Assess the Claim That Ethnic Differences in Educational Achievement Are Primarily the Result of School Factors.

In: Social Issues

Submitted By Pmylona97
Words 632
Pages 3
Assess the claim that ethnic differences in educational achievement are primarily the result of school factors.

It is important to start by recognising that it is hard to measure the education achievement in different ethnic groups, as there are other factors apart from school factors that affect the achievement in pupils from different ethnic groups.

Sociologists have identified several factors that could suggest that school factors are a big part of ethnic differences in educational achievement. An example of this is schools being blamed for coming across as ‘racist’ due to the ethnocentric curriculum that appears in the Curriculum within secondary schools. David conducted a research into the Ethnocentric Curriculum, whereby; he found that the history curriculum revolved around the history of white British people and their ‘glorious past’, with no recognition to any other ethnic groups and their history. However, the school would argue that this isn’t strong enough evidence to suggest that this is a factor that wouldn’t have any impact on educational achievement.

Another factor that sociologists have suggested that affect educational achievement among different ethnic groups within schools is institutional racism. This is when a school is organised in such an ethnocentric way that every day school life discriminates ethnic minorities, with dress codes of the school policy, food supplied assemblies and school holidays could all be seen as institutional racism. School holidays is seen as institutional racism as the British secondary school calendar is based around Christian (Christianity being a traditionally white religion) holidays with the likes of Easter and Christmas, with religious celebrations from other ethnic groups being ignored and not fitted into the secondary school calendar. This is a big example of institutional racism and points to the…...

Similar Documents

Assess Sociological Explanations of Ethnic Differences in Educational Achievement

...Assess sociological explanations of ethnic differences in educational achievement. (20) Tony Lawson and Joan Garrod (2000) define ethnic groups as ‘people who share common history, customs and identity, as well as, in most cases, language and religion, and who see themselves as a distinct unit.’ When talking about culture we use terms such as customs, language and religion that is, about all of the things that are learned, shared and valued by a social group. It is a mistake to think of ethnic groups as always being defined by physical features such as skin colour. Although many ethnic minority groups in the UK are non-white, this is not applicable to all groups. According to Crystal (03), well over 100 languages are in routine use in the UK. Today, children from minority backgrounds make about21% of the pupils in English schools. The level of achievement of different ethnic groups varies greatly in Great Britain. This may be due to factors such as home background, class, language and in-school factors. Recent studies highlight the effects of racism. It is believed that ethnicity influences such factors, leading to an impact upon their education. When ethnic minority students do underachieve in education this may be explained partly by social class disadvantages and partly by educational disadvantages related specifically to their ethnicity. Although members of ethnic minorities are found throughout the UK class structure, Afro-Caribbean, Pakistani and Bangladeshi...

Words: 1510 - Pages: 7

Educational Achievement

...Analyse the importance of poverty as an explanation of social class differences in educational achievement Introduction Sociologists have argued that social class differences in educational achievement can be explained in terms of 4 not necessarily mutually exclusive kinds of theory: IQ theory; theories emphasising social class differences in material circumstances; theories emphasising social class differences in subcultural attitudes and values; and theories emphasising the importance of within school labelling processes. Sociologists tend to be critical of IQ theory for several reasons and point out that there is good evidence to show that social class is a major determinant of educational success even independently of measured differences in IQ. I shall therefore concentrate upon the three more sociological approaches and in each case it may be argued that the factors which may disadvantage working class students in general are especially likely to disadvantage those working class students who experience poverty. However before analysing the possible effects of poverty on educational achievement some preliminary investigation of the nature and extent of poverty in the UK is first necessary and for these purposes we must first distinguish between absolute and relative poverty. Absolute poverty is said to occur when individuals lack the money necessary to ensure their basis physical survival whereas relative poverty exists where individuals have insufficient money...

