Free Essay


In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By snowryder1
Words 779
Pages 4
His name may not be as common as Socrates or Plato, but Boethius’s work in philosophy and logic deserves a place in bookshelves right along these titans of thought and contemplation. Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius (born: circa 475–7 C.E., died: 526? C.E.) has long been recognized as one of the most important intermediaries between ancient philosophy and the Latin Middle Ages. The senator, philosopher, and prisoner spent his life in Rome. He belonged to the ancient Roman family of the Anicii, which had been Christian for about a century and of which Emperor Olybrius had been a member. Boethius’s father had been consul in 487 but died soon afterward, and Boethius was raised by Quintus Aurelius Memmius Symmachus, whose daughter Rusticiana he married. He became consul in 510 under the Ostrogothic king Theodoric. Although little of Boethius’s education is known, he was evidently well trained in Greek. His everlasting work, The Consolation of Philosophy, was written while he was awaiting an execution for treason he may not have even committed.
Many people consider The Consolation of Philosophy one of the most time proven works of philosophy ever. This work helped to reshape numerous popular ideas in Europe at the time, and many of its principles still hold true even today. It is thought many believe that it is a commentary on Christianity even though it never mentions Christianity in itself; however it does lend itself towards Christian beliefs and Boethius was also known for his work with the church. While not necessarily a religious problem, Boethius spends a great deal of time contemplating evil; more specifically if God is perfect in his goodness, and is the unity of all things rules the world, how is it that evil is allowed to exist and is not always punished? In addition, where wickedness flourishes, virtue is often downtrodden and even stamped out. If God is omniscient and omnipotent and beneficent how can this evil continue in His world?
When Boethius contemplates the evil going on in the world, he is torn between what the church says to do versus what is really going on all around him. How could such evil men become so successful, while he himself (whom he considered a good man) be imprisoned, and eventually put to death, for a crime he did not even commit? In the end, Boethius comes to the highly optimistic conclusion that man is in fact not inherently evil. He in fact believes exactly the opposite, man is born good, but throughout life by performing sinful action man can become evil. Boethius compares evil to disease, and throughout life he is known to show love and compassion, whereas others would not, to sinful people. Boethius believe that naturally man is good and innocent, it’s only when the corruption of evil enters the picture that man becomes evil. This brings up another of his contemplations; does man really have free will or is his fate predetermined?
Boethius’s ideas on good versus evil hinge on the idea that man actually has free will. He argues with himself if mankind truly possess free will; and if not does man have a predetermined destiny that God has laid out before him at birth. Just like before, this topic bears heavy religious significance. In the end, Boethius’s contemplation tells us even if the future is already ordained (actually not ordained, since, to God, it has already happened) we still must strive to join ourselves with our Creator through prayer. We are temporal creatures, and we can only understand things in a temporal way. This doesn't mean we can't participate in eternity by striving to be one with God. Both The Consolation of Philosophy, along with many of Boethius’s other works, helped to shape philosophy and logic yesterday as well as today. His work is some of the most inspirational work known to date. Boethius’s ideas were not only influential in the Middle Ages, but are still heavily discussed today; many people live today by the principles laid down by these immortal thoughts and contemplations.

[ 1 ]. Marenbon, John, "Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius", The Stanford Encyclopedia of 1 1 1-1 1. Philosophy (Summer 2013 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), URL = .
[ 2 ]. 2 "Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius". Encyclopædia Britannica. Encyclopædia Britannica Online.
Encyclopædia Britannica Inc., 2013. Web. 20 Nov. 2013
[ 3 ]. Elizabeth Hayes Smith. Miller, W.C. ed. "The Consolation of Philosophy Study Guide: Summary and Analysis of Book IV". GradeSaver, 07 July 2007 Web. 20 November 2013.
[ 4 ]. Elizabeth Hayes Smith. Miller, W.C. ed. "The Consolation of Philosophy Study Guide: Summary and Analysis of Book V". GradeSaver, 07 July 2007 Web. 20 November 2013.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay


...Boethius was an influential philosopher; poet; translator and Politian. While in prison Boethius wrote an influential book ‘The consolation of Philosophy’. Within this book it consists of a dialogue between Lady Philosophy and Boethius as characters discussing many topics such as; the problem of evil; the relationship between divine foreknowledge and human free will. Boethius had many discussions and views example of these are; the idea of divine foreknowledge; eternity the two types of necessity and to prove that God rewards and punishes justly. Boethius concept of God links to the idea of the Platonic God. God is not part of the temporal world and as a result of this; time does not pass for him as it does for us. This links in with Aquinas’s view of divine foreknowledge is different for us to God. This is a traditional concept of God who is wholly; simple; immutable and perfect. This can be argued to be a realistic view of God because the idea of change and perfection is questioned today therefore if God was in time this would mean God is not perfect as being able to change makes being lose what they once had. Firstly, in the Book ‘The consolation of philosophy’ Boethius argued that God knows the past; present and future. Boethius described this as God’s foreknowledge however; Boethius argued that although God has this foreknowledge he does not cause the future to happen. Boethius argues that God sees our timeline of our life as it is progressing in one timeline.......

Words: 929 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


...Al-Ghazali Reflection The section of Deliverance from Error in the readings of The Path to Sufism is very fascinating to me. The way Al- Ghazali speaks in his teachings is very different from that of Boethius and Aristotle. Al- Ghazali expresses his support for mathematics almost as an exact science, he shows that it cannot be used to support religions whether they be Islamic or not. This type of truth is called Apodeictic, which can be defined as truth by definition or necessity, which can also include logic, math and Astronomy. The other type of truth that Al- Ghazali speaks of is conjectural truth. This can be described as truth by speculation, which means that something can be assumed to be real, true, or genuine. An example of a conjectural truth can be Doctor’s advice. Both apodeictic and conjectural truths come from Al- Ghazali’s view of Philosophy, and can prove all of his thoughts true. One word that I found to be an important part of Al- Ghazali’s Deliverance from Error is the word Fitra. Fitra can be defined as a fundamental spiritual interest. Fitra has many different interpretations, some of which include creation, nature, natural disposition, constitution, and temperament. I believe that Fitra can be the driving spirit that directs people in the right path. I think that Fitra can relate to apodeictic truth because people believe what they see, and if they see something out of the ordinary that shouldn’t happen, they will not believe it and have to...

Words: 326 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

St. Thomas Aquinas

... Magi,  1966).     Major  Commentaries  on  Aristotle,  Boethius  &  Others     Thomas  Aquinas,  Saint  Thomas  Aquinas:  Commentary  on  the  Nicomachean  Ethics,  trans.  C.I.   Litzinger,  2  vols.  (Chicago:  1964;  reprint  Notre  Dame:  Dumb  Ox  Books,  1993).     Thomas  Aquinas,  Commentary  on  the  Metaphysics  of  Aristotle,  trans.  J.P.  Rowan,  2  vol.   (Chicago:  1961;  reprint:  Notre  Dame:  Dumb  Ox  Books,  1995).     Thomas  Aquinas,  Commentary  on  Aristotle's  Phyiscs,  trans.  Richard  J.  Blackwell,  Richard  J.   Spath,  and  W.  Edmund  Thirlkel  (New  Haven:  Yale  University  Press,  1963;  reprint:  Notre   Dame:  Dumb  Ox  Books,  1999).     Thomas  Aquinas,  An  Exposition  of  the  On  the  Hebdomads  of  Boethius,  trans.  Janice  L.  Schultz   and  Edward  A  Synan  (Washington,  DC:  Catholic  University  Press  of  America,  2001).     Thomas  Aquinas,  Faith,  Reason,  and  Theology.  Questions  I-­‐IV  of  His  Commentary  on  the  De   Trinitate  of  Boethius,  trans.  Armand  Maurer  (Toronto:  Pontifical ......

