Free Essay

Case of Gm (Non-Market Environment)

In: Business and Management

Submitted By cassiusls
Words 1582
Pages 7
Question 1: Identify and explain the 4l’s based on the case.
a. Issues
The dispute over the safety of the pickup trucks, vehicle safety and defective design
Firstly, the root cause is that the GM company has a unreasonable design of their gas tank on the collisions GM C/K pickups, the report shows that this pickups’ gas tank was too close with the bumper, it only 25 centimeters long. This is dangerous because that will cause explosions if there is any strike. A safety design should be place the gas tank on the top of axle or add on a shield between the gas tank and bumper. Further, the report also shows that the gas tank design was used for trucks manufactured between 1979 and 1987, and the fact is GM knows about their design problem but take no measure to fix or recall their cars because that will cause more cost.
At the Moseley case happens, there are at least 130 other lawsuits involving the design of the gas tank GM need to faced. So the major issue of this case in this point is that whether the gas tank design and placement were defective and because that explosion case after their pickup was struck on the side by another vehicle. And those assumptions were proved by the GM engineer who is testified that GM company hidden the knowledge of this dangerous safety defect, but GM try to block his testimony because they had known for years and refused correct it for fear of alerting the public. Moreover, the provided videotapes of GM’s own crash tests between 1981 and 1983 showed that it’s truly dangerous when the pickup was stuck on the side by another vehicle its gas tank broke open.

b. Interest
Car buyers, Medias and the other car manufactory like Ford and Dodge.
As we know, this case is a famous nonmarket environment case. And one of the important factors that changes in the nonmarket environment is interest group activity. After the Moseley case, the car buyer more cares about the safety of pickups and are pickups inherently more dangerous than smaller vehicles and the car buys as the consumer, they also care if they may get compensation after the accident cause by defective car design.
As for the news media, we have the knowledge of the NBC versus GM, after the accident happened, there is a good story for the NBC, which is a highly critical Dateline story, and as the result, this story was aired nearly three months ago, therefore GM also expresses concerns to NBC about the fairness, they thought in this accident, their design was not the main cause of explosions, the deadly reason is the slammed by another car. But that’s obviously accepted by public.
From the data showed by NHTSA, besides GM, Ford or Dodge also have similar problem although they are using the different design, this case also impact to them for developing their safety standards.
In fact, day after GM press conference, NBC news made an embarrassing retraction not disputing GM’s facts. Last, NBC established the position of ombudsman for professional standards and program review, also the dateline senior and executive producers resigned, and Michelle Gillen was reassigned to Miami.

c. Institution
NHTSA (The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration)
The NHTSA recorded data shows that they do not control for how the vehicles were used, which could affect the frequency with which they were involved in accident. Once NHTSA has asked GM to recall the pickups because their gas tank design, but GM maintains they are safe refuse to recall the trucks.
The pickup owners were seeking to force GM to make the gas tanks less dangerous to compensate all pickup owners for either the cost of repairs or the resale value they lost because of the defect. But the fact is that GM hasn’t set aside any money to cover the cost of the program and doesn’t expect to take a special charge.
As we know about in 1999, finally the GM being sentenced to pay 1.9 billion as compensation for the 1993 accident, it is a success for judging their defective gas tank design, but still GM doesn’t recall their productions.
Finally, GM’s interpretation was that there was internal disagreement within NHTSA and/or lack of support from the department of Justice, and there are no recall but GM agreed to spend 51 million on safety programs including buying 200,000 child safety seats for low-income families.

d. Information
Superior information
GM has superior information about the crash test between 1981 and 1983. But that’s hidden until the GM engineer discourser those test.
The alternative choice for GM at that time may be admit that their defective design will cause the explosion if slammed, but they won’t, if GM admitted, means that they were make a big mistake and that is a life threatening problem, and lead to recall all of their pickups between 1981 and 1983, further, they would suffer a large amount of fund to correct it and make a settlement of claims, it’s unaccepted for the management of GM at that time.
Look back to NBC, they don’t have general information for the whole affairs, but come out the Dateline program, the presentations includes: human tragedy, controversy and conflict like Ditlow, trial attorneys and experts, visual and vivid, demonstration of crash and fire which is based on NBC’s proof, protector of people’s right to know. But ended public is ignorant what is actually conclude from Dateline, the audience which means the consumers, people are more likely to see whether there is any compensations for them, and how GM response to this affair.

