Free Essay

Can the Media Influence Politics? If so, How? If Not, Why Not?

In: Social Issues

Submitted By nat880
Words 1775
Pages 8
Introduction
The media is the link between the public and politics. However, while media sources are viewed as purveyors of the day's news, they maintain considerable influence on politics. It is important to differentiate the concept of media influence from the concept of media bias. While some media sources will have an undoubted bias in the way they are reporting the news and the issues they select and prioritise, this does not necessarily equate with influence. Influence can be far less obvious or overt than bias, and can lead to changes in opinion in an indirect manner. While United States news outlets such as Fox News or the New York Post may have a more direct political bias, other outlets such as CNN or the New York Times – while appearing less openly biased – will also wield considerable influence. Similarly, in the United Kingdom, while The Daily Mail has an agenda which must be obvious to many who read it, less openly biased newspapers such as The Guardian will still have the potential to influence politics and politicians. In fact, media sources with a less overt bias will have potentially more influence than others, as they could be considered to be more reliable or trustworthy than biased tabloid entertainment news. This paper will assess the issue of media influence on politics, and evaluate the methods and forms this influence can take.
Discussion
Media Influence
The role of the media in influencing politics has been long recognised. Comparative analysis of media sources from a number of countries has shown the influence organisations have over the political system (Hallin and Mancini, 2004, p. 4). With the development of 'mass media' and the increasing centralisation of news sources, the influence of the media has only grown. Since the 1970s, scholars have discussed the way in which the media has influenced politics and politicians. In The Agenda Setting Function of the Mass Media, McCombs and Shaw outlined how the media can take steps to determine which news would be published and which would be prioritised. Since then there has been a number of studies into media influence in the political sphere, whether that amounts to indirect forming of debate, or outright media bias. As noted by McQuail, ''the history of mass media shows clearly enough that such control is regarded as a valued form of property for those seeking political or economic power'' (p. 21). The media, and particularly mass media, can be a useful and effective tool for exerting political influence. This can be done by those involved in the media industry in both a direct and an indirect manner, i.e. with or without the level of knowledge of the degree of influence. McQuail argues that the mass media can effectively set the agenda and determine which ideas have importance in the political realm, all the while seeming as mere purveyors of the day's important happenings. ''The mass media can divert and amuse and they can flatter. In general, mass media are very cost effective as a means of communication in society; they are also fast, flexible and easy to plan or control'' (p. 21). While the literature is by no means settled on the extent of the existence of media influence over politics and political debate generally, studies that consider media to have little influence often focus on whether such influence amounts to bias, or whether such influence is liberal or conservative (Entman, 2007, p. 164). Entman notes that studies which attempt to disprove a particular bias among news sources will often explain that liberal or conservative bias in mainstream news sources is overstated, however they tacitly acknowledge that news sources must necessarily have a certain degree of influence over politics (2007, p. 168; Domke et al, 1999, p. 35).
The way in which the mass media set the agenda in the political arena is multi faceted. Studies have shown that issues deemed by the public to be important are often influenced or completely replaced by issues deemed by the media to be important or pivotal. As noted by Entman, this can take the form of obviously biased reinforcement of particular values, such as ''consistent framing in favour of capitalism, patriarchy, heterosexism, individualism, consumerism, and White privilege, among other deeply entrenched values that certainly help allocate power in American society'' (2007, p. 170; Gilens, 1999 p. 3). Cohen, Tsfati and Sheafer cite the example of almost the entire Israeli Knesset participating in a taping of The Apprentice as it was deemed beneficial to their political standing – even though the benefit of the appearance was minimal outside of media value (2008, p. 1). However, influence need not be so overt for it to be remarkably influential. The media effectively sets the boundaries for political debate, reaffirming that each issue falls somewhere along the political spectrum – whether liberal or conservative – according to criteria developed by news organisations themselves. Attitudes towards particular aspects of government policy can be framed and reinforced by the media, until such attitudes are adopted by politicians and the wider public. Entman notes that in the United States the mainstream media has advocated for widespread reduction in taxation since the 1980s, and this has influenced the way in which both politicians and the public deal with the issue of taxation. Politicians and members of the public who held attitudes inconsistent with this lower tax view – for instance noting the social benefits of higher taxation – were marginalised and portrayed as being off the spectrum (Entman, pp. 169-170). Even non-domestic issues such as foreign policy will often be within the media's sphere of influence (Robinson, 2001, p. 524).
One clear area where media has a strong influence in the realm of politics is in regard to elections. Candidates understand that a favourable opinion among those in the mass media is crucial to their electoral hopes. As far back as the 1970s, scholars noted that ''in our day, more than ever before, candidates go before the people through the mass media rather than in person'' (McCombs and Shaw, p. 176). With the degree of money that is involved in contemporary media, there is an obvious benefit in encouraging or discouraging particular viewpoints. A political candidate may adopt a position which will be beneficial to a media organisation, and the organisation may favour the politician accordingly. While this may happen by a news source adopting a particular political position and thereto reporting in a consistent manner, it can also be through specific campaigns – particularly election campaigns. This is only furthered by larger news providers and centralised media ownership. As noted by Entman, ''Powerful players devote massive resources to advancing their interests precisely by imposing such patterns on mediated communications. To the extent we reveal and explain them, we illuminate the classic questions of politics: who gets what, when, and how'' (2007, p. 164).