Words: 4110 - Pages: 17

Assess the Importance of Inside School Factors in Causing Social Class Differences in Educational Achievement

... discussed or agreed upon. Examples of these are obedience, politeness and equality. There is an unspoken agreement, for example, that if you look at which students constitute the bottom sets in school, that they will be primarily working class boys. Lastly, pupil subcultures are an internal factor that affects achievement. Subcultures are the end result of the labelling process as those who are mainly the working class end up in anti-school subcultures and those with positive, mainly the middle class end up in pro-school subcultures. A vital example of this is a study done by Lacey who researched a boy’s grammar school and identified middle class pro-school subculture who earned their status through academic success whereas working class anti-school subcultures earned status by cheeking the teacher and truanting. However, Willis argued that anti-school subcultures are shaped mainly by their expectation about jobs they will get in the future. In conclusion, all internal factors are supported by interpretivists as the data shows a valid picture of the research. Although internal factors are important to consider when assessing educational achievement between classes, there are external factors that need to be considered. External factors such as cultural deprivation, materialisation and marketisation severely hamper a child's future in education. Most sociological groups would agree that external factors are the most important factors to the difference in class achievement....

Words: 712 - Pages: 3

Asses the View That Gender Difference in Achievement Are a Result of Outside the Educational System.

...Asses the view that gender difference in achievement are a result of outside the educational system. The gender difference in achievement in the past and the present portray two different perspectives. In the past boys did better than girls’ bout as times go on due to internal and external factors this has changed as girls are doing better than boys in the current education system. In this essay it will explore how the perception of girls in past were perceived and how external factors has contributed to the change in the gender difference in achievement. In the past girls underachieved in the education system due to the expectation created by wider society in the past. The fact of the matter is that in the past girls ‘feared success’ because they were not encourage to achieve because there was this idea that a girls future laid in domestic labour. Fontana argues that girls had lower self-esteem as it was constantly reinforced in the home and wider society that boys were superior to boys thus causing them to underachieve in the education system. Feminists argue due to early socialisation this idea that they had hardly no control over their own lives were fabricated form the roots. Therefore they were more likely to view their success down to luck and fate whereas boys saw their success was down to their ability. Feminists argue that female s are likely to suffer from material deprivation then males from a very early age which yet again reinforces this inequality within...

Words: 1624 - Pages: 7

Assess the Importance of School Factors Such as Racism and the Pupil’s Response to Racism in Creating Ethic Differences in Educational Achievement

...Labelling someone means to attach a feeling, meaning or definition to them, e.g. teachers might label their students as troublesome, or intelligent, mature or irresponsible. Interactionist theorists study face-to-face interactions where labelling occurs, looking at different ethnic differences in achievement. They focus on the range of labels that teachers will provide them with due to their different ethnic backgrounds. Their studies prove that teachers often see black and Asian pupils as far from being the ‘ideal pupil’. An example of this is that black pupils are often seen as a disruption to the class and the Asians as unreceptive. These negative labels may lead teachers to treat ethnic minority pupils differently and this could result to failure. A good example of black labelling is from the studies by Gillborn and Youdell; Gillborn found that teachers were quick to tell black students off for behaviour rather than others. They found that black pupils were expected by teachers to disruptive and have behavioural problems which would be seen as threatening or challenging authority. When this was interpreted wrongly, this resulted in negative feedback from the black students which also resulted in further conflict. They both conclude that most of the conflict that occurs between white teachers and black pupils comes from the racial stereotypes that teachers hold. Bernard Coard explains how the ethnocentric curriculum may create under-achievement. An example of this is the...

