B) What Are the Five Civilizational Traits That Huntington Presents in This Article? What Is One Trait/Aspect That He May Have Overlooked? Why Was This Potential “Trait” Not Included Among Huntington’s Original Five?

In: Business and Management

Submitted By joyceyan51
Words 3926
Pages 16
Also known as Dr. Madan Lal Goel
University of West Florida

Abstract. The notion of a clash of civilizations has gained notoriety since the terrorist attack on WTC on 9/11/2001. Professor Samuel P. Huntington has popularized the view that the coming global conflict will be among major civilizations, not among different political ideologies. He identifies eight major civilizations: the Western (Europe and North America), Slavic (Russia and Eastern Europe), Islamic, Confucian, Hindu, Japanese, Latin American, and the African. Of particular focus in the present paper is the threat to civilization from radical Islam. Three factors that foment radicalism are described: the Islamic theology of exclusiveness, the nostalgic memory of a Muslim empire that lasted nearly 1,000 years, and the consequences of oil boom in the Middle East. Population estimates for different civilizations are provided at the end.


The theory of a clash of civilizations has been with us for some time. British historian Arnold Toynbee used the term in a series of lectures he delivered in 1953. The Middle East specialist Bernard Lewis wrote in 1990 that the Muslim rage against the West is “no less than a clash of civilizations” (Lewis, 1990, p 60). Samuel P. Huntington, a Harvard University political science professor, has given new currency to the notion of a clash of civilizations. His 1993 article in Foreign Affairs has gained global audience. A few years ago, I lectured to a political science class at Pondicherry University in Southern India. I was pleasantly surprised by the extent of the knowledge that Indian students possessed on this topic. A majority of the Indian students agreed with Huntington(s conclusion. The bipolar division of the world based on political ideology (communism versus…...

Similar Documents

Trait Theory Leaders

... the purpose of the announced change, provide a picture and a plan for them, and describe the parts that people will be playing in them. -This will show the employees that an actual plan is in place to manage the change, rather than it all just being talk. Analyze who stands to lose what in the changes. -You have to figure out your loses so you can find a way to turn them around moving forward. Appoint a “change manager” to be responsible for seeing that the changes go smoothly. -This is imperative to making sure that transitioning is effective. 2=Worth doing but takes more time. Start planning it: Rewrite the memo to convey more sensitivity to the impact on the company’s employees. -This can be done once there is a firm plan in place so the employees will feel valued. Fire the CEO. He’s lost his credibility. -He needs to be replaced by someone who better understands the industry and market trends. Get the senior management to agree to a one-year 20% cut in their own salaries. -This can be beneficial because senior management are paid well but they aren’t working hard for the salaries they earn. Immediately set new, higher production targets for the next quarter so that people will have something clear to shoot for and, by aiming high-adequate output will be ensured even if they fail to reach the goals. -Have clear and defined goals makes it easier to hold people accountable. It’ll also help...

Words: 1227 - Pages: 5

Personality Trait

... for you to deal with highly competitive individuals. 2.5 'Openess' This personality trait pertains to originality and intellect. It is related to the extent to which a person searches for new insights, or has a more practical, routine-like attitude. Your score on this trait is extremely low. You are clearly more focused than others on the here and now. Instead of thinking new things up or considering alternatives, you prefer to get right down to work. Why make things difficult? Thus you are also not the type who readily wants things discussed. As a result, you will appear polite and correct. In general, you prefer routine and take a practical approach. As a result, others may think you are conservative or rigid, but also loyal and rule abiding. It will be difficult for you to deal with people who are very dreamy, vague or always wondering whether there is a better way to do things. You prefer to accept things as they are. Your preference is for people who take a level-headed approach. 3. Key personality types In this section, whether combinations of personality traits will result in an additional key personality type is reviewed. You have seen your score for each of the main traits for the Big Five. The score was assessed in terms of (very) high, (just) above-average, average, (just) below-average or (very) low. Combining the non-average scores results in key personality types that significantly add to your five personality traits. A key personality type can be used......

