Free Essay

Art and Literature

In: English and Literature

Submitted By shakeshack
Words 1531
Pages 7
2/15/12 Sponenberg

Unit Paper #1 One of the many goals of producing a work of art is to generate a response from the ideal audience. Sometimes certain artworks are even based off of history or historical events to stimulate further response. Or they are simply created for the artist’s own desires. Thereby it is art’s responsibility to reality to portray history in an unbiased manner as best as possible. Displaying forms of art that are not truthful toward history or reality can distort one’s belief of a person or an event if the intended audience knows nothing more about the person or the event then what was shown in that particular art form. By not following this, certain events/people are going to be remembered for inaccurate reasons. Surprisingly, not everyone would agree with this idea. There are definitely those who believe that the real world and the “art” world are two separate realities.

Creating a piece of art that is not bound to the facts of reality and history can be beneficial for multiple reasons. When the director has personal opinions about a certain idea or event, then it is best to produce their opinion in their art. It can be argued that Sofia Coppola did this in her movie Marie Antoinette. This can be seen in the fact that in the movie, the Dauphine of France was portrayed as the heroine. The viewer sympathized with Antoinette’s situation from the get go. For example, the audience was put into the shoes of the Austrian archduchess as her family gave her up to France in order to amend foreign relations between the two countries. Then the audience suffered with her as she took down the emotional stress of her

husband, Louis XVI’s sexual ineptitudes. Her affair with Court Fersen, which actually did occur in history, was shown in the movie as if Antoinette deserved some type of bachelor (Patarin 104). Due to the king’s strange tendencies, he was not very emotional and Coppola made it appear if is Antoinette wanted someone to take care of her. These events and the way they were shown in the film humanize the Queen of France as a mortal just like anyone else, when in fact she was not at all.

It can be proven by historical documents that the attempts to humanize Marie Antoinette were done because of Copland’s opinions of her and not actual fact. Based upon “A full, true, and most authentic account of the execution of the Queen of France,” a pamphlet created by the people of France, it stated that Marie Antoinette was not the person Sofia Copland made her out to be. The pamphlet described the Queen as an instrumental in distributing counter revolutionary publications throughout France, that she obtained a majority in the National Assembly declining the declaration of war against Germany in a corrupt way, and that she sought to introduce a famine into France in 1789 (pages 1-­‐3). Antoinette was also labeled “Madame Deficit” due to her extravagant spending on clothes, jewelry, and her retreat at Petit Trianon during times of harsh financial crisis among the common French people (Kaiser 1). Pretty much while the people of France were struggling for ends meat, Antoinette was living the life with servants at her side for every desire she had.

Even though a director or artist of any piece of artwork has the right to create it in anyway they desire does not mean that they should do it. It is an artist’s duty to accurately portray historical events and people as they truly were.

According to the Oxford Encyclopedia of Women in World History, “Antoinette was hostile toward the Revolution from the onset” (Kaiser 1). Not once during the movie did the Queen show any ill will or resentment toward her people. It was almost the opposite of that as it is showed when she bows to the angry mob outside her palace at Versailles. To top off the historical inaccuracies, the movie ended with the royal family leaving Versailles in a carriage. This abrupt ending does not accurate represent history because the story of Marie Antoinette did not end there. Sofia Coppola ends the movie at this point because the last image she wants people to remember is Antoinette and her family fleeing from the evil, out of control French common folk. This creates a feeling of sorrow and pity for the royal Queen. What is not shown is the conditions of the French people for the numerous years that Antoinette enjoyed living the life of a god in Versailles. In order for this movie to fully adhere to its duty of constituting reality, Coppola should have showed how the Queen’s life ended, with the guillotine. Without letting the audience know how Marie Antoinette finally met her match is further creating a veil of distortion for the viewer because they have no idea what ended up happening to her. Seeing her being executed would have changed the perception of Antoinette, continuing to prove why Coppola did not want to show the scene.

Another movie that we watched in class, Roberto Benigni’s Life is Beautiful, was also criticized by people for certain aspects of the movie and dealing with reality. Critics were angry that Benigni made a movie about the Holocaust that had certain aspects of comedy. In the movie, Guido, the main character, and his family are taken to a death camp in Italy. He and his son manage to get into the same

