Premium Essay

Arguments of Peter Singer

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By ammiss5444
Words 1027
Pages 5
Arguments of Peter Singer

PHI200: Mind and Machine (ABT1315A)

April 19, 2013

Singer’s goal in the article “Famine, Affluence and Morality” is to get people to think differently about famine relief, charity, and morality. These are key issues that people need to be more aware of and act on them. People who are financially stable and well off should take more of an active role by giving more. They should feel obligated in helping those in need. There are many people suffering severely, those who can help are doing nothing. People should be more willing to give help rather than being obtuse & self-centered.
Singer argues it is wrong for a person to suffer from homelessness, hunger, or lack of medical attention. These needs are essential in life and without them can alimentally lead to one’s death. Another argument Singer gives is if a person is wealthy, they are more than capable to help others financially. They need to feel obligated to do so. Instead of a person spending money on extras and materialistic items for themselves, they should donate that money to the poor. The money should help with necessities for the poor and uplift them. On the same point he points out, one should not sacrifice if it would put them in harm’s way.
Singer’s concept of marginal utility is that one should give as much as possible to the unfortunate; it should never create a hardship to the giver. This would be doing more harm than good. When a person contributes to the poor, it should not financially affect their lifestyle by putting them in debt, homeless, or without food.
People that are wealthy and well off should donate to the people that are unfortunate and suffering. It would be morally correct to help the less fortunate.
An argument Singer makes is the distinction between a duty and charity. He states, “That a duty is an action that is an…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Peter Singer

...In Peter Singer’s essay “The Singer Solution to World Poverty,” he explores the possibilities of each and every American giving up about 2/3 of his/her income. However, rather than simply talking of his own solution as another theory, he tells the reader in so many words (literally) that he/she is wrong. A large chunk of the essay is basically a big middle finger to everyone reading it. It is almost as though Singer wanted to invoke anger out of the reader so that he/she would then go and donate money to charity, so as to say something along the lines of “You lookie here, Singer, I’m not who you say I am.” Some people might think that Singer is just out of his mind, but I think he was angering the reader by making harsh accusations on purpose. Singer opens his essay with a ridiculous story from a film about a fictional woman named Dora. In the story, Dora is a “retired schoolteacher who makes ends meet by sitting at the station writing letters for illiterate people.” First off, how could anyone make enough money to live comfortably like that? She ends up selling a homeless boy to what she is told to be a “wealthy family.” Her neighbor somehow knows that this is not the case, that the boy will be put to death and his organs sold. Second of all, how does the neighbor know this? This accusation is not explained. Dora then goes home with her brand new television, feels guilty, and takes the boy back. Why would Dora do this without further research? She has no proof other than......

Words: 1248 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Peter Singer Famine

...Peter Singer – “Famine, Affluence, and Morality” Dora Crawford Prof. David Tredinnick 12/19/2012 When it comes to the article "Famine, Affluence, and Morality" mostly argues about not one but more than several things. In some point most people can agree with his arguments unlike others whom may not see his point of view. One of these arguments was lack of food. This was brought up or inspired by the starvation of Bangladesh his main focus was that if one can use one's wealth to reduce suffering for example, by aiding famine-relief efforts without any significant reduction in the well-being of oneself or others, it is immoral not to do so. According to Singer, such inaction is clearly immoral. If a child is drowning in a shallow pond and someone can save it but chooses not to; nor does placing greater geographical distance between the person in need and the potential helper reduce the latter's moral obligations. “It makes no difference whether the person I can help is a neighbor's child ten yards away from me or a Bengali whose name I shall never know, ten thousand miles away. The moral point of view requires us to look beyond the interests of our own society. Previously, this may hardly have been feasible, but it is quite feasible now. From the moral point of view, the prevention of the starvation of millions of people outside our society must be considered at least as pressing as the upholding of property norms within our society.” Singers......