Words: 1919 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Philosopher Profile

... -soul deciding, monist, privation, free will Iranaeus -soul making, dualist, spiritual growth, free will Anselm -faith first then reason -ontological argument -god is ultimate perfection Cullman - God lasts for “endless duration” NOT timeless Whitehead, Hartshorne -process theology Descartes - God can do everything, logically possible or not -can doubt body not soul (what is doing the thinking) Anthony Kenny -narrow omnipotence, only logically possible things -“eternal present= incoherent” Plantinga -God limits power to maintain free will - beliefs don’t need rational justification - omnipotent god may equal God limiting his powers Geach -almighty god Ockham -Ockhams Razor -Absolute&Ordained powers of god Boethius -Lady philosophy -lib of spontaneity/indifference -divine free will VS freedom of human will -god is timeless Plato - forms, perfection -dualism- body soul distinction -arguement for knowledge (K is innate) -cycles of opposites (light needs dark to exist, body needs soul) Calvin -humans, sinful -predestination Kant - faith over knowledge -we cannot know God empirically Dawkins -materialist, neo-darwinist -soul one (traditional soul), soul two ( intellectual, not separate to body) -legacy Aristotle -soul is not “extra” - plant,animal, human soul -rationality survies death Ryle - soul belief is a category mistake, Descartes is assuming the soul is something extra Blackmore -chemical reactions from dying......

Words: 588 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Unhappy Life When No One Wills to Be Unhappy

...PAGE 23) b. How would the Consolation of Philosophy answer this question? vii. Book III is taken up with the proof of God’s existence viii. Based on the inadequacy of human desires to produce true happiness ix. Being capable of perfect happiness-in fact the source of that perfect happiness is innate and no human beings attain it through earthly goods, and the source of that perfect happiness must exist outside the earthly realm x. Emphasis is on the futility of seeking happiness through earthly desires xi. Examples of earthly desires: wealth, power…etc… xii. True Happiness is the pursuit of God through intellectual and spiritual means. It is considered the supreme good by Boethius and the only good worth pursuing. xiii. All earthly goods are false goods, and only our spirit and intellect can lead us to the true good of the soul; God. xiv. Lady Philosophy contends that happiness comes from within and that ones virtue is all that one truly has, because it is not imperiled by the vicissitudes of fortune. xv. According to The Consolation of Philosophy is acquired by attaining the perfect good. xvi. Man is often in the dark about what true happiness is because he spends so much time chasing goods that are not perfect goods. xvii. Whatever mistakes and poor decisions man makes, he is still striving, however poorly, to attain happiness xviii. All goods are......

Words: 568 - Pages: 3

Free Essay


...vorbire (Wittgenstein) Actul de vorbire (Austin) Discursul (Habermas) Rationalitatea Întemeierea Sofismul genetic Sofismul functional Întemeiere si rationament Întemeiere si explicatie Validitate si adevar Identitatea (Principiul identitatii) Consistenta (Principiul noncontradictiei) Consecventa (Principiul tertului exclus) Întemeierea (Principiul ratiunii suficiente) Abordarea predicativa si abordarea propozitionala Termenul si structura sa Raporturi între termeni Determinarea si generalizarea Regulile definitiei Definitii nominale Definitii reale Diviziunea Clasificarea Operatii mereiotice Propozitia interogativa Propozitia axiologica Propozitia deontica Propozitia cognitiva Tabloul clasic al propozitiilor (Kant) Inferenta Patratul logic (Boethius) Conversiunea si obversiunea Contrapozitia si inversiunea Rationamente teoretice si rationamente practice Rationamente nemodale Regulile silogismului categoric 2 Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Ø Sensul demonstrativ al figurilor silogismului categoric Modurile silogismului categoric Entimema si epicherema Polisilogismul si soritul Silogismul disjunctiv Silogismul ipotetic Dilema Rationamente inductive Rationamente abductive (Peirce) Demonstratia si felurile ei Regulile demonstratiei Argumentarea si structura ei Erori semantice Erori logice Erori cognitive Metodele inductive de aflare a cauzelor (Mill) Teoria stiintifica 3 ...

