Premium Essay

Arizona Immigration Law

Submitted By
Words 1446
Pages 6
Immigration is something that I have seen and have heard people experience. Growing up you here unbelievable stories of how people have died and suffered in trying to cross the border. My dad came here to escape the civil war in El Salvador and my mom came for a better future. They meet in Washington D.C. and when they were both 20 years old they got married and had me when they were 21. My mom is now a proud American citizen and my dad is a resident. Thanks to the less strict laws that were placed when they were younger they were able to stay here with permission from the government. If it wasn’t for their strength and endurance to overcome their struggles to be where they are now, I wouldn’t be here writing this paper. Immigration is such …show more content…
However long before S.B. 1070 was enacted into the laws of Arizona, the citizens, legislature and governors were known for making many anti-immigrant laws. Kristina M. Campbell an Assistant Professor of Law and Director, Immigration and Human Rights Clinic at University of the District of Columbia David A. Clarke School of Law states in her paper,“ Long before the enactment of S.B. 1070 thrust Arizona onto the national scene as a symbol of enforcement-only immigration policy, the state had already become the site of a growing effort by local legislators, politicians, and anti-immigrant groups to regulate the benefits, privileges, and rights available to undocumented persons on the state and local level. What this demonstrates is that making anti-immigrant laws weren’t such a big deal in …show more content…
Many have proposed that the S.B. 1070 is just a tactic to make undocumented immigrants lives harder, thus making them want to go back to their home countries ( Marshall). Some have proposed to make another Dream act that would help undocumented immigrants stay in the United States letting them have some sort of residence. Then thus letting them get some sort of better education, which then will benefit the country because they will be helping innovate alongside with American citizens (Wanlund). Also an idea which private businesses already do is recruitment of immigrants that way they can be educated and be a part of the American labor force. This idea to some extent makes sense because then the country is picking the smartest immigrants which then will help us in the long run. (Pascal-Emmanuel Gobry). However there are many ethical problems with the idea, especially when determining who is permitted to come. Some people have gone as far to make a comparison to slavery; that you would basically be picking the most capable to work. (Pascal-Emmanuel Gobry). There so many solution to this problem but also many gray areas, which demonstrates the sensitivity of the topic but also the complexity of immigration and why we should be coming up with some type of solution at the local, state and national

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Arizona Immigration Law

...PHIL 3515 Arizona Immigration Law-Was it wrong? If a state passes through a law that takes away people’s rights and freedom because you’re considered to be a minority, is it racist? The law I’m referring to is the Arizona SB 1070, which was introduced in 2010 by the Arizona House Bill 2162, and then signed by Governor Jan Brewer of Arizona.2 The Arizona SB 1070 (also known as The Support Our Law Enforcement and Safe Neighborhoods Act) is a legislative Act in Arizona that at the time it was brought up, it was the widest and strictest anti-illegal immigration measure in recent U.S. history.2 The law reads that every alien living in the United States over that is fourteen years or older must have registration papers or documents in their possession at all times; if this condition isn’t followed, its considered a federal misdemeanor crime. The law also allows people in the police force to stop anyone who looks or seems to be from another country, to check if they have the right documents in their possession.2. While the law specifies who “aliens are”, the law makers and officials clearly target the Hispanic race in living in Arizona. According to the Census numbers, the Hispanic population has grown over 50% from 1990 to 2012, which also includes the number of undocumented immigrants living in Arizona.4 The total Latino population in Arizona is increasing every year and the Arizona officials believe that the only way to contain it is by forcing them out of the country. 4 I believe...

Words: 594 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Arizona Immigration Law

...English essay – The Arizona immigration law We get an assignment, to write an essay about the Arizona immigration law. We get some material as, facts, articles and interviews with Barack Obama. In the following part I would make a summary of the materials. To discuss the problems about the Arizona immigration law, I need to know something about the US political system, how you approve the law. In the USA, there are two types of laws: The Federal legislation there applies to all Americans and all the states. It's about everything that is common to all. For example, the civil rights, immigration law, foreign policy laws. There is also The State legislation that stands for the law in the single states, things there can be different from state to state as taxes. In this text we will mostly work with the state Arizona, where the governor signs the Immigration law. ” Immigration - local impact of Arizona law” summary In TV-program about “the Arizona Immigration law”, are about the state Arizona and a new immigration law. The new law makes it possible for Arizona’ police department to check every person they suspect as illegal immigrants. They can hold them at the station, to the suspects background where discovered. Neighborhood state California, see the opportunities in the law because of the many immigrants in California. “President Obama on fixing the broken Immigration system” summery The American President Barack Obama talks about the immigration system. He said every American...

