Premium Essay

Auditing Cases

In: Business and Management

Submitted By hamgod78
Words 162000
Pages 648
Auditing Cases instructor resource Manual

f our th

e d itio n

Mark S. Beasley Frank A. Buckless Steven M. Glover Douglas F. Prawitt do not coPy or redistribute
Prentice hall
Upper Saddle River, New Jersey

ta b l e s e ct ion

o f

co n t e n t s

1 2

client acceptance
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

S o l u tionS inc lu de d in t h iS Section 1.1

Ocean Manufacturing, Inc.


The New Client Acceptance Decision

s e ct ion

Understanding the Client’s Business and assessing risk
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13

S o l u tionS inc lu de d in t h iS Section 2.1

Evaluating eBusiness Revenue Recognition, Information Privacy, and Electronic Evidence Issues
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25

2.2 2.3 2.4

Dell Computer Corporation
Evaluation of Client Business Risk

Flash Technologies, Inc. Asher Farms Inc.

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39

Risk Analysis and Resolution of Client Issues
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49

Understanding of Client’s Business Environment

s e ct ion


Professional and ethical issues
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 59

S o l u tio nS inc lu de d in t h iS Section 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5

A Day in the Life of Brent Dorsey
Staff Auditor Professional Pressures

Nathan Johnson’s Rental Car Reimbursement
Solving Ethical Dilemmas–Should He Pocket the Cash? Recognizing It’s a Fraud and Evaluating What to Do

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 63

The Anonymous Caller WorldCom

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71

The Story of a Whistleblower
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 79…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Auditing Case

...Summary of Method Consistency With Other DOE Risking Efforts Challenges and Benefits of Risk Estimation and Interpretation Conclusions Recommendations Risk Assessment Participants The Geothermal Risk Analysis Team The Geothermal Expert Team GETEM Reference Cases and Input Organization The GETEM Model Reference Cases The GETEM Model Input Variables Geothermal Technology Improvement Opportunities Risk Cases Considered Geothermal Expert Team Scoring Matrices Suggested Scoring Process for the Expert Team MYPP Cases Scoring Changes Made to Experts Inputs 1 4 5 5 5 7 8 9 9 9 11 11 11 13 19 19 27 27 28 iii Summary of Results Case-Specific Results Hydrothermal Binary 2010 Experts Case Hydrothermal Flash 2010 Experts Case EGS Binary 2010 Experts Case EGS Flash 2010 Experts Case EGS Binary 2040 Evolutionary Experts Case Hydrothermal Binary 2010 MYPP Case EGS Binary 2010 MYPP Case Appendix A: Hydrothermal Binary Power System Case – Inputs Appendix B: Hydrothermal Flashed-Steam Power System Case – Inputs Appendix C: EGS Binary Power System Case – Inputs Appendix D: EGS Flashed-Steam Power System Case – Inputs Appendix E: Consensus Expert Team Scoring Matrices Appendix F: Cumulative Probability Distribution Functions of LCOE by Case 30 32 33 35 37 39 41 43 45 A-1 B-1 C-1 D-1 E-1 F-1 iv Executive Summary This report introduces the development and first use of a management tool for risk analysis for the Geothermal Technologies Program (GTP, “the Program”) of the U.S.......

