Premium Essay

Case on Trust

In: Historical Events

Submitted By parulkumar
Words 16670
Pages 67
Occasional Paper 5

The Recovery of Trust: Case studies of organisational failures and trust repair

Published by the Institute of Business Ethics

Occasional Paper 5


Dr Graham Dietz is a Senior Lecturer in Human Resource Management and Organisational Behaviour at Durham University, UK. His research focuses on trust repair after organisational failures, as well as trust-building across cultures. Together with his co-author on this report, his most recent co-edited book is Organizational Trust: A cultural perspective (Cambridge University Press). Dr Nicole Gillespie is a Senior Lecturer in Management at the University of Queensland, Australia. Her research focuses on building, repairing and measuring trust in organisations and across cultural and professional boundaries. In addition, Nicole researches in the areas of leadership, teams and employee engagement.


The authors would like to thank the contact persons in the featured organisations for their comments on an earlier draft of this Paper. The IBE is particularly grateful to Severn Trent and BAE Systems for their support of this project.

All rights reserved. To reproduce or transmit this book in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, please obtain prior permission in writing from the publisher. The Recovery of Trust: Case studies of organisational failures and trust repair Price £10 ISBN 978-1-908534-00-2 © IBE First published February 2012 by the Institute of Business Ethics 24 Greencoat Place London SW1P 1BE Registered Charity No. 1084014 The Institute’s website ( provides information on IBE publications, events and other aspects of its work.


Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Providian Trust

...Providian Trust: Tradition and Technology Business context/Key business drivers Providian Trust, headquartered in New York, is a financial and fiduciary services company. In 1994, it had 216 branches and managed $49.4 billion in trust assets with a staff of 840 full-time employees. The firm was falling behind the competition because the institutional custody business was becoming extremely technology-intensive, with some of the larger players outsourcing their entire backroom function in order to make large operations more effective. Therefore, a project was initiated to convert the trust division’s outdated information system into a more efficient system using Access Plus, a new trust and custody management software. Initiatives objectives/Benefits Intensive competitive pressures, client demands, and some internal problems were driving the need for the initiative. Specifically: 1. Competitors were having more advanced systems and technical competitive advantages 2. Clients were unhappy about the quality of the services 3. Decentralized control and lack of a clear distribution of responsibility Providian Trust wished to solve the above problems through the implementation of the new system. They also expected that the improved computerized trust system would consolidate and centralize data administration, give trust officers more time to interact with clients, reduce the number of full-time employees from 840 to 660, and save $9.2 million annually.......

Words: 1004 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Anti Trust Policy in the Modern Economy: Microsoft Anti-Trust Case

...Anti-trust Policy in the Modern Economy Microsoft's Anti-trust Case Mark Hinman UCCS Baud 5590 Anti-trust Policy in the Modern Economy Microsoft's Anti-trust Case This paper's intention is to discuss the role of anti-trust legislation in the modern economy. To accomplish this, we will be reviewing the United States Government's anti-trust case against Microsoft that began nearly twenty-two years ago. To begin we will look at the history leading up to the filing, the government's argument, Microsoft's argument, and the outcome of the case. We will also look at the intent of the Sherman Anti-Trust Act. Specifically, how does the Sherman Anti-Trust Act protect consumers? Finally, we will discuss whether the anti-trust legislation actually accomplishes what it is intended to do, with respect to the technology industry. Microsoft has been under constant scrutiny since June 1990 when the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) launched a probe into the possible collusion between Microsoft and IBM. Three years later, the FTC handed over their investigation to the U.S. Department of Justice. After years of accusations for monopolizing and engaging in anti-competitive acts, Microsoft finally, on May 18, 1998, received a suit for violation of federal anti-trust laws.[i] The suit alleges that Microsoft is in violation of Sections 1 and 2 of the Sherman Anti-Trust Act, and seeks to prohibit Microsoft from selling certain products and engaging in certain......

Words: 2315 - Pages: 10

Free Essay


...create their own that they will follow. The five values that I chose were trust, happiness, independence, love/affection, and achievement/ success. After analyzing and trying to decide on one value that means the most to me, I realized that four of the values I chose all play an intricate roll in one value. My achievement and success in my life is very important to me. Without having achievements or accomplishing something that I have set out to do, I would be an extremely miserable and lost soul. I believe everyone was put on this earth to achieve or accomplish something. It is up to the individual whether they are successful. While reflecting on previous years in my life, I noticed that trust, happiness, independence and love/affection have almost deterred my courage to achieve and succeed in certain situations. Trust is the very thing that everybody in this world desires, or at least should desire from one another. Trust is the reason a husband does not question his wife’s whereabouts, because he believes her faithfulness. Trust is the reason a boss does not check behind the work of his employees, because he knows that they will do it to his standards. I believe that trust is faith. When I say that I am placing my faith in somebody, I trust them. Whenever I die, it is one thing that I want to be remembered for. That as a woman, I maintained people’s trust in me. When there is trust in any type of relationship, the parties involved are able to let their......