barrack and throughout their time at the dreadful camp, Guido creates a fictional game for his son to comfort and protect the boy. This story line in the movie might not have been the closest thing to reality because people argued that not everyone in the Holocaust made up imaginary games for their children. Even though Life is Beautiful was a movie of historical fiction, I still believe that it filled its duty of providing a piece of artwork with correct perceptions of reality for many reasons. To start off, the movie accurately depicts life in Italy during the late 1930’s into the 1940’s building up to the terrible ordeal of the Holocaust. Examples of crimes against Jews leading up to the Holocaust were Guido’s uncle’s horse being painted green with black letters reading “Jewish Horse” on it. His house was then looted later on. Guido’s own bookstore was similarly graphitized on the outside of it, identifying it as a Jewish store. Due to this, people avoided his store since he was Jewish and he was forced to sell all his books for half price. Another aspect of the movie that properly depicts reality was the life in the concentration camps. Guido and his family were transported like millions of other prisoners by boxcars to the horrible camps. When they arrived at the camp the men and women who were able to work, worked, generally the ones who were unable to were killed. Guido was forced to carry iron anvils. Also, in the film people were killed when they were told that they were going to take a shower similarly to real life. At the end of the film, the American army liberates the camp and Guido’s son Joshua finally gets the tank he was promised to by his father for winning the “game.”

Ultimately though, this film is based a Jewish family trying to survive in a concentration camp. Guido creates this imaginary game in order to help his son and

do whatever he can to get him through the camps alive. I believe this form of art accurately portrays the time period because most parents would do anything to help their kids survive. Guido eventually does this in the fact that he is murdered by one of the guards. As represented during the time period, parents were willing to sacrifice themselves for their kin.

When it comes down to both of these movies, they both provide the viewer

with some sense of what actually happened, one perhaps better than the other. Yet there are still certain aspects of these movies that possibly reveal some misperceptions about how things actually went. The authenticity of these movies is pretty straightforward or clear. Marie Antoinette takes you into a snapshot of the life of the French Queen and what Sofia Coppola ultimate portrayed her as. While as Life is Beautiful is a fictional story about the harsh times during the Holocaust and the willingness of a man to do whatever it took for his son to feel comfortable in the horrid death camps. In the end, art based on historical events and people should be as authentic as possible, very similar to reality to ensure that the viewer gets a sense of true reality. Therefore the viewer can actually get a sense of what really happened and hopefully almost imagine being involved in the scene themselves. When it comes to dealing with two separately realities between the real world and “art,” the artist, when it is said and done, has the final say, but should strive to make a combination of the two to create the fullest authenticity.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Art and Literature

...Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela was born on 18 July, 1918 in Transkei, South Africa. He was the son of Henry Mandela a local leader of the Tembu people. Mandela was a qualified lawyer after attending the University College of Fort Hare and the University of Witwatersrand in 1942. Mandela established his reputation after his graduation when he joined hands with the African National Congress (ANC) in 1944. He started engaging in rebellion against the apartheid policies of the ruling National party after 1948. The apartheid law or policy promoted inequality among people and with time it had become the governing system of South Africa. This law mostly discriminated against the black South African people. The country separated according to the different race of black, white and colored. Each class had its own separate hospitals, schools and buses. Mandela reputation against apartheid policies had started growing over the country. Later on he was seized and taken to trial for treason in 1956-1961, and he freed in 1961 because he was not guilty. The banning of ANC In the year 1960, but this did not stop Mandela from putting up a military wing in the ANC. He also set up a campaign on the use of aggressive plans. The ANC leaders supportive of his proposal this is how Mandela ended up forming the Umkhonto we Sizwe. Umkhonto we Sizwe group under the leadership of Mandela started becoming stronger and its reputation had grown stronger, (Mandela 112) This led to Mandela arrest in1962......

Words: 3630 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Art and Literature

...[pic] Discover the Eternal Principles The Bible doesn’t have a theology of beauty or an aesthetic (a theory about the beautiful) of beauty. However, many things in the Bible are described as beautiful. And there is much about beauty that can be inferred from the Bible. Some of the teaching points below will deal with Scripture texts in which the Bible directly talks about beauty, but most will deal with texts that provide a theological foundation for how we, as Christians, should think of beauty. Teaching point one: God’s creation is beautiful and meant for our enjoyment. Read Ecclesiastes 3:11–14. The book of Ecclesiastes is best known for its ode to time: “For everything there is a season and a time for every matter under heaven: a time to be born, and a time to die…” (NRSV). Alongside this theme, there is the well-known theme about life being vain, “a vanity of vanities,” a mere chasing after the wind. Missed, sometimes, in the midst of this gloomy, almost despairing perspective is another motif: that life is a gift from God and that the good things of life—food, drink, work, play, and love—are to be enjoyed. Beauty is part of them. [Q] What does this text teach us about beauty? ➢ How should we live in relation to the beauty of God’s creation? In the article, Stackhouse says that evangelicals generally don’t see the need for aesthetically pleasing church buildings because, they argue, the money could be better spent on......

