Premium Essay

Analysis of the 1978 Film All Quiet on the Western Front for Historical Accuracy

In: Historical Events

Submitted By amcbride
Words 1631
Pages 7
All Quiet on the Western Front
Analysis of historical accuracy in the 1978 television production

The 1979 film, All Quiet on the Western Front, is based on the 1929 novel by World War I German veteran, Erich Maria Remarque. The narrative portrays the nature of WWI from the perspective of a young German boy from his enlistment and deployment to the Western Front in 1916. It explores many concepts of the war including trench warfare, total war, and the overall long term mental and physical effects of war. Minus minor flaws where minimal information is given, the film appears to be a historically accurate portrayal of Trench Warfare and Total War.
The film accurately portrays major elements of WWI, giving historically accurate insight into life in the trenches, war tactics, and gas warfare. The film accurately depicts the trenches as home to, not only the soldiers, but also to disease spreading rats and lice. Those fighting in WWI faced the devastating trench foot condition which was treatable only by amputation; the film truthfully portrays this issue as the duckboards which were used in an attempt to avoid this are shown on the trenches’ muddy and puddled ground. “No Man’s Land”, the term referring to the gap of land between the trenches of the opposing armies, is distinctly portrayed as lifeless, with smoking artillery induced craters, and the bodies of fallen soldiers left strewn across it. As the war progressed, bodies had to be left as it became too dangerous to collect them. Precisely as it was during the war, the film shows soldiers going “over the top”, as they attempted to climb out of the trenches to attack many are gunned down even before clearing their own bunker and if they were lucky enough to make it out they were likely killed shortly after. These futile tactics are both historically documented and displayed in this film as being used throughout…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

All Quiet on the Western Front

...moment is the feeling many of the soldiers had in the novel All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque. The camaraderie felt between the soldiers was quite evident throughout this piece of work. One connection that was immense throughout the book was the main character and narrator, Paul’s feelings toward Kaczynski (Kat), a fellow soldier and great friend. Paul’s relationship with Kat only seems to grow, creating a special bond as the novel progressed. From comforting Paul after his first hand to hand combat to simply being a friend to rely on, Kat was always by Paul’s side. Kat had an amazing impact on Paul during his time at war and on leave. When Paul was released for his short leave in Chapter 9, Paul couldn’t help but feel like he was out of place once he arrived back home. Paul realized he had changed as a person and was worried about his fellow comrades fighting on the battlefield. He often longed to return to the war so he could be back with his friends. When he arrived back however, he felt different. “I have an uneasy conscience when I look at them, and yet without any good reason” (89). He found his confidence when he was with Kat and felt that is where he belonged, fighting along side him. Kat always had a way of comforting Paul, and even though he did not want to seem childish, Paul looked up to Kat. This bond kept Paul strong and ready for anything. While fighting on the front, Paul resumed an animalistic instinct and faced......

Words: 650 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

All Quiet on the Western Front

...All Quiet on the Western Front Like the cover of a book, we often judge a movie based on its opening scene. If it is too dull or bland, we immediately lose interest in the film and can often have difficulty regaining the focus needed to enjoy the remainder of the movie. For films that deal with such emotional and controversial ideas, such as war, it is important for the film director to create a powerful and captivating opening sequence. Lewis Milestone was faced with these problems while he was directing the 1930’s film, All Quiet on the Western Front. Through his strong sound, filming and editing techniques, along with inspiration from Sergei Eisenstein, Milestone was able to draw in the audience right from the beginning of the film. Like most films during that time period, All Quiet on the Western Front begins with a dramatic orchestral performance as the credits are shown on the screen. The use of snare drum and brass instruments give the piece a very patriotic and wartime feel. The audience does not need to recognize whether the piece is German or American, they all just feel the same sense of urgency to act upon their patriotic duties and go to war. As the march reaches its climax and falls to a close, the preface of the novel is shown as a slide on the screen. These words are used to show both the reader and the audience that this war, World War I, should not be glorified. It is a reminder that war devastates and destroys all. As the opening scene truly......

