Free Essay

Case Study in Unfair Labor Practice

In: Business and Management

Submitted By gingersnap
Words 1330
Pages 6
Case Study in Unfair Labor Practice
Labor unions have been in decline over the last few decades. However, labor unions in the healthcare industry have been in the news recently, in particular, large and well-funded nursing unions. Sanders and McCutcheon (2010) point out that there is a sense of urgency among nursing unions in large numbers and that nurses in these unions aren’t just concerned about wages, hours and benefits, but patient care and nurse patient ratios. This issue is a key factor in the 2013 case of New York State Nurses Associations v. Olean General Hospital. In this case, the union, the New York State Nurses Association (NYSNA) filed a complaint that Olean General Hospital (OGH) had violated Section 8(a)(1) in the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) which is the interference with employees’ Section 7 rights and Section 8(a)(5), failure to engage in good faith collective bargaining duty with certified unions. This paper will look at the case, the National Labor Relations Board’s (NLRB) decision and why it had merit.
New York State Nurses Association v. Olean General Hospital
In 2013 NYSNA filed charges against OGH alleging that the hospital had violated Sections 8(a)(1) and (5) by implementing the Dedicated Education Unit (DEU), a program where nurses in the bargaining unit acted as clinical teachers for Alfred State University. The main issue with the program was that the union believed it was significantly different than other programs the hospital had with other nursing school programs and therefore required notice and the opportunity with the union. The union requested more information regarding the program including whom the bargaining unit nurses would receive orders from, the type of training they would be provided and the weekly expectations of the bargaining unit nurses. The hospital refused to provide specific information about the program and the union only learned the details of the program after a nurse in the bargaining unit provided a copy of the letter from Alfred State University with details of the program. The letter explained that the nurses selected would be an Alfred State representative as well as an employee of OGH. Additionally, the selected would be required to attend a mandatory orientation. Seven RNs in the bargaining unit were selected and were supposed to be with their students for 36 hours every two week pay period and received $1,000 from Alfred State in addition to the wages. The union argued that while the hospital had other agreements that were not negotiated by the union, the DEU was different because the RNs were required to sign agreements, were paid by the school, and were required to attend training by the school. The second part of the complaint involved a Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO) unannounced survey where 40-43 deficiencies were found involving patient care. NYSNA had requested a copy of the report and received a reply from the hospital VP that their request had been referred to hospital attorneys and provided no further response. The hospital argued that they did not need to provide a copy of the report to the union because it was not relevant to union responsibilities.
NRLB Findings and Decision The NLRB found that the DEU program was sufficiently different from other arrangements made between the hospital and nursing schools. Thus the hospital was obligated to provide the union with prior notice and the opportunity to bargain over the implementation of the program. The NLRB also disagreed with the hospital regarding the JCAHO report and argued that it was relevant to the Union’s responsibilities since the deficiencies may be related to staffing issues which had been a major issue in ongoing contract negotiations. Therefore, the NLRB decided that union was entitled to the JCAHO report and a list of the deficiencies found in the survey. The NLRB determined that by failing to notify the union about the DEU program in a timely manner and provide it the chance to bargain about the decision, OGH violated 8(a)(1) and (5) because the program was not part of the collective bargaining agreement. Additionally, OGH violated 8(a)(1) and (5) by refusing to bargain in good faith with the union by not providing the union with relevant information it requested regarding the DEU and the JCAHO survey. The NLRB ordered that OGH cease and desist from these actions as well as furnish the additional information the union had requested and allow the union to bargain. Finally, OGH was required to post a notice throughout the hospital stating that the NLRB found the hospital had violated labor law.
Analysis and Merit of NYSNA v. OGH
Clearly the case NYSNA had against OGH had merit. To understand the reasoning behind filing the complaint, it is important to understand at the negotiations that were going on between NYSNA and OGH at that time. This section will look at the events involved with the negotiations, why the case against OGH had merit, and the effects the decision had on the workplace. The DEU program violated Section 8(a)(5) because the hospital had taken unilateral action on a matter subject to bargaining. Kubasek, Brennan and Browne (2012) point out that giving employees a raise or additional benefits during the term of collective bargaining without first consulting with the union is an example of this because the behavior would have the effect of undermining the union as a bargaining representative and is therefore unlawful. When the DEU was implemented, OGH and NYSNA were in the middle of ongoing and lengthy contract negotiations.
Additionally, one of the main issues involved in the negotiations was staffing levels. When negotiations broke down, NYSNA engaged in a public awareness campaign that called for improved staffing levels at OGH. The union maintained that the number of nurses working at the hospital were too low, forcing nurses to care for more patients than they could safely handle and sometimes nurses had to work in units they not been properly trained to work in (Michel, 2014). Thus, it was appropriate for the union to request a copy of the JCAHO report and survey results to see if the deficiencies were due to staffing issues, a major issue that caused the impasse in reaching a new contract.
While the decision made by the NLRB was in favor of the union, determining that the hospital was in violation of Section 8a(1) and (5), it ultimately helped rather than harm the business environment. Christopher Michel (2014) reported that after 17 months of negotiations and an impasse, the hospital and union came to terms on a new five year contract that focuses on safe staffing guidelines including the amount of staff and what kind of staff needs to be in each unit. Additionally advanced training and certifications for nurses will be provided as well as tuition reimbursement for RNs that want to pursue a higher degree.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the NLRB made the right decision when ruling in favor of NYSNA and finding OGH in violation of Section 8a(1) and (5). By not allowing the union to review the DEU or the JHACO report and survey, the hospital had violated the sections and participated in unfair labor practices. However the decision ultimately helped the nurses in collective bargaining process which lead towards better staffing of nurses in the new five year contract. Ultimately, this will help, not harm the business environment at OGH.
References
Kubasek, N., Brennan, B. & Browne, M. (2012). The legal environment of business: A critical thinking approach (6th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, Inc.
Michel, C. (2014). OGH, nurses’ union agree on new contract. Olean Times Herald. Retrieved from: http://www.oleantimesherald.com/news/here_and_now/article_7c21f870-c639-11e3-b82c-001a4bcf887a.html
New York State Nurses Association v. Olean General Hospital, 03-CA-097918 (2013).
Sanders, G. and McCutcheon, A. (2010). Unions in the healthcare industry. Labor Law Journal, 61(3), 142-151.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Advantages of Walmart Working with Unions