Words: 1650 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Literature As An Art Form

...INTRODUCTION Literature, in its wide range of sense, it is a written work of any single body. Literature is writing that is considered to be an art form. It is used to refer to all written account, though living at or belonging to the same time definitions extend the term to include text that are spoken or sung. “Literature is a process of producing grand, beautiful, well – ordered lies that tell more truth than any assemblage of facts, by Julian Barnes”. Literature is a Latin word, originated in the southern Mesopotania of Sumar C. 3200. Literature usually means works of poetry and prose that are especially well written. There are many kinds of literature, such as poetry, plays or novels. They also put into groups through their language,...

Words: 921 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

1920's Art and Literature

...P.1 24 April 2011 To create something brilliant, there must be truth and reason. Artists hiding behind paper and art only kept the truth hidden. In the 1920’s Art and Literature revolutionized American Society by turning away from the traditional ways and exposing the reality of American life. Art that was being published in the twenties was a representation of a new and wide variety of the movements, forms and points of view. This decade was one that “produced many great works of art, music [and] literature” (Mintz). In the early twenties American culture stood in Europe’s shadow and towards the end Americans were leading the struggle to liberate the arts. Artists were ready to develop new structures, tastes and styles. Poets like E.E Cummings, Langston Hughes, and Wallace Stevens were experimenting with new writing styles and format. Artists were doing the same, Charles Demuth, Georgia O’Keefe, and Joseph Stella, by challenging the dominant and realist traditions in American art. Not only did the techniques change but as did the genres. The 1920’s era was also an era of the Harlem Renaissance “a golden age in American Literature and significant developments” in other arts such as painting and music (Burg). Creativity exploded in Harlem and jazz came into being. Photographers captured the essence of Charles Demuth’s art work by pioneering expressionist art forms. Even as college enrollment doubled during this time period people began to veer away from the traditional......

Words: 663 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Literature, Arts, and the Humanities: Analysis and Interpretation

...Literature, Arts, and the Humanities: Analysis and Interpretation Literature, Arts, and the Humanities: Analysis and Interpretation A1. Earlier Historical Art Period - Impressionism Impressionism has been considered the first modern movement in painting. It started in the 19th century and was developed in Paris. Impressionist paintings are work produced between about 1867 and 1886. Its influence spread throughout Europe and eventually the United States. “Its founding members included Claude Monet, Edgar Degas and Camille Pissarro” (Art, 2000-2014). “Claude Monet's Impression, Sunrise exhibited in 1874, gave the Impressionist movement its name. A critic Louis Leroy accused it of being a sketch or "impression" not a finished painting. The original artists were rejected by the government-sanctioned exhibitions, or salons. Short visible strokes are the style included in Impressionism. This may include dots, commas, smears and/or blobs. Paintings by Impressionists often show shadows and highlights in color. The style of loose brushwork gives an effect of spontaneity and effortlessness. Impressionism shows life in bursts of brief moments. There was major political and social transition in central Europe that helped lead into the Impressionism period. This included the 19th Century industrial expansion. Farmers were forced to become paid labors in factories. Governments across Europe are exploring methods to balance the polarities of social right...

Words: 1495 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Is Literature a More Reliable Way of Finding Truth Than Other Arts?

...and ethical aspects that are revealed in the book. They were used in the search for the truth. Truth is the state of mind of being real or fact. Through the ways of knowing, truth can be found. There are different ways of depicting truth. Through the arts, an artist can express him or herself and show truth through their expression. One form of art is Literature. Literature is a way of reaching truth but is not necessarily the best at “telling the truth”. Truth can also be represented in historical fiction in great literature works such as in To Kill a Mockingbird. Literature is the way that a writer can express him or herself through written language. Some might believe that literature is a more reliable way to find truth. However, there are others who might raise the questions such as “What is literature?” and “Who decides what literature is?” If questions like these can be raised, that means that the definition of literature can interpreted differently thus is it a reliable source of truth? Literature may be a way of expression but expression is shown through other arts as well such as music and paintings. So ultimately, it can be concluded that all types of art can tell the truth. To further investigate the extent that literature can tell the truth...

Words: 1632 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

How Are Women Reflected in Art and Literature at the Turn of the 19th/20th Century?

