Free Essay

Anti-Trust Claims

In: Business and Management

Submitted By 2prissy4u
Words 590
Pages 3
Antitrust Claims
Antitrust represents an uneasy compromise between laissez faire and interventionist visions of public policy. It recognizes the need for governmental involvement in the economy beyond the protection of property rights; yet it rejects overt control of market outcomes. The appropriate degree of governmental involvement for antitrust policy remains a contentious issue. Laissez faire and interventionist economic theories have competed for influence in antitrust decision making ever since the enactment of the Sherman Act of 1890. Antitrust laws were adopted by Congress to outlaw or restrict business practices considered to be monopolizing or which restrain interstate commerce. The Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 declared every contract, combination or conspiracy in restraint of trade or commerce between states of foreign countries to be illegal. Clayton Antitrust Act of 1914, was amended by the Robinson-Patman Act of 1936, prohibits discrimination among customers through pricing and disallows mergers, acquisitions or takeovers of one firm by another if the effect will substantially lessen competition. The Antitrust Division of the United States Department of Justice enforces for the federal government, but private lawsuits to halt antitrust activities have become popular, particularly since attorneys fees are awarded to the winning party. This act is seen to be a legal specialty that has kept a few industries honest.
The world’s largest media company and Microsoft, the biggest software maker, have squared off on several fronts in recent years. New York-based AOL Time Warner sued Redmond, Washington based Microsoft in January 2002. The lawsuit alleged that Microsoft used anticompetitive practices to ensure that its Internet Explorer browser would dominate Netscape Navigator. America Online bought Netscape for $10 billion in 1999, but has not used its browser in AOL's client software. Microsoft said it will provide AOL with technical information to ensure that its products run well on Windows, and the companies also plan to explore how to integrate their instant-messaging software.
According to Aaron Ricadela (2003), Gates and Parsons emphasized the importance of the deal to building a technical infrastructure that ensures consumers can conveniently purchase digitally delivered music, films, and television programming, while protecting copyright holders. According to Ricadela (2003), Parsons stated the market for these products won't expand unless AOL Time Warner creates a platform that can secure multiple forms of content, on multiple computing platforms. The holdup has obviously been piracy.
The claims against Microsoft are valid claims. Microsoft has monopolized the computer arena since day one of its existence. The vast majority of the world's personal computers, estimates range from 80 percent to more than 90 percent, run on Microsoft software from the instant they are turned on. In 1999 Microsoft’s future could not be more assured than any other company. The Internet posed a threat along with a new set of standards that Microsoft could not control. Microsoft was threat to itself. The threat came with Microsoft’s self fulfilling destiny of any monopolist. Microsoft could have failed to drive consumers to new waves of upgrades. The company could have stagnated financially as it retained a grip on the market. Microsoft in a sense is a capitalistic business. No company has Microsoft’s power to place bets. There are few companies that can afford to chance a new approach in a product category near the advancing boundary of Microsoft’s Window package. Microsoft’s attitude is that consumers should be grateful that they have the ability to put a computer on every desk and in every home, all running Microsoft software while connecting to the Internet.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Anti Trust Claims

...Antitrust Claims Antitrust laws were put in place to preserve competition as the rule of trade. Microsoft was accused of violating antitrust laws, and engaging in anti-competitive behavior by illegally using its Windows operating system monopoly. Netscape contended that Microsoft’s anticompetitive practices caused anti-trust injury by violating the Sherman Act. The Sherman Act The Sherman ACT of 1890 prohibits every contract, combination, or conspiracy that restrains trade, or any attempted or actual monopolization or conspiracy or combination to monopolize. While the Sherman Act does not ban all forms of trade, it does stop those that are considered unreasonable. Fixing prices, rigging bids, and dividing markets are all considered violations of the Sherman Act (Anonymous, 2012). It is not illegal for a company to have a monopoly in their industry. However, if the organization attempts to hold their monopoly status through ventures that exclude other companies from having a hold in the market, then the Sherman Act comes into play. Microsoft As most of the world is aware, Microsoft is a monopoly. AOL Time Warner accused Microsoft of engaging in illegal practices to maintain this monopoly (Well & McMillan, 2003). The alleged anticompetitive practices pertained to their Windows operating system. The suit claimed Microsoft held its position as a monopoly in the personal computer operating trade by unlawful exclusionary conduct (Ohlhausen, 2008). In layman’s terms...

