Premium Essay

Business and Management Kantian Ethics

In: Business and Management

Submitted By mjoseph
Words 1704
Pages 7
Kantian Ethical Analysis

Kantian ethics are perhaps one of the world most loved branch of ethical philosophy. It is to some extent the Eden lost of moral philosophy, for it argues that moral requirements are based on established standards of rationality, reason and dignity embedded in Categorical Imperative and whereas, immorality is somewhat a violation of moral philosophy and is not embedded in Categorical Imperative, which is self governing reason that each and every individual possess as a guiding factor in practical affairs, business decisions such as the failed merger of AT&T and TMobile merger. Reason, declared Kant, is the source and ultimate basis for morality (Cavico & Mujtaba, 2013). Meaning, morality is not based on the animalistic side of man, but, rather on a God given conscience weaved in the moral laws which are the opposite of intuition or utility. This moral law is binding on human beings, simply because they are rational (Cavico & Mujtaba, 2013), however; what makes man rational? Does the rationality of man only apply to personal matter not business matter? Does that rationality prevent business controversies? Rationality is a most desirable quality of man, however; such rationality does not always apply to business matter. The merger of the second and fourth largest telecommunications companies, AT&T and T-Mobile is a prime example of how far man will go in order to ignore his God given conscience. However, the same man that is often ready to make irrational business moves is somewhat careful when it comes to personal matter or family matters. A perfect example is the fast food industry, where without any doubt, these fortunes 500, companies would not allow their children to consume food in the dollar menu; but, that same man would not hesitate to open a restaurant in a poor neighborhood and contribute to the existing

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Business Ethics

...BUSINESS ETHICS 'COLLECTIVE ACTION PROBLEMS' IN PARTICULAR HOW MUCH RESPONSIBILITY DOES AN INDIVIDUAL MANAGER HAVE FOR THE ETHICAL CULTURE OF HIS/HER ORGANISATION? Ram Visvanathan Business Ethics May 28, 2014   Introduction. Ethics is very important for the prosperity of any organization. Every employee or stakeholder of an organization has got an important role to play in nurturing an ethical culture in an organization. This research paper discusses the level of responsibility that an individual manager has in the ethical culture of his or her organization. This is done with close attention to academic journals and research. The paper will derive its arguments from veteran theories like the Utilitarian and the Kantian theories. The paper will also relate its discussions with the case study about Enron a USA company that collapsed as a result of unethical behavior in the management.  Some of the components that will be highlighted in the paper include; the importance of an ethical culture in an organization, the dangers of lack of ethics in an organization and the strategies that can be used to promote ethics in an organization. Justification of the research. The study of the role of individual managers in the ethical culture of an organization is a justified venture. This is because of the increased calls for ethical behaviors in organizations. The expectations of the staff and the society at large on ethical behaviors have increased tremendously...

Words: 5413 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Bsb111

...Utilitarianism Utilitarianism is a teleological form of ethics which promotes the action which will achieve the greatest net total happiness (Barnes, 1971). This action is usually identified through a consequential theory analysis – by identifying stakeholders, and their relevant utility payoffs from each action available. Whichever action results in the greatest net happiness, is the action that should be taken (Barnes, 1971). Samantha is the first stakeholder identified from the case. Samantha’s life and general well-being, along with her life-savings invested in the business are at stake, depending on Nathan’s decision. If Nathan is to tell Samantha of the unethical actions of Beth, Beth will be sacked and will face even greater financial hardship, thus Beth is also a key stakeholder. The customers are also stakeholders. If Nathan does not tell Samantha, prices will increase – negatively impacting customers. The final key stakeholder identified is Nathan. If Samantha finds that Beth has been stealing, and Nathan did not report this - Samantha will lose trust in Nathan and he will be considered a disloyal employee. The consequential analysis has been displayed in the table below, listing the stakeholders and their consequential payoffs if Nathan chooses to tell, or not tell Samantha of Beth’s wrong-doing. Each unit represents one utility point on a scale of -10 to 10 units of happiness. Through the consequential analysis of the stakeholders identified, and their relevant...