Words: 864 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay


... clubs and access to materials is available to all people. As an example, the game of Football has typically been a sport reserved only for men. Unfortunately, this stance has eliminated the ability of some skilled females to effectively participate in the sport. In the Southern United States a female football player was recently removed from her team based on her gender. Prior to her removal her coaches had given her only positive feedback. The girl and her parents did not understand why she had been removed after receiving only positive feedback from her coaches. When asked why the decision had been made the coach replied that a verse in the bible was interpreted to mean a female should not participate in a “male” sport. In this case the school, team, players, student athlete and her parents all suffered from the notion that certain groups should be excluded rather than included. Diverse societies are better Diverse societies blend different cultures, genders and economic levels together. In a society where differences are valued the society is progressive and innovative. Understanding different cultures allows us to expand our knowledge, remain open minded and collaborate with individuals that may be different but who have knowledge we lack. We are able to learn from one another and develop our minds. Additionally, we are able to successfully avoid genetic problems that arise from inbreeding. Our country was founded on the notion that all men are created...

Words: 969 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Unit Trust

...The main role of a unit trust consultant would be distributing unit trust or mutual funds on behalf of a unit trust managemen company/ bank to the public. By explaining and analysing each and every fund that are distributed, unit trust consultant aid their clients in giving their best bets on their investments. In reality, a unit trust consultant is helping their clients in achieving financial independence at earlier age. And these need to start from educating them how important a financial plan is. Many people do not sense the urge of having a financial plan till they face financial difficulties. Therefore most of the governments “force” their citizens to build up their personal retirement fund which is mostly directly deducted from their pay/wages. For example, in Malaysia, every employees and employers ought to contribute to Employee Provident Fund (EPF). People can only withdraw the money when they reach the age of 55. However, 70% of the contributors spent all their EPF money after 3 years from their retirement, which seems do not serve the main purpose of setting up EPF. Thus in this case, unit trust consultant comes in and serve a role. There are many ways or types of investment which we can use to build up retirement fund. Long term investment in unit trust would be one of the most efficient way to build up a fund and at the same time offer a handsome return. There are 2 rules to follow in investing for unit trust: First, mid to long term investment. Second,...

Words: 295 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How to Increase Global Consumer Trust in Online Shopping? a Case Study of Amazon.Com

...Abstract Online shopping or e-commerce is developed rapidly and has a gigantic impact in globalization. Many consumers around the world start to trade products or do business using this system. The most crucial factor for consumer who shops online is trust. Grabner-Kraeuter (1989 p.43) states “Trust can serve as mechanism to reduce the complexity of human conduct in situations where people have to cope with uncertainty”. This paper tries to analyze that which method can be use by online merchants to increase their consumer trust. Various action and tools are introduced to increasing customers’ trust and verify the website information. is chosen to be the case study. The reason behind this is the popularity and reliability of the website and it is ranked in the top30 website in the world. Introduction Figure: E-commerce market size from 2004 to 2014 Source: Euromonitor, International Telecommunication Union; A.T. Kearney analysis E-commerce is now widely used and has a huge impact in globalization The graph above shows the upward trend of e-commerce market size which increasing respectively since 2004 and from now on the trend is also estimated to be rising due to the benefits of it. There are significant reasons behind that why majority of people use this method of trading. First of all, consumers can trade goods easier than by traditional shopping. Consumers can obviously gain convenience when they shop online since they can purchase or sell......

Words: 2265 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Providian Trust

...Providian Trust (1) What key issues and challenges led to the initiation of the Access+ project? The key issues and challenges let to the initiation are as follows: * The Pension and Institutional Trust Services business had $42.7 billion in assets in 1994,which was the tenth-largest provider and they were losing money. They had outdated reporting systems as far as the clients were concerned. The institutional custody business was becoming extremely technology-intensive, with some of the larger players outsourcing their entire backroom function in order to make large operations more effective. * Internal process: The administrative functions were being done both by the front and back offices. There is an environment where everybody could point a finger at everybody else if something went wrong. The trust officers blamed the operations people and the operations people blamed the trust officers. * Intense client demand: (2) What organizational changes that the company should have made during the project to ensure the success of the Access+ project? * The front office of PITS and Personal Trust and the back office of Operation department which were responsible for handling, settlement, and record keeping for securities should made the changes during the project. * All existing trust information would be converted to the Access Plus system and the Operations group would become the primary caretakers of the data, taking over sole......

