Premium Essay

Capital Punishment: Just or Cruel?

In: Social Issues

Submitted By amitchell18
Words 597
Pages 3
Personal/Creative Writing

Turning your essay into a conversion

Capital punishment ends guilty lives to save innocent ones

Is an eye for an eye really that fair and simple? Is it always going too far to take someone's life even if they were guilty of a horrible deed? Before, you answer that put yourself in the shoes in a family where a relative was murdered. A husband who lost a wife, or a father who lost a son. would you not want justice? That's what the death penalty is. A harsh punishment that can only be fitting for the most cruel of crimes. This wouldn't bring your loved one back, but it guarantees the person who is responsible cannot harm another person or their family.

My opinion on the death penalty started in 2008 during the election for governor in Massachusetts. Being only 15 at the time i couldn't vote however one of the major debate points was reestablishing capital punishment in Massachusetts, which was abolished about two decades ago. Everywhere i went people argued about which candidate had better views on the death penalty. At my age I had heard so much discussion in local politics there were the pro death penalty debaters stating it would lower crime rates while those who opposed this would say there hasn't been a significant difference in crime since capital punishment was ended. One statement really stuck with me about this topic and brought my view to agree with it. It's point was about executing the death penalty on murderers. It was said my father and he claimed, "When you take a life from someone, you lose the right to keep your own." Initially I didn't put much thought into this statement. However over time I came to realize my dad's point life is a privilege and abusing that privilege should have equal consequences.

Another incident that affected my view towards the the death penalty only a year later i was told...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Capital Punishment

...Problem Definition Assignment Capital Punishment The issues on capital punishment and the problems associated, this policy should always be considered an issue until it is resolved in a just manner. Capital punishment directly violates the ban on cruel and unusual punishment, giving the authority to take the life of another, if for no other reason, than it is discriminatory, or done in a premeditatory fashion. One chief complaint is that capital punishment exacts retribution for crimes that severs as justice to murder victims and their survivors. Another complaint is the inequities that relate to the moratorium on executions, this just states the debate as to the fairness of the policy. According to the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), their opposition is that the death penalty in the US is applied in a manner that is unfair towards people, based on money, skills of their attorney, race and where the crimes have taken place. Statistics state that the race of the victim is the biggest factor in determining whether or not a person will be executed. The importance of capital punishment is to answer some direct questions: 1. Does this deter crime? 2. Is this fiscally responsible for the government and taxpayers? Does this somehow fix the deficit? 3. Does this create a better economy? 4. Who does this punishment have the greatest impact on?...

Words: 403 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Capital Punishment Argument Essay

...Of course there must be proportionality between criminal and punishment making the punishment for murdering someone or multiple people a more serious punishment. Many people against Capital punishment would also argue that the death penalty is unconstitutional, saying that it violates our rights that our country is based upon. Our Constitution never clearly stated anything about capital punishment. People can manipulate the amendments however they...

Words: 838 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Pros And Cons Of Capital Punishment

...So how is capital punishment going to serve the society? Punishment should be a means of and rehabilitation and not retribution. 3. Capital punishment is hypocritical It sounds incredibly bizarre that a justice system would resort to killing to denounce the crime of murder! By means of capital punishment we are proving the point that a person’s life can be controlled by someone else. No one’s life should be in the hands of others, even a hardened criminal. 4. Capital punishment is always cruel In the US there is 5 ways of putting a criminal to sleep: lethal injection, electrocution, gassing, hanging and firing squad. It is said that all these 5 means of execution are painless but how can there be a proof for it? Has a criminal executed come back to life and said: “oh! It was so painless and peaceful”? All these 5 means of execution sound cruel just by feel. 5. Prison is hell on earth We have all heard and read about the fact that prison is not cool. Were it being a happening...

Words: 1650 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Cruel and Unusual Punishment: the Death Penalty

...Georgia case, the Supreme Court recognized that capital punishment was indeed a roll of the dice, and as a consequence held that as practiced it violated the Cruel and...

