Free Essay

Big Brother Is Watching You More Closely Than Ever: Cctv Cameras, the Spies in Our Midst

In: Computers and Technology

Submitted By puggi22
Words 904
Pages 4
Big Brother is watching you more closely than ever: CCTV cameras, the spies in our midst

Privacy is essential to our humanity. It permits us to shape and maintain lives, from which personal identity, selfdetermination and freedom arise. In today’s society, however, undisturbedness is mainly an illusion. The line between privacy and public space has simply become as fragile as porcelain. This is due to increased monitoring of human behaviour. In “Big Brother is watching you more closely than ever”, written by John Kampfner in 2012, it is discussed whether surveillance provides protection or disturbs the individual liberty.

A coherent structure in essence is the foundation for the written amount of text. The article consists of three components: an introduction, a body and a conclusion. Thus it achieves structural integrity. The text mostly centers on the subject of surveillance and its effect on society. To what extent the use of security cameras can be justified is, however, also a focus of attention. The major topic is presented in the introduction by using the words: “The march of CCTV cameras.” The ideas, to which the writer will adhere when discussing the theme, are likewise indicated in the introductory section. The body, where the issue is elaborated, covers the critical evidence that defends the position of John Kampfner. The documentation includes specific facts, description, quotations and references to authoritarian persons. Numerical examples are also used to support the claims. The following sentence provides proof of that: “The average person is likely to be spotted by CCTV 300 times.” By using facts as valid documentation the author appeals to the logic of the audience. The article is brought to an end with a conclusion. The conclusion attempts to persuade the reader to accept the writer’s arguments by raising a number of rhetorical questions: “But do we really want to be monitored round-the-clock, wherever we are? If the man in charge of the system is worried about Big Brother, why shouldn’t we be?”

The author’s attitude towards surveillance and its common occurrence clearly emerges from the text. The views he expresses are predominantly characterized by considerable scepticism. This assumption is supported by the phrase as follows: “Perhaps you forget, say, to pay a parking fine or your TV license, and your name has been entered on one of the many impenetrable state files. And the worst thing is that you would never know.” Furthermore, John Kampfner expresses a lack of trust towards the monitoring system by saying that surveillance cameras do not fulfil their operational function: “The cameras that are meant to make us feel safer, and to make potential criminals think twice, weren’t up to the job. If that was ever true, it certainly isn’t the case now.” In his opinion the cameras are invading and ruining privacy instead of ensuring security. A boy, who appears in the BBC news clip “Concern over Oxfordshire school cameras“, has the same view. Equally, an article in New York Times says that surveillance is detrimental and leaves people without any privacy in public.

The writer’s opinion is consistent with the attitude of Andrew Renninson, who is Britain’s first surveillance commissioner. This fact establishes ethos and improves the quality of his argumentation. In the main part of the article the efficiency of the Big Brother technology is identified. Thereby the writer’s attitude is made even more explicit: “Thanks to the state’s extensive collection of personal data, you could be walking along a crowded street and the camera could home in on you, zooming up, forwards and backwards, keeping tabs on you.” A female figure from the BBC news clip is, in accordance with John Kampfner, an opponent of CCTV cameras. This is shown by the following citation: “Cameras don’t fix human behaviour. They just monitor it.”

At some point in the text, it appears that the writer has a positive approach towards the advanced technology: “Although the camera did not prevent the crime, its images helped the police find the two boys who were later convicted of his murder.” With the author’s acknowledgement of the oppositely directed point the appeal to credibility is strengthened. Moreover, his ability to treat the topic fairly is established. The quoted passage is succeeded by a personal anecdote. This recounts a criminal offence that made him even more insecure about the purpose of investing millions of pounds in security cameras. By involving an own experience pathos is brought into action. The pathetic appeal puts the audience in a suitable mood by addressing their feelings about the subject.

It can be assumed that John Kampfner has written the article with the aim to persuade the readers to reaffirm their exiting believes about close monitoring. The appliance of different appeal forms, quotes and references to experts contribute to a convincing argumentation. It is also conceivable that the author wishes to create political awareness, so that mass surveillance can be controlled in an appropriate way. The text succeeds in fulfilling the writer’s main intentions.

