Free Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures

In:

Submitted By azyriabrianna
Words 1437
Pages 6
Business Ethics across cultures
The first of the two articles that will be reviewed for this paper is by Tamar Lewin of the New York Times. In August of 2001 thirty Nigerian families sued the large drug company Pfizer in the Federal Court of the United States. The families alleged that Pfizer conducted an unethical trial on their children during the meningitis epidemic of 1996
The Pfizer Company sent a research team to the Infectious Disease Hospital in Kano, Nigerian in 1996 to test an experimental antibiotic, Trovan, on 100 children that had come down with meningitis. Pfizer want to ascertain whether this drug would be effective on the disease; until this point the drug had never been tested on children. For their control group Pfizer administered the very best treatment, ceftriaxone, too 100 other children. The suit states that Pfizer did not even administer the full dose of the ceftriaxone. The results from this trial left 11 children dead and many others brain damaged, paralyzed, or deaf. Pfizer’s only comment on the suit was that the fatality rate was less from the trial, than the overall fatality rate from the epidemic. Their spokeswoman also said that the trial had been a humanitarian mission and not a self-serving action. The suit against the company however, states that the company took opportunity from the chaos caused by the crises. They were able to quickly test a potentially dangerous drug without proper approval. The suit also claims that Pfizer also falsified document to later prove that they had the backing of the Hospitals ethics committee.
The trial was conducted at the same hospital where Doctors Without Borders were administering free treatment with the internationally recommended and cheaper antibiotic chloramphenicol. The suit further states that the company did not gain the informed consent of the parents and children; they were not even offered the chance to refuse and take the recommended treatment that was also being offered for free at the hospital; this act alone violates international law. According to the article many of the children were not even given proper diagnostic tests to make cretin the even had meningitis, did not receive follow up care, or have their treatment changed when it was found to be ineffective. Many of the parents did not even know that their child had been given the experimental drug or that they had been part of a trial. They were only told that Pfizer was giving their children volunteer relief.
Nigeria has also filed a law suit against Pfizer and has developed the National Health Research Ethics Committee (NHREC). The NHREC of Nigeria now has United States Federal Wide Assurance. This means that the committee proceeds according to the National Code and reviews protocols and these protocols must meets the requirements of United States Federal Government funded research. This will help insure the safety of the people. Companies wanting to conduct research in Nigeria will now need to make sure that their proposal has been approved by the United States ethics committee.

