Free Essay

Baboon Metaphysics

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By lejlababic21
Words 2649
Pages 11
While reading the book, Baboon Metaphysics, I came to the conclusion that there is more to Baboons than what meets the eye. Cheney and Seyfarth do a wonderful job on exploring the complex and mysterious world of Baboons, focusing in on their social structures, relationships, and even touching on aspects of a possible language. The authors make it clear that baboons have an understanding of bonds, ranks and social networks. I also believe that baboons have a clear and intricate understanding of social networks and hierarchical ranks because of the amount of evidence shown. To begin, I will set out to present the research presented by Cheney and Seyfarth in Baboon Metaphysics concerning baboon social bonds and networks. In the chapter five of the book, Cheney and Seyfarth observe the social bonds and rank recognition between female baboons. Like humans, baboons differ in social ranks and are exposed to different environmental stress factors. When a female baboon is faced with the loss of an infant or relative, for example, she experiences stress. Due to this stress, she forms stronger and broader bonds and social networks. Because their feelings of loneliness increases, the formation of social bonds and networks alleviates it. Humans also rely on friends and relatives greatly when trying to cope with the loss of a loved one. Besides strengthening their social networks, female baboons also tend to strengthen their grooming networks when coping with the loss of a loved one. For example, their grooming partners increase as well as their grooming rate. In the next paragraph, I will set out to examine male social networks. In male baboons, the behavior that is seen in female baboons is not evident. Whereas female baboons are mainly stressed by factors such as infant loss, predation, and rank instability, male baboons are mainly stressed by dominance rank, longevity and predation. Male baboons are not as stressed by rank instability as they are by dominance rank. For example, a male baboon throughout his life is primarily concerned with achieving dominant rank, always striving for a higher position in the hierarchy. Although we would expect a higher ranking dominant male to experience less stress than a lower ranking subordinate male, this is not the case. According to Cheney and Seyfarth, higher ranking male baboons tend to experience more stress than lower ranking male baboons, especially during rank instability. This is because the dominant male’s power and reproductive control is threatened and he may feel as if it could be taken away. In the next part, I will set out to examine the evidence shown that baboons know of other animal’s dominance ranks, which also has to do with social networks. In baboons, particularly female baboons, rank is not distinguished by one’s size, age, or other physical attributes. Therefore, there has to be something else that allows baboons to know what one’s rank is. When observing female baboons in tasks such as grooming, it is evident that rank plays a role and is recognizable. According to Cheney and Seyfarth’s research, if female baboons are grooming and a dominant female approaches them, the lower-ranking female usually leaves, thus recognizing her own rank and the dominant female’s rank. To prove that females have an intricate understanding of rank in the society, Joan Silk, Cheney and Seyfarth designed an experiment to test their understanding. In the next paragraph, I will go into detail of what the experiment involved. The experiment that Joan Silk, Cheney and Seyfarth carried out was an experiment involving sound playback. The experiment essentially used call sequences from various baboons of different rank and mimicked an interaction between the female baboons that went against the dominance hierarchy. The sequence they used contained grunts from a lower ranking female along with a series of fear barks from a higher ranking female. This was essentially a violation of the female dominance hierarchy because a higher ranking female would not give fear grunts to a lower ranking female. They also added grunts of an even higher ranking female than the other two to serve as a control. This sequence mimicked an actual scenario that happened with the female baboons. This sequence was played back in a number of trials to a female unrelated to the scenario throughout the course of several days and her response was recorded. Cheney and Seyfarth’s prediction was that the baboon would respond in surprise by paying attention to the loudspeaker for a period of time, recognizing that the female dominance hierarchy was being violated. Cheney and Seyfarth played sequences of consistent and inconsistent calls, consistent ones agreeing with the female dominance hierarchy and inconsistent ones violating the female dominance hierarchy. Indeed, the subjects who were played back these calls looked at the loudspeaker significantly longer when the inconsistent calls were played as opposed to the consistent calls being played. Thus, the subjects seemed to understand who was of higher rank and who was of lower rank, responding in a stronger fashion when the inconsistent calls were played. Next, I will set out to examine an experiment by Cheney, Seyfarth and Dawn