Words: 552 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Music Genre Paper

...throughout each one of them in similar ways. Greece was the root of all Classical art, so it is no coincidence that Classical music is rooted in Grecian innovations (Hollis, 2012). In 600 BCE, famed mathematician Pythagorus dissected music as a science and developed the keystone of modern music: the octave scale (Martinez, 2010). After Pythagorus was discovered with his great ideas of creating notes and sounds Aristotle wrote about the theory of music scientifically. Boethius made the next step in music evolution in 521 (Hollis, 2012) who allowed each musician to create their own folk songs and sounds for their land. He also was the first to write on the idea of the opera. As far as music schools are concerned, Pope Gregory had this created in 600 in Europe and China was not far behind with allegedly creating orchestras of musicians that performed for assorted dynasties (Hollis, 2012). Once the printing press was first used in 1465 then composers could organize and publish their pieces and Boethius’ writing were the first to be printed and republished in Italy in 1490. Music has developed and had many contributors to the evolution in which it shares today. There are many well-known contributors who have created new sounds and will forever be remembered in years to come. Had it not started out as just a beat on a rock it may be something completely different, as we know it to sound today. There are many composers that have created music that will never be......

Words: 2063 - Pages: 9

Free Essay


...European’s Contributions to the Number system/Numerical system. This project also shows, you famous mathematicians, and more so sit back, read and enjoy this project. (1) History of European Mathematics During the centuries in which the Chinese, Indian and Islamic mathematicians had been in the ascendancy, Europe had fallen into the Dark Ages, in which science, mathematics and almost all intellectual endeavour stagnated. Scholastic scholars only valued studies in the humanities, such as philosophy and literature, and spent much of their energies quarrelling over subtle subjects in metaphysics and theology. From the 4th to 12th Centuries, European knowledge and study of arithmetic, geometry, astronomy and music was limited mainly to Boethius’ translations of some of the works of ancient Greek masters such as Nicomachus and Euclid. All trade and calculation was made using the clumsy and inefficient Roman numeral system, and with an abacus based on Greek and Roman models. By the 12th Century, though, Europe, and particularly Italy, was beginning to trade with the East, and Eastern knowledge gradually began to spread to the West. Robert of Chester translated Al-Khwarizmi's important book on algebra into Latin in the 12th Century, and the complete text of Euclid's “Elements” was translated in various versions by Adelard of Bath, Herman of Carinthia and Gerard of Cremona. The great expansion of trade and commerce in general created a growing practical need for mathematics, and......

Words: 985 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Worship Manual

...society of the time. Indeed, much of medieval scholarship was found in the monastic and cathedral schools. Early Church Fathers who were also considerable scholars (and wrote extensively on music) include Augustine, Boethius (ca. 480524), Isidore of Seville (ca. 560-636) and Cassiodorus. It was Cassiodorus who founded a monastic school in Italy around 554 AD at a time when secular scholarship was not widely encouraged. The real impetus in education and musical development was provided by Irish and Scottish monks in the 7th and 8th centuries, under whom the monastic schools amassed important libraries. This was no doubt in part because all books had to be copied by hand on to parchment or vellum and were therefore highly time-consuming and costly to produce - only the church really had the resources and scholars to produce them. Of particular importance was the work of Eriugena (Johannes Scotus Eigena, 810-886 AD). All these writers share a common influence in the Ancient Greek scholars such as Pythagorus, Plato, Aristotle and Dionysius (later writers gaining access to them 9 For a flavour of Eastern monasticism see The Sayings of the Desert Fathers, transl. Benedicta Ward, Mowbray, 1975. 3-11 through the earlier works of Augustine, Boethius and others). The Mediaeval world view was therefore heavily influenced by Platonism. Faulkner points out that Eriugena, in particular, adopted the Platonic view that the philosopher/theologian was the best......