Words: 495 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Case Study

...are some of the anti-competitive behaviours SesamWare might be guilty of? How did/might SesamWare’s behavior adversely affect free market competition upon which international trade depends? ( 5 Marks) 3. Is there an international law governing Sesame’s behaviour? How will competition laws be enforced globally? (5 Marks) 4. If SesamWare had been headquartered in a country that had no competition laws, as is the case in many developing countries, or if SesamWare never entered into a contract (for example to buy out a competitor) with a party from the U.S., how could the U.S. claim jurisdiction over the enforcement of its competition laws?? (5 Marks) 1. Assuming that ParaWorld is an open-world game, the scope for IP infringement seems to be infinite. Being a gamer who has played many open world games, it would be difficult to know what kind of infringements would ParaWorld had committed without playing the game and knowing about its rules and environment. The following infringements are likely to have been committed by ParaWorld: * Trademark Infringement: ParaWorld, being a simulation of the real business world, would have replicated trademark logos of Coca-Cola, Mcdonalds and Subway etc without the permission of the owners. * Undisclosed Information and Trade Secrets: The simulation could have revealed certain undisclosed sensitive information of governments and businesses which results in breach of privacy, and national security. * Anti-Competitive licensing...

Words: 672 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Is Genetically Modified Food Safe?

...Is Genetically Modified Food Safe? Shana Kritzer Lourdes University 23 April 2013 Is Genetically Modified Food Safe?   In the spring of 1998, a riot broke out, just outside of Norfolk, England. The cause was not labor disputes or race relations, but a crop of genetically modified food. What began as a peaceful demonstration of anti-genetic modification Greenpeace protesters evolved into a riotous crowd of about 150, who after trampling security guards, marched onto the field and began uprooting and destroying a plot of genetically modified (GM) corn. Protesters used bare hands, trimming shears, and a mowing machine to destroy over 4 acres of the 6 acre plot. Farm workers tried to drive protesters away with a mechanical digger and shovels, while the farm manager disabled the mowing machine by ramming it with his tractor, but the protesters continued to demolish the crop field. After fifteen minutes police arrived and managed to break up the riot. The protest led to 30 arrests and 26 injuries (6 police officers, 12 farm workers, 8 protesters) (“GM Protesters”). After 12 more incidents like this one, numerous raids and attacks on food stores and labs selling or producing genetically modified products, the controversy and upset in England has still not reached an end. Around the world the debate on genetically modified food continues.         Products containing genetically modified ingredients dominate the grocery shelves, with at least seventy-five percent of processed...

Words: 5994 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Media Controls Your Mind

...effect on the choices you make and the morals you live by. One cannot trust everything they see on TV either. Most commercials you would see today are overly exaggerated just to persuade consumers into buying the product. For example, in the 1930’s America’s first “drug czar” Harry J. Anslinger, began one of the world’s greatest public relations campaigns just to demoralize marijuana by telling apparent lies to society and persuading them to believe it. Such as that marijuana is more harmful to the body than alcohol, and tobacco. 70 years later people still believe the lies even after decades of scientific proof. Seeing as how media can “control your mind” we as a whole need to be more aware of it on a daily basis. The mass media has a responsibility to use only truthful explanations as opposed to exaggeration when arguing against the legalization of marijuana. The campaigns that Anslinger participated in consisted of many movies, musicals, and advertisements all demoralizing the usage, and or the distribution of marijuana. The promotion of marijuana making you insane was his main theme throughout his claims. Every single one of his claims missed some very important facts that make them obviously false. Studies over the years has proved that marijuana is less dangerous than alcohol or tobacco, and it is not a “gateway drug” leading to the usage of other drugs. Harry tried to promote these falsely claims to the general public just so that it would stay illegal. He even tried...