Words: 1119 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Sb 1070

...Show me your papers For the past two years, the state of Arizona has been causing a huge controversy that arose due to the enactment of the Senate Bill 1070, known as the Arizona law. This arguable state law gives the right to police officers to attain immigrants and take them into custody during lawful contact if they are found to not be carrying legal documents to prove that they are rightful immigrants of the United States. The Arizona law has caused a stir, as immigrants feel that they are not being treated fairly as other citizens and harshly targeted. Despite this, the Arizona law is a privilege to the state, for it gives a hand to the federal government when dealing with crimes affiliated with illegal immigration. Many senators and representatives of the state of Arizona support this law in order to guard citizens and lawful residents against vicious crimes that could be committed by illegal immigrants. According to John C. Eastman the state of Arizona has been challenged by crucial illegal immigration problems even before the passing of SB1070. These problems include the increased rate of drug usage, human-smuggling, unlawful transportation of those aliens, and huge numbers of illegal immigrants being captured at the Arizona-Mexico border. CBS news reported that “Forty-five percent of all immigrant arrests by U.S. Customs and Border Protection are made in Arizona, and smugglers use Phoenix as a hub for moving illegal immigrants across the country.” Further, Governor...

Words: 1516 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

When the Great Melting Pot Stopped Melting

...deportation may not be the answer either. America is a melting pot in which many cultures have peacefully come to make their lives as American citizens. The issue of illegal aliens has divided this nation which is in need of unity and consistency in law enforcement. Research shows that in order to reduce illegal immigration, the American government must enforce the current laws, secure the American Mexican border, eliminate the magnets that attract illegal aliens (such as: employment, anchor babies, social services) and offer no tolerance for criminal activity. Understanding the Problem Many people enter this country through the American Mexican border and usually can do so unchallenged. By not securing the southern border, America has left an opening that anyone can come through. It is not just illegal aliens that cross that border. America is exposed to entry by terrorists, drug smugglers and human trafficking. (Hedgecock, 2010, para 17-19) Another avenue used to enter this country is through Visas. With this process individuals come here through legal channels and then become illegal afterwards by staying on after their Visa expires. Statistically “40% of illegals entered legally and in bad faith overstayed their visas.” (Immigration counters, n.d. para 3) Currently...

Words: 4268 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Jfjfjf

...Arizona Immigration Law: Pros Cons Mathew Hogsed With immigration becoming and ongoing problem with no clear sign of relief several states are beginning to pass new laws in order to slow down illegal immigration. Take Arizona for instance, their law gives them the right to suspend or terminate business licenses to those people hiring illegals and even illegal to simply apply for a job inside the United States. The bill will make it illegal to provide transportation to someone whom you know is residing illegally. It will also require all immigrants to carry registration papers with them at all times. Illegal aliens make up over 25% of federal prisons populations. In certain areas of the nation illegals are responsible for 12% of the felonies, 25% of burglaries and 34% of thefts. With this being said there are 22 other states that are deliberating on instituting legislations similar to that of Arizona’s in an attempt to stop illegal immigration. Crimes are not the sole problem we face with the immigrants; the US holds a vast market for Mexico’s narcotic’s trade. One of the biggest debates that come with Arizona’s new law is racial profiling. This law allows law enforcement officers to detain suspects under reasonable suspicion of being an illegal alien and transfer custody to the ICE. This bill also allows for officers to check people’s immigration status if they are stopped for any other reason. The debates begin with it is not possible by simply looking at someone...

Words: 403 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Media

...will draw more viewers. Latinos have generally been negatively stereotyped in the media as poor, uneducated, lazy, and violent. Another popular representation of Latinos is that they have poor language skills, and that they are gang members, teen mothers, illegal immigrants, drug dealers and traffickers, and common criminals. When it comes to stereotyping Latinos, the media tends to translate everything negatively. Comfortable sexuality is labeled as prostitution; having a lot of kids is associated with being impoverished and acting assertive is viewed as ‘macho’. I would say, however, that without a doubt, the most overwhelming Latino representation in the media deals with immigration. With states such as Arizona and Georgia establishing immigration laws and Latino Profiling Laws (specifically in Arizona), there has been a dramatic increase in anti-Latino activity and hate crimes as well as a growth in white supremacist hate groups. The internet is bombarded with images of White males holding picket signs and banners that...

