Premium Essay

Carnage and Culture

In: Historical Events

Submitted By marinamatthews1
Words 1298
Pages 6
Hanson’s Theory Of The Western Way of War The novel Carnage and Culture written by Victor Davis Hanson whom is a military historian and professor at California State University gives a new perspective on why the West always wins their wars. Hanson states his theory that the West always wins their fights because of the influence of their culture. He continues to explain this theory of the Western way of war with a coherent argument. Although Hanson uses examples of battles in which do not quite fit his argument, the background of the nine battles he uses support his claim; thus, making his theory agreeable overall. Furthermore, the title Carnage and Culture best illustrates Hanson’s theory on the western culture. The reason being why the west always wins their wars is due to the culture- “The Western Way of War”. This culture follows with characteristics in which represent the West: being freedom, individualism, civic militarism, superior weapons, organization, discipline, morale, initiative, flexibility, and command. All of these characteristics are shown through the West in the battles fought against the Non-West. Hanson talks about nine different battles in which helps back up his theory. Western warfare, a common foundation and continual way of fighting, that has made Europeans the most deadly soldiers in the history of civilization. With this being said, Hanson believed that with the western culture, the armies produce better quality arms and soldiers. Culture being such a big part of the Western way of life, the people believed in themselves and their rights to freedom. Although, for a long time the Western expeditionary forces were outnumbered and often deployed from their home they continued to fight off the superior enemies. This led to the Western culture to slaughter mercilessly their opponents. The cultural background is what Hanson’s theory is as...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Movie vs. Play: the God of Carnage

...Annette vs. Nancy When taking the time to examine the characters of Annette Reille, from the play, and Nancy Cowan, from Carnage, it is easy to find their likenesses, but there are also some noticeable differences. One of the main reasons for all of these differences is merely different interpretations of the character by different readers. For example, the tone in which certain lines are said or in the way a certain action is portrayed can change the whole personality of a character. When reading, the reader portrays each of the characters as he/ she believes them to be, but then another reader could have a difference of opinion and change the whole attitude; this was the case if you consider the readers to be myself and Kate Winslet. Although Annette often appears to be conciliatory, her counterpart Nancy seems more invested in ending in the conflict. In the play Annette is trying to work out the situation going on between the boys with no conflict between the parents, and this conciliatory side is shown many times throughout the play. One of the times we realize Annette is trying to keep the peace is in the beginning when she says to Veronique “We should be thanking you. We should” (Reza1258). Annette says this as a response to Veronique, after she finishes “discretely” bragging about how she and Michel handled the situation. She is very complimentary of Veronique, which is her way of keeping things calm. This line, along with others, shows Annette agreeing with these...

Words: 1675 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Evolution Of Jazz Research Paper

...could transform the soul of anyone. “Jazz is a revolt of the emotions against repression.” To sum up, jazz isn’t confined to one race or culture, jazz has always existed and it is the spirit of jazz that makes people happy, which is evident historically throughout mankind. Rogers expresses this opinion: (Jazz) is in the Indian war-dance, the Highland fling, the Irish jig, the Cossack dance, the Spanish fandango, Brazilian maxixe, the dance of the whirling dervish, the hula of the South Seas, the danse du ventral of the Orient. Jazz is “musical fireworks,” it is present in all cultures and lives on a higher level than music because it has the ability to affect the human soul....

Words: 455 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Dealing with Conflicting Values for which individuals govern themselves, a conflict in values between individuals and organization/interpersonal business protocols could pose a huge threat to the overall effectiveness of the organization. With this in mind, what do you do if your personal values are in conflict with organization and/or interpersonal business protocols? Mary Gentile, author of “Giving Voice to Values: How to Speak Your Mind When You Know What’s Right,” offers several solutions to this problem. Before confronting the issues of conflicting values, it can be assumed that most people have a set of core values also known as universal values. Mary Gentile supports this concept and provides that there are “lots of talk about different cultures, but even across cultures there is a list of core values”(Simon, 2010). When conflict of values between an individual and a company arise, Gentile suggested that the individual can leave the company, do what is asked, or find a way to change the problems within the organization. When I consider the solutions that she presents in her book, it seems apparent that these are the few options that the individual has. Unfortunately for many, making a decision is very difficult because it forces them to compromise the very foundation of their being. When I entered into the military over eight years ago, I was asked if I was a conscientious objector. I didn’t know what it meant at the time, but after it was explained to me, I knew that the......