...for their protests. It wasn’t until 1920 when the Nineteenth Amendment that is finally became unlawful for individual states or the government to deny women the right to vote. Along with these political changes came overall changes in the way that woman were reflected. Writers began to endorse women’s liberation and equality. Literature and plays during the modernism era were often considered scandalous. Marriage was one subject of writers of the period. A Doll’s House, by Henrik Ibsen, was a play about a woman who was treated childishly by her husband and father, and in the end she leaves her husband. It was so controversial, that the play had to be rewritten to include and ending where she stayed for the sake of her children. It is considered to be the first feminist play. Other writers helped society accept the role of women outside of the home. Women no longer wanted to be viewed as domestic, but instead wanted do things that showed their intelligence and skills. The Yellow Wallpaper, by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, was written during this time. It was a satirical story that symbolized the oppression of women. Art and literature during this time depicted the changes in women, addressing marriage, divorce, rights, and independence in general. It was a movement that began to change the way women were viewed. It is mostly because of the authors and artist of this time period that the stage was set for the rights that women have...

Words: 293 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

What Effect Has Any Piece of Literature, Independent Research, Work in the Arts, Mathematics/Science Project, Etc., Had on Your Personal Growth and Development Since You Have Been Enrolled at the Community College? How

...The piece of literature that grabbed my attention and had a great effect on me is A Long Way Gone: Memoirs of a Boy Soldier, which was written by Ishmael Beah. The book is about Ishmael and his older brother and how they survived during the war in Sierra Leone. The boys live in horrific conditions and under a constant risk for their lives. The only thing that keeps them going is their hope, faith, love and memories about their family since they were told that there family was alive. However, due to the heartbreaking circumstances, the boys do not meet their family. As a consequence of such a cruel surviving, Ishmael and his friends are forced to become fearless child soldiers. However, Ishmael is eventually rescued by the United nations where he undergoes complete rehabilitation in the United States. Ishmael’s book inspires me to fight against injustice and crimes. I was born in Nepal, where we moved from, to the current residence in the US. Nepal is also under great political instability and social differences. Hence this book inspired me to fight against injustice and crimes. As a consequence, I am trying to make people aware by encouraging my friends and family to educate the Nepalese citizens. The book also provides a unique perspective of the dark sides of civil wars. I have learnt not to judge people instantly because their upbringing may have been completely different. Here, at the community college, I have met friends from different cultures and backgrounds. I......

Words: 499 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Renaissance Time Capsule

...time capsule from both the Renaissance and the Baroque ages. Thereafter, I was required to identify at least two examples of art, music, architecture, philosophy, and literature depicted during the periods. By doing so, I expected to identify how these examples reflected world events and cultural blueprints of their periods. The Renaissance refers to the cultural transformations witnessed in Europe between the fourteen-century and the sixteen-century (Cheremeteff, 2000). The transformations originated in Italy before spreading to the other parts of Europe. Owing to the transformations, Europe came out of the economic crisis experienced during the middle ages. As such, the period was marked by robust financial growth. Similarly, the period saw changes in art, music, architecture, philosophy, and literature. On the other hand, the Baroque refers to the cultural style witnessed in Europe between the 17th century and the mid 18th century (Cheremeteff, 2000). The style was depicted by the use of overstated motion and interpreted features to create stage shows, tension, enthusiasm, and sumptuousness from monuments, work of arts, literature, and songs. Detailed below is what I expect to unravel from the two time capsules. Art From the Renaissance period, I expect to find the Last supper by Leonardo da Vinci. The piece of art is one the most renowned work of art in the human history (Cheremeteff, 2000). The work depicted the scene of the last supper as illustrated in the Bible.......

Words: 1199 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

How Did The Role Of The Church Change Throughout The Renaissance

...the Renaissance the power of the church began to decline rapidly. Although the role of the church changed throughout the Renaissance it was the base to everything in this time period, such as art, literature, poetry, science, and philosophy. Art was being controlled by the church during and before the Italian Renaissance. Every piece of art had to go through the church and be approved. A lot of the art from the 16th century has the bible or something religious in it because the church was controlling the art. As the church began to lose power, the style of art began...

Words: 587 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Emerging Adulthood

...Key to notes listed a = also approved for Analyzing the Natural World b = also approved for Understanding the Individual and Society c = also approved for Understanding the Past d = also approved for Understanding the Creative Arts e = also approved for Exploring World Cultures f = also approved for Understanding U.S. Society g = Indicated courses specifically designed for those majoring in areas other than science and mathematics h = LAS nonlaboratory courses Anthropology (ANTH) | 102 | Introduction to Archaeology | 4 hourscg | 105 | Human Evolution | 4 hourscg | 218 | Anthropology of Children and Childhood | 3 hoursbh | 238 | Biology of Women Same as GWS 238 | 3 hoursgh | | | | Biological Sciences (BIOS) | 100 | Biology of Cells and Organisms | 5 hours | 101 | Biology of Populations and Communities | 5 hours | 104 | Life Evolving | 5 hoursg | | | | Chemistry (CHEM) | 100 | Chemistry and Life | 5 hoursg | 112 | General College Chemistry I | 5 hours | 114 | General College Chemistry II | 5 hours | 116 | Honors General Chemistry I | 5 hours | 118 | Honors General Chemistry II | 5 hours | 130 | Survey of Organic and Biochemistry | 5 hours | | | | Computer Science (CS) | 100 | Discovering Computer Science | 3 hoursh | | | | Earth and Environmental Sciences (EAES) | 101 | Global Environmental Change | 4 hours | 111 | Earth, Energy, and the Environment | 4 hours | 200 | Field Work in Missouri | 2 hours...

