Premium Essay

Case Analysis of “Does This Milkshake Taste Funny?”

In: Business and Management

Submitted By gogowanglu
Words 496
Pages 2
In the case, George Stein is a college student who was employed by Eastern Dairy during the summer. George Stein found Eastern Dairy was lack of quality control and quality management, so he was faced with an ethical dilemma. I will analyze the case from George‘s perspectives. George’s position required him to remove the filters form the plant’s piping and allow the current production run of milkshake mix to be contaminated with maggots. On the one hand, if George could do Paul told him to do, he can have many benefits. George can go on the good job to make money and he can avoid to study. He could go back home on time. And, Working at Eastern Dairy seemed relatively easy for him since it paid twice the amount he used to earn in his previous job. One the other hand, if refuse to remove the filters, and report the maggot problem to management, he will have some advantages and disadvantages. First, he would be happy because he can avoid all innocent kids to drink milkshakes contaminated with pulverized maggots. Also, he will win praise from all kids’ parents because of social responsibility. However, he have some disadvantages about the job. He will lose the job and he cannot continue to get extra money from Eastern Dairy. Moreover, Eastern Dairy will compliant about having to close down his business. Also, Paul will express criticism of losing job. No matter how George choose, he have to face with an ethical dilemma. In the case, George was confronted with an ethical dilemma. His thoughts and actions were affected by several factors, including his personal moral values and corporate social responsibility caused by improper management of the company. This case is a good example about the lack of ethics. George doesn’t make right decision in the end of case because he have to struggle against his personal moral values and corporate social

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Management Case Study

...Case Analysis for “Does this Milkshake Taste Funny?” by Julius Datinguinoo A Case Analysis for “Does this Milkshake Taste Funny?” Assignment 3, Unit 1, Organizational Behavior Robert Kennedy College Presented by Julius Datinguinoo on 12 May 2009 I. Statement of the Problem(s) There are three major corporate problems that I can see on this situation: 1. Eastern Dairy is lacking in contemporary quality control, quality management, and quality assurance systems that would ensure compliance to quality standards like ISO 9000, HACCP & ISO 2200. 2. Eastern Dairy is lacking in modern health, safety and environment (HSE) policies, procedures, and controls that would ensure compliance to environmental standards like ISO 14001 and ISO 14004. 3. Eastern Dairy has a poor inventory management & control system. II. Analysis 1. George Stein i. George is familiar with change because he had lived in various suburbs of a major city. He understands the need for change and he is comfortable in managing the change in his environment. It is possible that his ‘change quotient’ (Clawson, 2001:10) has been developed at an early age by the constant need to adapt to a new neighborhood. As a teen, he is able to work on different types of menial jobs probably in different companies, which can confirm his adaptability. ii. George is a social person. This is supported by one of his major interest, which is hanging out at the local teenage gathering place, a drive-in restaurant. He also likes the camaraderie...

Words: 2624 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Does This Milkshake Taste Funny

...Case Analysis for “Does this Milkshake Taste Funny?” by Julius Datinguinoo A Case Analysis for “Does this Milkshake Taste Funny?” Assignment 3, Unit 1, Organizational Behavior Robert Kennedy College Presented by Julius Datinguinoo on 12 May 2009 I. Statement of the Problem(s) There are three major corporate problems that I can see on this situation: 1. Eastern Dairy is lacking in contemporary quality control, quality management, and quality assurance systems that would ensure compliance to quality standards like ISO 9000, HACCP & ISO 2200. 2. Eastern Dairy is lacking in modern health, safety and environment (HSE) policies, procedures, and controls that would ensure compliance to environmental standards like ISO 14001 and ISO 14004. 3. Eastern Dairy has a poor inventory management & control system. II. Analysis 1. George Stein i. George is familiar with change because he had lived in various suburbs of a major city. He understands the need for change and he is comfortable in managing the change in his environment. It is possible that his ‘change quotient’ (Clawson, 2001:10) has been developed at an early age by the constant need to adapt to a new neighborhood. As a teen, he is able to work on different types of menial jobs probably in different companies, which can confirm his adaptability. ii. George is a social person. This is supported by one of his major interest, which is hanging out at the local teenage gathering place, a drive-in restaurant. He also likes the camaraderie...

