Audit Research After Sarbanes-Oxley Evaluation

In: Business and Management

Submitted By www010415
Words 681
Pages 3
EVALUATION OF REASEARCH PAPER
Title: Audit Research after Sarbanes-Oxley
Author: Mark L. DeFond and Jere R. Francis
A. Describe the research problem or question. Evaluate the importance of the research question to audit practice.
This paper attempts to stimulate research into some of the important questions implicitly raised by SOX regarding the audit profession’s potential failings.
Enron’s failure and the accounting scandals at Worldcom and other companies provide compelling evidence that auditing matters and is important. However, it is unclear that whether auditing was sufficiently “broken” in the first place to warrant the radical reforms and changes effected by the SOX.
The disconnection is large between the scientific evidence on audit quality and institutional changes premised on the assumption that auditing is broken. This research gives us the direction which we need to collect scientific evidence to guide public policy-making in audit.
B. Explain the author’s approach to solving the problem.
The authors discuss the following areas and give some suggestions for future research in each of them:
1. Why auditing matters now more than ever
2. Institutions that affect auditing
3. Engagement-specific characteristics that affect audit quality
4. The role of auditing and corporate governance
5. Audit quality and other accounting firm characteristics
C. Describe the major findings of the research.
1. The criticism embodied in SOX is usually intense, and appears to be partially motivated by political expediency and often based on anecdotes.
2. SOX transforms auditing from a self-regulated industry that is overseen by a government agency, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), to an industry that is now directly controlled by a quasi-governmental agency, the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB).
3. SOX made changes to…...

Similar Documents

Audit Report and Internal Control Evaluation

...------------------------------------------------- To: The Board of Directors and Shareholders of Apollo Shoes Inc. From: CBA Auditing Firm Re: Audit Report and Internal Control Evaluation Date: June 10, 2013 CBA Auditing Firm has audited the balance sheets of Apollo Shoes as of December 31, 2012. In addition, our auditing firms also reviewed statements of income such as shareholders equity, comprehensive income, and cash flows for the same period. Our company also assessed Apollo Shoes financial reporting internal controls based on the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO criteria) and determined that they are adequate and effective for the period ending December 31, 2012. Apollo Shoes Inc. management holds sole responsibility for maintaining effective internal controls, validity of their financial statements. CBA Auditing responsibility is only to reflect an opinion on management’s assessment, the company’s internal controls, and the financial statements based on the results of our Audit. Our audit was conducted in accordance with the standards set by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. These standards require for our organization to prepare and execute the inspection to attain reasonable assurance of whether Apollo Shoes Inc. financial statements are without material misstatements and determine if the internal controls are effective enough over financial reporting for all material aspects. Our audits provide a...

Words: 542 - Pages: 3

Sarbane Oxley Act

... allowing investigation process become easy when are asking questions. 4. Process is a whistleblower policy that instructed employee where to take their claim. Such as taking the information to their higher manager or external parties. Or they other processing method could be including telephone, email, hotlines, website and suggestion that employee could report information to. Conclusion: In 1989 The Whistleblower Protection Act was passed and amended in 1994, to protect any Federal Employees from a worked place from retaliation when they disclosed any fraud. In addition,Whistleblower policies should prevent discrimination or retaliation against employee who reports the problem. Whistleblowing policies help to increase awareness within company, universities, corporates, and non-profit organization in preventing fraud internally and externally. This paper suggests that company and organization should detect fraud by making certain procedure such as a set of clear standard from the begnning, control and audititor who is reviewing and approve sensitive documents.The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (SOX) had shaped the way of our corporate and government businesses. Company had lost billion dollars every year due to frauds, money laundry, kickback and etc. The article is about introducing Whistleblowing policy and increasing awareness to companies, universities, corporate and nonprofit organizations. It also highlights the important of the component of the......