Q2: Discuss the roles of news media in the business environment
We are mentioned that this case is a nonmarket environment issue, nonmarket issues are often incompletely-formed and thus their development can be affected by managers (particularly early in the issue life-cycle), but they become much more difficult in the eye of the media. And the news media here in this case is NBC, and it comes out the dateline program and brings troubles to GM. For the GM, they were luckily, because it is really hard to beat the news media.
The news media plays a significant role not just in society but also the nonmarket environment. In society the news media is there to give information to the public about anything that is affecting people’s lives and the society we live in. The role the media has in the nonmarket environment is also very important, by identifying issues and placing them on the agendas of firms. The media is a good way to:
1. Alert the public, activists, interest groups, and government officeholders to nonmarket issues.
2. Raise concerns about the policies and practices of firms.
3. Provide information about the likely effects of alternative courses of action.
4. Reduce the costs of collective nonmarket action.
5. Enhance a nonmarket strategy by conveying information provided by an interest group.
6. Represent certain interests and principals consistent with the news media’s perception of its role in society.
In general, the news media is a very resourceful way to get messages across to the public, whether it’s to bring attention to a certain issue or a resolution for a previous issue.
The media cannot be “used” as part of a strategy, but, its decisions about coverage and treatment can be anticipated--theory of the media--and activists and interest groups choose strategies anticipating the media’s decisions.
But there is a big problem on this area about this case, NBC uses their own ‘proof’ to proven that the explosion is caused by GM’s defective design. They hired a consultant and set up a test on a rural road in Indiana. They rigged two GM trucks with rock engines – “igniters” to throw out sparks – and pushed old cars from the top of a hill into them. The first time a small fire resulted, the second time nothing happened. An exaggerated video of the first fire was used in the segment, but no disclosure was made of the rocket engines. The producers decided against disclosure because they were satisfied, as everyone who has looked at these videotapes has been – with the exception of GM – that the rocket engines had nothing to do with the explosion, the fire was started by the broken headlight.
But GM after beat back with testing that the fire was caused by sparks from the rocket engines and by a defective gas cap instead of a defective gas tank, and further they use x-rays show that there was no hole in the gas tank caused by the collision which will cause fires.
NBC as a news media wants protect people’s right to know about this affairs, but it’s fairly to maintain the truthfulness of the case, that makes the opposite effect, even final GM pay the compensations to consumers but still don’t means NBC wins the affair.

Reference:
1. The Non-Market Environment of Business. Retrieved on July 08, 2013 from https://www.msu.edu/course/ec/360/Matraves/ch1&2nonmktenv.htm
2. Sustainable Business Netweek (2013).Good news for business and the enviorment. VOL. 8
3. New York Law Journal (1993). Communications and Media Law- The Inside Edition of ‘GM v.NBC’. VOL.4
4. Elizabeth Kolbert(1993). NBC Settles Truck Crash Lawsuit, Saying Test was ‘Inappropriate’. The New York Times, Feb 10,1993.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Case of Gm (Non-Market Environment)

...he dispute over the safety of the pickup trucks, vehicle safety and defective design Firstly, the root cause is that the GM company has a unreasonable design of their gas tank on the collisions GM C/K pickups, the report shows that this pickups’ gas tank was too close with the bumper, it only 25 centimeters long. This is dangerous because that will cause explosions if there is any strike. A safety design should be place the gas tank on the top of axle or add on a shield between the gas tank and bumper. Further, the report also shows that the gas tank design was used for trucks manufactured between 1979 and 1987, and the fact is GM knows about their design problem but take no measure to fix or recall their cars because that will cause more cost. At the Moseley case happens, there are at least 130 other lawsuits involving the design of the gas tank GM need to faced. So the major issue of this case in this point is that whether the gas tank design and placement were defective and because that explosion case after their pickup was struck on the side by another vehicle. And those assumptions were proved by the GM engineer who is testified that GM company hidden the knowledge of this dangerous safety defect, but GM try to block his testimony because they had known for years and refused correct it for fear of alerting the public. Moreover, the provided videotapes of GM’s own crash tests between 1981 and 1983 showed that it’s truly dangerous when the pickup was stuck on the side by...

