Premium Essay

Bosman Case

In: Business and Management

Submitted By kuromint
Words 36127
Pages 145
Bachelor Thesis for the discipline European Studies:

The effects of the Bosman-case on the professional football leagues with special regard to the top-five leagues

Bachelor Thesis Supervisor: Prof. Dr. Ramses A. Wessel Co-Reader: Dr. Tsjalle van der Burg Word count (Text only): 25686 Daniel Schmidt Helbecker Weg 30 58769 Nachrodt Germany daniel18schmidt@web.de

Student number: s0146773

12.07.2007

1

Table of Contents:

I List of Abbreviations…………………………………….………………….………………6

1.Introduction………...…………………………………………..…………….…..…………7

2. EU Sport politics and Sport Law……………………………………………...…...……9

2.1 Council of Ministers and Sport …………………………………….…,……10

2.2 The ECJ…………………………………………………………………....…….11

2.3 Walrave and Koch………………………………………………………….…..11

2.4 The Dona Case…………………………………………………..…………..….12

2.5 The legal situation for sport before the Bosman case……………..…...13

3.The Bosman Case………………………………………………………………….……..14

3.1 Transfer rules before Bosman…………………………………………….... 14

3.2 Jean-Marc Bosman………………………………………...………….……….15

3.3 The basic of the judgement ………...………………………………….…….16

3.4 Reactions of officials……………..………………………………….………..19

2

3.5 Ideas and outlooks of scholars for the future after the judgement…...20

3.6 Immediate results of the Bosman case……………..…………………...…21

4. Cases after Bosman…………………….…………………………………...…….…….22

4.1 The Lehtonen Case…………………………….……………………….……...23

4.2 Kolpak Case…………………………………………………………….……….24

4.3 Simutenkov Case…………………………………………………..…….…….25

4.4 Summing up of the cases after Bosman………………………..………….26

4.5 Politics and Sport after Bosman…………………………………..………...26

5. Implementation of the Bosman Case………………………………………..………..27

5.1 Direct Implementation after the ruling……………….………….………….28

5.2 The slow process of adjusting the teams……………………….…..…….28

5.3 Harry van der Meer and…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Economic Justification for High Salaries in Sport

...into the area of Labour Economics, and hence the determinants of supply, demand and wages for labour. In this essay, I will be looking at the unique example of the Sports Labour Market with specific focus on the European Football Market, and use various economic models to justify the huge salaries currently offered to top athletes within this field. The wages of professional footballers have risen dramatically since the Bosman ruling in December 1995, in which EU football players were given the right to a free transfer at the end of their contracts, with the provision that they were transferring from a club within one EU Association to a club within another EU Association (European Commission, 2012).This has been supported by various studies, including (Simmons, 1997), who argued that the move towards a free agency had the consequent impact of increasing players’ salaries, as the forgone transfer fees translate into increased salaries, since the bargaining power is transferred to the player. This was reinforced by (Downward, 2000) who found that post-Bosman, the wages within the United Kingdom’s Premier League rose considerably. However, these findings conflict with other studies conducted, including (Szymanski, 1999), who argued that the new ruling only lead to increased wages for superstar players who have the greatest bargaining power, and that it did not affect the wages for the average player. During this essay I will first discuss the basic economic principles......

Words: 2605 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Supply Chain Risk

...are caused by not having alternative solutions set in place in the case that things do not end up going according to plan. The fifth risk is cultural risks that “are caused by a business's cultural tendency to hide or delay negative information, and such businesses are generally slower to react when impacted by unexpected events” (Queensland government, 2013). Whether a company’s supply chain gets hit by and expected risk or an unexpected risk it is all about how the business can handle. What processes or plans has the company gone over in order to bring the company back to a normal state of functioning. WEF (2013) describes this with a term called resilience, “which is the ability of the system to return to its original state after a major disruption,” (p. 19). The way this is achieved is through strategic risk management techniques. Even though there are many types of risk that can have an impact on the supply chain network there are ways companies can cope or mitigate those risk. In fact a good question was asked by Bosman (2006) asking “How can companies manage the many risks to which modern supply chains are vulnerable, particularly when that supply chain might stretch from Singapore to Seattle, Wash., USA?” (p. 4). It is easier to say that risks can simply be managed than actually doing it. Although several risks exist there are strategies that can be put into place to minimize the risks involved. Bosman also follows up with an answer stating “understanding how those......

