Premium Essay

Approaches to Ethical Dilemmas

In: Social Issues

Submitted By msilvas84
Words 1040
Pages 5
Approaches to Ethical Dilemmas
Michelle Silvas
BSHS/335
August 11, 2014
Alma Carpio

Protecting a friend In the case study 18, protecting a Friend, it describes Dr. Adam Marshall, a well-known, much respected physician that works at Uptown General Hospital. He has done many things for the community, such as charities and missionary work. He has worked at the hospital for 20 years with a spotless record. He goes at least twice a year with a group of other physicians to Zambia to provide medical care and much needed medical supplies for the Zambian people. HIV is very prevalent in Zambia and most of the people there are infected. While in Zambia, Dr. Marshall decides to go sightseeing and while out he collapses due to dehydration and suffers a significant laceration on his arm. A woman comes to his aid and because Dr. Marshall was so worried about his injury, he fails to notice that this woman is HIV positive and has wounds on her arms that are oozing and she helps Dr. Marshall with his open wound. After returning to where his fellow physicians are, he decides to confide in his friend Dr. Singh, he tells him that he is afraid he may have been exposed to HIV because of the woman who help clean up his wound. Dr. Singh runs HIV testing on Dr. Marshall and it comes back positive. Dr. Marshall does not want Dr. Singh to share this information with anyone back at home because he is afraid of his reputation and since they are out of the country, they did not document the testing that was done. Dr. Singh agrees to keep this information confidential between the two of them. Moreover, a year passes by and Dr. Marshall wakes up one day and was not feeling well butt decides he will still go to work in the surgery department at Uptown General Hospital and not reschedule his patients. Most of his day was going fine until he was in the middle of a procedure and

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...Ethical Dilemma (Author’s name) (Institutional Affiliation) Abstract This research paper seeks to resolve a particular case of an ethical dilemma. This has been necessitated by the fact that ethical dilemmas are a recurrent part of life. Moreover, ethical dilemmas have become a key point of argument in the field of ethics and interestingly, philosophy as well (Garsten & Hernes, 2009). As an inividual, I find myself facing moral dilemma situation quite frequently which makes the exploration of this subject a fascinating intrigue. This exhaustive research thus attempts to integrate all the possible actions that can be undertaken to lead towards the understanding of ethical dilemma. Methodologies used to accomplish this include the three stage ethical dilemma solving process that duly applies two main approaches. These approaches are consequentialist and deontological which have been widely applied to give step by step details on how to handle the given ethical dilemma. The article dissects on subsequent decision making after thorough strive to balance between what is morally acceptable within a person’s surroundings and self interests entrenched in a human being. A thorough discussion on the particular viewpoints of ethical dilemma has unearthed the common result of individuals getting torn between self morals and societal expectations.. Finally, the research concludes that there is a need to evaluate decisions based on viewpoints arising...

Words: 1725 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemmas

...Ethical dilemmas are common issues that every businessman has to face at their working environment. It is not such an easy task for businessman to have an ethical decision making, to choose what the “right” thing to do. In this following factual scenario, John also has to face some ethical dilemmas in his working environment and have difficulty to find appropriate solution. After a brief summary of the facts, I will discuss some ethical dilemmas which John is confronting and some approaches to ethical reasoning. John is a Patient Accounts Manager of Greensburg Hospital with responsibility to monitor the charges which accrue to a patient’s account while the patient is hospitalized. He discovers an unusual bill listed on a patient’s account without charged. This patient is Izzy Indigent, who is an unemployed Medicaid one and she has been hospitalized for several day. She gave her children the supply of body lotion, soap, toothpaste, mouthwash, and Kleenex in the hospital when they come to visit her daily and asked for refilling on the next day. John asked the supervising nurse and received the answer that she knew about it but let it go. The prognosis is that the hospitalization of Ms. Indigent will last several more weeks. In this situation, John has to face an ethical dilemma which is whether his personal value system are versus his professional responsibiities, whether he should keep silent about the charges on Indigent’s account or he should report it accurately and truthfully...