On the basis of the analysis it can be concluded that the structure of the article is coherent. This is due to its division into three different sections: an introduction, a body and a conclusion. Moreover, it can be determined that the writer’s attitude towards surveillance and its dominating role in the modern society is critical. This is despite the fact that he is able to illuminate the subject from different angles.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Big Brother Is Watching You

...Big Brother is watching you more closely than ever: CCTV cameras, the spies in our midst Britain is one of the most watched-over societies in the world, with as many as two million CCTV cameras around the country. These cameras are supposedly to protect the British population, and to get criminals to reconsider what they are doing, before committing any crime. But according to John Kampfner, the author of the article “Big Brother is watching you more closely than ever: CCTV cameras, the spies of our midst”, which was published in 2012, this surveillance of the British population is a wrong way to fight crime. In the first part of his article John Kampfner writes, that if it was ever the case that security cameras were not up to their job, which is to make us feel secure, then it is certainly not the case right now. He writes about how Britain’s first surveillance commissioner Andrew Rennison has sounded a wake-up call, because he believes that most people have no idea how advanced the technology has become, and therefore also have no idea how much they are getting watched. In the next part of the text, John Kampfner mentions the Jamie Bulger case. Jamie Bulger was a two-years-old, who was abducted from a shopping centre in Liverpool. The surveillance cameras ended up leading to the conviction of the abductees. According to John Kampfner this was a great breakthrough for the police. He writes: “This was seen as a huge and very welcome breakthrough in policing. Although......

Words: 1036 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Big Brother Is...

...STX Engelsk Eksamen Delprøve 2B 2014 Analytic essay: “Big Brother is watching you more closely than ever:CCTV Cameras, the Spies in our midst. Privacy is essential to our humanity. It permits us to shape and maintain lives, from which personal identity, selfdetermination and freedom arise. In today’s society, however, undisturbedness is mainly an illusion. The line between privacy and public space has simply become as fragile as porcelain. This is due to increased monitoring of human behaviour. In “Big Brother is watching you more closely than ever”, written by John Kampfner in 2012, it is discussed whether surveillance provides protection or disturbs the individual liberty. A coherent structure in essence is the foundation for the written amount of text. The article consists of three components: an introduction, a body and a conclusion. Thus it achieves structural integrity. The text mostly centers on the subject of surveillance and its effect on society. To what extent the use of security cameras can be justified is, however, also a focus of attention. The major topic is presented in the introduction by using the words: “The march of CCTV cameras.” The ideas, to which the writer will adhere when discussing the theme, are likewise indicated in the introductory section. The body, where the issue is elaborated, covers the critical evidence that defends the position of John Kampfner. The documentation includes specific facts, description, quotations......

Words: 912 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

China Fragile Superpower

...Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Shirk, Susan L. China: fragile superpower / by Susan L. Shirk. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-19-530609-5 1. Nationalism—China. 2. China—Politics and government—2002– I. Title. JC311.S525 2007 320.951—dc22 2006027998 135798642 Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper For Sam, Lucy, and David Popkin This page intentionally left blank Contents Acknowledgments ix 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Strong Abroad but Fragile at Home China’s Economic Miracle Domestic Threats 35 13 The Echo Chamber of Nationalism: Media and the Internet 79 The Responsible Power 105 Japan: “When the Chinese People Get Angry, the Result Is Always Big Trouble” 140 Taiwan: “A Question of Regime Survival” 181 The United States:...

