Free Essay

Buck V Bell

In: Historical Events

Submitted By JSteve2013
Words 482
Pages 2
A Sterilizing Decision

Jordan Stevenson
Period 4
Supreme Court Cases
Mr. Packer

Buck v. Bell was the worst Supreme Court decision made in the 20th century. The whole court case was about eugenics. It all took place in 1924 in Virginia. Virginia just got done passing a law authorizing compulsory sterilization of the mentally handicapped. If you were an alcoholic, a petty criminal, or an epileptic you were considered in the “feeble minded” category. If you fell in this category you would have two different outcomes. The first one was sterilize the person for the betterment of society. The second option was you would be left alone and have your rights entitled to you as an American citizen. The whole case dealt around with the idea of the right to reproduce. People thought that the feeble minded were unfit to reproduce and therefore, not have the right to do so. Carrie Buck, who was 18 years old, lost her inalienable rights even though she couldn’t control it. Buck v. Bell is looked at as a landmark case because it violated the U.S. Constitution’s 14th amendment. It also violated the 5th amendment stating that Carrie Buck’s right of due process of law. The final decision that they came up with was in favor of the defendant. Justice Holmes, the man who gave the verdict, said that it was just to sterilize the feeble minded for the good of society. After the decision was made more than 30 states made their own sterilization laws. As a matter of fact, Germany made their own eugenics laws that were almost similar to Virginia’s. Back in the 1970’s is when the last of any eugenics laws were terminated. Having made this decision, it should’ve been the other way around.

Personally, the Buck v. Bell case was overlooked in my opinion. To say that it is ok to sterilize the feeble minded is completely outrageous. Everyone in this country has the same rights as the next person in line, being feeble minded shouldn’t change that. People who do have a family background of having eugenic disorders shouldn’t be looked at as somebody who should be treated so harsh like Carrie Buck and her mother was. Sterilizing someone who has a disorder is wrong and shouldn’t have happened. Simple tests to see if they can ever handle themselves is ok in my opinion but sterilizing someone who probably doesn’t know why this is happening to them is just plain wrong. In closing, Buck v. Bell and the decision that came out of it was a mistake. They should’ve gone in the favor of Carrie Buck not just because of her being feeble minded but because it has been happening to everyone who was feeble minded. That many people who were sterilized is appalling and something completely different should’ve been decided in this court case.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

U.S Supreme Court Case Buck V. Bell

...Crime and Deviance Revision SCLY 4: Crime and Deviance with Methods in Context Sociology Department Greenhead College SCLY 4: Crime and Deviance with Methods in Context Remember: You have to revise everything, because you have no choice on the exam paper. The specification 1 Different theories of crime, deviance, social order and social control * Different definitions of crime, deviance, social order and social control * The distinction between sociological theories of crime and other theories (eg biological, psychological); crime and deviance as socially constructed * Functionalist theories of crime: Durkheim, anomie, collective conscience; Merton’s strain theory; manifest and latent functions; functionalist subcultural theories * Marxist and neo-Marxist theories of crime: classical Marxism, laws reflecting class interests; Neo-Marxism, hegemony, the CCCS studies, critical and new criminology * Interactionist theories of crime: labelling theory, the self-fulfilling prophecy * Feminist theories of crime: patriarchy, male control of women’s lives * Control theory and other contemporary approaches to crime: social bonds, communitarianism, situational prevention; postmodern theories; Foucault on individualisation and surveillance * Realist theories: New Left Realism and Right Realism * The relevance of the various theories to understanding different types of crime, and their implications for social policy. 2 The social......

Words: 25825 - Pages: 104

Free Essay


...procedure and ruling in my opinion creates an interesting example of American arrogance or at very least shows a clear short sighted mentality. After doing research I found that 30 states at the time of the Buck v. Bell case had passed legislation in favor of sterilization. It was not as if Virginia was on the fringe of the country on this topic, it was rather widely held that sterilization in an effort to prevent “feeble minded” persons from having children was a positive idea with merit. It was an idea that many people in the country saw as a useful way to handle these people and the idea of their procreating. Many influential people during the time even saw the procedure as a positive, such as Helen Keller. I think the Helen Keller example truly shows how much the entire country latched onto the idea of wiping out mental illness but taking away reproductive rights. When a woman who went through all the hardships that Keller did can come out and agree with legislation such as this it is clearly a popular and widely held idea. This thought process toward the so-called feeble minded during that time period interests me greatly. During Hitler’s reign many Americans saw many, if not all, of his actions to be morally reprehensible. Yet it was this same idea used in the Buck v. Bell case that was used by Hitler. The Nazi party would even directly give credit to acquiring the idea from the state of Virginia. While the Nazis would take it a step farther and sterilize people......