Words: 1782 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Singer Bangladesh

...BUSINESS STRATEGY TERM PAPER ON STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF SINGER BANGLADESH LTD Submitted to Mr. A.K.M. Saiful Majid Course Instructor & Professor Strategic Management Submitted by Quazi Asaduzzaman, Roll # 14, MBA 44E B M Hasan Mahmud, Roll # 36, MBA 44E Submitted on June 13 2013 Institute of Business Administration, University of Dhaka June 13, 2013 Mr. A.K.M. Saiful Majid Professor Institute of Business Administration University of Dhaka. Subject: Submission of Term Paper. Dear Sir, It gives us enormous pleasure in presenting herewith the Term Paper on “Strategic Analysis of Singer Bangladesh Ltd” which was assigned to us as partial fulfillment of Strategic Management course. While preparing the term paper we got an opportunity to have an insight on Singer Bangladesh Ltd. An attempt has been made in this report to get an insight of Singer Bangladesh Ltd. We have tried heart and soul to make the report effective and useful. We are grateful to you for providing us this opportunity of gaining such practical experiences. If you need any assistance for further interpretation, please call us up. Sincerely Yours, (Quazi Asaduzzaman) ID#14, 44th(E) batch (Quazi Asaduzzaman) ID#14, 44th(E) batch (B M Hasan Mahmud) ID#36, 44th(E) batch (B M Hasan Mahmud) ID#36, 44th(E) batch ACKNOWLEDGEMENT It gives us immense pleasure to thank few individuals for their cordial cooperation and encouragement, who have contributed directly or......

Words: 7584 - Pages: 31

Free Essay

Du Singer

...har identifierat de kapitalintensiva perioderna. De kapitalintensiva perioderna är svåra att identifiera i en enkel resultatbudget men hade vi varit projektledare hade vi velat komplettera Vi kan också konstatera att detta handlar om att internt projekt utan externa aktörer. Detta kan visa sig vara en styrka då medarbetarna har erfarenhet av att arbeta tillsammans och har koll på företagets maskinpark, system och processer och företagskultur etc. D.U Singer Hospital Products Corp har efter den initiala produktutformningen delegerat projektansvaret till företagets Research & Develeopment –grupp. Mike Richards, vetenskapsmannen som stod för den basala produktens formgivning delegeras ansvar för projektutformning och genomförande. Övriga företagsdepartement som involverar sin personal i projektutformning och genomförande innefattar: Packaging Task Force, Research & Development, Corporate Engeneering, Corporate Purchasing, Hospital Products Manufacturing Group samt Packaged Products Manufacturing Group. D.U Singer Hospital Products Corp har en företagspolicy vad avser projektutformning, vilken innefattar ett informationsflöde till marknadsföringsdepartementet, ett informationsflöde från produkttillverkningsexperterna och slutligen ett godkännande och arbetsverifikation från samtliga övriga departement som är direkt involverade i projektet. Därefter ska informationen och verifikationerna granskas av det verkställande utskottet (executive......

Words: 1649 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Singer Paper

...In his essay “All Animals are Equal,” Peter Singer argues that there is no moral justification behind our refusal to extend some form of equality to animals. He states that because attitudes such as racism and sexism are fundamentally wrong, so too is the premise that one species is more deserving of ethical treatment based solely on the idea that one is more capable of thought or suffering than the other. The idea of treating animals as our equals is one that has been mocked in the past, but only because many have taken that idea to mean that animals are equal to humans in the most literal sense possible. As far as we can tell, most animals do not invent, think deeply, or create culture, and therefore are not equal solely in terms of rational behaviors. However, this is not the kind of equality Singer advocates for in his essay. First, he argues, we should not be equating moral equality with that particular kind of factual equality. If we were to base moral equality on factual equality, then we would be justified in discriminating against fellow humans based on ideas of inequality in regards to sex, race, or intelligence. The only way to fight this type of discrimination would be to prove that the feature or capacity we have chosen as a marker for factual equality is arbitrary, and can provide qualifiers from some other feature or capacity instead. The African-American and women’s liberation movements took this approach. They argued that skin color and sex were only......

