Premium Essay

Audit

In: Business and Management

Submitted By AlyshaJ
Words 3860
Pages 16
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN INTERNAL
AND EXTERNAL AUDIT
Professor PhD Atanasiu Pop, „Babeş-Bolyai” University of Cluj-Napoca, e-mail: apop@econ.ubblcuj.ro
PhD Student Cristina Boţa-Avram, „Babeş-Bolyai” University of Cluj-Napoca, e-mail: botaavram@gmail.com PhD Student Florin Boţa-Avram, „Babeş Bolyai” University of Cluj-Napoca, e-mail: botaavramflorin@yahoo.com ABSTRACT: Analyzing the evolution process of internal audit, from its beginnings and so far, we can easily notice that internal audit function was born through detaching of some activities from external audit, the result being that there some situations when these two functions could be easily confused. The reality is that internal audit and external audit are two distinctive functions; net differenced, but which are also characterized through some complementary relationships. In this paper, we try to give our contribution at the clarification of the similarities and differences between these two functions, making a literature review that allowed us to identify some very interesting studies that permitted us to emphasize the main criterions that influenced the relationship between internal audit and external audit.
Keywords: internal audit, external audit, objectivity, competence

JEL Codes: M42
1. Introduction
The coordination of internal audit activity with external audit activity is very important from both points of view: from external audit’s point of view is important because, in this way, external auditors have the possibility to raise the efficiency of financial statements audit; the relevancy from internal audit’s point of view is assured by the fact that this coordination assures for the internal audit a plus of essential information in the assessment of risks control (Dobroţeanu, L.&
Dobroţeanu C.L., 2002).
The importance of the relationship from internal audit and external...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Audit

...Ethical threats Self-interest threat It occurs when auditor could benefit from a financial interest in an audit client. Self review threat It occurs when the audit from a member or audit team put itself in a position of reviewing the subject that previously the member is responsible Familiarity threat It occurs when auditor has a close relationship with the client Advocacy threat It occurs when the audit from a member of the audit team promotes/support or may be perceived to promote an audit client’s position or opinion. Intimidation threat It occurs when a member of the audit team may be deterred from acting objectivity and exercising professional judgment due to pressure given by the audit client to terminate the service. Auditors have an obligation to disclose -where the courts order them to do so -where they suspect their client...

Words: 6177 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

Audit

...INTERNAL AUDITING AS AN EFFECTIVE TOOL FOR CORPORATE GOVERNANCE This journal of JBM International Science Press, examines the study of the relationship between internal audit and corporate governance with various argumentations of internal audit activities, attempting to sketch out their relationship. It analyses the contribution of internal audit to corporate governance. Based on what I found in the journal and my opinion, this journal have emphasized the importance of internal audit which is really compulsory for every company to follow as it improves the efficiency and effectiveness of the management and company. Moreover it also have mentioned that the relationship and communication between employer and management is important in internal control which is an effective idea on maintaining employer’s loyalty and reduce fraud. But this journal less focus on the disadvantage of internal control if it is not handled wisely which is really need to be considered before implementing internal audit control system. The journal have explained well on how the internal control benefits the company but as an auditor or a manager, one should also consider the disadvantage that might be faced by the company from internal audit control.  Internal audit control systems have a few weaknesses that business owners must address. First, broad application....

Words: 917 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Audit

...Queensland University of Technology Faculty of Business School of Accountancy AYN411 Audit & Assurance – Semester 1, 2013 Final Exam Revision Questions Additional Resources AYN411 Audit & Assurance – Semester 1, 2013 Final Exam Revision Questions Additional Resources Final Exam Revision QUESTION 1 – Audit Planning a. The Auditing Standard ASA 300 ‘Planning an Audit of a Financial Report’ states that the auditor needs to plan the audit so it will be performed in an effective way, by establishing the overall audit strategy for the audit and developing the overall audit plan. Required: List four benefits to the auditor in properly planning an audit engagement. L3 (slide 28) Properly planning an audit engagement helps the auditor to: * Devote appropriate attention to important areas of the audit * Identify and resolve potential problems on a timely basis * Properly organise and manage the audit engagement efficiently * Select an engagement team with appropriate expertise * Facilitate supervision of the engagement team members (inc. review of work) * Co-ordinate work done by auditors and experts * Render the correct audit report b. The following is a list of four activities carried out by the auditor during the planning phase of the audit. Planning Procedure 1. Client acceptance/continuance decision 2. Obtain an understanding of the entity and it’s environment 3....

Words: 1980 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Audit

...The auditors should communicate so that the team maintains an independent state of mind at all times during the audit. The audit approach and tests/procedures are customized to the fraud assessment made. The audit team can incorporate random testing and sampling approach in the audit work which are difficult to anticipate by the client. Also the team understands where the focus will be as a result of the fraud assessment b. Theft of personal property from the business for the purposes of depriving the owner of its possession is a method of fraud referred to as lapping. Disagreed. Lapping refers to misappropriation of cash receipts. The theft is concealed by manipulation of A/R to cover the cash receipts. The cash received later is recorded toward the original A/R. The fraud is also covered by recording cash transfers to rare expenses or other accounts in G/L. c. A critical evaluation of evidence and professional skepticism are required for all financial statement audits, fraud examinations, and financial forensic examinations. Agreed. A critical evaluation of evidence is required to ensure that what has been stated is not misrepresented. Professional skepticism ensures that the auditor is alert and with a questionable mind to situations which indicate possible misstatements due to error or fraud. d. A client...