Words: 1833 - Pages: 8

Educational Achievement

...Suggest three factors within schools that may lead to the educational under-achievement of pupils from some minority ethnic minority groups. Three factors that can lead to the under-achievement of pupils from ethnic minority groups are; stereotyping from teachers, this is when a teacher assumes that pupils from a certain ethnic group will behave in a negative way, so therefore they treat the pupil negatively. Assuming that a pupil from a certain ethnic group will not do as well as those from another ethnic group so they place them in lower sets, which then means those pupils will not be able to achieve higher. Misunderstandings, teachers can often misunderstand pupils’ behaviour as see it as threatening instead of enthusiastic and willing to join in. Suggest three reasons for boys’ educational under-achievement. Three reasons for boys’ under-achievement are; the introduction of the National Curriculum, this made it compulsory for boys and girls to study the same core subjects, giving girls a better chance at achieving. Boys have a laddish culture, which means they mess around more, therefore they don’t concentrate meaning they underperform. Working class boys’ don’t try and achieve as they believe they are only capable of working class jobs. Outline some of the ways in which factors outside of the education system have resulted in improved educational achievement. Some factors outside the education system that may have resulted in girls’ achievement improving are; the...

Words: 355 - Pages: 2

Assess the View That Social Class Differences in Educational Underachievement’s Are the Result of School Processes Such as Labelling.

... class pupils scored lower on tests of ability than middle class pupils. He argues that this is because working class parents are less likely to support their children's intellectual development through reading with them or other educational activities in the home. Basil Bernstein and Douglas Young(1967) concluded that middle class mothers are more likely to choose toys that encourage thinking and reasoning skills and prepare children for school. The importance of language for educational achievement is highlighted by Bereiter and Engelmann (1966). They claim that the language used in lower class homes is deficient. They describe lower class families as communicating by gestures, single words or disjointed phrases. As a result, their children fail to develop the necessary language skills. They grow up incapable of abstract thinking and unable to use language to explain, describe, enquire or compare. Because of this, they are unable to take advantage of the opportunities that school offers. Like Bereiter and Englesmann, Basil Bernsein (1975) also identifies differences between working class and middle class language that influence achievement. he distinguishes between 2 speech code, the restricted code and the elaborated code. The restricted code is typically used by the working class. It has limited Vocabulary and is based on short ungrammatically simple sentences. Speech is predictable and may even involve just one word or gesture. This is one of the reasons working......

Words: 2534 - Pages: 11

Assess the View That Social Class Differences in Educational Underachievement Are the Result of School Processes Such as Labelling.

...In this essay, the view that social class differences in educational underachievement are the result of school processes such as labelling will be assessed. Internal and external factors will be assessed with the use of researchers such as: Bernstein, Bereiter & Engelmann, Keddie and Howard. Internal factors such as labelling have been shown to effect education achievement. To label someone is to attach a meaning or definition to them. Becker carried out a study on labelling on 60 Chicago high school teachers, and found that they judged pupils according to how closely they fit an image of the ideal pupil. The pupils work, conduct, and appearance were key factors to the teachers’ judgements. Becker found that middle class children were closer to the image of the ideal pupil whereas the working class children were furthest away and seen as badly behaved. Cicourel & Kituse’s study of educational counsellors in an American high school shows how this labelling can disadvantage working class student. They found that the way in which counsellors would assess the student’s suitability for courses. They judged students on the basis of their class and/or race. Where students would have the same grades, they work more likely to label middle class pupils as having college potential and to place them on higher level courses. Rist did a study on an American kindergarten and found that the teachers used information about the children’s home, background and appearance to place...

Words: 3404 - Pages: 14

Assess the View That Factors Within a School Are the Main Cause for Social Class Differences in Educational Achievement (20 Marks)

...Over the board, middle class students generally do better than working class students in educational achievement. Some sociologists argue that this is due to three key factors. Labelling, subcultures and marketisation. This focuses on things that occur internally. One of these key factors is labelling. To label someone is to attach a meaning or definition to someone. An example of this would be that teachers often apply labels to students on the basis of their behaviour or appearance. Becker found some evidence behind this after he did some research on high school teachers. He found they would label students according to how closely they fitted the image of the, “ideal pupil.” Pupils work conduct and appearance were the key factors in influencing their judgement. Cicourel and Kitsuse also found some evidence when studying counsellors. They found inconsistencies in the way in which students suitability for courses were assessed. The councellors said they judged students according to their ability. In practise however they judged them on the basis of social class or race. Middle class students were more likely to be placed on higher level courses and seen as suitable college material. Following on from this labelling theory, Rist did some research and found that teachers used a range of methods to place students in separate groups and this had implications in terms of access to knowledge and achievement. Each pupil was streamed into a different group. Streaming is when...

