about dangerous practices associated with cults and referenced different actions that they deemed destructive, from coercion to enslavement, which they believe to be inhumane and unjust. This research study will attempt to uncover some of these practices and find out what draws people to these unorthodox religions or cults. Likewise, this research project also attempts to determine the point at which practices become inhumane or unjust. It’s interesting to note, that three out of the five unorthodox religions or cults included...

Words: 2155 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Unorthodox Theology of the Revisionists Stream of the Emerging Church Developed from Culture

...LIBERTY UNIVERSITY BAPTIST THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY  The Theology of the Emerging Church: Unorthodox Theology of the Revisionists Stream of the Emerging Church Developed from Culture  Submitted to Dr. Richard Elligson, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the completion of the course  THEO 510 D13 Survey of Theology by Ray Ruppert May 7, 2014 Table of Contents Introduction...................................................................................................................................... 1 Definition of Emerging.................................................................................................................... 2 Emerging from Modernism.................................................................................................... 2 Emerging from Culture.......................................................................................................... 3 Emerging Theology................................................................................................................ 4 Comparing Revisionists Theology with Orthodox Theology....................................................... 5 Identify with the Life of Jesus.............................................................................................. 6 Transform the Secular Realm................................................................................................. 8 Conclusion.............................................................

Words: 3877 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Outline

...you need to do is find a talent agent a talent agent is pretty much your connection to casting director. a casting director is The person responsible for assigning roles in a movie, play, or other production. Next is location according to a magazine called Hollywood vine location is important in New York and Los Angles it is easier to become an actor. 3. Another reason why location is important is because most casting directors live In New York and Los Angeles even though some shows are filmed in other places around the U.S most of the casting is done in New York or Los Angeles. B. Different styles of acting 1. There are different styles of acting the different styles of acting are method acting , Brechian and some unorthodox styles of acting....

Words: 540 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

What Role Can Alternative Healing Process Play in Mental Health.

...reason or the other seemed to work; and from my observation I could say this could be based on psychological adaptations. There are different religions; Islam, Christianity, Buddhism, traditional and the like. These two religions also have their strict spiritual principles and modes and methods with Odusifuo, Prophets and the likes which also subjectively speaking seem to work and as such have been accepted by different people from different backgrounds in the country. More often than not, though, reliance on these unorthodox methods, all of the above mentioned causes problems and only escalates the problems the clients or patient or in this case victim faces. TIME FACTOR: It is quit mind boggling to see the shock some victims go through and the extent to which they are marred and yet still people patronize these services from the known fetish priests and so on as mentioned above. But upon some survey it will be noticed that these administers of unorthodox methods for instance have more time for their patients or clients. Due to the fact that their reputation stands the risk of being lost as they may be known to the locals far and near and also for the fact that their customers want value for their money as they are charged, they go through excruciatingly long hours with their patients in order to ensure they are healed. PSYCHOLOGICAL IMPACT: Also another point to be noted is the psychological impact had on the patients. The whole scenario of attention...

Words: 712 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

David Sedaris

...was experiencing, allowing the reader to share in the sadness. Luckily, he was able to relate with his classmates; they had in common a feeling of compassion for each other and “took no comfort in the fact that, unlike Hyeyoon Cho, we all knew the irregular past tense of the verb to defeat,” (122). As the school year continued, the feeling that it was going to be “impossible to believe that any of us would ever improve,” (125) sunk in deeper and deeper. At one point, the teacher insulted Sedaris, maybe worse than she had previously; it was that moment that he realized he understood every word she had said and a huge sense of accomplishment overcame him. All at once, he had his ah-ha! moment and realized that while the teaching method was unorthodox and sometimes outright abusive and scary, through hard work and perseverance he had learned far more than he was cognizant of. He felt as though “the world opened up,” (137). He recognized that while he still had a lot of work to do to be able to speak French fluently, understanding was the first milestone and he had overcome...

Words: 864 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Low-High Context

...(Masculine) or liking what you do (Feminine). Masculinity | | Femininity | social gender roles are clearly distinct: Men are supposed to be assertive, tough, and focused on material success; women are supposed to be more modest, tender, and concerned with the quality of life. | | social gender roles overlap: Both men and women are supposed to be modest, tender, and concerned with the quality of life. | Uncertainty Avoidance The extent to which the members of a culture feel threatened by ambiguous or unknown situations and have created beliefs and institutions that try to avoid these High UA | | Low UA | maintain rigid codes of belief and behaviour and are intolerant of unorthodox behaviour and ideas | | maintain rigid codes of belief and behaviour and are intolerant of unorthodox behaviour and ideas. | Long Term Orientation How every society has to maintain some links with its own past while dealing with...

Words: 395 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Defying Expectations Of Women In Little Women

...and Amy are all loving sisters who journey from adolescence into womanhood experiencing many captivating moments along the way. Jo, unlike her “prim and proper” sisters, goes about life in a very different way than that of a typical nineteenth century woman. She recognizes her disparities and strives to be different when she says, “I want to do something splendid...something heroic or wonderful that won’t be forgotten after I’m dead. I don’t know what, but I’m on the watch for it and mean to astonish you all someday” (Alcott 147). This quote shows her determination to be something other than a domestic housewife. Jo March defies the traditional expectations of nineteenth century American women through her unladylike behavior and her unorthodox career choice. First, Jo demonstrates her unladylike behavior through her use of language, opinionated remarks, and choice of clothing. Unlike her three sisters, Jo March is clumsy, blunt, and very opinionated. She is not afraid to speak her mind and be different. In the novel, Jo is very opinionated with her feelings towards John Brooke. She conveys them to Meg saying, “‘He's dull as powder, Meg. Can't you at least marry someone amusing?’” (Alcott 312). This type of response is demonstrates Jo’s unladylike qualities because she has a tendency to lose her temper and lash out. This temper nearly costs her the life of her youngest sister, Amy, after finding out she burned her manuscript. In addition to her use of language and opinionated...

