Free Essay

Can the Human Memory Be Trusted?

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By rrachaell
Words 761
Pages 4
Can The Human Memory Be Trusted?
Many factors can influence eye witness testimony (EWT), EWT is a term used in the legal system when witnesses recall information concerning individuals who have committed crimes. The factors that could affect the accuracy of EWT may include leading questions, age and anxiety. So can the human memory really be trusted with so many effecting factors?
Loftus and Palmer (1974) conducted a study with the aim of assessing the accuracy of memory after witnessing a car accident, and including leading questions to assess whether they could affect immediate recall. The researchers showed forty five students seven different traffic accidents, and giving each participant a questionnaire asking specific questions about the accidents. They also asked the critical question of ‘how fast were the cars going when they hit each other?’ however the other groups where given other verbs of smashed, collided, bumped and contacted instead of hit. Their findings included they word ‘smashed’ generated the highest mean score of 40.8 mph and ‘contacted’ generated the lowest of 31.8 mph. Loftus and Palmer reached the conclusion that the form of questioning has a significant effect on witnesses accounts of events. Therefore EWT is unreliable and inaccurate according to these researchers, although others can dispute this. Yuille and Cutshall (1986) interviewed thirteen people who had witnessed an armed robbery in Canada. These interviews took place four months later, and the interviews included two misleading questions, these questions did not affect the witnesses’ accuracy to accounts they had given police at the time of the crime, and very still detailed descriptions of the event. Meaning that information given after events does not affect memory and accurate recall in real life EWT.
Age can also affect accuracy, Parker and Carranza (1989) conducted a study to compare the accuracy between college students and primary school children. They had to identify a specific individual within a slide sequence of a mock crime. While identifying photos children found it easier to choose ‘someone’ compared to the adult witnesses however made more errors of identification compared to the adults. So errors can be made while identifying individuals at any age group, meaning it could be unreliable with this influence as well. However Yarmey (1993) asked 651 adults in public places to give a description of the physical characteristics of a young woman they had spoken to for fifteen seconds, two minutes ago. Young and middle age adults were more confident with their recalling, compared to older adults, although there were no significant differences in the accuracy of recall that could be because of the age group of witnesses.
Anxiety could also affect EWT. A really traumatic event (as some psychologists argue) could negatively impact the accuracy of eye witness testimony. Deffenbacher et al. (2004) conducted a meta-analysis of eighteen studies that were published between 1974 and 1997, aiming to discover the effects of high anxiety and accuracy of eye witness recall. His findings backed the theory that high levels of anxiety do negatively affect accurately. However, Christianson and Hubinette (1993) questioned 58 witnesses of real bank robberies, the witnesses that had been threatened in some way, had a more accurate recall to those that had not, and were not as emotionally aroused. The weapon focus effect could also decrease the accuracy of eye witness testimony as witness tend to focus more on central details (e.g. weapons) rather than peripheral details (e.g. offenders face and characteristics, or what else is going on). Loftus et al. (1987) conducted a study into the weapon focus effect, using two conditions, participants heard a discussion in another room and someone emerge with a greasy pen in their hand. The other group heard a heated discussion and someone emerge with a paperknife covered in blood. When asked to identify the man that emerged from fifty photographs, participants of condition 1 had a 44% accurate recall, compared to condition 2 which had a 33% accurate recall. Loftus believes the weapon from condition 2 distracted the participants, and could explain why EWT is not as accurate as it could be.
So, can human memory really be trusted? Arguments can be justified from both sides, with an extensive amount of evidence to back it. In the circumstances of a court case, it can be crucial for a prosecution to go ahead, however in this day and age much more accurate technology can be used to convict someone, for example DNA testing or Crime scene re-enactment. So EWT could be seen as dated in today’s legal system.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Nature of Though

...Nature of Thought A tree lined street with trimmed lawns and homes nicely kept set in a quiet cul de sac offers the perception all in well in the neighborhood. In this instance, perception gives a sense of security and normalcy. What tools, as individuals, are employed to arrive at this perception? Perception is the process humans use to gain insight of the reality of circumstances using the information the senses provide. The combination of perception, cognition and understanding separates humans from the animal kingdom allowing either collectively or individually the ability to learn and to know a certain reality. An individual one can perceive a situation far from the facts. One’s sensing and memory processes can block logic and influence perception. Teaching oneself the art of critical thinking one can recognize that quiet, tree lined streets may give an illusion of security and normally. Individuals begin at an early age the process of thought and perception, thus, setting the stage for the sensing process and memory. Senses allow humans to experience the world using the entire collective of human sensory perceptions: hearing, seeing, feeling, tasting, and touching. When the senses work in unison with each other delivering information to the brain, in a millisecond the brain attaches implication to the information based on socialization and experience. The sensing process adds to recognition of the stimuli from the external world, and we to react or take an...

