Free Essay

Business Law I: Class Action Law Suits

In: Business and Management

Submitted By yatesa
Words 2643
Pages 11
Class Action Law Suits
Allen R. Yates One of the most fascinating aspects of business law is the class action lawsuit. I find this intriguing because class action law suits are often litigated on the same principles as other types of civil action suits, however, the outcome of the class action lawsuit often may have a deep impact on our society, as well as our legal system as a whole. In a normal civil lawsuit, where the plaintiff is the victor, said plaintiff is typically well compensated for their respective damages. Thus it can be viewed that is how justice is served in these cases. In the class action lawsuit where the plaintiffs win, often the individual is not proportionately compensated for their damages as compared to the victor in the average civil suit. In fact there have been class action law suits that have been held in favor of the plaintiffs, damages have been rewarded by the courts, but the individual did not receive a cent of monetary compensation. Yet, in these cases, justice has still been adequately served on the basis of morality. . In this paper, we are going to take a look at class action lawsuits. This paper will cover the history of class action lawsuits, what exactly a class action law suit is, how a class action suit is filed, and we’ll take a look at some of the more famous and impacting class action lawsuits in our nation’s history. The history of most of the United States legal system is deeply rooted in the heart of English common law, and class action lawsuits are no exception. The origins of class actions suits actually go back to medieval times, around the year 1200 in England. During that period of time, a form of what is called by modern observers as “group litigation” was very common. Basically, a group of people conglomerated on some form of societal structure (i.e. village or town), and would be suing another person or group, or the conglomeration was being sued by another person or individual on some issue involving the common law of the time. An interesting fact to mention is that unlike in today’s modern courts, it was quite common that a small group of people, or an individual for that matter, could bring suit or represent the larger group when the group was being sued, without question of the validity of that person or group being able to represent the larger group as whole. This unquestionable ability of an individual or small group of individuals to represent the larger group has been attributed to the poor communication, transportation, and administrative systems of the medieval times. The fact is it was nearly impossible for the English sovereign (a.k.a. the king and the courts) to manage the entire country in terms of “individuals”. Hence this collectiveness known as group litigation was widely accepted and applied because it was much easier for the King, his judges, and lawyers to impose obligations on groups of that time, rather than an individual. By the year 1700, group litigation went from being the norm in England, to the exception. This developed mainly due to the concept of the corporation, which in turn led to the development of what is still known in the modern day as the concept of the unincorporated or voluntary association. During this period of time, the English court system was basically gridlocked. Out of the confusion and turmoil of the times, the Court of Chancery emerged, and handled all group litigation. To say the least, the cases litigated by the Chancery where a shamble. More or less the cause of this frazzled mess was due to the fragmentation of the individual, and group litigation cases where no longer viewed as a consent of representation of the group, but as what was in the best interest of the group, a problem of group litigation that exists to this very day. In the early to mid-1800’s, the English parliament had passed several statutes on a case by case basis which removed the driving force in regards to group litigation. By 1850, group litigation in England was all but dead. Despite group litigation’s demise in England, it survived in the United States. Credit for this is almost solely given to a Supreme Court Associate Justice by the name of Joseph Story. Story gave light to group litigation in summary discussion during a two of his equity treaties, as well as his opinion in the case of West v. Randall (1820), which has been noted as one of the first class action lawsuits in the United States. In 1833, Story was a key architect in manifesting Equity Rule 48, which allowed representative suits in situations where there were too many parties involved. Even though Story was highly versed in the merits and precedents of English common law, he did not learn from the mistakes and failings of the Court of Chancery. Equity Rule 48 did not allow these representative suits to bind similarly situated absent parties, which relinquished its intention, and made the rule useless. In the early twentieth century Equity Rule 48 was replaced with Equity Rule 38, which in turn was renamed Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (FRCP) during the restructuring of the federal courts in 1938. Through all this change to name and structure, the original Rule 48, now known has Rule 23 remained more or less the same, with slight variances. In 1966, a major revision of the FRCP gave revolutionary changes to Rule 23. As in the medieval times that started the very essence of group litigation, the changes to Rule 23 bound all members of the class regardless of whether they all actually appeared in court or not. Note: the contrasting difference in modern times versus medieval times is today an individual or individuals can actually appear in court, and state that they do not wish participate in the suit, hence opting out of the current litigation. This allows an individual to seek litigation on behalf of themselves against the defendant for the same injury that the class action suit was filed for, but in a different case. Thus, modern day class action lawsuits where born. We now have a brief idea or where class action lawsuits originated, so let’s take a look at what exactly a class action lawsuit is. Our text book, Business Law; The Ethical, Global, and E-Commerce Environment 14th ed., defines a class action as “an action brought on behalf of the plaintiff and others similarly situated.” In layman’s terms, it means that a large group of people as a collective bringing a suit or a claim to the courts against a class of defendants that are being sued. A wonderful example is the case that we have been intermittently discussing throughout this term, Dukes v. Wal-Mart, a.k.a Women v. Wal-Mart. In this case a female employee is suing Wal-Mart Stores for sexual discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 claiming that after several years of excellent work evaluations she was denied a promotion. The case was converted to class-action status to represent every female employee from 1998 onwards, and is currently awaiting certification of being a class action lawsuit from the Supreme Court. If the Supreme Court allows this case to go forward as a class action lawsuit, it will be the quintessential example of a