Free Essay

Bioenergy Crops for Illinois

In: Science

Submitted By cwss1116
Words 1017
Pages 5
Bioenergy Crops for Illinois
As everyone knows, fossil fuel is a finite resource and is the accused culprit of global warming after the industrial revolution. Yet, economic development has a strong correlation with energy consumption. Consequently, seeking and developing alternative energy resources is required to maintain our high quality lifestyles. Although food-based biofuel is a relevant mature technology and lessens our reliance on fossil fuel, it has resulted in soaring food prices. In order to decrease food versus fuel concerns and satisfy the increasing need of energy consumption, developing advanced biofuel (e.g., cellulosic ethanol, biodiesel) is pivotal.

The current U.S. Renewable Fuel Standards (RFS2) set up the goal of using 21 billion gallons of advanced biofuels as a transportation fuel by 2022. In 2010, the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) developed a regional strategy to meet the RFS2 mandate. In this report, Central-Eastern, one of the most potential regions, was expected to produce up to 9.1 billion gallons of advanced biofuel, which is near a half of the total mandate volume by 2022. Besides, it also suggests that the possible feedstock could be perennial grasses, biomass sorghum, crop residues, soybeans, and woody biomass. Therefore, the State of Illinois, in this area and known for its great agricultural productivity, should carefully consider which bioenergy cropping system is capable of meeting the mandate and more sustainable to the environment.

According to statistics, in 2010, the land in farms in Illinois was around 27 million acres or 75% of total land area, including 12.4 million acres of corn and 9 million acres of soybean. Despite the fact that USDA claimed it will only require 4.5% cropland and cropland pasture to produce enough advanced biofuel2, the land resource will be limited because of the projected population growth. Furthermore, corn production in Illinois ranked second in the country3, that is to say, the conversion of land use may dramatically affect food prices, so that an ideal bioenergy crop for Illinois should be able to be planted in marginal land and have high biomass yield.

However, merely these characteristics of bioenergy crops are not convincing enough for farmers to adopt new plants. Financial incentives are the main driving forces of their decision-making. For example, growing perennial grasses is fast to return the investment in comparison with woody crops. Furthermore, to compare with annual crops, perennial grasses demand less energy and money investment after the first year establishment. Taking these factors into consideration, I suggest that perennial grasses, such as switchgrass and Miscanthus x giganteus (Miscanthus), have more opportunities to succeed in Illinois.

Both miscanthus and switchgrass are warm-season grasses and can adapt to the cold temperature in Illinois. Yet, in terms of biomass yield, miscanthus outweighs other perennial grasses. Plant height is a crucial feature for selecting bioenergy crops. Over all, miscanthus can grow up to four meters per year, while switchgrass can only grow up to three meters. Moreover, the previous side-by-side trials demonstrated that the yield of miscanthus was three to four times higher than that of switchgrass in Illinois. The more biomass it can produce per acre, the less land it will need to produce the same amount of biofuel. Planting high yield bioenergy crops can minimize the land competing with food crops. From this point of view, miscanthus is a prospective bioenergy crop.

In addition, miscanthus seems to be able to utilize nutrients very efficiently, so it requires less nitrogen fertilizer annually than switchgrass. Khanna (2008) tried to calculate the costs of production for miscanthus and switchgrass and found that the fertilizer costs $57.39 (ha-1) for switchgrass and $40.42 (ha-1) for miscanthus per year. Applying less fertilizer is not only a financial incentive to farmers but also benefits the environment. Nitrate leaching from the cropland may contaminate groundwater by eutrophication. Also, nitrogen, a main greenhouse gas, could escape from the soil through volatilization and lead to global warming. For the reasons stated above, miscanthus is a more sustainable and economical option.

It is undeniable that miscanthus is not a perfect bioenergy crop. It still has many drawbacks that need to be addressed. For example, miscanthus is sterile, so expensive rhizomes asexual reproduction is required. Jain et al. (2010) reported that it cost approximately $1200 to establish an acre of miscanthus. On the other hand, it is cheaper to establish switchgrass because it can be reproduced by its seeds. Nevertheless, Khanna (2008) concluded that the breakeven delivered cost of miscanthus is lower than switchgrass while taking the opportunity cost of land into consideration5.