How? Manner of Influence Utilised by Media Sources
The way in which different media sources influence politics will depend on the type of media employed. McQuail notes that the gatekeeper role occupied by the media allows media to select which information will become news (p. 21). Essential to the provision of news by media organisations is the determination of which issues are deemed to be the most important of the day, a process known as determining the 'currency' of the news. This is generally done by a team of editors pursuant to the rules laid out by a chief editor or by another actor who has determined a set or features according to which news must be organised and priorities. McQuail lays out a number of ways in which this can occur (p. 21):
“First the media can attract and direct attention to problems, solutions or people in ways which can favour those with power and correlatively divert attention from rival individuals or groups. Second, the mass media can confer status and confirm legitimacy. Third, in some circumstances, the media can be a channel for persuasion and mobilisation. Fourth, the mass media can help to bring certain kinds of publics into being and maintain them. Fifth, the media are a vehicle for offering rewards and gratification.”
Whichever media medium is employed, whether newspaper, television, internet or radio, the method will differ as to how news is prioritised (McCombs and Shaw, p. 178). For newspapers and internet sources, placement is of particular relevance, as front page news will be received by more readers and will be deemed to be of a greater importance. The size of the article (how many centimetres and how many columns, as well as the size of the headline) will also be important, but but not nearly as indicative as placement. Similarly, placement and time period are important to determining the priority of radio or television news stories. New media, such as social media and others enabled through internet and smartphone platforms have also been found to be considerably influential (Axford and Huggins, 2001, p. 193).
Conclusion
The essay question asks 'can the media influence politics'. The answer to that question is an emphatic yes. Not only has the media considerable influence over politics and the political cycle indirectly, but the media can decide to target particular candidates or parties to receive favourable results. Through determining the currency and priority given to each item of news, the media frames the issues and sets the political agenda in which politicians are required to operate.
Bibliography
Axford, B, Huggins, R, (2001), New Media and Politics, London, Sage Publications.

Cohen, J, Tsfati, Y, Sheafer, T, (2008), The Influence of Presumed Media Influence in Politics, Public Opinion Quarterly, Vol 1, No 0, pp. 1-14.

Domke, D, Watts, M, Shah, D, Fan, D, (1999), The Politics of Conservative Elites and the Liberal Media Argument, Journal of Communication, Vol 49, No 4, pp. 35-58.

Entman, R, (2007), Framing Bias: Media and the Distribution of Power, Journal of Communication, Vol 57, pp. 163-173.

Gilens, M, (1999), Why Americans Hate Welfare, University of Chicago Press.

Hallin, D, Mancini, P, (2004), Comparing Media Systems, London, Cambridge University Press.

Jebril, N, Loveless, M, (2013). The Media and Democratisation. What is Known about the Role of Mass Media in Transitions to Democracy?, Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism.

McCombs, M, Shaw, D, The Agenda-Setting Function of Mass Media, pp. 176-187.

McQuail, D, (1979), The Influence and Effects of Mass Media, in 'Mass Communication and Society', J Curran (ed), Sage Publications.

