Free Essay

Andragogy vs Pedagogy

In: English and Literature

Submitted By eadavis2
Words 1420
Pages 6
Andragogy vs Pedagogy

Andragogy vs Pedagogy Today, there are many ways to obtain an education. Before, students obtained their education through sitting in a classroom in schools, colleges or universities. Now, obtaining ones education may be done by home schooling and online classes. The changes in the education system have led to the development of many teaching methods. Two major and common methods of teaching are andragogy and pedagogy. The purpose of this paper is to compare and contrast andragogy and pedagogy. “Andragogy is the process of engaging adult learners in the structure of the learning experience” (Conlan, Grabowski, & Smith. 2013). In simple words, it is the art and science of helping adults learn. This learning experience consists of different methods and strategies to assist adult humans in obtaining their education. Pedagogy is the connection of the teaching by the teacher, to the learning of a child student (Gehring, 2010). Thus, pedagogy literally means the art and science of teaching children. This is the most dominant form of teaching and referred to as the traditional, teacher-directed approach. “Andragogy is a newer word that was coined in the 1800s by Alexander Knapp, a German educator, and popularized in the 1960s by Malcolm Knowles, an American educator whose focus was on adult education” (Findsen, 2010). It fell into disuse and didn’t reappear until 1921when Rosenstock argued that adult education required special teachers, methods and philosophy (Smith, 2010). Andragogy was first introduced to the United States in 1927 by Martha Anderson and Eduard Lindeman, but they did not attempt to develop the concept (Smith, 2010). In 1959, Malcolm Knowles expanded on the work of Eduard C. Lindeman. Extensive work by Knowles and other educators resulted in the development of new assumptions about adult learners.

The word pedagogy is much older than the word andragogy. “Pedagogy, as a word, first appeared in the mid- to late-1500s, in Middle French, and has roots in Latin and Greek” (Ozuah, 2005). The roots of pedagogy can be traced back to seventh century Europe during the introduction of organized education at monastic schools. The primary purpose for the establishment of these institutions was the induction of young men into the priesthood. The model of pedagogy first emerged at this time and was founded on several assumptions about learners (Ozuah, 2005). Malcolm Knowles is the father of andragogy as he proposed five factors involved in adult learning. The five assumptions underlying andragogy describe the adult learner as someone who: • Has an independent self-concept and who can direct his or her own learning • Has accumulated a reservoir of life experiences that is a rich resource for learning • Has learning needs closely related to changing social roles • Is problem-centered and interested in immediate application of knowledge • Is motivated to learn by internal rather than external factors (Merriam, 2011, p.5) Knowles used these principles to propose a program for the design, implementation and evaluation of adult learning. Since the development of his theory, Knowles has acknowledged that the principles he outlined did not apply solely to adult education. The development of the theory simply illustrates that the designer "should involve learners in as many aspects of their education as possible and in the creation of a climate in which they can most fruitfully learn" (Merriam, 2011, p.7). Knowles' main focus with the development of andragogy was the notion of the material being very learner centered and the learner being very self-directed. Pedagogy Malcolm Knowles is the father of andragogy as he proposed five factors involved in adult learning. The five assumptions underlying pedagogy describe the learner as someone who: • The learner is dependent upon the instructor for all learning • The instructor assumes full responsibility for what is being taught • The instructor assumes full responsibility for how it is learned • The instructor evaluates learning • Is motivated to learn by external factors Pedagogical assumptions made about learning and learners were based on observations by the monks in teaching simple skills to children (Findsen, 2010). These assumptions were further adopted and reinforced with the spread of elementary schools throughout Europe and North America in the 18th and 19th centuries. When educational psychologists started scientifically studying learning around the Geraldine Holmes and Michele Abington-Cooper turn of the 20th century, they limited their research mostly to the reactions of children and animals to systematic instruction (Findsen, 2010). One of the benefits of andragogy learning style is adults know why they are learning something and able to see how it fits into their immediate situation. Adults have a specific need for the information they are learning as it pertains to their role within their life, and they want to feel like they are in charge of their learning. Another benefit is the opportunity to learn not just from the course materials but from the students in the course. Adults bring a wealth of experiences and knowledge to the learning environment and can share it freely and timely.