Words: 1558 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Daily Mail Case

...Daily Mail (Case 81/87, 27 September 1988) Daily Mail was a tax-law case. Daily Mail plc wanted to move its de facto head office (tax residence) to the Netherlands because of the more favourable tax regime there, while at the same time it planned to remain a company subject to UK company law. The UK Treasury Department refused permission for the transfer of seat, which is necessary under UK law. EC law implications Because of the refusal of the UK Treasury Department to allow the transfer of the de facto head office, Daily Mail referred the question to the ECJ, whether Articles 43 and 48 EC Treaty preclude a member state from obstructing the transfer of the de facto head office from a member state. Decision of the court The ECJ concluded that this issue falls outside the scope of the Treaty provisions on freedom of establishment. Moreover, the Court added obiter dictum some comments regarding several conflicts of law questions. The Daily Mail judgment was recently confirmed by the Cartesio decision (see below). Centros (Case C-212/97, 9 March 1999) Two Danes established Centros Ltd under UK company law. The company was trade only in Denmark, however. The incorporators clearly stated that they had established the entity under UK company law solely to avoid the minimum capitalisation requirement for Danish limited liability companies. The Danish commercial registry considered this to be an unlawful circumvention of the Danish minimum capitalisation rules and so refused......

Words: 2779 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Overpaid Baseball Players

...pie. Mergers and acquisitions, alliances, cross-promotion, enormous advertising expenditures, staggering media contracts, and a host of other phenomena are used as a means of retaining competitive advantage among teams, among corporations, and among media and advertising players. People who believe that athletes are paid fairly look at the... View Full Essay Join Now Please login to view the full essay... Essay's Statistics Submitted by: skhaga Date shared: 03/01/2011 06:56 PM Words: 547 Pages: 3 Save Paper Report this Essay Similar Documents Overpaid Atheletes Kansas City Zephrys Baseball Club, Inc. Case Study Freud’s Lifespan Development And Personality The Use Of Performance Enhancing Drugs In Sports Perception Of The Athlete In Modern American Society Steriods Other Attribution Theory Nothing Sports Pr Bosman Case Functions Of Management Not Your Everyday Hero Persuasive Essay Comm/215 Rich Dad Guide To Investing Robins & Robins Sues Casings, Inc., Ggggg Tainted Idols Introduction To Sabermatrics Jack Johnson...

Words: 436 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Probabtion and Punishment

...Assignment 3: Probation and Punishment Dedra Clark Strayer University Professor Berry 8 March, 2016 This paper was prepared for CRJ100 Abstract The purpose of this paper is to provide a comprehensive analysis of probation and prison programs and amenities Introduction Classification plays a crucial role in parole and the probation process by deciding the type of rehabilitative strategy that the offender has to adapt to in the process of correction. Classification systems were utilized after sentencing in order to appropriately determine and plan the offender’s treatment and management. This paper will analyze a probation case study, ISP programs, and prison programs and amenities. Review of Kris’ file At the age of 13 years, Kris was given probation because of being involved in a battery case. He was arrested for trespassing during his juvenile probation hence accorded additional time in probation as a consequence of his actions. He is currently 25 years old and has completed his probation successfully. He however has a recent adult conviction for which he is being sentenced. My findings equate to Robert’s findings which elaborate that parole boards determine when an offender is rehabilitated from crime and ready to rejoin liberal society. Our findings additionally agree on the fact that it is the work of supervising officers to advice parolees and probationers besides ensuring that the recommended interventions are being undertaken. The role of......