Newton, K, (2010), Foundations of Comparative Politics, 2nd Ed, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Robinson, P, (2001), Theorising the Influence of the Media on World Politics, European Journal of Communication, Vol 16, No 4, pp. 523-544.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Medias Negative Effect on Politics

...Political Science 201 June 7, 2012 Media’s Negative Effect in Politics The media plays a heavy negative role in American politics. During the past few years, society’s judgment has been based on what was given to it through the media. People rarely specifically research on candidates or propositions anymore. Much of the mass media is biased by trying to persuade viewers into believing what they want them to believe are true. Media is created for consumption by a large number of people watching it. The media has a remarkable impact on politics, which is not always good or beneficial. The data collected from the media can either be used for or against a politician. If a politician is favored by a certain network, such as CNN, NBC, or FOX, then the network can help his or her career reach new heights; however, if a politician is disliked then the network is capable of destroying the politician’s career. The media has the desire to make decisions for itself and in return try to convince people of its rightness and distort its viewers’ perspectives. There are many different types of media that can have a different influence on society’s political view. The four biggest forms of media are radio stations, newspapers, the internet, and television. People could tune into radio stations or talk radios to listen to political candidates being interviewed. An example would be in 1992 when "President George H. Bush interviewed with conservative talk show host Rush Limbaugh" (Curl).......

Words: 2554 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Political Science

...Balance of Media Media is a huge part of politics. Without the mass communication systems we have in the US today, there would be an even bigger knowledge gap in our population. The percentage of people who are actually up to date on current politics and issues is astounding when you look at all the media coverage these areas have. The media serves as a politician’s biggest survivor tool and worst enemy; although some like to say any media is good media, when dealing with politics it can be a detriment, not only to a politician but to the entire political system. Having freedom of press leaves unlimited opportunities to convey whatever news there may be in whatever way best suits that source. How the media influence has changed people’s mind about politics can be seen as good and bad. With an already considerably low number of citizens active in their knowledge of politics, the media is a huge reliant. Without television broadcast, and radio stations there would be millions of more people clueless as to what is going on in our government. So for their general purpose of simply informing the public, the media overflow is a good thing and has positive influence on people. There are also media outlets that stand on either side of the spectrum, so people can see the difference and get the correct information for both sides. And even better there are some less popular channels that convey both sides equally without bias toward either party or view, making an excellent source...

Words: 757 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Celebrities, Capitol Hill, and the 2009 Health Care Debate

...celebrities run our world at times. Social media is to blame for that I believe, as it has become an everyday necessity. Naturally on these social media sites like Twitter and Facebook we like to follow our favorite actors, musicians, athletes, etc. and their opinions, while they may not matter to us, are without a doubt at least seen due to the sheer number of followers. Is it right for us to blindly follow the opinions of someone based of social status? Of course not. In fact, Ignacio Gatti, the author of the article “Celebrities: Why Do They Have So Much Influence?”, went as far as to say that following someone’s opinions based simply off of social status is unethical. Does that mean that it doesn’t happen? Of course not. Whether we like it or not, celebrities have a large impact on much of our society, and their political opinions are no exception. Looking at the critical analysis questions in the textbook, the first question is “Do you think celebrities should have the chance to address congressional committees even if they are not experts on the policies being discussed?” (Pg. 464) To answer this question is a tough one for me, as it gives me mixed feelings. My initial reaction to the question is that celebrities, unless a proven expert on the policies at hand, should not have a place in congressional committees. I’m sure if you polled the nation they would share this viewpoint as well. No one wants to admit that celebrities influence your opinions, political or not,......

Words: 921 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Blank Paper

... Media Influences on American Culture 6 – 10 p.m. Tuesdays Course Start Date: 06/14/2011 Course End Date: 07/12/2011 University of Phoenix South Florida Campus Miami Learning Center 11410 NW 20th Street, Miami, FL 33172 Whenever there is a question about what assignments are due, please remember this syllabus is considered the ruling document. Copyright Copyright © 2011, 2009 by University of Phoenix. All rights reserved. University of Phoenix® is a registered trademark of Apollo Group, Inc. in the United States and/or other countries. Microsoft®, Windows®, and Windows NT® are registered trademarks of Microsoft Corporation in the United States and/or other countries. All other company and product names are trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective companies. Use of these marks is not intended to imply endorsement, sponsorship, or affiliation. Edited in accordance with University of Phoenix® editorial standards and practices. Course Description The course provides an introduction to the most prominent forms of media that influence and impact social, business, political, and popular culture in contemporary America. It explores the unique aspects of each medium as well as interactions across various media that......

