Free Essay

Case Reaction to Japanese Management Styles

In: Business and Management

Submitted By agentbay
Words 1576
Pages 7
Tiffin University


Submitted for
MGT 505 (Section 91)
Fundamentals of Business Enterprise
Dr. Perry Haan, Professor of Marketing

Michael Bond
Ypsilanti, Mich.
September 25, 2011

The Effectiveness of Japanese Styles of Management

Introduction The article was a review and critique of the effectiveness of Japanese styles of management. Through case studies, three main research questions emerged: 1. What are the distinctive qualities of Japanese work organizations? 2. What happens to these qualities when Japanese organizations are established in western countries? 3. Are there ‘universal’ effects of particular forms of organization, or is it more the case that what is required at one place or time would not have the same effect at another place or time?

Points of Agreement • The difference between the western viewpoint of Japanese society and the Japanese management style. (Smith, 1984, p. 123, col 1, par 1). Western society, mainly writers and movies, have presented Japan as a conformist society. The movie, Gung Ho (1986, Paramount Pictures) is about a Japanese auto company taking over an American auto company. The Japanese management is shown as working as a unit and not trying to rock the boat. They also lower salaries and try to get everyone trained on every job as to conform. A study by Klauss & Bass (1974) studied group decision making by managers in 13 countries (Smith, 1984, p. 123, col 1, par 1). Japanese managers showed the highest amount of high individualism and anti-conformity. They were more likely not to be influenced by the group and were willing to go in a direction not recommended by the group. The results of the study were very surprising for me based on the aforementioned points. I’ve always view Japan as a country that valued conformity more than anything else • Japanese blue-collar workers are no more satisfied and possible less satisfied with their jobs then Western workers (Odaka, 1975; Azumie & McMillan, 1976; Cole, 1979) (Smith, 1984, p. 122, col 1, par 1). I feel that this is due to the differences between Japanese and Western viewpoints on their jobs. In the western world, we are satisfied with coming in, working 9-5 and leaving the job at the work place. We tend to view our job as a source of income and something we have to do. We have an attitude of settling. There is more of an emphasis on how much you can accomplish than there is on quality. We still care about quality as long as it is done quickly. In terms of management positions, the most qualified person is not always hired. In Japan, the workers take pride in their job. They see the workplace as an extension of themselves. How they conduct themselves at home is how they want to be at work. They are an equal concern for quantity and quality. They are expecting themselves and their company to make mass quality goods and services. When you compare these viewpoints, it’s easy to see where the Japanese could become frustrated. That frustration would come when they felt the company was not living up their expectations. They would also see that as negative mark on their character.

• Japanese managers more willing to spend on product quality and less willing to spend on pollution control (Smith, 1984, p. 130, col 1, par 4). I agree with the conclusions of the report of Bass & Burger (1979) (Smith, 1984, p. 130, col 1, par 4). As I stated in the points of agreement, Japanese workers are very committed to produce a quality product. So, in terms of budgeting, that would be a high priority for the managers. There are apparently contradictory attitudes toward nature and air pollution in modern Japan. ( Japan is well known for their cherry trees, efforts to maintain and improve their parks and their society feels that they are more sensitive and in tune with nature than the rest of the world. Japan is also well known for taking advantage of the environment and the natural world to meet human needs and the demands of labor. At times, Mount Fuji, outside Tokyo, was completely obscured by smog. A chemical company in Minimata dumped chemical waste into the bay. The end result was nearly 2300 cases of mercury poising (

Points of Disagreement

• Japanese managers score highest on belief in participation in decision making by subordinates (Smith, 1984, p. 130, col 1, par 4). This conclusion was reach by Haire et al. (1966) (Smith, 1984, p. 130, col 1, par 4). As stated in one of my points of agreement, Japanese managers would not be influenced by a group decision. That would lead people to think well if a group made suggestions, then the Haire conclusion would be valid. I disagree with that line of thinking on the basis of wording. To me, decision making refers to the person or person who actually makes the decision. Employees can be involved in offering input or making suggestions, but they aren’t the ones making the final decision. For example, my boss is trying to decide whether to redesign the Tiffin Athletic website. He will call me in, get my thoughts on the matters, and ask me how we can improve it. A few days later, he will make the decision whether we redesign it or not. I’m not involved in the actual making of the decision.

