Free Essay

Assessing Advertising Efficiency

In: Business and Management

Submitted By eggegg
Words 4914
Pages 20
Does the Internet Play a Role?
Albena Pergelova, Diego Prior, and Josep Rialp ABSTRACT: This research focuses on a major concern for marketers addressing the claims of inefficiency of spending on advertising. We examine whether the Internet can help increase overall advertising efficiency. Using a sample from the Spanish automobile industry, we combine a nonparametric method—Data Envelopment Analysis—with recent important insights from statistics and econometrics studies, and find that online advertising improves the efficiency levels and that this effect is more pronounced in the long-term temporal framework.

During the past few decades, expenditures in manufacturing and general management have been declining while marketing costs have risen (Sheth and Sisodia 1995). From a “budgetary” context perspective, the biggest part of marketing expenditures usually goes to advertising and promotion (Ambler 2000). Some empirical evidence suggests that in the long term, advertising has a positive effect on differentiation and brand equity, while this is not the case for promotion (Boulding, Lee, and Staelin 1994; Jedidi, Mela, and Gupta 1999). Although recent studies have found that promotion has a role in building brand knowledge (e.g., Palazón-Vidal and Delgado-Ballester 2005), the “traditional wisdom” of advertising enhancing brand equity has given rise to very high amounts of advertising budgets. However, researchers claim that advertising is “rife with productivity problems” (Sheth and Sisodia 1995, p. 19). Consequently, advertising is under increasingly severe scrutiny because of the growing emphasis on accountability of advertising results (Bhargava, Donthu, and Caron 1994). The pressure to justify advertising expenditures has led marketers to look for a new advertising mix, stressing Internet usage. Online advertising is believed to be highly cost-effective relative to other media, particularly when taking into account its ability for more precise targeting and two-way dialogue with customers (e.g., Briggs and Hollis 1997). At the beginAlbena Pergelova (Ph.D., Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona) is a full-time faculty in the School of Business, Grant MacEwan University, Edmonton. Diego Prior (Ph.D., Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona) is a full professor of accounting and management control in the Department of Business Economics, Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona and IESEG School of Management. Josep Rialp (Ph.D., Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona) is an associate professor of marketing in the Department of Business Economics, Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona.

ning of 2006, marketing chief officers of Fortune 500 companies announced that they planned to increase online advertising spending up to 32% compared to the previous year. Could this be part of the way of making advertising more efficient? Academic research in Internet advertising has grown exponentially in the past decade in search of the role of the Internet as a marketing tool. Researchers refer to the Internet’s capability of addressing individual customers (Deighton 1997), its interactivity and ability to store vast amounts of information (Peterson, Balasubramanian, and Bronnenberg 1997), and the fact that it allows customers to seek unique solutions to their needs (Sheth, Sisodia, and Sharma 2000). Moreover, Internet advertising attracts attention because of the current shift in advertising strategy in favor of deriving maximum response from selected target groups instead of maximum exposure to many unknown audience groups (Yoon and Kim 2001, p. 53). The accountability of online advertising along with its contribution to marketing efficiency and effectiveness are expected to lead to further growth in Web-based advertising efforts (Brackett and Carr 2001; Hollis 2005; Sharma and Sheth 2004). In spite of the expanding attention to the role of the Internet in advertising, the contribution of online advertising to overall advertising efficiency still remains unclear because of a lack of studies that deal with this issue. This study, therefore, aims to address this gap in the literature and assess advertising efficiency with a focus on the role of the Internet. We verify whether the use of the Internet as an advertising tool affects the overall advertising efficiency in the Spanish automobile

The authors gratefully acknowledge financial support from the Commissioner for Research and Universities of the Departament d’Innovaciò, Universitat i Empresa de la Generalitat de Catalunya and the European Social Fund, as well as the Spanish Ministry of Science and Education (projects SEJ2007-60995/ECON and SEJ2007-67895-C04-02).
Journal of Advertising, vol. 39, no. 3 (Fall 2010), pp. 39–54. © 2010 American Academy of Advertising. All rights reserved. ISSN 0091-3367 / 2010 $9.50 + 0.00. DOI 10.2753/JOA0091-3367390303


The Journal of Advertising

industry over a period of seven years. The research approach used in this study encompasses two dimensions—competition and time—as crucial in the assessment of advertising efficiency. Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) was chosen as the appropriate technique for measuring advertising efficiency because it can deal with the concern in the marketing literature that advertising expenditure decisions are often made with competitors in mind (Rust, Lemon, and Zeithaml 2004). Therefore, it is important to benchmark the results of advertising against the best performers in the industry. In this field, research (Simar and Wilson 1998, 2007) demonstrates that DEA efficiency coefficients are biased estimations of the true, unknown, efficiency levels; this bias being potentially amplified when the number of units included in the sample under analysis is relatively small. As this may well be the case in our sample, bootstrapping techniques to correct the observed bias in the DEA efficiency estimates are applied. Once the bias is adjusted in the estimated efficiency scores, following Simar and Wilson (2007), we use the corrected efficiency scores as a dependent variable in a seven-year truncated regression. The results of this study suggest that the Internet has gained its place as a necessary part of the advertising mix since firms that had invested consistently in online advertising achieved long-term gains in efficiency. CoNCEPTuAl bACkGRouND Advertising Efficiency Early research in assessing advertising performance focused on advertising ROI (return on investment) (Dhalla 1978), efficiency of advertising spending measured by the advertising cost/sales ratio (Smith and Park 1992), and the effect of advertising on sales measured by econometric models (Assmus, Farley, and Lehmann 1984). However, scholars have been pointing out that environment and competition have to be taken into account when assessing the productivity of marketing actions (Sheth and Sisodia 2002; Vakratsas and Ambler 1999). Rust et al. (2004, p. 86) argue that firm performance is fundamentally affected by competition and it changes over time; therefore, it is necessary to capture both dimensions (competition and time) in marketing productivity measurement. We discuss, in turn, the theoretical rationale supporting this view. The Competition Dimension According to the information processing theory, consumers process information independently for different brands and then compare the values across all relevant attributes (Fishbein and Ajzen 1975). Nevertheless, as Teng and Laroche (2007) claim, the information processing theory places a limit on