class action lawsuit because it has all of the basic elements: the large group: almost a million women; bringing a claim: discrimination; against a class of defendants: Wal-Mart. A class action lawsuit may be brought up in either the state or federal courts. Traditionally thinking indicates that the state courts favor the plaintiffs in class action suits, whereas the federal courts tend to favor the defendants, so many class action lawsuits start at the state level. However, often times federal jurisdiction applies, and this is where the suit ends up. Today in United States federal courts, class action lawsuits are governed by the fore mentioned FRCP Rule 23. A class action lawsuit may be brought in federal court if a claim arises under federal law, or the federal courts have original jurisdiction if the amount in controversy exceeds $5,000,000.00 as well as either one of the following criteria are met in accordance with 28 USCA § 1332 (d): (1) any member of the class of plaintiffs is of a different state of residence than any defendant (2) any member of a class of plaintiffs is a foreign state or subject of a foreign state and any defendant is a citizen of a State (3) any member of a class of plaintiffs is a citizen of a State and any defendant is a foreign state or a citizen or subject of a foreign state. The procedure for filing a class action lawsuit is a lot like filing a claim in any other civil suit, however there are some stark differences. In a class action, an individual files the suit, with at least on named plaintiff on behalf of a class that consists of a group of individuals or business entities, that have suffered the same or similar injuries inflicted upon them by a specific defendant or class of defendants. After the complaint is filed, the plaintiff must move to have the class certified, after which the defendants have the option to contest the validity of the claim to move forward as a class action. In federal civil procedure law a class action lawsuit must meet the following guidelines: (1) the suit must be so large that it makes individual suits impractical *Note: this is one of the many reasons for gridlock under England’s court system during the 1700’s, (2) there must be legal and or factual claims in common, (3) The claims or defenses of the plaintiffs or defendants must be typical, (4) the representative parties must protect the interests of the class, (5) the common issues between the class and the defendants will predominate the proceedings, versus an specific individual(s) issues predominating the proceedings, (6) that the class action, instead of the individual litigation is the superior vehicle for resolution for disputes at hand. This is the gist of what a class action lawsuit is. Typically they are extremely complicated and far reaching, thus what has been described here are the basics of the basics. Understanding the basics of class action lawsuits allows us to take a look a few cases that have either helped to form our society, shape our laws, or due to their respective intricacies have brought some form of fame or light upon them. So, let’s take a look at just a few of these infamous cases. Anderson v. Pacific Gas & Electric- This class action case was made famous by the movie Erin Brockovich (2000). The history behind the case is in California in 1952 Pacific Gas & Electric (PS&G) started disposing a chemical called Chromium XI into their unlined wastewater ponds, which ended up in the local water supply due to seepage and runoff. This contamination was not discovered until a routine check of the local water supply in 1987. In the early 1990’s PG&E undertook an expensive cleanup process to clear up the pollution to the local water supply. Many residents had been drinking, bathing, and swimming in the contaminated water for over twenty years. Shortly thereafter, an egregious number of residents began to come down with ailments that where linked to the chemical Chromium XI. In lieu of the rampant sicknesses, residents of Hinkley, California filed claim against PG&E. These lawsuits consisted of 36 claims by over 650 residents of Hinkley. Ultimately, the residents won their suit in arbitration to the tune of $333 million, yet it is undisclosed as to how much each individual resident received. This landmark case has since set precedence on the liability of large companies in regards to disposal of the chemicals that are used during industry and manufacturing. AOL Time Warner Litigation- In 2002, Investors in AOL Time Warner stock sued the company in over thirty class action lawsuits in three different federal court districts for fraud under the Federal Securities Act of 1933. The company was alleged to have improperly accounted for dozens of advertising transactions between 1998 and 2002. The alleged transactions created the appearance that they were generating revenue when, in reality, were just shifting money back and forth. The alleged false earnings statements inflated the company’s value by $1.7 billion. The case went on for nearly three years, ending in July of 2005 when an agreement in principle of $2.5 billion was reached to settle the Securities Class Action. Exxon Valdez- This class action lawsuit related to the Exxon Valdez oil spill which occurred on March 24th, 1989 off of the coast of Valdez, Alaska. The oil spill affected thousands of people, more than 1,300 miles of coastline, and had a very deep and lasting impact on wildlife and the ecosystem of the area for many years afterwards. The ship was commanded by Captain Hazelwood, who was known to have issues with drinking alcohol. ExxonMobil knew of Captain Hazelwood’s drinking problem, but allowed him to pilot the gigantic oil rig anyways, and the rest is environmental history. A federal judge found ExxonMobil and Captain Hazelwood liable for the atrocious disaster, and ordered ExxonMobil to pay punitive damages and interest to thousands of commercial fishermen, cannery workers, land owners, Alaska natives and others who were harmed by the spill. This class action lawsuit is often viewed as the cookie cutter for environmental justice. In summary, this paper covered the meager beginnings of class action lawsuits as group litigations during medieval times, through the tribulations fraught upon group litigations via the struggle of English common law, to the culmination of what is the modern day class action lawsuit in the United States. This paper also covered exactly what a class action lawsuit is, the basic criteria it must meet, as well as how a class action suit is filed. The discussion was summed up by a look at some of the most famous and deep impacting class action lawsuits in recent history. Class actions lawsuits have been a part of our legal system in some form from the very beginning of what is considered common law. Typically, these suits are complicated, taking many years to litigate, and the outcomes are unpredictable to say the least. Class action lawsuits are more often than not far reaching, and have helped to shape our society as we know it. In the end, there is no doubt that class action lawsuits will continue to be a stringent part of our legal system, impacting not only business law itself, but the businesses and people on to which they effect, as well as our day to day lives.