Kitchen, involving male Wahoo call recognition. Wahoo calls are “extremely loud, low-pitched calls that can be produced only by large, fuly adult males (p. 52).” A Wahoo call is also seen as “an exhausting demonstration of a male’s stamina and coordination (p. 52),” because they are done in long bouts, most of the time as the male baboons are racing or leaping from tree branch to tree branch. To test whether or not males recognize rank by a baboon male’s Wahoo call, individual baboon males were exposed to playbacks of Wahoo sequences that “mimicked a contest between either adjacently ranked ir disparately ranked males (p. 95).” As a control, the experiment only involved calls between adjacently and disparately ranked males which had interacted at the same rate in the past six months. Higher ranking males responded strongly to the playback between the disparate ranks, and less strongly to the playback between the adjacent males. The results showed that “males recognize each other’s Wahoos and can assess the distance in rank between any two males (p. 95).” This shows that males also have an intricate understanding of social networks and ranks because ranks change so often within the male baboon hierarchy. In the next paragraph, I will examine baboon knowledge and recognition of other animals’ kinship relations. Throughout much research, it has been established that baboons know who their own family members and kin are. Cheney and Seyfarth conducted an experiment involving two unrelated female baboons as their subjects, one being dominant to the other. The experiment consisted of three sequences of calls consisting of two other individuals’ threat grunts and screams. Essentially, the experiment was aimed to mimic a scenario in which a higher-ranking baboon threatens a lower-ranking baboon with aggressive grunts and the lower-ranking baboon in turn screams. The first time the experiment was run, neither one of the subjects involved were related to the subjects being tested. In the second run, one of the subjects was a close relative of the dominant female, and the other was unrelated to either one. In the third run, one of the subjects was a close relative of the dominant female being tested and the other subject was a close relative of the subordinate female being tested. In the first run where neither of the subjects were related to the females being tested, both females showed little or no interest in what was happening. In the second run where the subject was a relative of the dominant female, the subordinate female looked in the dominant females direction, as if she knew that the subject in the playback was related to the dominant female. The dominant female did not look at the subordinate female. In the third run, where both subjects were related to one of the females being tested, both female baboons looked at one another. As a result, both subjects seemed as if they recognized that their family members were involved in an argument and this caused conflict in their relationship as well. All in all, the experiment proved that baboons indeed recognize each other’s kin and also that baboons are not only influenced by their own interactions with each other, but also by the interactions of their family members with others. In the next part of the paper, I will examine male baboon relationships and tracking of sexual consortships. So far, we have seen that male dominance ranks change often and that male baboons are very good at keeping track of these changes, concerning themselves and others. Along with tracking each other’s ever so changing ranks, male baboons also seem to monitor each other’s sexual consortships. If an alpha male is mating with his female, the other male baboons keep an eye on the pair, and once the alpha male is not around, the other males come around to quickly mate with the female. If the alpha male abandons the female after their sexual consortship ends, other males try to form a sexual consortship or try to mate with her. An experiment was conducted by Cathy Crockford and Roman Witting to see how closely male baboons monitor other’s sexual consortships. The experiment consisted of three playback calls. The first trial consisted of a male’s consort grunt and played from one speaker and a female copulation call played from the other speaker, suggesting that the alpha male had separated from his consort and that she was secretly mating with another male. The second trial was similar to the first trial, except for a grunt of a nonconsorting alpha male was played from one speaker and the same female’s copulation call was played from the other speaker, implying that the sexual consortship between the alpha male and the female was still going on and that another male was simply close to their area. The third trial, played after the consortship had ended, consisted of the same consorting male’s grunt from the first trial and the same female’s copulation call, suggesting that the alpha male had separated from the female and that she was again mating with another male. The males were expected to react strongest to the first trial, not at all to the second trial because it should have been unsurprising, and not at all to the third trial because it should have been unsurprising as well, if the male had been keeping a close eye on the consortship. As a result, this is how most males reacted. When