Premium Essay

Can Leadership Be Taught

In: Business and Management

Submitted By daward1988
Words 1369
Pages 6
Teaching Leadership; can it be done?
David Ward
Everglades University
MAN 2435

Thesis When managing a complex entity in any industry, developing strong leaders is one of the most important assets to the longevity and success of that entity. Can this highly complex experience based social skill be passed down to younger generations through education?

Developing strong leadership is a common focus in all industries, the argument that teaching the basics of leadership is merely a single step in developing the strong moral and ethical character defined in a good leader. Currently there are many programs in place with the sole intention of training new leaders and improving current leadership skills. However the debate remains, Is leadership a skill, or a trait? Whereas most management educators agree that is both a skill and a behavior, This mutual agreement has only widened the gap in defining whether or not leadership is something that can be taught. Is leadership based upon character, or is it something that can be developed like a skill? Leadership is deeply rooted in management research and development. Many top business schools are reported as such based upon by their publication of leadership coursework. Leading us to the presumption that leadership is widely viewed as an important skill set and our business education institutions are giving the education needed to develop competent leaders. Asking whether or not leadership can be learned is another way of approaching this question. There has been general agreement that basic leadership skills can be learned, but who, and where are the most effectively places to learn these skills are debatable.

The US ARMYs Westpoint Academy is a good example of an institution that focuses on specifically teaching leadership skills, such as courage, respect, and loyalty. Through the use of experienced...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Can Leadership Be Learned

...Can Leadership Be Learned? The principles of leadership remain constant; it's how leadership is put into practice that keeps getting smarter. BY Mark Sarner | 12-19-2007 Can leadership be taught? The answer is simple. Yes, leadership, like all skills, can be taught. The literature is clear on the essential components, styles, and dynamics. Educational materials and programs abound. But can leadership be learned? The answer to that question isn't obvious. It seems that leadership, one of the scarcest and least enduring components of human capital, is not learned easily or well. First things first. What is leadership anyway? According to Al Gini, a lecturer at Loyola University in Chicago, leadership is a "power- and value-laden relationship between leaders and followers who intend real changes that reflect their mutual purposes and goals." In plainer language, leadership is the dynamic that galvanizes individuals into groups to make things different or to make things better -- for themselves, for their enterprise, for the world around them. The "Great Man Theory" of human history focused our attention solely on the ideas espoused, the actions taken, and the outcomes generated by people in positions of power. Today, ideas and assessments of leadership are more democratic. Leadership itself is a collaborative function; the leader and the led are seen as in a potentially symbiotic and synergistic relationship. And power and impact are a function of that relationship rather than......

Words: 873 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Are Leaders Born or Made?

...Are Leaders Born or Made? Leadership-Mgmt Abstract Being a leader is something that at times can be very difficult to identify simply by definition. Not only does the term carry with it a great deal of meaning but it also has powerful implications that immediately come to mind. Among these are the positive traits required to be a leader. The Academy of Management Executive stated that Key leader traits include: drive (a broad term which includes achievement, motivation, ambition, energy, tenacity, and initiative); leadership motivation (the desire to lead but not to seek power as an end in itself); honesty and integrity; self-confidence (which is associated with emotional stability); cognitive ability; and knowledge of the business. (Lock, 1991) The point here is that being a leader can not be simply assigned, as to effectively function as a leader one must possess many or all of these required traits. What interests me is the question of whether or not people are actually born leaders, or is it simply a book that people read and learn on their own. The purpose of my research paper is to better understand this question. Are the best leaders born or taught? It’s quite possible that all of the skills of a leader are naturally ingrained into an individual thought process. An example that could relate to this might be a child that learns to play an instrument by ear rather than being taught. From my earliest memories as a child in pre-school and into......

Words: 1378 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Classroom Teaching

...Can Management be taught "The assumption that we can take people who have never managed, bring them into a classroom and teach them management is utterly wrong." Argument: The question of whether management education should be limited to candidates with prior experience in a work place cannot be answered without first answering the more fundamental question, what is the objective (or in MBA-speak, deliverable) of management education? At first glance, it seems irrational to restrict any particular field of education on the basis of something as unconnected from academic merit as age. The proponents of having students without work-ex in management schools argue on a number of planks, the prime one being the freshness of high quality talent just out of premier undergraduate schools, a claim which rests on the premise that being scholastically inclined inherently makes one a good manager. The latter view is particularly in vogue in Indian management education, especially when one considers the top rung schools like the IIMs, which pride themselves on selecting the best and brightest from the country's best undergraduate institutions like the IITs through a rigorous entrance process and subjects them to an exhaustive programme that teaches concepts in economics, business mathematics, organisation theory and even communication, convinced that after two years, they have produced thought leaders who are ready to contribute significantly to the firms they join and society as......