In spite of the potential for ethical problems, health care research in developing countries has been expanding and is likely to continue in the years to come. An increasingly large number of the research submitted to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is being conducted overseas. The FDA has agreed to accept trials conducted outside the United State. Health care research has grown considerably. Although some of the reasons for this are acceptable, the economic disparities between the rich and the poor of the world make exploitation more likely, not less. The reasons for the move to developing countries are fairly obvious; cheaper, easier, and faster to carry out trials. Ethical regulations, approval, and oversight may be less rigorous and the processes faster. Participants are easier to recruit and it is not likely that they would be on any other medications that might interfere with the trial.
It would be nearly impossible for Pfizer to do a test, like they did in Kano, in the United States. One of the biggest ethical problems lies in consent. When a company goes into a third world country to conduct tests it is difficult for them to explain what exactly will be taking place in a way that the participants will understand. It is their fore sometimes necessary for a government body to step in and protect the people. Here in the United States most of us can understand what is being asked of us and we can make an educated informed decision. These people were not even given that chance. Pfizer played upon their emotionally frightened state and did tests on their children without consent.
The second of the article that will be discussed covers the topic of labor unions and human rights in Columbia. In 2005 Rob Harris and Tovin Lapan traveled to Columbia to investigate the allegations that the Coca-Cola Company and even members of the Columbian government were torturing, kidnapping, bullying, and even killing union leaders and their followers at several of their bottling plants. Frontline/World has the entire video series available for view on PBS.org; a transcript of the program is also available. In 2001 a lawsuit was filed against Coca-Cola and its Colombian bottlers in Miami’s federal court. The suit aleged the company had collaborated with paramilitaries factions to threaten and assassinate union organizers. U.S. companies working on foreign soil may be sued in America for their actions abroad. Lawyers from the International Labor Rights Fund took up the case with the assistance of the United Steelworkers of America.
SINALTRAINAL is the main labor union and the ones that have brought the lawsuit against Coke. They are a left-wing union whose militancy has antagonized the management of Coke. In 2004, the union organized a hunger strike to protest local plant closings by Coca-Cola. Union leaders in Columbia live with constant death threats from right-wing paramilitaries. Many of them do not travel without bodyguards and most carry a gun. Many have had family members kidnapped, threatened, and even killed.
Coca-Cola FEMSA is the Mexico-based owner of the plant and they bottles 40 percent of the Coke consumed in Latin America. The company makes billion here however, Coca-Cola owns only 40 percent of FEMSA and is under a bottling agreement. This means that Coca-Cola is not legally responsible for FEMSA’s labor practices.
Coca-Cola and FEMSA were cleared of any wrong doing in two judicial inquiries conducted by the Colombian courts. But that’s hardly conclusive, according to labor historian Daniel Garcia Peña of the National University of Colombia. “It is sad to say, but crime does pay in Colombia,” Due to the chaotic and corrupt Colombian judicial system, it is unlikely that anyone will be held accountable for the violence against SINALTRAINAL in Colombia.
The union members will continue to fight for justice in the American court system. Many universities here in the United States have been boycotting Coke and are fighting for the human right denied these employees. Every time FEMSA fires one of its long time employees it saves itself over $200.00 per month. Starting wage for this company are about $130.00 a month, where as one of their skilled employees who has worked there for some time might make as much as $380.00 a month. These jobs are very sought after even with the despicable conditions, long hours, and threats if they complain.
In The United States workers are protected from unscrupulous companies by the unions they work for. Every company in America wants to make a profit; some will even running over their employees if it will improve their bottom line. The unions however, see that the hours are controlled, the conditions are safe, and give the employee an avenue of complaint if there is a problem. The same types of problems facing Colombia today happened in the United Stated during the first decades of the Industrial Revolutions. It could happen here again if our right to form unions were deigned us. Count yourself lucky that you were born into a country of relative piece and remember to give thanks to the men and women who fought and died in this country to give us the rights and freedoms we have.

References
Harris, R., Lapan, T. (2005) Frontline/World “Columbia: the Coke-Cola Controversy” http://www.pbs.org/frontlineworld/fellows/colombia0106/ Lewin, T. (2001) The New York Times “Families Sue Pfizer on Test of Antibiotic” http://www.nytimes.com/2001/08/30/business/families-sue-pfizer-on-test-of-antibiotic.html

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures

...Business Ethics across Cultures Juanita Bates Axia College University of Phoenix Business Ethics across Cultures 1 Ethics is a guideline of knowing what is right or wrong. Ethical perspectives are a moral view of things. Business ethics are a form of professional or applied ethics. These ethics examines ethical principles and ethical or moral problems that may arise in the business world. All aspects of businesses are affected including individuals and organizations. With the growth in industrial population, the rise of consumerism and popular reaction to large numbers of scandals and corruption, there has been a change in perception and attitude. The United States passed the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act in 1977 forbidding the United States companies from giving bribes to high level government officials of other countries. Many business people did not like the act; they felt it was unfair because foreign countries continued to use bribes while the United States companies could not. German companies were allowed to use their bribes as tax deductible expensive until 1998. They felt the foreign countries would have an advantage of the United States companies. The United States government used what pressure it could to encourage other countries to adapt the same type of law. After 20 years, many other countries agreed. By the 1980’s , many companies started using ethical structures by developing code of ethics, providing ethics training for employees, monitoring...