Words: 763 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


...   A/B Trusts An A/B Trust is any type of trust that splits into two separate and distinct trusts upon the death of the grantor. One of the separate and distinct trusts is a Credit Shelter Trust, which is designed to hold as much of the grantor's property as is sheltered from the federal estate tax by virtue of the unified credit; i.e., $2,000,000 for decedent's dying in years 2006, 2007, and 2008, and $3,500,000 for decedent's dying in the year 2009. The other separate and distinct trust is a Marital Trust, which is designed to hold the remainder of the decedent's property, which is sheltered from the federal estate tax by virtue of the unlimited marital deduction. These separate and distinct trusts are designed to eliminate or reduce the federal estate tax liability of a married couple over the deaths of both spouses. An A/B Trust arrangement can be created under a living trust or a testamentary trust, since these provisions do not take effect until after the grantor's death. See "Credit Shelter Trusts" and "Marital Trusts." See also "Family Trusts" and "By-Pass Trusts." Back to Table of Contents     Asset Protection Trusts An "Asset Protection Trust" is a type of trust that is designed to protect assets from the claims of creditors. There are two types of Asset Protection Trusts - a Domestic Asset Protection Trust (also known as an "Onshore Trust" or "DAPT") and a Foreign Asset Protection Trust (also known as an "Offshore Trust"). Both types of trusts are also......

Words: 3639 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Case Study: Trust Issues Glaxo Smith

...Trust Issues: A GlaxoSmithKline Scandal Kamelia D. Sutton Rasmussen College School of Business Management Trust issues a GlaxoSmithKline Scandal GlaxoSmithKline is a global manufacturer of pharmaceuticals, vaccines, and consumer healthcare. “GSK’s mission is to improve the quality of human life by enabling people to do more, feel better, live longer (GlaxoSmithKline, 2014).” According to GSK “prioritizing ethics and performing with integrity is a priority (GlaxoSmithKline, 2014).” GlaxoSmithKline’s research and development is the center of the organization. When research is conducted it is done so in an ethically high standard along with quality standards. Since GSK is a public organization they state they are transparent in their research regardless if the outcome of the research is positive or negative. From 1999 through 2010, GlaxoSmithKline was involved in a scheme to deceive and defraud physicians, patients, regulators, and federal health care programs such as Medicare to prescribe and receive payment for drugs such as Paxil, Wellbutrin SR, and Advair. When we are children we are taught that doctors and nurses are supposed to make us feel better. They are the ones that make all the “boo boo’s” go away. But, what happens when someone puts their trust in a doctor, nurse, or medical professional and that trust is destroyed because of greed, and unethical and socially irresponsible practices? One of the top three global vaccine manufacturers, GlaxoSmithKline......

Words: 896 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Concept of Trust

...Concept of Trust All human beings want a person they can talk to about important matters they don’t want public and someone they can rely on. People want someone who has strength they don’t have to help them. Some human being want to trust people some don’t and there are others who can trust many or only a certain few. But what causes someone to be able to trust people? How do you know you trust someone? How long can you trust someone and what can you trust them about? There are many factors to the concept of trust that make it what it is. Some people feel that they don’t trust people even though they just met just because of the way they act or the gestures they make. Do you really know you can trust someone from the way they move? In the article “Who’s Trustworthy? A Robot Can Help Teach Us” by Tara Parker-Pope there was a research experiment conducted using 86 undergraduate students. This experiment involved the students getting tokens and exchanging tokens with other people to get more but you had to work in pairs. The catch is you can take tokens from your partner and you don’t have to give them back and you can win more tokes then your partner. The point of this is to see if you can trust your partner or see if he/she would take it all and leave you dry and they filled out a survey to see if you trusted this person because of the way he acted or moved. Later on in the experiment the students where one by one sent to this robot to have a conversation. This robot made...

Words: 1325 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Wills, Trusts

...Wills, Trusts and Estate Planning Everyday many loved ones die without a Will in place and as a result, their affairs are left in limbo. Without a valid Will in place, your loved ones will be left to pick up the pieces, pay the unpaid bills and correspond and possibly litigate with creditors. There is a common misconception that a Will can or should only be created later in life. However, if you have assets eg. a house, savings, or a business, and people or others you would like to look after, you must consider making a will no matter your age. Thinking, talking & planning for death may feel uncomfortable. However, if you died or became incapacitated, through illness, accident, old age or emergency without sorting your affairs, this could wreak havoc on those you’ve left behind. Like Wills, another widely misunderstood concept is that of trusts. Trusts are often seen as something only the rich need to be concerned with. A trust is created when assets (which can include property, cash, shares etc) are transferred by a person (the settlor) to one or more persons (the trustees) with instructions that they are held for the benefit of others (the beneficiaries). A trust may be set up during a person’s lifetime and have immediate effect, in which case it is usually evidenced by a formal trust deed and commonly referred to as a settlement. Trusts play a key role in everyday life and can provide to be extremely useful depending on the intentions of the Settlor. A...