Words: 1086 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

All Quiet on the Western Front Essay

...The War’s Effect’s Towards Soldiers World War I was one of the most significant wars in U.S. history. It was significant because it created a gateway for new tactics, weapons, and it carved the way for a whole new style of warfare. In the book All Quiet on the Western Front, by Erich Maria Remarque, Paul Baumer, the main character, and his comrades go through horrifying experiences that affect them both physically and mentally. Throughout the book Paul shows how war is a dehumanizing experience, but he continues to find ways to make him more human by appreciating the little things that he didn’t notice before his previous war experiences. Throughout the war Paul witnesses things that make him more empathetic and compassionate. These specific war experiences have influenced Paul in both negative and positive ways. For example when Paul comes to realize that the Russian prisoners are suffering he suddenly shows sympathy towards them by, “I take out my cigarettes break each one in half and give them to the Russians.” (194) As Paul overlooks the violence and fighting of the war he realizes that the so called “enemy” is just another man fighting for the same reason as he is. Paul now has a new outlook on the war and he is showing a very unexpected sensitive side, which is most definitely him being “human”. During the intensity of the war Paul was holding nothing back while being in battle with the men shooting at them with no feelings or regret. As Paul now looks at the......

Words: 1016 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

"All Quiet on the Western Front" Juxtaposition Essay

...All Quiet on the Western Front Juxtaposition Essay In any war, there are two separate and shockingly different perspectives: that of the warrior, and that of the average citizen. To those not actually fighting, casualties might seem simply a number while to the soldiers, they are a constant reminder of the price their friends, brothers and more often than not themselves are willing to pay for the protection of their country. In Erich Remarque's revolutionary novel All Quiet on the Western Front, Remarque shows the world what is really like to fight a war. By juxtaposing seemingly polar opposites, Remarque shows the reality of war. Remarque weaves a substantial amount of war imagery into All Quiet on the Western Front, using this technique to further exhibit the appalling realities of war. Though all the general public might see is that a soldier has been injured, Remarque vividly describes how that injury came to be, saying, "His hip is covered with blood...If he has been hit in the stomach, he oughtn't to drink anything. There's no vomiting, that's a good sign. We lay the hip bare. It is one mass of mincemeat and bone splinters. The joint has been hit. This lad won't walk anymore" (68). Using graphic and striking adjectives, Remarque brings the reader into what a common soldier's train of thought in times of great stress. Due to the fact that Remarque's main character Paul is in the middle of a battle, his thoughts are few, though precise. Writing sections of a......

Words: 640 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

All Quiet on the Western Front

...Baumer is no different. In All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque, Paul Baumer enlists into the war and is transformed from a young man to a hardened veteran. Throughout the war, Paul Baumer changes in a variety of ways: physically, emotionally, and mentally. One way Paul Baumer changes in the war is through a physical way. While evacuating a village, Paul and Kropp get injured, with Kropp’s injury being dangerously close to his knee. They go to get medical help, and Paul refuses to get chloroform for fear that he will wake up with something amputated. Paul thinks to himself, “I am frightened and think quickly what I ought to do; for everyone knows that the surgeons in the dressing stations amputate on the slightest provocation” (242). Paul’s injuries are hurting him very, very badly. His physical pain is so much, he fears of amputation. But, he absolutely refuses to receive chloroform in order to see what is going on and to make certain he leaves the same he came. This is a physical change because Paul has never had injuries as bad as he did in the war, and has never felt that much pain. Another way Paul makes a physical change is on October 1918. It is a rather peaceful day with little to no fighting going on at all. It was quiet on the western front. On this day, Paul Baumer dies. “Turning him over one saw that he could not have suffered long; his face had an expression of calm, as though almost glad the end had come,” (296). After all the pain, the......

