Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice

In: Social Issues

Submitted By abbeygirl
Words 864
Pages 4
Running head: APPLYING ETHICAL FRAMEWORKS IN PRACTICE

Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice
Grand Canyon University



Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice

Implications of a breach of confidentiality

In the NBC’s ER: Betraying trust or providing good care? A14 year old girl Andrea came to trust the nurse that was caring for her and after being told that the information would be confidential, disclosed that she had been sexually active. When it became apparent that she had cervical cancer and needed treatment which required parental consent; Nurse Carol Hathaway faced a dilemma of remaining true to her promise and allow Andrea to possibly go untreated or break confidentiality and inform the parents.
The purpose of confidentiality between patient and medical care provider is to gain trust and provide the patient with privacy regarding their medical care and allow the patient assurance that personal matters will remain confidential. When private information is disclosed without the patient consent this is regarded as a breach of confidentiality and is morally, ethically and legally wrong. The implications are a lack of trust between the patient and the healthcare provider and the patient may not disclose vital information regarding their condition thereby may not receive adequate care.(Nathanson, 2000). There are exceptions which “require physicians to report certain infectious diseases to public health authorities to protect the health of the community” (Nathanson).
When approaching ethical decisions the nurse must be an advocate for the patient. Advocacy is an important function of nursing and is viewed as an essential component of nursing (Hanks, 2008, p. 469). Nurse Hathaway felt that in order for the patient to receive care the parents needed to be involved and proceeded to inform them. This may be an appropriate action so that the…...

Similar Documents

Applying Ethical Framework in Practice

...Applying Ethical Framework in Practice Adele Wolf, RN Grand Canyon University Ethical Decision Making in Health Care NRS 437V Charlene Cowley, MS, RN, CPNP February 26, 2011 Applying Ethical Framework in Practice Confidentiality is the right of an individual patient to have personal, identifiable medical information kept private; such information should be available only to the physician of record and other health care and insurance personnel as necessary. The only time information should be disclosed is with informed consent, with concern for the safety of other specific persons, or in concern for public welfare (K. Edwards, 2008). This paper will discuss the choices made by one nurse who cared for teenage girls in an episode of ER in 2000. Did she make the correct choices? Is it ever the right thing to do when confidentiality is broken? We will explore this case with the choices that can and should be made in this situation. In this episode of ER, the nurse is Carol Hathaway, she promises two young patients who are reluctant to enter into care that no matter what they tell her, she will not divulge any information to their parents or to anyone else. Test result for Andrea, one of the 14 year olds, is positive for human papillomavirus-(HPV) an extremely common sexually transmitted disease (STD). There are over 85 types of HPV infection and 95% of all cervical cancers are linked to HPV infection, which makes HPV the first sexually transmitted cancer...

Words: 1064 - Pages: 5

Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice

...Running head: APPLYING ETHICAL FRAMEWORKS IN PRACTICE Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice Grand Canyon University Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice Implications of a breach of confidentiality In the NBC’s ER: Betraying trust or providing good care? A14 year old girl Andrea came to trust the nurse that was caring for her and after being told that the information would be confidential, disclosed that she had been sexually active. When it became apparent that she had cervical cancer and needed treatment which required parental consent; Nurse Carol Hathaway faced a dilemma of remaining true to her promise and allow Andrea to possibly go untreated or break confidentiality and inform the parents. The purpose of confidentiality between patient and medical care provider is to gain trust and provide the patient with privacy regarding their medical care and allow the patient assurance that personal matters will remain confidential. When private information is disclosed without the patient consent this is regarded as a breach of confidentiality and is morally, ethically and legally wrong. The implications are a lack of trust between the patient and the healthcare provider and the patient may not disclose vital information regarding their condition thereby may not receive adequate care.(Nathanson, 2000). There are exceptions which “require physicians to report certain infectious diseases to public health authorities to protect the health of the...