Words: 728 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


... PHI 210 Professor Carter Lauren Vinson Oct. 17, 2012 Human senses come in variety of ways from hearing, seeing, touching, feeling, and tasting. Our senses can also help with thinking and memory as well. When our senses help with our memory and thinking, it can make information accurate, and not false. Likewise, human senses do have its drawbacks. Being sick and tired can clutter human senses. We cannot smell certain things, due to the fact that our noises may be stuffed up because of a cold. Also, when humans are sick, hearing things can be a negative factor as well. Humans may not be able to hear good enough because their body is in a different state of mind, which is by being sick. It can slow down the body, and sometimes human’s body do not cooperate well when being sick. Meanwhile, the accuracy of sensory information is true due to the fact that, when it comes to touching, when someone touches something very cold their senses sends a message through their body to the brain, telling that they should remove their hand or finger. Another factor would be our sense of smell. For example, if someone is cooking in the house and forgot to set a timer for the food being cooked, they can tell when the food is being overcooked; because they will smell or sense a burnt smell throughout the house, letting them know that the food has been overcooked. When it comes to our senses as far as smelling, it can alert us on what may be going on as far as overcooked food, and......

Words: 821 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Psychological Testing

...There are different ways to do psychological testing. There has to be a way to measure different criteria of a specific element one is trying to study. A test can help psychologist determine, predict and explain a persons’ behavior and can attempt to use the information gathered through such tests to help the patient with their behavior or mental disorders. The word “test” comes from an Old French word, with the earliest recorded use in English being by Chaucer in 1368. Another definition of the term “test” is the process or an instance of testing the academic, mental, physiological, or other qualities and conditions of a human subject” (Vol. 17, p. 826). In order to better understand the concept of a psychological test, one has to break it down to having categories of tests. There are five major categories including mental ability tests, achievement tests, personality tests, interests and attitudes, and neuropsychological tests. The mental ability tests are comprised of many different tests which main goal is to test a wide variety of cognitive functions including memory, spatial visualization and creative thinking. In general, tests can be used for clinical purposes, educational purposes, personnel purposes or used for research. Mental ability tests are used by doctors, psychologist and psychiatrists and can be used to provide an index of an overall mental ability of individuals (Hogan, 2007). Achievement tests are used to assess a person’s knowledge and skill......

Words: 789 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay


...Sensory Perceptions Edward George Scherz IV PHI 210 26JAN14   What is the accuracy or inaccuracy of the human sensory information system, and what are the contributing factors to the accuracy of the sensory data. This is something that many have taken a life time to explore and find the true facts of the complicated system that transmits what we see, hear, feel, smell and taste. The senses are the connection between the world we live in and how the mind portrays the data collected. Every sense that the brain translates works hand and hand to build a picture of where we are, and what is happening. When an extremity nears something hot, the sense of feeling sends messages to the brain so that part can be removed before it gets burned. The sense of smell can signal things are pleasant or dangerous. If smoke is smelled, there could be a fire or something smoldering or smelling Barbeque on a grill lets the brain know that good food is near, so the accuracy of that sensory information can be trusted when functioning correctly. The information provided by the sense of sight usually provides accurate information about the world around. Seeing two people walking, there is no doubt about them actually walking. If the sun can be seen clear during the day, then it is not night, etc. Are there reasons not to believe sensory information can be accurate? Past experiences can influence the perception of sensory information. For example, Seeing two people walking, there is no......