Words: 710 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Atomic Bomb Synthesis Essay

...The receiving end will face the barrel of the gun. The improvements to intelligence gathering efforts have even become weaponized (i.e. Unmanned Aerial Vehicles to Armed Drones), which propels this idea of videogame-likeness that modern warfare has become and desensitization it has induced. In short, modern weaponry has facilitated obsequious comradery to carnage; killing has become less painful. The only way to prevent these negative side-effects would be to prevent the weapons’ use—illegalize them, essentially. In spite of this, laughing at the proposition, these weapons will improve from technology and necessity both their components and...

Words: 505 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Persuasive Speech On Truth Rhetorical Analysis

...You know 1,000 people (you'll know more than that over the course of your life but for the sake of argument lets say 1,000 people), every one of the those thousand people knows 1,000 people. That means you're one person away from a million people and you're two persons away from a billion. So Don’t underestimate the power of your speech. Western culture was predicated on the idea of the logos and that logos is the sacred element of our culture, and what does that mean, it means that your capacity for speech is divine. It's the best way to pull order and civility out from chaos and carnage. Don't underestimate the power of truth, there's nothing more...

Words: 723 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The Media Effects

...The Broadcasting Effects of Terrorist Attacks Vernon T. Branson HSM435: Psychology of Disaster Instructor: Sandra Rebeor February 20, 2012 Over the years terrorism and homeland security represent a challenge to American journalism. Broadcast journalism bears and extra burden because it is on the front lines of all breaking news and plays a special real-time role in informing the public during a crisis. Since September 11th, new grim realities have confronted the media and redefined the responsibilities of the media as providers of information and holders of public interest. Reporting in an emergency is not merely a matter of getting the story right or beating the competition, it is a matter of saving lives, conveying vital information and contributing to an orderly response. Those who work in and with the media must understand and navigate in an uncertain landscape (Kamien, D. 2006) In today’s current society the new methods of technology can also affect the way the information is disseminated to the public. This technology intensifies immediacy and emotion as disturbing events can hit airwaves before official news media sites even get a hold of the information. Cell phones, PDA’s, camcorders all make the many citizens potential news reporters now. Eyewitness accounts and “man on the street” interviews can give voice to fears and cause more chaos before news officials are given a chance to assess the situation. The most important goal of any news......

Words: 2071 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

The New College Classroom

...unlikely, I know that each time I saw a backpack fall to the floor, I would react a little differently than before. We have all seen the horror when a troubled person at school is wanting to make a statement by causing as much carnage as possible. Whenever a tragedy happens in this country, we want answers. If a tragedy involves young people within a school, it hits us all even harder and we demand immediate solutions. Supporters of this law state that bad guys will think twice about coming onto a campus knowing their planned attack may be cut short by students packing heat. The National Rifle Association's Executive Vice President and CEO, Wayne LaPierre, says "The only thing that stops a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun." While in theory that could be true, I don't buy it. We have seen shootings at police stations, courthouses, Embassy's and many other places where everybody is aware guns are present. If there is someone out there with the intent to hurt others, a math teacher, coed or classmate won't prevent him from his mission as common sense rarely plays a large part of their plan. None of that matters as the law has passed and is coming soon to a campus near you. The effect I see from this law will be reflected more in the college culture and the psychology of the student body. A college campus...

Words: 785 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Andy Warhol Red Car Crash Analysed jpeg jpeg Andy Warhol Red Car Crash (Death and Disaster Series 1963) It is important to note that Andy Warhol’s Red Car Crash Piece was part of a series of car crash images produced in different colours and repeated and put in groups of the same image and colour. Warhol was a serial artist that used the same image again and again in different pieces and so the red car crash image can be taken to be self-contained but also as part of a bigger picture. Warhol’s Pop Art style was clearly deadpan; it was often the endless repetition of mass media. He consistently, unlike the likes of Pollock (who ironically died in a car crash) used Commercial images in a commercial way. This somewhat removes him from his work emotionally. The Red Car Crash image is no exception and for me this is what makes it so violent and morbid. Warhol takes a violent subject matter and makes it look like a commercial image. The piece is conventional in form, however Warhol chooses a media image of a car crash; which is a violent subject matter in its own right and then paints over it, removes emotion and turns it into ‘the normal’ everyday image, which alone is violent and disturbed. The actual process of printing can also be seen to remove him from the process and in the same way take away any empathy from him towards the piece, which again is dark. Warhol makes the piece as a whole more powerful by being unconventional in taking himself away from the process.......