the consumer behavior models to discover the real marketing phenomenon because competition has been ignored. New developments in the field posit that the consumer decisionmaking process is a competitive comparison and is the result of competition at each stage of ad and brand information processing (Laroche, Kim, and Zhou 1996; Teng and Laroche 2007). Because the consideration of competing brands is a central element of brand choice (Guadagni and Little 1983) and competition has an effect on each consumer’s purchase decisions (Rust et al. 2004), we contend that competition should be included in the measurement of the effect of advertising on sales. The competition dimension has received relatively little attention in advertising research. Only recently have researchers started to examine the effect of advertising by taking the competition into consideration (e.g., Vakratsas and Ma 2005; Yoo and Mandhachitara 2003). Over the past decade, a few studies have applied DEA methods to evaluate advertising efficiency in competitive settings. Luo and Donthu (2001) assessed the best advertising practices among the top 100 U.S. advertisers and found that many leading advertisers have low advertising efficiency (below 20%). Färe et al. (2004) estimated the cost efficiency in advertising in the U.S. beer industry and found that the overall cost efficiency index was low and there was considerable variability in media-mix efficiency among firms and over time. Büschken (2007) revealed 8% inefficiency of brand advertising spending in the German car market. Luo and Donthu (2005) compared two frontier methodologies—DEA and the Stochastic Frontier Model—to benchmark inefficiency, demonstrating about 20% inefficiency of media spending for the top 100 U.S. advertisers. Lohtia, Donthu, and Yaveroglu (2007) used DEA to evaluate banner advertisements efficiency. We follow the latter stream of research and address the competition dimension by evaluating advertising efficiency relative to competitors. Thus, the competition dimension in our study is introduced by the use of DEA, a technique that explicitly considers the competitors in evaluating the efficiency of advertising by benchmarking the performance of each unit under analysis to the “best performers” in the industry. The Time Dimension Measuring the effect of advertising on sales, with attention to the duration of this effect, has been extensively studied. Among the techniques applied are the Koyck model (e.g., Leone 1995), the VAR (vector autoregressive) model (e.g., Dekimpe and Hassens 1995), and the examination of cumulative effects of advertising on choice and quantity (Jedidi, Mela, and Gupta 1999). Much of the literature used distributed lag models that capture the relation between advertising flows and sales flows. Clarke (1976) estimated that the duration interval of advertis-

Fall 2010


FIGuRE 1 Advertising Efficiency Measurement Model

ing varied widely, but the effect of advertising on sales lasts only months. Conversely, other authors claim that the advertising effect on sales carries over for multiple years (Dekimpe and Hanssens 1995; Peles 1971) and that advertising affects long-run marketing productivity by creating knowledge and maintaining acceptance about brands (Berkowitz, Allaway, and D’Souza 2001; Cobb-Walgren, Ruble, and Donthu 1995; Ehrenberg et al. 2002). A critical part of how advertising influences consumer behavior is explained by memory because consumers usually do not make brand purchase choices at the time of advertising exposure, but rather on the basis of the memory of the advertising messages (Mehta and Purvis 2006). Braun-LaTour and LaTour (2004) explain that the conventional wisdom in advertising was that memory for an ad creates a separate memory trace that decays over time. Failure to remember the ad was considered a consequence of the inability to find the right cue to access its content (Keller 1987). However, a newer view in this respect (Edell 1993) is that the memory for the ad interacts with other information stored in the memory (other ads, personal experience, word of mouth about the brand, etc.). Therefore, the memory for advertising is dynamic in nature (Braun 1999). In line with the latest developments in consumer behavior and memory research, advertising efficiency in our study is defined as the efficiency of the expenditures in advertising made by a company in generating sales relative to its competitors, and we estimate the efficiency over a period of seven years. The advertising efficiency measurement model is presented in Figure 1. We adopt the definition of technical efficiency, that is, the ability to minimize input use in the production of a given output vector, or the ability to obtain maximum output from a given input vector (Kumbhakar and Lovell 2000). Internet Advertising Since the early 1990s, Internet advertising has grown exponentially and has occupied a place as a necessary part of the