Words: 1367 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Leadership

...leadership ARE LEADERS BORN OR MADE? OR BOTH? Which came first - the chicken or the egg? Do great leaders learn to be superb inspirational figures? Or is it all in the genes and do people with exemplary leadership skills have a  natural aptitude for the job? The old ‘nature’ versus ‘nurture’ question! Can we finally put this age-old argument to rest and come to a conclusion? Let’s go to basics first. Encyclopaedia Britannica states: “Leadership - exercising of influence over others on behalf of the leader’s purposes, aims or goals.” Leaders are born not made: The 19th century Great Man theory believes that people inherit certain qualities and traits that make them better suited to leadership, claiming there are specific inborn characteristics which predispose people to be and become leaders. There is a significant difference between ‘learning a skill’ and ‘mastering one’, in the same way that some are born with outstanding musical or athletic talents. They will excel naturally in these areas but in others they would be like a fish out of water. This theory is supported by a 2013 research from UCL (University College London). The study is the first to identify a specific DNA sequence associated with the tendency for individuals to occupy a leadership position. Using a large twin sample, the international research team, which included academics from Harvard, New York University, and the University of California, estimate that a quarter of the......

Words: 1043 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Youth Sports

...sports can develop a lot of great qualities that can make children excellent individuals in the long run. Youth sports allow many children to form into great leaders by teaching them great leadership qualities. They also help children learn sportsmanship, problem solving skills and even something as a simple as time management. Being involved in sports teams comes with, many times, being part of a diverse group of people. Due to that, there will be members of the team that will play the role of the leader and others just as the members of the team. Forming part of a team also comes with having disagreements, which is okay. This is just another way for children to learn how to settle disagreements. Everyone sometime in their life faces situations where these skills are very important to have. The best time to instill these qualities is when children are young and this is why youth sports come to an advantage at an early age. Leadership comes in many different forms and is something definitely taught throughout youth sports. When I was younger, for example, I was very quiet and shy. I believed that I was a leader but was too afraid to express that vocally. My dad later explained to me that not all leaders are vocal and some simply just lead by example. Throughout youth sports, I always lead by example and was often considered a leader of my sports teams even though I was not vocal. Today, I remain the same and continue to lead by example, showing others that they can reach......

Words: 997 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Lsi Results Assignment

...D03454209 | LSI Style Interpretation | Leadership and Organizational Behavior | GM5910N_HProfessor Kenneth Goldsmith | Robert Neal White | 8/31/2011 | | After finishing the LSI Style Interpretation for this class I was identified as have the humanistic- encouraging style as my top style with a score of 38 which placed me in the top 93 percent of persons who took the interpretation. My second top style was the affiliative style in which I scored 37 and placed in the top 90 percent of persons who took the interpretation. After contemplating my work / leadership style(s) and comparing how I interact with co- workers and subordinates, I agree with the results and will further discuss my reasoning in this paper. First, I will discuss the humanistic- encouraging style. As depicted on the description of the humanistic- encouraging style, scoring high on the humanistic – encouraging scale is “positive, healthy and effective”. (International, 2011) The high score shows that I am “sensitive to people’s needs, and will devote energy to counseling and coaching others”. (International, 2011) The scale itself measures the takers interest in people and the tendency to care about others. It also measures the takers ability to encourage others to improve. As stated on the description, since I scored as high as I did I should “ have an unconditional positive regard for others”. (International, 2011). I completely agree with the results of the survey and am......

Words: 1552 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Leadership Approach Paper

...Leadership Approach Paper Sharon Boahn LDR/531 May 13, 2013 Drew Stevens Ph.D Leadership Approach Paper Leaders aid a group in achieving a common goal. Leaders have new ideas and goals they introduce to the group and motivates the group to work on the new ideas and achieve the goal. Leaders also inspire the group to perform at their best and assist them in their performance. Leaders have leadership skills and approaches that help them to be successful. The trait leadership approach is based on the theory that leaders are born with the leadership characteristics that enable them to be great leaders, instead of being developed or taught into the leadership role. There are strengths and weaknesses in the trait approach concerning leadership. Strengths There were several characteristics founded to be very strong in the trait leadership approach. “This approach emphasizes attributes of leaders such as personality, motives, values, and skills” (Yukl, 2010). The personality of a leader has a large role in his or her success. The personality of a leader can be very valuable when interacting with individuals, the personality of a leader can set the mode within the workplace. A leader with a positive personality will create an encouraging atmosphere where goal accomplishment and motivation will be successful. There are strong abilities identified in the trait approach of leadership, such as continuous force to get the job complete, sharp perception, and influential power.......