Words: 923 - Pages: 4

Evaluation of Secondary and Primary Research

...Marketing Report Assignment 1 MBA7003 Assignment 1: Marketing Research Report “Evaluation of Secondary and Primary Research” Student Name: Rana Ahmed Saeed Khan Student Number: ST20027073 Course Title: Module Title: MBA Marketing Module number: MBA 7003 Module tutor: Katherine Mutter Submission details: To be submitted on 18th April 2013 Marketing Report Assignment 1 MBA7003 Table of Contents S no. Topics Page 01 1. Introduction………………………………………………………………………... 2. Primary Research…………………………………………………………………. 01 3. Secondary Research……………………………………………………………… 01 4. Value and weaknesses of Secondary research carried out…………………… 03 5. How primary research may be used to supplement the secondary research…03 6. Research report on UK mobile market…………………..…………………..……..03 7. Conclusion…………………..…………………..…………………..……………….. 04 8. References…………………..…………………..…………………..……………….. 04 Marketing Report Assignment 1 MBA7003 1. Introduction: The report analyzes various aspects of primary research and offers an understanding of how secondary research can be used to supplement it. Merits and demerits of primary and secondary research are discussed in academic and marketing terms. 2. Primary Research: Primary research is developed by researchers by witnessing first hand sources without using their own analysis, interpretation and opinions. It usually includes diaries, speeches, autobiographies, interviews and newspapers or magazines (University...

Words: 1155 - Pages: 5

Industrialization After the Civil War Research Paper

...Assignment 1.2: Research Paper Industrialization after the Civil War Shana Dukes History 105 Professor Tracey M. Biagas February 3. 2014 Introduction Industrialization after the Civil War was a period where Industrial city were being built, there were jobs for people and the political aspect was having corruption. In this paper the main points in this paper discussed the major aspects of the Industrialization Revolution, such as groups that were affected by the Industrial society, and the affects the life of the average working American. While the Industrial Revolution was a great turning point in the history of mankind, it led humanity to great technological advancements, middle and lower class, African American rights, woman equal rights, and many others. Three Aspects of the Industrial Revolution Three major aspects of the Industrial Revolution during 1865 to 1920 influenced society, economy, and politics. Society was a major aspect of Industrialization because companies were being built, railways was distributing goods to different states (Arrington, 2013). Also, a lot of people were moving from the South and farm areas to the Northern urban areas. Iron and steel had become more vital to the Industrialization of America, and the United States was becoming more Industrialized and less agricultural (Gilder Lehrman Institute, 2009). The society worked in factories to earn money; they also worked at steel plants, and other jobs. Society played a major...

Words: 1315 - Pages: 6

Audit Report and Control Evaluation

...The Audit Report and Internal Control Evaluation University of Phoenix Michelle Melville Auditing/ACC 546 April 21, 2014 Professor Hillary Edmondson Auditor’s Responsibility for Detecting and Reporting Fraud It is the responsibility of the audit engaged in the audit process to detect material misstatement in management’s assertions. These material misstatements must also be properly reported. Arens et. al (2012) defined fraud as “…any intentional deceit meant to deprive another person or party of their property or rights” p 433. Fraud as it relates to financial reporting is the intentional misstatements of the company’s financial statements and the misappropriations of the company’s assets. In conducting the audit, the audit company needs to be able to identify whether the conditions for fraud, as indicated by Arenet. al (2012) exists. These conditions are; incentives or pressures, opportunities, and attitudes or rationalizations. The existence of certain factors help the auditor to identify whether the conditions for fraud exists. According to SAS 99 auditors are required to enter into the audit engagement with professional skepticism, a questioning mind, and must critically examine and evaluate audit evidence using audit procedures. In using professional skepticism the auditor must never assume the honesty or dishonesty with management reporting. The conditions for rationalization may cause even the most honest person to make allowances for committing...

Words: 404 - Pages: 2

Res 341 (Research and Evaluation) Complete Course

...RES 341 (Research and Evaluation) Complete Course IF You Want To Purchase A+ Work Then Click The Link Below , Instant Download http://hwnerd.com/RES-341-Research-and-Evaluation-Complete-Course-1508.htm?categoryId=-1 If You Face Any Problem E- Mail Us At Contact.Hwnerd@Gmail.Com Research and Evaluation I Week 1: Individual Assignment: Current Business Research Project Paper • Use the University Library or the Electronic Reserve Readings to locate a peer-reviewed article that reports original research. • Search "major databases (e.g. - ProQuest)" in the Online Collection, and use the key search words, "research studies in" to obtain an article. You can select communication, finance, economics, marketing, technology, or another faculty approved topic for the research study. • Write a 350- to 700-word synopsis of the article, including the following: • Define the business research and its purpose.• Explain the business problems under investigation.• Describe the data collection methods used in the research project.• What did the researchers conclude as a result of their research? Week 2: Individual Assignment: Research Terminology Matching Assignment • Resource: Research Terminology Matching Assignment• Complete the Research Terminology Matching Assignment located on your student website. Learning Team Assignment: Research Process Paper • Resources: Data sets available on your student website • Identify a research issue...