Words: 1383 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Ethical Leadership

...Available online at www.sciencedirect.com International Journal of Project Management 27 (2009) 456–463 www.elsevier.com/locate/ijproman E-ethical leadership for virtual project teams Margaret R. Lee * Capella University, 225 South Sixth Street, Minneapolis, MN 55402, United States Received 30 March 2008; received in revised form 21 May 2008; accepted 27 May 2008 Abstract This paper presents a review of current literature on ethical theories as they relate to ethical leadership in the virtual business environment (e-ethics) and virtual project leadership. Ethical theories are reviewed in relation to virtual project management, such as participative management, Theory Y, and its relationship to utilitarianism; Kantian ethics, motivation, and trust; communitarian ethics, ethic of care and egalitarianism; Stakeholder Theory; and the use of political tactics. Challenges to e-ethical leadership are presented and responses to these issues discussed. The conclusion presents four propositions for future research. The purpose of this paper is to identify secondary literature on e-ethics and how this new area of business ethics may affect the leaders of virtual project teams. Ó 2008 Elsevier Ltd and IPMA. All rights reserved. Keywords: E-ethics; E-leadership; Virtual project management; Virtual teams; Project management; Ethics; Project leadership; Ethical project leadership; E-ethical project management; Sensitive material; Code of conduct; Social isolation; Virtual community;...

Words: 6774 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Legal and Ethical Issues on the Job

...Every corporate entity has a fundamental part of its ethics. This is business ethics. These companies have their own unique identities within the business world in our country. These companies have a responsibility to themselves, their employees, their stock holders and their customers to follow the legal and ethical principles and regulations that the US has set up. If these companies do not follow the regulations that have been set up for them concerning the basic business ethical principles, many issues can arise, both legal and ethical. Within the business world there are many different issues in ethics that may arise in a business environment. If these issues are not handled correctly then they may turn into a legal battle. Companies need to make it a top priority to give their employees and all who work close to the company an idea of what the company’s mission is and what their overall vision is. They also need to have the knowledge of what is expected of them on the job and how they are expected to act. This will allow the employees to put into practice the correct code of ethics and those policies and procedures that the company has put into place. Fair business practices dictates that a company must put forth good effort to deliver the best level of ethics on a continued basis so that employees, applicants and customers may receive them because they are entitled to them. The goal of this paper is to examine the ethical and legal theories that apply to an ethical situation...

Words: 3705 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Ethics Case Study

...Part A Utilitarianism When applying the consequentialist theory of Utilitarianism to Tom’s decision on whether to falsify information on his resume I have found exaggerating details on his resume be unethical. The table on the following page analyses the benefits and harms of each course of action for Tom. With a higher overall number of harms and lower overall number of benefits from falsifying information than if he is honest. In line with utilitarian theories when looking at the wellbeing of all stakeholders the ‘greatest good’ comes from Tom being honest. If Tom is to exaggerate the details of his employment he could cause a likely negative impact on all stakeholders from his family to his possible future supervisor and peers while only providing an uncertain benefit for himself and others. Being honest may reduce his chances in securing employment but will provide a bigger possible benefit to all stakeholders overall regardless of success or failure in securing employment. Tom ought to be honest in his work history; as the requirement of previous experience is only desirable he is still has a chance at securing employment, and will be fairer on all applicants, the hiring company and it’s employees thus providing the greatest good for the greatest number of people. ¬ Stakeholders Lie - Harms Lie - Benefits Truth – Harms Truth - Benefits Tom – employment could be halted due to misleading information – if unable to secure employment confidence for future...