Words: 3584 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Effect of Media During Elections

...Introduction The purpose of this interview was to examine the role of media in the electoral process, or during elections to be precise. The activities of the media are various, so this perhaps was just by noting and classifying some of the things the media do in elections. The interview was quite entertaining and there were no conflicting views or controversial opinions. The interview was conducted via cell phone while the interviewee was in the comfort of her home. This set a casual and comfortable tone for the interview. The topic for the essay which stood out after the interview was “ELECTIONS AND THE NEWS MEDIA.” Below is a summary of the interview: What is Media? Most journalists define media as a channel of communication through which news, entertainment, education, data or promotional messages are disseminated. Broadcasting, newspapers, magazines, TV, radio, billboards, telephone, fax and internet are all considered media. Who are the News Media? News media are those elements of the mass media. Generally focus on delivering news to the public or target public. Print media such as newspapers and news magazines are part of news media. Broadcast news such as radio and television, Internet such as online newspapers and news blogs are all news media. So what is a newsreel? (follow-up question) Newsreel was a documentary film common in the first half of the 20th Century. This released a public presentation place containing filmed news stories on a regular......

Words: 1410 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Media Influence On Election Essay

...How the media influence gave rise to Donald Trump In this new era of globalization, the media has more power and influence than it has ever had in the history of technology. The role of media over the years has become very important when it comes to political election. There is an interdependent relationship between politics and media, when it comes to the political elections. The media affects political elections and campaigns by communicating the agendas and beliefs of different political parties. The strong influence of media on political election can seal the fate of any electoral candidate or party. That is what happened in the case of Donald Trump, when he won the Republican primary votes. Prior to the Republican primary votes...

Words: 1620 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

How Social Medias and Modern Technology Have Affected Today’s World?

...Advertising Strategy How social Medias and modern technology have affected today’s world? I) The 90’s, a new communication way is born (1990-2001) a) Internet and the firsts social medias (1990-1997) b) The expansion of the market (1997-2001) jlb II) Web 2.0: a new influence for social medias (2002-2010) a) The booming market b) A new kind of addiction III) Social media: a revolutionary marketing tool a) Companies and politics b) Conclusion I) The 90’s, a new communication way is born (1990-2001) a) Internet and the firsts social medias (1990-1997) If we are speaking about social Medias we must deal with the enhancement of technologies. Effectively, social Medias can’t exist without the creation and the publication of internet, that’s why social networks are affecting today’s world. But what is a social media? Social media is a web site or a platform allowing all users to publish data in purpose of sharing with other people. It can be messages, photos, videos, wikis etc… Nowadays, there are millions of social media users, so the question is how it all began? This global phenomenon was created in USA just after the publication of the internet during the early 90’s. Usually people assimilate social media by the development of web 2.0, but the first websites was founded before 2003 (creation of the term “web 2.0”). Indeed, in 1988 AOL created a new kind of social platform and in 1995, the network of......

Words: 1377 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

June 2011

...turnout to the general election was just 60%. This was seen to be a participation crisis by some. This extract would argue that casting a ballot is only part of a person’s political participation. It shows that 62% of people had given money to an organization in the previous 12 months. Also, 50% of people had signed a petition. This suggests individuals choose their involvement in politics in their own way and generalizing that if general election turnout is low, political participation is low is incorrect. This is supported by the POWER report in 2006 that suggested there is not a political participation crisis as there is still involvement on a local level. This suggests that political participation should not just be judged on turnout for general elections but also other acts of political participation. Using your own knowledge as well as the extract, consider why some commentators have spoken of a ‘participation crisis’ in recent years. In recent general elections, declining levels of turnout have led some to believe Britain is having a participation crisis. Meaning, political participation is so low it threatens to undermine Britain’s democracy. In the 2005 general election just 60% of registered voters cast a ballot and this increased slightly in 2010 to 65%. Low levels of turnout cause numerous problems. If not enough of those able to vote do, it calls into question the legitimacy of the result and any decisions made by the winning party. For example, the......