One of the benefits of pedagogy learning style is that the instructor focuses on teaching the children life preparing knowledge and they focus on the well-being of the child. Children need a structured environment and pedagogy gives this to them. The instructor decides in advance what is going to be taught, decides how it is going to be taught, and then develops a plan for presenting it to the students. Another benefit is the instructor supports the child in their mental and social development. Pedagogy is the more of learning as a teacher. The art of teaching and instructional methods, pedagogy focuses a child-centered learning. Children rely on their instructors for all bases of learning with this learning style. Andragogy can be seen in the educational setting especially in online classes. Adult learners have already gone through the pedagogy stages as a child. But, as an adult learner they already have a knowledge base and need to obtain more knowledge. Adult learners want to be independent and direct their own learning. Andragogy learning style gives adult learners this opportunity by providing assignments and resources to help adult learners acquire information and skills. An example is the professor prepares a syllabus for the students to follow, student is expected to be responsible, independent in their learning and self - motivated to learn. Pedagogy can be seen in the administrative role when there is a need for training for new changes. Such as evidence based practice in the nursing field. When the core measures first came out there was no knowledge base so all the clinical staff had to be trained. The instructors had to decide in advance what needed to be taught, decides how it is going to be taught, and then develops a plan for presenting it to the clinical staff. The clinical staff depended on the instructor to teach them what they had to learn. The clinical staff had to rely on the instructor for all bases of the core measures so they could put it into practice. In conclusion, pedagogy can be used for children and adult learners. These two learning styles are situational and should be used based on the needs of the learner and the situation. Pedagogy and andragogy are problem centered and focus on details pertaining to the student’s background, experience, environment and situation. The goal should be the same for both learning styles; the learner should benefit the most, making the learning experience process more fun, exciting and challenging.

References
Conlan, J., Grabowski, S., & Smith, K.. (2013). Adult Learning. In M. Orey (Ed.), Emerging perspectives on learning, teaching, and technology. Retrieved from: http://epltt.coe.uga.edu/
Findsen, B. (2010). Comparative Adult Education 2008, Studies in Pedagogy, Andragogy and Gerontagogy, Volume 61. Studies in the Education of Adults. 42(2), 198-201. Retrieved from: http://eds.a.ebscohost.com
Gehring, T. (2010). A Compendium of Material on the Pedagogy-Andragogy Issue. Journal of Correctional Education. , 51(1), 151-163. Retrieved from: http://eds.a.ebscohost.com
Merriam, S. B. (2011). Andragogy and self-directed learning: Pillars of adult learning theory. New Directions for Adult & Continuing Education, v. 89, p. 3-14. Retrieved from: http://eds.a.ebscohost.com
Ozuah, P. O., (2005). First, There Was Pedagogy And Then Came Andragogy. Einstein Journal of Biology and Medicine 21(2), 83-87. Retrieved from: http://eds.a.ebscohost.com
Smith, M. K. (2010) ‘Andragogy’, the Encyclopedia of Informal Education. Retrieved from:

http://infed.org/mobi/andragogy-what-is-it-and-does-it-help- thinking-about-adult-

learning/

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Pedagogy of Oppressed

...Santana-Resto, Marianés August 29, 2012 221 Pedagogy of the Oppressed by Paulo Freire In Pedagogy of the Oppressed, Paulo Freire brings a panoramic vision of the problems to education based of a concept narrative of the teacher. This concept of narration is a problem because is based on filling the student without the option to explore what learned. In this type of education Freire says that can more the sonority that the transformations of the words. That means that the education tends to be mechanical where the creativity is invisible and not seen like a valid option. In the lecture Paulo Freire inserts the banking concept of education, where the student is like an account of the bank, the teacher is the costumer and the education is deposited and filed. The banking concept of education lacks of wisdom, since the stiffness of this education don’t allowed the imagination to build beyond the learned. The students don’t recognize that they also can educate the teacher and this is because are immersed in the ignorance where this system of education maintained. According with Freire the individualistic concept of teacher and student has to be overcome to be a unifying concept in which the teacher and the student learn from each other. The banking concept has a distorted vision of generosity, distortion that the students don’t see; its mission is to forge an adaptation that leads to domination. The banking concept had the domestication concept where the...