Words: 916 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Africas Contribution to the Development of Diplomacy

...like Asante for example, is an epic requiring the welding together of separate Akan communities and states, into a single political unit. The evolution of its constitution, Ajayi argues, called for high diplomatic skills such as is credited to the genius of the statesman warrior King Osei Tutu, and the magical powers of his divine counsellor, Okomfo Anokye. It called for the use of inherited ideas in the creation of new institutions of inter-state coordination such as the confederal army, the elaboration of the idea of the Golden stool and of ritual usages and traditions of common origin. (Ajayi, 1976:78) There are other numerous examples of state formations, but not all have yet been put together in such detail as the Asante case. However, most state systems in West Africa as in other parts of Africa, meant the bringing together of disparate groups. Perhaps, it is imperative to consider the workings of Yoruba state-system, or the composition of the more diversified Benin imperial structure to realise the diplomatic effort required to keep them together. The remoter periods of the formation of these West African states and empires have not always been studied in depth. This can be attributed to the difficulty of recovering the essential details of diplomatic manoeuvres and procedures from the oral traditions. In the later periods of expansion, the issues of external relations of these imperial systems become clearer. The dealings between the Benin Kingdom and its......

Words: 1897 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Harvard

...Real Madrid Club de Futbol Real Madrid Club de Futbol Case Study by Kurt Eschbacher Abstract The case study is about one of the best known and best playing soccer team in the world, Real Madrid. It tries to backlight the myth of soccer and the tremendous merchandising system behind soccer. Especially the era of Florentino Pérez, who brought a new dimension in managing and merchandising soccer clubs to Spain, will be analyzed in detail. soccer The game What makes a team like Real Madrid so interesting for sponsors and fans worldwide? What makes soccer so interesting for us? Soccer is the world’s most popular sport. Nearly every child kicked a soccer ball once in his live. More than 240 million people play at least once a week. Such a big sport needs a big parent organization in its background. This job is done by the Fédération Internationale de Football Association (FIFA). The FIFA which was founded 1904 in Paris established a unified set of rules. This rules are easy to understand and are of course one of the reasons why soccer is so popular all over the world. Also the time a soccer game lasts is defined by the FIFA, its two halves of 45 minutes split by a 15 minute brake. In elimination games an overtime of two times 15 minutes and also a penalty shoot-out at the end of overtime is possible. This is a big advantage for sponsors and TV broadcasts compared to other sports like American football or......

Words: 1588 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Jgfs

...Joshua Bosman Professor Brown ENG102/9:55am 10/2/14 Concussions in Sports “As Larry got checked out by doctors’ moments ago, he re-enters the game on offense as the Cardinals attempt to win the game.” Concussions are becoming a huge topic in all four major sports leagues, The National Football League (NFL), Major League Baseball (MLB), National Basketball Association (NBA), and the National Hockey League (NHL). Most of the concussions do tend to happen in football or in hockey, but even boxers, professional wrestlers, Mixed Martial Artists (MMA), and soccer players have been diagnosed with concussions. “Over 250 current or retired athletes - including 50 NFL players and 12 hockey players - have pledged to donate their brains, including Keith Primeau, who retired from the NHL in 2006 due to post-concussion syndrome” (McIlroy and Mick). That itself is a pretty crazy number and that is just in the past five years. That kind of shows how committed to fixing and understanding the concussion crisis is upon us. Concussion protocols in all sports needs to be redefined. There have been concussion protocols for the NFL and NHL that have been put into place since the frequency of concussions started happening. Teams across the nation and even world have started to employ neurologists for when a player gets a concussion so that the proper steps are taken. Usually a player has to sit out if he has failed a part of the concussion test. Recently an Arizona Cardinals player named......

Words: 2087 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Catfish

...the end of the show when Dr. Phil asked, “Are you still going to talk and chat with him?” She nodded her head with a yes. People not only get their wallets scammed but their emotions and their life also. It is not an easy process to make a person forget about someone they have loved for a long time. Victims will live in their own world by creating these false fantasy lives that they are hoping to have in the future because all of these scammers have made promises and swear to God that they will come and marry these hopeless women or men. Some people will even stop socializing with other people because they think that they have found the part they are missing in their life. Sometimes this means even giving up time with their family. In the case of Norma and also and many others, she stopped visiting her daughter and her grandson all together; all for someone was deceiving her. They will spend more and more time sitting and chatting with this fake person without realizing that they are sinking into a deep dirty mud. As a result people have to raise awareness in order to prevent this issue. Online websites still can help a person’s situation, only if they are used in the right way. People should be educated before going into the online dating world, and be extremely aware of the consequences. People needs help these victims from getting scammed. According to the Telegraph News, “One in every ten people have fallen victim to financial fraud, losing an average $ 1,000 a year......