Words: 1203 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Immigration: Should It Be Legal?

...The history of this great nation has been historically built on the foundation of immigration, the forming of one great nation from the generations of many others, coming together with many great and marvelous ideas. From the beginning we have fought for many different freedoms such as speech and religion, just to name a couple and the list goes on. These types of freedoms people throughout the world covet, therefore attempt to enter the United States of America with hopes of sharing these freedoms. Some immigrants come with a legal passage by an ever-growing generous nation jumping through a large number of hoops and legalities, others on illegal terms in large numbers. Now, is it fair for a nation that has been built on such a vase array of different cultures and world travelers to turn away any new comers like to say “we are full?” Is it ok to punish these people for trying to make a better life for themselves and their families? Is it also fair to the tax paying individuals of this great nation to support such a noble cause from blood sweat and tears of our brows? In this debate we will discuss both sides of the argument, pros and cons of illegal immigration in the United States of America, in hopes to bring about a more clear understanding. Illegal immigration is the migration of people from one country into another illegally, violating laws of that country or state. Illegal immigration is universal and present in developed and underdeveloped countries (Palivos, 2010)...

Words: 2559 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

The Amnesty Plan

...THE PLAN OF AMNESTY: The Solution to Illegal Immigration Michael Mays ENG 102: Composition II February 10, 2012 The Plan of Amnesty How much would it cost to put 10 Million people in busses or airplanes and ship them back to their countries of origin? Is there a better way to deal with illegal immigration in the United States? Is the answer a strict and enforceable amnesty, allowing illegal immigrants to report themselves in order to achieve legal status, or is mass deportation of the estimated 10 million illegal aliens living in the U.S. the solution? A well laid-out, simplified, yet fair and enforceable amnesty plan could solve the multi-billion dollar battle of amnesty, deportation and illegal immigration. The cost of illegal immigration to the United States is estimated in the billions by numerous news avenues but what are the actual numbers and their impact on the United States? “More than 10 million illegal immigrants live in the United States, and 1,400 more arrive every day” (Katel, 2005). This number seems very high and somewhat scary to people but the truth is that “illegal immigrants only make up about 5 percent of the U.S. work force” (Ketel, 2005). Nonetheless, strong actions have been taken by the government to try to put a stop to illegal immigration. Over the past decade or so, billions of dollars have been spent on border-control measures such as walls, fences, and increasing border patrol personnel. From 1993 to 2004, the federal government quintupled...

Words: 3058 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Imigration Laws

...Immigration laws currently are not making good use of the current laws to the extent they are intended and are out of date to the current times. Currently government has no practical approach to who can come into this country or to what level they will be able to contribute to the economy. With a country changing its primary industry to advanced technology and less low skilled manufacturing the ratio of immigrant coming into the country should mirror that demand. With 11 million illegal unskilled laborers living in this country and still growing something has to change. Even though politicians are unable to agree on the correct approach to fixing the immigration problems Immigration laws need to be changed. Over the years there have been many changes in immigration laws but many of them failed. For example in 2005 the real identification (ID) act was mandating that all states would be required to enforce requirements for state-issued drivers’ licenses. In 2006 many of the states started looking into the cost associated with the new real ID act. Many states were not happy with the cost associated with the new act and did not want to enforce it. On, “September 21, 2006, the National Governors Association, National Conference of State Legislatures, and the American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators released a report that judged the cost to the states of implementing REAL ID to be more than $11 billion over five years.” (Stock, 2007). As the states began to implement...

Words: 1425 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Immigration in Human Resources

...Immigration in Human Resources In today’s world, the economy is weak and we are facing a shortage of work and qualified workers. There is much debate over whether or not that statement is completely true. Some people say there is a shortage of work, due to immigrants taking over American jobs, while others say there aren’t enough qualified Americans to fill the open positions. In this paper, I will discuss both views on the topic and provide information from both point-of views to provide my answer to the question: Is the hiring of foreign workers good for business and fair to citizens? Some Say It Is Based on a study from the San Francisco Federal Reserve, an article in The Huffington Post states that immigration increases wages, employment, and productivity. States that have had a large influx of immigrants tended to produce more, hire more, and pay workers more than states that have few new foreign-born workers. For every one percent increase in employment from immigration, a state will see a .4 to .5 percent increase in income per worker. (Hindman) Based on the letter The Effect of Immigrants on U.S. Employment and Productivity (Peri), there is no evidence that immigrant workers take jobs at the expense of citizens. The letter reviews the analysis of how foreign workers affect productivity, income, and employment over a period of time. The study conducted indicates foreign workers may actually increase the job opportunities rather than displacing American workers, based...