Words: 1161 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Historical Inaccuracies in the Films

...What reasons do your authors give to explain the historical inaccuracies in the films? It’s hard to sometime to see the truth for what it is. When I was growing up my grandma used to say, “There’s HER STORY, HIS STORY AND THE TRUTH!” Inaccuracies in history are usually originated from story tellers (move producers or writers) placing their personal view to a story. In the story Black Robe, the authors wrote the movie from the journal of the missionary Father Jesuit Laforque. To keep the adventurous feel of the film there were a couple of inaccuracies. According to Carnes, M., & Garraty, J. (2008). Father Laforque wrote down a conversation between himself and Chief Algonquin. Later on Father Laforque took this documented conversation to a second European whom was not present and asked him to read the document aloud; Europeans by contrast were illiterate during this timeframe (Carnes & Garraty, p. 46, 2008). In the mystery/suspense film, “The Crucible”, another example of an inaccuracy was Indians tribes journeying 1500 miles in the midst of winter only to set up camps to habituate until spring. The “Dilate” according to Carnes, M., & Garraty, J. (2008) was to keep the audience interested in the story line by focusing in on the girls behavior (Carnes & Garraty, p. 76, 2008). . In the “Patriot” Benjamin Martin wasn’t a real person, but in leaders such as Francis Marion similarity can be found, which could also provide some inaccuracies. Historians......

Words: 734 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Musical Films Analysis

...Major Essay: Question One Musical films have been present in Hollywood since The Jazz Singer (1927) premiered. Mast states that a film is a musical when the primary entertainment and investment lie in the musical numbers (p. 309, Wood, 2008). Musical films are often a beloved or hated genre due to the unrealistic nature of characters erupting into song and dance. This essay analyse four main conventions of the musical genre the spectacle, the narrative, the adaption of established stories and the power the combination of lyrics and music can achieve on screen. Examples from different periods in Hollywood will be used to explore these conventions and how they apply and have evolved to suite conventions of modern cinema. Kellner (2005) explains spectacles have been present in different cultures since pre-modern times. Examples of these spectacles include plays, the Olympics of Ancient Greece, in Ancient Rome public offerings of bread, circuses and gladiator games (Kellner, 2005). The human desire for the spectacle has not fallen into extinction but rather evolved with society and technology. Entertainment has always been a prime field of the spectacle and film has been one of the most productive industries to utilise the spectacle (Kellner, 2005). Hello Dolly (1969), My Fair Lady (1964) and Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Cinderella (1997) are three examples of film musical spectacles. All three of these movies contain elaborate costumes, bright colours and large......

Words: 2739 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

All Quiet on the Western Front

...“All Quiet on the Western Front” by Erich Maria Remarque is not merely a novel itself, but an honest picture of the devastating war to its every corner. Throughout the story, all characters undergo continuous changes, from their appearances to their personalities, from their actions to their thoughts, from their previous lives to the brutal present. As a result, a man coming out of the war turns into a different person as he adapts to the changes. This general idea embraces the whole story and links the details together. Most of the soldiers in the story are Paul’s comrades. Despite their different backgrounds, they are all young and just standing at the threshold of life when they are pushed into the war. In their pre-war lives, they were taught at school about the mind, literature, and other subjects. They strived for freedom and happiness. For such a long period of over 10 years, they were surrounded by teachers, friends and the culture, which were important and had great impression over our men. However, on coming to the training system, they are now taught in the army with guns. They put an end to all dreams and habits. The only things that matter are drill and more drill, boot brush and surviving in the harsh system. Specifically, the narrator, Paul, used to write a play and a bunch of poems earlier, which indicates that he has an artistic mind and a sense to melody and rhythm. Sadly after being trained for the war, not only does he stop writing and composing, but he......

Words: 648 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Western Front

...WAR LITERATURE ASSIGNMENT ON PAUL BAUMER’S CHARACTER AS A REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ‘LOST GENERATION’ IN REMARQUE’S NOVEL, ALL QUIET ON THE WEATERN FRONT All Quiet on the Western Front is a novel by Erich Maria Remarque. The novel is about the experiences of ordinary German soldiers during the war. It is based on Remarque’s own experiences at war which enabled him to capture the realism and authenticity needed to exemplify the feelings of a soldier. Through the novel he was able to capture the feeling of seclusion and loneliness among the soldiers. In 1916, he was drafted into the German army to fight in World War I, in which he was badly wounded. In 1926, after the war ended, he published Im Westen Nichts Neues which he later translated into English as All Quiet on the Western Front. The novel has been heralded by critics throughout the world as the greatest war novel of all time. It helped capture every thought that went through a soldier’s mind who belonged to the "lost generation". War changes life. Conditioned by the aggression and lifestyle of being a soldier, young adult Paul Baumer in Erich Maria Remarque’s novel All Quiet on the Western Front, over the course of four years, changed from a naive high school graduate to a mature but disillusioned adult. The violence and trauma in the trenches of World War I exposed Paul to the horrors of injuries and infections, the fragile state of life, the terrors of......