There is no single silver bullet, as the saying goes. In my opinion, monoculture over a wide area is not necessarily a good idea. It reduces the biodiversity and is more prone to pests, disease, and weather change; miscanthus in particular has low genetic diversity. There is no reason to restrict only one bioenergy crop in a certain region. For example, switchgrass, the top candidate of bioenergy crop of U.S. Department of Energy, can also be another choice for Illinois. Yet, in the current stage and single region, switchgrass does not appear to be as competitive as miscanthus in Illinois in terms of biomass yield, fertilizer application, and cost.

--------------------------------------------
[ 1 ]. Ghoniem, A.F., et al. (2011). Needs, resources and climate change: Clean and efficient conversion technologies. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science, 37(1), 15-51.
[ 2 ]. U.S. Department of Agriculture, (2010). A USDA regional roadmap to meeting the biofuels goal of the renewable fuels standard by 2022
[ 3 ]. U.S. Department of Agriculture, NASS (2011) Illinois Fact Sheet
[ 4 ]. Heaton EA, et al (2006). Miscanthus x giganteus: the results of trials alongside switchgrass (panicum virgatum) in Illinois. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign: Depart- ment of Plant Biology.
[ 5 ]. Khanna, M. (2008). Costs of producing miscanthus and switchgrass for bioenergy in Illinois. Biomass and bioenergy, 32(6), 482-493.
[ 6 ]. Jain AK, et al. (2010). An integrated biogeochemical and economic analysis of bioenergy crops in the Midwestern United States. Global Change Biology Bioenergy 2(5):217–234.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Emerging Technology: Agricultural and Animal Waste to Energy

...EMERGING TECHNOLOGY: AGRICULTURAL AND ANIMAL WASTE TO ENERGY Kathleen Cimino, Kimberly Andros, Teresa Bartley NEW TECHNOLOGIES IN ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT University of Maryland University College Spring 2009 Table of Contents 1.0 Introduction 1.1 Waste to energy definition/history/uses 1.2 Agricultural / Animal waste production 1.3 Graph, chart, quantities produced in United States, etc.. 2.0 Conversion of w2e 2.1 Conversion Pathways 2.1.1 Thermochemical 2.1.2 Biochemical 2.1.3 Physico-chemical 2.2 Factors affecting energy recovery 3.0 Agricultural Residue 3.1 Introduction to residue 3.2 What is it 3.3 Where is it produced 3.4 What is role in environment 3.4.1 Environmental risks 3.4.2 Health risks 3.5 Conversion of agricultural residue to energy 3.5.1 Process 3.5.2 Risks 3.5.3 Benefits 3.5.4 Future as energy source 4.0 Animal Wastes 4.1 Introduction to animal waste 4.2 What is animal waste comprised of 4.3 Where is it produced 4.4 What is its role in environment 4.4.1 Environmental risks 4.4.2 Health risks Table of Contents (Cont’d) 4.5 Conversion of animal waste to energy 4.5.1 Process 4.5.2 Risks 4.5.3 Benefits 4.5.4 Future as Energy source 5.0 Processes/Regulations/Technology 5.1 Availability of w2e facilities, costs 5.2 Technological benefits/risks 5.2.1 Other information on technology of w2e, production, transportation, environmental implications 5.3 Regulation governing...