Words: 2307 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Us Migration Law

...U.S Immigration Law Name Institutional Affiliation   INTRODUCTION The U.S immigration law has a major effect on the business community. Many business people are concerned about the increasing government raids targeting managers and employers who have employed illegal aliens in their workplaces. For this reason, it is evident that immigration laws lead to unintended consequences for employers who have taken measures to cope with down economy by employing cheap labor and also downsizing their workforces. Recently, president Obama passed an executive order allowing immigrants to become official citizens of the U.S. Although the immigration laws that were passed by the President have been criticized by the legal community, it is evident that have a significant impact on the business community. This paper provides a discussion of the major business issues that have been affected as a result of the immigration law. THE DOWNTURN OF IMMIGRATION LAW The immigration law has a major effect to the business community. The business that operates in the U.S should always be aware that the consequences of employing illegal aliens could affect their business performance to a greater scale. This is because any employer who has been caught having illegal aliens as their employees could lead to a jail term. In addition, employment law has also significant impact as it can lead to hiring freezes, layoffs, and forced leaves of absence, terminations and benefit reductions. Employers are expected...

Words: 1590 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Immigration Law Essay

...Sound legal, an immigration firm serving families and growing businesses. This article is distilled from a forthcoming book to be published by the American Bar of Association Family law provides a brief introduction to the immigration law context, wherein the form is used and describes the scope of the financial obligations it imposes then describes the United States. Citizenship is one of the most wishes for immigrants in the United States and the U.S government can bestow and the most important immigration benefits that USCIS can grant. As a U.S citizen you have the right to vote, travel with a U.S passport, work as a federal employee and much more but some jobs will be limited to U.S citizens for security reasons...

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Illegal Immigration

...Illegal Immigration Policy Reform Matthew Benham 02/29/2012 ITT Technical Institute Composition 1 Abstract This paper addresses the number of illegal aliens in the U.S., where they are coming from now and where they were coming from in the past. It shows the detrimental effects these numbers have on our healthcare and education systems. It also shows some of the estimated amounts it costs federal, state and local governments to provide services to illegal immigrants, and how the federal government has tied the hands of healthcare and education providers. It demonstrates that the influx of funds from tax revenue does not cover the cost of the services utilized. The final problem is not with the immigrants themselves but the laws controlling who can and cannot get into the country. The United States has always been a country where any individual can create a better life for him or herself. Migrants from the world over have come here to start again and provide their children with the opportunities they never had. Unfortunately, the requirements to legally come to the United States are very stringent and difficult to navigate, thus many people choose to come here illegally. Illegal immigration has numerous detrimental effects on our economy; reducing wages, burdening our jails, depleting social services, and the most heavily burdened resources: healthcare and education. We need to reform the laws surrounding immigration to deal with this growing problem. The first...

Words: 1907 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Illegal Immigrants: Article Analysis

...Illegal Immigrants are not impacting the economy, it’s the politicians. Gittleson, Kim. "US Economy: Will Immigration Reform Help the Recovery? - BBC News." BBC News., New York, 24 Nov. 2014. Web. 12 Nov. 2015. In this article the point the author is tyirng to make is Illegal Immigrants are willing to work and with higher skilled workers they wouldn’t have to be a replace. It’ll give undoucemnted workers a chance to work again, and with theiry high skilled job experienced it’ll be a advantage to the increases of pays, but only high pays towards legal workers. However, it could cause many problems, because of the huge amount of how many undocument workers actually want to take over the poistion can cause to many people in a small enviroment with little pay, but most Illegal Immgirants are getting average pay as much as a legal worker because they’re livng...

Words: 480 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Argumentative Essay About Illegal Immigration

...There are twelve million immigrants living within America's borders, which all together consists of just over three-hundred million people. Moreover, 11.4 million of them are here undocumented. Illegal immigration in the United States, remains one of the biggest controversial issues. Many Americans postulate that granting citizenship to undocumented immigrants will only worsen, and contribute to America's over-population dilemma. Immigrants are quickly neglected by Americans, that accuse them of generating criminal actions, embezzlement of American jobs and taking advantage of American dollars. However, these absent minded individuals overlook the facts. Immigrants are hardworking and tax paying individuals, who struggle on a daily basis for...

Words: 498 - Pages: 2