Free Essay

Case Digest

In: Other Topics

Submitted By Reality
Words 2054
Pages 9
G.R. No. 126102, December 4, 2000


FACTS: * This petition seeks to reverse the decision of Court of Appeals, dated March 25, 1996, in CA – G.R. SP No. 39193, which nullified the write of the write of preliminary injunction issued by the Regional Trial Court of Pasig City, Bramch 261, in Civil Case No. 64931. * On August 25, 1976, petitioner Ortigas & Company sold to Emilia Hermoso, a parcel of land known as Lot 1, Block 21, Psd-66759, with an area of 1,508 square meters, located in Greenhills Subdivision IV, San Juan, Metro Manila, and covered by Transfer Certificate of Title No. 0737. The contract of sale provided that the lot: a. Be used exclusively for residential purposes only, and not more than one single-family residential building will be constructed thereon. b. The BUYER shall not erect any sign or billboard on the roof for advertising purposes. c. No single-family residential building shall be erected until the building plans, specification have been approved by the seller. d. Restrictions shall run with the land and shall be construed as real covenants until December 31, 2025 when they shall cease and terminate

These and the other conditions were duly annotated on the certificate of title issued to Emilia. * In 1981, the Metropolitan Manila Commission (now Metropolitan Manila Development Authority) enacted MMC Ordinance No. 81-01, also known as the Comprehensive Zoning Area for the National Capital Region. The ordinance reclassified as a commercial area a portion of Ortigas Avenue from Madison to Roosevelt Streets of Greenhills Subdivision where the lot is located. * On June 8, 1984, private respondent Ismael Mathay III leased the lot from Emilia Hermoso and J.P. Hermoso Realty Corp. The lease contract did not specify the purposes of the lease. Thereupon, private respondent constructed a single story commercial building for Greenhills Autohaus, Inc., a car sales company. * On June 16, 1995, the trial court issued the writ of preliminary injunction. On June 29, 1995, Mathay III moved to set aside the injunctive order, but the trial court denied the motion. * Mathay III then filed with the Court of Appeals a special civil action for certiorari, docketed as CA-G.R. SP No. 39193, ascribing to the trial court grave abuse of discretion in issuing the writ of preliminary injunction. He claimed that MMC Ordinance No. 81-01 classified the area where the lot was located as commercial area and said ordinance must be read into the August 25, 1976 Deed of Sale as a concrete exercise of police power. * Ortigas and Company averred that inasmuch as the restrictions on the use of the lot were duly annotated on the title it issued to Emilia Hermoso, said restrictions must prevail over the ordinance, specially since these restrictions were agreed upon before the passage of MMC Ordinance No. 81-01.
W/N the CA properly exercised police power
Yes, the Court held that, in issuing the disputed writ of preliminary injunction, the trial court observed that the contract of sale was entered into in August 1976, while the zoning ordinance was enacted only in March 1981. The trial court reasoned that since private respondent had failed to show that MMC Ordinance No. 81-01 had retroactive effect, said ordinance should be given prospective application only citing Co vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, 162 SCRA 390 (1988).
Laws are to be construed as having only prospective operation. Lex prospicit, non respicit. Equally settled, only laws existing at the time of the execution of a contract are applicable thereto and not later statutes, unless the latter are specifically intended to have retroactive effect. But, the foregoing principles do admit of certain exceptions. One involves police power. A law enacted in the exercise of police power to regulate or govern certain activities or transactions could be given retroactive effect and may reasonably impair vested rights or contracts. Police power legislation is applicable not only to future contracts, but equally to those already in existence. Noteworthy, in Sangalang vs. Intermediate Appellate Court, the court held that, MMC Ordinance No. 81-01 as a legitimate police power measure.
The trial court’s reliance on the Co vs. IAC, is misplaced. In Co, the disputed area was agricultural and Ordinance No. 81-01 did not specifically provide that “it shall have retroactive effect so as to discontinue all rights previously acquired over lands located within the zone which are neither residential nor light industrial in nature,” and stated with respect to agricultural areas covered that “the zoning ordinance should be given prospective operation only.” The area in this case involves not agricultural but urban residential land. Ordinance No. 81-01 retroactively affected the operation of the zoning ordinance in Greenhills by reclassifying certain locations therein as commercial.
The instant petition is DENIED. The challenged decision of the Court of Appeals dated March 25, 1996, as well as the assailed resolution of August 13, 1996, in CA-G.R. SP No. 39193 is AFFIRMED. Costs against petitioner.
Lex prospicit, non respicit- The law looks forward, not backward.