References
Class Action Lawsuits
Allen R. Yates
References:
Business Law; The Ethical, Global, and E-Commerce Environment, 14th edition; Mallor/Barnes/Bowers/Langvardt

Websites:
Class Action http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Class+action+lawsuit Dukes v. Wal-Mart http://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=7023771032625911493&q=dukes+v.+wal-mart&hl=en&as_sdt=2,44&as_vis=1
Women v. Wal-Mart http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/women-walmart-supreme-court-decide-millions-female-employees/story?id=13215351 Anderson v. Pacific Gas & Electric http://law.justia.com/cases/california/caapp4th/14/254.html
AOL Time Warner Litigation http://www.aoltimewarnersettlement.com/aolbackround.html
Class Action http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Class_action Exxon Valdez http://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=11632309141529010848&q=exxon+valdez+class+action+lawsuit&hl=en&as_sdt=2,44&as_vis=1

Endnotes:

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Discrimination

...Harassment and Discrimination BUS:311 Business Law I Instructor: Marla Muse 9/26/2013 Many of us who are a part of the workforce wake up every day and think about what needs to be accomplished at work today? Work can be frustrating and sometimes enjoyable, at no point should an individual feel that their security is in jeopardy or also that they are being verbally attacked because of their gender, race, or age. With providing facts this will prove that there the law protects the working force from harassment and discrimination in the workplace. Most of us who have jobs realize that there are times where either harassment or discrimination takes place. Even in today’s modern world these situations still presents itself. The focus of my argument is to show that these acts do not go unseen or unheard from a legal standpoint. Harassment and discrimination is highly illegal and very unethical within the workplace or any business. There are laws out there that protect individuals who are subjected to this type of behavior, so much so that companies spend a vast amount of time and money trying to educate employees about harassment and discrimination. My stance on this topic is very clear, these acts should not occur and the law is fair in the consequences that follow when a business is involved in a harassment or discrimination act. I understand that every company cannot speak for each employee; however there should be policies and procedures that are addressed. At no time...