Words: 837 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Vaccines Cause Autism

...agendas that brushed aside a generation of children. Notwithstanding all the evidence, one in four Americans still believes that vaccines cause autism (Gross, 2009). Because of this lack of trust in vaccinations, the US saw the largest outbreak of measles in 2008, a disease that was declared eliminated in 2000, due to decreased rates of vaccinations (Ratzan, 2010). Mumps and whooping cough also made a comeback. By 2007, over 5,000 parents of children with autism had sued for compensation. One case in November of 2007 solidified beliefs that vaccines cause autism. The Department of Health and Human Services acknowledged that vaccines had aggravated a preexisting disorder in a baby girl, which caused “regressive encephalopathy with features of...

Words: 971 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The Rhetoric of Cover Girl Advertisements

...DeGeneres promoting a new anti-aging product. In the advertisements featuring Ellen, the advertisers at Cover Girl uses ethos, logos, and pathos in an attempt to convince women to buy their products. By identifying the ways in which Cover Girl’s new advertisements appeal to their audience, students of rhetoric can gain a more complete understanding of how advertisers employ rhetorical principles as tools of persuasion in order to motivate their audience to buy new products. Choosing Ellen DeGeneres as the new spokesperson for Cover Girl most overtly appeals to authority. Many women trust Ellen both because she maintains a level of respect both personally and professionally. On a personal level, Ellen presents herself as an average woman who happens to be funny. Cover Girl hopes that women will identify with Ellen because of her positive and prominent personal reputation. Furthermore, Ellen hosts a talk show that, among other things, establishes her as an honest and reliable source of information. Several American women watch Ellen’s talk show daily and trust her as an authoritative and reliable source of helpful information. For example, Ellen recently included a segment giving advice to her audience about how to save money on Valentine’s Day. Several women rely on Ellen for important consumer information. Therefore, when women see Ellen featured in a Cover Girl advertisement endorsing Cover Girl products, they trust the product to do what Cover Girl claims that it will do. Because...

Words: 698 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Unethical Business Practices

...were intended, and approved for by the FDA. These promotions for non-intended uses were being made through back channels, such as directly to physicians through sales representatives, speakers at sponsored events, as well as advertising in medical journals. GSK had been circumventing the approval process to increase sales of drugs such as Paxil, and Wellbutrin, both anti-depressants. The company had neglected to provide information to the FDA regarding specific findings in research done after the drugs had gone to market. In one medical journal, GSK had published a misleading article that was contrary to actual findings. The misleading claims of GSK to healthcare providers regarding the effectiveness of specific drugs have had far reaching affects, of which cannot be immediately determined. Several of the medications are well known and branded for anti-depressants, and diabetes. According to the US Department of Justice release, GSK had made unsubstantiated claims that the diabetes medication had a "positive cholesterol profile". In fact GSK had no documentation to support the claim. It also was branding the anti-depressants for off-label uses that were never reported to the FDA, nor had proper research done to determine if the off-label uses were safe and effective. These drugs had been marketed, and prescribed to those without the intended medical...

Words: 1160 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Literature Review

...The role of non-evidence based beliefs on anti-vaccination-Literature Review Student Name: Institution: Introduction Anti-vaccination proponents have largely embedded their energies in promoting doubt in parents, instructing forms of biomedical fear while capitalizing on their spiritual and paranormal belief naivety to enforce the same. These approaches are ensured to make it possible that even with any increase in people’s knowledge and evidence, their rational strength over anti-vaccine movements become a myriad.[Lewandowsky et al. 2013] Decision making becomes a weak thing to do because by looking at both ends, things seem to parallel each other. There those who believe in an unquestionable trust in political figures, doctors and other medical professionals. Other parents seem to look at homeopathy, nature and metaphysical tendencies to resolve their medical dilemma as regards to the vaccine.[Huntley and Peeters, 2010; Battles, 2008]. It is at this point that Lewandowski et al. [2013] and his believed that with an increase in knowledge the worldview polarization of science also doubled. Apparently, these issues are evident to point out to the fact that anti-vaccine attitudes are predicted by them. But there is very limited research in place, to depict the underlying factor beneath these forms of psychosocial behaviors against vaccines. The notion of worldview approach to anti-vaccine over vaccines is a current one and stems from paranormal, spiritual, and conspiracy beliefs...