Words: 864 - Pages: 4

Ethical Framework

...Running head: ETHICAL FRAMEWORKS Ethical Frameworks Anna Marie Santana Grand Canyon University Ethical Decision Making in Helath Care NRS-437V Marianne Murray May 19, 2011 Ethical Frameworks Introduction Ethical decisions in healthcare are difficult. This is why it is essential for nurses to understand how to approach these problems and when to ask for help. Privacy and confidentiality are ethical issues where there may be confusion regarding the best course of action to take. Nurses need to know the laws and patient obligations regarding these issues. In Health care we have a law called HIPAA, (HIPAA.ORG, 2008) that ensures patient privacy. It is crucial for nurses to understand the regulations relevant to confidentiality in order to practice within the guidelines of the law. In the article "Bioethics on NBC's ER: Betraying Trust or Providing Good Care? When is it ok to Break Confidentiality?" (Nathanson, 2000), the author addresses an ethical issue that incites ethical conflict for a nurse. In order to coerce two young girls reluctant to seek medical help, Nurse Hathaway made a promise that no matter what she learns about them during the exam she will not divulge this information to the parents or anyone else. Finding out that her patient 14 year old patient not only had HPV, but also cervical cancer from participating in sex parties with multiple partners, Nurse Hathaway is faced with an ethical decision. Nurse Hathaway must decide to honor her patient’s...

Words: 1152 - Pages: 5

Ethical Framework in Practice

...Running head: APPLYING ETHICAL FRAMEWORK IN PRACTICE Applying Ethical Framework in Practice Jaclyn Hughes Grand Canyon University: NRS-437V August 21, 2011 Applying Ethical Framework in Practice Patient confidentiality is one thing that cannot be breached nor as a patient that you would want to be breached. In this day and age as healthcare professionals it is a very fine line of what breaching confidentiality is. We all want to know that when we are sick and in the hospital, the one thing that we can keep personal is our privacy which would include our health information. It is hard to imagine that in a state of vulnerability that some things must be disclosed to certain departments regardless of your desire to keep it private and confidential; some examples include: domestic violence, child abuse, rape, psychiatric evaluations, and communicable diseases. These situations if not taken care of could cause more harm to the patient. Knowing your ethical principles and nursing code of ethics allows for the nurse to make a moral and ethical decision based on the five basic principles without breaching confidentiality and doing what is morally and ethically right for the patient. A patient’s trust is sacred and breaching that information is a violation of the trust between the relationship of the nurse and the patient (Burkhardt & Nathaniel, 2008). An ethical implication of a breach of confidentiality would include: patient confidentiality and informed consent...

Words: 1231 - Pages: 5

Applying Framework Into Practice

...Applying Ethical Frameworks into Practice Grand Canyon University: NRS-437V Ethical Decision Making in Health Care October 9, 2011 Health care professionals are exposed to a mass of professional, legal, and ethical responsibilities which call for special judgment to be employed in such a manner as to safeguard an individuals as well as public wellness and interests. Considerations in managing such responsibilities may be considered the respect of an individual’s autonomy, confidence, and acknowledgement of responsibilities owed to all individual. The above-mentioned acts fall within the professional jurisdiction; there are legal repercussions that direct care. As a result, it can be said that ethical respects transpire in remark of legal responsibilities. According to the Encyclopedia of Nursing & Allied Health, confidentiality is the right of an individual patient to have personal, identifiable medical information kept private; such information should be available only to the physician of record and other health care and insurance personnel as necessary. With ethics playing an essential part in the groundwork of nursing, a break of confidentiality can have ethical consequences fluctuating from individual’s uncertainty, legal implications, and other inadvertent results. Difficulties on the subject of the exemption to the obligation of confidentiality come under the imprecise description of public distress and awareness. Which increases ethical...