Words: 773 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The Pursuit of Freedom

...oppressed.” With great relevance to many women who are striving for freedom around the world, the memoir Unorthodox: The Scandalous Rejection of my Hasidic Roots by Deborah Feldman portrays a young woman named Devoireh, struggling to grow and gain the freedom she deserves under all the restrictions and barriers laid upon her. Contained in these pages, are the examination of the primary and secondary sources such as: the movie Erin Brockovich directed by Steven Soderbergh, the memoir The Bite of the Mango by Mariatu Kamara, articles such as Norse Jewish Women Tells Of Holocaust from the New York Times and Judaism, the women’s version by Tamar Rotem which brings out the major themes like freedom, determination, struggle and courage. Within these primary and secondary sources a strong relation to the major archetypal figures are displayed through out the memoir such as: the crusader, the survivor and the innocent, the contexts of these sources depict Feldman’s interpretation of Devoireh. There are many strong willed women who are told they are incapable of pursuing what they want because they are “women”. With many struggles and obstacles, in the film Erin Brockovich, the major character Erin displays herself as a remarkable woman who achieved what she desired most because she had a vision to pursue her goal. This plot unveils the theme determination from the memoir Unorthodox because in relation to Erin, Devoireh was in pursuit to set herself free from her Satmar community and...

Words: 1520 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Qaqc

...processes underlying the appearance of a stable social reality, in mapping complexity and journeying through difference to new frontiers. (O’Brien 2009) Arguments Berger’s (1963) approach was more like an invitation to assess one’s conceptions and realize if they are really valid and applicable in understanding or identifying the real subject or ‘problem’ at hand. He’s not asking you to disregard the ideas that the said society had accustomed to you but to consider seeing things in a wider scope. One must search for the backbone of everything and not be fixated on the obvious. When something is not in order, do not focus on the exterior but try to examine the roots and branches that hold it together. For O’Brien (2009), to dwell on the unorthodox part of a study, the personal conflicts that one experiences, is an effective way to edify one’s knowledge when it comes to her expertise and of course, not only does it add to one’s growth as a professional but also to one’s awareness of himself or herself. Even if a sociologist is considered as ‘value-free’, one’s experience and all the conflicts that he or...

Words: 688 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Mississippi State Case Study

...Mississippi Mayhem In the world of college football, Mississippi State fans are not used to having such great success on the field. Every year Mississippi State experiences a mediocre season at best, mainly due to the daunting SEC West division. Over the past century, Mississippi State has never experienced a championship season. It has been a hundred years of heart break and disappointment for the bulldogs. This season Mississippi State is 9-1, and is actually relevant in the College Football Playoff discussion. What caused this miraculous season was a progress that started with unorthodox recruiting, development of players, and Heisman Candidate Dak Prescott. The past five years, Mississippi State has had an average recruiting rank of twelfth in the SEC. Those underrated recruiting classes have played in four consecutive bowl games, and a current 9-1 season. The coaching staff prides themselves on finding talent that has been overlooked by the rest of the SEC, especially in state talent. Sixty percent of Mississippi State’s current roster consists of athletes from the state of Mississippi. What the recruiting rankings do not show are how well the underrated prospects develop into star athletes....

Words: 484 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Brave New World

...Miranda Chester Mr. Meyer Senior English March 5th, 2013 Journal Entry #1 After considering my current tastes, desires, talents, gifts, and intellectual capacity, I believe that if I had to pick a caste between Alpha, Beta, Gamma, Delta or Epsilon to stick with for the rest of my life, I would pick Beta. Why? I would choose Beta because I picture Alpha being almost perfect. Perfect abilities, perfect features, the perfect capacity to do amazing on everything. I know that I make mistakes in my life and I know that sometimes I struggle and that I could do better on many assignments, but I accept my flaws and know that I need leeway to make mistakes and not be perfect. Beta is the perfect caste to me because it gives me that leeway that I need. I would be extremely happy with being a Beta for the rest of my life. But thats not to say that one caste is better than another. Every caste is a necessity for the World State. As a quote in the book reads, “Every one works for every one else. We can’t do without any one. Even Epsilons are useful. We couldn’t do without Epsilons. Every one works for every one else. We can’t do without any one.” This quote perfectly defines what I am trying to say. Every caste is needed and appreciated by others. Of course, no caste would want to be that lower or higher caste. People will be who they want to be but there needs to be variety of people and I am proud to say that I would fall...

Words: 1258 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Bernard Marxism In Brave New World

...In Brave New World by Aldous Huxley, Bernard Marx’s character is established as an individual seeking social acceptance, yet one who is also confined by society’s expectations. Though he resists society initially, underlying his strained unorthodox ways and perceived rejection of social norms is a man who ultimately needs to be accepted. Huxley shows readers the multifaceted sides of Bernard’s journey towards acceptance, while also creating a utopia-like world. Initially, Bernard is a character who is dissatisfied with himself. It was being rejected that forged Bernard’s resentment towards society - this is apparent in his hypocrisy at the Solidarity Service and how he goes out of his way to unorthodox in chapter seven, when they arrive at...

Words: 566 - Pages: 3