Words: 2635 - Pages: 11

Leadership Approach Trait Theory

... extensive may not be applicable to the successes of the leaders assessed. This also can be a limitation because some traits being important within differing leadership scenarios. For example, a military leadership position may require traits that will not be as important with a management position within a retail store. Though the theory also helps to pinpoint what characteristics can help a leader to become more successful, another limitation is that leadership still requires the “application of special skill sets and techniques” (Trait Theory of Leadership, 2013). Though certain skills may already exist for the leader in question, there will still be necessary development of the skill sets and traits. Furthermore, the exact trait that the individual may possess may require development over time. For example, even though a confidence may be a strong trait within a leader, confidence is a trait that is developed over time. So while trait theory can identify successful, there is still limitations of the theory to explain individuals who may possess certain traits but are not suited for leadership positions (Cherry, 2013). Conclusion The use of the trait theory helps to evaluate many different types of leaders and the traits that can help lead them to be successful. The awareness of the trait theory’s strengths and weaknesses increases the strength of the theories and the realistic environments for which it can be......

Words: 672 - Pages: 3

B) What Are the Five Civilizational Traits That Huntington Presents in This Article? What Is One Trait/Aspect That He May Have Overlooked? Why Was This Potential “Trait” Not Included Among Huntington’s Original Five?

.... In a visit to my native village recently, I found that religious differences had assumed nefarious importance in the wake of extremism that pervaded the state of Punjab in the 1980s. My village has a Sikh majority; Hindu families have left the village and migrated to nearby Hindu majority towns. Critique I agree with much of what Huntington says. The world suffers on account of religious and nationality-based violence. However, Huntington(s argument is flawed in two ways. One, civilizations are not monolithic. They encompass a great deal of cultural, social and political diversity. The West is divided not only among Catholics, Protestants and Jews, but also between Europe and North America. Catholics and Protestants still fight in Northern Ireland. Political differences between the European Union and the United States have increased. Hinduism is similarly divided between the North and the South, and between secularists and traditionalists. Islam is even more fractured. It has numerous warring factions: Sunni versus Shia, Wahabis versus mainline Muslims, secularists versus fundamentalists, the Arab versus the Turk. The bloodiest conflict of the second half of the 20th century was the decade long war between Iran (Shia) and Iraq (Sunni dominated under Saddam Hussein). My second disagreement with Huntington concerns the nature of the civilizational conflict. Huntington argues that the coming world conflict will be between (the West and the rest.( The (rest...

Words: 3926 - Pages: 16

My Personality Trait

... say why or explain any symbolism connected with the things you love. Avoid Unclear Definitions It is really easy to get lost when you are writing something as vague and as perspective-oriented as an essay about yourself. People tend to choose a number of themes of who they are and try to describe them all. That would be very confusing for the reader. Not to mention that it would be hard to write and navigate in between those themes. After all, very few people know you well enough, and it is almost certain that your essay is going to be read mostly by strangers or just people who know you marginally. What you do instead is pick one theme: which light do you want to be seen in? Once you have answered that question, you are ready to go. Stay true to the theme, and you will get a coherent piece that will get you a good grad Introduction My name is Amit Vaidya. I am from India. I am in my first semester of senior year in Civil Engineering at Clemson University, SC. In this memo, I am going to tell you little bit about my background, interests, achievements and my goals. Background I was born in a small village called Bilimora. Bilimora is located about 70 kilometers south of the city of Surat which is 8th largest city in India, in the state of Gujarat. I spent my first 16 years of life in Bilimora. Bilimora is famous for temples, textile mills. My everyday activities included going to school, playing cricket, watching television, and going to temple at the night......