Words: 1453 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Acc 260 Entire Class Dqs and All Assignments

...Week 3 - DQ 2.doc Week4 ACC 260 Week 4 - Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making - Appendix B.doc ACC 260 Week 4 - Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making.doc Week5 ACC 260 Week 5 - DQ 1.doc ACC 260 Week 5 - DQ 2.doc ACC 260 Week 5 - Approaches to Stakeholder Impact Analysis.doc Week6 ACC 260 Week 6 - Presentation of the CEOs Position.doc ACC 260 Week 6 - Presentation of the Stakeholders Positions - Kardell Legal Counsel.doc ACC 260 Week 6 - Presentation of the Stakeholders Positions - Residents of Riverside.doc Week7 ACC 260 Week 7 - DQ 1.doc ACC 260 Week 7 - DQ 2.doc Week8 ACC 260 Week 8 - Briefly Applying a Decision-Making Framework.doc ACC 260 Week 8 - Fully Applying a Decision-Making Framework.doc Week9 ACC 260 Week 9 - Capstone Discussion Question.doc ACC 260 Week 9 - Solving Ethical Dilemmas in the Accounting Profession.doc ACC 260 Entire Class DQs and all Assignments Purchase here http://chosecourses.com/acc-260-entire-class-dqs-and-all-assignments Product Description Week1 ACC 260 Week 1 - Ethics in the Accounting Profession.doc ACC 260 Week 1 - DQ 2.doc ACC 260 Week 1 - DQ 1.doc Week2 ACC 260 Week 2 - Unethical Practices of Arthur Andersen.doc ACC 260 Week 2 - The Enron and WorldCom Scandals.doc Week3 ACC 260 Week 3 - DQ 1.doc ACC 260 Week 3 - DQ 2.doc Week4 ACC 260 Week 4 - Philosophical Approaches to Ethical...

Words: 1155 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Business Ethical Decision Making

...Introduction Ethical behavior is generally expected to be conducted within a business by its managers and employees. When business ethics is spoken by business people of it usually means one of three things (1) avoid breaking the criminal law in one’s work-related activity; (2) avoid action that may result in civil law suits against the company; (3) avoid actions that are bad for the company image (Erwin 2011). . Ethical issues in business will occur but can be solved and avoided in many cases that can help a company continue to be successful. Using an ethical decision making process will guide companies and its employees in the right direction to success and respect within the communities they serve. Most people involved in business whether functioning as a small business owner, employee, or chief executive officer of a multination company eventually face ethical or moral dilemmas in the workplace. Such dilemmas are usually complex, for they force the person making the decision to weigh the benefits that various business decisions impart on individuals including him or herself and groups with the negative repercussion that those same decisions usually have on other individuals or groups. What is Ethics? Business ethics is a subject that can be difficult to define. Any discussion of business ethics is a subjective one, for everyone brings different concepts of ethical behavior to the table. These moral standards are shaped by all sorts of things, from home environment to...

Words: 2343 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Introduction to Business Ethics

...Introduction to Business Ethics Objectives: * Gain an understanding of why business ethics is important. * Learn how business ethics fits into the broader discipline of philosophy. * Realize that the culture in which we live influences our thinking. Business ethics, some would say, is an oxymoron. After all, the media presents, on nearly a daily basis, the shenanigans of corporate representatives as they ply their trade. Price fixing, anti-competitive behavior, fraud, deceptive advertising, and insider trading are but a few of the many questionable tactics found in the quivers of corporate moguls and their charges. Corporations and their activities have been fair game for attack, both factual and fictional. The level of corruption is epidemic in the estimation of many observers. This rather bleak picture is probably the one most familiar to what has become a very cynical populace. We have come to think of ourselves as current or potential victims of evil corporations. Is business evil incarnate? Of course it isn't. Is business completely innocent of the charges against it? Again, the answer is no. The truth lies somewhere in between. It is, after all, the modern enterprise, with all of its strengths and weaknesses, that has brought to larger numbers of people around the world, a level of material comfort and cultural opportunities than has ever before existed. Businesses must be doing something right. In fact, while business has less than a stellar reputation...