G.R. No. L- 59234 September 30, 1982
Topic: Test of Valid Exercise

Facts: Petitioner Taxicab Operators of Metro Manila, Inc. (TOMMI) is a domestic corporation composed of taxicab operators, who are grantees of Certificates of Public Convenience to operate taxicabs within the City of Manila and to any other place in Luzon accessible to vehicular traffic. Petitioners Ace Transportation Corporation and Felicisimo Cabigao are two of the members of TOMMI, each being an operator and grantee of such certificate of public convenience.

* On October 10, 1977, respondent Board of Transportation (BOT) issued Memorandum Circular No. 77-42 which reads:

SUBJECT: Phasing out and Replacement of Old and Dilapidated Taxis

WHEREAS, it is the policy of the government to insure that only safe and comfortable units are used as public conveyances;
WHEREAS, the riding public, particularly in Metro-Manila, has, time and again, complained against, and condemned, the continued operation of old and dilapidated taxis;
WHEREAS, in order that the commuting public may be assured of comfort, convenience, and safety, a program of phasing out of old and dilapidated taxis should be adopted;
WHEREAS, after studies and inquiries made by the Board of Transportation, the latter believes that in six years of operation, a taxi operator has not only covered the cost of his taxis, but has made reasonable profit for his investments;

NOW, THEREFORE, pursuant to this policy, the Board hereby declares that no car beyond six years shall be operated as taxi, and in implementation of the same hereby promulgates the following rules and regulations:

1. As of December 31, 1977, all taxis of Model 1971 and earlier are ordered withdrawn from public service and thereafter may no longer be registered and operated as taxis. In the registration of cards for 1978, only taxis of Model 1972 and later shall be accepted for registration and allowed for operation; 2. As of December 31, 1978, all taxis of Model 1972 are ordered withdrawn from public service and thereafter may no longer be registered and operated as taxis. In the registration of cars for 1979, only taxis of Model 1973 and later shall be accepted for registration and allowed for operation; and every year thereafter, there shall be a six-year lifetime of taxi, to wit:
1980 — Model 1974
1981 — Model 1975, etc.
All taxis of earlier models than those provided above are hereby ordered withdrawn from public service as of the last day of registration of each particular year and their respective plates shall be surrendered directly to the Board of Transportation for subsequent turnover to the Land
Transportation Commission. For an orderly implementation of this Memorandum Circular, the rules herein shall immediately be effective in Metro-Manila. Its implementation outside Metro- Manila shall be carried out only after the project has been implemented in Metro-Manila and only after the date has been determined by the
* On January 27, 1981, petitioners filed a Petition with the BOT, docketed as Case No. 80-7553, seeking to nullify MC No. 77-42 or to stop its implementation; to allow the registration and operation in 1981 and subsequent years of taxicabs of model 1974, as well as those of earlier models which were phased-out, provided that, at the time of registration, they are roadworthy and fit for operation.

ISSUES: 1. W/N, petitioners rights to equal protection of the law was violated 2. W/N, the BOT has valid exercise of power


On equal protection of laws

No, the petitioner’s rights to equal protection of laws was not violated. The court held that, As enunciated in the preambular clauses of the challenged BOT Circular, the overriding consideration is the safety and comfort of the riding public from the dangers posed by old and dilapidated taxis. The State, in the exercise, of its police power, can prescribe regulations to promote the health, morals, peace, good order, safety and general welfare of the people. It can prohibit all things hurtful to comfort, safety and welfare of society. It may also regulate property rights. In the language of Chief Justice Enrique M. Fernando "the necessities imposed by public welfare may justify the exercise of governmental authority to regulate even if thereby certain groups may plausibly assert that their interests are disregarded". The Board's reason for enforcing the Circular initially in Metro Manila is that taxicabs in this city, compared to those of other places, are subjected to heavier traffic pressure and more constant use. This is of common knowledge. Considering that traffic conditions are not the same in every city, a substantial distinction exists so that infringement of the equal protection clause can hardly be successfully claimed.

On valid exercise of power

Yes, the BOT validly exercised their power.

Presidential Decree No. 101 grants to the Board of Transportation the power

4. To fix just and reasonable standards, classification, regulations, practices, measurements, or service to be furnished, imposed, observed, and followed by operators of public utility motor vehicles.