• Japanese respondents had a strong motivation to please the researchers (Smith, 1984, p. 125, col 1, par 3) This was the reasoning by Haire et al. (1966) Smith, 1984, p. 125, col 1, par 3) to explain their surprise by their findings. Going back to what was stated in one of my points of agreement; this statement does not hold water. Japan is not a conformist society and it does not make sense that they would feel that motivation to please the researcher’s. • Preference of vertical differentiation and horizontal differentiation (Smith, 1984, p. 128, col 1, par 1). Lincoln et al. (1978) (Smith, 1984, p. 128, col 1, par 1) hypothesized that Japanese workers and managers would prefer organizations with a maximum amount of vertical differentiation and minimal horizontal differentiation while Americans would prefer the opposite. Vertical differentiation is where there are several goods that can be ordered in an objective way, basically along one decisive feature. Horizontal differentiation is when goods cannot be ordered in an objective manner due to many different variables, I.E. ice cream cones. Based on my earlier assessment of the Japanese and American workers, the opposite is true. The Japanese would be more concerned with the bigger picture. They would want to take everything in and make the decision that is best for the company. The Americans would be focused on what is right in front of them. They would prefer fewer choices because they could make their decision quicker and then move on to the next thing.

Application of information to worldly views The recalls at Toyota were a big eye-opener for many consumers. The case studies in the article presented Japanese management and workers caring about the product. Toyota comes out and admits mistakes were made and they are taking care of it. Then several months later, more cars are recalled and you got insight to the company caring about quality.

Integration of information with materials or concepts from the text As a whole, Chapter 6 Management (Dias, Shah, 2009, pg. 174-206) is a good guideline to what the article is discussing. The chapter tells you what management is, the functions, and the levels of management among other items. I reread the chapter after reading the article which gave me a better understanding of what was being discussed. In particular, I could see Theory X, Y and Z (Dias, Shah, 2009, pg. 196-199) in what was being said in the article. By going back and looking at each of the theories, then applying them to the article, I could see what they were talking about.

Points of Interest This was an interesting paper to write as I had problems at times understanding the language of the article. There were some valid points made about the Japanese management style. However, no one style is the end to beat all. The one issue I wish had been covered more was the cross-cultural study of managerial effectiveness.

New Questions Sparked 1. There were a lot of words that I had to look up in order to understand what was being discussed. Is there a way to write the review and critique in a more understandable format? 2. How would the Japanese management style need to be adjusted to work in the United States? 3. The article mentions vertical and horizontal differentiation. What are they and how do they affect worker morale? 4. What are the criteria for being an effective manager?
Reference List
Smith, P.B. (1984). The effectiveness of Japanese styles of management: A review and critique, Journal of Occupational Psychology, 121-136

Dias, L. & Shah, A. (2009). Business in Global Markets, Introduction to Business, Chapter 6, 174-206.

Tsutsui, W. (5/15/09). Nature and the Environment in Postwar Japan. Retrieved from (

Minamata Disease The History and Measures (n.d.) Retrieved from (

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Japanese Companies in Germany- a Case Study in Cross-Cultural Management

...Japanese Companies in Germany: A Case Study in Cross-Cultural Management JAMES R. LINCOLN, HAROLD R. KERBO, and ELKE WITT'ENHAGEN* From a series of qualitative interviews with Japanese managers and German managers and workers in thirty-one Japanese-owned companies in the Dusseldorf region of western Germany, this article discusses differences in cultural patterns and organizational styles between the German and Japanese employees and the problems these pose for communication, cooperation, and morale. First, we deal with cultural contrasts: language issues, interpersonal styles (personability and politeness), and norms regarding the taking of responsibility. Second, we examine the impact on cross-nationality relations of established organizational practice: for example, German specialism vs. Japanese generalism; direct and vertical vs. indirect and incremental decision making. We also discuss efforts by these firms to find compromise systems that would meet the needs and interests of both sides. The third focus is the reactions of Japanese companies in North Rhine-Westphalia to German unions, works councils, and codetermination regulations. In the labor view, Japanese firms overall do no better or worse than comparable German firms. Japanese direct investment in Western economies is concentrated in North America and the United Kingdom. In consequence, a rich journalistic and scholarly literature examines the Japanese experience in the Anglo-American countries, the......