Words: 8663 - Pages: 35

Free Essay

Emergingtechnology: Agricultural and Animal Waste to Energy

...EMERGING TECHNOLOGY: AGRICULTURAL AND ANIMAL WASTE TO ENERGY NEW TECHNOLOGIES IN ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT University of Maryland University College Spring 2009 Table of Contents 1.0 Introduction 1.1 Waste to energy definition/history/uses 1.2 Agricultural / Animal waste production 1.3 Graph, chart, quantities produced in United States, etc.. 2.0 Conversion of w2e 2.1 Conversion Pathways 2.1.1 Thermochemical 2.1.2 Biochemical 2.1.3 Physico-chemical 2.2 Factors affecting energy recovery 3.0 Agricultural Residue 3.1 Introduction to residue 3.2 What is it 3.3 Where is it produced 3.4 What is role in environment 3.4.1 Environmental risks 3.4.2 Health risks 3.5 Conversion of agricultural residue to energy 3.5.1 Process 3.5.2 Risks 3.5.3 Benefits 3.5.4 Future as energy source 4.0 Animal Wastes 4.1 Introduction to animal waste 4.2 What is animal waste comprised of 4.3 Where is it produced 4.4 What is its role in environment 4.4.1 Environmental risks 4.4.2 Health risks Table of Contents (Cont’d) 4.5 Conversion of animal waste to energy 4.5.1 Process 4.5.2 Risks 4.5.3 Benefits 4.5.4 Future as Energy source 5.0 Processes/Regulations/Technology 5.1 Availability of w2e facilities, costs 5.2 Technological benefits/risks 5.2.1 Other information on technology of w2e, production, transportation, environmental implications 5.3 Regulation governing w2e 6.0 Recommendations 6.1 Policy recommendations/guidelines...

Words: 8657 - Pages: 35

Free Essay

Should Congress Pass the Farm, Nutrition, and Bioenergy Act of 2007?

...of billions of dollars annually committed to agricultural and food policies” (18). Now the controversy and social problems—as seen by each side—are introduced. The Farm bill is responsible for funding numerous food related programs, such as subsidies, the food stamp program, and also the farmer’s safety net, to name just a few. Where this money goes and how it is spent reflects what the United States values, and what it is defining as a social problem. Some supporters of this bill maintain that this bill provides financial security not only to agriculturalists but also to consumers as well. They believe that this bill promotes an increased emphasis on of conservation, and that it also encourages efforts to explore the merits of bioenergy. The value placed on conservation, cleaner, more efficient energy sources, and the financial protection of American citizens is paramount to most supporters of the 2007 Farm Bill. Proponents also argue that the bill is necessary for a country to provide a financial safety net for the men and women that are providing food for this country. Other supporters maintain that this single bill is crucial to preserving our forestry, wildlife, and farm lands. Meanwhile, groups against the legislation argue that what is...

Words: 15532 - Pages: 63

Premium Essay

Zara

...Department of Agricultural Economics, Texas A&M University, 600 John Kimbrough Blvd, 2124 TAMU. College Station, Texas, 77843-2124, U.S.A. b f a Professor, Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering, Room 127, Hobgood Building, Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas, 77843, U.S.A. Abstract This paper analyzed the economic feasibility of a mobile bioenergy pyrolysis system using a Monte Carlo simulation model. Pyrolysis transforms any cellulosic materials into i) a bio-oil similar to crude oil ii) a synthesis gas similar to natural gas, and iii) a bio-charcoal substance. The pyrolyzer machine is currently being manufactured and tested with various types of feedstocks including corn stover and energy sorghum. The economic analysis focused on creating an automated process that integrates a transportation logistics cost optimization model with geographic information system (GIS) data. The geographic data provides possible paths for the mobile bioenergy pyrolysis unit as it moves to and from each harvest area, depending on stochastic availability of feedstock (determined by historical crop yields) and distance to oil refineries. The results indicated that there is a low probability of a positive Net Present Value (NPV) with current economic conditions. In general, the NPV was highest with a stationary scenario and it decreased with...