Words: 665 - Pages: 3

Free Essay


...Assignment Title: Paper #1 Forensic Analysis of UEFI by Pui Yee (Pearl) Pang By submitting this assignment I acknowledge that I have read and agree to abide by the Champlain College Academic Honesty Policy. I declare that all work within this assignment is my own or appropriately attributed. I accept that failure to follow the academic honesty policy may result in a failure grade, or expulsion from Champlain College. Date Due: _11/4/2015___ Date Submitted:_11/4/2015__ Abstract The Unified Extensible Firmware Interface (UEFI) Specification is an interface between the operating system (OS) and the platform firmware and is managed through the UEFI forum, a collection of chipset, hardware, system, firmware, and operating system vendors. One of many benefits of using UEFI is that it provides a more secure environment during the boot process by adding several security mechanisms such as secure boot, and update. With the added secure boot feature, the correct bootloader certification is needed and database key authentication is also required before the booting process. As a result, rootkit or other malware program have a hard time hijacking the boot process and concealing itself from the operating system. This paper will focus on the analysis of UEFI's secure boot feature and its implications and challenges for digital investigators conducting computer forensic investigation. Keywords: UEFI secure boot, boot firmware, malware,......

Words: 1677 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Leadership Communication

...though there are certain traits that can be attributed to genetics which can, let’s say, gives a person the propensity to be a leader, I think through hard work and training anyone can master the “Art of great leadership”. In this paper, I am exploring some of the ways a person can train to be a great leader by drawing parallel from training techniques used by an actor. The primary source from which an actor can draw to create the emotional world of their character is their own life. In an analogous way, an authentic leader must draw from the experiences in their own life. This involves ‘connecting with themselves’ and drawing from the emotional memories and from key events of one’s life. To be a great leader, the quality to recall past experiences from the personal life that trigger certain emotions can evoke the feeling of authenticity in your audience. A growing number of studies point to the importance of leaders expressing their vulnerabilities in order to fully engage with and establish trust from followers. By revealing vulnerability followers can more readily identify with leaders, resulting in more positive and influential relationships between leaders and followers. Let’s take the example of President Obama, who I have always considered to be a good and genuine leader. He comes across as a person who is speaking from experience such that he truly understands and this helps us connect with his message. Similarly, by invoking memories that trigger the emotion I......

Words: 1279 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

"Dream Time" by Randall E.Auxier Summary

...“Dream Time” by Randall E. Auxier Christopher Nolan’s films, Memento and Inception, both approach the question of how humans experience time. What is known as the “pathologies of temporal experience”, is exemplified in Memento, where Leonard’s head injury breaks his main connection between the present and the past, also by causing him the inability to make new long-term memories. In the movie Inception, this same idea is presented to us but in a different form. Auxier describes it as “ a lasagna of ideas about time and dreams” (Auxier, 280) and begins with firstly explaining the idea of mementoes and totems. A “totem” is an object that the characters in this film keep with them in real life and in the dream world. It is identified as something unique, heavy and that only the owner is allowed to handle. Its purpose is to provide the dream-invaders a way of knowing whether they are in the dream world or in reality. If a totem is expected to fall, or operate in a certain way, then any change in this indicates that you are in a dream. Most importantly, Auxier says that this serves as “a point of connection between what you’re experiencing within yourself (beliefs, perceptions, assumptions) and the way the world really is.” (Auxier, 282) The idea of a “totem” allows for continuity of time in the narrative, it acts as a guide when discontinuities are found. Furthermore, both films attempt to explore the same problem, the continuity and discontinuity in our experience,......

Words: 1336 - Pages: 6

Free Essay


...about the Internet, and specifically about the effects of the wed search engine like Google. Many respected writers, a plethora of articles and books have been published lately arguing both sides of the issue. While many writers claim that the internet has a negative, damaging effect on the brain and cognition, others see the benefits of technology in helping us achieve the previously unachievable and freeing us from many time-consuming activities. Based on our research and personal experience, we have found out several reasons to support the argument such as the negative impacts on human behaviour, degeneration of human abilities and contradictory information. Therefore, we strongly agree that the sheer amount of information that we have access to nowadays is actually making us dumber. Information that we have access to is making us dumber because of contradictory information. Information can be defined as facts or details about a situation, person, or event. According to Wikipedia (2013), as the world moves into a new era of globalization, an increasing number of people are connecting to the internet to conduct their own research and are given the ability to produce as well as consume the data accessed on an increasing number of websites. Users are now classified as active users because more people in society are participating in the Digital and Information Age. More and more people are considered to be active writers and viewers because of their participation. ......