Words: 10081 - Pages: 41

Premium Essay

Japanese Management

...Introduction The culture of Japanese management so famous in the West is generally limited to Japan's large corporations. These flagships of the Japanese economy provide their workers with excellent salaries and working conditions and secure employment. These companies and their employees are the business elite of Japan. A career with such a company was the dream of many young people in Japan, but only a select few attain these jobs. Qualification for employment is limited to the men and the few women who graduate from the top thirty colleges and universities in Japan. Placement and advancement of Japanese workers is heavily based on educational background. Students who do not gain admission to the most highly rated colleges only rarely have the chance to work for a large company. Instead, they have to seek positions in small and medium-sized firms that can not offer comparable benefits and prestige. The quality of one's education and, more important, the college attended, play decisive roles in a person's career. Few Japanese attend graduate school, and graduate training in business per se is rare. There are only a few business school programs in Japan. Companies provide their own training and show a strong preference for young men who can be trained in the company way. Interest in a person whose attitudes and work habits are shaped outside the company is low. When young men are preparing to graduate from college, they begin the search for a suitable employer. This......

Words: 991 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Scientific Management Styles with Modern Management Styles

...TOPIC# Compare and contrast scientific management styles with modern management styles Word Count: 1092 words Velko D Savov October 4, 2006 Table of Contents Introduction Management hypothesis………………………………………………....3 Defining of aims in past and present management styles…………….....3 Criticism of theories …………………………………………………..3 Similarities of theories ………………………………………………....3 Past theories applied in present days……………………………………3 Factors leading to a change……………………………………………..3 Past management theories used in present time………………………...3 Theory of past and present management styles………………………..4 Comparison of theories……………………… ………………………..4 Conclusion……………………………………………........5 Bibliography…………………………………………...........6 Velko D Savov October 4, 2006 Throughout this essay, I will be putting emphasis among the different theories from the different scientific and modern management styles. A clear comparison and distinguishment will be contrasted. It will be based upon past and present management hypothesis. Throughout the expansion of scientific management, the main aims were to achieve a developed approach were studies of work and their improvement could have been done. Past theories were strongly focused on the human......

Words: 1439 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Management Styles

...Leadership Styles and Management: A Look into Different Styles and Theories Jamie McCreery Fort Hays State University Abstract Different leadership and management styles affect and motivate individuals differently and directly impact successfully achieving organizational goals within the group. This paper discusses the different styles seen as well as the theories, characteristics and pros/cons of each style and theory. Keywords:leadership style and theory, management What is leadership? Leadership has been described as "a process of social influence in which one person can enlist the aid and support of others in the accomplishment of a common task" (Wikipedia, 2014). Leadership skills are considered to be of highest importance when looking for quality management personnel (Wolniak, 2011). By employing managers who are successful in influencing and motivating staff companies are successful in achieving objectives defined by the organization (Taleghani, Salmani, Taatian, 2010). Varying countries, cultures, conditions, and expectations all weigh heavily on the success of individual groups (Taleghani, Salmani, Taatian, 2010). Leadership and motivation styles vary from person to person, that is why it is essential for managers to know and understand their leadership style and how their particular leadership affects their workplace. Leadership is influenced by many things that is......