Words: 769 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Peter

...Organization Peter F. Drucker Jim Collins, Philip Kotler, James Kouzes, Judith Rodin, V. Kasturi Rangan, and Frances Hesselbein 5 “Nobody, not even Socrates, has ever asked better questions than Peter Drucker. All the personality, all the wisdom is here to make your work dramatically more effective. There’s nothing better. It’s like having Peter at your side.” —Bob Buford, author, Halftime and Finishing Well, and founding chairman, Peter F. Drucker Foundation for Nonprofit Management “Peter Drucker’s penetrating and profound insights are more relevant and needed today than when he originally produced them. This helpful revision of his classic Self-Assessment Tool offers managers and leaders in every sector—nonprofit, business, and government—a useful guide to figuring out what’s needed, why it matters, and how to make it work. At a time when the need for more effective management and more ethical leadership are the moral equivalent of global warming, Drucker’s common sense and courage should be modeled by everyone who cares about doing things right and doing the right thing.” —Ira A. Jackson, dean, Peter F. Drucker and Masatoshi Ito Graduate School of Management, and board member, The Drucker Institute “Peter Drucker’s Five Most Important Questions continue to be the indispensable questions that an organization must ask itself, regardless of size or sector, if it is determined to be an organization of the future. When these questions are asked, the journey begins. And......

Words: 20187 - Pages: 81

Free Essay

An Evaluation of Singer

...Logic: Peter Singer An Evaluation of Singer Peter Singer questions our conception of equality as it relates to the human species and other animal species. He fundamentally argues that, “The principle of the equality of human beings is not a description of an alleged actual equality among humans: it is a prescription of how we should treat humans.” The statement, revealing Singer’s essential argument, also comprises two approaches we might take towards establishing equality among living things. Let’s trace Singer’s claims surrounding these two approaches and finally consider his fundamental, philosophical assumption. One approach to equality stems from philosophers, who determine a base-line set of attributes or functions that constitute human beings. Typical treatises attribute humans with rational, linguistic, or emotional capacities that differentiate them from “brutes.” However, Singer culls evidence from the medical field, not research but simple observations of medical disabilities, where a human with born defects actually functions at a lower level than certain animal species. For example, someone with severe cognitive paralysis may be less rational or “able” than a normal-functioning dolphin. Thus, Singer points out that if we wish to establish equality based upon attributes, we have a hard time excluding many species of non-humans. As a corollary, the standard of equality by a typical set of characteristics must be set lower and lower to encompass all humans......

Words: 1333 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Apostle Peter

...* Given 5 different names: Symeon (Hebrew); Simon (Greek, Hear; listen); Peter (Greek); Cephas (Hebrew, rocks); Simon Peter. * Son of John or Jonah (Matt. 16:17; John 1:42) * Engaged in the fishing business * Viewed as “unlettered and ordinary” by the Jewish leaders; meaning with no training in the Rabbinic study of Scripture * Married; wife traveled with him in his missionary work. * Shared home with wife, mother-in-law, and Andrew (his brother) * Jesus gives him the name Cephas upon becoming his disciple * Became a strengthen influence on his fellow Christians following the death and resurrection of Jesus * Received the call from Jesus to become fisher of men * Was in discipleship for 1 year before being included as an apostle * Accompanied Jesus un the transfiguration scene, raising of the daughter of Jairus, and Jesus’ personal trial in the garden of Gethsemane * Raised questions that resulted in Jesus’ clarifying and amplifying illustrations * Was most frequently corrected, reproved, rebuked for being outspoken and challenging * Jesus turned back in Peter, calling him an opposer, Satan, who was pitting human reasoning against God’s thoughts found in prophecy; indicating that Peter spoke sentiments shared by the other apostles * Displayed initiative/courage/strong attachment for Jesus * Voiced determination to stay by Jesus; however, Peter failed and suffered consequences * Reproved by Jesus for cutting a......