Words: 576 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Leg 500

...Court legitimized state–sponsored sterilization in the name of eugenics in its landmark decision of Buck v. Bell. Carrie Buck was sent to the State Colony of Epileptics and the Feeble–Minded in Virginia to have a child conceived when she was raped by the nephew of her foster parents. At that time, Virginia permitted sexual sterilization when it was determined that a patient or “inmate” was afflicted with hereditary forms of in- sanity or imbecility. The authors of the law designed it to prevent the reproduction of “mentally defective” people in the best interest of the patient and society. Buck was ordered sterilized against her will. Dr. Albert Priddy (superintendent of the State Colony for Epileptics and Feeble–Minded) and Aubrey Strode (counsel for the State Colony and drafter of Virginia’s sterilization law) chose Buck as the test case for the new law.... In its case, the State of Virginia simply analogized the forced sterilization to compulsory vaccinations. In 1927, the U.S. Supreme Court...dismissed Buck’s concerns. An employee of the Eugenics Record Office studied Buck’s medical records and concluded that she exemplified the “shiftless, ignorant, and worthless class of anti–social whites in the South.” Despite her appeals to the highest court in the land, Carrie Buck could not be spared from the cruelest corruption of Darwin’s theories. The Court emphasized that Carrie Buck was the daughter of a “feeble–minded” mother and the mother of an “illegitimate”......

Words: 1480 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Eugenics and Beneficence

...historically associated with programs put in place by the government of Nazi Germany (1933-1945), however, that government actually took for a model the programs already in place in the United States, one of the earliest and most enthusiastic adapters of the idea. Between 1907 and 1979, more than 60,000 Americans were legally sterilized, often without their knowledge or consent. The vast majority of these people were those deemed by officials to be “feeble-minded”, “imbeciles”, “retarded” or were criminals. Beginning with Indiana, thirty-one states eventually adopted compulsory sterilization laws, and in 1927 the Supreme Court of The United States in Buck v. Bell decided in favor of the State of Virginia, which, under the auspices of its Racial Integrity Act of 1924, had performed involuntary sterilization on citizen Carrie Buck, a seventeen year-old rape victim who, after giving birth to her first child, was committed to the Virginia Colony for Epileptics and the Feeble Minded and sterilized. (Kaelber, 2012) Beneficence is one of the ethical principles to which all registered nurses must adhere. Beneficence in the most basic sense is simply doing good. While “good” may have different interpretations to different people, every health-care profession subscribes to the notion that it must act in the interest of doing good. Indeed, from the ancient Hippocratic Oath to the current iteration of the American Nurses Association’s Code of Ethics for Nurses, beneficence is an......

Words: 1951 - Pages: 8

Free Essay


...**Tongue depressors x 5 **1 penny and 1 paperclip **Instrument for sharp/ dull (more tongue depressors) **Tuning forks: 128 Hz and 512 Hz **Penlight **Triangular reflex hammer **Centimeter ruler *please read below before purchasing **Pocket Snellen eye chart **PA class sells packets that contains all these CARDIOLOGY-GRADE STETHOSCOPE: ~$ 140-160  Get at least a cardiology-grade stethoscope: has a diaphragm, bell, and dual lumen. Plan to spend at least $140. Examples: 1. Littman: Cardiology III: pediatric side can be a bell or can adjust pressure on diaphragm ~$140160, Master Cardiology ~$185 (is single sided and NOT necessary) 2. Heine: Gamma C3 Cardiology ~$140 3. Welch Allyn: Tycos Elite ~$140 4. MDF: Procardial C3 ~$162  Your stethoscope will be used to hear heart murmurs, lung sounds, bruits--- things not always so easy to hear. You will not be working in sound proof environments. DO NOT skimp in this area or you’ll just buy another one because you can’t hear anything.  Chest piece can be two sided: bell (low pitch) and diaphragm (high pitch) or single sided. We suggest for ease of use that you purchase a scope with a two-sided chest piece  Should have replaceable, multi-size ear tips, esp if you have small ear canals!  Multiple tube colors and different chest piece finishes available; get whatever color you desire. Get a name tag piece to identify yours or you can get it engraved. SPHYGMOMANOMETER (Blood Pressure cuff)......