Words: 344 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

General Motors Like a Rock

...Papers Home Page » Business and Management Case of Gm (Non-Market Environment) In: Business and Management Case of Gm (Non-Market Environment) Question 1: Identify and explain the 4l’s based on the case. a. Issues The dispute over the safety of the PICKUP TRUCKS, vehicle safety and defective design Firstly, the root cause is that the GM company has a unreasonable design of their gas tank on the collisions GM C/K pickups, the report shows that this pickups’ gas tank was too close with the bumper, it only 25 centimeters long. This is dangerous because that will cause explosions if there is any strike. A safety design should be place the gas tank on the top of axle or add on a shield between the gas tank and bumper. Further, the report also shows that the gas tank design was used for trucks manufactured between 1979 and 1987, and the fact is GM knows about their design problem but take no measure to fix or recall their cars because that will cause more cost. At the Moseley case happens, there are at least 130 other lawsuits involving the design of the gas tank GM need to faced. So the major issue of this case in this point is that whether the gas tank design and placement were defective and because that explosion case after their pickup was struck on the side by another vehicle. And those assumptions were proved by the GM engineer who is testified that GM company hidden the knowledge of this dangerous safety defect, but GM try to block his testimony because they......

Words: 570 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Gmo's (Genetically Modified Organisms

...Scientists find that GM foods promise to meet this need and it has been more and more popular not only for the producers but also for the consumers because of its numerous advantages such as pest resistance, lower price, more nutrition and so on. Although it is undeniable that GMO’s (genetically-modified organisms) still have some challenges to overcome including environmental hazards, human health risks and influence on the food chain of our ecosystem, the development of GMO’s will not be stopped since these difficulties are slight. Scientists find that GMO’s promise to meet the needs of a growing population, and has become increasingly popular with producers and consumers a like because of its numerous advantages such as pest resistance, decrease in price, nutritional value and more. But what are GMO’s and GM Food? GMO’s and GM Food are plants that have been modified in the laboratory to enhance desired traits such as increased resistance to herbicides or improved nutritional content. The enhancement of desired traits has traditionally been undertaken through breeding. Genetic engineering, on the other hand, can create plants with the exact desired trait very rapidly and with great accuracy. For example, plant geneticists can isolate a gene responsible for drought tolerance and insert that gene into a different plant. The new genetically-modified plant will gain drought tolerance as well. Not only can genes be transferred from one plant to another, but genes from......

Words: 1336 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Essay On Safety Of Food

...pasteurization cooling and canning etc. Today we increase array of new food and food chemicals that do not have history of use in society. Before using these foods and food chemicals as food supply ensures that they don’t have harmful effects to humans. Regulation of Food in New Zealand and Australia For public health and safety protection New Zealand and each state of Australia designed food safety law. These laws for food safety and reliability are enforced and interpreted by their respective government. While setting food regulation must know history of food usage and this regulation effects level of risk a community accept due to food relation. IN New Zealand and Australia food for sale must comply trade laws and other laws which protect environment and less usage of...