Words: 2699 - Pages: 11

Trait Approach to Leadership

... certain traits will be more effective in some situations than in others. Recently, however, there has been somewhat of a resurgence in research on the trait approach to leadership, especially with the emergence of the five-factor model of personality. Recent research has attempted to correct some of the methodological shortcomings of the earlier research on leadership traits. For example, researchers have developed conceptual models linking leadership attributes to organizational performance. Additionally, they have begun to highlight consistent patterns of relationships between traits and performance measures. Rather than simply studying what combinations of traits would be successful in a particular situation, researchers are now linking clusters of personality traits to success in different situations. SUMMARY In general, the trait and situational approaches have resulted in only limited advances in the understanding of leadership. Although early studies highlighted the One of the concerns about such lists is that the attributes typically associated with successful leaders are often perceived as “male” traits. Reportedly, when men and women are asked about the other gender’s characteristics and leadership qualities, significant patterns emerge, with both men and women tending to see successful leaders as male. PROBLEMS AND LIMITATIONS OF THE TRAIT APPROACH As discussed previously, many early researchers found no differences between leaders and......

Words: 2000 - Pages: 8

Personality Trait

... reciprocal determination explains how human behavior and personality is a reaction of behavioral, cognitive, and environmental factors. The trait perspective on personality is a theory that focuses on identifying, describing, and measuring individual differences. Most people can be outgoing others can be shy. There are some people that are average not too shy and not to outgoing. There are hundreds of psychological test that can be used to assess the abilities, aptitudes, interests, and personality. The first projective test was the Rorschach Inkblot Test, originated by a Swiss psychiatrist Hermann Rorschach in 1921. The test consists of 10 cards, 5 cards are black and white inkblots and 5 were colored inkblot. The patient then describes the image and is recorded by the psychologist as the behavior, gestures, and reactions the patient shows. The Thematic Apperception Test consists of a patient given a serious of cards to be seen. The patient needs to start with the first card by giving a story, the middle, and the ending of the story. The personality assessments are scored and compared with norms established by other research. Many studies have shown the assessments to be accurate, and consistent. These can be used to predict behavior. The weakness for these test consist of patients successfully fake on their responses and answer in socially desirable ways. Most patients do not answer correctly. They prone themselves to answer only in one way, either......

Words: 472 - Pages: 2

Blog on Trait Theory

... people behave as they do. I found that any type of behavioral and or genetic issue, it does not discriminate who or what you are. It doesn’t care if the person is female or male, just as long as it has a place to live. There are many types of census out there to figure out the ever growing population of different cultures that are residing in the United States, but that doesn’t mean that they are showing different cultures that are residing in the United States, but that doesn’t mean that they are showing trait theories due to different cultural backgrounds. This does raise many questions to one’s mind when it comes to this type of information that is being released into the public. I often wonder since trait theory is something that Carl Jung felt was genetic, how is it that when a couple of one ethnicity adopts a child of another ethnicity, this child will have no signs of being the race it is? The child will have traits of his or her biological father and mother, but the child will not exhibit what biological parents are doing or acting like in their country. The child will definitely show if he or she is introvert or extrovert on their own because it is genetic. So how is it important what race we all are in life when we solely show what we were given in our genetic pool? Putting people in a box of race is just one way to surrogate each person by their race and not of their genetic life of their past family members. This seems to be unfair to everyone and......

Words: 835 - Pages: 4

Analyzing Humanistic Trait Theories

...ANALYZING HUMANISTIC THEORIES KELLY KOVACS WALDEN UNIVERSITY Introduction Many individuals would agree that the theory behind our personalities mainly derive from biological factors. However, there are certain theorists that disagree with this, and view human instinct is the main contribution to the way we develop within society. Is there really any truth to this theory or is it just based off of an individual’s perception? There are several unanswered questions surrounding these analogies but they all have one thing in common, human development. Every theory ever documented has in some way implied that we evolve from childhood into adulthood, by conquering different milestones in life. Whether these steps involve sexual stages, conflicting situations or discovering self-worth, they all tie back to how our interactions or decisions allow us to move forward in life. Analyzing Humanistic Theories Some theorists believed that one does not develop their personality just through genetics in general, but also by discovering their true self through a series of emotional and physical accomplishments. These achievements were then grouped together to form what was referred to as our humanistic traits. There were two specific theorists, Rogers and Maslow, which during this time took their theories to a whole new level, thus combining both our psychological and physical needs with human instinct (Boeree, C. G., 2006). They disagreed with the theories of others such as Freud...