Words: 571 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Speech

...important club at my high school and that was the Renaissance Program. The Renaissance Program is a leadership committee in a high school setting to promote achievement and success throughout the school. I joined when we first started the committee and that was when I was a freshman in high school. I am certainly the person I am today because of this committee. As a member I learned how to become a leader, travel throughout the states, and become friends with amazing people. Leadership is what I learned as I enjoyed my four years of being a committee member for The Renaissance Program. Some people see leadership as simply someone who people follow, or as someone who guides or directs others. Well I see leadership as organizing a group of people to achieve a common goal. Leadership is also a social influence enlisted by a person to support others in an accomplishment. As the Renaissance Program grew I was one of the main members, making me feel welcoming. As the four years went on I became more and more of a leader due to the actions I was making on the committee. These actions include getting students and teachers involved in the committee and outside the committee. I was in charge of different Rallies throughout the years to help promote our Program. Rallies would involve teachers and students and different activities that were performed in front of the whole school. We taught our school how to accomplishment different goals as students and rewarded them....

Words: 852 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Army Report

...Organizational Behavior and Communication Com 530 January 13, 2012 Organizational Behavior and Communication The United States Army focused on personnel, training, technology, and leadership or this entire combine for the success of the Army in both peace and war. One of the important variables is culture; military culture of army personality, values, or way of thinking. Culture within the Army is widely diverse with the varieties of gender, religious background, races, or whether they are or will be active or reserve duty. As new people enter the Army, then they have to deal with external adaption and integrate them into the Army’s way of life and beliefs. New members are then taught to perceive and feel the same in the Army. The servicemen are taught limited use of forces in war at all possible, effects of military growth on units, insubordination causes, and innovation in the military, learning abilities impact within the organizations, leadership development, and potential conflicts on reconstruction teams. The Army has to be able to move large formation of servicemen safely on the battlefield, so there is a need to have critical control and command. Cultures The Army has the traditional approach where they have a higher up command (hierarchy) to direct and enforce policies, procedures, and process to fit the Army culture. Then the soldiers (clan culture) have more flexibility but less focus on control and structure. They are driven to shared goals,......

Words: 1136 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Business

...The Synthesizing Curriculum Paper Name: Institutional Affiliation: Date: Introduction The book ‘Curriculum Leadership: Strategies for Development and Implementation’ is addressed to the present leaders and those in practice for the role. The primary goal of the book is to provide learners with knowledge and qualities needed to become exemplary leaders in many parts. The first part of the book begins with the research of foundation of the field. This act helps make decisions from a broad perspective with intense knowledge. The second part discusses the procedures needed to bring about significant curriculum change. The third part is more interested in the management on the curriculum. It states that for a curricular to be effective then management must be handled well. The fourth section, this being the last part of the book it talks about the curricular trends in our current days. Thesis; the book Curriculum Leadership: Strategies for Development and Implementation Issues study that can help in our day to day leadership skills and requirements to educate and govern the public to a better-living standard. Report In the topic ‘The Nature of Curriculum’ which provides the general oversight of concepts for analyzes, we learn that the key to leadership is by making sure the leadership policies should line up with the set curricular goals to assist in student learning (Glatthorn, Boschee & Whitehead, 2015). In the concept of......

Words: 1471 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Born or Made

...What is leadership? What defines a great leader? Firstly leaders usually tends to step up in times of crisis and is able to act and think in challenging situations. They are also very inspiring, and charismatic this in turns inspire subordinates to engage and perform their duties in achieving their goal. Secondly leadership is a process of social influence which motives others in getting the best out of them towards the accomplishment of a task. Throughout the world there are a lot perception, interpretation and definitions that can be formulated from the word “leadership”. And to most extent what a leader is. What is understood, is to be a remarkable leader one must possess some of these skills such as being ambitious, having a positive attitude in terms of holding their own emotions in check especially in tough situations. They must be able to step down to be in touch with their people. Setting the right example by the way they act whiles focusing on the bigger picture. They usually are well-organized they establish a clear vision and provide information knowledge and methods in realizing that vision, they are also capable or coordinating and balancing conflicting interest of all members of a group, organization or institution. Unlike management leadership cannot be taught, some may argue that leadership can be learned through proper mentoring and coaching where others may say that leadership is a rare skill that not any one individual can obtain unless they are......