Words: 1113 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Integrating Values - the Legality, Morality, and Social Responsibility of the George Brothers & the Largest Pill Mills in South Florida

...Integrating Values - The Legality, Morality, and Social Responsibility of the George Brothers & the Largest Pill Mills in South Florida Abstract This paper examines the legality and ethics of the George brother’s pain medication clinics in South Florida. It explains the legality of the pain medication supply that is available for consumers that medically need it and how its source can also be an easy access to addicts. Although it is considered legal, is it ethical? In this paper we study different theories in ethics, including Kantian and Utilitarian ethical models. These models provide clear analyses that guide us in deciding if pain medication distribution from pain clinics is ethical. Finally, we review and conclude if the George brother’s pain medication clinics were acting socially responsible within their communities. Given the rise of pain medication abuse and illegal reselling, pain clinics in South Florida should adhere to strict rules to provide services to those that need it and not turn their businesses into pill mills. Introduction Purposes of Paper The intent of this paper is to provide a detailed and analytical examination of the George brother’s pain medication clinics. Throughout this paper all approaches will be examined such as the legality and ethics of the case, and how social responsibility plays a role. In the past few years in South Florida, there has been a rise of pain medication addiction and the reselling of these narcotics. Pain...

Words: 6754 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

An Ethical Assessment of the Acme, Inc. Environment

...An Ethical Assessment of the ACME, Inc. Environment April 3, 2016 Introduction ACME, Inc. is a company that is heavily regulated by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The company is preparing for an audit. In view of the recent toxic waste spill occurring on company grounds, it has raised concerns for management and an employee. Mary, who is the employee aware of the situation, was approached by her boss and told not to mention the hazardous spill. At a later time, Mary witnessed her boss getting rid of documents that had been specifically requested by the EPA. When Mary identified to her boss that she was uncomfortable with the situation, she was threatened with losing her job should she raise the issue again. This paper will analyze and discuss the concepts of employment at-will, whistleblowers, and the Utilitarian and Kantian ethical frameworks as relevant ethical topics to the ACME, Inc. scenario. Employment at Will According to Arnold, Beauchamp, & Bowie (2013), “EAW [employment at-will] is a common-law doctrine that states in the absence of law or contract, employers have the right to hire, promote, demote, and fire whomever and whenever they please.” This law also takes into consideration the employee where he or she is able to terminate their employment for whatever reason without violating any legal laws. This concept stems back to the 20th Century were it was believed that employers and employees should have...

Words: 1178 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...Introduction The unfortunate tragedies involving the explosion of Ford Pinto's due to a design defect led to a main debate regarding the use of a cost-benefit analysis and the ethics revolving around the company’s decision to go further with the initial, defective prototype. Ethical Dilemma Ford was completely aware of the safety issues the prototype was facing, but solving the issue would cause great disadvantage for the company: production schedule had to be modified, resulting in delays to bring the new car on the market, and also production costs would increase. In this context an ethical dilemma raised, so two crucial issues were addressed: either go further with the production of Pinto regardless the defects and the danger to future customers, or delay the production and modify the original model to assure safety and reliability, regardless the higher costs? Ford’s decision was to continue the production of the defective design while basing it on a cost-benefit analysis. In this context another dilemma was created: should such an analysis be used in situations where defects could lead to death or cause tremendous harm, such as in the Ford Pinto situation? Utilitarianism Based on the information provided by Ford, the company assumed and decided that the most benefit would come from going ahead with the production of the initial design. Utilitarianism is defined as a normative, empirical philosophy that is based on the principle that “the right thing to...

Words: 1860 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Humanistic Ideology

...The humanistic Ideology is the human wants needs and rights. Organizations that follow the humanistic approach have a business strategy which is to create a stakeholder benefit rather than shareholder maximization strategies. Besides that, governance under humanistic work towards using resources to meet society’s needs. Structure of humanistic company’s is decentralized. Furthermore, enormous roles of leaders in determining the character of the organization and guiding the organization on ethical principles. In addition, culture in a humanistic company is of human centered organization culture which allows constant organic change and evolution and promotes human development within and outside the firm. Lastly, in the societal system,...