Words: 1611 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

The Existence of an International Management Style

...International Management deals with the maintenance and development of a multinational operation across national borders, whose manager has the knowledge and the skills to manage and handle cross-cultural processes, stakeholders and environments in a right way. In my opinion , an international management style is created and developed. International businesses are conducting themselves on common ground in order to compete globally. They don't necessarily do business the same way ,with identical processes, functions, and operations while approaching this elevated stage; but by the time they attain it, successful companies do share certain qualities and practices. Firstly, this kind of style is created, as we all know multinationals that are conducted after international standards and expectations. John Quelch describes this style as an amalgam, built atop a U.S. model that has borrowed freely from others around the world. He characterizes the U.S. model of management as focused on immediate outcomes and results and generally accustomed to having its way. But it has an added feature that enables it to remain powerful even as it is transformed. A prime example is America's absorption of Japanese manufacturing techniques in the 1980s." Over time, with this kind of ongoing cross-pollination, today's system of global management, to the extent it can still be called American, will look less like it used to and more like something "multinational." Secondly, international......

Words: 650 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Case Reaction Paper

...The globalization of businesses has become very common today, when compared to the past. Companies have started branching out to different countries in order to expand their business using the advanced technology - the Internet. Understanding their respective culture is very crucial to develop an establishment in any country. The working style and method varies from country to country based on their culture. There is always a scope of conflicts due to culture variations. The article “Impact of cultural intelligence level on conflict resolution ability” talks about the importance of cultural intelligence level and how this helps to resolve the conflicts. “Therefore, this model presents that a higher level of cultural intelligence positively affects and predicts whether an individual will select an appropriate conflict resolution strategy fitting for the cultural backgrounds of those involved in the conflict” (Ramirez, 2010, p. 2). The author starts off with briefly discussing why it is so important for the business leaders to use different conflict resolution strategies using the cultural intelligence level of the persons involved in the conflict. The author first described the gaps in the current studies of “impact of culture intelligence level in resolving the conflicts” and then explained how the current model would fulfill those gaps. This model helps leaders to prepare different strategies and to use the correct strategy based on the cultural intelligence level of...

Words: 1297 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Japanese Management

...Japanese Management Style 505 Fundamentals of Business Enterprise   Japanese Management Style: Still Relevant Today? Cultural norms and business practices vary throughout the world. It would be foolish for an American businessman to travel to Africa or Asia and believe that the manner in which they conduct business in the States will translate effectively to interactions with their foreign counterparts. Peter Smith’s 1984 article titled, “The effectiveness of Japanese styles of management: A review and critique,” details the similarities and differences between the accepted management styles in America and Japan. The impetus behind the article concerned the growing number of American subsidiaries in Japan. Smith attempts to analyze the distinctive qualities of Japanese work organizations, whether there are consistent or universal themes across all Japanese organizations, and what tends to happen when the distinctive qualities in Japanese business come into contact with Western business practices. As a result, there are several interesting lessons provided within this article that managers from all corners of the world can learn from. Japanese work organizations are structured In terms of exhibit rigid hierarchical organizational structure. Nonetheless, while organizations in Japan are less functionally specialized, the Japanese stress the collective unit rather than individual responsibility, as reported by Yoshino in 1975 when he discusses the ringi method that...

Words: 295 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Case Study Japanese Earthquake

... Yixin Gao Case Analysis #1 Sep 21 Supply Chain Lessons from Catastrophic Natural Disaster in Japan Supply chain management refers to the management of the flow of goods and services from the suppliers to the producers then to the consumers. The supply chain can however get hit by natural, economic or even humanitarian system disruption. In case of this event of disaster strike, companies have to come up with supply chain risk management to prevent their businesses from collapsing. With case study on some Japanese companies, this paper gives an analysis of how these manufacturing firms responded to Japan’s recent disaster strike, the earthquake, tsunami and nuclear disaster. Japan’s recent earthquake attack of 8.9-magnitude on its northeast coast was a devastating one. The tsunami which shortly followed the earthquake made everything even more severe. This led to destruction of property and loss of lives (Park et al., 75). Many were also forced to evacuate their homes as the earthquake and tsunami destroyed thousands of homes, leaving about 550,000 people homeless. The number of deaths was very high, exceeding 86,000, with 13,000 missing. Altogether, this was one of the most costly disasters caused by earthquake and tsunami, registering damage cost of about 235 billion dollars (Park et al., 75). The damages caused by these two natural disasters in Japan disrupted the supply chain, both globally and domestically. As a result, the disruptions caused negative impacts on...