Words: 1131 - Pages: 5

Ethical Framework

...As professional Registered Nurses (RN’s) maintaining patient confidentiality is very important. Confidentiality is defined as “the right of an individual patient to have personal, identifiable medical information kept private.” (http://www.ceus-nursing.com/courses/material_detail). This information should only be shared with the physician, nurse and other members of the health care team. The imperative of confidentiality can be traced back to the Hippocratic Oath not to reveal secrets, and to the Nightingale Pledge. “I will do all in my power to elevate the standard of my profession and will hold in confidence all personal matters committed to my keeping and all family affairs coming to my knowledge in the practice of my profession”. (Burkhardt & Nathaniel, 2008, p. 69). The implications of a breach in confidentiality can have a significant impact on the nurse and the patient and create ethical dilemmas. Disclosure of information can cause problems on a personal, legal and professional level. The ethical need for confidentiality in nursing is vital, due to the need to establish mutual trust between the nurse and the patient. When this relationship is established the patient would be more comfortable in discussing personal matters such as their sex life and other things considered taboo if they know that their information would remain confidential. Several ethical implications occur as a result in the breach of confidentiality, for example the loss of patient trust and...

Words: 1263 - Pages: 6

Ethical Framework

... cafeteria while eating lunch or even faxing medical records to the wrong fax number (AMA, 2012). Confidentiality is considered one of the key ethical principles, a patient right, and always utilized on a ‘need to know’ basis (Ludwick & Silva, 1999). When violated, it is essentially as if a nurse was stealing from the patient, utilizing something that belongs to that patient without their expressed consent. The Hippocratic oath states: “Whatever I see or hear in the lives of my patients, whether in connection with my professional practice or not, which ought not to be spoken of outside, I will keep secret, as considering all such things to be private”(HMD & NLM & NIH, 2010). Medicine has altered this what is necessary, but all who practice abide by this oath in principle. Confidentiality and Ethical Theories All ethical theories not being equal, it is difficult to say any one theory will suffice for every situation that arises. Deontology suggests that treating all patient’s with the same regard no matter background, age, disease process, insurance, etc. is doing one’s duty and to this end, the theory makes sense (Doherty & Purtilo, 2011). If one utilizes the theory as an approach for making decisions on confidentiality by basing each patient care situation on the same situation before, then deontology would not be ideal for the principle of confidentiality. Utilitarianism focuses on the ‘greater good’ or what will produce the most ‘happiness’ (Upton,......

Words: 1228 - Pages: 5

Applying Ethical Principles in Practice

...Running head: CONFIDENTIALITY Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice Chandra H. Dillow Grand Canyon University: NRS-437V March 18, 2012 Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice In the profession of nursing, there are many ethical principles which one must maintain as the basis for their nursing care. One of these principles is confidentiality, which requires nurses to preserve the privacy of one’s patients and ensure their autonomy. Maintaining confidentiality is essential in the nurse-patient relationship as it shows respect for the patients. Since the time the Nightingale Pledge was written, confidentiality has been one of the main standards to uphold as a nurse. The following will discuss ethical theories and the application of them when faced with dilemmas in the work setting. Breach of Confidentiality Nurses and physicians alike are accountable for maintaining a patient’s confidentiality. Having a breach of confidentiality has the possibility of causing undue harm or the patient being averse to seeking medical care. Undue harm can be described as “embarrassment, ridicule, discrimination, deprivation of rights, physical or emotional harm and loss of roles or relationships” (Burkhardt & Nathaniel, 2008). One’s personal values and principles establish the foundation for ethical knowledge and decision making. There are instances, however, when breaching confidentiality is necessary to prevent harm to the patient or community. Ethical Principles...