Words: 823 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Mgmt

...(M00502049) Bikas Shrestha (M00504031) Crispen Rodrigues (M00511976) Sameer Dhulekar (M0050750) Shanon Jaywardane (M00504738) Report Word count: 1328 Group No: 3 Ahmed Musfar (M00502049) Bikas Shrestha (M00504031) Crispen Rodrigues (M00511976) Sameer Dhulekar (M0050750) Shanon Jaywardane (M00504738) Report Word count: 1328 Assignment: Group Course Work Subject: Ethics, CSR and Governance Prof: Dr. Andrea Werner Module: Management Perspective (MGT4814) Report: The Case Study Primark (Rana Plaza, Bangladesh) Assignment: Group Course Work Subject: Ethics, CSR and Governance Prof: Dr. Andrea Werner Module: Management Perspective (MGT4814) Report: The Case Study Primark (Rana Plaza, Bangladesh) Thesis Statement An Ethics and CSR responsibilities for the organization using a case study of Primark Contents Thesis Statement 1 Contents 2 Abstract 3 Introduction 3 Analysis 4 Business Ethics 4 CSR 5 Conclusion 7 References 8 Disclaimer: 10 Abstract This report discusses corporate social responsibilities and business ethics in the case of the Rana Plaza collapse. In April 24, 2013 the Rana Plaza factory in Savar district of suburb Dhaka, Bangladesh collapsed, where death tolls reached 1129. Those were garment workers for outsourced operations from well-known Western high street fashion brands. One of the factories buried in the collapse was a supplier of Primark. The incident unveiled debate on duties in supply chain...

Words: 1900 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Role of Ethics in Business

...| The Role Of Ethics in Business | | | | 1/16/2014 | | In this paper I will discuss the role of business ethics as it relates to business operations and the challenges of starting and maintaining an effective business ethics program. I will begin with Jennings' (2012) definition of ethics in business and its role from his perspective. I will then make comparisons with other authors' opinions for discussion, including Peter Drucker’s (1981) take on business ethics and Carr’s (Jennings, 2012) viewpoint as well. How business ethics' role relates to the notion of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) and ongoing challenges will also be discussed. I will conclude with my own comments on the relationship between personal and business ethics and my thoughts on how to start and maintain company ethical standards. Business Ethics And Its Role: Definitions and Discussion The concept of being ethical in business is a mercurial topic these days; given the expansive and rapid global reach of today's multimedia, it can take mere hours for a reputable business image to get tarnished because of one ethics-related incident. In his text, Jennings' definition of business ethics is "...not the study of what is legal but of the application of ethics to business decisions. (Jennings, 2012, p.45)" Many business leaders today focus on what is legally allowed--they are aware of the legal parameters within where they can operate, and simply execute their profit-driven...

Words: 2963 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

International Business

...COLLEGE OF ECONOMIC AND MANAGEMENT SCIENCES DEPARTMENT OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT An assignment submitted in partial fulfilment of the course: INT4801 (International Business) Assignment 03 Due Date: 09 October 2015 Table of Contents TABLE OF CONTENTS ..................................................................................................................................................... 1 QUESTION 1: CRITICALLY EVALUATE THE IMPORTANCE OF WORLD TRADE ORGANISATION (WTO) AS A REGULATORY BODY IN INTERNATIONAL TRADE ARRANGEMENTS. .................................................. 2 INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................................................................... 2 AGREED LIBERALIZATION ............................................................................................................... ERROR! BOOKMARK NOT DEFINED. RULE OF LAW.............................................................................................................................. ERROR! BOOKMARK NOT DEFINED. QUESTION 2: EXTENSIVELY ANALYSE THE RELEVANCE OF SUBSIDY AS AN INSTRUMENTS OF TRADE RESTRICTION, ESPECIALLY IN AGRICULTURE SECTOR. ................................................................... 9 INTRODUCTION ...........................................................................................................................................................