Words: 408 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Organizational Trust

...Building Organizational Trust Kirsimarja Blomqvist Telecom Business Research Center, Lappeenranta University of Technology and Sonera Research, P.O.BOX 20, 53851 LAPPEENRANTA, FINLAND e-mail:, mobile +358-40-755 1693 Pirjo Ståhle, Competence, Knowledge and Technology Management, Sonera Ltd, PL 116, 00051 SONERA, FINLAND e-mail: ABSTRACT In this paper we study the role of trust in enhancing asymmetric partnership formation. First we briefly review the role of trust. Then we analyze the state-of-the-art of the theoretical and empirical literature on trust creation and antecedents for experienced trustworthiness. As a result of the literature review and our knowledge of the context in praxis, we create a model on organizational trust building where the interplay of inter-organizational and inter-personal trust is scrutinized. Potential challenges for our model are first the asymmetry of organizations and actors and secondly the volatility of the business. The opportunity window for partnering firms may be very short i.e. there is not much time for natural development of trust based on incremental investments and social or character similarity, but so called “fast” or “swift” trust is needed. As a managerial contribution we suggest some practices and processes, which could be used for organizational trust building. These are developed from the viewpoint of large organization boundary-spanners (partner/vendor managers)......

Words: 7325 - Pages: 30

Premium Essay

Providian Trust Case

... PROVIDIAN TRUST: TRADITION AND TECHNOLOGY (A) Fenway Cohort Kamanasish Kundu 1. Business Context/Key Business Drivers * In 1994, Providian Trust, the tenth largest provider of financial and fiduciary services, slowly slipped away from profitability and competition due to the lack of efficient business processes and information technology. * The company was headquartered in New York and had three divisions Pension and Institutional Trust Services (PITS), Personal Trust and Trust Operations with a network of 216 branches. * To address the problems that Providian Trust were facing, Michael LeBlanc, the Senior Vice President of Trust, Investment and Treasury, took the initiative to lead the project aimed at not only implementing new technology but also reengineering Providian Trust’s business processes by implementing a major software system, Access plus, developed by Select One. The project, supposed to last for 20 months, cost $18 million, was finally approved by board members in April, 1994. * The key driver behind the above initiative was intense client demand on the part of PITS division, lack of control and discipline in the trust division, lack of operation efficiency and outdated reporting system. 2. Initiative Objectives/Benefits * Decrease the cycle time and improve operation efficiency. As stated in the case, the clients......

Words: 986 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Case 6.1: the Greater Providence Deposit & Trust Embezzlement

...Assignment # 1 Case 6.1 The Greater Providence Deposit & Trust Embezzlement Accounting Information Systems – ACC 564 Professor Jim Ridilla October 23, 2011 Discuss how Greater Providence Deposit & Trust might improve its control procedures over the disbursement of loan funds to minimize the risk of this type of fraud. Segregation of duties is a fundamental element of internal control in any company. No single employee should be given too much responsibility over certain business transactions or processes. When one person in an organization has too much control or access over these responsibilities, problems can and often do arise. In the case of The Greater Providence Deposit & Trust, James Guisti was a manager and trusted employee. Mr. Guisti’s job required him to know the details and intricacies involved in the operation of processing consumer loans. Adequate segregation of duties were not put into place at the Bank, creating a scenario that allowed Mr. Giusti to use his knowledge to embezzle close to $2 million from his employer. Mr. Giusti was authorized to make consumer loans up to a certain dollar limit without loan committee approvals. He then used his position of authority over the customer service representative, Lucy Farioli, to have her co-sign loan checks that were, unbeknownst to her, bogus. Mr. Giusti should have been required to have a member of upper management, not Ms. Fraioli, co-sign the checks. Backup documentation......

Words: 1147 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Trust Mechanisms

...Trust In Semantic Web Muhammad Arslan Shafiq (081212) Department of Computer Science SZABIST Islamabad, Pakistan _______________________________________________ _______________________________________________ Abstract—Trust management is important in semantic web in order to achieve the goals of semantic web vision. In this paper two approaches of implementing trust have been discussed. One approach is strong and secure i.e. Policy based systems, the other approach is more of a social approach which takes feedback from the users in order to build and maintain trust. Also discussed in this paper are pros and cons of both the techniques. Keywords-component; semantic web;Trust; Policy Based Systen; Reputation Based Sytems Introduction The idea behind semantic web seems great and offers a lot but why one should trust in semantic web. Who would trust such a system where anyone can say anything. We say that it is going to be a smart web, it will be intelligent and it will know the semantics. It will know what we are looking for. But what happens when a person says that x is yellow and another person says x is not yellow. Would semantic web fall apart? The idea behind SW is its authenticity of information which isn’t available in today’s web. Information comes from different sources which could be wrong or write and for a specific situation. So how are we going to determine which is reliable and whom should we believe? To tackle......

Words: 3887 - Pages: 16