Words: 3023 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Title Vii

...With the research I have uncovered with the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, along with other areas of more extensive discrimination suits that have been filed in the work force has really helped to understand that importance of compliance of the laws that are set in front of you as a manager, supervisor and/or a business owner. With a lot of people turning a blind eye to some of the smallest delegations when it comes to discrimination, that could be their biggest down fall as a business owner, as the smallest mistakes can turn out to be the most costly mistakes. You are going to learn more insight on race discrimination as this has really opened my eyes, with my past work experiences and to know what to expect in the future, also what to look for while in the job force. There is many different verification to the law of racial discrimination whether it is on an employee of employer level. It ranges from a fine, all the way to time punishable in prison. In most cases that I have researched it has been against an employee to an employer, and it has been settle in a monetary settlement. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 protects individuals against employment discrimination on the bases of race and color, as well as national origin, sex, and religion. Title VII applies to employers with 15 or more employees, including state and local governments. It also applies to employment agencies and to labor organizations, as well as to the federal government. Some...

Words: 2672 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Class Action Lawsuits

...Jay Laub December 8, 2010 Business law I Class Action Lawsuits Class action lawsuits, sometimes called “multiple litigation lawsuits”, can be used when many individuals have been injured by the same product or action of a single defendant. The individuals can come together to seek justice when “their injuries have been cause by defective products, including pharmaceutical drugs, motor vehicles and other consumer products, and medical devices. Other types of conduct over which people have sued as a class include consumer fraud, corporate misconduct, securities fraud, and employment practices.” Class action lawsuits are most useful to individuals who by themselves could not bring a lawsuit against a large company because the damage done was relatively small. It enables many people to come together and sue as one “class”, and only one case has to be made on behalf of the group of plaintiffs. Legal fees are significantly reduced when the case only has to be made once, even if the damages to each individual in the class were very small. If, for instance, a company was to sell a mouthwash that did not work as it was supposed to, one person would probably not attempt to sue for damages if the amount was only twenty dollars. If one million people who are entitled to remuneration of twenty dollars each come together, it becomes feasible to sue the make of the mouthwash when twenty million dollars is at stake. A class action lawsuit can occasionally be of some benefit to corporations...

Words: 1440 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Employee Motivation at Publix Supermarkets

...HOW LAWSUITS FILED AGAINST PUBLIX CAN AFFECT EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION Introduction Publix is the sixth largest supermarket chain in the United States and the largest employee-owned supermarket chain in the country, it is a privately-held company which operates stores in Florida, Georgia, South Carolina, Alabama and Tennessee. This supermarket chain was founded by George W. Jenkins in 1930 in Winter Haven, Florida, and currently operates 1073 supermarkets, 8 distribution centers and 5 manufacturing facility employing in excess of 162,000 employees. (figure 1.) Store Locations * Florida - 755 * Georgia - 180 * Alabama - 55 * South Carolina - 48 * Tennessee - 35 | Distribution Centers * Boynton Beach, FL * Miami, FL * Deerfield Beach, FL * Orlando, FL * Jacksonville, FL * Sarasota, FL * Lakeland, FL * Lawrenceville, GA | Manufacturing Facilities * Atlanta, GA - Bakery Plant * Deerfield Beach, FL - Dairy Plant, Fresh Foods  * Jacksonville, FL - Fresh Foods * Lakeland, FL - Bakery Plant, Dairy Plant, Deli Kitchen, Fresh Foods, and Printing Services * Lawrenceville, GA - Dairy Plant | Publix Supermarket’s sales in 2012 were $27.5 billion this represented increase of 3.8 percent over 2011 sales and placed net earnings $1.6 billion, up 4% from 2011. Publix’s sales for the first half of 2013 were $14.5 billion, a 5 percent increase from last year’s $13.9 billion. In pursuit of achieving its mission statement “Our Mission at Publix is to be...