Words: 1720 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Syllabus for Media

...| Course Syllabus College of Humanities HUM/186 Version 3 Media Influences on American Culture WCFYS0712 | Copyright © 2012, 2011, 2009 by University of Phoenix. All rights reserved. Course Start Date: Tuesday, 8/28/2012 Week 2: Tuesday, 9/4/2012 Week 3: Tuesday, 9/11/2012 Week 4: Tuesday, 9/18/2012 Week 5: Tuesday, 9/25/2012 Course End Date: Tuesday, 9/25/2012 Facilitator Information                                                                                                Ststeve Headley sheadley@email.phoenix.edu (University of Phoenix faculty) Steve.Headley@phoenix.edu (work) 727-642-4993 (cell) 513-551-5144 (Work) Course Description The course provides an introduction to the most prominent forms of media that influence and impact social, business, political, and popular culture in contemporary America. It explores the unique aspects of each medium as well as interactions across various media that combine to create rich environments for information sharing, entertainment, business, and social interaction in the United States and around the world. Policies Faculty and students/learners will be held responsible for understanding and adhering to all policies contained within the following two documents: University policies: You must be logged into the student website to view this document. Instructor policies: This document is posted in the Course Materials forum. University policies......

Words: 2484 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Political Science Process Essay

...Before taking PLSC 112 this summer, my knowledge and views of the American government and politics were very limited. I’m embarrassed to admit it, but I have always been a little ignorant when it came to knowledge about the government or political issues, but have always wished that I knew more, especially with the economic problems we are facing today. I never really did form many political opinions, one way or the other. I vote every election, but never really understand the bigger picture at hand. Such as, all the issues that a candidate stands for or the impact of proposals on the government. When people around me have conversations about American politics, I am embarrassed that I either do not understand what they are saying, or cannot add to the conversation because I don’t know what to say. I guess you could say that I have always been a little cynical when it came to politics. Part of this reason is because I have always felt that the political game played in American politics was just a bunch of people talking baloney, making empty promises, trash talking their opponents, and trying to persuade people to think their way. And whoever does this the best wins, end of story. I’ve always known that there was more to American politics that this, but never really tried to find out more. So, when I signed up for this class, I wanted to shed my ignorance and learn more about my government and how it operated. I am proud to say that my knowledge of our government has been......

Words: 2201 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Love

...Chapter 6  The media, government accountability, and citizen engagement  Katrin Voltmer  The past two decades or so have seen an unprecedented spread of democracy around the  globe.  With  the  fall  of  the  Berlin  wall  in  1989  and  the  end  of  the  Cold  War,  the  ‘third  wave’  of  democratization,  which  started  in  the  early  seventies,  now  encompasses  countries  in  Asia  and  Africa.1  And  even  in  states  whose  governments  continue  to  resist  a  more  open  and  participatory  form of governance, such as North Korea, Burma or Zimbabwe, the idea of democracy is a powerful  force that inspires people to take on a more active role in public life. However, many of the newly  emerging  democracies  seem  to  fall  short  of  some,  often  many,  of  the  basic  standards  that  define  democratic  rule,  with  irregular  voting  procedures,  corruption,  inefficiency  and  autocratic  styles  of  government  being  but  a  few  of  the  maladies.  In  addition,  as  many  of  the  newly  emerging  democracies belong to the developing world, inequality and poverty remain severe obstacles to full  self‐determination of the people.  The experiences of the past decades have shown that democracy is not a one‐way road and  that  a  viable  democracy  requires  more  than  the  implementation  of  the  key  institutions  of  government.  Rather,  an  accountable  and  efficient  government  is  embedded  in  a  complex  web  of  interdependent  conditions ......