Section 2 of said Decree provides procedural guidelines for said agency to follow in the exercise of its powers:

Sec. 2. Exercise of powers. — In the exercise of the powers granted in the preceding section, the Board shag proceed promptly along the method of legislative inquiry. Apart from its own investigation and studies, the Board, in its discretion, may require the cooperation and assistance of the Bureau of Transportation, the Philippine Constabulary, particularly the Highway Patrol Group, the support agencies within the Department of Public Works, Transportation and Communications, or any other government office or agency that may be able to furnish useful information or data in the formulation of the Board of any policy, plan or program in the implementation of this Decree.
The Board may also can conferences, require the submission of position papers or other documents, information, or data by operators or other persons that may be affected by the implementation of this Decree, or employ any other suitable means of inquiry.

It is clear from the provision aforequoted, however, that the leeway accorded the Board gives it a wide range of choice in gathering necessary information or data in the formulation of any policy, plan or program. It is not mandatory that it should first call a conference or require the submission of position papers or other documents from operators or persons who may be affected, this being only one of the options open to the Board, which is given wide discretionary authority. Petitioners cannot justifiably claim, therefore, that they were deprived of procedural due process. Neither can they state with certainty that public respondents had not availed of other sources of inquiry prior to issuing the challenged Circulars. operators of public conveyances are not the only primary sources of the data and information that may be desired by the BOT.

The Writs prayed for are denied and this Petition is DISMISSED. No costs.


Equal protection of laws - the right of all persons to have the same access to the law and courts and to be treated equally by the law and courts, both in procedures and in the substance of the law.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Case Digest

...ELSA B. REYES vs. COURT OF APPEALS, SECRETARY OF JUSTICE, AFP-MUTUAL BENEFIT ASSOCIATION, INC., and GRACIELA ELEAZEAR ------------------------------------------------- G.R. No. 120817 November 4, 1996 ------------------------------------------------- I. FACTS Elsa B. Reyes is the president of Eurotrust Capital Corporation (EUROTRUST), a domestic corporation engaged in credit financing. Graciela Eleazar, private respondent, is the president of B.E. Ritz Mansion International Corporation (BERMIC), a domestic enterprise engaged in real estate development. The other respondent, Armed Forces of the Philippines Mutual Benefit Asso., Inc. (AFP-MBAI), is a corporation duly organized primarily to perform welfare services for the Armed Forces of the Philippines. Reyes petitioned two resolutions. On the resolution dated January 23, 1992 for the complaint against Graciela Eleazar in which both parties entered into a contract of loan being Reyes as the creditor and Eleazar as the debtor with no collateral but with a higher interest amounting to P216.053,126.80 for the construction of Condominium and Gold Business Park of Eleazar. In return, Eleazar issued 21 postdated checks to cover payments of the loan packages. However, when those checks were presented for payment, the same were dishonored by the drawee bank, Rizal Commercial Banking Corporation (RCBC), due to stop payment order made by Graciela Eleazar. Despite Eurotrust's notices and repeated demands to pay, Eleazar......

Words: 987 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Case Digest

...After due trial, on December 29, 1992, the trial court rendered a decision in the two cases convicting petitioner. Petitioner appealed to the CA, but the same was dismissed by the CA in its October 15, 1996 Decision wherein it affirmed in toto the RTC’s Decision. ISSUE WON Lim violated B.P. No. 22. HELD The elements of B.P....

Words: 888 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Case Digests

....: Before us is the disbarment case against retired Supreme Court Associate Justice Dante O. Tinga (respondent) filed by Mr. Jovito S. Olazo (complainant). The respondent is charged of violating Rule 6.02,[1] Rule 6.03[2] and Rule 1.01[3] of the Code of Professional Responsibility for representing conflicting interests. Factual Background In March 1990, the complainant filed a sales application covering a parcel of land situated in Barangay Lower Bicutan in the Municipality of Taguig. The land (subject land) was previously part of Fort Andres Bonifacio that was segregated and declared open for disposition pursuant to Proclamation No. 2476,[4] issued on January 7, 1986, and Proclamation No. 172,[5] issued on October 16, 1987. To implement Proclamation No. 172, Memorandum No. 119 was issued by then Executive Secretary Catalino Macaraig, creating a Committee on Awards whose duty was to study, evaluate, and make a recommendation...