Words: 875 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Why Too Many Organisations Are over-Managed and Under-Led

...first attempt to explain the difference between leadership and management, and then explain what happens when an organisation is over-managed and under-led. There are many theories regarding leadership. Firstly, there is the Great man Theory, developed by Stogdill. He believes that leaders are born, not made. I interpret this to mean that leadership is not something that you can learn and that only certain people will make effective leaders. Therefore, if a person does not possess these qualities, then they will only ever be a manager rather than a leader. According to Northouse (2007), leadership is a process whereby an individual influences a group of individuals to achieve a common goal. According to John Kotter (1990), to achieve these outcomes, a common goal, leadership and management have different functions. For example, management deal with planning and budgeting, whilst leaders will motivate people. In my opinion, if you manage a team of factory workers, you simply ensure that they all meet the minimum targets and conform to company policy. If you are a leader, you also motivate these workers and engage with them on a more personal level to ensure that targets are consistently met and that workers are not demotivated due to a lack of motivators (Herzberg). If one acknowledges Kotter's theory as correct, then it is understandable how organisations can become underled. It is when not enough managers are showing leadership qualities. If you believe The Great Man......

Words: 912 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Leadership

...Leadership Leadership is defined as the process of motivating others to work to meet specific goals and objectives. My idea of leadership is being able to inspire others, motivate, set a vision, communicate, respect others, and of course, lead by example. A leader must have an honest understanding of who they are, what they know, and what they are capable of. To be a successful leader, you have to be able to convince your followers, not just yourself or your superiors, that you are worthy of being followed. I have been blessed to have a role model like my grandfather, Anthony Modzelewski. A leader motivates others to action, which is exactly what my grandfather does on a daily basis. He constantly urges me to do my best so that I succeed in whatever I am doing. Leadership is not only reflected in someone’s performance, but in accomplishments. Whether in personal, community, or business matters, a leader should always strive to achieve their goals. Whether they be physically in the world or spiritually, a leader is someone a person can look up to for encouragement and motivation. We all look up to someone in one way in one way or another as a sense of comfort. Imagine a man coming to a new country halfway across the world with his wife to start a new life with his new family. Role models are a great help in leadership situations. Leadership role models are people who are already in a position of authority that you look up to and hope to be like. Being a leader takes......

Words: 765 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ldr531 Week 3

...is someone that can take someone and make a positive impact on an individual’s life. Not everyone can be a leader or shall I say a good leader. Everyone claims they want that title but does not have what it takes to become one. “Leadership is the art of leading others to deliberately create a result that would not have happened otherwise” –SIY Characteristics of a good leader consists of a individuals having; self awareness (you have intimate knowledge of you inner emotional state), self direction (you are able to direct yourself effectively), vision (you have greater goals that you are working towards), ability to motivate (giving the desire to want to participate and help), and social awareness (understanding who is the key influencers). A leader that I admire is a past supervisor that I had in a prior department I was in with my company. Her name was Nicole. Besides liking her leadership style which was a coaching leader her personality was caring but strict at the same time which reminded me of a parents parenting style. Not only was she concerned with what was going on inside the workplace she was also concerned about each individuals personal life and showed genuine concern as to many supervisors do not care . Their only concerned with what is going on with an individual in the business aspect. That makes me feel like a person has my best interest and will lead me in the right direction that will benefit me in the long run. With Nicole’s leadership style being a......

Words: 865 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Lweek One Leadership

...Week One Leadership Approaches LDR 531 February 17, 2013 Dr. Pat Abstract Leadership can have several definitions. Researchers can take many different approaches to studying leadership and leadership styles. Indicators can be examined to determine the effectiveness of leaders and potential leaders. It can be argued that leaders are not “born”; they are trained and taught skill sets that develop their leadership style. Leadership approaches are classified into the following five approaches: the trait approach, the behavior approach, the power-influence approach, the situational approach, and the integrative approach. I believe the behavior approach may be a better suited approach for companies like the one I worked at for eight years. Table of Contents Introduction 4 Research 4 Behavioral Approach 4 Workplace 5 Pros and Cons.................................................................................................................................6 Conclusion......................................................................................................................................6 Reference........................................................................................................................................8 Week One Leadership can be defined many ways. One way to define it is; Leadership is “the behavior of an individual . . . directing the activities of a group toward a shared goal.” (Hemphill......

Words: 1035 - Pages: 5