Words: 527 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Singer Solution to World Poverty

...In Peter Singer’s article “Singers Solution to World Poverty” suggest that U.S. citizens give away the majority of their dispensable income in order to end global suffering. Singer uses some extreme methods in order to achieve his goal of getting readers to truly believe in his ideas and change their values and lifestyles. Singer gathers his information and unique capabilities to determine the voice in this article and rewrite the tone being given in the conversation. The author’s main point is that many people spend too much money on food just by wasting time with their lives and instead we have starving countries eating leftovers by these people. The use of this points out that the author believes in moralistic and compassionate values.  In addition, Peter Singer loves to judge whether acts could be right or wrong by their course of actions. Singer’s Solution did not seem to evaluate into account the long term effect it may have caused. He may have convinced many people to follow in his choice of actions, but certainly not me. All humans have the right to their mortality when they want to buy a certain item in favor of their exquisite needs. In a hypothetical situation, Singer describes a man named Bob and his love for his uninsured Bugatti. Bob has just used up the greater part of his nest egg on an extremely valuable classic automobile. He loves his car not only because he enjoys driving it around, but also because its value continues to go up. This strategy makes Bob......

Words: 1248 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Peter

...regard for Rimsky-Korsakov. However, his personal life during this period was not as successful as his professional one. Tchaikovsky’s intimate relations throughout his lifetime are difficult to verify, but it is generally accepted that he was gay. It is from his letters to his brother Modest that we can infer that he experienced no unbearable guilt over his sexual orientation, but did take the negative social implications seriously. It was particularly important to him that he did not impact his family with any potential scandal. Despite his preference for male companionship, he seriously courted the diva, Désirée Artôt, who was performing in Moscow in 1868. Initially Artôt was interested, but she ended up marrying his rival, another singer from the opera company, which left Tchaikovsky heartbroken. While his career continued to grow, his health was failing through much of 1886-1887. Believing that the end was near, he drafted his will and prepared for the inevitable. But it turned out that it was not his time. Instead, he continued to write music in his last years, staying very busy and in 1888, was awarded a lifetime pension for his work from Tsar Aleksandr III. His last work, Symphony No. 6 (Pathetique), premiered a week before his death. Now regarded as one of his best pieces, it unfortunately received a rather icy reception at the premiere. Tchaikovsky died on October 25, 1893. The circumstances of his death are still a topic of debate. The original report......

Words: 1963 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Peter the Great

...James Crarer 12EUC709 - The Russian Empire   The Russian Empire Essay “In what ways did Peter the Great’s reforms transform the concept of the Empire?” Peter the Great’s reforms are widely considered to be one of the most defining moments in Russian history. Beginning as an effort to modernize the country’s military, as the era progressed the reforms expanded, instigating economic development, governmental modernization, intellectual reorientation and social reconstruction.1 The injection of European practices into Russia arguably set the precedence for the onslaught of a top down modernization that has since been a trait of Russian state development, as well as illuminating the beginning of the transition into a form of Russian modernity. The geographical historian Dennis Shaw, reiterates this by suggesting Peter exposed Russia “to the ideas of the Renaissance and the Scientific Revolution. Building on the achievements of his father, Peter launched a thoroughgoing reform or modernization of his realm with the aim of transforming it into a major European state.”2 In order to comprehend this transformation of the Russian empire, an appreciation of meaning of the term ‘empire’ is required. Stephen Howe suggests that ‘an empire is a large, composite, multiethnic or multinational political unit, usually created by conquest, and divided between a dominant center and subordinate, sometimes far distant, peripheries.’3 While Howe’s definition provides a coherent basis from......

Words: 2922 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Singer

...Filosofía Mirada crítica a la visión de la dignidad humana de Singer En este curso se ha discutido, principalmente, sobre la dignidad de los seres vivos, de la cual se desprende el derecho o no a la vida de estos mismos, específicamente de los seres humanos. Ante la posición de Singer, la cual defiende la idea de que no todos los seres humanos tienen derecho a la vida, ya que no todos éstos son considerados personas, y solo aquellos que ejercen la facultad de conciencia y pueden defender sus intereses, lo son y por ende tienen derecho a la vida, no así, aquellos que queden fuera de esta descripción. Mi postura es de discrepar con esto y pienso que todos los seres tienen derecho a la vida. Como primer argumento debo decir que no me parece sensato, sino más bien arbitrario reducir el valor o la dignidad de un ser a su capacidad de conciencia, y menos sensato aún, a partir de esto, deducir que un ser de ésta naturaleza no tenga derecho a la vida. Una cosa es definir lo que es una persona, otra es derivar necesariamente que los que no entran en esta definición no tienen derecho a vivir ya que esto último no es lógico. Por lo demás, ser persona (entendida como ser racional, consciente, como lo entiende Singer) está presente potencialmente también en un embrión o niño pequeño, si bien aun no ejerce ciertas facultades, las ejercerá en un futuro y será igual de capacitado o quizás más aun que cualquier otra persona existente. También así, estas facultades están presentes en......