Words: 1622 - Pages: 7

Assess the View That Factors and Processes Within the School Are the Main Cause of Differences in the Educational Achievement of Different Social Groups.

...Assess the view that factors and processes within the school are the main cause of differences in the educational achievement of different social groups. It is clear that there are differences in educational achievement of certain social groups, such as gender, ethnicity, and social class. Some may argue that this is due to internal factors, reasons from within the education system. However, others argue that the differences are due to external factors, which occur outside of the education system. An internal factor that causes difference in educational achievement is labelling. This is when a teacher makes assumptions about a student and treats them accordingly to that assumption. An example of this is the fact that teachers label boys as more disruptive than girls. Teachers communicate with girls more positively because they see them as being more co-operative. This can then raise girl’s self esteem which raises their achievement. Teachers have lower expectations of boys, and expect them to misbehave more often. Becky Francis found that while boys got more attention in class, they were disciplined more harshly and felt picked on by teachers. This would lead to them retaliating with bad behaviour, thus lowering their achievements. Labelling can also happen to people due to their ethnicity. Gillborn found that teachers were quicker to discipline black pupils than others for the same behaviour. Gillborn and Youdell found that this is the result of teacher’s radicalised...

Words: 2451 - Pages: 10

Assess the View That Social Class Differences in Educational Achievement Are the Result of Internal Processes Such as Labelling.

...Assess the view that social class differences in educational achievement are the result of internal processes such as labelling. Many sociologists would agree school processes such as labelling have an effect on a child’s educational achievement. However there are many other school processes that cause underachievement. To label someone is to attach a meaning or definition to them. For example, teachers may label a student as smart, thick, hardworking or troublemaker. Studies have shown that teachers often attach such labels regardless of the pupil’s actual ability or attitude. Instead they label pupils on the basis of stereotyped assumptions about their class background. Becker carried out an important study of labelling. He carried out interviews with 60 Chicago high school teachers. His findings were that they judged pupils according to how closely they fitted an image of the ‘ideal pupil’. Pupils work, conduct and appearance were key factors influencing teacher’s judgments. Middle class children were seen as the closest to ideal by teachers however lower working class children were seen as furthest away from it because they regarded them as badly behaved. Cicourel and Kitsuse’s study of educational councilors in an American high school shows how such labelling can disadvantage working class students. Cicourel and Kitsuse found inconsistencies in the way the councilors assessed students’ suitability for courses. Although they claimed to judge students...

Words: 1421 - Pages: 6

Outline and Assess the View That in School Factors Have the Main Influence on the Educational Achievement of Different Social Classes (50 Marks)

...Outline and assess the view that in school factors have the main influence on the educational achievement of different social classes (50 Marks) INSIDE - The Curriculum What is taught in schools disadvantages working class pupils. The knowledge taught in school is different to the cultural experiences of working class pupils. For example, History deals with the ruling class such as kings, queens and politicians, rather than the majority of ordinary people. Cultural Bias of the hidden curriculum favours middle class pupils. This may lead the underachievement and truancy of those from working class backgrounds. Ramsay argues that knowledge is used as a form of social control and that there is a hidden curriculum behind the subjects of Maths and English to keep the working class in their place. Ramsay argues that truancy is a protest against this pressure. - Teacher Labelling Interactionists study the interactions between teacher & student and student & student. Their explanations are based on a “labelling theory”. Teachers judge students not by their ability or intelligence, but by characteristics such as class. Keddie – “Classroom Knowledge” Keddie studied classroom interactions in a large, socially mixed comprehensive school in London. She had found that teachers categorised and evaluated classroom knowledge. The knowledge that teachers gave pupils was based on their assessment of the pupil’s ability to cope with the knowledge. Pupils that were categorized as...