Words: 6697 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Aca Pros And Cons

...In a proprietorship, unlimited liability means that the owner is personally responsible for the debts of the business. In a partnership, it means that if any partner is unable to meet his or her pro rata obligation, the remaining partners are responsible for the unsatisfied claims and must draw on their personal assets if necessary. A Limited Liability Company (LLC) with at least two members is classified as a partnership for federal income tax purposes. The partners are often called members, and only the assets of the LLC or the assets of any members personally responsible for the liability are subject to the claims of creditors. For a multiple member LLC, a separate tax return is filed. As the name suggests, people in this type of business entity have limited liability: only the LLC is liable for the debts and liabilities incurred by the business, not the owners or...

Words: 1081 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Thank You for Smoking (Film Review)

...adapted from a novel by Christopher Buckley. „Thank you For Smoking“ tells a story about Nick Naylor (Aaron Eckhart), who is a tobacco lobbyist. His job is to questioning opposing health claims and advocating personal choice and smoking. As he says in the film, he has a bachelor's degree in kicking ass and taking names. At the same time he tries to be a good father for his twelve year old son, Joey. As the tobacco sales are falling and anti-tobacco campaigns getting more influential, Naylor suggests that putting cigarettes back to movies could once again boost tobacco sales. His boss, called BR (J. K. Simmons), sends him to Los Angeles to meet the Hollywood superagent Jeff McGall. They work out a plan to put cigarettes in upcoming movies. Everything goes perfectly until Nick has an affair with ambitious journalist, Heather Holloway (Katie Holmes). Nick belives he can trust her and tells everything about his life and work. But Heather publishes an article about his life and secrets. After that, Nick gets kicked from his job. Eventually, he talks himself out of that mess and gets another job. Actors carry out their role perfectly especially Aaron Eckhart and J.K. Simmons. This film portrays perfectly the pain spots of America's society. However, in my opinion, I did not like the way how film portrays anti-tobbaco people, because they seemed to be rather ridiculous, which they are not. To sum up, „Thank You for Smoking“ is an excellent comedy, making laughable America's free market economy...

Words: 281 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Hostile Takeovers Microsoft V. Oracle

...PeopleSoft v. Oracle: Hostilities Involved in a Takeover Precious Richey OMM 640 Business Ethics and Social Responsibility (MFF1226A) Instructor – Ken Edick Submitted: 7/23/2012 Abstract The hostile takeover of PeopleSoft by Oracle was the results of a lengthy court battle that raised many issues. One issue in particular concerned anti-trust laws and their application to technology companies. The Department of Justice, in an attempt to block the takeover, argued that a merger of this nature would lessen competition and ultimately limit customer choice. An appellant court judge ruled that this case did not meet the criterion of an anti-trust breach and ruled in favor of Oracle. Never the less, many other factors concerning the role of shareholders, the board of directors and chief officers gave rise to some grey areas. It has been speculated that the outcome of this case has paved the way for similar acquisitions in the technology arenas. The hostile take-over bid by Oracle to acquire the controlling shares of PeopleSoft was a long and drawn out acquisition. The process was marked with uncertainties, government intervention, and changed trends. Some analysis considered the move to be a merger while others considered it to be a consolidate that served as a prelude to the inevitable changes in the software market. In 2003 when Oracle’s CEO announced plans to wage an unsolicited takeover of PeopleSoft’s stock (Boatright, 2009), the decision was met with...