Words: 4430 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Case Digest

...Gonzales is the counsel of Araceli in two civil cases filed against Anastacio. The first involved the settlement of the estate of Manuela Teodoro and while the case was pending, Gonzales assisted in filing the subsequent case for Annulment of Document, Reconveyance and Damages without indicating the special proceeding earlier filed. According to Anastacio, this was a deliberate act of forum shopping made by Gonzales. Initially, the commissioner found that Gonzales was indeed guilty of forum shopping for the ruling in either case would result in res judicata over the other and that he instituted the subsequent case without indicating the pending case. The commissioner ruled that Gonzales violated Canon 1 of the code for he disregarded the SC circular prohibiting forum shopping.Hence, suspending him for 1 month. However, the board of Governors of the IBP reversed the Commissioner’s recommendation and dismissed the case. Issue: Whether Gonzales committed forum shopping and thereby violating the Code of Professional Responsibility? Held: Yes. The court held that the respondent was guilty of forum shopping. Lawyers should be reminded that their primary duty is to assist the courts in the administration of justice. Any conduct that tends to delay, impede or obstruct the administration of justice contravenes this obligation....

Words: 8164 - Pages: 33

Premium Essay

Nintendo Case Digest

...Nintendo Case Digest – Team Pops BA 170 THR Nintendo, a pioneer of home video game consoles, has redefined how video games are to be played in this modern age. The innovative Nintendo Wii, with its unconventional remote-like game controller, proved to be a huge success for the Japanese corporation, instantly taking the top spot again after almost a decade of trailing behind Sony and Microsoft in the realm of video game consoles. Positioning Wii to become the go-to-game console of hardcore and non-traditional gamers alike, Nintendo enjoys the best of both worlds. Customers find that they can now enjoy playing video games with their families instead of playing by themselves – a new kind of fun which they cannot get from playing a PS3 or an Xbox 360. Adding to this, customers are convinced to jump ship from Sony and Microsoft for a cheaper yet family-friendly Nintendo console. While Sony and Microsoft lose money for every PS3 and Xbox 360 they sell, Nintendo has already been making huge profits from each unit of Wii sold. The Wii phenomenon is not a mere lucky strike but rather an adept execution of the Blue Ocean and the Sumo business strategies. Rather than having a bloody battle with the graphics-superior console makers in the hard-core gamers segment, Nintendo looked for a blue ocean. It launched its Wii console to serve a larger audience – the family....

Words: 1294 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Case Digest Modina

...11224053 MODINA vs. COURT OF APPEALS (317 SCRA 696) FACTS: The parcel of land under the name of Ramon Chiang is in questioned since Mr. Chiang claims that the land has already been sold by his wife to him. Mr. Chiang in turn sells this land to Modina which are all evidenced by deed of sale. Modina then filed Complaint for Recovery of Possession with Damages before the Regional Trial Court of Iloilo City. On the other hand, Merlinda, the wife of Ramon, presented also a complaint which is to make the deed of sale between her husband and Modina null and void. ISSUE: The first issue raised was that whether the sale of the parcel of land should be nullified or not. Second is that whether the petitioner, Modina, was a purchaser in good faith or not. Third is whether the decision of the trial court was in excess of jurisdiction or the court's acting beyond the limits of its power; and lastly whether or not only three-fourths of subject lots should be returned to the private respondent. RULING: The court declares the sale of land between Chiang and Modina as null and void. This is because under Art. 1490, husband and wife are prohibited to sell properties to each other. Not being the owner of the land, Ramon Chiang cannot sell the land to Modina. The sale by Ramon Chiang in favor of Modina is, likewise, void and inexistent. As for the second issue, the court concluded that Modina is not a purchaser in good faith. It was found that there were circumstances......

Words: 1181 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Cisco Case Digest

...Cisco was highly successful in its EPR effort. What accounts for this success? What were the most important things that CISCO did correctly? While lots of companies couldn’t implement EPR (Enterprise Resource Planning)- new computerized system- successfully because of problems such as upgrading software and also its failure in supporting some business process, CISCO was not one of them. The key success of CISCO was communication and cross- functional work in organization, (reeingineering), and team work. All of team members were directly involved in project. The belief that not only the management can make decisions but employee at bottom of pyramid can also share their ideas and be a part of decision-making process along with full training lead to success. CISCO did not update its old system but replaced the whole data of different departments with new system. That called “Reeingineering”. This helped the company to achieve quality, service and innovation. Reengineering is based on decentralizing the system, trying to change the old rule of controlling and the idea that only specialized staff could bring solutions. This system creates cross-functional community that helped better track the EPR launch. Team was composed of Information system leader, business leader, IT and Business consultant. In order to connect the old system with new one, company created data warehouse. Leaders were aware that EPR system should be compatible with their business process, so in one......