Words: 1165 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Peter Singers Ethics

...Media resource Eidos84. (2010, Nov. 27). Peter Singer’s ethics [Video file]. Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gVViICWs4dM Argument Outline: (CONTEXT): Instead of spending money on things to make life a tad bit easier for others, why do we feel that it is necessary to go above and beyond to spend money on things that are a necessity? Issue: Why do we go overboard on spending money on ourselves instead of giving and helping others with the extra funds we do have and not seeing anything morally wrong with that? Conclusion: We must practice thinking ethically and learn to take in or account the interest of others. Premises: Singer uses an example that someone may decide to buy a pair of shoes that costs over two thousand dollars. If they had to decide between rescuing a drowning child in a shallow pond, they would save the child and they won’t care about ruining a pair of two thousand. However morally, for the price of those shoes, a person could have helped several children in a poor country who may need medical attention to recover from simple illnesses. I believe that this is basis for a good argument because he is absolutely right when he refers to some of our terrible spending habits. Every year I donate to St. Jude Children’s Hospital because I know that it truly helps children in need. Bran new clothes every month for me could be the cost of a child’s medication in another county. Singer goes on to say, “we make our lives most meaningful when we......

Words: 274 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Singer

...of "Don't Cry Out Loud". It also includes her own cover version of Selena's "Dreaming of You". Since then, she has headlined concerts locally and internationally, recorded seven albums, which became certified gold and double platinum records. Go is recognized as an international award singer, having won the Silver Prize award for her song, From The Start, at the Shanghai Music Festival 2005 and Best Own song, Isang Lahi, at the Astana International Song Festival 2005 in Kazakhstan. Go has performed in musicals as well: her debut in The Little Mermaid, playing as the role of Ariel during 2011 - where she won a Best Actress award from Broadway World Philippine Awards; and another in 2013 for Tarzan, playing as the role of Jane Porter. Go's theater career continues as she was cast for the 2014 West End revival of the hit musical Miss Saigon, for the role of Gigi Van Tranh.[2] Following this, She was cast for the 30th anniversary staging of "Les Miserables" to play the role of Fantine.[3] Birth name Rachelle Ann Villalobos Go Also known as Shin Born August 31, 1986 (age 29) Pasig City, Metro Manila, Philippines Origin Manila, Philippines Genres Pop R&B broadway Occupation(s) Singer actress model Instruments Vocals Drums Rachelle Ann Go was born on August 31, 1986. She is the daughter of Mr. Oscar Go and Mrs. Russel Villalobos-Go. She is the eldest of four children. She studied Pre-school level to Secondary level at La Immaculada Concepcion School (L.I.C.S)...

Words: 423 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Peter Singer's Solution to Poverty

...Solution to World Poverty In this paper, I will argue that Singer fails to establish that we are morally required to give to charity. In Peter Singer’s Famine, Affluence, and Morality, he makes the claim that we ought to give up any surplus money we might have and send it to places like Bengal to prevent people from suffering or dying. However, is this really something we are obligated to do? Singer relies on two important yet controversial principles that help him establish his conclusion. These two principles state that, “…suffering and death from lack of food, shelter, and medical care are bad” and that “if it is in our power to prevent something bad from happening, without thereby sacrificing anything of comparable more importance, we ought, morally, to do it” (605). The first principle is most likely unable to be refuted as almost everyone can agree that suffering and death has nothing to do with good. Now the second principle can be explained by the example Singer gives that if you were in a situation where you were walking past a pond and see a child drowning you ought to pull the child out resulting in wet or muddy clothes, which in no means outweighs the death of a child. In other words, preventing something bad will always compensate ruining a materialistic thing or spending money on something insignificant. Relying on these two principles helps Singer establish his conclusion at the end of his argument. He first states that there are people in East Bengal......

Words: 736 - Pages: 3