Words: 1912 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

All Quiet on the Western Front

...Lady Macbeth Essay Shakespeare’s play Macbeth was written in the early 17th century and chronicles the lives of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth as Thane of Crawdor and lady of Crawdor, and later on as King and Queen of Scotland respectively. Lady Macbeth is known as one of Shakespeare’s most famous female characters due to her ambition, strength and ruthlessness. Lady Macbeth can be seen as the dominant half in the relationship between Macbeth and his lady, often convincing, persuading and willing Macbeth to do her bidding. Lady Macbeth can even be seen as a tragic heroine, a term made famous by Shakespeare’s numerous tragedies. However, just like all tragic heroes, Lady Macbeth’s hamartia or tragic flaw would lead to her demise. In exploring the character that is Lady Macbeth, we can see many flaws in her character such as greed, ambition, dishonestly and manipulative to name a few. A tragic flaw, as defined by Merriem-Webster dictionary, is a flaw in character that brings about the downfall of a hero in a tragedy. Lady Macbeth’s greed for power coupled with her moral righteousness led to her demise. This is evident after first, persuading Macbeth to kill the king in order for her to become Queen, second, planning Kind Duncan’s death to the minute detail, and third, being flooded with guilt and blame afterwards leading to her suicide. After Macbeth’s confrontation with the three witches who said that Macbeth will be named Thane of Crawdor and eventually become King of Scotland,...

Words: 519 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Historical Analysis

...BASIC BATTLE ANALYSIS: (Student Handout 1) Study Guide for Battle Analysis Overview: 1. General: The U.S. Army Command and General Staff College developed the battle analysis methodology to help its students structure their studies of battles and campaigns. The format can be easily applied by any military professional seeking insight from historical battles and campaigns to help deepen his/her understanding of warfare and the profession of arms a. The battle analysis methodology is a process for systematic study of a battle or campaign. b. This process takes the form of a checklist that ensures completeness in examining the critical aspects of the chosen subject. c. There are two forms of the Battle Analysis: Basic and Advanced. Both utilize the same four steps, but the Advanced is more complex and detailed. Also, the Advanced analyzes the strategic influences on the battle. 2. Format: The checklist is divided into four steps, each of which builds on the previous one(s) to provide a logical order for the study. a. The four steps are: (1) Define the Subject/Evaluate the sources. (2) Review the Setting (Set the Stage). (3) Describe the Action. (4) Assess the Significance of the Action. b. In the first step, you decide what battle you are going to study. In the next two, you gather the information necessary for a thorough and balanced study, and organize it in a logical manner to facilitate analysis. In the......

Words: 1707 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

All Quiet on the Western Front Review

...Meredith Cheyenne Professor Brillman EUH 2030 August 30, 2014 All Quiet on the Western Front All quiet on the western front is said to be the greatest war novel of all time. Written by Erich Remarque, this novel is set in the early 1900’s during World War 1. It is told in the voice of Paul Baumer, a young German soldier who joins the war to fight on the French front. We follow the events of Paul’s life during the war as well as his group of comrades with whom he lives and learns. While Paul and his friends once entered the war with a child-like innocence, they are quickly shaken with the realistic and painful lives that they are living. They learn to understand the brutality of the war that they are in and that maybe “to die for one’s country” is not as sweet an honorable as they once thought. Throughout the book, there is a constant theme of war and the difficulties of it. It is up to the reader to decipher if they consider the novel to be pro- or anti-war. The book begins at suppertime after coming back from the front lines. Out of their company of 150 men to have gone with them, only 80 returned. Paul and his comrades believed that the extra rations that had been prepared should be dispersed among the remaining men. It is here that we first meet some of Paul’s comrades in war. There is Mueller, Kropp, and Katczinsky. Mueller is said to have been the more realistic one of the group. He sees the war for what it really is and his observance seems to foreshadow the loss...