Words: 40141 - Pages: 161

Premium Essay

Auditing Cases

...enron corporation and andersen, llP analyzing the fall of two giants inS tr uc t ional o b je c t ive S [1] c a s e 4.1 Mark S. Beasley · Frank A. Buckless · Steven M. Glover · Douglas F. Prawitt [2] [3] To help students understand what happened at Enron Corporation and how Andersen’s involvement with Enron led to the accounting firm’s downfall. To enhance students’ appreciation of the importance of understanding an audit client’s core business strategies. To develop students’ understanding of the role of confidence, reputation, and trust both in the corporate and auditing professions. [4] [5] [6] To provide a venue for exploring professional issues relating to auditor independence and the provision of non-audit services for clients. To introduce students to the current debate on rules- versus principles-based accounting standards and related implications for the auditing profession. To actively involve students in considering the challenges facing the accounting profession and in evaluating alternative courses of action for overcoming these obstacles. KEY FACTS ƒƒ Enron entered the year 2001 as the seventh largest public company in the U.S., only to exit the year as the largest company to ever declare bankruptcy in U.S. history (until WorldCom’s bankruptcy in 2002 later claimed the record). ƒƒ Enron engaged in very aggressive accounting approaches, including the establishment of special purpose entities (SPEs), the intent of which appears......

Words: 33542 - Pages: 135

Premium Essay

Mr. Friehling – a Future Auditing Case Study

...David Friehling will quite possibly be a future case study in auditing textbooks and courses throughout the United States. Mr. Friehling was the auditor for Bernard Madoff, who was recently convicted of running the largest Ponzi scheme ever uncovered through his business, Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities, LLC (BMIS). Mr. Madoff claimed to actively oversee more than $65 billion in private investments (it was later revealed that roughly $823 million remained of the more than $170 billion that went through his accounts over the years).(1) Mr. Friehling flagrantly and purposely violated provisions of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants’ Code of Professional Conduct,(2) Generally Accepted Auditing Standards,(3) promulgations of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board and Securities and Exchange Commission, and other applicable laws, regulations, rules, and guidelines. Mr. Friehling is a former Certified Public Accountant in New York State; he had a modest office with a total of three employees in suburban New City, NY. Mr. Madoff claimed to manage $65 billion in resources…how could what was essentially a one-person practice audit financial statements of that magnitude? The blatantly obvious answer is that Mr. Friehling could not. After accepting an engagement, the initial task for any CPA firm would be to establish an audit plan, which would plainly show that many auditors would be required for that type of engagement. There were countless...

Words: 1215 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay


...associated with professionally standard auditing (Olagunju, 2011, pp.85). In other to maintain the utmost standard for the accounting profession, independence is seen as being free from control or pressure and not allowing situations which would tend to weaken objectivity or create personal preconceived notions (Porter and Simon et al., 1996). Audit improves the trustworthiness of the financial statements giving it sensible assertion from an independent source that the financial statements is true and fair in agreement with accounting standards (Olagunju, 2011, pp.85-86). The next section of this essay provides detailed information on how value is added to the financial statement when the auditors’ audit with independence whilst appraising how the accounting profession has or is reacting to auditor independence. While the last section will evaluate the risks or threats to independence and explain ways of mitigating identified risks. Value of Independent Auditing on Financial Statements The significance of audit services will be impaired when independence is absent (Sweeney, 1992); therefore, an uncompromised independence gives a better quality audit to the financial statements (Baber et al., 1995). In addition, if an auditor is independent, the motivation to do a better audit is not undermined as the auditor will report misstatements (Pike, 2003). Stewart (1994) in Porter and Simon et al., (1996), likened independence to the “corner stone of auditing”. This means if the......

Words: 2487 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Auditing Corruption Case

...Corruption Case The case study “Why is this Furniture Falling Apart?” is about Art Metal U.S.A., a furniture manufacture, that had put out “$200 millions of worth of defective and useless that the General Services Administration (GSA) bought.” (Wells, 2011, p. 237) Federal agencies and GSA customers put in several complaints but nothing was done to investigate. After many years of complaints and suspicion of a corruption scheme there were articles written that instigated a congressional investigation. This type of investigation is more thorough than a regular audit and looks into all areas of the financials and operations. The investigation found that there was indeed corruption going on between top management at Art Metals and GSA inspectors. They revealed several unusual payments by reviewing cancelled checks. There were payments in whole numbers to a subcontractor that was cashed rather than deposited and made out to 3 different names. There were also many checks that were made out to “Auction Express” that was all in large and whole amounts. This provided enough reasoning to now look for evidence of a bribery which is when they began looking into GSA inspectors. This is where they discovered a previous inspector’s financial life-style was more than his income. After interviewing an past bookkeeper of Art Metals they had testimony that they did in fact bribe GSA inspectors and they even had a petty cash fund that they used to pay for their meals and hotels.......