Words: 1181 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Carlos Ghosn’s Management Style

...I-Carlos Ghosn’s Management Style Carlos Ghosn, clearly an extraordinary man with an impressive list of accomplishments already under his belt at a relatively young age. But what is it exactly about his management style that makes him stand-out from other leaders, why is it that so much attention has been showered onto him? In the first part of this report that is exactly what we will try to uncover. Ghosn truly does have a unique management style, one that is perfectly suited to today’s global economic reality. In our view the following management practices are the ones that have been integral to the success of not only Ghosn’s turnaround of Nissan but also in his previous accomplishments at Michelin and Renault: Adaptability What really strikes you as you read and learn more and more about Ghosn is that he truly does not have any preconceptions or stereotypes. Whether he is facing a new and unknown country and culture or a situation within a company, Ghosn’s approach is what he calls “a clean sheet of paper.” What Ghosn has been able to do so well is transcend what Peter M. Senge describes as “Mental Models” in his article The Fifth Discipline: The Art & Practice of the Learning Organization. As we have seen in the Senge’s article whenever you limit yourself to your Mental Models you reduce you ability to react effectively to changes in the environment. Senge uses the example of oil companies unable to effectively deal with changes in market......

Words: 2626 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Management Style

...As you may know, different management styles are required in different parts of the world. It is important to choose the right management style for each situation, which is a key to success for an organization. All managers use a management process which consists of planning, organizing, leading and controlling. So they have to perform many roles in an enterprise. What they can do with various situations will totally depend on their style of management. A management style is an overall method of leadership used by a manager (Lessem et al, 1999). This essay will first demonstrate different types of management styles, and then discuss three key factors that can influence management style, with reference to Japan and America. Each of the management style below has its unique features and if they will be well understood and used, they can give scope to maximum effect in the specific field. In daily management, there are usually four management styles. The first is autocratic management style (Wallace et al, 1988) which also called instructive management style. In instructive management style, managers give instructions to the subordinates or teams about what to do, how to do, when to do in every possible way without getting any opinion or suggestion. The management behavior module is: I come to decide what you would do. It might save time when making decisions, but it could lessen the motivation of the staff. Autocratic management style may be suitable in circumstances when a......

Words: 1293 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Management Styles Throughout the World

...Running head: MANAGEMENT STYLES THROUGHOUT THE WORLD Management Styles throughout the World Tambra Sullivan Minot State University – BADM 535 Abstract A management style is a leadership method used by a manager. As diverse as cultures are throughout the world, so are management styles. A key value underlying the American business system is reflected in the notion of a never ending quest for improvement. The prevailing question is can it be done better? (Roa, 2010). In other cultures, the strength and power of those in command rest on the premise that the status quo demands stable structure. (Roa, 2010). Researchers debate whether it is organizational or ethnic culture that is predominant. In today’s business environment, Globalization requires different cultures with contrasting management style to work together. This paper will explore management styles throughout the world and analyze their effectiveness. Management Styles throughout the World Management styles are characteristic ways to make decisions and relate to subordinates. The culture of a business may affect the type of management styles that are acceptable to utilize, as well as the nature of the task, the nature of the workforce and the personality and skill set of the leaders. There are an abundance of management styles throughout the world. Management styles in many parts of the world are consistent with their culture. For example, hierarchy societies tend to foster a......

Words: 3992 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Management Style

...Management Style HCS/325 April 4, 2016 Lisa Jones Management Style Every manager has a unique management style when it comes to handling employees. Managers play a major role in building a bond between employees. Using a management style, managers can formulate strategies to ensure all employees come together as a single unit. It is ultimately the manager’s responsibility to make sure that employees are content with their job obligations to ensure self-fulfillment and a stress free workplace. Managers must understand the employees and must fight hard to fulfill his or her expectations. What is Management? Management can be defined as the act of getting individuals to work together to accomplish goals and objectives utilizing obtainable resources effectively and efficiently. Management is the driving force of the business. In today’s society, businesses are highly competitive and rely on an effective, efficient, competent, and capable manager to bring success to the organization. It is through management that company activities are well organized and carried out effectively. Without a constant flow of managers to guide organizations, society would not improve or exist from a professional stand point. Establishing managerial and employee communication is key. This ensures efficiency in the workplace. Good and Poor Qualities of a Manager There is a variety of qualities that determine if a manager is good or bad at his or her job. There are......