Words: 1588 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Strategy

...Contents Introduction 2 Definition 2 Method 2 Theory and Analysis 2 Conclusion 8   Introduction To establish strategy is an indispensible part of any organisation. It plays an important role in directing and helping organisation to achieve the objectives. In this context, the strategy is considered as the way which organisations communicate with the competitive landscape to obtain the above average return. Therefore, to build an effective strategy, there is a need for profoundly understanding the competitive environment and estimating correctly the resource of organisation. This essay will examine the role of strategy as a “bridge” in order to assist firms to reach their targets in the competitive landscape. Definition There are many ways to definite strategy, however, it can be found that almost of them accept that ‘Strategy is an integrated and coordinated set of commitments and actions designed to exploit core competencies and gain a competitive advantage’. (Hitt, Ireland and Hoskinsson 2009). Organisational resources include skills of employees, finances, capital equipments, patents and talented managers (Hit, Ireland and Hoskinsson 2009). Organisation resource is defined as ‘an asset, competency, process, skill, or knowledge controlled by the corporation’ (Wheelen and Hunger 2002). Competitive landscape is more complex in the context of globalisation; however, the fundamental constituents of landscape are customers, suppliers and competitors. Method To......

Words: 1547 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Gm Food

...Why does the green movement appose GM in agriculture? Word count: 994 BSE – Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy EU – European Union GE – Genetic Engineering GM – Genetic Modification GMO – Genetically Modified Organism The green movement is a broad belief system focussing on a whole array of issues targeting such things as: technology; monopolisation of GM; alleged dangers of corporate control; risk in food, health and farming; furthermore, encompassing issues of poverty; trade and human rights (Scoones, 2008). The green movement came about in the 1970’s when people became environmentally aware and socio-political groups began to spring up. The ideals of the green movement have spread globally in the form of political parties who believe their ethics will lead to world peace (Green peace international, 2006). However, these principles encompass an extreme dislike towards GM technology. This essay explores the reasons why the green movement appose GM. The use of GM was first perceived as having many benefits such as better yield, reduced pesticide use and a reduction in food cost. However, the green movement believe GM is a risk to public health, safety and environment. Firstly, they believe genetically modified foods will cause gene disruption and modification of existing genes causing toxicity; secondly, they will cause an increase in antibiotic resistance due to gene splicing and thirdly, genes will escape into wild populations (Jerome et al., 2010; Thies......

Words: 1590 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ford Motor Company: the Product Warranty Program

...business environment change in the form of new warranty policy announcement by its major competitors General Motor, which changes the current philosophy of warranty in U.S car market. This policy change may have implications not only on Ford’s sales and market share but also on various departments within organization (such as manufacturing, quality assurance, parts and service, and extended service plans) and their dealer network. In answer, Ford executives have to respond through a best suitable course of action by carefully analyzing the current market variables. Changes in the business environment created both opportunities and threats for Ford’s strategic development. The organization improved its strategic capabilities while witnessed and coped with the forces of comparative market continually result into: • Build the business • Development of strategic capabilities that move the organization forward • Improvement of the ways of organization in which it creates quality products and Increases sales and profit in existing markets with a view to offering its customers better service This case study analysis illustrates how Ford, analyzed its business operations and market performance, moved its business forward by choosing an appropriate strategy for warranties and services. Competitive forces that shaped the Ford’s strategy: Ford was founded in the USA in 1903. In addition to facing strong Macro Enjoinment forces like 1970s economic recession and U.S. car market......

Words: 1718 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Monsanto Seed Are They Safe

...are a leading producer of genetically engineered (GE) seed and of the herbicide glyphosate, which it markets under the Roundup brand. Glyphosate is a broad-spectrum systemic herbicide used to kill weeds, especially annual broadleaf weeds and grasses known to compete with commercial crops grown around the globe. Is using the weed killer Rounds an ethical thing to do when it has the potential to harm plans and animals? Monsanto seeds are they Safe Does Monsanto maintain an ethical culture that can effectively respond to various stakeholders? Like any other large firm, Monsanto also has the responsibility to maintain an ethical culture that can respond effectively to stakeholders when issues arise.   There are issues with their products that still need to be resolved including the risks to health and damage to the environment.   They also need to enforce their code of ethics to mitigate employee misconduct.   Although Monsanto has made ethical mistakes in the past, it is trying to remedy this. Monsanto accepts full responsibility for its employees’ behavior. The incidents showed that although Monsanto has not been immune to scandals, it is willing to work with authorities to correct them. (Ferrell, Fraedrich, & Ferrell, 2011, p. 313) Compare the benefits of growing GM seeds for crops with the potential negative consequences of using them. With the potential benefits of GM seeds being more resistance to stress and if the crops can be made more resistant to pest......