Words: 1204 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay


...“The German Law for the Prevention of Defective Progeny for the Science of Racial Cleansing.” (Kuhl, 1994) (Laughlin, 1936) 5. The eugenic idea was a social philosophy which claimed all human genetic traits can be improved through social intervention Sterilization 1. Legally mandated cleansing allow the state to enact regulation to allow sterilization of the “socially inadequate” (Lombardo, 1982). 2. Includes: a. the feebleminded, prior criminals, epileptic, inebriate, diseased, blind, deaf, deformed, and in any way dependent to incorporate orphans, ne’er do wells, tramps, homeless or impoverished. 3. The first recognized success for the American Eugenic Party over a U.S. citizen a. The case for Carrie Buck i. 17yo, unmarried mother, first sterilized, Virginia ii. the law’s description as a “probable, potential parent of socially inadequate offspring.” (Lombardo, 1982) 1. Additionally: impoverished, feebleminded mother with epilepsy, a resident of a local asylum. 2. Carrie was supposed to have shared the traits genetically transmitted through her mother’s heredity. (Lombardo, 1982) 4. “It is better for all the world, if instead of waiting to execute degenerate offspring for crime or let them starve for their imbecility; society can prevent those who are manifestly unfit from continuing their kind.” –Judge Oliver Wendell Holmes, US Supreme Court Justice. 5. The US Supreme Court......

Words: 1516 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

History Review

...For example, if Sharecropping were a term, you would want to both define it and also explain the consequences of sharecropping, what it meant for ex-slaves, that it was part of the failure of social reconstruction, etc. Wounded Knee The US government wanted to ban Indian Culture such as the Ghost Dance Freedmen’s Bureau Working Class Dawes Act Open Door Haymarket Emilio Aguinaldo Progressivism Espionage Act The Grange William Jennings Bryan The Great Uprising Pullman Pure Food and Drug Act Mark Twain W. E. B. DuBois Eugene Victor Debs Overproduction Populists V. I. Lenin Surplus Capital Upton Sinclair Federal Reserve Act The Lusitania Part II: From the Readings (20 points) You will be given three terms from the material from As They Said It (chapters 1-2) and American Society since 1900 (chapters 1-2, but only through the end of “Buck Versus Bell”), of which two you will need to address TWO. These terms will be titles of specific selections from the two readers. You MUST demonstrate knowledge of the reading material and not simply try to respond based on lecture material. When explaining the significance of the term, however, you will want to connect it to broader themes/events from the lectures and textbook. As you read, pay attention not only to a summary of each term based on the content from the readers, but also the meaning behind arguments presented in the selections; be ready to explain the significance of each......

Words: 704 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Marketing Services Ebay Customer Service

...industry, and the high fees indicated that the services standard would be adequate. Type of encounters that occurred * Remote Encounters: Email the customer service support team * Technology-Mediated Encounters: Person-to-person phone call between customer and provider Source of pleasure/displeasure | Satisfying | Dissatisfying | 1) Recovery | Acknowledges the problem, and explain the situation by person-to-person phone call. | Provider appeared as if there nothing was wrong. Ignores the customer request to speak to a manager.Customer left to fend for self. | 2) Adaptability | Explains polices & rules briefly. | Ignores or undervalues need. Provider also unwilling to try and solve the problem. Passes the buck onto an automated email response service | 3) Spontaneity | Takes time to listen & respondProvides information on whom to contact if more information is required on the situation. | Shows impatience and got frustrated really easily.Rude to customer with a patronizing tone. | 4) Coping | Listens to the situation | Provider customer behavior personally- acted rude and impatient towards the situation. | Dimensions of the servqual scale Measuring service quality using the servqual scale can assist in determining what part of the customer service dimensions did not meet the expectation of the customer and what improvement can been drawn out by examining the five dimension exclusively (Gremler et al., 2013, p87). Reliability:...