Words: 8029 - Pages: 33

Premium Essay

Time Capsule

...in there to tell you about it all. With that being said, I will pick two from a few different categories and discuss those. This means I will be writing on two pieces art, music, architecture, philosophy, and literature. After telling you all about these findings, I am required to tell you how these items reflect world events and cultural patterns of time. The Renaissance refers to the cultural transformations witnessed in Europe between the fourteen-century and the sixteen-century (Cheremeteff, 2000). The transformations originated in Italy before spreading to the other parts of Europe. Owing to the transformations, Europe came out of the economic crisis experienced during the middle ages. As such, the period was marked by robust financial growth. Similarly, the period saw changes in art, music, architecture, philosophy, and literature. On the other hand, the Baroque refers to the cultural style witnessed in Europe between the 17th century and the mid 18th century (Cheremeteff, 2000). The style was depicted by the use of overstated motion and interpreted features to create stage shows, tension, enthusiasm, and sumptuousness from monuments, work of arts, literature, and songs. From the Renaissance period, I expect to find the Last supper by Leonardo da Vinci. The piece of art is one the most renowned work of art in the human history (Cheremeteff, 2000). The work depicted the scene of the last supper as illustrated in the Bible. Through the painting, da Vinci was able to......

Words: 1222 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Humanities 102

...2015 Nancy Erickson Humanities Today Paper In this paper, I will discuss humanities. I will differentiate between the humanities and other modes of human inquiry and expression. I shall list types of humanities and explain why each one gives reflects current developments in politics, socioeconomics, and technology. Colorado State University defines humanities as, “The branches of learning (such as philosophy or languages) that investigate human constructs and concerns, as opposed to natural processes. The humanities, such as classical and modern languages, literature, history, and philosophy, have the overall goal of the exploration and explanation of human experience.” Art has long been a means of expressing social or political ideas. Anselm Kiefer took art and brought it to an entirely new level by using his art to bring attention to national identity and collective memory. In the process his art began evolving to include occult symbolism, theology, and mysticism. All of his work shares a common theme of the trauma experienced by entire societies and the continual rebirth and renewal in life. Music defines periods of history as well as generations. It evolves with societies/cultures and tends to give people their identity. Music has a strong connection through celebration, remembrance, expression of emotions, and ministering to others. It allows the human race to connect to their own humanity not only as individuals, but as a......

Words: 866 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Church During The Renaissance

...lives of the people and in the government. The church ran everything which made it very powerful and controlling. Since the church was so powerful and controlling, people had faith in it and were willing to devote time and money to the church. Throughout the Renaissance the power of the church began to decline rapidly. Although the role of the church changed throughout the Renaissance it was the base to everything in this time period, such as art, literature, poetry, and government, etc. Since the role of the church changed during the Renaissance everything the church was involved in also changed. Art was being controlled by the church during and before the Italian Renaissance. Every piece...

Words: 1060 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Forum

...ideals were also done away with as they become infamous. Male dominance became less famous as they had no careers after the war. Most of them could not get careers after the war as they had joined the army at a young age. The war had a great impact on the art especially the Russian revolution. Artist got new ideas and the themes of their paintings become one sided, most of the arts had revolution inspire themes. At this time, a group of artists emerged a good example of the groups was the Association of Russian Revolutionary Artist (ARRA). The ARRA got their themes from the Russian revolution. Sculptures and painting were created all showing the impact of the Russian revolution. For example, Lanser, an artist decorated the Moscow Railway station with paintings that demonstrated the work of the soviet construction. The Russian revolution can be said to have had a great impact on the arts as t gave the artist inspirations on their works. Breton defined surrealist as spiritual automatism in its most pure state that one wishes to express in a verbal or written way. He also defined surrealist as a definite implementation of thought. Breton further stated that surrealist is the all-powerfulness of ones dreams. This form of art...

Words: 577 - Pages: 3