...Wal-Mart being such a large retailer and employer in the United States could potentially revolutionize as well as revitalize the union movement if it would work more closely with it instead of closing stores who speak of unionizing. The disadvantages to Wal-Mart of working with the Unions can include- Higher wages- our text book states that it is common to find 30% higher wages in union businesses. Medical Benefits- Most unions push for medical benefits for its members Loss of the Sam Walton way- By allowing Unions to enter into the Wal-Mart business model the concept of how Wal-Mart does business could change dramatically. Wal-Mart is accustomed to being the Big Dog. They are able to tell suppliers and vendors to change their practices if they want to continue to supply Wal-Mart. If Wal-Mart becomes unionized they may lose some of that Big Dog way if the supplier they are dealing with is also a member of the same union- (grocers or teamsters) 2. Explain the advantages and disadvantages of union membership from the employee perspective. Advantages of a Union Membership for employees normally include...

Words: 1077 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Term Paper

...discrimination in the workplace. You also study regulatory compliance issues for an organization, as well as the associated business consequences. The readings focus on workers’ compensation, occupational safety, and other worker protection laws, with a specific attention to the Family and Medical Leave Act. This week also covers the collective bargaining agreements and labor law, as well as several laws and decisions a company must make regarding these labor law issues. In addition, you examine equal opportunity in employment and Title VII, including what comprises this significant law. You review regulatory laws, environmental protection and global warning, as well as antitrust laws and unfair trade practices. The readings focus on introductory concepts and the laws that support these concepts. Employment and Regulatory Risk OBJECTIVE: Differentiate between types of employment relationships and the associated legal considerations. Resources: Ch. 31 & 32 of Business Law: Legal Environment, Online Commerce, Business Ethics, and International Issues Content • Ch. 31: Employment, Worker Protection, and Immigration Laws o Introduction to Employment, Worker Protection, and Immigration Laws o Worker’s Compensation • Case 31.1 Workers’ Compensation: Medrano v. Marshall Electrical Contracting Inc. o Occupational Safety • Ethics Spotlight: Company Violates OSHA’s Safety Rule o Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) ...