Words: 486 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Andragogy

...What is Andragogy? Mercedes McIntosh COLL 100 B136 American Public University Tom Werner Title of Paper Begin your paper here. Double space the entire document and be sure that you put two spaces between each sentence. Indent the first line of each paragraph between five and seven spaces by pressing the Tab key one time on the keyboard. Start with a strong introduction that includes a thesis statement (what the point of the paper is). Then add at least three additional paragraphs of details that support your theme or thesis. These paragraphs should end with a sentence that transition to the next paragraph in order to create a paper that reads well and “flows” from one idea or concept to the next. Do not forget PIE: Proof, Information, and/or Evidence to support your points. PIE can be in the form of examples from your own life and/or citations from your resources. End your paper with a strong conclusion. Think of the conclusion as the closing arguments presented by a lawyer to a jury. Include the most important points from your paper you want your reader to remember. Do not introduce any new ideas or topics in your conclusion. If you feel the need to add more content, go back and add that information to the body of your text. Happy writing! References Knowles, Ph. D., Malcolm S., Burlington. The Adult Learner: The Definitive Classic In Adult Education and Human Resource Development. 2011 Elsevier Science Forrest III, Stephen Paul &......

Words: 325 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

A Comparison of Andragogy to Pedagogy

...A Comparison of Andragogy to Pedagogy Before the differences between Andragogy and Pedagogy can be examined a working definition of both needs to be established. Pedagogy is derived from the Greek words paid and agogus, which translates to the art and science of teaching children (Sarapin and Bertoline, 2000). Pedagogy is in actuality the study of being a teacher, the process of teaching, and the correct use of instructional strategies (“Pedagogy,” 2011). Pedagogy helps teachers understand the role of learning theory in the design and function of class activities (Okojie, Olinzock, and Okojie-Boulder, 2006). Pedagogy evolved in 7th and 12th century schools of Europe and its foundational theories about learning and learners are based on observations of monks teaching simple skills to children. These ideas were further adopted and reinforced in 18th and 19th century Europe and North America elementary schools. Even in the beginning stages of the scientific study of learning around the turn of the 20th century, research was limited to mostly the reactions of children. Because of this pedagogy evolved into a learning model predominately for the education of pre-adults (Holmes and Abington-Cooper, 2000). In the early 20th century when adult education began emerging, teachers of adults began seeing problems with the pedagogical model. One of the biggest problems was that pedagogy proposes that the purpose of education was the transmittal of knowledge and skills through......

Words: 1648 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Pedagogy of Teaching

...Personal Pedagogy Statement: Being a Witness, Teaching English Cherise Mayes Azusa Pacific University November 4, 2013 Language and Second Language Acquisition Language is not fixed or limited to words and a series of rules that connect them together. Language is a rich form of communication and social practice involving interpretation and meaning making. Language is our system of communication before anything else; it bridges knowledge, beliefs, opinions, and emotions from one being to the next while creating a bond between them. To learn a language is to understand the relationship between language and culture. How people learn a second language varies systematically and involves the development of listening, speaking, writing, and reading skill sets in the target language. Penny Ur (2012) gives some theories and main ideas on how one acquires second or foreign languages. Intuitive acquisition, habit-formation, cognitive process, and skill learning are defined and probably some of these theories have truth in them. (p. 7) But not one of these alone can underline the complexity of the process of learning a second language. Concrete learning drills in writing and reading literature, acknowledges grammar, uses translation methods, and creating a learner-centered environment where naturalistic communication is utilized. Students and the Teacher: Playing their Parts The student role is being an active learner within all four skill sets, writing, speaking,......