hearing the first trial, they looked toward the speakers and even approached them because they inferred that the alpha male had separated from his consort and that she was engaged in mating with another male, suggesting that further mating may be possible. This showed that in a social network, not only do males keep watch of their and other males’ rankings, but also of other’s sexual consortships. In the next part of the paper, I will proceed to examine a field study of social cognition in spotted hyenas studied by Kay E. Holenkamp and Anne L. Engh, and to compare it to baboon social networks. Like most baboons and monkeys, carnivorous mammals also live in permanent and complex social groups and also engage in group activities, such as hunting. In this article, the objective was to determine whether or not hyenas have the same cognitive abilities as do primates, such as recognizing one another’s calls or kinfolk. Like primates, hyenas acquire rank according to the ranks of their mothers, and this goes for both sexes. Their social status is not determined by their physical attributes, such as size or strength. Hyenas, like monkeys, know they are dominant over hyenas that rank lower than their mothers do. A similar experiment was used for the hyenas as was used with vervet monkeys. In the experiment concerning vervet monkeys, a distress scream from a juvenile was played through a hidden speaker. The scream was played to a group of female vervet monkeys, including the juvenile’s mother. The mother responded stronger than the other female vervet monkeys, but the other females often looked at the mother when hearing the scream, as if recognizing that she was the juvenile’s mother. The experiment was run with hyenas to identify whether or not hyenas can recognize one another and third-party relationships based on their “whoop” vocalizations. The results showed that hyenas were capable of identifying the “whoop” sounds of other individuals, but there was no evidence that they were capable of identifying third-party relationships. In the next part of the paper, I will set out to examine an article by Cheney and Seyfarth concerning a study on the structure of social knowledge in monkeys. Vervet monkeys live in groups of 8-30 individuals. Their ranks are also determined by their mothers, offspring ranking immediately below their mothers. Vervet monkeys, like baboons, are very social and family oriented. Most social interactions and alliances are formed within families. Vervet’s are also capable of recognizing their kin and associations of other group members. For example, if a vervet monkey is involved in a conflict with another monkey, he will threaten the opponents family soon after. Also, as seen in baboons, vervet monkeys are capable of recognizing the ranks of one another. For example, if a higher ranking mother approaches a lower ranking mother holding an infant and she grunts at her, wanting to handle the infant, the lower ranking mother will hand over the infant. Sometimes lower-ranking females will make “fear barks” when approached by a more dominant female, indicating subordination. An experiment was performed to test whether or not the monkeys are aware that only a subordinate female can make a “fear bark.” This experiment was done by playing back a sequence in which a lower-ranking female grunted at a higher-ranking female and the higher-ranking female emitted a “fear bark.” As a control, the same females were used but a more dominant female was included. The subjects tested responded strongest to the inconsistent sequence, as if they realized the identities and the ranks of the subjects on the playback. This suggests that vervet monkeys have similar understanding of social networks, kinship and ranks as do baboons. In the following paragraph, I will set out to conclude the discussion on the subject of baboon social knowledge. As discussed throughout the paper, baboons clearly have intricate knowledge of their social networks and surrounding baboons. They know to recognize individuals belonging to their families and third-party relationships. Not only that, but they recognize their rank and the ranks of others. This is surprising in males, since their ranks change rapidly, yet they still keep track of them. They are prominent at realizing an individual’s identity by just listening to the sounds they make. Males, again, are good at recognizing another male by just their Wahoo call. Also, not only do they recognize one another, males keep track of the courtships of other males, in hope of mating and reproducing themselves. After presented with all of this evidence, to say that baboons do not have an intricate understanding of their social network is preposterous. Some may say that it is anthropomorphic of us to attribute human behaviors to baboons, but just like humans, baboons form social networks to bond and cope with problems, recognize their kinfolk and friendships, pay attention to third-party relationships, and so on. While reading Baboon Metaphysics, it just deepened my understanding of baboon social structures and how complex they truly are. To me, there is no way that baboons can be distinguished as not having a complete and complex understanding of their social structures.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Critical Analysis- the Evolutionary Origins of Friendship