Words: 1495 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures

...Business ethics across cultures Karen Lovelist XMGT 216 07/25/2010 Elizabeth Berg Business ethics across cultures Urdu is Pakistan’s official language and most widely spoken but in regard to businesses in the country English is generally used. Communication and building relationships are important to Pakistanis they prefer working with people they already know they believe the relationship they have with people they trust is worth more than trying to develop new ones it provides them with a strong foundation which is necessary for business relationships. In the Pakistan culture third party introductions are needed in the relationship. Pakistanis are hospitable people and are bound to ask some personal questions it is their way of getting to know you better. It is best to answer them because it helps in building trust that is important to any business relationship and all business related commitments. Pakistanis are indirect communicators in a group meeting and usually speak in round about fashion, direct communication only happens with people they know and trust Pakistanis are known for their diplomatic talk and would rather say they will try rather than refusing the business deal so be prepared to flatter and be flattered because Pakistanis go out of their way to praise business partners. Business in Pakistan is like doing business with a friend, businessmen feel that telephone numbers are an impersonal way of maintaining a business relationship. Business meetings...

Words: 1077 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures

...Business Ethics across Cultures Jeff Christison XMGT 216 / Organizational Ethics and social Responsibility (AXIA) Carolyn A. Fuentes December 5th, 2010 The first country I chose to research was Germany. I chose them because the world already knows about their personal morals and ethics in history, and how they could be swayed by one individual. They systematically set their morals aside and allowed one man to dictate the country’s ethical stand. They were subsequently able to recover and even improve what had been so easily given away. When it comes to current ethics in German businesses, they are becoming more and more influenced by American business and international trade. While Germany had, in the past, been recognized as a model for personal and business ethics, it was a little more than fifteen years ago that their clean image began to show signs of wear. It is hard to know for sure, though, if it is a case of new issues with ethics, or if globalization is simply shedding a new light on an age old problem. It seems feasible, to me, that businesses have been dealing with their own issues without allowing the public to have knowledge of what is going on. Even with their clean image they have been allowed to practice behaviors that other countries see as illegal. “For example, insider stock trading became illegal only this year, as the Government and investment community tried to respond to pressure from international investors” (Nash, 1995, para. 15). ...

Words: 1494 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures

...Business Ethics across Cultures Etumie Morris January 27, 2013 XMGT/216 Beverly Isaman Business Ethics across Cultures In both The United States and China there have been many ethical dilemmas reported, though some are the same there are numerous difference in which both countries classify as either being ethical or unethical, they to have some things in common. Some of the bigger differences are in their life styles and culture. In this paper I have outlined one of the larger ethical differences and ethical perspectives in relation to business. In china most main ethical concerns are based upon how they live their lives, their goals in life, and also how to conduct themselves if ever they should hold a position of power. However in the business world china has on numerous occasions been found unethical with the way they run their businesses. In plain terms they often violate the essential rights of humans. “During the late 1980s and the early 1990s, China was routinely cited by various international; organizations such as Amnesty International and Freedom Watch for major human rights violations, including torture, beatings, imprisonment, and executions of political dissidents” (Ekonomi, 2007). Despite this, in the late 1990s and early 2000s China received record levels of foreign direct investments, mainly from firms based in democratic societies amongst these was the United States (Ekonomi, 2007). Meanwhile in the United States our ethical issues are of a totally...

Words: 813 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures

...Business Ethics Across Cultures Globalization has not only moved nations nearer together, but has also generated a single moral perception for nations conducting business together. Management teams are discovering that there are great moral challenges waiting to be found out by the enhanced progress to a global scale. If ethics are an issue inside a country, one can visualize the difficulties that arise when the quantity of people involved grows up to an international scale, cultures are different, and the language is alien. In this report we are going to consider two articles which deal with the moral perceptions of China and India, how these articles add to understanding international ethics, and how China’s and India’s business ethics contrast to that of the United States. Santa Clara University printed an article penned by Stephen Rothlin called Business Ethics in the Chinese Context” that thrashed out some of the growth China achieved in 2006 and 2007 in business ethics. Stephen Rothlin works as the general secretary of the Center for International Business Ethics in Beijing. In January 2008, Rothlin modernized the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics Business and Organizational Ethics Partnership with the growth he had seen since his last trip in 2006. Rothlin thrashed out six types including; conditions for moral companies, community role, ecological sustainability, anti-corruption action, and customer privileges. In each of the six types he discussed both developments...