advertising mix. This is so because the Internet is believed to be more effective than traditional media in accomplishing certain advertising objectives (Li and Leckenby 2004). As stated by Briggs and Hollis (1997), the Web offers unique advantages over other media in terms of targeting and direct marketing. Deighton (1997) highlights two critical features of the Internet: addressability (the communication is directly addressable to individuals) and responsiveness (the communication is alert to the receiver’s response). Thus, the Internet provides a targeted means for reaching consumers (Burke 1997). The most frequently highlighted feature of Internet advertising is its interactivity (e.g., Rodgers and Thorson 2000). Interactivity is considered one of the main reasons that make the Internet a substantial advertising vehicle (Roberts and Ko 2001). Although different definitions of interactivity have been provided in the literature (e.g., Steuer 1992), there is a common view that in an interactive environment, the marketing communication is changed from a one-way to a two-way process (Stewart and Pavlou 2002) where, on the one hand, advertisers have the advantage of identifying customers, differentiating them, and customizing purchasing and postpurchase service (Roberts and Ko 2001), and, on the other, consumers have more influence on the process by selecting advertising and choosing whether, when, and how to interact (Pavlou and Stewart 2000). The described features of the Internet have led several authors (Brackett and Carr 2001; Hollis 2005; Sharma and Sheth 2004) to the expectation of further growth in Web-based advertising efforts, stressing the contribution of the Internet to marketing efficiency and effectiveness, in view of the shift in advertising strategy in favor of deriving maximum response from selected target groups instead of maximum exposure to many unknown audience groups (Yoon and Kim 2001). Because of its ability to transmit information quickly and inexpensively, the Internet is expected to have a greater impact on marketing communications than on other marketing elements. Peterson, Balasubramanian, and Bronnenberg (1997) suggest that communication channel intermediaries


The Journal of Advertising

will probably be the most affected by the Internet because it has been designed to deliver information efficiently and is more flexible and superior in targeting buyers, enabling direct interaction. In a similar vein, Zeng and Reinartz (2003) argue that the Internet has a very differentiated effect along the three different stages of the consumer decision-making process—search, evaluate, and transact. The Internet has been very successful, the authors state, in increasing the efficiency and effectiveness of the first stage—the information search. For different industries and products, the possible gains from the Internet at the three stages would vary greatly. Products such as books, travel, and computer equipment can provide customer values at all three stages, whereas, for new cars, the Internet currently has its highest potential in the first stage, thus increasing the communication benefits for consumers. Indeed, Sheth, Sisodia, and Sharma (2000) point out that in 1999, around 40% of automobile buyers perused the Internet before visiting a dealer, which is 25% more than in 1998. Yoon and Kim (2001) found that the Internet affected the purchase decision of customers that are highly involved with automobiles more than other media. Klein and Ford (2003) found that an increasingly greater proportion over time of searching for automobiles is conducted using Internet sources. Ratchford, Lee, and Talukdar (2003) study the effect of the Internet on information search for automobiles and report gains for consumers stemming from time savings and also from better buys (reductions in opportunity losses). They further state that the Internet reduces time spent with the car dealer/ manufacturer and thus leads to efficiency gains for both the consumer and the dealer. Another line of research compares the effects and effectiveness of the Internet with those of other media, with substantial differences among the media not being found (Faber, Lee, and Nan 2004). Comparing online and print advertising, Gallagher, Foster, and Parsons (2001) found that those two media are equally effective, given an equal opportunity for exposure to the target audience. The advantage of the Internet is, therefore, in its cost-effectiveness. Research has reported that the Internet can boost brand impact at 60% less cost than offline ads (McCarthy 2003). Taking an efficiency perspective, if online advertising is equally effective, is better at targeting interested consumers, and is less costly, we expect that: H1: Investing in Internet advertising will increase overall advertising efficiency. The latest developments in Internet advertising suggest that it maximizes its effect when combined with conventional advertising. Li and Leckenby (2004) suggest that the integration of traditional and new media is nowadays essential for many advertising campaigns. Parker and Plank (2000) explain that people do not abandon traditional forms of media for the Internet in their search processes. Besides, people

are usually exposed first to offline ads, and consumers can be biased toward the Web efforts of advertisers based on previous attitudes toward the brand formed during exposure to offline advertisements (Balabanis and Reynolds 2001). Researchers have long suggested that multiple-source messages would be more easily processed by (and will motivate more) consumers than repetitive messages (e.g., Chang and Thorson 2004; Edell and Keller 1999; Harkins and Petty 1981a, 1981b, 1987). A greater number of sources affects message credibility and this, in turn, influences purchase intention. Chang and Thorson (2004) advocate that marketers should apply multiple-source strategy since presenting information in varied contexts leads to ad messages being encoded in a slightly different way, which enhances retrieval ability and therefore increases awareness. In their study of multiple-source strategies, the television–Web ad mix led to higher attention, higher perceived message credibility, and a greater number of total and positive thoughts, and this effect was superior to the repetitive ad condition. Likewise, Tsao and Sibley (2004) found that there were reinforcing effects between online ads and several offline ad channels, such as television, billboards, and direct mail, which led them to conclude that the Internet served a complementary and not a displacement role in the advertising mix. Similarly, Saeed, Hwang, and Grover (2003) found evidence about the complementary effect of Web site value and offline advertising. In their study, performance was influenced by advertising expenditures complemented by Web site features facilitating product search, product choice, and the productownership experience. Ilfeld and Winer (2002) found that both online and offline advertising increase Web traffic and this, in turn, increases brand equity. Therefore we expect that: H2: Companies that employ an advertising mix in which conventional media are complemented by Internet advertising will have greater advertising efficiency. A great deal of the research in online advertising has focused on brand-related response measures. This is not surprising because much of the marketing communications efforts of the companies are oriented toward building a favorable attitude, brand familiarity, and brand preference in consumers’ minds as a basis for purchase intention and decision. Ehrenberg et al. (2002) view advertising as having the function of brand maintenance or refreshing acceptance of the brand. They further explain that, since advertising works through people’s memory, the gap between exposure and behavior will be different for different types of products; it could be seconds for an in-store display, months for an instant coffee, or years for car or insurance campaigns (Ehrenberg et al. 2002, p. 9). Berkowitz, Allaway, and D’Souza (2001, p. 29) suggest that in the case of advertising for brand building, its effect on sales could be seen in the long term, especially when buying products after