Words: 2425 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Andragogy

...ASSESMENT 1 - Authentic Tasks Report On Andragogy For Human Resource Manager At Google Nathan Puljic 07/04/2014 4057624 Executive Summary Within this report I will be covering the basis of adult learning, other wise known as andragogy. It will be based upon me recently working in a HR graduate position at the Google office in Sydney. I will be covering what andragogy actually means and the types of principles of learning that are suggested by this theory by Malcolm Knowles. Then I shall be writing suggestions on how the Google training manager could use the principles of the theory andragogy in skills training at Google, on the principles they have yet to introduce in their training. Finally I will list four references that I will recommend to the HR manager at Google that I found gave me a better understanding of andragogy. Introduction Learning is "a relatively permanent change in behaviour (or behaviour potential) resulting from one's experiences" (Delahaye, 2011: 31). When adults are learning, we call this andragogy. As we already should know, adults learn vastly different to how children learn (pedagogy). There are many key differences in the learning department when comparing children to adults, such as instead of asking what, adults would ask why. Andragogy is a theory that holds a set of assumptions about how adults......

Words: 2322 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Andragogy

...As a current adult learner Andragogy is a great manual for adult education. The core principles embody all of the ingredients that create a successful student and person. Although Andradogy is geared towards adult learners its principles can be applied to children. Two of these principles really capture why I returned to school. Experience and Readiness to Learn. Experience: As a person matures he accumulates a growing reservoir of experience that becomes an increasing resource for learning. (Matthew Knowles) This is so true. We make mistakes every day, hopefully ones we can recover from, and try to use our experience to make sure we are prepared the next time the situation or problem arises. The experience of not reaching my earning potential because of my lack of degree lead me to Cambridge College. Experiences are the key to life. Without them we would never learn how to survive. Readiness to Learn. As a person matures his readiness to learn becomes oriented increasingly to the developmental tasks of his social roles. Throughout your professional career you learn new software, techniques and policies all the time. To compete in today’s job market you have to be adaptable. Social roles evolve with time. You see that today with technology. It has eliminated numerous jobs that were some family’s single source of income. People who held jobs for twenty plus years were finding themselves unemployed. But on the other hand technology has created numerous......

Words: 358 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

A Pedagogy of Belonging

...A Pedagogy of Belonging Mitchell Beck and James Malley ABSTRACT: The psychological sense that one belongs in a classroom and school community is considered a necessary antecedent to the successful learning experience. In an era when traditional sources of belonging have diminished due to changing family and community demographics, the school plays an increasingly important role in meeting this need. There is evidence that conventional classroom practices fail to engender a sense of belonging, especially among at-risk students. Indeed, conventional practices may exacerbate feelings of rejection and alienation and place these students at higher risk for dropping out, joining gangs, or using drugs. Schools can increase the sense of belonging for all students by emphasizing the importance of the teacher-student relationship and by actively involving all students in the life of the classroom and the school community. Specific examples of programs that promote a sense of belonging for students are discussed. To Belong: To have a proper, appropriate, or suitable place. To be naturally associated with something. To fit into a group naturally — Webster’s New Collegiate Dictionary Can children succeed in a school in which they do not feel they belong? Most children fail in school not because they lack the necessary cognitive skills, but because they feel detached, alienated, and isolated from others and from the educational process. When children feel rejected by......

Words: 3465 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Adult Learning Theory: Andragogy

...Running head: ADULT LEARNING THEORY: ANDRAGOGY1 Adult Learning Theory: Andragogy Jonathan S. Ponce American Public University System Author Note Jonathan Ponce for COLL 100, American Public University System, taught by Instructor Anthony Underhill ADULT LEARNING THEORY: ANDRAGOGY2 Abstract The andragogy theory can best be defined as the art and science of helping adults learn. This paper will explore exactly what the andragogy theory is and how it differs from pedagogy. A few examples of earlier andragogy strategies used in adult education were group discussions, interviews, and joint problem solving sessions. Now a days we see online tools such as discussion forums and blogs being used online to promote learning among adult learners. Simply put, andragogy is an organized and sustained effort to assist adults to learn in a way that enhances their capacity to function as self directed learners. ( Mezirow 1981) But does this method really only apply to adults? Could it be used by the younger learners before they reach adulthood? Is either method greater or more efficient than the other? Though mostly seen as a useful tool in adult education, studies into andragogy have shown that there are flaws within the core principles that conflict with its purpose of being a ......