Words: 2624 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

A Case Analysis for “Does This Milk Shake Taste Funny?? “

...A case Analysis for “Does this milk shake taste funny?? “ For RKC MBA, Unit # 1, Assignment # 3 Class #442 - MBA 57597 - Organisational Behaviour Analysis: There are four things / persons involved in this situation; we must go thru all these characters. 1) Paul 2) George 3) The Eastern Dairy company 4) The Union & Colleagues Paul has taken the head of operators / production for the night shift. The other operators are following for the plan and production even though he is in the same position with others. His main objective is to produce at any quality and clean up the pipes before end of the shift George looks a social person & friendly nature with other colleagues. This nature he might have been learnt from local teenage gathering place ( a drive in restaurant)). He is a loving nature person (We come to know from his romance with Cathey). His family looks old convention & tradition family. He is not high achiever, is not interested in the studies even his parents are ready to support. He took menial jobs in the past summers and not a challenging job. He took Eastern Dairy job for money that he needs for dating & for car (physiological & social needs).He likes excitement and challenge, as we can see that he has interest in Hot Cars. Eastern Dairy company looks a good pay master (with this many employees may stick to longer years by motivated with good pay scale). The company has given a free hand to the night shift operators, no manager for the night shift. The day shift...

Words: 745 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Does This Milkshake Taste Funny

...“Does this Milkshake Taste Funny?” Major Issues and Players The major players in this case study are George Stein and Paul Burnham with regards to their employment at Eastern Dairy. The major issues at play relate to poor business planning, improper management, lack of ethics (decisions made by George and Paul) and social responsibility (the possible health issues of related to the contaminated products). Analysis of the Issues and Players In this case, there are several instances of poor management including but not limited to: lack of proper training, accountability and adherence to manufacturing industry standards, etc. A company as large as Eastern dairy should have a manager on site and more than 4 employees for the night shift, especially given how critical the night shift is in meeting production needs. The so‐called “leader” of the group, Paul is worried about going home early and the cost impact to the company if product needs are not met for one night. Paul’s decision to ignore the issue puts George in an extremely difficult situation. Another problem to note is the management in many corporations today. All too often, employees have self‐serving motives and conflicts of interest that essentially stems from culture of the organization and how it operates. When George initially brings the issue to Paul, we learn quickly from Paul’s demeanor that he had encountered the problem in the past and had seen the maggots several...

Words: 312 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Does This Milkshake Taste Funny?

...Håkon Olaisen Case Study – “Does This Milkshake Taste Funny?” BUS 565-02 – Organizational Theory and Development Dr. Nanette Metz George Stein is a college student who is working at Eastern Diary during the summer to satisfy his immediate need for dating and car money. He chose to work for Eastern Diary because it was unionized and the wages paid were more than twice the minimum wage George had been paid on previous jobs. George, after a brief visit with the HR director, was assigned to work the night shift. The night shift was from 11:00 PM to 7:00 AM six nights a week (Sunday through Friday); the regular wages were paid, supplemented by 8 hours of guaranteed overtime each week. This implied that George would be able to save up a tidy sum of money during the summer. Eastern Diary manufactured milkshake and ice cream mix for a number of customers in the metropolitan area. The ice cream mix was sold in 5- and 10-gallon containers to other firms, which then added the flavoring ingredients, packaged and sold the ice cream under their own brand names. Their milkshake mix was sold in 5-gallon cardboard cartons, which contained plastic liner. Eastern Diary delivered these packages to various restaurants in the area. The design of the packaging enabled it to fit into automatic milkshake machines, used in many types of restaurants and drive-ins. The night shift consisted of a six-person crew of operators. Paul Burnham, a member of this crew, received each night`s production orders...

Words: 1637 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Does This Milkshake Taste Funny

...Joshua R. Upthegrove MGT 585 – Dr. Pane Case Analysis 2: Does this Milkshake Taste Funny? In this scenario, George Stein, a young college student, employee, son, and boyfriend ends up facing an ethical dilemma, in which he must evaluate what possible scenarios, could be right or wrong. However, can George overcome the possible scrutiny from his colleagues, if he decided to go the route adverse their recommended action? With just a thought he can already hear their negative statements and derogatory comments (Robbins, De Cenzo & Coulter, 2013). Within this analysis, critical points are analyzed with respect to what might cause George to act in an ethical manner or an unethical manner, in the situation that stands before him at his workplace. As Alahmad (2010) indicated, ethics are a person’s concept of right and wrong. Will George do what’s right on his moral compass, or wrong? In a society so based on competition and innovation, one must always stay true and honest; in which case they won’t have to worry if they are keeping up and remembering the next lie. “If you tell the truth, you don’t have to remember everything.” (Alahmad, A., 2010). Background George is an East coast college student who has spent the entirety of his life in modern suburbia. Like most his age, his interests remain rather ordinary, gathering with the locals his age at the city spot (drive-in restaurant), fast cars, and of course girls. George had not necessarily wanted to be a college...