Words: 1027 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Origin of Arcee Through a Feminist's Touch

...The Origin of Arcee Through a Feminist's Touch Modern day pop culture has much to answer for. We live in a time where political correctness dictates the necessity of ignoring all our old world prejudices. Yet sexism, racism and all other such examples of outmoded concepts still manage to seep into mainstream culture. For this essay, I intend to apply the literary theory of feminism to showcase such an example of glaring sexism in the origin and back-story of Arcee. Arcee is one of the very few female characters from the popular series Transformers. While there will be examples from alternate storylines, the one I would focus on primarily is the IDW Generation 1 Continuity comic books. The Transformers series has been ongoing for over 30 years. It has spawned various comic books, cartoon series, video games and movie remakes. Unfortunately this has led to numerous re-imaginings and alternate universes of the story. But the underlying theme centers around the robotic inhabitants of a planet called Cybertron. Here a war has been raging for centuries between two factions sharing completely opposing ideologies. The Autobots, who believe in the rights of freedom for every sentient being, and the Decepticons, who believe in establishing peace through domination. Arcee is a female member of the Autobots. Although portrayed as one of the 'good guys', she is nevertheless an example of the pervading sexism that exist in our society. The world of Transformers is comprised......

Words: 962 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Relativism and Morality

...RELATIVISM AND MORALITY Week 2 Assignment Sarah Knight SOC120: Introduction to Ethics and Social Responsibility Prof. Thomas Reeder November 4, 2013 Relativism and Morality Moral choices are conducted on a daily basis, by every culture, which can be viewed on an ethical scale of right or wrong, by other cultures. In her writing of “Some Moral Minima”, Lenn E. Goodman views several aspects of morality and relativism, and argues that certain things are just wrong. In presenting my own morals, I agree with this statement; however, pondering the image, that only one accurate ethic exists and that we may be able to find universal moral requirements and arrive at a multiethnic agreement on issues presented by Goodman is a parable. In this paper, I will state my opinion on challenges Goodman presents to relativism. I will also provide my thoughts on if there are such universal moral requirements. In Goodman’s initial area of discussion of “Some Moral Minima; Genocide, Famine, and Germ Warfare (Goodman, L.E., 2010)”, she states “Genocide targets individuals as members of a group, seeking to destroy a race, a culture, a linguistic or ethnic identity (Goodman, L.E., 2010)”. I reflect back to after the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks were made on The United States. The threat of germ warfare became a very real aspect of war for our nation. Governmental groups, that we were at war against, were considering the decision to use this type of weapon in order to defeat......

Words: 1212 - Pages: 5

Free Essay


...Crusades In Usama Ibn Munqidh’s Book of Contemplation: Islam and the Crusades, the main focus is on the relationship between Muslims and Christians in the East after the Christians capture Jerusalem. After the capture of Jerusalem, the east was basically a hot zone wherever Muslim and Christian armies were set up. Although there were multiple crusades after the capture of Jerusalem, crusaders from past crusades stayed back in the crusader states for many reasons. Some did not have anything back in the west to go back to. Others wanted to start a new life in the crusade states or even spread the Christian word wherever it may take them. Although there were some instances of peace, most of the west was stained by war and carnage. Usama writes about an encounter with Tancred of Antioch on page seventy-seven. After a year’s truce between Muslim armies and Tancred’s Antioch, Tancred set out for battle against a Muslim army. He told the story of Hasanun watching his brother in cavalry, Kamil, fight in battle. Hasanun was beginning to get impatient while watching Kamil drive his spear into the bodies of Christian infantry. After waiting for his armor to arrive for quite some time, he decided to go ahead without armor. Not long after he charged into battle, he was captured by Tancred’s army. Usama soon began to explain that although Hasanun did surrender, he was tortured in a variety of ways. He did not explain all of them, but he did mention that Tancred wanted them to cut out......