Fall 2010


evaluation and discussion with others (which is normally the case when buying automobiles). Similarly, in the online environment, brand-building and brand-supporting activities are not usually expected to produce quick results. Ilfeld and Winer (2002) found that neither online nor offline advertising lead to immediate development of brand equity; therefore, brand equity for Web sites should be built over time. Drèze and Hussherr (2003) found that banner ads have a positive effect even beyond the traditional click-through measure, influencing recall, brand recognition, and brand awareness. Goldsmith and Lafferty (2002) also supported the positive effect of online advertising on brand recall and consumers’ view of the brand; and Briggs and Hollis (1997) provided evidence about the sizable effect of banner ads on brand loyalty and attitudes. Hence, desired outcomes such as brand awareness, positive attitude, and purchase intention will likely be observed after investing consistently in Internet advertising over time. Thus, we expect that: H3: The more temporally consistent the firm is in investing in Internet advertising, the better its overall advertising efficiency. METhoD To test the effect of Internet advertising on the efficiency of the advertising mix, we followed a two-stage research approach. In the first stage, efficiency coefficients per firm and year using the DEA technique were calculated. The second stage uses the DEA estimates as a dependent variable in a bootstrap truncated regression analysis. A detailed explanation of the method follows. First Stage: Data Envelopment Analysis DEA has become an important tool in efficiency measurement in the past two decades. It is based on the seminal work of Farrell (1957) and was originally developed by Charnes, Cooper, and Rhodes (1978), with constant returns to scale, and later extended by Banker, Charnes, and Cooper (1984) to include variable returns to scale. DEA is a nonparametric, linear programming-based technique designed to measure the relative performance of decision-making units (DMUs) where the presence of multiple inputs and outputs poses difficulties for comparisons. DEA uses the ratio of weighted inputs and outputs to produce a single measure of productivity (relative efficiency). Efficient DMUs are those for which no other DMU generates as much or more of every output (with a given level of inputs) or uses as little or less of each input (with a given level of outputs). The efficiency of each unit, therefore, is measured in comparison to all the other units. An important feature of DEA is that it builds an efficient frontier comprising all of the efficient units, thus allowing a comparison to the best

performers (Charnes, Cooper, and Rhodes 1978). The efficient DMUs have an efficiency score of one (or 100%), whereas the inefficient DMUs have an efficiency score of more than one (or more than 100%) in the output-oriented DEA model and less than one but greater than zero in an input-oriented model. An input-oriented model will look for efficiency by proportionately reducing inputs, whereas an output-oriented model will focus on increasing outputs given the observed inputs consumption. In the case of measuring advertising efficiency, the output-oriented model seems to be preferable since advertising budgets are usually preliminarily decided and the goal is maximization of outputs with the available budget (Low and Mohr 1999; Piercy 1987). The DEA models employed in our study are, therefore, output oriented and with variable returns to scale in order to control for possible different economies of scale at which companies operate. The model is presented below: Max.β t , s.t. k =1 K o ∑ λ k ⋅ yikt ≥ β t ⋅ yit , i = 1,..., I, K

k =1 K

∑ λ k ⋅ x jkt ≤ x ojt , j = 1, ... J, ∑ λ k = 1,

k =1

λ k ≥ 0,

where βt is the efficiency coefficient for the unit under analysis in period t (βt = 1 indicates that the DMU under analysis is efficient, and βt > 1 that this DMU is inefficient; βt – 1 determines the output growth rate required to reach the frontier), yito is the observed outputs vector of the DMU under analysis in period t, xjto is the observed inputs vector of the DMU under analysis in period t, yikt and xjkt refer to outputs and inputs vectors for the k (k = 1, ..., K) DMUs forming the total sample, and l stands for the activity vector. The “true” production frontier and the efficiency measure are all unknown. Estimates of the efficiency can be calculated using observed, or actual, input–output combinations. These estimates will yield information on the input–output pairs that are considered efficient given the observed data. Although this information may appear to be deterministic, past studies have examined the statistical properties of the DEA estimators. Banker (1993) proved weak consistency of the DEA estimator for the single-input, single-output case. Gijbels et al. (1999) derived the asymptotic sampling distribution for the singleinput, single-output model along with the asymptotic bias and variance. However, in the multi-input, multi-output case that typifies our study, the bootstrap seems to be the only way to