Words: 23268 - Pages: 94

Free Essay


...God engage with the world? Terrance Tiessen in his book Providence & Prayer explores eleven theological models that discuss the relationship between God and humanity. Inevitably these models contain overlapping and interweaved concepts namely; creation, the nature of God, the powers and limitations of God, human will, freedom and predestination, the role of prayer and suffering. To answer the question ‘Hoe does God engage with the world?’ this essay will logically progress through these concepts highlighting particular models where relevant. The first point is that God is the creator and thus is not bound by the limitations experienced by creation. As creator He is outside and beyond our concept of time (Tiessen, 2000, p. 190). Boethius puts this nicely “as the complete and perfect possession at once of an endless life” (Tiessen, 2000, p. 190.) As creator, he established a set order of natural law in which the world operates (Jeremiah 31:35-36). As creator He is attributed ownership and lordship of His creation (Psalm 24:1-2). The Bible establishes a paradigm where God is distinct from creation in substance, knowledge, time and power. God’s nature outside of creation renders Him special knowledge. The various models differ in their descriptions and extent of this knowledge and link it inseparably to human freedom (Ariel, 2005). Process theology and the openness model would argue that God does not know with absolute certainly the future (Tiessen, 2000, pp.......

Words: 1666 - Pages: 7

Free Essay


... What follows is an account of Occam’s razor, its being rooted in Occam’s position on the problem of universals and the distinction he draws between the knowledge capable of being reasoned and the understanding based solely on faith. His ethical and political views are touched and a few comments are made about the impact and relevance of his views in the Middle Ages. The beginnings of what has come to be classified as the ‘Medieval period ‘ in the historical discourse on philosophy lie in the latter period of the Roman Empire . St Augustine ( c.354-43- AD) can be said to have been the first philosopher of note who drew on Christian theology to develop his philosophical standpoint. The medieval period extends from Boethius and Augustine right up to the 17 the century, so that it becomes a long, intriguing and important phase in the philosophical thinking of the west. The term ‘medium aevum’(Latin for ‘the middle period’), was coined in the Renaissance period to point to what was then looked down upon as the rather inactive and irrational period between the end of ancient era and the progressive , ‘modern’ period. This period, as per common academic practice, is divided into three stages : The early ( c. 4th century AD – 12th century AD) , the high (c.12th century AD-13th century AD) and the late (14th century AD- 17th century AD) middle ages. The early part of the middle period was dominated by a subscription to Platonic tendencies......

Words: 3058 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay


...empire, including in Rome itself. Boethius In Rome, Boethius propagated works of Greek classical learning. Boethius intended to pass on the great Greco-Roman culture to future generations by writing manuals on music and astronomy, geometry, and arithmetic.[6] Several of Boethius' writings, which were largely influential during the Middle Ages, drew from the thinking of Porphyry and Iamblichus.[7] Boethius wrote a commentary on the Isagoge by Porphyry,[8] which highlighted the existence of the problem of universals: whether these concepts are subsistent entities which would exist whether anyone thought of them, or whether they only exist as ideas. This topic concerning the ontological nature of universal ideas was one of the most vocal controversies in medieval philosophy. Besides these advanced philosophical works, Boethius is also reported to have translated important Greek texts for the topics of the quadrivium. His loose translation of Nicomachus's treatise on arithmetic (De institutione arithmetica libri duo) and his textbook on music (De institutione musica libri quinque, unfinished) contributed to medieval education.[8] De arithmetica, begins with modular arithmetic, such as even and odd, evenly-even, evenly-odd, and oddly-even. He then turns to unpredicted complexity by categorizing numbers and parts of numbers.[9] His translations of Euclid on geometry and Ptolemy on astronomy,[10] if they were completed, no longer survive. Boethius made Latin translations of......