Words: 2511 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Organizational Behavior

...person Course Description This course deals with human behavior in organizations and with practices and systems within organizations that facilitate or hinder effective behavior. Conceptual frameworks, case analysis/discussion, and skill-oriented activities are blended within each topic. Topics include communication, motivation, group dynamics, leadership, social responsibility, diversity, stress/fear, and organizational change. Class sessions and assignments are intended to help participants/students acquire the skills that managers need to improve organizational relationships and performance. Course Objectives This course aims to improve ones understanding of human behavior in organizations and ones ability to lead people to achieve more effectively and how to increase organizational performance. Readings are assigned to give the student a clear understanding of the specific material. Cases are assigned to afford the student the opportunity to apply the theory, and put it into practice. Students will be expected to explore and reflect on their own experiences in the workplace, and discuss ways in which they might apply the material to their daily work. Required Books for Readings (Again – Please note that both books are Required) Hitt, Miller, & Colella: OB: Organizational Behavior, 3rd ed. John Wiley & Sons; “Binder Version” or “Version” to be uploaded to tablet, computer etc. Buller & Schuller; Managing Organizations: Cases in Management, Organizational...

Words: 906 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Mgmt E 4000 Organizational Behavior Syllabus

...Fax: (516) 944-4005 E-mail: cgibaldi@fas.harvard.edu Appointments: By appointment via the web, telephone, and in person COURSE DESCRIPTION This course deals with human behavior in organizations and with practices and systems with in organizations that facilitate or hinder effective behavior. Conceptual frameworks, case discussions, and skill-oriented activities are blended within each topic. Topics include communication, motivation, group dynamics, leadership, power, and organizational design and development. Class sessions and assignments are intended to help participants acquire the skills that managers need to improve organizational relationships and performance. COURSE OBJECTIVES This course aims to improve ones understanding of human behavior in organizations and ones ability to lead people to achieve more effectively and how to increase organizational performance. Readings are assigned to give the student a clear understanding of the specific material. Cases are assigned to afford the student the opportunity to apply the theory, and put it into practice. Students will be expected to explore and reflect on their own experiences in the work place, and discuss ways in which they might apply the material to their daily work. REQUIRED READING/BOOKS Buller,P. and Schuller, R.; Managing Organizations: Cases in Management, Organizational Behavior and Human Resources Management: South-Western College Publishing, OH. Hitt, Miller, and Colella; OB: Organizational...

Words: 828 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ethics Does This Milkshake Taste Funny

...Development: MGT 585-02W Fall 2013 Case Analysis Does this milkshake taste funny? George Steins’ Ethical Dilemma * Discuss all of the reasons why you believe George might act unethically and remove the filters, allowing the maggots to remain in the mix. The first reason George might act unethically is due to Social Learning Theory. “Analysis revealed that perceived learning opportunities were shaped, enabled, and constrained by a variety of social, cultural, structural, and process-related imperatives. This was manifested through two learning systems: (1) a formal learning system directly managed by the organization and (2) an informal system that was fostered through strong social networks and driven by the organizational culture. From this investigation, we posit a social theory of learning, which encompasses sharing knowledge and experience through social interaction” (O’Toole, 2011). This is an article for developing learned systems by the Australian Army in their ‘fighting for knowledge’ campaign to understand learned systems in a military setting. Using a focus group of over 150 armed personnel to understand some of the cultural and social systems enforced. Social theory is a theory that states that we learn through observation and our direct experiences with others (Robbins. 2013). The social learning theory is enacted by both formal learning systems, decreed through management, and informal social networks. In the case George is faced with an ethical dilemma...