Words: 1656 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Corpus Linguistics and Language Pedagogy

...Corpus linguistics and language pedagogy: The state of the art – and beyond Joybrato Mukherjee Justus Liebig University, Giessen Abstract The present paper provides a selected overview of the state of the art in corpusinformed language pedagogy. Starting off from a general assessment of the impact that the corpus revolution has already had on English language teaching (ELT), the focus of the main part of this paper is on some typical examples of corpus use in three language-pedagogically relevant areas: (1) using corpora for ELT (e.g. producing learner dictionaries); (2) using corpora in the ELT classroom (e.g. in data-driven learning); (3) using learner corpora. With regard to learner corpus research, for example, the paper also sketches out some prospects for future research, e.g. the compilation of local learner corpora. 1 Introduction: the corpus revolution and English language teaching There is general agreement among empirically-oriented linguists that the advent of large, computerised corpora has revolutionised the linguistic description and analysis of the English language. In modern corpus linguistics, not just any group of texts qualifies as a corpus, but it must be "a collection of texts assumed to be representative of a given language, dialect, or other subset of a language" (Francis 1982: 7). Representativeness is a key issue in corpus design because it captures the attempt to compile a database that provides a statistically viable sample of language...

Words: 7079 - Pages: 29

Free Essay

Andragogy

...------------------------------------------------- Andragogy The most dominant instructional method used in Europe and America is “pedagogy,” or what some people refer to as didactic, traditional, or teacher-directed approaches. Pedagogy, though, concerns teaching children. A competing idea in terms of instructing adult learners, and one that has gathered momentum within the past three decades, is called “andragogy.” (Note: I am using the spelling of this word preferred by Malcolm Knowles, the leading proponent of this theory.) The pedagogical model of instruction was originally developed in the monastic schools of Europe in the Middle Ages (and it is pretty much still the same today). Young boys were received into the monasteries and taught by monks according to a system of instruction that required these children to be obedient, faithful, and efficient servants of the church. The term pedagogy is derived from the Greek word “paid,” meaning child, plus “agogos,” meaning leading. Thus, pedagogy has been defined as the art of leading (or teaching) children. There is an old story concerning the origin of the word “pedagogue;” and, while this may not be true, it is an interesting anecdote. According to the legend, ancient Greek citizens who were wealthy would have a slave whose job was to lead their children to and from the school (the place of knowledge). That slave was called the “paidagogos” (leader of boys), and from that word we get the term for leading children to......

Words: 1429 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Pedagogy of Oppressed

...for authentic existence o Authentic existence requires struggle o The oppressed are fearful of struggle o Therefore, the oppressed have a fear of freedom. • Goal of the Pedagogy of the Oppressed: o This pedagogy must be used in concert with not for the oppressed. o A recognition and reflection on oppression will precipitate the struggle for liberation • The Central Problem: o “How can the oppressed, as divided, inauthentic beings, participate in developing the pedagogy of their liberation?”1 • Process of Humanization: o The oppressed is “host” to their own oppression (through the process of adhesion). [Midwifery example as liberation] o Must struggle to divorce one’s self from the adhesion to the oppressor and thereby liberate both the oppressed and the oppressor. o Recognizing the Situation of Oppression: 1 Is not totalizing 2 Can be transformed into a situation of free autonomy, which is a necessary though not sufficient condition. 3 Recognition of oppression is the first state of liberation [birthing example], but not the only state. Chapter 1 §3: 1 For the oppressor, being an oppressor can cause considerable stress. 2 The oppressor rationalizes his guilt through paternalism. [explanation of paternalism] 1 Freire, Paulo. Pedagogy of the Oppressed: 30th Anniversary Edition. New York: Continuum, 1970: p. 48. 4 • Solidarity with the Oppressed: o The oppressor must have solidarity with the......

Words: 4563 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

Andragogy

...Critics of andragogy state that “it lacks the fundamental characteristics of a science because it cannot be measured.” (Taylor & Kroth, 2009) It is not that they disagree with the foundations of andragogy, but that its variables are subject to interpretation and do not allow for a scientific validation. Within the model of andragogy there are a series of checks and balances with allow the instructor to tailor the model to the needs of the learner. It is a broad model that does not specifically point to one type of learner at a time. However andragogy is a theory about the characteristics of adulthood and the process from which these characteristics come from. Knowles states that the key characteristics of adulthood are “a) self-directed, b) task or problem-centered orientation to learning, c) internally motivated, d) life experience is a rich resource for learning and e) readiness to learn develops from life tasks and problems.” (Knowles, 1980) The best about the model is that it can be modified and adapted with the use of other theories in conjunction with Knowles idea. The worst is that it looks to the individual only and does not take into account the boundaries an instructor has within a classroom environments, were the are more than one individual that needs the program tailored to them. Sometimes it can work well if you have a classroom of like-minded individuals; but often you have to take into account other theories to adapt to the......