Words: 1637 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures

...XMGT/216 Business Ethics Across Cultures In this paper, I will be reviewing the business ethics found in two countries, each from a different continent. The two countries I have chosen are China and Mexico. The articles I have located for this research are both drawn from the University Library, the first one being Business Ethics and Social Responsibility in Contemporary China, by St. Clair and Norris, the second being Introduction to Central America and Mexico: Efforts and obstacles in creating ethical organizations and an ethical economy, by Collins and Whitaker. I will be reviewing China first, followed by Mexico. Chinese Business Ethics In their article, St. Clair and Norris examine the source of Chinese business ethics from multiple angles. Socially, culturally, and politically, the business atmosphere is quite different in China than it is here in the US. There is, really, no formal culture or system of business ethics for the general, private business sector (St Clair & Norris, 2011). Since its induction into the World Trade Order in 2001, China has modified its business regulations quite significantly to ensure that its businesses operate within the WTO guidelines. However, transition and reform aside, centralized decision making, internal bargaining, and bureaucratic red tape still seem to be the norm, despite the decentralization of many industries and the growth of consumerism. This turn towards progressive business ethics could be due to the recent scandals...

Words: 1507 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures

...Business Ethics across Cultures Dolphinette Williams XMGT/216 December 18, 2011 Shakema Fleming-Sanders If we thing how globalization has not just brought countries closer together, then just how it has created a definite moral view for countries doing business together managing groups are finding out that there are huge moral encounters waiting to be discovered by the enriched growth on a global scale. If ethics are a problem in a nation, imagine the problems that come up when the amount of the population affected matures to global scale, backgrounds are not the same, in addition to the dialect being unknown. At the University of Santa Clara an article wrote by Stephen Rothlin titled “Business Ethics in the Chinese Context” was printed, that tossed out several of the growths china accomplished in Global Business Ethics in 2006 and 2007 in Beijing. 2008 of January, Rothlin updated the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics Business and Organizational Ethics Partnership with the development he had seen since his last trip in 2006. Rothlin tossed out six styles counting conditions for moral businesses, community role, ecological sustainability, anti-corruption action, and consumer opportunities. In all of the styles he debated each stage seen along with proposed subjects which necessitated attention for growth (Business Ethics in the Chinese Context, 2008). China’s job values and employee rights have developed throughout the development of their Labor Contract Law which now...

Words: 1596 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures

...sure that people are not being taken advantage of. When doing business with other countries we need to be sure that practice ethically which is not always the case. One country where these ethics might not be in place is Mexico. There are many American businesses that are moving their companies to Mexico so they can take advantage of the low cost of labor. The cost of living in Mexico is not as high so these companies can get away with paying less and not having laws against child labor and laws that ensure that the employees are paid properly. Although the companies are saving money they have to be extra careful to be sure that the employees that are hired meet the American guidelines. The Mexican worker does not like to be checked on and does not like when they are given feedback where the Americans expect this type of feedback in order to better themselves at their jobs and get ahead. Where the Americans are motivated by getting ahead in business and proving themselves to the companies that they work for, the Mexican loyalty belongs with their immediate superior. With the society being the way it is in Mexico they are not able to plan for long term goals because the future is uncertain. For this reason as well the deadlines are not as important as they are with American businesses. Mexico is a very poor country unlike America which means that they are more susceptible to bribes by corrupt business men. There are many laws that are in place in Mexico but unlike...