The Journal of Advertising

investigate the sampling distribution of the DEA estimators (Simar and Wilson 2000b). The “smoothed” bootstrap approach of Simar and Wilson (1998) is used here, and the theoretical underpinnings can be found in the extensive work by Simar and Wilson (1998, 1999, 2000a, 2000b). The key assumption behind this approach is that the known bootstrap distribution will mimic the original unknown distribution if the known data generating process (DGP) is a consistent estimator of the unknown DGP. The bootstrap process will, therefore, generate values that mimic the distributions that would be generated from the unobserved and unknown DGP (Simar and Wilson 1998, 2000a, 2000b). Because DEA estimates a production frontier boundary, generating bootstrap samples is not straightforward. The “smoothed” bootstrap is based on the DEA estimators by drawing with replacement from the original estimates of β and then applying the reflection method proposed by Silverman (1986). The seven steps in this procedure are simple to implement: 1. Solve program (1) and obtain the original efficiency scores β1, ..., βk. 2. Define a sample βB1, ..., βBk generated from β1, ..., βK. 3. Smooth the sample. 4. Obtain the final value β1*, ..., βK* by adjusting the smoothed sample so that the variance of the final bootstrap sequence is asymptotically correct. 5. Adjust the original outputs using the ratios β1/β1*, ..., βK /βK*. 6. Resolve model (1) using the adjusted outputs to * * obtain β {b1, ..., β {bK. 7. Repeat Steps 2 to 6 B times to obtain B sets of estimates (usually 2,000). Once the desired number of samples is obtained, the bias of the original estimates β1, ..., βK is calculated as follows: ˆ bias β k = b =1 B ˆ ∑ β* − β k bk

all the years and controlled for year and firm effect, including dummy variables. This allows us to control for time effect and for unobservable firm-specific effect. Because DEA efficiency coefficients are censored (in our case, the output-oriented DEA model results in coefficients that are censored with a lower bound of 100), the traditional ordinary least squares model is not appropriate. Although other studies have used Tobit models when the dependent variable is censored (e.g., Datar et al. 1997; Luo and Homburg 2007), recent research in econometrics has demonstrated that with DEA efficiency scores, truncated regression models are much more suitable and produce more robust results (Simar and Wilson 2007). In particular, Simar and Wilson (2007) found that the best-performing model is the truncated regression with bootstrap estimates. We follow their recommendation and use this technique for our model estimates. Thus, we apply a double bootstrap1 model (once in the first stage with the DEA measurement and then in the truncated regression analysis). DATA, ANAlYSES, AND RESulTS Input and output Variables for the Efficiency Analysis In this research, we focus on car advertising. Eighteen car dealers operating in Spain were considered as being suitable for the study because of the availability of all the necessary data for input and output variables. The car dealers included represent 74% of the new cars sold in the Spanish market in 2007. Data for input variables were obtained from the INFOADEX (Information for Advertising Expenditures) database. INFOADEX provides detailed information on advertising expenditures made in Spanish media (television, newspapers, magazines, Sunday supplements, radio, cinema, Internet, and outdoor). INFOADEX computes advertising expenditure by monitoring daily communication markets and their prices. We consider as output variables: (1) sales revenue, available from the SABI (Sistema de Análisis de Balances Ibéricos) database, and (2) sales as measured by number of cars sold, made available to us by the Spanish Association of Manufacturers of Cars and Trucks. Data were obtained for seven years—from 2001 to 2007. There is a requirement in applying DEA that input and output variables should be positively correlated (Luo and Donthu 2005). A correlation analysis was run in order to see the relationship between the variables. Descriptive statistics and correlations between the variables are presented in Table 1. Efficiency coefficients were estimated per firm per year following the bootstrap bias-corrected DEA technique. We also estimated optimal weights for each input giving the relative value of the inputs for the resulting efficiency scores. The DMU-specific optimal weights are reported in Table 2.






which finally provides the bias-corrected estimator of the true value of β1, ..., βK: ˆ ˆ β* = β k − bias β k . k Second Stage: Truncated Regression Analysis To assess the effect of Internet advertising on efficiency, we used the bias-corrected efficiency coefficient resulting from the DEA-based bootstrap as a dependent variable in an explanatory truncated regression model. We pulled the data for (3)

TABLE 1 Descriptive Statistics and Correlations Between Input and Output Variables
Descriptive statistics SD 1 Min. Max. 1 2 3 Correlation matrix 4 5 6



1. y1-sales_unitsa 2. y2-sales_eurob 3. x1-printc 4. x2-broadcastc 5. x3-Internetc 6. x4-outdoorc 61,296.95 1,931.30 4,323,894.44 9,091,021.68 636,120.62 1,300,095.20 .718*** .587*** .874*** .346*** .376*** 126 126 1 .550*** .637*** .155 .295*** 126 126 126 2,110 5.22 975,375 18,690 0 0 193,811 6,658.41 18,619,256 37,240,707 4,842,455 6,432,297

67,186.11 1,693,36 8,036,582.24 13,520,407.22 322,402.10 1,220,398.17

1 .683*** .300*** .491*** 126

1 .482*** .483*** 126 1 .394*** 126 1 126




Variable in units.


Variable in millions of euros.


Variables in thousands or euros.