Words: 50148 - Pages: 201

Premium Essay

The Knight Tale as the “First Mover” speech, then ordered Emelye to marry Palamon after a funeral ceremony honoring Arcite: and the Knight’s story finishes on a happy note. Analysis It is very likely that the Knight’s Tale was written before the Canterbury Tales as a whole project was planned, and so it has the unusual status of being both a part of the tales as a whole, but also a separate work of literature in its own right (though the text has been adapted into the Tales – lines 875-92). It is a very free adaptation of a story by an Italian writer, Boccaccio, whom it seems clear Chaucer very much admired. Chaucer – as he regularly does – hugely compresses the story into the Tale, and adds material heavily influenced by his philosophical hero Boethius (including Theseus’ “First Mover” speech). The Tale is undoubtedly a romance as Chaucer presents it, supposedly a true history of many hundreds of years ago told by an authoritative, high-status figure (in this case the Knight). Yet Chaucer never merely adopts a literary tradition without commenting on it, and the oddities of the Tale often lie in the way it over-stresses the traditional things expected of a romance of its genre. For example, the question of status (raised at the end of the General Prologue when the Host – perhaps duplicitously – has the Knight picked as the first teller) and rank is immediately raised by the progression of the tale. The Knight begins not with the main characters of the tale, Arcite and Palamon, but......

Words: 1689 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Hum 111 Quizzes

...made up nearly one-tenth of the empire's population • Question 3 4 out of 4 points What is the symbolic heart of a Roman domus? Correct Answer: The atrium • Question 4 4 out of 4 points Why was the Arch of Titus constructed? Correct Answer: To celebrate Titus's sack of the Second Temple of Jerusalem • Question 5 4 out of 4 points To what two groups does Roman culture trace its origins? Correct Answer: The Greeks and the Etruscans • Question 6 4 out of 4 points Why was the Nicene Creed so important? Correct Answer: It unified the church behind a prescribed doctrine. • Question 7 4 out of 4 points Which of the following did Boethius consider the highest form of music? Correct Answer: Musica mundana • Question 8 4 out of 4 points Why did the San Vitale artists depict their subjects in reverse perspective and in shallow space? Correct Answer: To reject earthly illusion for the sacred space of the image • Question 9 4 out of 4 points Why had Judaism split into three distinct sects by the early first century CE? Correct Answer: Difference in philosophy and key religious beliefs • Question 10 4 out of 4 points Why was early Christianity syncretistic, incorporating into itself pagan mythic traditions? Correct Answer: To convert pagans by presenting Christianity in their......

Words: 1934 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Canterbury Tales and the Panchatantra: Two Frame Narratives Contrasted

...varied collection of literary genres: courtly romance, racy fabliau, saint's life, allegorical tale, beast fable, medieval sermon, alchemical account, and, at times, mixtures of these genres. Because of this structure, the sketches, the links, and the tales all fuse as complex presentations of the pilgrims, while at the same time the tales present remarkable examples of short stories in verse, plus two expositions in prose. In addition, the pilgrimage, combining a fundamentally religious purpose with its secular aspect of vacation in the spring, made possible extended consideration of the relationship between the pleasures and vices of this world and the spiritual aspirations for the next, that seeming dichotomy with which Chaucer, like Boethius and many other medieval writers, was so steadily concerned. The word Panchatantra means the "Five books," the Pentateuch; it was written by an extremely shrewd Brahmin by name Vishnu Sharman. Each of the five books is independent, consisting of a framing story with numerous inserted stories, told, as fit circumstances arise, by one or another of the characters in the main narrative. Thus, the first book relates the broken friendship of the lion Rusty and the bull Lively, with some thirty inserted stories, told for the most part by the two jackals, Victor and Cheek. The second book has as its framing story the tale of the friendship of the crow, the mouse, the turtle, and the deer, whose names are Swift, Gold, Slow, and Spot.......

Words: 2772 - Pages: 12