...the purpose in writing the article, is to provide facts and details on “the evolution and adaptive value of human friendship and to consider how stable, enduring friendship might have evolved” (2012, p.154) In human both authors argue “having a strong social network reduces stress, lower the risk of disease, and increase longevity, and was stated by Beckman and Holt-Lunstad (2004 and 2010). On the other hand, Robert and Dorothy believe that in animals “enduring social bonds can increase individual’s reproduction success. However, among female baboons, individuals with the most stable, enduring relationship experience higher infant survival and live longer” (2012, p.170). Robert then goes on and describes the benefits of friendship. In the animal life, animals such as Hyenas, chimpanzees, monkeys, baboons, elephants can only be leaders of their group by creating a long-term friendship with other colleagues. The baboon: when female baboons...

Words: 1701 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Sapolsky Male Baboons Chapter Summaries

...Sapolsky a professor and researcher talks about the time he spent with savanna baboons. During his studies he found out many discoveries about baboons. He not only found out how they live, but he found out information about their stress levels. During his stay he was intruded to the baboons and their ranks in the troop. Sapolsky learned the multiple social dominances like fighting to be top ranked and mating strategies the troop participated in. He also learned the nature and instinct created a complex social hierarchy for the baboons. Throughout the book Sapolsky gives multiples ways that baboons show social dominance. Generally, the males show the social dominance during Sapolsky’s time in the troop. There are a few females that do show...

Words: 1689 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Chacma Baboons

...SOCIAL BEHAVIOUR STUDY OF CHACMA BABOONS IN THE CAPE PENINSULA Catherine Shutte – Student Number 350 795 92 Table of Contents ABSTRACT: 2 INTRODUCTION: 3 STUDY AREA: 5 METHODS: 6 RESULTS: 8 DISCUSSION: 12 CONCLUSION: 16 REFERENCES: 18 TABLES: 19 APPENDICES: 21 ABSTRACT: Behavioural activity data was gathered over a thirty hour period on two of the main Papio hamadryas (Chacma Baboon) troops on the Cape Peninsula. The first based on the Blackhill mountain slopes above Da Gama Park and the second on the slopes of the Swartkop Mountain range above Millers Point. During the visual observations, the troops mostly exhibited “normal” diurnal mammal behaviour, the exception being that of the feeding habits of both troops, both relaying on their human neighbours for nutritional extras and feeding predominantly throughout the day. The prevailing hot dry weather found in the Cape during the summer increased the resting activity of the baboons and reduced their foraging area. The Smits troop spent most of their day on the side of the main road. INTRODUCTION: Watching baboons interact with each other is addictive, their social behaviour within the troop provides a framework of inter-family relationships that cause fighting, playing, power struggles and tender care from a mother to her infant child. Their relationships, bonds and social behaviors resemble ours as humans so closely that...

Words: 5955 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Baboon Research Paper

...Baboons are small primates located in Africa and belong to the genus Papio. They are divided into different phenotype a such as yellow, olive, and sacred Baboons. Baboons are adequately small animals good for normal handling and when put in suitable conditions they have positive fertility rates (Stevens 1997). Fertility is the capability of one to conceive a child and in baboons the fertility rate can reach up to 80% if the baboons are in optimal conditions (Stevens 1997). Studies on reproduction have been administered on captive baboon for more than three decades because they can be exported at a reasonable cost. Also, the hormones baboons release during their menstrual cycle and during their gestational period are similar to the hormones that humans release during their gestational period and menstrual cycle (Stevens 1970). These hormones are oestrogen and progesterone and the secretion of the two are extremely...

Words: 505 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

New Age Spirituality

...New Age Spirituality February 19, 2012 New Age Spirituality Is New Age Spirituality really new? Is it something old that has been creeping in and out as a worldview? The Bible says there is nothing new under the sun. “That which has been is that which will be, And that which has been done is that which will be done. So there is nothing new under the sun” Ecclesiastes 1:9). This paper will show that New Age Spirituality is not so new, but is an ancient religion which holds to the belief that there are many gods and is essentially the revival of the substitute faith called occultism (Martin, 1989, pg. 14-15). We will see that this spirituality movement is merely a clever attempt made by depraved mankind in his ongoing quest to be his own God. I will examine the opinions of scholars and come to the conclusion that the New Age Religion is actually the Old Religion repackaged. This paper will show that the New Age Religion leads to an unfulfilled life in contrast to Christianity which leads to eternal life. The New Age Spiritualism worldview is a hodgepodge of beliefs that combines many beliefs together into a sweet, appetizing, appealing sounding religion. But drinking from this “fountain” is detrimental to the soul. A little bit of cyanide in the Kool-Aid will kill (Martin, 1989, pg. 52). Cult leader, Jim Jones, was heavily influenced by New Age spiritualism. As a result of this, 915 people died in Jonestown, Guyana at his indirect hands in a standoff between...