Words: 4491 - Pages: 18

Free Essay

Microwave-Assisted Enzymatic Hydrolysis of Rice Straw Using Effective Microorganisms for Bioethanol Production

...develop alternative renewable fuel to replace the current and existing petroleum-based fuels. Biofuels have been demonstrated by several researches to reduce GHG emissions as compared to gasoline (petrol) (Leen, 2012). Among the alternative biofuels, bioethanol has received considerable attention in transportation sector because of its utility as an octane booster, fuel additive, and even as neat fuel (Mudliar, et. al., 2009). Bioethanol can be derived from organic materials, such as energy crops like corn, wheat, sugar cane, sugar beet, and cassava, among others (Neves, et. al., 2007). However, due to their primary utility as food, these crops cannot provide the global demand for bioethanol production. Among other feedstock for bioethanol production, biomass has been reported ideal and well-suited because of its large-scale availability, low cost, and environmentally benign production (Brodeur, 2011). Feedstock biomass is an organic matter that can be converted into energy from crop residues and agricultural wastes like rice straw (Bracmont, 2012). Rice straw is consists predominantly of cell...

Words: 10036 - Pages: 41

Premium Essay

Gmos: Truth vs. Myth

...GMO MYTHS AND TRUTHS An evidence-based examination of the claims made for the safety and efficacy of genetically modified crops Michael Antoniou Claire Robinson John Fagan June 2012 GMO Myths and Truths An evidence-based examination of the claims made for the safety and efficacy of genetically modified crops Version 1.3 by Michael Antoniou Claire Robinson John Fagan © Earth Open Source www.earthopensource.org 2nd Floor 145–157, St John Street, London EC1V 4PY, United Kingdom Contact email: claire.robinson@earthopensource.org June 2012 Disclaimer The views and opinions expressed in this paper, or otherwise published by EOS, are those of the authors and do not represent the official policy, position, or views of other organizations, universities, companies, or corporations that the authors may be affiliated with. GMO Myths and Truths 2 About the authors Michael Antoniou, PhD is reader in molecular genetics and head, Gene Expression and Therapy Group, King’s Cols: lege London School of Medicine, London, UK. He has 28 years’ experience in the use of genetic engineering technology investigating gene organisation and control, with over 40 peer reviewed publications of original work, and holds inventor status on a number of gene expression biotechnology patents. Dr Antoniou has a large network of collaborators in industry and academia who are making use of his discoveries in gene control mechanisms for the production of research, diagnostic and therapeutic products...

Words: 78055 - Pages: 313

Premium Essay

Isi List

...ISI, IBSS & SA DHET - FOR 2012 SUBMISSION TITLE LIST COUNTRY ISSN E-ISSN PUBLISHER'S DETAILS Subject classifaction International Accreditation - SA JOURNALS 4Or-A Quarterly Journal Of Operations Research ISI SCIENCE A + U-Architecture And Urbanism ISI ARTS & HUMANITIES A Contrario IBSS Aaa-Arbeiten Aus Anglistik Und Amerikanistik ISI ARTS & HUMANITIES Aaohn Journal ISI SCIENCE Aaohn Journal ISI SOC SCIENCE Aapg Bulletin ISI SCIENCE Aaps Journal ISI SCIENCE Aaps Pharmscitech ISI SCIENCE Aatcc Review ISI SCIENCE Abacus: Journal Of Accounting, Finance And Business Studies IBSS Abacus-A Journal Of Accounting Finance And Business StudiesISI SOC SCIENCE Abdominal Imaging ISI SCIENCE Abhandlungen Aus Dem Mathematischen Seminar Der UniversISI SCIENCE Abstract And Applied Analysis ISI SCIENCE Abstracts Of Papers Of The American Chemical Society ISI SCIENCE Academia-Revista Latinoamericana De Administracion ISI SOC SCIENCE Academic Emergency Medicine ISI SCIENCE Academic Medicine ISI SCIENCE Academic Pediatrics ISI SCIENCE Academic Psychiatry ISI SOC SCIENCE Academic Radiology ISI SCIENCE Academy Of Management Annals ISI SOC SCIENCE Academy Of Management Journal ISI SOC SCIENCE Academy Of Management Journal IBSS Academy Of Management Learning & Education ISI SOC SCIENCE Academy Of Management Perspectives ISI SOC SCIENCE Academy Of Management Perspectives IBSS Academy Of Management Review ISI SOC SCIENCE Academy Of Management Review IBSS Academy Of Marketing Science Review IBSS Acadiensis...

Words: 151197 - Pages: 605