Words: 135807 - Pages: 544

Premium Essay

★Global Citizen ★

...JaNuaRy–FeBRuaRy 2014 23 consumer Behavior What Marketers Don’t Get About Online Reviews Itamar Simonson and emanuel rosen 78 competition The Big Lie of Strategic Planning roger l. Martin 103 risk Management The New Rules of Globalization Ian Bremmer : -( : -( ; -) : A greAt plAce to work What ideo, BlackRock, and Netflix know about building high-performance cultures Page 53 ©2013 Cartier calibre de cartier CHRONOGRAPH 1904-CH MC THE 1904-CH MC, THE NEW AUTOMATIC WINDING CHRONOGRAPH MOVEMENT, WAS CONCEIVED, DEVELOPED AND ASSEMBLED BY THE CARTIER MANUFACTURE IN THE GREATEST WATCHMAKING TRADITION. THIS MOVEMENT IS EQUIPPED WITH INGENIOUS SYSTEMS FOR UTMOST PRECISION: A COLUMN WHEEL TO COORDINATE ALL THE CHRONOGRAPH FUNCTIONS, A VERTICAL CLUTCH DESIGNED TO IMPROVE THE ACCURACY OF STARTING AND STOPPING THE TIMING FUNCTION, A LINEAR RESET FUNCTION, AND A DOUBLE BARREL TO ENSURE UNRIVALED TIMEKEEPING. 18K PINK GOLD 42 MM CASE, MECHANICAL MANUFACTURE CHRONOGRAPH MOVEMENT, SELF-WINDING, CALIBRE 1904-CH MC (35 JEWELS, 28,800 VIBRATIONS PER HOUR, APPROXIMATELY 48 HOUR POWER RESERVE), CALENDAR APERTURE AT 6 O’CLOCK, 18K PINK GOLD OCTAGONAL CROWN, SILVER OPALINE SNAILED DIAL, GOLD FINISHED CHAMFERS. ALLIGATOR STRAP. EXPLORE AND SHOP WWW.CARTIER.US - 1-800-CARTIER hbr.org January–February 2014 Contents 53 SpoTlIghT on TalENT aND PErformaNCE 54 IDEo’s Culture of helping Research at one office of the design......

Words: 59824 - Pages: 240

Free Essay

2009-Report to Congress of the Us-China E and S Review Commission

...2009 REPORT TO CONGRESS of the U.S.-CHINA ECONOMIC AND SECURITY REVIEW COMMISSION ONE HUNDRED ELEVENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION NOVEMBER 2009 Printed for the use of the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.uscc.gov dkrause on GSDDPC29 with K1 VerDate Nov 24 2008 08:23 Nov 10, 2009 Jkt 052771 PO 00000 Frm 00003 Fmt 6012 Sfmt 6602 M:\USCC\2009\52771.XXX APPS06 PsN: 52771 M:\USCC\USChina.eps Report Documentation Page Form Approved OMB No. 0704-0188 Public reporting burden for the collection of information is estimated to average 1 hour per response, including the time for reviewing instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection of information. Send comments regarding this burden estimate or any other aspect of this collection of information, including suggestions for reducing this burden, to Washington Headquarters Services, Directorate for Information Operations and Reports, 1215 Jefferson Davis Highway, Suite 1204, Arlington VA 22202-4302. Respondents should be aware that notwithstanding any other provision of law, no person shall be subject to a penalty for failing to comply with a collection of information if it does not display a currently valid OMB control number. 1. REPORT DATE 3. DATES COVERED 2. REPORT TYPE 01 NOV 2009 4. TITLE AND SUBTITLE 00-00-2009 to......

Words: 185166 - Pages: 741

Free Essay

Telco Regulation

...Tenth Anniversary Edition Tenth Anniversary Edition TELECOMMUNICATIONS REGULATION HANDBOOK TELECOMMUNICATIONS REGULATION HANDBOOK The Telecommunications Regulation Handbook is essential reading for anyone involved or concerned by the regulation of information and communications markets. In 2010 the Handbook was fully revised and updated to mark its tenth anniversary, in response to the considerable change in technologies and markets over the past 10 years, including the mobile revolution and web 2.0. The Handbook reflects modern developments in the information and communications technology sector and analyzes the regulatory challenges ahead. Designed to be pragmatic, the Handbook provides a clear analysis of the issues and identifies the best regulatory implementation strategies based on global experience. February 2011 – SKU 32489 Edited by Colin Blackman and Lara Srivastava Tenth Anniversary Edition TELECOMMUNICATIONS REGULATION HANDBOOK Edited by Colin Blackman and Lara Srivastava Telecommunications Regulation Handbook Tenth Anniversary Edition Edited by Colin Blackman and Lara Srivastava ©2011 The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank, InfoDev, and The International Telecommunication Union All rights reserved 1 2 3 4 14 13 12 11 This volume is a product of the staff of the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank, InfoDev, and The International......

Words: 132084 - Pages: 529