Words: 2277 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

The Audit

...Chapter 1 Introduction to Audit & Assurance Engagements Difference between ACCOUNTING and AUDITING • Accounting – preparing financial statements • Auditing – examining financial statements Financial Statements Consist of: • A statement of financial position • A statement of profit or loss • A cash flow statements • Notes to the financial statements • Statement of movement in reserves Together with the documents above, companies also produce director’s reports, chairman’s statements, graphs, forecasts and public relations material and combine the whole lot into their annual report. The annual report will also include the auditors’ report. For large companies this is often a glossy booklet designed to impress shareholders and potential investors. However, the audit report covers only the financial statements, not the other documents that might be included, but the auditor need to examine some of the other documents as well. Assurance Engagements An assurance engagement is when a professional examines information for which another party is preparing. 1. Audit engagement • Means external audit • It is a form of assurance engagement 2....

Words: 1419 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Audit

...AUDIT TUTORIAL 5 MCQ 1. D 2. B 3. A 4. D SHORT QUESTION 1) The benefits that auditor derives from planning audits are * Helping the auditor to devote appropriate attention to important areas of the audit. * Helping the auditor identify and resolve potential problems on a timely basis. * Helping the auditor properly organize and manage the audit engagement so that it is performed in an effective and efficient manner. * Assisting in the selection of engagement team members with appropriate levels of capabilities and competence to respond to anticipated risks, and the proper assignment of work to them. * Facilitating the direction and supervision of engagement team members and the review of their work. * Assisting, where applicable, in coordination of work done by auditors of components and experts. (Slide 4) 2) The auditor shall obtain an understanding of the following: (a) Relevant industry, regulatory, and other external factors including the applicable financial reporting framework....

Words: 1070 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Audit

...University of Phoenix Material Audit and Business Structure Worksheet Write a response of no more than 150 words for each the following questions: |Compare a review and an audit. What are the differences? What are the similarities? | |The accounting information is the target of the audit. It is a measure to check internal control and financial reporting of the company. | |This entails a plan of action and systematic steps to consistently audit a business. The audit is an objective process of evaluating the | |statements the company makes about its economic condition. It also determines if the company followed the proper procedures in communicating| |the financial results to its users. | |In a review, the accountant receives limited assurance of no material modification made to financial statements. A review is generally | |completed for banks or potential purchasures that a mainly looking for comfort in the financial statement....

Words: 587 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Audit

...ACCT 4304, Fall 2014 Audit case Read the attached audit case and answer all the questions that follow. A total of 90 points are available for the actual responses to the questions and 10 points are available for presentation, clarity and grammar. Total points for the assignment are 100. Note: Answer the questions as comprehensively as possible. Reference to Auditing Standards, your textbook, and other relevant authoritative sources is expected where appropriate. Even where some of the questions are quite general, try as much as possible to relate your answer to the case. 1. Some of the members of Phar-Mor's financial management team were former auditors for Coopers & Lybrand. (a) Why would a company want to hire a member of its external audit team? (3pts) (b) If the client has hired former auditors, would this affect the independence of the existing external auditors? Explain. (3pts) (c) How did the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 and related rulings by the PCAOB, SEC or AICPA affect a public company's ability to hire members of its external audit team? (3pts) 2 (a) What factors in the auditor-client relationship can put the client in a more powerful position than the auditor? (3pts) A) A client can be put in a more powerful position than the auditor in an auditor-client relationship if the auditor is trying to sell the client additional services. ...

Words: 2003 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Audit

...Dalam audit yang pertama kali terhadap laporan keuangan klien, tidaklah mudah memperkirakan reaksi yang mungkin diberikan oleh klien terhadap jurnal adjustment yang diusulkan. Dalam audit berikutnya, auditor akan dengan mudah memperkirakan reaksi klien terhadap jurnal yang diusulkan. Copy daftar ringkasan jurnal adjustment tersebut diserahkan kepada klien untuk dibicarakan. Jika klien menyetujui jurnal adjustment yang diusulkan...

Words: 1244 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Audit

...One of this relates to the internal auditor reporting to the audit committee rather than to management. Required: (i) Please explain as to why this is an important condition to be met (2 Marks) (ii) Provide three benefits of the audit committee in enhancing governance (6 Marks) (Total: 8 Marks) Question 2: In your preliminary assessment of control risk, you have assessed it as low. In undertaking your tests of control you note that the results fail to confirm your preliminary assessed level of control risk. Required: Explain the impact this would have on your audit plan. (Total: 3 Marks) Question 3: The sales system of John limited is as follows. John Ltd is a wholesaler of office supplies and sells them to a number of retail outlets (customers) in the Perth region on credit. Its prices are competitive and it offers a same day delivery service for orders telephoned before noon. The sales cycle relative to the phone ordering, despatch of goods and update of ledger are as follows: i. The customer phones through an order to the sales department which raises a sales order and two invoice copies which are priced and totalled. This is forwarded to the despatch department. ii.The despatch department makes up the orders and gives the goods to the driver with the two invoice copies of the order. iii. The driver delivers the goods, provides the customer with one copy of the invoice and returns with the other copy of the invoice. iv....