Words: 522 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Canon 15 Case Digest

...As the former Personnel Manager and Retained Counsel of Taggat together with the case he handled as government t prosecutor was labor-related case which fact, is not a sufficient basis to charge respondent for representing conflicting interests. The...

Words: 953 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Criminal Procedures Case Digest

...Since the dismissal of the case against Opulencia for violation of an ordinance alrdy amounted to...

Words: 23071 - Pages: 93

Premium Essay

Case Digest on Sales Law

...SUBJECT MATTER OF SALE 1. MELLIZA vs CITY OF ILOILO (23 SCRA 477) Facts: Juliana Melliza during her lifetime owned, among other properties, 3 parcels of residential land in Iloilo City (OCT 3462).Said parcels of land were known as Lots Nos. 2, 5 and 1214. The total area of Lot 1214 was 29,073 sq. m. On 27 November 1931she donated to the then Municipality of Iloilo, 9,000 sq. m. of Lot 1214, to serve as site for the municipal hall. The donation was however revoked by the parties for the reason that the area donated was found inadequate to meet the requirements of the development plan of the municipality, the so-called “Arellano Plan.” Subsequently, Lot 1214 was divided by Certeza Surveying Co., Inc. into Lots 1214-A and 1214-B. And still later, Lot 1214-B was further divided into Lots 1214-B-1, Lot 1214-B-2 and Lot1214-B-3. As approved by the Bureau of Lands, Lot 1214-B-1, with 4,562 sq. m., became known as Lot 1214-B; Lot 1214-B-2,with 6,653 sq. m., was designated as Lot 1214-C; and Lot 1214-B-3, with 4,135 sq. m., became Lot 1214-D. On 15 November1932, Juliana Melliza executed an instrument without any caption providing for the absolute sale involving all of lot 5, 7669 sq.m. of Lot 2 (sublots 2-B and 2-C), and a portion of 10,788 sq. m. of Lot 1214 (sublots 1214-B2 and 1214-B3) in favor of the Municipal Government of Iloilo for the sum of P6,422; these lots and portions being the ones needed by the municipal government for the construction of avenues, parks and City......

Words: 9930 - Pages: 40

Free Essay

Research Guide

...I. Statement of Purpose The Copyright Act of 1976 amended the Copyright Act of 1909 and serves as the primary basis of copyright law in the United States[1]. The Act spells out the basic rights of copyright holders, codifies the previously patchwork doctrine of fair use and adopted a unitary term of copyright exclusivity based on the date of the author’s death instead of using a fixed number of years and renewal terms as was previously spelled out in the 1909 Act. The 1909 Act was the last major piece of copyright legislation, and Congress recognized that technology had changed to the point where several pieces of the Act were no longer fit to serve as the basis for interpretation. The 1976 Act was designed to address intellectual property issues raised by new innovations in technology that were previously unforeseen. The Act addresses to the legal practitioners and non-lawyers what kinds of rights they have based on the medium in which they have chosen to communicate an idea as what as what constitutes a copyrightable idea. The sine qua non of copyright is originality, however, the Copyright Act sets the standard for creativity extremely low. Rather than the completely novel ideas protected by the patent laws, copyright laws dictate that an idea only needs a minimal degree of creativity to be protected. The Copyright Act is seen as a compromise between the rights of the publishers and the rights of the authors. The extension protects the rights of the authors with......

Words: 5094 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

For This Magazine, Internal Audit Proved Hard to Digest

...Case Study – FOR THIS MAGAZINE, INTERNAL AUDIT PROVED HARD TO DIGEST Janet Leonard AC 562 – Auditing: An Operational and Internal Perspective Including Fraud Examination This case revolves around the globally renowned company, Reader’s Digest. Best known for its popular magazine of the same name, the company is one of the world’s largest direct-mail publishing houses. As with other global companies, Reader’s Digest made a decision in the mid-1980’s to outsource a large portion of its direct-mail business to specialized mailing companies. Its Pleasantville, New York facility was to be converted into an office complex, complete with auditorium. The company hired Terrence McGrane as its chief internal auditor. Mr. McGrane set up meetings with the company’s vice presidents in an effort to learn more about the company. In an effort to learn the accounts coding system, Mr. McGrane borrowed some recently processed invoices from the accounting department. He then proceeded to his first scheduled meeting with the vice president of administrative services, Mr. Harold Scott. Part of Mr. Scott’s duties involved the oversight of construction projects, as well as maintenance services. According to the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners’ 2006 Report to the Nation, 25% of all fraud in large businesses is discovered by accident. Such was the case with Reader’s Digest. When Mr. McGrane showed Mr. Scott the invoices he had retrieved from accounting, Mr....