Words: 936 - Pages: 4

Trait Theory of Leadership

... distinguish between leaders and followers. Leaders tended to be slightly higher on traits such as height, intelligence, extraversion, adjustment, dominance, and self-confidence as compared with followers. The little differences between leaders and non-leaders were said to be mistakes in leader selection, mistakes in measuring leadership traits, or the failure to measure critical attributes. Many early trait researchers had implied that, no matter what the situation, there was a set of characteristics that made a leader successful. Nevertheless, the differences between leaders and followers were found to vary widely across different situations. Variables on leadership effectiveness were not put to the situational test. (Zaccaro, S. J., & Klimoski, R. J. 2001) Are these simply the results of the added responsibilities that come with building a career and family? "One could argue that as you get further into adulthood, you have new responsibilities and that's why you are more conscientiousness. If you have a family you may become more agreeable. But the cause of why these traits change wasn't examined directly in his study. Biology may be programmed to make people adapt better to life's new chapters. Two experts not connected with the study agree that leadership traits will change throughout life, but they question how the study was conducted. It did not follow the same people over time, but rather compared self-perceived ratings among different people in different age......

Words: 967 - Pages: 4

Trait Paper

... business (Lapidus & Ference, 2014). It is nicer to that the NLRB may force an employer to reinstate the employee and even pay for damages such as back pay. I think that should be the case especially dealing with the constitution and freedom of speech. As you can see there are two main ways that discipline can be used. One being the fact that is in a disciplinary or punishment action. Then in a way of training or improving yourself in a certain way. I have personally been on the side of training and not have been in situation with any of my employers where I had to face a type of disciplinary action. I hope to continue that streak or not be disciplined in the future. REFERENCE PAGE 1) In The Supreme Court of The State of Illinois. (July 1, 2009). Article VIII, Illinois Rules of Professional Conduct of 2010. Retrieved from: http://www.state.il.us/court/SupremeCourt/Rules/Art_VIII/ArtVIII_NEW.htm#scope 2) American Institute of CPAs. (June 1, 2013). Code of Professinal Conduct and Bylaws. Retrieved from: http://www.aicpa.org/Research/Standards/CodeofConduct/DownloadableDocuments/2013June1CodeOfProfessionalConduct.pdf 3) American Institute of CPAs. Disciplinary Actions. Retrieved from: http://www.aicpa.org/FORTHEPUBLIC/DISCIPLINARYACTIONS/Pages/default.aspx 4) David R. Campbell Sr., Timothy S. Doupnik, George T. Tsakumis. (January 31, 2009). IFRS: Beyond the Standards. Retrieved from:......

Words: 1263 - Pages: 6

Psychoanalytic and Trait Theories

...Psychoanalytic and Trait Theories Shavon R. Gray University of Phoenix Author Note Week 2 Individual Assignment Abstract I will write a 1,050 to 1,400 word paper analyzing the components of the psychoanalytic approach to personality. My paper will cover a comparison and contrasting the psychoanalytic theories of Freud, Jung, ad Adler. I will attempt to explain two characteristics of these theories in which I agree and disagree with. I will describe the stages of Freud’s theory and explain characteristics of personality using these components. I will also use at least three Freudian defense mechanism with real-life examples. Psychoanalytic and Trait Theories Sigmund Freud, was an Austrian physician, he was responsible for the development of the psychoanalytic theory in the early 1900s. “According to Freud’s theory, conscious experience is only a small part of our psychological makeup and experience. He argued that much of our behavior is motivated by the unconscious, a part of the personality that contains the memories, knowledge, beliefs, feelings, urges, drives, and instincts of which the individual is not aware.” (Feldman, 2011). His theory is compared to the unseen floating Mass of a floating iceberg; where the unconscious contents far surpass in quantity the information that is in our conscious awareness. Freud maintained his stand by stating that when it comes to understanding personality, one must expose the unconscious. Due to the fact that the...