Words: 2254 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Business Strategy

...is considered average (Medium-high). Since Amazon is big organisation having several product lines and sectors, they need to be stocked appropriately, if they fall short of stock, it may have adverse effect on their reputation. Amazon is having partnerships with Target, Borders and office depot (Askville. Amazon, 2012), which makes them to have enough stock at right time and right place. Threat of substitutes: Threat of substitutes for Amazon is considerably high for almost all products and services except Amazon’s 1-click ordering which is patented. (The Register, 2011) Amazon’s substitutes could be those who are brick and mortar stores also having online service facility, such as, Barnes & Noble’s Borders, Target and Office Depot. (Bosman J, 2012) In addition other substitutes could be eBay.com, walmart.com, bestbuy.com, kohls.com (US) and lowes.com (US). There are several websites which provides electronics, apparels, music collection, kitchen items, DVD, toys and games. Customers may choose to buy goods from others but they may not give good customer service as Amazon has done over the years. In 2011 Amazon is topped in giving good customer service (Whitney, 2011) Managing Strategy 10 Amazon STRATEGIC CAPABILITIES Strategic capability means capacity of any organisation to employ competitive strategies that assist the businesses to survive, lead and raise its value over time. It not only takes into account, competitive strategies of business, but also, its assets,......

Words: 5866 - Pages: 24

Free Essay

Lang Leve de Lezer

...en daarmee teleurstellende leeservaringen voorkomen” (Stalpers, 2002, p. 192) en zijn ze beter geïnformeerd over welke boeken er in omloop zijn. In de Verenigde Staten loopt een gelijkaardig project volgens het onderzoek van Gilbert en Fister (2011). Een ander project volgens hetzelfde principe, dat ook succes kent in de Verenigde Staten, is de boekenclub. Studenten lezen hetzelfde boek en komen samen om hun meningen te delen met elkaar. Ook boekenlijsten, uitbreidingen van de bibliotheekcollectie, aparte ruimtes in de bibliotheek voor recreatief lezen, langere uitleenperiodes in vakanties en het openhouden van de schoolbibliotheken tijdens de vakanties zijn manieren waarop lezen volgens Gilbert en Fister (2011) bevorderd kan worden. Bosman, Glover en Prince (2008) startten in 2005 een blog om de collectie van de bibliotheek te promoten en om aan te geven welke boeken beschikbaar zijn in de bibliotheek. Zowel bibliotheekmedewerkers als bezoekers kunnen op de blog boekbesprekingen schrijven. De methode komt ook bij het onderzoek van Gilbert en Fister (2011) voor. Meer promotie van recreatief lezen was het doel en ook zij maakten onder andere gebruik van een blog. Leesbevorderingsprojecten in Nederland zijn echter niet uitgebreid. Zij gaan vooral terug op de beschikbaarheid en bereikbaarheid van de boeken. “Wanneer boeken duidelijk ingedeeld zijn en op een aantrekkelijke manier aangeboden worden, zullen lezers sneller iets vinden dat aansluit bij hun behoeften en......

Words: 14202 - Pages: 57

Premium Essay

The Uninvited Brand

...brands, identify relevant brand communities, and build peer-to-peer relationships within which they can collaborate and share brand information. While some social media brand favorites like Apple and Starbucks are predictable given their sizable offline fan bases, others are more surprising. For example, 196 to receive them. People are motivated to cull their social networks to grant the offer’s needed scale and scope. BuyVIP.com, Gilt.com, and Rue La La are other businesses that entice consumers to build shopper communities in order to earn ‘mobdeals’: discounted merchandise available for short time periods, only to those in the club. Targeted programs can also be designed to focus the power of the collective on brand objectives, as in the case of the Paramount/DreamWorks movie, Paranormal Activity. Via the company’s Fans Demand It promotion, Paramount Pictures (2009) committed to releasing the movie nationwide if 1 million consumers banded together online to command it. Backed by a groundswell of pre-formed demand, the film garnered stature as one of the most profitable movies of all time. President Barack Obama is wellknown for focusing the power of the collective to garner support for his own and the Democratic Party brands. Starting with an online campaign that raised funds through shared social networks and encouraged the spread of campaign messaging, the President now uses his own site to blog and solicit citizens’ comments on proposed legislation, YouTube to......