Words: 1477 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Film Analysis

...Brooks was born Melvin James Kaminsky on June 28, 1926, in Brooklyn, New York. His father's family were Jews from Danzig, Germany (present-day Gdańsk, Poland); his mother's family were Jews from Kyiv, in the Pale of Settlement of the Russian Empire (present-day Ukraine). He had three older brothers: Irving, Lenny, and Bernie. Brooks' father died of kidney disease at 34 when Brooks was two years old.He has said of his father's death, "there's an outrage there. I may be angry at God, or at the world, for that. And I'm sure a lot of my comedy is based on anger and hostility. Growing up in Williamsburg, I learned to clothe it in comedy to spare myself problems—like a punch in the face." In middle age, Brooks became one of the most successful film directors of the 1970s, Brooks started working in various Borscht Belt resorts and nightclubs in the Catskill Mountains as a drummer and pianist. Around this time, he changed his professional name to "Mel Brooks" (from his mother's maiden name Brookman) after being confused with the Borscht Belt trumpet player Max Kaminsky. After a regular comic at one of the nightclubs was too sick to perform one night, Brooks started working as a stand-up comic, telling jokes and doing movie-star impressions. He also began acting in summer stock in Red Bank, New Jersey, and did some radio work. He eventually worked his way up to the comically aggressive job of Tummler (master entertainer) at Grossinger's, one of the Borscht Belt's most famous resorts.......

Words: 1912 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

All Quiet

...All Quiet on the Western Front Basic Information Erich Maria Remarque, All Quiet on the Western Front, published by Ballantine Books, 1956, 295 pages. Author Erich Maria Remarque was born on July 22,1897 and died on September 25, 1970 at the age of 72. His hometown is located in Osnabrück, Germany. His real name is Erich Paul Remark. Erich is the brother of two sisters and the son of Peter Franz Remark and Anna Maria Remark. His family never really stayed in one place, they moved at least 11 times. His original goal was to be a elementary teacher, and began his schooling at the University of Münster. He was drafted into the army in Germany at the age of 18 and was wounded multiple times. After returning from the war he became a race-car driver while working on his famous piece, All Quiet on the Western Front. His first real job he worked at was at a tire manufacturer. He was move to the 2nd company on Western Front on June 12, 1917. He then left Germany in the 1932, after he left the Nazis banned his books through all of Germany. After World War II he moved to Porto Ronco, Switzerland where he then married a famous actor Paulette Goddard. He then left Switzerland and arrived in the U.S. In 1939. Enrich later moved back to Switzerland in 1948, where he spent the rest of his life in peace for 22 years. Setting The time period of the book was during World War I from the 1914-1918. The scene of the book happens in the middle of the war. All the trees have been removed......

Words: 632 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

All Quiet on the Western Front

...thinks to herself, “I need out. Now!” These instances cause Rebecca to become more fearful. She is afraid of the repercussions these instances will have. Will her overwhelming emotions cause future problems for her health or for family? What are these intense moments that are affecting her quality of life? They are known as panic attacks. Panic attacks are a form of anxiety, a common emotion. Anxiety occurs in all of us, and mild amounts, it is healthy. For some, however, anxiety can take the ugly form of anxiety disorders. Because anxiety is so widespread, and potentially dangerous, it is important to understand what it is, how it affects us, and what we can do to cope with it. Anxiety can take many different levels of severity and emerge from many different emotions or attitudes. It can emerge from a fear of a future event, whether that event is real or perceived. Others may feel general uneasiness all the time. No matter what the trigger for anxiety, one detail is key. Anxiety is illogical. Yet, despite this fact, one of anxiety’s most severe effects is common. 1/3 of all 15-35 year olds have at least one panic attack in their lifetime (Hales, Hales 119). What exactly is a panic attack though? A panic attack is when an individual is overcome with a sudden and intense fear. It does not need a specific reason for appearing, and it triggers a severe physical reaction. Panic attacks are no joke, even if at one time people once believed they were just a negative reaction......

Words: 1653 - Pages: 7