Words: 1387 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Case Study: Trust Issues Glaxo Smith

...Trust Issues: A GlaxoSmithKline Scandal Kamelia D. Sutton Rasmussen College School of Business Management Trust issues a GlaxoSmithKline Scandal GlaxoSmithKline is a global manufacturer of pharmaceuticals, vaccines, and consumer healthcare. “GSK’s mission is to improve the quality of human life by enabling people to do more, feel better, live longer (GlaxoSmithKline, 2014).” According to GSK “prioritizing ethics and performing with integrity is a priority (GlaxoSmithKline, 2014).” GlaxoSmithKline’s research and development is the center of the organization. When research is conducted it is done so in an ethically high standard along with quality standards. Since GSK is a public organization they state they are transparent in their research regardless if the outcome of the research is positive or negative. From 1999 through 2010, GlaxoSmithKline was involved in a scheme to deceive and defraud physicians, patients, regulators, and federal health care programs such as Medicare to prescribe and receive payment for drugs such as Paxil, Wellbutrin SR, and Advair. When we are children we are taught that doctors and nurses are supposed to make us feel better. They are the ones that make all the “boo boo’s” go away. But, what happens when someone puts their trust in a doctor, nurse, or medical professional and that trust is destroyed because of greed, and unethical and socially irresponsible practices? One of the top three global vaccine manufacturers, GlaxoSmithKline agreed...

Words: 896 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Apologeicsplications

...all people grasped this word as it was spread. Some even started to believe that there was no God, or if there was, based on their observations he wasn’t a God they wanted to know. Such a group are those that call themselves Anti-theists. Anti-theists promote an ideology that denies the existence of God, any god, and that all religion is evil and not good for us. In this paper the anti-theist worldview will be examined to understand the worldview, its key attributes and why one might be so inclined to pursue such an ideology. The worldview will be compared to the Christian worldview, the purpose of which will be to refute the arguments of the anti-theists worldview and provide a basis for which the anti-theist can be presented with information that might enable them to have a change of heart/mind and begin their journey to acknowledging Christ with the hope of ultimately receiving him. Significant Elements of the Anti-Theist Worldview What is Anti-Theism? Anti (against) -theism is quite simply the opposition to theism, specifically to God or to a god. It is not just the opposition to the Christian God, the Creator, the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, no, anti-theism is opposition to any god, religion or spiritual authority. Anti-theists have “an active distaste for religion in its various forms and believe, to one degree or another, that religion, all religion, is a bad thing”. [1] Joshua Kelly, in Oh, Your God, affirms this when he states that “the idea...

Words: 4852 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

A Rhetorical Analysis Of 'Fit Bottomed Girls'

...The way the author uses ethos starts with the manuscript. The ad is not poorly documented, and it does not have any spelling errors. Therefore, the author is creating credibility by demonstrating professionalism. The author also demonstrates professionalism by using the correct tone by making it confident and convincing, and by making the word choice motivating. “Not because the old me is bad but because the old me can improve” can motivate many people to choose a healthy lifestyle. In order to create an effective ethos, the author must be knowledgeable about the issue. According to “Fit Bottomed Girls Anti-Diet,” the founders of the “Fit Bottomed Girls” website have spent years helping hundreds of thousands of readers fall in love with a healthy lifestyle. On account of that, the ethos is strengthened because the audience can trust that “Fit Bottomed Girls” can help them get the changes they want....

Words: 434 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Google Antitrust

...of not only copyright issues, but censorship and privacy violations as well. However, despite these accusations, Google.com was reportedly the most visited website in 2013 (Savitz & Cooper, 2012). Google's critics claim that it unfairly utilizes its search engine to advance its own services over their competitors. Companies with no ties or google affiliations claim that, “Google engages in anti-competitive behavior across many vertical categories of search that harms consumers by restricting the ability of other companies to compete or put the best products in front of Internet users, who should be allowed to pick winners and losers online, not Google” (Savitz & Cooper, 2012). Google has fired back to these allegations by claiming that search users are easily able to locate other service providers and that their website is built for users and not for websites. Ironically, Microsoft was the company who originally launched the initial claims regarding Googles online practices. Many people remember a time when Microsoft had a monopoly on operating systems and many other areas of emerging technology. Microsoft claims that Google makes it difficult for mobile phones that use its Windows software to access Googles popular You Tube video site. They go on to claim that Google promotes its own phones and software which is the well-known Android system. According to the Huffington Post,...

Words: 922 - Pages: 4