*** p

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Resource and Capabilities

...resources do not appear on the firm’s balance sheet – for the simple reason that the firm does not own its employees; 6. This appraisal occurs at the hiring stage when potential employees are evaluated in relation to the requirements of their job and as part of an ongoing appraisal process of which annual employee reviews form the centerpiece. The purposes of appraisal are to assess past performance for the purposes of compensation and promotion, set future performance goals and establish employee development plans. Trends in appraisal include greater emphasis on assessing results in relation to performance targets (for example, management by objectives) and broadening the basis of evaluation (for example, 360-degree appraisal). 7. Competency modeling involves identifying the set of skills, content knowledge, attitudes, and values associated with superior performers within a particular job category, then assessing each employee against that profile.[11] An important...

Words: 1650 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Financial Management

...ratio Google: 0.08 Microsoft: 0.2 1. Operating performance ratio: Asset turnover ratio Google: 0.6 Microsoft: 0.7 1. Cash flow indicator ratio: * Dividend payout ratio Google – Nil Microsoft- 0.64/2.69 =23.7% 1. Investment valuation ratio: * Price / Earnings ratio Google: 20.3 times Microsoft: 9.5 times 2. Compare and contrast each company’s business model: (1) core business, (2) leading products and/or services, (3) management/leadership style, and (4) innovation track record. As per Annual report of Google, “Google is a global technology leader focused on improving the ways people connect with information.” Its core business is of providing information and earning advertising revenues on it. Its leading products are: 1) Google...

Words: 870 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Economic Case Against Monopoly

...* A profit-maximising firm will produce at the productively and allocatively efficient level of output in a perfectly competitive industry * The conventional argument against market power is that monopolists can earn abnormal (supernormal) profits at the expense of efficiency and the welfare of consumers and society. * The monopoly price is assumed to be higher than both marginal and average costs leading to a loss of allocative efficiency and a failure of the market. The monopolist is extracting a price from consumers that is above the cost of resources used in making the product and, consumers’ needs and wants are not being satisfied, as the product is being under-consumed. * The higher average cost if there are inefficiencies in production means that the firm is not making optimum use of scarce resources. Under these conditions, there may be a case for government intervention for example through competition policy or market deregulation. Potential Benefits from Monopoly A high market concentration does not always signal the absence of competition; sometimes it can reflect the success of firms in providing better-quality products, more efficiently, than their rivals One difficulty in assessing the welfare consequences of monopoly, duopoly or oligopoly lies in defining precisely what a market constitutes! In nearly every industry a market is segmented into different products, and globalization makes it difficult to gauge the degree of monopoly power. What......

Words: 659 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...Every company wants to ensure their marketing and advertising strategies are as effective as possible to ensure profit and sales will be generated for the upcoming future. Once a company’s marketing team launches an advertisement it is vital to test how effective it was amongst the audience, to understand what was successful and what did not work. Thus, ensuring whether or not the ad the marketing team invested time and capital on is delivering the results required. Once understanding which tactics are appropriate and which aspects of the advertisement were not as effective, one can then better understand how to optimize the next advertisement campaign and achieve the goals set up originally. Advertising effectiveness can be defined as the “evaluation of the performance of specific promotional programme elements – the approach depends a lot on the objectives of the advertising” (Belch and Belch, 2012, pg596-597). Reasons for why it is necessary to measure the effectiveness of an advert varies from avoiding costly mistakes, to increasing the efficiency of advertising by evaluating alternative strategies. It would be beneficial for a company to do this in order to enhance sales and structure better outcomes in the future. However, doing so is costly for the organization and a long process. There may also be conflict within the company, regarding to the objections of creativity and disagreement on what to test. It would be necessary for the effectiveness to be......

Words: 822 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


...International Business class. Recent scholarly articles and various publications were examined and reviewed covering standardization process as a measurement to manage global operation of international business. Its limitations and drawbacks are deliberated as well. Through out this research papers, the following subjects were deliberated: reasons for picking this key term as a topic, a specific explanation and definition of standardization and its role, process, a summary for the major article chosen which is titled “A Model of Advertising Standardization in Multinational Corporations” and the main points it covered, a specific discussion covering the relation of this article to key term and to manage global operations and international market, the relation of the four other scholarly articles research and their discussion to the relation to the major article and main key term. Keywords: standardization, global operation, culture, marketing mix, advertising Standardization Key Term and Why I am Interested In It The key term I decided to extend my research on for this week is “Standardization”. After reading the required material for the International Business class, I have acquired a better conceptualization for the aspects and dimensions of doing business abroad. Consequently, I have desired to further my understandings on one of the important topics covered in Chapter 8 of the textbook (Satterlee, 2014) under the notion of global operation management process......

Words: 1616 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Acct 504 Course Project

...Profile Microsoft As per MSN, “Microsoft Corporation is engaged in developing, licensing and supporting a range of software products and services. It also designs and sells hardware, and delivers online advertising to the customers. It has five segments: Windows & Windows Live Division (Windows Division), Server and Tools, Online Services Division (OSD), Microsoft Business Division (MBD), and Entertainment and Devices Division (EDD). Its products include operating systems for personal computers (PCs), servers, phones, and other intelligent devices; server applications for distributed computing environments; productivity applications; business solution applications; desktop and server management tools; software development tools; video games, and online advertising. Its cloud-based computing services include Bing and Windows Live Essentials suite. In October 2011, it acquired Skype Global S.a r.l. In November 2011, the Company acquired VideoSurf Inc.” Microsoft’s leading products are: 1) Windows Division 2) X-Box 3) Skype Leadership style and innovative track record. Microsoft’s leadership style was earlier guided by Bill Gates , founder of Microsoft. Oracle’s profile As per, “Oracle Corporation, an enterprise software company, develops, manufactures, markets, distributes, and services database and middleware software, applications software, and hardware systems......