Words: 745 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Advanced Auditing Final Review Case Note

...Final Exam Review Practice Case IPI Case: Required: 1. Identify Accounting System Issues * System implementation * Lack of training * I: people try to override the system, inaccurate reporting * R: The company who installed the system needs to be contacted and hold training session for employees * Glitches * I: inaccurate reporting, create room for error * R: Contact the company again and get them back and give them responsibility to fix the glitches 2. Identify Control Issues: * Understaffing people are overworked, may get sloppy * R: Hire more staff * Lack of segregation of duties, bookkeeper does the bank rec and A/R ledger * R: Get someone else to do one of those duties * Mismatch b/w what’s shipped and what’s recorded as revenue since sales reported based on what they are supposed (when order is confirmed for shipment) but Louis goes down to the shipping department and adds a few more COGS is correct but revenue is not * R: Base revenues on actual quantities shipped * Year end cut-off error – Revenue: Takes 3 weeks to get the orders out but actg department records sales based orders * R: System is changed so that revenue is recorded only when shipment is confirmed, send shipping log to the actg department so they know 3. Policy compliance * Costs capitalized to inventory * IPI’s accounting policies state that only the rental......

Words: 1267 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Case 3 Auditing

...Prefab Sprout Construction Company You have been approached about auditing Prefab Sprout Construction Company, a family-run general contracting company which is publicly traded on the New York Stock Exchange. The president of Prefab is Jack Warner. His wife, Joan, is the vice president and his son, John, is the treasurer. The Warner family owns about 40 percent of all outstanding shares and no other investor owns more than 1 percent. The company has been previously audited (receiving standard unqualified opinions) by a sole practitioner who closed his practice and is now the controller of Prefab. The company has an audit committee consisting of Joan, John and a local college professor. The company also has a compensation committee consisting of Jack, the company’s lawyer and an employee selected on a rotating basis. Prefab specializes in modular home developments located in areas of South Florida that are densely populated by retirees and recent immigrants from the Caribbean basin. Prefab acquires land, builds streets and other land improvements, builds modular homes on the land and then sells the entire development to limited partnerships that are set up as tax shelters. Prefab finances most of its construction costs through the Sun Atlantic Bank in Fort Lauderdale. Prefab's condensed financial statements for 2013 (audited) and 2014 (un-audited) are presented below. 2013 2014 Cash Receivables Projects in progress Total assets Bank loans......

Words: 867 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Case #1 - Advanced Auditing

...An anonymous caller seeks help from her former university professor. The caller thinks that the company that he is working for only three and one-half month is committing a fraud. The main reason that the caller is worried is because he is the controller of the company and he has to sign the quarterly statement of his privately-held company. Those quarterly statements are for the bank that his company has the line of credit, those statements have to look good so that the bank approve their credit. There are two big problems in the case. The first one is the as he started on the company he had to sign the closing of the prior fiscal year. If the fraud was being made in the last year, he could be treated like an accessory to the fraud because he signs the statements. The other problem is that the CEO and CFO, the highest in command, are the ones that are committing the fraud. I would recommend that the caller has to report the fraud to the FASB. The Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) has been the designated organization in the private sector for establishing standards of financial accounting that governs the preparation of financial reports by nongovernmental organizations. Those standards are officially recognized as authoritative by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. If the caller continues to work in the company he could get caught committing the fraud and could go to jail. There are two risks if...