Words: 2154 - Pages: 9

Audit Report and Internal Control Evaluation

...Audit Report and Internal Control Evaluation Nathalie Salib University of Phoenix ACC546/PR April 9, 2015 Prof. Rafael Marrero - Diaz ANDERSON, OLDS & WATERSHED Certified Public Accountants Independent Auditor’s Report To the Board of Directors of Apollo Shoes, Inc. We have audited the accompanying balance sheets of Apollo Shoes, Inc. as of December 31, 2007 and 2006 and the related statements of income, shareholder’s equity and cash flow for the two years in the period ended December 31, 2007. Apollo Shoes’ management is responsible for the financial statements presented, for maintaining effective internal control over financial reporting, and for its assessment of internal control. Our responsibility is to express an opinion on these financial statements, an opinion on management’s assessment, and an opinion on the effectiveness of the company’s internal control over financial reporting based on our audits. We conducted our audits in accordance with the standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States). Those standards require that we plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements are free of material misstatement and whether effective internal control over financial reporting was maintained in all material respects. Our audit of the financial statements including examining, on a test basis, evidence supporting the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements, assessing...

Words: 939 - Pages: 4

Res 341 (Research and Evaluation) Complete Course

...RES 341 (Research and Evaluation) Complete Course IF You Want To Purchase A+ Work Then Click The Link Below , Instant Download http://hwnerd.com/RES-341-Research-and-Evaluation-Complete-Course-1508.htm?categoryId=-1 If You Face Any Problem E- Mail Us At Contact.Hwnerd@Gmail.Com Research and Evaluation I Week 1: Individual Assignment: Current Business Research Project Paper • Use the University Library or the Electronic Reserve Readings to locate a peer-reviewed article that reports original research. • Search "major databases (e.g. - ProQuest)" in the Online Collection, and use the key search words, "research studies in" to obtain an article. You can select communication, finance, economics, marketing, technology, or another faculty approved topic for the research study. • Write a 350- to 700-word synopsis of the article, including the following: • Define the business research and its purpose.• Explain the business problems under investigation.• Describe the data collection methods used in the research project.• What did the researchers conclude as a result of their research? Week 2: Individual Assignment: Research Terminology Matching Assignment • Resource: Research Terminology Matching Assignment• Complete the Research Terminology Matching Assignment located on your student website. Learning Team Assignment: Research Process Paper • Resources: Data sets available on your student website • Identify a research issue...

Words: 2154 - Pages: 9

Acc546 Week 3 Audit Report and Internal Control Evaluation Cc 546 Week 3 Audit Report and Internal Control Evaluation

... materiality and risk in designing the audit. * Explanation as to how technology will be incorporated into the audit * Engagement checklist * Rough Draft Engagement letter * Outline of timeframes and milestones for the audit Click the Assignment Files tab to submit your assignment. ACC 546 Week 2 Learning Team Charter Complete the Learning Team Charter and post in the assignment section ACC 546 Week 3 Audit Report and Internal Control Evaluation Evaluate the evidence provided by Apollo Shoes.  Decide how to structure the audit report for the provided evidence.  Compose an audit report reflecting the appropriate length, sections, and content for the provided information but no more than 1,400. In addition to the Audit Report, include the following:  * A description of the evidence * A description of the accounting sampling and testing procedures used * A rationale as to why the type of audit report selected was chosen and the value of the audit report.  **Use Ch. 3 of Auditing and Assurance Services to complete the assignment.   Click the Assignment Files tab to submit your assignment. ACC 546 Week 3 Weekly Summary Discuss this week's assignments and learning objectives in the Learning Team Forum.  Write a summary of your team's discussion and submit your summary to the Assignments link by Day 7. Include a title page that indicates that each member of the team has substantively participated in the discussions. ACC 546 Week 4 Audit Report Section......