Words: 304 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Pedagogy of Freedom

...Pedagogy of Freedom Pedagogy of Freedom Paulo Freire has some interesting beliefs in his work, Pedagogy of Freedom. He takes a deep look into the current education system and shares his ideas looking to shape a new learning process. He mentions that the education system is too structured, which hinders the ability for teachers to teach and that students need to learn in an environment of freedom. This ultimately allows students the opportunity to engage in “right learning.” Freire believes that the current education system is too structured and limits teachers on what they are allowed to teach. Teachers are given a particular curriculum that they are supposed to abide by, which is not always in the best interest of the students. Freire (1998) indicates, “Such teachers inhabit an idealized world, a world of mere data, disconnected from the one most people inhabit” (p. 26). When he brings up the idea of teachers living in an “idealized world,” he is referring to the structure of public schools. Public schools are regulated and given a specific criteria that teachers must cover throughout the year, hindering teachers from teaching topics they may like to cover. Teachers essentially are handicapped when they make lesson plans and have little time during the school year to implement fun or creative lesson plans. On the other hand, the “data” is referring to the materials such as textbooks which are all written by authors not affiliated with the school for the most part.......

Words: 1816 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Andragogy

...------------------------------------------------- Andragogy From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia An•dra•go•gy [an-druh-goh-jee, -goj-ee] Andragogy consists of learning strategies focused on adults. It is often interpreted as the process of engaging adult learners with the structure of learning experience. The term ‘andragogy’ has been used in different times and countries with various connotations. Nowadays there exist mainly three understandings: 1. In many countries there is a growing conception of ‘andragogy’ as the scholarly approach to the learning of adults. In this connotation andragogy is the science of understanding (= theory) and supporting (= practice) lifelong and lifewide education of adults. 2. Especially in the USA, ‘andragogy’ in the tradition of Malcolm Knowles, labels a specific theoretical and practical approach, based on a humanistic conception of self-directed and autonomous learners and teachers as facilitators of learning. 3. Widely, an unclear use of andragogy can be found, with its meaning changing (even in the same publication) from ‘adult education practice’ or ‘desirable values’ or ‘specific teaching methods,’ to ‘reflections’ or ‘academic discipline’ and/or ‘opposite to childish pedagogy’, claiming to be ‘something better’ than just ‘Adult Education’. The oldest document using the term "Andragogik": Kapp, Alexander (1833): Platon's Erziehungslehre, als Pädagogik für die Einzelnen und als Staatspädagogik. Leipzig. Originally used......

Words: 469 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Andragogy

...ANDRAGOGY Merriam and Caffarella (1991) pointed out, Knowles conception of andragogy is an attempt to build a comprehensive theory (or model) of adult learning that is set in the characteristics of adult learners (as cited in Smith,2002,pg.1) Dr Malcolm Knowles was one of the early advocates of continuing professional development. The educational term andragogy was coined by Dr. Knowles. Dr. Knowles focused on finding a coherent and comprehensive theory of adult learning. He felt that the center point should form informal links between people, believing that people could learn a lot from others. Knowles developed the term into a set of principles designed to encourage adult learners to move from dependency to self-directedness. He also believed adult learners could draw upon their reservoir of experience for learning. He also acknowledged that adult learners are ready to learn, when they assume new roles. They want to solve problems, and apply new knowledge immediately (Margerison, 2005). Accordingly, Knowles adult facilitators should set a cooperative learning climate. Adult learners could also create mechanisms for mutual planning and arrange for a diagnosis of learner needs and interests. This would enable the formulation of learning objectives based on the diagnosed needs and interests of the learners. According to Smith (1999),”The facilitators would then design sequential activities for achieving the objectives, execute the design by selecting methods,......

Words: 740 - Pages: 3