Words: 4762 - Pages: 20

Free Essay

Ge Succession Planning

...ETHICAL DILEMMA An ethical dilemma can be defined as a complex situation that often involves an apparent mental conflict between moral imperatives. In this movie context, an ethical dilemma is a debate between two moral principles, where two sides can argue about what is wrong or what is right. This is simply because each person has their own self-interest. However, there is no real answer to an ethical dilemma. It is simply a matter of what one believes in. In this movie, it tells us the story of parents who conceived a daughter which is Anna through genetic engineering in purpose to save her elder daughter Kate who was the patient of leukemia by donating her sister the blood and other body organs like kidney and marrow all over her life span. The ethical dilemma issue was portrayed in the movie started when Anna want to protect her own body from medical procedure by engage a lawyer and filed a law suit of medical emancipation against her parents. Now the question arises who is ethically correct? Whether Anna or her parents. Both sides argue that they are right and have a right to do so. From the parents’ perspective, the mother, Sarah fitzgerald strongly stick with ethics of care which a person should take care of the person close to him or dependent upon him. In this case, Kate depending on Anna for her living and Anna should help her out in every possible way. During the court session, Sarah make statement that people give their kidney to total stranger and...

Words: 855 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Appendix a

...problem-solving and decision-making skills developed throughout the course. The “Qualify or Not” Ethics Case on pp. 288-290 (Ch. 4) introduces an accounting professional who faces an ethical dilemma. Your task is to apply your understanding of philosophical approaches to ethical decision making and stakeholder impact analysis to resolve the ethical dilemma detailed in the Ethics Case. Decide upon an ethical course of action the accountant could take and support that action with critical thinking and argumentation. Analyze the case using the concepts involved in stakeholder impact analysis and the philosophical approaches to ethical decision making. Explain what you think the accountant should do. You might also refer back to resources from your Critical Thinking class to refresh your memory on topics such as structuring arguments that will help your write a persuasive paper. Final Project Timeline You should budget your time wisely and work on your project throughout the course. As outlined below, some assignments in the course are designed to assist you in creating your final project. If you complete your course activities and use the feedback provided by the instructor, you will be on the right track to successfully complete your project. □ Suggested in Week One: Read The Dilemma of an Accountant Ethics Case, which is the focus of the final project, on pp. 288-290 (Ch. 4) of the textbook. □ Suggested in Week Two: Reflect on the lessons that can be learned...

Words: 495 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Acc 260 Entire Class Dqs and All Assignments

...Week 3 - DQ 2.doc Week4 ACC 260 Week 4 - Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making - Appendix B.doc ACC 260 Week 4 - Critiquing Philosophical Approaches to Ethical Decision Making.doc Week5 ACC 260 Week 5 - DQ 1.doc ACC 260 Week 5 - DQ 2.doc ACC 260 Week 5 - Approaches to Stakeholder Impact Analysis.doc Week6 ACC 260 Week 6 - Presentation of the CEOs Position.doc ACC 260 Week 6 - Presentation of the Stakeholders Positions - Kardell Legal Counsel.doc ACC 260 Week 6 - Presentation of the Stakeholders Positions - Residents of Riverside.doc Week7 ACC 260 Week 7 - DQ 1.doc ACC 260 Week 7 - DQ 2.doc Week8 ACC 260 Week 8 - Briefly Applying a Decision-Making Framework.doc ACC 260 Week 8 - Fully Applying a Decision-Making Framework.doc Week9 ACC 260 Week 9 - Capstone Discussion Question.doc ACC 260 Week 9 - Solving Ethical Dilemmas in the Accounting Profession.doc ACC 260 Entire Class DQs and all Assignments Purchase here http://chosecourses.com/acc-260-entire-class-dqs-and-all-assignments Product Description Week1 ACC 260 Week 1 - Ethics in the Accounting Profession.doc ACC 260 Week 1 - DQ 2.doc ACC 260 Week 1 - DQ 1.doc Week2 ACC 260 Week 2 - Unethical Practices of Arthur Andersen.doc ACC 260 Week 2 - The Enron and WorldCom Scandals.doc Week3 ACC 260 Week 3 - DQ 1.doc ACC 260 Week 3 - DQ 2.doc Week4 ACC 260 Week 4 - Philosophical Approaches to Ethical...