Words: 898 - Pages: 4

Acc546 Week 3 Audit Report and Internal Control Evaluation Cc 546 Week 3 Audit Report and Internal Control Evaluation

... materiality and risk in designing the audit. * Explanation as to how technology will be incorporated into the audit * Engagement checklist * Rough Draft Engagement letter * Outline of timeframes and milestones for the audit Click the Assignment Files tab to submit your assignment. ACC 546 Week 2 Learning Team Charter Complete the Learning Team Charter and post in the assignment section ACC 546 Week 3 Audit Report and Internal Control Evaluation Evaluate the evidence provided by Apollo Shoes.  Decide how to structure the audit report for the provided evidence.  Compose an audit report reflecting the appropriate length, sections, and content for the provided information but no more than 1,400. In addition to the Audit Report, include the following:  * A description of the evidence * A description of the accounting sampling and testing procedures used * A rationale as to why the type of audit report selected was chosen and the value of the audit report.  **Use Ch. 3 of Auditing and Assurance Services to complete the assignment.   Click the Assignment Files tab to submit your assignment. ACC 546 Week 3 Weekly Summary Discuss this week's assignments and learning objectives in the Learning Team Forum.  Write a summary of your team's discussion and submit your summary to the Assignments link by Day 7. Include a title page that indicates that each member of the team has substantively participated in the discussions. ACC 546 Week 4 Audit Report Section......

Words: 898 - Pages: 4

Audit Research After Sarbanes-Oxley Evaluation

...EVALUATION OF REASEARCH PAPER Title: Audit Research after Sarbanes-Oxley Author: Mark L. DeFond and Jere R. Francis A. Describe the research problem or question. Evaluate the importance of the research question to audit practice. This paper attempts to stimulate research into some of the important questions implicitly raised by SOX regarding the audit profession’s potential failings. Enron’s failure and the accounting scandals at Worldcom and other companies provide compelling evidence that auditing matters and is important. However, it is unclear that whether auditing was sufficiently “broken” in the first place to warrant the radical reforms and changes effected by the SOX. The disconnection is large between the scientific evidence on audit quality and institutional changes premised on the assumption that auditing is broken. This research gives us the direction which we need to collect scientific evidence to guide public policy-making in audit. B. Explain the author’s approach to solving the problem. The authors discuss the following areas and give some suggestions for future research in each of them: 1. Why auditing matters now more than ever 2. Institutions that affect auditing 3. Engagement-specific characteristics that affect audit quality 4. The role of auditing and corporate governance 5. Audit quality and other accounting firm characteristics C. Describe the major findings of the research. 1. The criticism embodied in SOX is usually intense, and...

Words: 681 - Pages: 3

Evaluation of Research Paper- When Bonding Fails: Audit Firm Oversight of Us-Listed Chinese Companies

...EVALUATION OF RESEARCH PAPER Title: When Bonding Fails: Audit Firm Oversight of US-Listed Chinese Companies Date: 15/11/23 Author: Joseph V. Carcello, Brian T. Carver, Clive S. Lennox, Terry L. Neal A. Describe the research problem or question. Evaluate the importance of the research question to audit practice. First, this paper composed by Joseph V. Carcello et al describes the traditional bonding argument failed for US-listed Chinese companies due to a lack of audit quality and audit firm oversight. Last, we think that there are two importance of what the paper relates to audit practice. One is that the study can implicate outside investors may be hit twice as a result of information asymmetry. Another is whether there are any omission or inadequate regulations need to amend due to transnational factors. B. Explain the author’s approach to solving the problem. This paper’s authors, Joseph V. Carcello et al used experimental designing and event studying to argue that the traditional bonding argument failed for US-listed Chinese companies due to a lack of audit quality and audit firm oversight. And, authors do provide descriptive evidence on the following research question: Which parties are most likely to detect financial reporting fraud and other accounting improprieties among the US-listed Chinese companies?(RQ1) because they didn’t test it. C. Describe the major findings of the research. The result of this paper find two...