Words: 1150 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Dadaism and Surrealism

...preposterous in form. Many of the art displays were made of different mediums such as urinals, garbage, bus tickets, even snow shovels. One of the more known pieces from the Dadaism period is from Marcel Duchamp “Fountain” in 1917 it was simply a urinal. This shows us that with Dadaism they were able to create art even from objects that would normally not be considered art. Surrealism as an art movement officially started in 1924. In 1924 The Surrealist Manifesto written by Andre Breton was published. Many of the artistic pieces of this era are dream like. Some type of art to wonder and marvel at, not an art of reason. ("Dada," n.d.) Surrealism is thought to have been formed as a reaction to Dadaism art movement, which was a protest of the carnages of World War 1. Surrealism was more focused on the positive outcomes of change happening in the world at that time. The common themes that can be seen in many of the paintings are the dreamy imagery that has an exaggerated analysis of reality. This is thought to produce a more truthful interpretation of what the mind may have experienced through dream. Salvador Dali used a technique which was coined ‘critical paranoia’ ("Dada," n.d.) The technique is very visible in...

Words: 1093 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Ethnic Studies from external dangers and gives each member a sense of belonging. Ethnicity can be defined as a group of people who see themselves as unique or distinct from others due to imagined or real mutual history, values and traditions. These things set them apart or distinguish them from their neighbouring ethnicities. Ethnicity also entails the sharing of specific ethnic traits, backgrounds, associations, allegiances or affiliations. There are therefore innumerable ethnicities all over the world which are composed of groups of people bound together by a common factor among them all, which could be racial, cultural, religion, tribal, national, ideological or linguistic. With so many differences between the various ethnicities in their cultures, values, traditions and beliefs, conflict between them is ultimately inevitable. Ethnic groups are almost always never socially homogenous nor are they ever united politically. (Cornell, 39) Several divisive factors are always present within such groups e.g. differences in ideology, social status, class, and religion. When differences between ethnicities fail to spark conflict among them, a particularly dominant ethnicity may attempt to establish hegemony in an area. When the minority ethnicities get the sense they are being oppressed politically, economically or even physically, they promptly summon their masses to demand and fight, if need be, for their rights. It is therefore evident that there are numerous precipitating factors......

Words: 1682 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ms 13 Theory

...the world that are not at war. The US Department of the Treasury labeled the group a "transnational criminal organization," the first title for a US street gang in October of 2012. This paper will discuss the history of MS 13 and use theory to describe the reasoning behind MS 13. (“MS 13” n.d.) In the course of El Salvador's Civil War, children as young as 11 and 12 years old were trained and used as soldiers. El Salvador, Nicaragua and Honduras were countries in chaos due to a clash between guerrillas persuaded toward communism and political rights encouraged by the U.S. Salvadoran families abandoned everything behind to escape from the terror of the civil war's outrages of tortures, rapes, the use of machetes to decapitate bodies and carnages with high-power artillery. The war distressed the small nation and displaced approximately one million Salvadorians, most of who migrated to the United States. (“MS 13” n.d.) El Salvadorian youth were not accepted by many of the Hispanic groups in Los Angeles and other American cities. Youngsters picked up English much faster than the adults, who faced discrimination and minimal wages. As poor refugee teens in Los Angeles, they were wedged again in a struggle. There was a violent gang war between Mexicans and African-Americans already going on. As the youth became ostracized, they banded together for protection and formed what is now known as Mara Salvatrucha, which would later become known as MS 13. The two largest rivals to MS 13 in......

Words: 921 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Politics of Cultural Pluralism and Ethnic Conflict

...have occurred in least developed countries. (LDCs) Cultural pluralism refers to ethnic diversity. It’s defined as a condition in which many cultures co-exist within a society and maintain their cultural differences. It can also be called multiculturalism. Cultural pluralism seeks to overcome racism, sexism, and other forms of discrimination. Cultural pluralism has been closely linked to the growth of the middle class and the emergence of politicians who articulated nationalist or other ethnic aspirations while mobilizing workers and peasants behind that ideal. The fear of and hostility toward other ethnic groups are far older and often more entrenched than modern principles of tolerance or equality under the law. No matter how we may wish for it otherwise, we did not leave violence against outsiders behind us as our nations became modern and democratic. Ethnic minorities have been victimized for hundreds of years. One needs only look to the nineteenth-century frontier wars between White settlers and Native Americans in the United States and Chile. Ethnic Conflict Incidents In the early years of the twenty-first century (2000s), like the first decades of the twentieth century (1900s), much of the Third World suffered from ethnic, racial, and religious tensions periodically punctuated by outbreaks of brutality and carnage. When progress was made in one location deterioration occurred in another location. In 2005, the Sudanese government (led by Arab......

Words: 1041 - Pages: 5