Words: 634 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Auditing Case

...collected. Below are a couple more of the more relevant ones to the Comptronix’s Case. The first factor to consider is the industry of the client’s business operations. When conducting an audit the auditor should understand the company and how day to day operations are run. Also they should understand the direct risk associated with the industry the company deals in. With Comptronix they produce circuit boards, a great deal of electronics have a very fast lifespan and an auditor should watch how the company values and accounts for such boards in their inventory. The more risky the business looks based on the results collected, the hire the inherent risk should be set for that type of company in the industry. Another factor that can influence inherent risk is the client’s motivation and presence of related parties. The auditor should always look at transactions that go n between related parties to ensure that the transactions have been recorded correctly. In this case Comptronix had a member of the board of directors’ who was the VP of manufacturing at a major customer the company did business with. This should be noted by the auditor as it is always possible that some of these transactions were not recorded properly by two companies. The motivation of clients can be driven by many things it is up to the auditor to be able to review how it could affect the inherent risk. In Comptronix’s case the management had stock options that they were granted for sitting on the board......

Words: 1909 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Auditing Case 12.4

...not disclosing the issue going concern may lead to large penalties for both George and Mark if get sued by the creditors, investor, customers or employers. Also Mark can reassure George that even if the going concern issue disclosure is mentioned in the financial statements it may not have a strong effect on his business. His reputation and past will prevent investors, customers and creditors from taking unfavorable actions against him. 5 How appropriate is it for an audit partner to have a friendly personal relationship with a client? It is appropriate for the auditor to have a friendly personal relationship with the client so long as it does not interrupt the level of professionalism of the business relationship. In this case; however, Mark was reserve about telling George about the going concern explanatory paragraph that Mark want to put in the audit report. This situation was awkward because Mark and George were friends. In the end, Mark had decided to tell George about the going concern explanatory paragraph, but not after Mark had some doubt. If Mark would issue a clean unqualified opinion, Mark’s friendship with George would have cause Mark to be not independent. 6 What factors should motivate Mark to be objective in his decision, despite his personal concern for his friend? The factors that should motivate Mark to be objective are the independent standard and ethic standard of an auditor. Mark’s personal belief and personal value also......

Words: 844 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Auditing and Assurance Case 1.2

...Auditing & assurance Case 1.2 1. Consider the principles, assumptions and constraints of Generally Accepted Accounting Principles. Define the revenue recognition principle and explain why it is important to users of financial statements. According to the revenue recognition principle, revenues are recognized when they are realized or realizable, and are earned. Thus, it does not matter when the cash is received. To break that definition down, revenues are realized when products are exchanged for cash or claims to cash. Revenues are realizable when related assets received are readily convertible to cash or claims to cash. Revenues are earned when the products are delivered or services are performed. It is important for a company to abide by this principle as it is will help investors. By not recognizing revenues when the goods or services are delivered or performed, investors are given false information. If a company is paid before they deliver a good, they have not technically earned that revenue yet. By deferring revenue in such a way, investors are provided with overstated numbers, which makes the company seem like they are performing better than they actually are. 2. Provide one example of how WorldCom violated the revenue recognition principle in this situation. WorldCom violated the revenue recognition principle when they made “top-side adjusting journal entries, often very large, that were allegedly made during the quarterly closing process in order to hit......

Words: 1059 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Auditing Case

...Keith Parkinson 2/3/15 Auditing Case 1: Merry-Go-Round Merry-Go-Round (MGR) is a clothing retailer that was founded in 1968. The company’s locations were in malls that targeted the youth and teen market. In the late 1980s, the company was listed by Forbes magazine as one of the top 25 companies. By the early 1990s, sales fell due to stiff competition from other retailers. Facing bankruptcy, the company hired turnaround specialists from Ernst and Young (E&Y) to help overcome the financial crisis. However, the company filed for Chapter 11 reorganization and due to that a group of 9,000 creditors filed a lawsuit against E&Y saying they were the main reason for MGR’s decline. First of all, E&Y violated GAAS first standard that states, “The audit is to be performed by a person or persons having adequate technical training and proficiency as an auditor.” The turnaround team included inexperienced personnel that included a retired consultant, a partner with little experience in the U.S. and with retail firms, and two recent college graduates. I would say the first standard of Field Work was violated because the work wasn’t adequately planned and there was no supervision. The leader of the team took an eight-day vacation at critical point during the engagement. Also, while store closing were key to MGR’s survival, only 230 of 1,434 stores had been closed and MGR still operated two stores in some malls. Last, the cost-cutting strategy called for only $11 million......