Words: 646 - Pages: 3

After

...After watching the video of the Student Resource Officer Deputy Ben Fields and the South Carolina student, I believe there are some valid reasons why this instance occurred. One reason being the teacher saw the student on her cell phone and asked her to put her phone away because there were no cell phones allowed in the class. This student defied the teachers order and continued to disrupt the class. The teacher asked her to leave and she refused therefore, the teacher called the assistant principal and again the student refused to leave the classroom. At this point the assistant principal called the SRO Deputy Ben Fields to contain the situation. Deputy Fields came into the classroom and spoke to the 16-year-old first stating “I treat you fair last year, right” the 16-year-old responded “I don’t know you.” Deputy Fields responded “you don’t know me? Deputy Fields then stated to the 16-year-old “I need you to come with me or I’m gonna make you.” The 16-year-old is heard saying “no” and Deputy Fields is also heard saying “C’mon, I am gonna get you up.” Deputy Fields, the teacher, and the assistant principal were all trying to get this 16-year-old to cooperate with them but she refused to obey with authority. Deputy Fields was allowed to use force because of this 16-year-old non-cooperation with authority. The Sheriff Lott, is quoted saying a student disrupts a classroom, disrupts the education process as well. When teachers are not allowed to teach, students cannot learn...

Words: 1064 - Pages: 5

The Quality of Financial Reporting After the Passage of Sarbanes-Oxley a

... Behavior Following the Sarbanese-Oxley Act. Journal of Accounting, Auditing & Finance, Winter2010, Vol. 25 Issue 1, p1-26, 26p, 7 Charts; (AN 48376500)   Subjects: AUDITORS; ACCOUNTANTS; AUDITORS' reports; FINANCIAL statements; UNITED States; UNITED States. Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002; Offices of Certified Public Accountants. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 And its Effects on American Business Lara Bergen Financial Services Forum College of Management University of Massachusetts Boston June 2005 Ball, R. and L. Shivakumar. 2005. Earnings quality in UK private firms: comparative loss recognition timeliness. Journal of Accounting and Economics 39 (1): 83-128. Becker, C., M. DeFond, J. Jiambalvo, and K. R. Subramanyam. 1998. The effect of audit quality on earnings management. Contemporary Accounting Research 15 (Spring): 1-24. Beckett, P. 2002. New SEC order forces executives to swear by their numbers. The Wall Street Journal, July 5. Browning, E.S. 2002. Dow Industrials decline after soaring on Friday. www.wsj.com July 9. Burgstahler, D. and I. Dichev. 1997. Earnings management to avoid earnings decreases and losses. Journal of Accounting and Economics 24 (1): 99-126. Cohen, D., A. Dey and T. Lys. 2007. Real and Accrual-based Earnings Management in the Preand Post-Sarbanes Oxley Periods. Working Paper. New York University, University of Chicago and Northwestern University. Dechow, P., R. Sloan, and A. Sweeney. 1995. Detecting earnings management. The Accounting......

Words: 2960 - Pages: 12

Evaluation of Research

...Evaluation of Research Today with a lot of information available in different format and forms it is very critical to have it evaluated properly in order to present credible research. To provide reliable, relevant, and bias free information the students should carefully review research to ensure that it meets the guidelines for writing. To make sure that the information is credible or reliable the students should pay attention “to proof of facts” (Litman, 2011, p. 7). Credibility of information depends on facts, statistics, and evidence; also, the students have to make sure that information agrees with personal knowledge and with other specialists in the field. In addition it is very important to see the publication of the source, either it “scholarly or peer-reviewed” (Litman, 2011, p. 7). According to Bell (2009), these article are written by researches and practitioners in particular subject areas and information includes footnotes, bibliography, or references. Another important aspect on searching is making sure that the information bias free. The students have to make sure that this “information has balanced presentation of opposing perspectives” (Litman, 2011, p. 7). In any publicity the author should not make any point of view critically. The reader should be responsible making his or her own decision on a particular topic. To make sure that the author uses proper tone of language in publication also make a major role on bias free information (Bell, 2009). Not...

Words: 437 - Pages: 2