Words: 2202 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Biodiesel

...10th February 2014 Content Page 1. Introduction 3 Internal Analysis 2. Financial Analysis 4 3. Human Resource Management(HRM) Analysis 7 4. Marketing Analysis 8 5. Operational Analysis 10 6. Strength and Weakness of the Company 11 External Analysis 7. P.E.S.T.E.L. Analysis 12 8. Porter’s 5 forces 14 9. Critical Success Factors 16 10. Marketing Analysis 16 11. Opportunities 17 12. Threats 17 Current Strategies 13. Strategic Position 18 14. Proposed Strategies 18 15. Selection of winning Strategy: Feasibility 19 16. Description and Risk Assessment 20 References 21 Appendices 23 1. Introduction. Note: “All work within this report is taken from the case study unless referenced otherwise”. McDonald’s started as BBQ restaurant by (“mac and dick”) which also known as Maurice and Richard. The concept of the McDonald’s at that time was a typical drive in restaurant that offers variety of BBQ menu to choose from. The brothers realised that it is important for them to highlight the menu that get the intention the most. Mac and Dick eliminated McDonald’s carhops’ concept to make McDonald’s as a self- service operation. They also narrowed down the menu from 25 menu lists on focus only 9 menus that is hot sellers. This action will increase efficiency and as an act of cutting cost. McDonald’s...

Words: 5883 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Market Analyses

...| Project 2 Market analyses | Brief summary SWOT analysis - The fast-food industry is highly influenced by governmental policies, sales rates are grooving even during the recession. The changing lifestyles of consumers to a healthier and quicker one can be seen as both- a threat and opportunity. As a threat- due to a healthier lifestyle McDonald’s as well as other fast food restaurants can lose many consumers. As an opportunity- as people are getting more and more busy due to their work, they do not have enough time to make meals at home, and they choose to eat at fast food restaurants. McDonald’s have good quality of service and promotions, which is also one of the reasons of successful marketing. The main strength is of course their huge brand they built up. On the other hand the strongest weakness is the perception of the customers that look at McDonald’s as a very unhealthy place to eat. Competitive situation – The competitive situation within the fast food industry is very hard. McDonald’s is the leader in this industry, but still it has to deal with big rivalry. There are many other restaurants and other substitute products that consumers can choose. A big variety of the “other possibilities what and where to eat” makes strong buyers power. While in the global market entry barriers are high (due to high expenses to establish a big company), in a more local market, these barriers are much lower because it does not require big capital to establish a small business...

Words: 6991 - Pages: 28

Free Essay

The Astrology

...McMullen Hoskins, who is gone from this world, but who would have been happy to share this page with my courageous kids, April Daisy White and Autumn Lee White; my brothers, George, Peter and John Hoskins; my niece Pamela Potenza; and my loyal friends Kitti Weissberger, Val Paul Pierotti, Stan Albro, Nathaniel Webster, Jean Valère Pignal, Roselyne Viéllard, Michael Armani, Joseph Stoddart, Couquite Hoffenberg, Jean Louis Besson, Mary Lee Castellani, Paula Alba, Marguerite and Paulette Ratier, Ted and Joan Zimmermann, Scott Weiss, Miekle Blossom, Ina Dellera, Gloria Jones, Marina Vann, Richard and Shiela Lukins, Tony Lees-Johnson, Jane Russell, Jerry and Barbara Littlefield, Michele and Mark Princi, Molly Friedrich, Consuelo and Dick Baehr, Linda Grey, Clarissa and Ed Watson, Francine and John Pascal, Johnny Romero, Lawrence Grant, Irma Kurtz, Gene Dye, Phyllis and Dan Elstein, Richard Klein, Irma Pride Home, Sally Helgesen, Sylvie de la Rochefoucauld, Ann Kennerly, David Barclay, John Laupheimer, Yvon Lebihan, Bernard Aubin, Dédé Laqua, Wolfgang Paul, Maria José Desa, Juliette Boisriveaud, Anne Lavaur, and all the others who so dauntlessly stuck by me when I was at my baldest and most afraid. Thanks, of course, to my loving doctors: James Gaston, Richard Cooper, Yves Decroix, Jean-Claude Durand, Michel Soussaline and to all those daring women in the white crepe-soled shoes who change tangled sheets and murmur comfort in the dead of night. This Copyright © 1986 Suzanne White...