Words: 2615 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Coconut , Ilk

...BIO1-BIOTECHNOLOGY AND HEALTH SCIENCE COCONUT MILK MACHINE (COMBINATION BETWEEN EXTRACTING AND GRATER COCONUT MACHINE) H. Azmi, M. S. Mohd Nasir &A. B. Mohd Kahirul Fadzli School of Manufacturing Engineering, Universiti Malaysia Perlis (UniMAP), Kampus Tetap Ulu Pauh, Jalan Arau-Changlun, 02600 Arau, Perlis, Malaysia. Abstract The purpose of this research was to design, construct, and evaluate a prototype ot Coconut Milk Machine which combined those two existing machines to produce the coconut milk. In current practices on the market today, to produce the coconut milk must be used two separate machines such as coconut grater machine to get the small pieces of coconut and then use the coconut extracting machine to get the coconut milk. Have two works must be done before getting the coconut milk. One big problem occurred during the grater the coconut kernel in the existing machine is not constant in order to produce the small pieces of coconut. In this project, first the research needs to focus on the design of the knife mill inside the existing coconut grater machine. It is important to get the small pieces of coconut in constant operation. Second the mechanism used to operate this machine such as mechanical and electrical devices and lastly how to automate that machine in order to reduce the operating time and to increase the productivity. Therefore, the proposed research is aimed to study the existing coconut machines available and investigated the problem occurred during...

Words: 342 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Unger

...Unger states an argument that ordinary things such as pieces of furniture, rocks, and planets, all do not exist. I will formally reconstruct and explain Unger’s argument for the conclusion that stones do not exists by presenting it with numbered premises and conclusions. I will then explain how Unger’s argument is supposed to work as well as critically assess Unger’s argument by bringing up an objection. Unger makes several different points in order to support his argument that stones do not exist. I have formulated an argument in order to support Unger’s argument and conclude how stones do not exist. 1. If stones exist, each is composed of a finite number of atoms. 2. When we remove an atom from the stone, the stone still exists. 3. When we continue to remove more atoms, we are left with a stone with zero atoms. 4. If each stone is composed of a finite number of atoms, then all space with zero atoms consist of stones. 5. All empty space does not consist of stones. 6. Therefore, stones do not exist. To go even further, I can add another step in order to conclude that ordinary objects do not exist. The additional step would be that if ordinary objects exist, then stones must also exist. Therefore, ordinary objects do not exist. First we must see what objects exists and what objects occupy a position in space and time. Objects in the universe include planets, people, atoms, chairs, and the sun. They are all made out of parts and they are all composite...

Words: 667 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

For What We May Hope According to Descartes

...In his book, “Mediation of First Philosophy’’, Rene Descartes attempts to separate the truth from false and the imaginary from reality while giving new hope to his readers. He actually tries to withdraw from his previous conclusions claiming that he could have used senses rather than thinking and therefore this round he withdraws totally from senses through a process of methodological doubt. He creates a sense of doubt in other scholars work by disputing their line of thinking with a distinguished line of logic. He sheds off any criticism directed at him and urges his readers to argue along his line of logic to get his concept and reason. HOW OR WHY THE COGITO EGO SUM IS HOPEFUL. Descartes concludes that he cannot doubt his existence. He argues that doing so would mean that even the idea of doubting would not exist and as far as it exists, then its source is him, his mind. However, the existence of the body puts him in a situation of doubt. He thinks that the idea of a mind implanted in a body is a deception and forms a basis of argument and cross psychological analysis. He goes ahead to state that this would be demons work of deceiving him or it can be that God was praying tricks on him, something he really doesn’t conquer with. God being perfect, He would not do that. ‘I think, therefore I am’ in the Discourse on method is hopeful because it brings out the picture of knowledge, that the mind can know itself better than it can do to anything else. Descartes is certain that...