Words: 778 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Student

...is not good for General Motors. The company face loss $286 million in the second quarter and over $1billion in the first quarter. GM losses are largely tied to be North American operation and rising supply, fuel, healthcare, and pension costs. GM makes money not on auto sales auto financing.GM is overly dependent on the U.S automobile market; more than two thirds of its sales are made in the United States. In addition it is overly dependent on its financing division. GM facing economic threats at home and abroad and stiff competition from more differentiated and lower priced products, GM manager must decide how it will produce and market its vehicles in the future. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: This paper will explain GM’s most pressing challenges. Overcapacity is negatively impacted their financial results, brutal international competition is causing GM to react with target costing strategies, rising fuel prices directly impacts their cash flows and complicates capital budgeting strategies and tactics and their ongoing health care and pension costs continue to color their future earning potential. These challenges will be addressed by using performance assessment measures. The financial assessment measures include net income and their market share value, liabilities of health care and pension benefits, revenues, target costing and capital budgeting. Non-financial measures include customer satisfaction and branding effects on sales volume....

Words: 1348 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Power of Food Safety

...There are many sites based around Food Safety. A large portion of them are either government regulated or overseen, but there also exist a few that are completely independent. The Center for Food Safety (CFFS) is an organization I found when searching for food safety websites. This site is a non-profit organization that was founded in 1997 to raise awareness of pressing food safety issues and create relationships with food companies of all levels, whether at a grassroots co-op market level or a large-scale international superstore level. Even more in -depth on the website and organization's purpose, they are very active in communities. The CFFS makes multiple appearances of rallies, conferences and speaking engagements to educate the public about issues that affect them nationally such as genetically modified organisms, sweet corn, and meat antibiotics and how these issues should be important to everyone. They also write articles about these issues and distribute them to co-ops throughout the country. One article I looked at on their site named "What's in a Label?" by Lisa J. Bunin, Ph.D., explained the differences between certified organic foods and natural foods. I learned that natural foods are unregulated and aren't tested. Many company make claims that all of their foods were natural. I took some time to look through my cupboards and found a box of tea and read the label. It claimed to be 100% natural, yet in the ingredients it listed "artificial flavor". This was......

Words: 1164 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Crop Plants

...GENETICALLY MODIFIED CROP PLANTS Biotechnology is providing us with a wide range of options for how we can use agricultural and commercial forestry lands. The cultivation of genetically modified (GM) crops on millions of hectares of lands and their injection into our food chain is a huge global genetic experiment involving all living beings. Considering the fast pace of new advances in production of genetically modified crops, consumers, farmers and policymakers worldwide are challenged to reach a consensus on a clear vision for the future of world food supply. Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs) are being made by inserting a gene from an external source such as viruses, bacteria, animals or plants into usually unrelated species. Biotechnology has granted us the ability to overcome insurmountable physiological barriers and to exchange genetic materials among all living organisms. Concerning bacteria, the ability to genetically modify plants depends on obtaining genetically identical populations and readily manipulating DNA. The use of recombinant DNA technology has the potential to allow the creation of an organism which is desired and designed by human. According by Halford, N.G, Shewry, P.R, genetically Modified crop means any crop containing or derived from a genetically engineered organism.   Another method is to culture plants from totipotent cells found in plant meristems. These plant cells can divide and differentiate into the various types of specialized cells.......