Words: 712 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures

...Business Ethics Reflection Thomas Sanford XMGT/216 August 28, 2011 George Camposano/Axia Faculty Business Ethics Reflection Several years ago I sold a large Video Security System to an industrial client that did a lot of Government work. This work was considered to be classified in some areas. The system consisted of 128 cameras of various sizes with some being exposed and some being hidden. This was a large task with some unusual specifications for installation such as the wiring had to be encased in plastic conduit and hidden in the rafters as much as possible. This was mainly in the manufacturing area so employees were not aware of the cameras presences. We were allowed to work only certain hours of the day when all employees were gone for the day and they had guards with us at all times. Our crews went in at a specified time and ran the entire conduit and wiring that was needed within 2 days time. The next crew went in and mounted all the cameras, set up all the recording devices within 2 days. The last crew to go in was there to make sure the system was fully operational and performing to the specifications. They would re-aim the cameras if needed, clear the picture up by adjusting the lens and making sure that nothing showing we were even there was left behind. The last night, I went in and instructed the management on the operation of the system. Our problem began when we found out that one of our associates was dating an employee...

Words: 761 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures

...The two countries I chose to write about are Argentina and the Dominican Republic. Argentina is a country located in South America whereas; the Dominican Republic is located in North America. These two countries seem to be the most interesting and I hear about them quite often. Business ethics are a lot different in these two countries than they are in the United States. It is very interesting to see how much different the jobs are in Argentina and the Dominican Republic when comparing to the United States. Every country conducts business according to their laws and regulations which can also be very different. Argentina is a relationship driven culture, so it is important to build networks and use them. The people of Argentina like to do favors for each other, but if a favor is done for you than you will eventually be called upon. When it comes to business, Argentines only like to do business with people they know. This seems a little close-minded and could have a negative effect on their business relations. In the United States, we do a lot of our business over the phone and face-to-face, but Argentina prefers face-to-face meetings only. Once a relationship is built, Argentines will be loyal to you rather than the company you work for. Argentines focus most on looking good to others and are very judgmental. They do not only judge the way you speak, but the way you present yourself is more important. When dealing with Argentines, one should watch what they say and how...

Words: 1148 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures Article

...A tariff is usually a tax that one country sets on the imported goods or services of another nation. A quota is a trade restriction set by a country to maintain and secure the country’s interests by limiting the amount of goods that can be imported into the country for a fixed time period. The tariffs and quotas in the United States were established to control the amount of goods that enter into the United States to protect the United States interests economically while still maintaining the healthy trading relationship with other countries. The United States utilize these trade restrictions to decide which countries will be suitable. These trade tools are meant to guard the country’s economic interests and establish relations with particular nations. Some critics of these trade tools argue that tariffs and quotas often lead to corruption, such as with smugglers seeking to escape tariffs and quotas and high prices for consumers as there is less competition between domestic and international goods, which tend to be less expensive.     When the dollar is strong then the United States can lower tariff to benefit the consumers and further spur the spending. When the dollar is weak the United States needs to protect the vulnerable economy and potential jobs by increasing the tariff. Domestic trading represents the most beneficial situation for domestic producers, as there is less competition and inflation of consumer goods becomes favorable but it is the least beneficial to domestic...

Words: 313 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures Article Review

...Business Ethics Across Cultures Article Review XMGT/216 Business Ethics Across Cultures Article Review The first article I reviewed was titled Islamic finance: Notion of stewardship imbues business ethics. The author discussed the global economic crisis of 2008 in Islam. He reviewed how the lack of training of Islamic employees in ethics contributed to the economic crisis. Several of the ethical lapses that occurred during the ethical crisis were caused by risk also known as gharar and gambling. Both gharar and gambling are banned by Islamic law (Smith, 2012). The author argues that religious beliefs not limited to Islam can influence more responsibility within a business’s leadership. Omneya Abdelsalam, the director of the El Shaarani Research Centre for Islamic Business believes the belief of god and his power brings an acute level of accountability and responsibility (Smith, 2012). The suggestion of Dr Abdelsalam is that the belief of religion has a direct power of the way individuals conduct business. Islamic businesses primary ethical perspectives are to fulfill social responsibility of the business to the best of its capabilities, have fair treatment for employees, care for the environment and customers, and fulfilling the obligation toward shareholders and other stakeholders (Smith, 2012). Challenges faced by Islamic businesses are the views of tangible assets and some principles. Cedomir Nestorovic, a professor of Islamic business and management states that...