Words: 719 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...started in Egypt, therefore it has to exceed customers' expectations and to beat the strong competitors in the same region (Vodafone and Mobinil),which are competing themselves by more offers, discounts and new services to delight their customers.Etisalat also needs more attention from the people in the region to attract people to it, so it makes a lot of advertising and also attractive advertising; to attract customers to Etisalat from all around the areas where its services are able to reach. 3. People Orientation: • People orientation in Etisalat is high. People working in Etisalat, work under one condition which is to achieve the organizational goal (satisfy the customer needs with lowest cost and price possible). Also there are many other factors affecting the people working in Etisalat Company, such as a suitable working environment, which has a big role in making the employees work efficiently and friendly with each other. Also salaries earned by the ope operating staff is a factor of great importance that greatly affects people orientation in the company, because salaries are not suitable, chances of employee's efficiency to decrease is likely high. The third important factor is the Incentives that employees get provided with. Incentives must be high in order to encourage staff to work. These factors are all achieved by Etisalat in order to increase and attain the highest level of people orientation possible. Etisalat's provides special offers to its employees, to......

Words: 1820 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay


...IKEA: Ecommerce Expansion/ IT Capacity Management Information System Initiative LASA 1 Organizational Structure IKEA currently holds the position as the world’s largest furniture retail chain, with 332 locations, in 32 countries worldwide. IKEA is operated and owned by an array of no-for-profit corporations. The Organizational Structure is divided into two main entities: Franchising and operations. Many of IKEA’s operations, including the manufacturing and design of products, the managerial operations, and the supply-chain processes, are overseen by INGHKA Holding, which is private, for-profit Dutch Corporation. INGHKA Holding currently runs 235 of the IKEA stores, the remaining are operated and ran by franchises that are outside of INGHKA Holding. IKEA has differentiate themselves from their competitors, by satisfying the needs and wants of their consumers, with upholding a value proposition that is center on providing, high-quality products (furniture), at affordable prices. IKEA’s value proposition differentiated them from their competitors, secured competitive advantage and positioned themselves as the leader in furniture retailer, on a global level, by their value-based services, and marketing mix that emphasizes on areas such as: Location, Merchandise, Store Format, Market Communications, and Service and Selling Environment, which produced a remarkable “brand image”; “The essential role of brands is to differentiate a product or service from others in satisfying......

Words: 2057 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Recruitment Techniques

...ASSIGNMENT TITLE…….ANALYSE USING EXAMPLES, THE SIX COMMON RECRUITMENT TECHNIQUES INTRODUCTION Recruitment is a fundamental human resource function that overarches many different aspects of the organisation’s overall performance. There are many different ways to recruit new talent to a company, all of which have pros and cons. Therefore recruiters employ a number of different techniques to search and obtain the best possible candidates from the multitude of interested employees. In this paper, the writer seeks to analyse common recruitment techniques which include advertising, head hunting, labour agencies, referrals, existing employees and e-recruitment. The key terms to be defined are recruitment and recruitment techniques. DEFINITION OF KEY TERMS Recruitment According to Beach (1987) recruitment is the development and maintenance of adequate manpower sources. It involves the creation of a pool of available labour from which the organisation can draw when additional employees are needed. Tyson and Fell (1996:28) define recruitment as, “the process of finding and hiring the best qualified candidate (from within or outside of an organisation) for a job opening, in a timely and cost effective manner.” Therefore, from the two definitions above, it can be said that the recruitment process involves analyzing the requirements of a job, attracting employees to that job at lower cost, ensuring that there are equal opportunity for employment for all potential applicants. The......

Words: 1636 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


...Sales and purchasing management Name: Institutional Affiliation: Introduction For the company to be able to make a good evaluation of its annual performance, the following need to be examined; the sales growth, average sales per call, sales per physician, and the selling expense as a percentage of the sales. Sales growth The average sales growth is determined by taking (Current period net sales- prior period net sales)/ prior period net sales* 100%. From the data, the total current net period is 3,529,000 while the net sale for the period is 2,815,000. Hence the sales growth (3,529,000- 2,815,000)/ 3,529,000 *100% = 20%. The company anticipated growth rate for the year is 20%. From the projection, 20% percent is fair for the overall company, but when examined for each sales rep it might seem to be an insignificant figure towards the company. Sales per call The average sale per call is used in determining the amount of money that the sales representatives are making for each call that they make. It is computed using by taking; Average sales per call= Total sales in time periods/ Total calls in time periods. 3,529,000/9,300 = 379.5 per call On average, each call from the sales representatives is generation 379.5 USD per call. Still it is not for the company for the company to......