Words: 611 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Auditing: Case Study

...utility use and costs (Kumar, Ranjan, Singh, Kumari, & Ramesh, 2015). Comparison of building performance to similar buildings can be made. A list of measures that can be used to conserve energy can be constructed by evaluating the building energy efficiency to determine the low cost and simple improvements that can be implemented. Conducting interviews with operating personnel gives a better understanding of how the energy is being consumed by the systems. Also, it helps determine energy-conservation measures that are appropriate for the facility. This is done through walk-through audit (Smith & Parmenter, 2016). Performing financial analysis based on estimated cost implementation, the cost of operations and other features are done. Auditing the energy use survey to give a detailed examination of the facility and how the energy is being used. This can involve measurements on site and soft wares to examine energy substitutes. Finally, the evaluation of the building's operating system and the functioning of the scheme including real-time data of operation, consumption of electricity and potential energy savings is done (Sutton, 2015). Repair and Maintenance * Determination of the test objectives. Tests are done to provide assurance that there are material misstatement and ability to correct the financial records. Errors can be from mistakes that are unintentional and fraud. * Definition of population characteristics. Repairs and maintenance is a risky expense......

Words: 1074 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Milianaw University Internal Auditing Case

...solid wood, the desk alone was rumored to be worth more than $10,000. Then there was the addition of over 50 workstations and related equipment to the administrative computer system, when, it was claimed, cheaper microcomputers would have done the job. Apparently, the equipment had been acquired without board approval, on the authorization of the vice president for business affairs, and had cost more than $290,000. In addition to these complaints, there were allegations that Lockwood had used cars from the university motor pool as personal vehicles; and also misused his authority with regard to the purchase of insurance policies. In response to these complaints, the president requested that Keith Tiller, the director of internal auditing, conduct a review of the Harris Hall purchasing procedures and university purchasing policies. During the course of the review, the president expanded its scope to include the award of university insurance contracts. It was Carter's charge to analyze Tiller's findings and report her conclusions directly to the president, along with any recommendations for changes. Tiller's report now lay on her desk. The president expected her response within the week. MILIANAW UNIVERSITY The University is controlled by a board of trustees, who are appointed by the governor of the state. The president is the chief executive officer of the University and is responsible to the board. Reporting directly to the president are: the general......

Words: 1320 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Auditing Case Study

...AUDITING CASE STUDY ACCT: 407-01 3/31/2010 The general definition of an audit is an evaluation of a person, organization, system, process, enterprise, project or product. Audits are performed to ascertain the validity[->0] and reliability[->1] of information; also to provide an assessment of a system's internal control[->2]. The goal of an audit is to express an opinion on the person / organization/system (etc) in question, under evaluation based on work done on a test basis. Due to practical constraints, an audit seeks to provide only reasonable assurance that the statements are free from material error. Hence, statistical sampling is often adopted in audits. In the case of financial audits[->3], a set of financial statements are said to be true and fair when they are free of material misstatements - a concept influenced by both quantitative and qualitative factors. Audit is a vital part of accounting[->4]. Traditionally, audits were mainly associated with gaining information about financial systems and the financial records of a company or a business (see financial audit[->5]). However, recent auditing has begun to include other information about the system, such as information about security risks, information systems performance (beyond financial systems), and environmental performance. As a result, there are now professions conducting security audits, IS audits, and environmental audits[->6]. In financial accounting[->7], an audit is an independent......

Words: 2038 - Pages: 9