Words: 1267 - Pages: 6

Leadership: Trait Approach

... possess most of the characteristics listed in trait theory. Northouse (2013) proposed the following trait theory characteristics including Intelligence, Self-Confidence, Determination, Integrity, and Sociability. I feel very confident and comfortable to say that I am not in doubt of having these characteristics prior to taking the questionnaire. My life experiences reflected the usage of these characteristics in different fields of endeavors up to date. I have been opportune to lead social organizations as the president. I am currently a member of the executive board of another socio-cultural organization. The leadership skills required to successfully lead in these positions are pretty much those that are on the LTQ ratings. Deegan (2009) stated that leadership entails having foresight and the ability to smartly direct the affairs of followers. The author further suggested that a leader should be authentic and transparent. The LTQ really speaks to me as I completed the questionnaire. There are few areas that the trait theory and my personal leadership styles may not be in congruence. I have never considered myself to be very articulate when it comes to delivery. An effective leader may need to have powerful oratory skills to carry along followers. One of those leaders with this skill that I admire is President Barack Obama. Some of the traits I believe I was born with that helps to shape who I am include my ability to be very decisive and outgoing. I am a firm believer......

Words: 682 - Pages: 3

Trait Choice Theory

... the trait theory. Dexter shows that he is not able to feel any of his feelings; he says even if he tries, he could not. He knows he is not normal, and he hasn’t been normal his whole life. This personality is common amongst most serial killers, and it shows how there isn’t much choice in the traits of their character. “Empty inside, like me.” This is another quote that Dexter has in the first season. By mentioning this, it shows that Dexter has a void inside of him, something missing. Many serial killers are known to not feel guilt or sorrow for their victims. They do not feel remorse after Murdering somebody. It is lead to believe that Dexter tries to fill the emptiness he feels inside of him by killing, but he seems to never be fulfilled. Although Dexter had murdered multiple individuals, he has never gotten caught. This is because of his particularly clean and knowledged acts. Dexter’s behavior shows that he feels a huge void inside of him. His personality doesn’t exactly make him kill, but really just makes him feel a bit better and more content after each murder. This “void” could have been from a way he was raised, or watching his mother get killed at such an early age. The possibility of a mental illness is a pretty big factor in how Dexter feels and how he acts. Consequently, this quote shows both trait and choice theory when it comes down to it. Dexter shows emptiness throughout the season and his emptiness is what stimuluses murder. When looking at the......

Words: 635 - Pages: 3

Character Trait

... this so this person can stay positive and strong all the time. I believe this is one of the hardship or negative aspect of keeping the solid character trait because humans have feelings and their own thought and it is not easy to control them as you want. Strong character trait is coming from all the experience. This person has to obtain the knowledge and other information so the next time is easier to deal with. As I mentioned earlier, the example of solving troublesome situation, person has to build the experience to become good at something. If you are strong as physically, than you have to build the muscles and do exercise for the decent amount of the time because strength for the body cannot be built in an instant. Same as mentally too. You get the first job and you learn every day by going out there and deal with the situation. I believe building character trait is related to those steps of achieving something. Strong characteristic is helpful in many ways. As I mentioned it can be helpful in solving unexpected situations when the person is mentally strong and as physically strong, it can give good impression from the outside to other people by having solid body. Impression is important matter in this society since we are living in the society where everybody is unfamiliar and mostly judged by each other. People does not trust everybody so they look at the other person’s first impression, what they have in common, and what they are good at it. “The......

Words: 600 - Pages: 3