Words: 693 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Business Ethics

...TUI UNIVERSITY Module 1 SLP: Ethical dilemma in the Military ETH501: Business Ethics Professor Dr. Michael Garmon January 13, 2012 Describe an ethical problem you have confronted in a business situation. It has been nineteen years since I initially raised my hand and took an oath to serve in the military. Since my initial enlistment there have been many changes within the organization and ethical standards of the Army. The ethical problem that I have confronted in the Military today has been to choose between the commitment that I made to the military, and my commitment to my family. Having to naturally make the decision that is expected of me has been a difficult task. Military Ethics provides the necessary foundation on which to explore the more intricate ethical issues facing those in uniform. However, how does one prioritize between family, and their duty to serve? The most recent missions of the Military are the War in Iraq and Afghanistan. The United States has only formally declared war against foreign nations five separate times; however this is the most documented time that dual military families served over seas at the same time. The U.S. Army recruited more than 2,600 soldiers this year, helping the military accomplish its goal of 80,000 recruits. The Army recruited 80,635 soldiers, roughly 7,000 more than last year. Of those recruited many of them were first-time enlistments who had never served before. But many of them were dual...

Words: 1216 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Satyam Scam

...Contents Introduction: 2 Ethical Issues Involved 2 1. Not Following Corporate Governance Norms 2 2. Tampering the financial data - 2 3. Misleading the Shareholders Fund- 3 4. Insider trading at Satyam- 4 Ethical Dilemma faced by Ramalinga Raju 4 Theories and Approaches that may be used to resolve dilemma 5 Hosmer’s Six Step Process: 5 Kohlberg Model: 6 Recommendations for Resolving the dilemma 8 Conclusion 9 References 9 Introduction: The Satyam Computer Services’ scandal brought to light the importance of ethics and its relevance to corporate culture. The fraud committed by the founders of satyam is a testament to the fact that “the science of conduct” is swayed in large by human greed, ambition, and hunger for power, money, fame and glory. Scandals to the recent financial crisis have time and again proven that there is a need for good conduct based on strong ethics. we examine the gross negligence of stakeholder concerns and over indulgence of key management on a personal and organizational level in immortal practices for personal benefit. We also assess the implications of ethics in the business environment. We then delve into the ethical dilemmas faced by the executives at Satyam, apply Hosmer’s framework to moral decision-making and suggest alternatives to handle such moral uncertainties. Finally, we conclude by providing recommendations for ethical code of conduct in organi...

Words: 2208 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Gullestedal

...Business leaders frequently face dilemmas, circumstances where whatever course of action they choose, something of important value will be offended. How can an organisation prepare its decision makers for such situations? This article presents a pedagogical approach to dilemma training for business leaders and managers. It has evolved through ten years of experience with human resource development, where ethics has been an integral part of programs designed to help individuals to become excellent in their professional roles. The core element in our approach is The Navigation Wheel, a figure used to keep track of relevant decision factors. Feedback from participants indicates that dilemma training has helped them to recognise the ethical dimension of leadership. They respond that the tools and concepts are highly relevant in relation to the challenges that occur in the working environment they return to after leadership training. Keywords: business ethics, leadership training, dilemma Introduction The purpose of this article is to present a pedagogical approach to dilemma training for business managers and leaders. In the past ten years we have been responsible for ethical training sessions in programs designed to help individuals develop their leadership skills. We have used elements from moral philosophy in attempts to cultivate the participants’ theoretical understanding of the morally challenging situations they can encounter in their practice as managers and...

Words: 7054 - Pages: 29

Premium Essay

Interoperability

...1 Approaching Ethical Issues and Dilemmas in Counseling Rosa Davis BSHS/335 February 16, 2015 Facilitator Carrie Hill 2 Approaching Ethical Issues and Dilemmas in Counseling Counselors, whether they are working in private practice, in an agency setting, or teaching and supervising; are struggling more and more with issues that are related to their own, trainees, and clients. As professional, we all have has training on legal and ethical issues in counseling. Even though our credentialing organizations might require a certain amount of training in ethics and we meet that requirement; there are still ethical violations. This could be due to two reasons: (1) most writing and courses on ethics does not teach us to think or how to make ethical decisions that are in the best interest of the client. Basically, the training teaches the do’s and don’ts but does not provide the tools to work through complex clinical situations. (2) Generally, the alcohol and substance abuse field does not provide adequate clinical supervision to its counselors. This field tends to gravitate toward what happens behind closed doors; stays unseen and unknown until things blow up. As professional counselors, there are three major issues that we must face when we are considering making a decision on how to act within the counseling setting: (1) what is legal, what is ethical and what is moral. Typically, the legal standard is the minimum acceptable level that will meet the requirement...