Words: 1136 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

A Hybrid Approach of System Security for Small Ans Medium Enterprises: Combining Different Cryptographic Techniques

...Proceedings of the 2013 Federated Conference on Computer Science and Information Systems pp. 659–662 A Hybrid Approach of System Security for Small and Medium Enterprises: combining different Cryptography techniques Georgiana Mateescu Polytechnic University of Bucharest, Splaiul Independenței 313, Bucharest, Romania, Email: Marius Vladescu Polytechnic University of Bucharest, Splaiul Independenței 313, Bucharest, Romania, Email: Abstract—Information protection is one of the most important issues in every domain, especially when we are talking about enterprises. Information safety can be translated into three key terms: integrity, availability and data protection. There is a great number of means used in order to achieve the three objectives simultaneously. The most popular is cryptography because it offers a lot of techniques which nowadays are impossible to fail. In this paper we want to prove their efficiency by comparing the different types of crypto algorithms and by presenting their weaknesses and strengths. In order to maximize the benefits of the crypto techniques, we propose a hybrid approach that combines three crypto algorithms. I. INTRODUCTION W HEN we are talking about information security we refer to it as the mean we use to protect our information from unauthorized access, use, disclosure, disruption, modification, perusal, inspection, recording or destruction. The main concepts......

Words: 2835 - Pages: 12

Free Essay


...Industrial Technologies Program Steam Digest A compendium of articles from 2003 on the technical and financial benefits of steam efficiency, presented by stakeholders in the U.S. Department of Energy’s BestPractices Steam efforts Volume IV Compiled for the Industrial Technologies Program By the Alliance to Save Energy Acknowledgements The Steam Digest: Volume IV is the fourth annual compilation of articles dedicated to steam system efficiency. The U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy sponsors the BestPractices Steam program, which either directly or indirectly facilitated the creation of all the articles contained in this volume. BestPractices Steam, which is part of the wider BestPractices program under DOE’s Industrial Technologies Program, works with industry to identify plant-wide opportunities for energy savings and process efficiency. The BestPractices Steam Steering Committee provides a great deal of input and guidance into the program (see more information about the Committee on pages 1 and 2). Mr. Fred Fendt, Technical Fellow with Rohm & Haas, serves as Chair of the BestPractices Steam Steering Committee. Ms. Debbie Bloom, Senior Consultant for Nalco Company, continues as Vice-Chair. Mr. Doug Riley, Director of Global Energy of Millennium Chemicals, serves as the Executive At-Large....

Words: 29283 - Pages: 118

Free Essay

P.P. V Param Cumararaswamy

...Malayan Law Journal Reports/1986/Volume 1/PUBLIC PROSECUTOR v PARAM CUMARASWAMY - [1986] 1 MLJ 512 - 3 January 1986 6 pages [1986] 1 MLJ 512 PUBLIC PROSECUTOR v PARAM CUMARASWAMY OCJ KUALA LUMPUR CHAN J FEDERAL TERRITORY CRIMINAL TRIAL NO 39 OF 1985 3 January 1986 Criminal Law and Procedure -- Charge of sedition -- Close of prosecution case -- Whether prima facie case made out -- Sedition Act, 1948, ss. 3(1) & 4(1) -- Criminal Procedure Code (F.M.S. Cap. 6), s. 180 -- Federal Constitution, art. 10 1986 1 MLJ 512 at 513 In this case the respondent was charged with uttering seditious words, an offence under the Sedition Act, 1948. At the close of the prosecution case, counsel submitted that there was no case to answer. Held: (1) all that is required at the close of the prosecution case is for the prosecution to discharge their evidential burden by adducing sufficient evidence to raise a prima facie case against the accused. At that stage, a trial judge should not consider whether or not a case has been proved beyond a reasonable doubt against the accused. If no evidence is called for the defence, then, and then only, the tribunal of fact must decide whether the prosecution has succeeded in discharging the persuasive burden by proving its case beyond a reasonable doubt; (2) in this case the prosecution has discharged their evidential burden by adducing evidence of primary facts....

Words: 4723 - Pages: 19