Words: 2879 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Jdt2 Task 1

...Termination on December 12, 2011 Executive Summary Based on the facts of the case, I believe we are not liable in the discrimination suit brought by Mr. Doe. Constructive Discharge Constructive discharge is defined as “if an employer's discriminatory acts result in working conditions so intolerable that a reasonable person in the employee's position would feel compelled to resign.” (Finnegan, 1986) Courts generally follow one of two “litmus” tests to determine if a person who willfully terminated their employment was constructively discharged and should receive compensation as a result of the termination. In the majority view, “an employee who resigns after being subjected to unlawful discrimination is said to have been constructively discharged if a reasonable person would have found the discriminatory conditions to be intolerable.” (Finnegan, 1986) The minority view is that the complainant “must show not only that conditions were intolerable, but also that the employer created those conditions with the specific intent of forcing them to resign.” (Finnegan, 1986) Mr. Doe is a member if the production staff. The company changed the production staff’s working hours to a rolling 12 hour shift four days a week that could occur on any day of the week. If the company’s intent was to get Mr. Doe or anyone on production staff to resign by changing the production staff’s hours, it is possible that the actions of the company could be considered a constructive discharge. In the case of Mr...

Words: 1050 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Employment Laws

...Introduction Employment laws have been constituted to ensure fair treatment of employees by employers and to prevent exploitation of employees in the workplace. It is of utmost importance that these laws are completely understood by an organization not only to ensure compliance of these laws but also to create a workplace that is conducive to harness the maximum potential of employees by harboring goodwill, equity and trust between employers and the employees which in turn would lead to higher returns for the shareholders. These laws strive to provide the employees with a fair compensation for the work done, and a safe and non discriminatory workplace. Employee Laws like other laws have evolved over time to respond to the societal and organizational changes. One of the oldest and significant employment laws is the “Fair Labor Standards Act” established in 1938 to set the minimum wage and overtime pay. Another monumental employment law is the Title VII of “The Civil Rights Acts of 1964” that has resulted after a long and passionate strife for equality by Americans. The Title VII of this law deals to tackle employment discrimination on the basis of race, color, national origin, sex, religion, and retaliation. In the year 1967, another law called “The Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA)” was passed to increase the set of discrimination criteria to include age. They have been followed by other very important bills like “Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970”, “Americans...

Words: 2329 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Test Paper

...important aspect both in business and society. We use the law to establish standards, maintain order, settle arguments and protect civil right. We also use the law to enforce consequences when individuals and business break these written laws. It is important for individual and business to understand the laws that govern their actions in order for them to avoid costly law suits. The Function of Law The function of the legal system is to maintain class rule or to promote social cohesion. Laws are created when a legislative body, elected to act on the best interests of their constituents, determines that certain actions that cause personal injury or damage property will not be tolerated. These laws are enforced by threat of punishment such as jail time, probation or monetary fines. Law The law establishes standards of acceptable conduct in a society and business. It is a crime to cause physical or monetary injury to another individual without justification. The law is used to ensure order is maintained within the acceptable guidelines of the law. When order is not kept and disputes arise parties use the court system to resolve their dispute. Disputes can be resolved in the federal court system or the individual state court system. In order to determine which branch of court will hear a matter you must determine which branch has jurisdiction to hear a matter. Lastly, the law protects our civil liberties and rights. Function of Law in Business Laws are important as they...

Words: 795 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Women vs. Wal-Mart

...submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the completion of MGT412 Touro University International College of Business Administration Module 1 INSTRUCTOR: The Women VS. Wal-Mart Gender or “sex-based” discrimination has been in existence for the past two decades. Many companies, employers, and analysts would argue that gender discrimination claims are exaggerated or taking advantages of the fact that so many pursue claims against companies. Most gender or “sex-based” discrimination claims are based on job promotions that were denied, unprofessional comments that were said to them or even something as simple as poor treatment in the workplace. In the paper I will be covering what legal statute(s) gave the EEOC the jurisdiction to prosecute the case, some new information concerning Wal-Mart since the start of the class-action suit and how private-sector organizations can help protect themselves from future claims of illegal discrimination. Federal laws were passed in the 1960s to help women have equal treatment within the workplace and are enforced by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). Two specific federal laws that I want to bring up are the Equal Pay Act of 1963 and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The EEOC were given jurisdiction to prosecute Dukes vs. Wal-mart case based off of those laws. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, 42 U.S.C. § 1981 et seq., (Title VII) and the Equal Pay Act of 1963, 29 U.S.C. §...