Words: 912 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Kathmandu

...and exist forever is immortality. Continuer is not the same person as the original deceased person , it is just a fissioned one,which lives in another space,is the continue existence of the deceased. Spatial-temporal continuity is the necessary condition of personal identity. Also,it provides the possibility for the immortality. 3.(1)From wikipedia,Peter van Inwagen (born September 21, 1942, United States) is an American analytic philosopher and the John Cardinal O'Hara Professor of Philosophy at the University of Notre Dame. He previously taught at Syracuse University and earned his PhD from the University of Rochester under the direction of Richard Taylor and Keith Lehrer. Van Inwagen is one of the leading figures in contemporary metaphysics, philosophy of religion, and philosophy of action. (2)In this article,Peter van Inwagen introduced the readers the causal relevant matter of immortality.he refers to it as the “naked kernel”,the seed that continues to exist until God "clothes it in a festal garment of new flesh".He also...

Words: 1147 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

A Short Review of Doctorflix

...A short review on Doctorflix.com Doctorflix.com is a website of its kind in this category. It mainly offers movie reviews, trailers ad viewer ratings. The movie reviews and ratings are real-time as the reviews are by the movie viewers. There is something unique in ratings called Flickometer. This tells you the actual critic reviews, awards won by the movie, etc. In short it helps you to decide the best movie to watch. What is much loved about this site is its simplicity and the content provided. There are different categories which cater to all, such as movies, celebrities, photos, videos, games, news and blog. As a registered user you can even write a blog on related topics. It is user friendly and provides just the information required. There is nothing complicated about it. There are categories like widgets and advertising as well. So if you own a blog or a website you can add doctorflix.com as a widget on the same. As per my research, there are about 30 or more similar websites in this category, but this wins over in simplicity and information provided. Other websites offer other features like movies and songs download, wallpapers, etc. which is very common. Doctorflix in return concentrates more on the reviews, ratings and the blog which differentiates it positively from others. Pros:- 1. Simplicity of content 2. User friendly 3. Real-time reviews and ratings 4. Interesting categories Cons:- 1. May be they can come up with more categories like the best...

Words: 299 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Good Life. Philosophy. Blog

...In order to answer the question whether philosophical reflection essential or at least helpful to living a good life we should define what is good and bad. In the essay of Bertrand Russell it is stated that philosophy gives does not give particular answers as for example math gives. In the essay it is stated that in order to understand philosophy, people should free their mind from the prejudices of what are wrongly called ‘practical’ men (Bertrand Russell). From my point of view in this world not many things could be defined as good or bad. Good or bad things are defined by society and put limitations of people’s view. So basically, people are afraid very often to do something because of the judgment from the society. Philosophy calls to get rid of these barriers put by society. That is why I think that philosophy is essential for living good life. In Bertrand Russell’s essay is stated that “man who has no tincture of philosophy goes through life imprisoned in the prejudices derived from common sense, from the habitual beliefs of his age or his nation, and from convictions which have grown up in his mind” (Bertrand Russell). I fully agree with this statement. A good example would be taking risk by changing job. For example, you have a good job, but you were offered a new one, with better conditions, better salary and etc. However the person can be so afraid of changing something in his life or judgment of other people, that he will refuse this opportunity. Philosophy can help...

Words: 341 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Meditation

...Critical Analysis of Meditations on the First Philosophy Gage Berryman Philosophy 101 April 17, 2014 Rene Descartes writes his Meditations on First Philosophy according to God and the soul. Both of these factors are addressed in all six of his meditations. Each meditation has its own theme and main objective that contribute to its explanation. Although Descartes writing was challenging to understand, I have found sources to help clarify and back up the ideas that have been stated. I will analysis the ideas Descartes has mentioned in the first three of his meditations. The first meditation: “Of the things which may be brought within the sphere of the doubtful” In this section, Descartes states that he does not trust his senses because they are deceptive. He questions the sciences and the deceptiveness that they have within them. The only science that he believes to be truthful is arithmetic and geometry. They are based on simple objects. The other sciences are untrustworthy because they come from composite ideas. Descartes states “there is nothing in all that I formerly believed to be true” God also plays a large part in the discussion of this meditation. He believes that God is not deceptive and only speaks the truth. The journal Substance and Action in Descartes and Newton states “from Descartes's point of view, we cannot think of God as extended because God lacks geometric properties, unlike ordinary material bodies, which have shapes, and whose parts have various...