Words: 1523 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures Article Review

...------------------------------------------------- Business Ethics across Cultures Article Review Meghan Kraft XMGT/216 Deborah Pryer November 22nd 2015 Business Ethics across Cultures Article Review For centuries countries have been sharing their goods, services, cultures, and ways of life with those who visit or decides to do business with their country. While most would assume that people in another land speaking a different language, following a different religion, and eating different food would more than likely perceive and behave differently from than our own; the truth is that even though these differences may be perceived, very little is done to actually understand them appropriately unless it is deemed necessary. It is obvious that through globalization, that not just one, but each and every country has its own problems with ethics regarding business. It is made quite clear that there is a common scourge in business practices worldwide. It is also very clear that we are victims to the same faults that occur in humanity on a global scale. However, what is quickly becoming equally apparent, for international businesses and corporations to deal successfully with a foreign contractor, business, or even government; the proper measures must be taken to understand the differences in ethical perception and to work to accommodate those differences. Failure to do so leave many of these companies and businesses vulnerable for international ethical dilemmas that are quickly...

Words: 1600 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures Article Review

...Business Ethics Across Cultures Article Review XMGT/216 March 5, 2012 Leat Kodua BUSINESS ETHICS ACROSS CULTURES ARTICLE REVIEW Business Ethics Across Cultures This paper will focus on the two articles that I chose to discuss, ‘Business Ethics in Australia and New Zealand1’ and ‘Business Ethics in Japan.” This paper will provide a brief summary of both articles and try to explain some of the primary ethical perspectives of the countries. In the contents of this paper there will also be a discussion on how the articles contribute to understanding global ethical perspectives and will briefly describe the similarities and differences of the business ethics in these two countries and the United States. Although the first article is titled ‘Business Ethics in Australia and New Zealand’ I will discuss only Australia as New Zealand is considered a separate country. Australia This article discusses the effects of the scandals of the 80’s and extending into the 90’s on Australia and New Zealand as both countries have always claimed to be open, fair and honest societies and the scandals that erupted during the 80’s and 90’s shocked the people of Australia exposing the corruption and dereliction of duty that existed where they felt none did. These scandals brought to light the need for ethical codes within the private and government businesses within Australia, however chief executives and senior government officials still are finding it difficult to accept...

Words: 1483 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Business Ethics Across Cultures Article Review

...Business Ethics Across Cultures Article Review Ken R. Johnson XMGT 216 May 27, 2012 Instructor: Deborah McCafferty Business Ethics Across Cultures Article Review Globalization has been an ongoing event for many centuries; ever since the first traders and merchants sought out other countries to bring back uniquely different food and goods, countries have been sharing their culture and perspectives with those they visit or those that come to their borders. Today, with the widespread use of Internet, digital information, and focus on international business, the positive effect of globalization is much more apparent as well as the challenges it presents to countries with different ethical cultures. While most would assume that people in another land speaking a different language, following a different religion, and eating different food would more than likely perceive and behave differently from than our own; the truth is that even though these differences may be perceived, very little is done to actually understand them appropriately unless it is deemed necessary. However, what is quickly becoming equally apparent, for international businesses and corporations to deal successfully with a foreign contractor, business, or even government; the proper measures must be taken to understand the differences in ethical perception and to work to accommodate those differences. Failure to do so leave many of these companies and businesses...

Words: 1516 - Pages: 7