Words: 611 - Pages: 3

Outline and Assess the View That Gender Differences in Educational Achievement Are Caused by Factors Outside School.

...Differences in educational achievement refer to the significant differences in educational success and failure. This difference can be found between the two genders where it is a fact that girls outperform boys in the education system; some may argue that this is a result of factors outside of school. The validity of this or whether the differences are caused by factors outside school will be discussed. One reason as to why it can be argued that gender differences in educational achievement are caused by factors outside school is because of changes in society’s views on females. In past generations, girls would not attend school and instead stay at home and learn from their mother how to cook and look after children, they were nurtured to become housewives for their future husbands. This meant that women had low aspirations, however this has changed. Sue Sharpe argues that this is a result of a gender quake that society is experiencing. Previously, girls had aspired to get married at a young age and become mothers to children early on in their lives. However, girl’s priorities have changed to getting an education so that they can have a career (Francis and Skelton) and therefore being able to support themselves above all other priorities rather than relying on a husband. This therefore means society accepts that it is normal for girls to get an education and provide for themselves; therefore society’s views on women can be argued to be an important outside school factor to...

Words: 1308 - Pages: 6

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere, Assess the Claim That Gender Differences in Educational Achievement Are Primarily the ‘Result of Changes in Wider Society

...January 2010 Item A Although the educational performance of both girls and boys has improved over the past twenty years, a significant gender gap in achievement has developed. Girls now outperform boys in most subjects and at most levels of education. This is especially true of pupils at GCSE where 10% more girls than boys achieve five or more A* – C grades. Some sociologists claim that gender differences in achievement are the result of changes in wider society, such as the impact of feminist ideas and changing employment opportunities for both girls and boys. However, others argue that the education system has become ‘feminised’, for example through an emphasis on coursework in assessment, which may favour girls. Furthermore, a lack of male primary school teachers means that many boys do not have an adult male role model in their early experiences of school. Using material from Item A and elsewhere, assess the claim that gender differences in educational achievement are primarily the ‘result of changes in wider society’ (20 marks) Gender differences in educational achievement have changed drastically over the past twenty years due to many various factors including alterations in wider society and the reshaping of the education system itself. Girls are now outperforming boys in the majority of subjects at all levels of education prompting an ongoing argument between sociologists on the reasons behind this change. Some sociologists claim that the reason for...

Words: 1056 - Pages: 5

Evaluate the View That Differences in Educational Achievement Between Social Classes Are the Result of Factors and Processes Within the School.

...Evaluate the view that differences in educational achievement between social classes are the result of factors and processes within the school. Within school there are educational differences within achievement between social classes. Generally the middle class on the whole tend to do better and outperform the working class. Some of the reasons why are put forward by interactionists sociologists who believe that the difference is “a result of factors and processes within the school” which are internal factors which cause this difference in achievement between social classes. Interactionists look at processes in the school on a small scale interaction to try and figure out why there is a difference. However there are other views such as external factors which suggest it is factors outside the school which lead to differences in educational achievement between social classes. One internal factor which can be seen as partly responsible for differences in educational achievement between social classes is labelling. Labelling refers to the process of defining a person or group in a certain way. Labelling by teachers can contribute to differences in educational achievement. For example a study by Howard Becker discovered how teachers judged pupils according to how closely they fitted the image of the “ideal pupil” and based their judgement on many key factors such as work, conduct and appearance. The teachers saw the middle class as the closest to the ideal pupil and the...

Words: 1357 - Pages: 6