Words: 1020 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Student

...of his friends, relatives, and former law partners packed the corridor. Within hours, a judge would sentence him to prison. Yet Lerach navigated the crowd like a party host, clasping hands, greeting former colleagues, and chatting up their spouses. Lerach looked a little pale, but he seemed impressively calm. A few reporters hovered nearby with notebooks out, watching him with the detached air of primatologists. He graciously sauntered over to say hi. His daughter Shannon, a graduate student, leaned against the corridor wall. As the hearing time neared, she caught his attention momentarily. Apparently put off by her father's nonchalance, she told him: "Don't smile." He nodded back at her. It would have been out of character for Lerach to lose his composure at this point. He'd spent three decades publicly accusing corporate executives of fraud. Privately, however, Lerach had compared the ordeal-pleading guilty to fraud himself and surrendering his bar license-to attending his own funeral. Six months earlier, Lerach had commanded a 190-lawyer firm from the penthouse office of a glass tower overlooking San Diego harbor. Since the late 1970s, he and his partners had been pumping out securities-fraud class actions, accusing nearly every major corporation in the United States. At age 61, he still set a furious pace. The lawsuits returned billions of dollars to investors. And even though business executives called the class actions "legal extortion," his success was undeniable...

Words: 4045 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Math

...Local Lawsuit Rosemarie South Professor Charlene Bean Business Law 1 August 14, 2012 First the client must file a complaint or petition. Any complaint or petition for relief in a court must be filed within the statutory time limit. A complaint is a general statement of the plaintiff’s claim.  The complaint must describe the actions that led to the claim of a violation.  The claim can be for money damages.  It could also be a claim for equitable remedies like specific performance of the court forcing a party to abide by a contract or an injunction like stopping a person from doing something.  The complaint must establish jurisdiction of the court in which it is filed.  The persons who start a lawsuit are the lead plaintiff. This is the person who have has a problem and need a lawyer to help them to get the ball rolling A lead plaintiff has a big job. And like any job, it has some benefits and disadvantages. For example: Even though the lead plaintiff starts the case and hires the attorneys, she doesn't have to pay attorney's fees or legal expenses. A lead plaintiff usually works very closely with the attorneys handling the case and participates a great deal in the court process. Only the lead plaintiff can agree to or reject a settlement offer. If he or she wins or the case is settled, the lead plaintiff is paid first after the attorneys get their fees and expenses. Service of process generally involves attaching a copy of the complaint to a summons...

Words: 1484 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Bylaws

...purposes of the NICB are civic and educational, specifically: a. to formulate general policies for the prevention and detection of all insurance-related crime and fraud including, but not limited to, arson and theft of vehicles, equipment, marine and other; b. to gather pertinent information and data with respect to insurance-related crime and fraud and disseminate such information and data to Members, public officials and law enforcement officials consistent with applicable law; c. to act as an interfacing agency between insurance and other companies and the criminal justice system for the prompt investigation of insurance-related crime and fraud referred to the Corporation for investigation and to provide a deterrent to such activities; d. to conduct investigations of insurance-related crime and fraud and to facilitate, whether through litigation or otherwise, the recovery of stolen or wrongfully obtained property or funds and the return of this property or funds to the victims of insurance-related crime or fraud; e. to assist and cooperate with public officials and law enforcement officers in their activities concerning the prevention and detection of insurance-related crime and fraud, including the investigation of such crime and fraud; f. to encourage and aid in the prosecution of persons engaged in insurance-related crime and fraud and in connection therewith to sign a complaint where, in the judgment of the Corporation,...