Words: 1138 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Strategy Management

...airways are tied to Great Britain. Economy Cost of the raw materials required for the business are high and an extant of good relationship with the supplier plays an active part in negotiations to drive down prices. (bargaining power of suppliers). Most continental flights generate a higher percentage of profits from loyal first class and business travelers. Social the growth in wealth globally has increased the spending power of the consumers and the demand for traveling is higher. With more savvy and increased expectations of consumers, they need to be constantly updated and firms reactive to their need also process strong negotiating price driver (bargaining power of customers). Technology The use of the internet is a strong advertising tool to reach a wider range of audience. And in recent years the use of social media. Environment The...

Words: 2024 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Consumer Topic

...1. Product strategies of private life insurance companies 2. A study on “why companies should go for outsourcing” 3. Effectiveness of advertising on real estate sector 4. Study on consumer expectations and perceptions towards consumer loans 5. Workers attrition rate at hotel industry is increasing. Study regarding this issue 6. Attrition rates at different sectors 7. Effectiveness and scope of employee referrals in the process of talent sourcing 8. Study of training needs across different industries 9. Study on creation of luxury brand 10. Strategies used to build successful Internet based customer services 11. Measuring the effectiveness of retail banking of a nationalised bank compared to a MNC 12. Conspicuous consumption 13. Study of awareness and acceptibility of UPVC windows and door systems 14. Opportunities of Financing the NANO’s in Bangalore 15. Changing trends in FMCG industry in India 16. A study of best HR practices in service industry 17. Fundamental analysis of Indian telecom companies 18. Study of consumer behaviour in automobile industry 19. customer buying behaviour towards insurance products 20. Promotion strategies followed in Insurance sector 21. Study on changing consumer preference towards organised retailing from un-organised retailing 22. study on “impact of advertising in B2B marketing” 23. Distribution network & general insurance industry 24. A study on distribution channels in aluminium industry 25. Study on strategies......

Words: 3792 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Human Resources

...Assessing the ROI of training Page 1 of 7 Assessing the ROI of training by Clive Shepherd If people really are your greatest asset, isn't it time to look at your training programmes as investments in your organisation's human capital and not just as an expense? In this article, Clive Shepherd argues the case for return on investment (ROI) as a primary tool for forecasting and evaluating the benefits of training and explains the steps involved in conducting an ROI analysis. Contents Measuring the success of training Forecasting and measuring costs Forecasting and measuring benefits Calculating return on investment Making ROI work for you Measuring the success of training The evaluation of training, like motherhood and apple pie, is inherently a good thing. But, because short term priorities always crowd out their longer term competitors, it's typically something we plan to do better next year after all, we've got away with it so far, so another year won't hurt! And even if training evaluation is undertaken, it is usually at the easiest and lowest level - the measurement of student reactions through happy sheets. Reactions are important and the happy sheets serve a purpose, but will they be enough to back up your arguments when there is a need for a greater investment in training, when major changes need to be made in direction, when there is stiffer competition for resources, when times get tough? Why evaluate training? Let's summarise the main...

Words: 3305 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Risk Management

...Risk management in the health care in the past risk management and quality improvement job was separate in the health care organization. Even though, the job function may have been different the goal was the same. As up today they have close the gap to provide a better, and safety quality patient care. Rationale What is risk management any way not everyone has the same meaning. It can be define as such Risk management is a process for identifying, assessing, and prioritizing risks of different kinds. Once the risks are identified, the risk manager will create a plan to minimize or eliminate the impact of negative events. A variety of strategies is available, depending on the type of risk and the type of business. Outline Risk Management and Patient Safety: The Synergy and the Tension Integrating Risk Management, Quality Management, and Patient Safety into the Organization Benchmarking in Risk Management Risk Management Strategic Planning for a Changing Health Care Delivery System Using Never Events to Reduce Risk and Advance Patient Safety Governance and Board Responsibility to Assure Safety in Health Care Organizations 1. Introduction What is the goal or the idea behind risk management one of their focus is to reduce the financial risk other areas that may seem not important is the regulation. One of the principal issues facing health care risk management is governmental regulation. Over the last few decades, there has been a growing......

Words: 4978 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay


...Proposed Merger Between Staples and Office Depot Leads to Concerns of Higher Prices Michael Baye and Patrick Scholten prepared this case to serve as the basis for classroom discussion rather than to represent economic or legal fact. The case is a condensed and slightly modified version of the public copy of the FTC's motion for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction against the proposed merger between Staples and Office Depot dated April 10, 1997. No 1:97CV00701. OFFICE SUPPLY SUPERSTORE MARKET Staples and Office Depot pioneered the office superstore concept within months of each other in 1986. Over the next ten years, they and a number of other firms seized on the same strategy of providing a convenient, reliable and economical source of office supplies for small businesses and individuals with home offices. These firms competed aggressively, developing office superstores as a one-step destination, carrying a full line of consumable office supply items as well as assorted other products. Staples and Office Depot have been immensely successful: today, Staples has almost 500 stores and Office Depot has more than 500 stores nationwide; they compete head-to-head in 42 metropolitan areas across the country. On September 4, 1996, Staples and Office Depot entered into an agreement whereby Staples would acquire the stock and assets of Office Depot for $4 billion. The merged company would have combined annual sales that exceed $10 billion. Absent the merger,......

Words: 7162 - Pages: 29