Words: 1702 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


...PSYCHOANALYSIS * HUMAN BEING endowed with a psychological history of their own that begins in childhood experiences in the family patterns of adolescent and adult behavior are the direct results thereof * The goal of psychoanalysis: to help resolve our psychological problems, often referred to as DISORDERS or DYSFUNCTIONS * the UNCONSCIOUS has a large control over us as we mostly do not know about our problems/disorders/dysfunctions thus: human beings are motivated, even driven, by DESIRES/FEARS/NEEDS/CONFLICTS which they are not aware of * the UNCONSCIOUS a storehouse of painful experiences/emotions/wounds/fears/guilty desires/unresolved conflicts it comes into being when we are very young by means of REPRESSION, i.e. the expunging from consciousness, of those unhappy events FAMILY is responsible for the “birth” of the UNCONSCIOUS it defines the way we perceive our place in it and how we react to this self-definition * the OEDIPAL COMPLEX competition with the parent of the same sex for the attention and affection of the other parent * the SIBLING RIVALRY competition with siblings for the attention and affection of parents * the PENIS ENVY * the FEAR OF CASTRATION Defences processes that keep the contents of our unconscious in the unconscious: * SELECTIVE PERCEPTION (seeing and hearing only what we feel we can handle) * SELECTIVE MEMORY (modifying memories or forgetting painful events entirely) *......

Words: 999 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

False Memories

... Professor: John Burke Kaplan University Sandra Exum False memories are thoughts about things that are from the past, but the perceiver thinks they are valid memories of personal experiences, but that actually are made from the perceiver’s imagination or from the suggestion of others (DeWolfe, 2013). There are many cases where a child will be sexually abused, and not recall it until they are older possibly even when they are an adult. It is possible to implant memories into a child’s mind to the point that they will really think that they were abused as a child (Loftus, 2003). An adult should know better than to try to implant memories of this type into a child’s mind. Memories of a happy experience will be retained longer, whereas an unhappy experience is more easily dismissed from a person’s memory. Nearly all human beings want to recall happy memories, rather than bad ones. False memories may happen accidentally or through unintentional and or intentional coaching, this is called influence, and this influence can come from opinions from authority figures, trusted family members, and even cultural beliefs. In a situation like this it is known as the interference theory, which suggests that forgetting is caused by other memories interfering with the retention of the target memory (Anderson, 2010). For example a husband and wife have three kid’s two girls and one boy, and they end up going through a...

Words: 1711 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Psychoanalytic Personal Assessment

...Psychoanalytic Personality Assessment Danielle Bridgewater Psychology of Personality 250 June 04, 2014 Jaime Schuler Psychoanalytic Personality Assessment Sigmund Freud, Carl Jung, and Alfred Adler are known as the pioneers of modern theories (Friedman & Schustack 2012). Their theories have changed psychological standpoints on the human mind and have become the greatest influences on modern psychology. (Friedman & Schustack 2012) Although much has changed over the years, Freud, Jung, and Adler came up with the ideas that has led to the theories of modern human behavior, personality, and thought processes. (The Science and Practice of Clinical Psychology, 2007) Nonetheless, their views, interests, and opinions were different in psychology. (The Science and Practice of Clinical Psychology, 2007) All three were psychiatrists. (The Science and Practice of Clinical Psychology, 2007) Sigmund Freud met Carl Jung after a meeting that lasted 13 hours. (The Science and Practice of Clinical Psychology, 2007) They became conspiring friends while circulating information on psychoanalysis. (The Science and Practice of Clinical Psychology, 2007) Sigmund Freud and Alfred Adler encountered one another at a psychology convention in Vienna. (Bridle & Edelstein, 2000, Spring/Summer) Jung and Adler were fascinated by Freud’s interpretation of ego, superego, and id; however, they had antipathy for Freud’s idealization of sexual theories. (Bridle & Edelstein, 2000,......

Words: 1422 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay


...classroom? After reading Teaching for Critical Thinking by Brookfield, I noticed that Brookfield chose to define critical thinking as primarily a way of living that helps oneself stay intact despite who other people, organizations and communities try to get you to act in ways that serve to benefit their own individual needs and demands. In a sense it is seen as a “survival necessity.” Brookfield draws parallels to how critical thinking can be both in and out of the classroom. He primarily suggests that there are several methods to develop someone’s critical thinking skills and suggests that they may not necessarily be confined to the classroom alone. To define this idea, Brookfield describes how critical thinking is a process involving four steps: hunting assumptions, checking assumptions, seeing things from different viewpoints, and taking informed action. Brookfield suggests that humans constantly make mental assumptions to guide and justify our day-to-day actions. Like muscle memory, I find it interesting how Brookfield suggests that humans will continue to have repeated interactions with them if they believe such assumptions will be successful. This process is also checked as we choose to carry them out as well. Brookfield notes The next step in critical thinking – checking assumptions – involves asking ourselves whether our assumptions valid and reliable guides for taking action. This is a process of appraisal in which we attempt to identify convincing......