Words: 8047 - Pages: 33

Premium Essay

Business Law Week Seven Assignment

...in securities acts; and (3) an investment contract. Next, we can use the family resemblance test to determine if the notes issued by Co-Op can be categorized as securities. The family resemblance test refers to a method of analyzing a debt instrument that is having a horizontal commonality. Horizontal commonality means pooling of interests, not only between the seller and each individual buyer, but also among all those who buy an investment contract in the same venture The following are the four factors to be considered while applying the family resemblance test: The motivation that prompts a reasonable buyer and seller to enter into the transaction in question: The Co-Op sold the notes in an effort to raise capital for its general business operations, and purchasers bought them in order to earn a profit in the form of interest. The plan of distribution of the instrument: the Co-Op offered the notes over an extended period to its 23,000 members, as well as to nonmembers, and more than 1,600 people held notes when the Co-Op filed for bankruptcy. The reasonable expectations of the investing public: The advertisements for the notes here characterized them as “investments,” and there were no countervailing factors that would have led a reasonable person to question this characterization. The existence of an alternate regulatory scheme reducing the risk of the instrument: There is no risk-reducing factor to suggest that these instruments are not in fact securities...

Words: 1428 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Billing Practices

...emergency and non-emergency situations. The company is a regional powerhouse covering 3 states and maintaining approximately 4000 employees and a fleet of ambulances, helicopters, and other transportation vehicles. The firm was recently designated as the largest privately owned ambulance service provider in the U.S. Of the three original founders, Zuschlag remains active CEO of the company. When a company becomes this big, especially in the medical field, ir must constantly be worried about liability. Unfortunately, Acadian is no stranger to lawsuits. Over the course of the company’s 45-year history, there have been numerous lawsuits brought against them for various reasons. One of the most recent and possibly most notable cases: a class action lawsuit claiming customers had been over-charged at one...

Words: 1933 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Law 531 Paper

...Alternative Dispute Resolution Paper Krista Brown LAW/531 August 5, 2015 Instructor: Beth Ann Lee Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) is defined as a forum or means for resolving disputes (such as arbitration or private judging) that exists outside the state or federal judicial system (Mallow, Barnes, Langvardt, Prenkert, & McCrrory, 2015, pg. G-1). ADR can be done through stages of communicating and agreeing rather than taking place in a long drawn out process in court. Arbitration and mediation are the-two primary forms of ADR, although there are others (Peterson, 2012). Allowing the parties to find a resolution that works for both is the most cost effective way to resolve a dispute. Regardless of profitability, size, ownership, or industry sector, all businesses share a common problem: conflict and conflict resolution (McDowell & Sussman, 2004). Avoiding ADR can result in an exorbitant amount of unnecessary legal fees for both parties. Alternative dispute resolution emphasizes mutual problem solving and broadens options for resolving conflicts in hopes of minimizing hostility (McDowell & Sussman, 2004). If ADR is not utilized, the other option is litigation. While litigation is an option, it is typically used as a last resort due to the fact that it is much more expensive and time consuming. Opperman’s (2000) study found the following: ADR effectiveness in twenty-nine medical malpractice claims against the government handled by Assistant U.S...

Words: 820 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Virginia Procedure

...VIRGINIA PROCEDURE OUTLINE CHAPTER I: EXTRA-JUDICIAL PROCEDURES Note: These Procedures take place without the participation of a judge or the court 1) Self Help a) Predates existence of the organized state b) Now greatly discouraged because police power of state more effective i) Discouraged, superseded in practice, and restricted by law now. c) Situations when available: i) Available in debtor-creditor situations where debts are voluntarily paid when they are due (most pay when get into financial position to pay) ii) When possession of goods bailed are returned to the Owner when the period of the bailment ends. iii) When debtor intentionally refuses to pay or neglects to pay creditor may resort to self-help to get paid. 1) May be independent or in conjunction with litigation. d) Usually attempt to get debtor to pay voluntarily before seeking assistance of the court. e) Repossession i) Allowed at common law where it can be accomplished without breach of peace. ii) Person disseised and dispossessed of land an reenter w/o a court order unless would involve breach of peace iii) Repossession of chattels is allowed where they have been: 1) Loaned, hired, bailed, lost and found, or stolen and wrongfully detained from the O provided it is done w/o ab reach of the peace. 2) Person may recover own chattels from land of the wrongdoer, but to do so from the land of a 3P would be trespass 3) Hunters...

Words: 113918 - Pages: 456