Words: 1030 - Pages: 5

Applying Ethical Framework in Practice

...Running Head: VARK Learning Style Assessment VARK Learning Style Assessment Joby Reji Grand Canyon University Family Health Promotion NRS-429V Dawn,Peter November19, 2011 VARK Learning Style Assessment Learning styles are different methods of learning. Each individual has his/her own way of learning . Identifying a learning style would help an individual to focus on his strong points and pay more attention on weak points. People with learning disabilities or attention deficit disorder would benefit from these learning styles. In 1987 Neil Fleming invented VARK Questionnaire which help users to identify learning preferences. These preferences are about the ways that they want to take in and give out information (VARK, 2011).VARK questionnaires are very helpful for some learners, which enable them to change their study habits, some learners already know about their way of learning, questionnaire or inventory does not make any difference in their study habits. VARK questionnaire can be found online or on paper, gives an option of more than one answer for a question. VARK questionnaire is short with 13-16 questions to prevent students survey fatigue (Fleming and Baume,2006).VARK questionnaire is not a distinctive measure, but it gives a method of thinking about how to prioritize the learning strategy. VARK consist of 5 strategies- visual, aural, read/write, kinesthetic and multimodal. In visual study...

Words: 1006 - Pages: 5

Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice

...Running head: ETHICAL FRAMEWORKS Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice NRS 437V September 01, 2012 Appling Ethical Frameworks in Practice A conclusive ethical foundation in the healthcare arena is confidentiality. It is referred to the standard of maintaining secure and private from others health care information revealed during a professional consultation. This is an essential legal right of every client and an ethical duty of the medical community (Bourke, 2008). Maintaining confidentiality between the client and healthcare professional translates to a trustworthy relationship, especially with adolescents. This paper will discuss implications to breach confidentiality, ethical principles, alternatives and ethical committee applications to an ethical dilemma. Implications of Breach of Confidentiality To promote trust between the patient and healthcare provider is a good reason to appreciate confidentiality in health management. To release information to a third party without consent of the patient is considered a breach of confidentiality and illegal. For example, adolescents are encouraged to participate in health care prevention. Many are depressed and even sexually active, but the challenge to provide access and receive adequate care is necessary. Confidentiality is the primary reason this juvenile group deter from health care prevention and management (English & Ford, 2007). A breach of confidentiality in juvenile health care...

Words: 1093 - Pages: 5

Marketing Practice Framework

...From the point of view of the contemporary marketing practice framework, companies usually have a one dominant focus, but they also practice other marketing practices. This allows managers to study and develop skills they need in the dominant practice. There are several marketing practices such as transaction marketing, database marketing, emarketing (this term is no longer in use), interactive marketing and network marketing. All of these practices are differs from each other in terms of purpose of exchange, nature of communication, type of contact, duration of exchange, formality of exchange and managerial intent. Transactional marketing The purpose of exchange in transactional marketing is economic transaction; it is not interested in any kind of information or relationships with customers or other firms. The aim is just to sell. The nature of its communication is from firm to mass market – no target markets or segments are defined. Transactional marketing also is not interested in communication “with” customers or with firms. To contact with its consumers firms using Transaction marketing select an arm’s length impersonal type of contact, because an information was not gathered, contact couldn’t be personalised. Face to face contact also is not used because relationships between firm and customers are not interpersonal. The duration of exchange is discrete, but in some cases occurred over time. In this type of marketing the aim is to make the customer to buy at least...

Words: 1062 - Pages: 5

Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice

...Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice Adetutu S. Toyin-oke Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice Under what circumstances is one allowed to break patient-nurse confidentiality? As a nurse one may think of a few personal situations where they had to break that confidentiality. Ethical framework such as the nightingale pledge and ethical principles stated in nursing textbooks were meant to provide guidelines on how to most appropriately treat people in the healthcare field; however, when ethical framework is applied to nursing practice, a nurse may run into many implications. Ethical implications What are the implications of a breach of confidentiality? Well, the most obvious consequence is that the patient will not be able to trust her nurse or maybe even all nurses in general. In Pamela G. Nathanson’s article, Betraying Trust or Providing Good Care? When is it okay to break confidentiality?, She depicts a story of a nurse who is in an ethical dilemma. This nurse promised two teenage patients “who [were] reluctant to enter into care that no matter what they tell her, she will not divulge any information to the patient's parents or to anyone else (Nathanson, 2000).” However one of these two patients tested positive for HPV. A physician advices this nurse “that not only should she inform Andrea's parents of her diagnosis, but that she should also inform the girls' school since it has become a ‘public health issue’ (Nathanson, 2000).” According to Nathanson, “If...