Words: 12470 - Pages: 50

Premium Essay

The Uninvited Brand

...brands, identify relevant brand communities, and build peer-to-peer relationships within which they can collaborate and share brand information. While some social media brand favorites like Apple and Starbucks are predictable given their sizable offline fan bases, others are more surprising. For example, 196 to receive them. People are motivated to cull their social networks to grant the offer’s needed scale and scope. BuyVIP.com, Gilt.com, and Rue La La are other businesses that entice consumers to build shopper communities in order to earn ‘mobdeals’: discounted merchandise available for short time periods, only to those in the club. Targeted programs can also be designed to focus the power of the collective on brand objectives, as in the case of the Paramount/DreamWorks movie, Paranormal Activity. Via the company’s Fans Demand It promotion, Paramount Pictures (2009) committed to releasing the movie nationwide if 1 million consumers banded together online to command it. Backed by a groundswell of pre-formed demand, the film garnered stature as one of the most profitable movies of all time. President Barack Obama is wellknown for focusing the power of the collective to garner support for his own and the Democratic Party brands. Starting with an online campaign that raised funds through shared social networks and encouraged the spread of campaign messaging, the President now uses his own site to blog and solicit citizens’ comments on proposed legislation, YouTube to......

Words: 12407 - Pages: 50

Premium Essay

Africa

...cultural interaction. Such efforts can take on different forms, including regional cooperation, market integration, development integration, and regional integration. African leaders have long envisaged regionalism as a viable strategy to pursue with a view to uniting the continent both politically and economically. While regionalism in Africa has taken on different forms to accommodate the changing national, regional, and international environment, all organizations that aim to integrate regional economies in Africa have adopted market integration as a component of their strategy, with a view to increasing intra-regional trade. Market integration is the linear progression of degrees of integration beginning with a free trade area (or in some cases a preferential trade area) and ending with total economic integration. The model for such integration is the European Union (EU). Notwithstanding the fact that market integration has failed miserably on the continent,1 it continues to be highly regarded by most African leaders as a solution to Africa’ growing marginalization within the world economy. The creation of NAFTA s (North American Free Trade Agreement) and the movement toward EU monetary integration, only served to reinforce the commitment African leaders have toward market integration. In response to these events, the member states of the Organization of African Unity (OAU) in 1991 signed the Abuja Treaty creating the African Economic Community (AEC), which calls for the......

Words: 11675 - Pages: 47

Premium Essay

The Ford Motor Company’s Supply Chain Management

...” (8, p.1) By allowing the suppliers to work in close proximity to Ford and other suppliers more ideas will be communicated between companies and any problems can be immediately identified and dealt with accordingly. This new concept of a supply park is something that Ford has used in the past as it has established supplier parks at plants throughout Europe. (1) Ford saw an opportunity to become more efficient in North America as its market share was slipping, by bringing the majority of its suppliers together the Ford Motor Company is able to keep most of its supplies in front of it and maximize control and save money as shipments to the factory have to travel less distance to reach the destination point. In its Chicago business case, “previous to the supplier park, the average number of miles traveled by the supply system was 460. The average now is only 120 miles.” (8, p.2) This allows for a greater cost reduction as Ford is able to save money on transportation costs and suppliers save on shipping and fuel expenses. The ability to cut costs is extremely important because it The Ford Motor Company’s Supply Chain Management 9 allows for greater profits and more flexibility for the company to devise strategies necessary for reaching its desired outputs. Furthermore, another perk of the supply park is that “suppliers are linked together more productively – becoming an integral extension of the plant, responding in broadcast and building in sequence.” (8, p...

Words: 4991 - Pages: 20