Words: 10604 - Pages: 43

Free Essay

The New Media: Distorting Politics

...The New Media: Distorting Politics Carreon, Elimar Andree L. Valmores, Michael Aldrin S. Hidalgo, Jebb B. Saint Louis College Mr. Al Gerald S. Barde English IV IV – St. Alphonsus of Ligouri October 21, 2011 The New Media: Distorting Politics The crucial function of mass media in influencing public’s knowledge and understanding on global and national issues is indisputable. In the Philippines, media plays a critical and widespread role in daily life (Suguitan, 2007). Suguitan proclaims that it is an understatement to say that the media is merely influential, for it is powerful enough to make or break persons and institutions, and even shape society (2007). Performing as the main source of information, media serves as the medium in which the government informs, explains, and tries to win the support of the people for its programs and policies (Soifer, Hoffman and Voss, 2001). In this jurisdiction, the media is often called the fourth branch of the government for it monitors political matters to ensure political players don’t abuse democratic processes (University of San Francisco, n.d.). According to Political scientist Harold Lasswell, a pioneer in media studies, the media must perform three societal functions: surveillance of the world to report ongoing reports, interpretation of the meaning of events, and socialization of individuals into their cultural settings. Surveillance involves two major tasks. When it constitutes to the need of general public, it...

Words: 2530 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Voter Information and the Democratic Citizen

...rule. In Washington, politicians are split along partisan lines, battling one another on decisive and controversial issues such as raising the debt limit, balancing the budget, and health care reform. While politicians carefully calculate the potential consequences of their decisions, the same battles are being waged ferociously on other fronts by the media and other self-interested groups. Ultimately, the results of these policy decisions depend on which party could convince the American public of what is in their best collective interest. This is precisely the nature of politics and democracy, and neither one is always fair. In a world where interest groups and lobbies have tremendous sway and influence over those in power, and when media reporting of the issues lacks fairness and accuracy, it should be the citizen's duty and responsibility to ensure that they are politically aware and civically engaged. This paper will argue that an informed citizenry is necessary to the proper functioning of the American political system. Decreasing levels of political knowledge amongst citizens and the manipulation of the facts by the media obfuscate the important issues that affect the public good, while preventing democracy from flourishing. As James...

Words: 2854 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Media Coverage of the Army

...Media Coverage of the Army By 16 November 2005 SGM Olson Group M15 Media Coverage of the Army The American public has come to know the United States Soldier and the army through the influence of the media. The American people have formulated a certain trust and support for the American Soldier at war, because of stories told by the media. This trust and support is evident as more than half the American public is against the war in Iraq and the global war on terrorism. The Soldier and the army now become in the middle of a public opinion war because of views, stories and perceptions from the media. At the same time, the media has disrespected the American Soldier by describing American fatalities in the war as milestones. The Soldier and the army must change public opinion, and rise up with an over whelming public relations campaign telling their side of the story. The media is quick to report a head line of “American Soldier shoots Iraqi civilian”. The story reveals only a statement from the dead Iraqi’s wife who said “an American shot my husband”. All the public has seen is the head line and one side of the story. The public instantly forms perceptions against the American army. The Soldier and the army automatically become the bad guys, public opinion sways against the army, and the Soldier is under investigation. Two days later an investigation concluded that the Soldier was innocent. The...

Words: 1398 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Control of the Mass Media

...The Control of the Mass Media Some nations can influence and control their media greatly. In addition, powerful corporations also have enormous influence on mainstream media. In some places major multinational corporations own media stations and outlets. Often, many media institutions survive on advertising fees, which can lead to the media outlet being influenced by various corporate interests. Other times, the ownership interests may affect what is and is not covered. Stories can end up being biased or omitted so as not to offend advertisers or owners. The ability for citizens to make informed decisions is crucial for a free and functioning democracy but now becomes threatened by such concentration in ownership. The idea of corporate media itself may not be a bad thing, for it can foster healthy competition and provide a check against governments. However, the concern is when there is a concentration of ownership due to the risk of increased economic and political influence that can itself be unaccountable. Global conglomerates can at times have a progressive impact on culture, especially when they enter nations that had been tightly controlled by corrupt crony media systems (as in much of Latin America) or nations that had significant state censorship over media (as in parts of Asia) (McChesney 2000, 22). The global commercial-media system is radical in that it will respect no tradition or custom, on balance, if it stands in the way of profits. But ultimately it is......

Words: 1684 - Pages: 7