Words: 1267 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Gmo's

... Some people regard genetically modified wheat and corn for their drought resistance and ability to feed millions of people in parts of the world that desperately need food. The other side of the argument stems from unwanted side effects caused by GMOs such as the creation of herbicide-resistant super weeds to the loss of biodiversity and uncontrollable transfer of modified genes into the environment (Whitman 4). The benefits vs. risks that GMO’s pose in regard to the environment and human health are still inconclusive. Only rigorous scientific research and time will yield conclusive results, along with possible advancements in technology that will help address most concerns. What is clear is that we need GMO’s to be able to feed the world’s population and that the potential risk GMO’s pose to human health and the environment can vary tremendously. The labeling of GM food is necessary will address the question of accountability of the impact GMO’s and large corporations have with their “proprietary crops” to the environment and health, along with minimizing potential risk.   The argument that corporate driven agriculture and bio technology are ill suited to address global hunger is incredibly complex; the factors include economic barriers that are inherent in large scale farming, displacement of the poor who rely on farming, and the use of homogenous crops that are used in nonfood products. As......

Words: 2999 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Monsanto Attempts to Balance Stakeholder Interests

...of crops through the introduction of new genes and gene-conditioning inside the seed a better way for the development of specific goals such as control pests and increase production rates. Monsanto produces and markets 90% of genetically modified seeds that have helped farmers around the world. Through its products from seeds or genes used by other companies have the monopoly of Monsanto arrived in some crops in 70-100 of the market share of the foregoing became Monsanto's supporters and anti-where the point of view of the supporters was that Monsanto since reached technology that can contribute to solving the problem of food shortages in the world, including availability of high-yield products and resistance to pests. The opinion of the owners and your monopoly may make Monsanto multinational giant requisition food supplies in the world modified seeds genetically its health effects and the environment and biodiversity with all this division between the pro and anti-Monsanto this giant did not stop from becoming the largest and most govern in crops. All this controversy makes us look into the history of Monsanto where beginnings were in the production of chemicals that make us more wary of Monsanto products, modified Rathian the safety of individuals and the environment violin that Monsanto record third parties free of moral ethical issues makes us more wary. In 1901 in St. Louis it was established Monsanto for the production of synthetic food additives and with the......

Words: 1389 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Science and Technology

...Science and Technology Consider: * Science and its impact on society * Scientific developments & effect on man; environment etc. * The Sciences VS the Humanities * Science & Religion Definitions: * Science - study of nature and the knowledge we gain through observations and experiments * Scientific discovery - finding out about something about the existing workings of nature that was not known before * Technology - application of scientific knowledge for practical purposes (e.g. antibiotics and their uses) * Invention - newly created product/process Science today causes as many problems as it solves. * Horrible pervasions of science * E.g. Invention of poison gas (holocaust), war against Japan ended with the atomic bomb * Even when science is intended to benefit humans, unintended consequences could occur. * E.g. Rachel carson's silent spring (1963) awakened the world to the dangers of pollution * How science in the service of business can produce catastrophic results ; pesticides for farms -> Are we blinded by profit so much so we don't do not care about the environment? * *air pollution is the biggest cause of human deaths today Science, money and value * Science is very much subservient to business interest today -> values of those who seek fame and fortune creep into science: profit often determines the direction of science, influencing the choice of problem investigated by......

Words: 778 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Bees

...intense development. Countries are choosing mandatory labeling or adherence to voluntary labeling. Challenges to mandatory labeling are unlikely to be successful under current World Trade Organization (WTO) rules. Marketers and trade negotiators should recognize this and move toward living with diversity in labeling policy. Keywords: GMOs; biotechnology; labeling policy; trade disputes. We are at another important crossroads on the path that will determine the market acceptance of foods produced with the use of biotechnology. Individual governments are managing a range of policies that affect biotechnology, including those on research and development, intellectual property rights, regulatory approval (safety assessment), and labeling requirements. They are taking divergent policy paths that make for market uncertainty. At the same time, companies are announcing their intentions regarding the use or non-use of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) in their products. These intentions make the market less uncertain for sales to those companies but raise the stakes in predicting the choices of other companies. Labeling policy for food products is currently under intense development in several countries. What are the basic requirements for such labeling programs and what policies are countries adopting? What are the consequences of each country’s pursuit of the policy that best seems to fit its needs? Finally, is it likely that these policies could be......

Words: 2432 - Pages: 10