Words: 3374 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Social Darwinism

...or after birth." The plan of the eugenics' movement was that since the poor had these genes for feeblemindedness, which led them to misery, vice, and crime, the obvious solution to American social problems was to sterilize them, and restrict the immigration from poorer countries (Marks, 2010). The concept of eugenics was created in the late 1800s by British scientist Sir Francis Galton. The mindset at that time was to use genetic selection used in breeding thoroughbreds and other animals to create a class of people who were free of inferior traits. Indiana became the first state in the nation to pass a eugenics law in 1907. In 1927 the Supreme Court case of Buck v. Bell moved the eugenics' movement further along when the court ruled that the state of Virginia could legally sterilize teenager named Carrie Buck. Buck was sent to the Virginia State Colony for Epileptics and for being Feeble-minded because her foster parents deemed her a moral delinquent. After this ruling the eugenics' movement in America gained a lot of momentum with in the United States, 33 states adopted some form of sterilization programs, which first targeted many individuals in mental institutions. However, as the years passed the definition of an unfit person expanded to include: alcoholics, epileptics, criminals, the deaf and blind, people on welfare, women labeled as being promiscuous, the feeble-minded, and children who were victims of rape. It's estimated that 65,000 Americans were sterilized......

Words: 3138 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Aaa Bbb

...el ow v short a (a) The short a (a) sound is made by opening the mouth wide. The teeth are apart, with some of the top and bottom front teeth shown. The sides of the tongue touch the bottom back teeth. Note: In the International Phonetic Alphabet, the short a (a) sound is pronounced: æ 6 Africa (af ri k ) Africa is the large continent between the Atlantic and Indian Oceans. It is a land of deserts, safaris and jungles. apple (ap l) An apple is a round, edible fruit with red, yellow or green skin and firm, white flesh. astronaut (as tr nät) An astronaut travels into space in a rocket to explore the solar system. 7 CLICK HERE el ow v medium a (ä) The medium a (ä) sound is made by opening the mouth and pushing the lips outward to form an oval. The teeth are apart, with some of the top and bottom front teeth shown. The tongue is in the middle of the mouth. Hint: Medium a (ä) sounds like short o (o). It is often written as ah, au, or aw. Note: In the International Phonetic Alphabet, the medium a (ä) sound is pronounced: a 8 almanac (äl m nak) An almanac is a yearly calendar containing information about the weather, astronomy, tides and other miscellaneous data. almond (äl m nd) An almond is a brown nut shaped like a teardrop. It is the nut eaten most often thoughout the world. auto (ä t ) An auto, also called a car, is a vehicle with four wheels and an engine which can be driven long distances. 9 CLICK HERE el ow......

Words: 8265 - Pages: 34

Free Essay

Canadian Companies

...* Banff Lodging Co * Bank of Montreal * Bank West * Barrick Gold * Bard Ventures Company * BBC Kids (television) * BC Biomedical Laboratories Ltd. * BC Hydro * BC Research Inc * Becancour Silicon (silicon manufacture) * Bell Canada * Bennett Environmental * Becker's * Ben Moss Jewellers * Big Blue Bubble (software firm) * BigPark (software firm) * Biovail * BioWare (video games) * Bison Transport Inc. (Transportation) * Black Diamond Cheese Limited * Black Hen Music (record label) * Black Photo Corporation * BlackBerry (wireless devices) * Blake, Cassels & Graydon (law firm) * Blackburn Radio * Bleeding Art Industries (special effects) * Blenz Coffee * Blue Water Studios (recording studio) * Bombardier Inc. * Bombardier Recreational Products spun off as an independent company in 2003 * Boeing Canada * Boston Pizza * Book City (Canada) * Bowring Brothers * Boyd Group Income Fund (Service) * Bre-X * Brightlight Pictures * Brookfield Asset Management (assorted activities) * Bridgewater Bank * BrightSide Technologies (display technology) * Brock Solutions * Buck or Two Extreme Retail, Inc. (retail) * Buckley's * Buhler Industries Inc. (Manufacturing) * Bullfrog Power (Low carbon domestic & business electricity supplier) * Brick Brewing Company * Bruce Power * Brunet (pharmacy) *......

Words: 1925 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Summary Reaction

... while gender is the social categories or role is the perceived behavioral outcome from association with a particular social category. As children our sexual orientation determined how we were raised, boys were taught to be masculine, tough, wild, and emotionless; while girls were feminine, pretty in pink, hair and nails, supple, it’s ok to cry. This is what make men so competitive and what puts them at a social advantage over women. Raising children solely based on sex/gender roles potentially creates social anticipated behavior such as sexism and homophobia. (59-60) The Male Role Stereotype—Doug Cooper Thompson The male identity make up is exposed in this piece. The six male role stereotypes: Act tough, Hide emotions, Earn big bucks, Get the right kind of job, Compete intensely, Win at all cost. No one should be surprised to learn that conforming to these standards has high failure to success rate. When measuring up to these types of expectations, heavily favors failure. Society is tough on whoever is supposed to be in the drivers’ seat… excuses will not be accepted (85-86). Why Are Gay Men So Feared?—Dennis Altman Bonds between men tend to be stronger than those between men and women. Lines of distinction are drawn, the natural gender roles of men and women are set; however, with the introduction of homosexuality these lines become threatened. Homophobia is the mask worn by tight nit groups of men in order to conceal their insecurities; thereby, ensuring......