Words: 231422 - Pages: 926

Premium Essay

Nothing

...Generated by ABC Amber LIT Converter, http://www.processtext.com/abclit.html THE PERKS OF BEING A WALLFLOWER by STEPHEN chbosky Published by: POCKET BOOKS, Simon and Schuster Inc., 1230 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10020. Copyright 1999 by Stephen Chbosky BOOK JACKET INFORMATION standing on the fringes of life ... offers a unique perspective. But there comes a time to see what it looks like from the dance floor. This haunting novel about the dilemma of passivity vs. passion marks the stunning debut of a provocative new voice in contemporary fiction: The Perks Of Being A WALLFLOWER This is the story of what it's like to grow up in high school. More intimate than a diary, Charlie's letters are singular and unique, hilarious and devastating. We may not know where he lives. We may not know to whom he is writing. All we know is the world he shares. Caught between trying to live his life and trying to run from it puts him on a strange course through uncharted territory. The world of first dates and mixed tapes, family dramas and new friends. The world of sex, drugs, andThe Rocky Horror Picture Show, when all one requires is that perfect song on that perfect drive to feel infinite. Through Charlie, Stephen Chbosky has created a deeply affecting coming-of-age story, powerful novel that will spirit you back to those wild and poignant roller coaster days known asgrowingup. visit us on the world wide web _inghttpwhststwwwlessimonsayscom_wh _inghttpwhststwwwmtvcom_wh stephenchboskygrew...

Words: 66427 - Pages: 266

Premium Essay

Lololoooll

...Longman English Grammar L G.Alexander Consultant- R A. Close, CBE Pearson Education Limited, Edinburgh Gate, Harlow, Essex CM20 2JE, England and Associated Companies throughout the world www longman com © Longman Group UK Limited 1988 All rights reserved, no part of the publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the Publishers Distributed in the United States of America by Longman publishing, New York First published 1988 Twentieth impression 2003 BRITISH LIBRARY CATALOGUING IN PUBLICATION DATA Alexander L G Longman English Grammar 1 English language - Text-books for foreign speakers 1 Title 428 2'4 PE1128 LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOGING IN PUBLICATION DATA Alexander, L G Longman English Grammar/L G Alexander, consultant, R A Close p cm Includes index ISBN 0-582-55892-1 1 English language - Grammar - 1950- 2 English language Text-books for foreign speakers 1 Close, R A II Title PE1112A43 1988 428 2'4-dc19 87-22519 CIP Set in 8 on 9 1/2pt Linotron 202 Helvetica Printed in China SWTC/20 Louis Alexander was born in London in 1932 He was educated at Godalming Grammar School and London University He taught English in Germany (1954-56) and Greece (1956-65), where he was Head of the English Department of the Protypon Lykeion, Athens He was adviser to the Deutscher Volkshochschulverband...

Words: 162388 - Pages: 650

Free Essay

Growing Up Asian in Australia

... Growing Up Asian in Australia Growing up Asian in Australia file:///D|/ /Calibre Library/Wei Zhi/Growing Up Asian in Australia (799)/text/part0001.html[2014-6-18 23:54:33] Growing Up Asian in Australia Growing up Asian in Australia ...................................... Alice Pung Edited by file:///D|/ /Calibre Library/Wei Zhi/Growing Up Asian in Australia (799)/text/part0002.html[2014-6-18 23:54:33] Growing Up Asian in Australia Published by Black Inc., an imprint of Schwartz Media Pty Ltd Level 5, 289 Flinders Lane Melbourne Victoria 3000 Australia email: enquiries@blackincbooks.com http://www.blackincbooks.com Introduction and this collection © Alice Pung & Black Inc. Individual works © retained by the authors. Reprinted 2008 . ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. 2008. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior consent of the publishers. Photo of Hoa Pham by Alister Air. Photo of Joy Hopwood by Yanna Black. The National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry: Pung, Alice (ed.) Growing up Asian in Australia. ISBN 9781863951913 eISBN 9781921825453 Pung, Alice. 2. Asians – Australia – Social life and customs. Immigrants’ writings – Australia. 4. Asians – Australia – Literary collections. 5. Race relations – Australia. 6. Australia – Social conditions. A820.80355 1. 3. Book design: Thomas...

Words: 113124 - Pages: 453