Words: 1403 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Applying Ethical Framework

...Applying Ethical Frameworks In Practice Ellen Kincaid Grand Canyon University NRS-437V-0504 September 5, 2015 Applying Ethical Frameworks In Practice When it comes to ethical dilemmas we can all feel challenged with complex decisions that are difficult to make. Ethical dilemmas refer to problems that arise which usually involve more than one moral correct mode of actions involving the individual responsible and the individual correcting the situation. The individual resolving the situation is often challenged by the fact that in either option he takes, he or she may be right about taking one option but wrong about leaving the other. Ethical dilemmas test our ability to use our morals and values as well as ethical principals that we have learned through out life, and put them into actions by weighing these beliefs and being able to determine the difference between right and wrong. For that reason is imperative that nursing professionals are well aware of their own beliefs, moral and values, so they can make correct ethical decisions especially when it comes to health care delivery. Ethical Dilemma I this case we have a 6 y/o child, which gets very sick while at school. The child presents with elevated temperature, vomiting and convulsing. The child is immediately taken to the closest hospital and is quickly diagnosed with meningitis. The attending physician is now requesting authorization to treat the child from the parents. The child’s parents are divorced and now...

Words: 1391 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma

...Collaborative Learning Community: Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma Collaborative Learning Community: Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma (Part 1) In your CLC group, select one of the following three options and view the video related to your chosen topic (a description of each is provided along with a link to access the electronic media): Dilemma 1: Embryo Harvesting and Freezing/Genetic Manipulation (Posthumous Conception Case) Ethical issues related to case: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EIenB7qgIVk Washington Post article of Karen Capato Case: http://articles.washingtonpost.com/2012-03-19/politics/35450022_1_karen-capato-robert-capato-survivor-benefitsUS Supreme Court (2011) Ruling on Capato Case: http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/11pdf/11-159.pdf Description: Eighteen months after her husband, Robert Capato, died of cancer, respondent Karen Capato gave birth to twins conceived through in-vitro fertilization using her husband’s frozen sperm. Should technology be used to create live posthumously? Dilemma 2: Marketing of Medical / Pharmaceutical Products Holding Back the Years? The Race to Slow the Aging Process http://library.gcu.edu:2048/login?url=http://digital.films.com.library.gcu.edu:2048/PortalPlaylists.aspx?aid=12129&xtid=36189 While medical treatments and pharmaceuticals are common approaches to address a wide variety of conditions, there is growing concern from consumer groups and the medical community regarding current marketing practices which...

Words: 653 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Managing Business Ethics

...scandals in large corporations today, business ethics is fast becoming an important subject to many business professionals. Not only do they have to learn what constitutes ethical responsibility, but they also have to “understand and manage” (p. 2) it. Companies while trying to uphold a reputable image, slip when there is a profit to be made, and this results in disasters such as the “no doc loans” or “liar loans” (p. 6) and the resulting crash of the housing market. Agencies need to be in place to ensure people are not taken advantage of and coerced into loans that they cannot realistically afford. Trevino and Nelson define “ethical behavior in business as “behavior that is consistent with the principles, norms and standards of business practice that have been agreed upon by society” (p. 19). Many standards and policies were translated into laws, but there are also some behaviors that cross into the ethics realm not considered illegal. Also, some behaviors illegal in the United States, but they may not be recognized as illegal in other countries. Where, when, and how is it determined what is ethical and what is not ethical? Should individuals even bother to conduct themselves ethically if there is no law against it? People in society have morals, values, and standards that feed into their ethical decisions. Organizations should be concerned with whether or not...

Words: 3131 - Pages: 13