Words: 971 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Illegal Immigrants and the Nlra

...[Type the company name] | Illegal Immigrants and The NLRA: | Protection for All? | | | | What rights are illegal immigrants afforded under the National Labor Relations Act? | This paper seeks to investigate whether or not illegal immigrants should be protected under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA). An illegal immigrant (alien) is anyone who is foreign borne and has entered the United States of American without examination or admitted provisionally and stayed past the time they are required to leave (http://cis.org/illegal). Once reading this definition, as outlined by the Center for Immigration Studies; precisely one would say no, he or she is here illegally. We will first question why individuals have entered the country illegally, their reason for being here, employer responsibly, the Immigration Reform and Control Act and how or why should illegal workers be protected under the NLRA. Illegal aliens accounted for 21% of the foreign born population in the U.S in 2000 with that number increasing to 28% by 2005. With numbers steadily increasing each year, many have begun asking why. Where are the immigrants coming from and why are so many entering into the United States? Statistics show that Mexico is the biggest importer of legal and illegal immigrants (http://cis.org/illegal). More than half of the Mexicans living in the U.S. in the year 2000 were illegal (Edwards, 2000). By 2004, 10.5 million legal and illegal Mexican immigrants were living in...

Words: 3310 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Articles

...Scholarship Repository University of Minnesota Law School Articles Faculty Scholarship 1988 Discovery in Labor Arbitration Laura J. Cooper University of Minnesota Law School, lcooper@umn.edu Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarship.law.umn.edu/faculty_articles Part of the Law Commons Recommended Citation Laura J. Cooper, Discovery in Labor Arbitration, 72 Minn. L. Rev. 1281 (1988), available at http://scholarship.law.umn.edu/ faculty_articles/307. This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the University of Minnesota Law School. It has been accepted for inclusion in the Faculty Scholarship collection by an authorized administrator of the Scholarship Repository. For more information, please contact lenzx009@umn.edu. Discovery in Labor Arbitration Laura J.Cooper* The mere statement of the topic, discovery in labor arbitration, suggests a paradox. Is not the essence of the arbitration process an effort to avoid the procedural complexities that make litigation comparatively slow and costly? More than forty years ago, Learned Hand admonished a litigant distressed with the procedural failings of an arbitration proceeding: Arbitration may or may not be a desirable substitute for trials in courts; as to that the parties must decide in each instance. But when they have adopted it, they must be content with its informalities; they may not hedge it about with those procedural limitations which it is precisely its purpose...

Words: 22162 - Pages: 89

Free Essay

Case Study Mgt 448

...Case Study Lesley Aponte MGT/448 Professor Luis Rios-Silva September 20, 2014 Starting s business is never going to be easy; a person encounters small issues to even major issues. The company I read about was Nike. Although Nike is a successful business it has legal issues that it is coming across for many years now. The legal issues that Nike is having have to do with the manufacturing of the business. Nike only does the marketing and design and does not do any of the manufacturing, the manufacturing is done in another countries, which consists of Vietnam, which was South Korea, and in the 1970s the Nike shoes were made in Korea and Taiwan. By the 1980s a majority of Nike shoes were made in Indonesia and China. The issue that is going on is the labor issues that is going on in these countries with the workers is that they are working more than 60 hours and not getting paid enough they are getting paid about $.20 an hour. The situation that is occurring is that different human rights organizations and anti-globalization protesters feel that for the hours and labor all those employees put in that this is unfair labor practice and it is unjust. The thing about the United State labor laws is that they are different in other countries labor law but at the same time the workers are still getting less than the amount that is considered minimum wage which can be $3.00 a day and the employers working at the manufacturing company that is owned by Nike is making...

Words: 703 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Type of Worker

...http://www.acas.org.uk/media/pdf/g/e/Model_Workplace.pdf Background Small organisation (about 50 employees) Type of worker Unionised workforce – implications of this Possible causes of conflict Long term breakdown of trust? Short term mishandling of discipline? Unofficial protest – failure of procedures? – problem with TU processes? Poor relationship with TU? How to find out Discussion with supervisors Employee attitude surveys Discussion with TU reps Possible solutions? Short term Long term Recommendations must be appropriate to a small organisatio 3. type of rowker http://www.referenceforbusiness.com/small/Di-Eq/Employee-Strikes.html < --- dobra stronka Six types of workers who often go on strike are unions (labor and social) guilds, sympathizers, trade unions and factory workers. Primitive unions, or guilds, of carpenters, cabinet makers and cobblers made their appearance in various cities...