Words: 866 - Pages: 4

Applying Theory to Practice

...Applying Theory to Practice Over the past decade, youth, and individuals under the age of 18 antisocial Mary Jo Buttafuoco had no idea that on answer and violence behavior has become a grave global concern and a top political policy issue being sensationalized by media coverage of rare but devastatingly murder crimes being committed by young individuals at school, homes and other social places. The increase of media reports of notorious murder by young people may skew the public perception of its actual prevalence. In our case study, we look at Mary Jo Buttafuoco who is murdered by a teenage girl at her home on Adam Road West Long Island, N.Y., on May 19, 1992. Moral Development Theory explanations of delinquency in which propositions identify certain concepts and describe and how they are related to delinquent behavior, this theoretically predicts relationships that may be tested through research. For instance, one simple proposition of differential association theory is that attitudes favoring delinquency may be learned in the context of inmate personal groups, in our case, the girl suggests to Mary Jo that they should have a talk about her husband, where she notices a car with a young man of which the girl claims to be her boyfriend. Mary Jo becomes upset and orders the girl to leave. The girl shoots her in the head without a second thought (Regoli, Hewitt, & DeLisi, 2014). The predicted relationship portrayed here is that youths develop attitudes, in this case we...

Words: 874 - Pages: 4

Applying Ethical

...Applying Ethical Frameworks Name Institute Applying Ethical Frameworks Yes, I would like to take action regarding the situation. Different ethical frameworks allow me to take action so that the justice could be maintained. I used ethical frameworks so that the justice, equality, utilitarianism and other things could be continued. I would not like to give favor to my colleague who is telling me that I should not take action and keep myself away from such action. If I accept his suggestion of ignoring it may lead the negative consequences in the future. I am taking action because I know that if today I ignore it and relaxed him it means I am not giving favor to ethics. The concept of utilitarianism is ignored if I do not take action. The concept of Consequentialism does not allow me not to take action against because its consequences would be very severe. Other ethical virtues such as retribution and honesty allow me to take actions regarding such situation. The emotional empiricism also permits me to take actions regarding such dilemma. In emotional empiricism if I don’t take action it will always disturb my gut feelings, not to take action when there is great problem relevant to ethics. The deontological framework of ethics also gives me permission that I should take action so that I could fulfill oath requirements (Donaldson's & Dunfee's, 1994). The duty includes such type of actions which lay under my job domain. It is also suggested that I am responsible...

Words: 976 - Pages: 4

Applying Developmentally Appropriate Practice

...Applying Developmentally Appropriate Practice Rasmussen Collage “Developmentally appropriate practice, often shortened to DAP, is an approach to teaching grounded in the research on how young children develop and learn and in what is known about effective early education” (2009). This is an ongoing learning process. When it comes to applying DAP educators must be able to have a strong understanding and knowledge of the way children develop. A very important part to knowing what is typical at each age is developmentally crucial. By observing each child separately not only helps to get to know them personally but can help us identify certain things in groups. One example that demonstrates how DAP works is when you have a group of toddlers sitting and coloring at the table. No one is really drawing much of anything particular however one child turns and says a few of the scribbles is her name. It is unreadable but if you look hard enough you can see the formation of a letter or two. You’ve been reviewing letters as a whole and the letters that make up their names for a while in hopes they start to identify their names / words. Another example to show how DAP works is at free play time you put out a bunch of different thing and the children all migrate in different directions. Giving them choices to pick what interests them. This helps you to understand what things they like vs don’t like. An example that does not demonstrate DAP is having the children in your......

Words: 360 - Pages: 2