Words: 1189 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Jwhqjhq;

...patient's death.) and voluntary (When the person who is killed has requested to be killed.) euthanasia, many people dispute this as they feel that some people especially handicapped or elderly people feel they have a duty to commit euthanasia. http://www.care.org.uk/advocacy/end-of-life/euthanasia-the-arguments-for-and-against The Prime Mover 1) Aristotle’s ideas about the prime mover link in with his ideas about cause because he believes there has to be a first cause, an unchanging, eternal perfect cause which then helps the material efficient formal and final causes to come into play. 2) “the prime mover “being eternal, substance and actuality”” 1. Aristotle’s idea of the Prime Mover is explained in this quote form the book Metaphysics to be “eternal”- forever living, “substance”- a particular kind of matter with uniform properties. And “actuality”- the state of existing in reality. 3) The Prime mover “moves without being moved” and “produces motion by being loved”, This shows that the relationship between the prime mover and the world is that everything in the world is attracted to the prime mover and aspires to be like it but they can’t reach their because the prime mover exists out of time and space therefore it cannot move. 4) Aristotle...

Words: 443 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Hello

...St. Thomas Aquinas listed what he saw as five intellectual proofs of the existence of God—proofs that were dependent on reason and observation, not the revealed word of God. 1. Aquinas recognized that for motion to take place, there had to be something that interacts with it to cause it to move. This, in turn must be an infinite being outside of creation and hence is God. 2. Every effect must have a cause, if you eliminate the cause you eliminate the effect. It only posits that a God exists who is the cause of all things and who is the effect of nothing. 3. Aquinas argued that from observation, the things around him had the possibility of being (or existing) or not being. Yet, if that first being exists, he must necessarily not have the possibility of not being.  In other words, as non-existence cannot bring about existence, the first being necessarily has to have always existed.  And this entity that necessarily exists and cannot not-exist, is God. 4. Note that this is not the suggestion that we get the idea of goodness or hotness from God, but simply that there must always be something that is more good or more hot than that which we are viewing and since there is a gradation, there must always be a top to the gradation that can never be surpassed.  Such a top or asymptote, by definition, requires an infinite being, hence it must be God. 5. Fifthly, Aquinas points out that there are entities in creation that have no consciousness at all, yet still act in a regular fashion...

Words: 308 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Philosophy and Religion

...Albert Rosales Professor: Gill Intro Philosophy: 213 In writing this paper, I was apprehensive by the immensity of the task that was required of me, having never studied Philosophy and philosophers before this class and not having a good understanding of it. I could not begin to comprehend Metaphysics, Ethics Epistemology etc. if it was not for this course. This may sound ignorant but I had never really given any thought to my worldview. If asked what I believed about something I would give my belief and that was that. What exactly is a worldview? A worldview is what it sounds like. It is the way one may see the world or as Nash puts it in his book Life’s Ultimate Questions “the sum total of a person’s answers to the most important questions in life(392).” Everyone has a worldview whether we realize it or not. How does one get their worldview? Our education, our upbringing, the culture we live in, the books we read, the media and movies we watch, all can help shape our worldview. Nash says, “Worldviews contain at least five clusters of beliefs, namely, beliefs about God, metaphysics (ultimate reality), epistemology (knowledge), ethics and human nature (14).” Using these five sections I will share my worldview. In general my worldview is a Christian one. I believe that there is one God who exists in three forms who created the Heavens and the earth. In the Bible Genesis 1:1 tells of how God is the beginning of everything; he created the heavens and the earth out of nothing...

Words: 2495 - Pages: 10