Words: 593 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Bankruptcy Prediction the Case of Japanese

...Rev Account Stud (2009) 14:534–558 DOI 10.1007/s11142-008-9080-5 Bankruptcy prediction: the case of Japanese listed companies Ming Xu Æ Chu Zhang Published online: 26 July 2008 Ó Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2008 Abstract This paper investigates if bankruptcy of Japanese listed companies can be predicted using data from 1992 to 2005. We find that the traditional measures, such as Altman’s (J Finance 23:589–609, 1968) Z-score, Ohlson’s (J Accounting Res 18:109–131, 1980) O-score and the option pricing theory-based distance-todefault, previously developed for the U.S. market, are also individually useful for the Japanese market. Moreover, the predictive power is substantially enhanced when these measures are combined. Based on the unique Japanese institutional features of main banks and business groups (known as Keiretsu), we construct a new measure that incorporates bank dependence and Keiretsu dependence. The new measure further improves the ability to predict bankruptcy of Japanese listed companies. Keywords Bankruptcy risk measure Á Accounting information Á Option pricing theory Á Japanese listed companies Á Bank dependence Á Keiretsu JEL Classifications G15 Á G33 1 Introduction When a company falls into bankruptcy, its stakeholders lose some or all the value they invested in the company. From an investor’s point of view, it is important to M. Xu (&) School of Accounting and Finance, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Kowloon, Hong Kong, China e-mail:...

Words: 13066 - Pages: 53

Premium Essay

Management Styles: American Vis-a-Vis Japanese

...Japan and the U.S. share a low-growth economy configeration and their management styles are beginning to merge. Management Styles: American vis-a-vis Japanese Charles Y. Yang THE JAPANESE STYLE of management has in recent vears been drawing a great deal of attention from American managers because of its apparent ability to insure organization stability in the face of unexpected external changes. At the same time, a slower rate of economic growth in Japan is compelling Japanese executives to .search for improvement iu management efficiency by focusing their attention on the American type of management. FALL 1977 This trend to draw on each other's strengths in order to better cope with growing external pressures is significant because both eountries now share a similar socio-economic situation characterized by a low rate of economic growth, a high degree of vulnerability to external variations and an advanced stage of technological development. A comparative analysis of the quality of management must first determine what is to be measured. 23 If the criterion is profit performance, most of the major Japanese companies compare favorably with leading American firms, and that is where the comparison ends. What is more meaningful is to measure the extent to which the underlying factors have contributed to profit perfonnance in the past, and how they will continue to function in the new socio-economic setting. These underlying factors consist of......

Words: 4413 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Japanese Management Style

...Japanese Management Style 505 Fundamentals of Business Enterprise   Japanese Management Style: Still Relevant Today? Cultural norms and business practices vary throughout the world. It would be foolish for an American businessman to travel to Africa or Asia and believe that the manner in which they conduct business in the States will translate effectively to interactions with their foreign counterparts. Peter Smith’s 1984 article titled, “The effectiveness of Japanese styles of management: A review and critique,” details the similarities and differences between the accepted management styles in America and Japan. The impetus behind the article concerned the growing number of American subsidiaries in Japan. Smith attempts to analyze the distinctive qualities of Japanese work organizations, whether there are consistent or universal themes across all Japanese organizations, and what tends to happen when the distinctive qualities in Japanese business come into contact with Western business practices. As a result, there are several interesting lessons provided within this article that managers from all corners of the world can learn from. Japanese work organizations are structured In terms of exhibit rigid hierarchical organizational structure. Nonetheless, while organizations in Japan are less functionally specialized, the Japanese stress the collective unit rather than individual responsibility, as reported by Yoshino in 1975 when he discusses the ringi method......

Words: 1159 - Pages: 5