Words: 398 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Audit

...Internal control, internal audit and risk management Internal control is under the Board of Director's responsibility. Internal control's function is, among other things, to ensure the efficiency and profitability of operations, the reliability of information, and adhering to rules and regulations. Internal control is a part of day-to-day management and company administration.   An essential part of internal control is the Internal Audit, which operates as a separate unit under the CEO and reports its observations to the Board of Directors. The Internal Audit supports the Group's/ Company’s management in directing operations by inspecting and evaluating the efficiency of business operations, risk management and internal control, and by producing information and recommendations to enhance efficiency. The Internal Audit also inspects the processes of business operations and financial reporting. Internal Audit's directive have to be approved by the Group’s / Company’s Board of Directors. The operations of the Internal Audit are guided by being risk-focused and emphasizing the development of business operations. Risk management The goal of risk management is to secure the Group's / Company’s earnings development and to ensure that the Group/Company operates without any disturbances by controlling risks in a cost efficient and systematic manner in all divisions/departments....

Words: 684 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Audit

.... • There must be a breach of duty of care (failure to follow GAAS, negligent audit). • There must be proof that the party suffered a loss or damage • There must be a connection between the party’s loss or damage and the breach of the duty. Question A HHH Company’s Case • HHH hired the auditors; therefore the auditors owe a duty of case to the shareholders. • The shareholders would have to show that the auditors were negligent in their audit, that is, the auditor issued an unqualified report even though there is a misstatement in the financial statements. • HHH lost its investment in the commodities • HHH shareholders would have to show that they suffered the loss due to the auditor’s negligence. Question A • Each store is managed by an owner of the business, which suggests that an external audit is not required. • The company is not public, so there is no statutory requirement for an audit. • If the company borrows from an outside source, then an external audit may be a requirement by the lender. • The existing shareholders are already creditors of the company, and they may wish to have an audit. Question B • Collusion requires 2 or more people to work together to circumvent the controls. In this case, the 2 purchasing clerks could have colluded by having 1 clerk record a false vendor number on the invoice and then the other clerk prepare the payment to M. Smith. • This is an example of management override....

Words: 683 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Audit

...Nonsampling error occurs when audit tests do not uncover errors that exist in the sample. Nonsampling error can result from: 1. The auditor's failure to recognize exceptions, or 2. Inappropriate or ineffective audit procedures. There are two ways to reduce sampling risk: 1. Increase sample size. 2. Use an appropriate method of selecting sample items from the population. Careful design of audit procedures and proper supervision and review are ways to reduce nonsampling risk. 15-24 a. (4) b. (3) c. (2) 16-20 a. (4) b. (4) c. (2) 16-21 a. (4) b. (2) c. (2) 16-22 a. (2) b. (1) 16-24 a. BALANCE-RELATED AUDIT OBJECTIVE b. PREVENTIVE INTERNAL CONTROL c. TESTS OF DETAILS OF BALANCES AUDIT PROCEDURES 1. Existing accounts receivable are included in the aged trial balance (com- pleteness). The accounts receivable master file should be reconciled to the control account periodically by an independent person. Foot the aged trial balance and compare the total to the general ledger. Trace a sample of accounts from the master file to the aged trial balance to determine if all are included. 2. Accounts receivable exist (existence). The accounts receivable master file should be reconciled to the control account periodically by an independent person. Foot the aged trial balance and compare the total to the general ledger. Trace from the aged trial balance to the master file, looking for duplicates. 3....

Words: 1290 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Audit

...Audit Committee Material Weaknesses in Smaller Reporting Companies December 2nd, 2010 OUTLINE: I. SUMMARY OF THE ARTICLE II. PROBLEM STATEMENT III. SUGGESTIONS FROM THE AUTHORS IV. RELEVANCE TO AUDITING ENVIRONMENT V. CONCLUSION I. Summary of the Article This report summarizes the article published by Gramling, Audrey A, Hermanson, Dana R, Hermanson, Heather M in the CPA journal of 2009. The main focus of the article is to show the importance of audit committee in auditing and analyze problems of small companies face in developing effective audit committee. The critical issue of the article is material weaknesses related to audit committee and possibility of management’s override of internal control within small companies. Before, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, audit committees in public companies were under more pressure to understand not just a company's financial statements, but to challenge management and auditors on key accounting, internal control and compliance issues. After the financial scandals that caused firms like Enron and WorldCom to collapse, audit committees have risen from relative darkness to center stage in modern corporate world. As it’s indicated in the article, the new role, the typical audit committee is charged with many duties....

Words: 1917 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Audit

...Enter The Marketing Audit One hears more talk today about the marketing audit as...

Words: 6893 - Pages: 28