Words: 3008 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Capital Punishment

...Capital punishment in America started when spies were caught, put on trial and hung. In the past and still today people argue that, the death penalty is cruel, unusual punishment and should be illegal. Yet many people argue that it is in fact justifiable and it is not cruel and unusual. Capital punishment is not cruel and unusual; the death penalty is fair and there is evidence that the death penalty deters crime. A big part of abolitionist’s argument is that the death penalty is not humane. They pull in Amendment 8, “…nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.” What the victim went though was indeed “cruel and unusual punishments’.” The murderers’ death is not cruel. The people will demand justice for what he or she has done (Bidinotto 19). Hanging and the electric chair are topics more reasonable to argue, but now because of lethal injection capital punishment has become more humane. The death penalty is not barbaric, the pain and agony that the victim went through is barbaric. Abolitionists were very upset in 1996 when rapist and murderer John Albert Taylor was executed by firing squad; they said his death was barbaric (Feder 32). Charla King, the poor 11-year-old girl he raped and strangled with a telephone cord, her death was barbaric! It makes no sense to think that John Taylor’s’ death was barbaric or inhumane. He would not even hear the bullets shoot out; his victim went through more pain than what any court system could have inflicted on him (Feder 32)....

Words: 989 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Arguments on Capital Punishment

...Arguments on Capital Punishment Length: 2 Pages 545 Words  Printer Friendly Version Capital Punishment: Is It Right or Wrong? Capital Punishment is a controversial topic discussed in today's society. There is a heated debate on whether states should be able to kill other humans or not. People that are in favor of the death penalty say that it saves money by not paying for housing in a maximum prison. Those opposed say that it is against the constitution, and is cruel and unusual punishment for humans to be put to his or her death. I believe that the death penalty is against the constitution and is cruel and unusual punishment. The death penalty is cruel because you cannot punish anyone worse than by killing them. It is an unusual punishment because it does not happen very often an it should not happen at all. Therefore, I think that capital punishment should be abolished. Capital punishment is the death penalty, and has been legal in most states for many years. The death penalty did not begin reporting executions until 1930, although legal executions have been preformed before then. From 1930 to 1992, there have been 4,002 executions in the United States (Foster, Jacobs, Siegel 54). From around the 1930s to the 1960s there was a steep drop in the total numbers of executions in the US until the mid 1960s. The drop in executions is due to the lack of public support and legal challenges....

Words: 2289 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Capital Murder

...Is it fair that someone should be murdered just because they were unlucky enough to be born with a brain defect? In my opinion if anyone does something so immorally wrong and to deserve the capital punishment is mentally not right but our...

Words: 811 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Capital Punishment V. Life W/Out Parole

...(History of capital punishment in California, 2010) Inmate executions were carried out like this until August 27, 1937 when lethal gas took its place. However, this law did not concern inmates...

Words: 2582 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Argumentative Essay On The Death Penalty

...Additionally, in this time period in which the Constitution was written, cruel and unusual punishments were common, such examples include public shame and physical chastisement, the act of scolding or punishing someone (Death Penalty Information Center). Times have changed and execution upholds a bad reputation for being so cruel. It is not right and should be...

Words: 1439 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Death Penalty

...“Some may attempt to argue that there is scriptural authorization for the death penalty and so capital punishment will never be listed as an intrinsically evil act” (Peter Black 338). This seems to be true when one consults religious scriptures like the Old Testament for example identifies it to be a legitimate form of execution. The New Testament however talks about crucifixion being used but itself prohibits capital punishment. In 1976, Canada however ended capital...

Words: 1624 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Arguement of Fact

...Margaret Dunn October 24, 2012 Is Capital Punishment Justifiable Is capital punishment really worth it. Is the planning of taking human life really that cost effective that we as humans can break our own morals and laws. Passions in the US are sharply divided and are equally strong on both sides of the argument. Since colonial times, roughly about 13,000 people have been executed under capital punishment, but what makes it right? Many people argue that capital punishment is well deserved to some of the criminals we see in the old today. "There are some defendants who have earned the ultimate punishment our society has to offer by committing murder with aggravating circumstances present. I believe life is sacred. It cheapens the life of an innocent murder victim to say that society has no right to keep the murderer from ever killing again. In my view, society has not only the right, but the duty to act in self defense to protect the innocent" says a New York Attorney. Many people agree with him as well. They feel that if someone feels like its ok to take anthers life then their life can be taken as well for punishment. People also feel that they pay for what these criminals do. To hold an inmate in prison, on death row or not, its about $30,600 per year that comes straight out of our taxes. So in reality people feel that we pay for the mistakes of these criminals when some of them should be held to capital punishment for the crimes that they have committed....