Words: 732 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Article Rebuttal

...This is a rebuttal to an argument made in an online article that marijuana is not an addictive drug. By doing a systematic process and analyzing the argument presented, it is easy to see how the use of logic and the knowledge of fallacies, bias, and opinions can help anyone spot a bad or weak argument. First Claim: The article from Wiki Answers first states that one must first know what the definition of "addicted" and "habitual" is. It claims that "addiction" is not the same a "habituating" are not the same. The author describes the definition of addiction as a gross physiological change in the way the body works and habituating is merely a crave. The article acknowledges that neurological and neuro-chemical changes can happen however they are minor and are not always substance related. Counter-argument: The author of the article is attempting to downplay the effects that long-term use of marijuana has on the human body. Although research of long-term effects on the brain are inconsistent, it has proven that long-term use can lead to addiction as defined by the writer of this article. NIDA reports that long-term marijuana abusers trying to quit report withdrawal symptoms as in any addiction, which contradicts the claim that marijuana use is simply a habit, possessing no physical effects on the body. Second Claim: The article also claims Delta-1-tetrahydrocannibinol is such a very low dosage that the user needs to get large-scale physiological changes to become a......

Words: 682 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...born the everyday events that occur in our lives play an important role on the foundation of our memory as well as our physical, mental, and emotion development. Most of us are filled with memories of a good and happy childhood, but unfortunatly that is not the case in all children. Many children undergo much abuse during their childhood. From the physical abuse, sexual abuse, emotional abuse, physical neglect, emotional neglect, to that of edcational neglect, child maltreatment not only affects the child’s childhood years, it affects the indivudual’s adult life as well. Child abuse comes in many different forms and types. The one we are most familiar with is that of physical abuse. Such abuse includes deliberate acts of violence that injure children. Verbal abuse, in forms of shouting, humiliation, threats, and severe put-downs are forms of emotional abuse. Such abuse lowers individual’s self-esteem and disrupts a healthy emotional development. Another type of child abuse would be that of sexual abuse. Sexual acts of any form on a young child are all examples of child maltreatment. For victims of sexual abuse the symptoms are even more severe. A child who is the victim of prolonged sexual abuse usually develops low self- esteem, a feeling of worthlessness and an abnormal perspective on sexuality. The child may become withdrawn and mistrustful of adults, and can become suicidal. Physical and emotional neglect are forms of child abuse that we might......

Words: 1026 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Comp Hardware

...8.1.6 Type I,II,III can be placed in the PC card slot SATA: most common for internal hard disks PCMICIA Type 3: would be used to the card slot for additional hard disk storage to your notebook Docking station: lets you use notebook systems as a desktop system. (Portable) Nickel Cadmium ( Ni-Cad) batteries experience a memory effect. It had the greatest need to be completely drained before being recharge. Digitizer pad: the input device that uses a stylus. Point stick: extra button or knob on a laptop keyboard that moves the moust cursor Block: (brick) converts ac power to DC power Lithium Ion (i-Ion): battery type that offers the greatest storage capacity in the smallest amount of space. ExpressCard/54: L Shape & 34mm wide at the connector /34: tectangular & 34 Mini-PCI: internal wireless networking cards in laptops STATEMENTS: You can use an expresscard/34 card or and expresscard/54 card in laptop Compatible expresscards for the laptop include cards which are rectangular shaped. 8.2.6 Hibernation: needs to have enough free hard drive space 9.1 Spyware: it monitors the actions you take on your machine and sends the info back to its originating source Trojan horse: this program appeards to be a legitmate application, utility, gane or screensaver and perform malicious activities surreptitiously. Cookie: a file saved on your hard drive that tracks web sit preferences nd use. Graywayre:legitimate service 9.2.3 Social engineering: dumpster driving...

Words: 935 - Pages: 4