Words: 2674 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Subway Restaurant Marketing Analysis and Research

...with hedonistic standard of living and strong focus on own appearance. Subway offers quick service, fresh and healthy food such as salad, fresh personalize sandwiches and soups that is fulfills their demand, wants and needs. 4.0 POSITIONING The existing positioning provides a spanking new solution to each day dining, with its sandwiches deems to be fresh also made without delay right in front of the customer. Moreover, Subway also positions itself as a fast-food chain offering a healthy and solution and a unique dining experience to customers. PART B 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.0.1 Brief History Fred DeLuca founded Pete’s Super Submarines in 1965 when he was 17 years old with his friend named Peter Buck in Bridgeport, Connecticut. DeLuca made $1,000 loan from Buck with hope the infinitesimal sandwich shop would earn enough to put him through college. After being under pressure all the way through the first few years, both founder changed the company’s name to Subway also in the year 1974, it began franchising. Subway offers a fresh and healthy alternative to fast-food industry. Moreover, Subway has 38,363 outlets in 99 countries around the globe. 1.0.2 Mission Statement “ Mission is an organization’s rationale for excising at all and/or its long term strategic direction and/or it’s values; its basic function in terms of the products and services the organization produces for it’s clients” (CIM, 2005). Subway’s Mission Statement: “Delight every customer so......

Words: 4377 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

International Law

...failure to enact the necessary implementing legislation or law may impose upon it international responsibility, as in the case of the Alabama claims. On the other hand, should its local legislation arrogate to itself privileges not permitted by international 7. Secretary Bayard in 1887 remarked: "This Department has contested and denied the doctrine that a government may set up the judgment of one of its own courts as a bar to an international claim, when such judgment is shown to have been unjust or in violation of the principles of irnternational law." Mr. Bayard to the President, Feb. 26, 1887, VI MooRE's DIcST" (1906) 667. See also, Mr. Bayard to Mr. Hall, Nov. 29, 1886 (1887) FOR. REL. 81; Howland (U. S.) v. Mexico, Apr. 11, 1839, Moore's Arb. 3227; Mather and Glover (U. S.) v. Mexico, July 4, 1868, Moore's Arb. 3231. 8. The law-breaker cannot always be dealt with as efficiently as in municipal law, whose law-breakers also frequently escape. But there are many pressures on states to observe international law, and the departure is usually profusely explained, if possible, even in time of war. No international law violations escape detection, as do municipal violations. VIRGINIA LAW REVIEW [Vol, 27 law, it will -be bound either to make restitution or to pay damages throught arbitration or diplomacy.' In the United States the courts are by the Constitution bound to give effect to treaties which even an aggrieved individual may invoke. In England. the rule is......

Words: 5052 - Pages: 21

Free Essay


...something to happen. Over the Top:  Very excessive. P Pass The Buck:  Avoid responsibility by giving it to someone else. Pedal to the metal:  To go full speed, especially while driving a vehicle. Peeping Tom:  Someone who observes people in the nude or sexually active people, mainly for his own gratification. Pick up your ears:  To listen very carefully. Pig In A Poke:  A deal that is made without first examining it. Pig Out :  To eat alot and eat it quickly. Pipe Down:  To shut-up or be quiet. Practice Makes Perfect:  By constantly practicing, you will become better. Pull the plug:  To stop something. To bring something to an end. Pulling Your Leg:  Tricking someone as a joke. Put a sock in it:  To tell noisy person or a group to be quiet. Q Queer the pitch:  Destroy or ruin a plan. R Raincheck:  An offer or deal that is declined right now but willing to accept later. Raining Cats and Dogs:  A very loud and noisy rain storm. Ring Fencing:  Seperated usual judgement to guarantee protection, especially project funds. Rise and Shine:  Time to get out of bed and get ready for work/school. Rome Was Not Built In One Day:  If you want something to be completely properly, then its going to take time. Rule Of Thumb:  A rough estimate. Run out of steam:  To be completely out of energy. S Saved By The Bell:  Saved at the last possible moment. Scapegoat:  Someone else who......

Words: 3089 - Pages: 13