Words: 731 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Capital Punishment

...Capital Punishment and Crime Deterred Should capital punishment be used in a justice system to deter the level of serious crimes in a society? There have been arguments that capital punishment is the best way to deter crime and arguments that say it is not all over the world. The justice system is in place to keep societies functioning proper, and punish those who hurt that goal, capital punishment is one of the ways that have been aiding in the success. If capital punishment does act as a deterrent for crime, shouldn’t a society use it as a tool for the justice system? However, if capital punishment does not act as a deterrent for crime, then should it be scrapped by the justice system and emphasis be placed on looking for a new way to deter crime? This is more than just a crime deterrent issue because it involves taking a life to save a life. This is an ethical issue of whether capital punishment is the best way to solve the problem, and this has been argued by millions of people all over the world for decades and it is still a highly debated topic to this day. Capital Punishment, also known as the death penalty, is the practice of sentencing a person to execution as punishment for a capital crime after a proper legal trail. It is typically only used as a form of punishment for people who commit serious types of murder....

Words: 2198 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

And Justice for All

...But this world is not perfect, and unfortunately we do have offenders who just have no place in this world. Today, one of the most controversial, debated issue within the Criminal Justice system is the use of capital punishment, also known as, the death penalty. As stated in; ‘Thirty-two states hold the death penalty as a legal punishment. Capital punishment, is the execution of a criminal by the state in which the...

Words: 1781 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Death Penalty

...To create a peaceful and just world even for the worst that humanity may offer. This criminal sanction also has a cost, in more ways then one. It is very expensive to preform physically but also has the ability to take a mental toll to those involved, it’s a costly situation. The worst of situations is those convicted and put of death row, only later to be found innocent of all charges. The lucky ones proved innocent before their scheduled execution but some are not half as lucky until they have reached their after life. The overall cost of executions have different ways to take a toll on someone. It’s the financial cost of carrying out the death penalty. The cost of an execution is much higher then the cost of life in prison. If sentenced to death, their are many financial costs that need be taken care of such as the lawyers, the medications for the actual execution, the trials to be tried, etc. Since 1978, in California alone, the death penalty has cost them $4 billion to carry out this capital punishment. It was further estimated that if given life in prison without possibility of parole instead of capital punishment to those now on death row, the state of California would immediately save $170 million annually, and in the coming 20 years a possibility of saving over $5 billion. The death penalty...

Words: 1835 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Death Penalty

...Capital Punishment Capital punishment has been the center of much controversy dating back to its origins. Although the roots of capital punishment can be traced as far back as the life of Christ, arguments over its effectiveness and morality continue in the midst of its existence today. There are many people who have come up with reasonable arguments for both sides of the issue. Most people who believe that the death penalty is a fair punishment use the argument, "an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth, an arm for an arm, a life for a life." Otherwise known as Hamarabi’s Code. While most people who are in opposition use the argument that capital punishment is a cruel and unusual punishment which violates the eighth amendment to the United States Constitution. In the times surrounding the origins of capital punishment, it was used for a wide variety of crimes. Capital punishment can also be found in the Bible. The Bible prescribed the death penalty for crimes such as murder, kidnapping and witchcraft. By 1500 AD, in England, only major felonies carried the death penalty: treason, murder, larceny, burglary, rape, and arson. (Lexicon Universal Encyclopedia, 1989) The United States inherited capital punishment from European settlers in the seventeenth century. They promoted the idea that heinous crimes deserved severe punishment. And this is what brought capital punishment to its present standing....

Words: 1495 - Pages: 6