Words: 5530 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Ethical Treatment of Shareholders and Workers in a Traditional, Capitalist Corporation; the Ford Motor Company and Compare and Contrast the Findings with the Treatment of These Stakeholders in the Mondragon Cooperative Corporation.

...This essay will aim to investigate the ethical treatment of shareholders and workers in a traditional, capitalist corporation; The Ford Motor Company and compare and contrast the findings with the treatment of these stakeholders in the Mondragon Cooperative Corporation. The structure of this essay will be as follows; firstly the fundamental differences between the two contrasting organisations will be examined and how these differences impact the ethical treatment of the relevant stakeholders; secondly, the ethical treatment of shareholders in regards to corporate governance and the executive’s accountability and control will be investigated, and lastly, the ethical treatment of workers within the two contrasting organisations will be scrutinized in relation to the employees right to participation and association, as well as the right to fair wages. To frame the purpose of this essay; to investigate the ethical treatment of shareholders and workers in a traditional, capitalist corporation compared to the treatment of these stakeholders in the Mondragon Cooperative Corporation, it is imperative to firstly examine the contrasting ideologies and points of difference between the two ways of organising. In understanding the fundamental differences between the two contrasting organisations, it is then possible to recognise the ethical dilemmas that arise for both shareholders and workers. The fundamental differences between a traditional capitalist corporation and the Mondragon Cooperative...

Words: 2184 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Business Ethics

...Executive summary: This report is about how ethically correct KFC and McDonald’s are in their business practices. They both are from the same industry which is food and beverage but still are two different companies. Basically Business ethics focuses on identifying the moral standards of right and wrong as they apply to behaviour within and across business institutions. In this report we evaluate and compare their business practices according to ethical aspects. Later on we discuss the 4 ethical theories for each of the company which are individualism, utilitarian, virtue ethics and Kantian theory and apply them to show how ethical the business practices of each company compared to the other company. We justify our report by giving authentic facts and figures for each company. Finally in the end giving a conclusion on the discussion done for both the companies. TABLE OF CONTENTS: * Background of the companies * Comparison between business practices according to ethical aspects * Constructive and commercial ethical aspects of both companies * Discussing and applying the ethical theories according to the practices of the companies * Conclusion * References A BRIEF DISCRIPTION ON THE BACKGROUND INFORMATION ABOUT KFC AND MCDONALD’S’: First we talk about KFC; it is one of the world's most popular fast food restaurant chains in the world founded by Colonel Harland Sanders in 1930. Every day, more than 12 million customers are served at KFC...

Words: 2888 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Ethic in Hr Mgmt

...Ethics In Human Resource Management Alisha Wood Saint Augustine’s University Ethics and Human Resource Management Wikipedia, defines ethics as: "…a study of values and customs of a person or a group. It covers the analysis and employment ofconcepts such as right and wrong, good and evil, and responsibility." Wikipedia, defines utilitarianism as: “…ethical doctrine of greatest good. The ethical doctrine that the greatest happiness of the greatest number should be the criterion of the virtue of action The complexities of business and our human/social society makes corporate ethics a very interesting study. To a practicing manager in the working world today, this becomes critically important, especially if they don’t get it! And many obviously have not and still do not. The questions are really simple to ask - yet hard to answer: What does good business today really mean? What does ethics have to do, if anything, with good business? What impact can the human resource function have on either? Within business, what is my responsibility as a human resource professional? Corporate social responsibility (CSR) is known as one of the areas that has drawn many attentions in the business environment over the last twenty years. Carroll (1991) argued that corporation should be addressed not only from economic and legal perspectives but also from ethical and philanthropic perspectives; the idea of CSR’s pyramid is then derived. Furthermore, the efficiency theory...

Words: 2132 - Pages: 9