Words: 921 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Lalala

...BOOK FIVE LABOR RELATIONS Title I POLICY AND DEFINITIONS Chapter I POLICY Article. 211. Declaration of Policy. - A. It is the policy of the State: (a) To promote and emphasize the primacy of free collective bargaining and negotiations, including voluntary arbitration, mediation and conciliation, as modes of settling labor or industrial disputes; (b) To promote free trade unionism as an instrument for the enhancement of democracy and the promotion of social justice and development; (c) To foster the free and voluntary organization of a strong and united labor movement; (d) To promote the enlightenment of workers concerning their rights and obligations as union members and as employees; (e) To provide an adequate administrative machinery for the expeditious settlement of labor or industrial disputes; (f) To ensure a stable but dynamic and just industrial peace; and (g) To ensure the participation of workers in decision and policy-making processes affecting their rights, duties and welfare. B. To encourage a truly democratic method of regulating the relations between the employers and employees by means of agreements freely entered into through collective bargaining, no court or administrative agency or official shall have the power to set or fix wages, rates of pay, hours of work or other terms and conditions of employment, except as otherwise provided under this Code. (As amended by Section 3, Republic Act No. 6715, March 21, 1989). ...

Words: 16644 - Pages: 67

Premium Essay

Human Resources Test Case

...Case study choice 1: Read the Application Case 15-1 on pages 503-505 of the textbook. Answer the following questions based on your reading of the case and the material in Chapter 15. Your response should be at least 3 pages in length, and you should cite references relied upon for your answers. All references should be cited according to APA guidelines, including the textbook. a. Evaluate the various claims made by the union and counterclaims made by the company regarding the charges of unfair labor practices. Which of the arguments are most persuasive? Section 8(a)(1) of the National Labor states, “It shall be an unfair labor practice for an employer to interfere with, restrain, or coerce employees in the exercise of the rights guaranteed by section 7.” (NLRB, 2012) From what I can gather from various readings (American Bar Assoc., UNK), (Cantrell, UNK), this section actually refers to the employer taking part in any of the following actions: • Threatening to terminate an employee or otherwise cause harm to them if they join or vote for a union. • Provoking violence in the workplace towards employees who may vote for a union. • Threatening to close down the business location if the union prevails in an election. • Questioning employees about their union sympathies and activities under threatening circumstances. • Spying on union members and/or organizers, or giving the impression of spying. • Giving an unscheduled raise shortly before a representation election. • Withholding...

Words: 1484 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Industrial Law

...CASE STUDY MODULE 11 INDUSTRIAL LAW Summary Of The Case Study Lanka Fashions Leather Products Company has been running a profitable business for the past several years. At the beginning there was no trade union for the company but about six months ago the workers of the company has formed a branch union of a registered trade union sponsored by a political party with radical views. after the formation of the union they requested several opportunities to meet the management to discuss about factors affecting the member attached to the company. however the management has turned a blind eye to the request made by the union to give an opportunity to discuss the matters. The union informed the management in writing that in the event management failing to grant an opportunity to discuss the matters effecting within 14 days the union will be compelled to resort to strike action. As there was no response from the management they extended there mandatory period for a further period of two weeks. Management continued to be indifferent towards the union's request, and the union ultimately launched a strike. the union had a membership of nearly 75% of the total workforce of the company and almost 70% of the membership joined the strike. Even after the commencement of the strike the management refrained from having an dialogue with the union. Two weeks after the commencement of the strike the management wrote to all the strikers individually by registered post...

Words: 1596 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Review of the Legal Environment of Business

...owned company and expands operations globally, this paper will focus on the employment and labor laws, along with legal considerations that influence company operations. It is important to keep in mind that XYZ uses a mix of manning methodologies throughout the company; a full time staff as the core of the company, while maximizing the use of contracted labor in the execution of projects. Employment Law Employment law is a broad category of law that encompasses all areas regarding employee/employer relationships except for the negotiation process and collective bargaining, which is covered by the narrower focused category of labor law. Employment laws consist of thousands of federal and state statutes, regulations, and judicial decisions that are designed to govern the rights and duties of employers and workers. The US Department of Labor (USDOL) reports that there are 180 federal laws alone managed by 28 different agencies within the department. (United States Department of Labor [USDOL], 2014) Employment laws are focused on providing a safe and fair work place for employees and employers, alike, and have their origins in the constitution. They were founded based on public outcry against oppressive practices during the industrial revolution. The first laws founded in the 1920s were focused on fair wages, compensation for injuries, a standard work week, and on eliminating child labor. In the 1960s and 70s, statutes focused on anti-discrimination and unsafe work environments...

Words: 2498 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

California Pamphlet De2320

...15 Labor Relations and Collective Bargaining 1) About ________% of people working in the United States belong to unions. A) 5 B) 12 C) 20 D) 45 E) 62 Answer: B Explanation: Just over 17.7 million U.S. workers belong to unions—around 12.4% of the total number of men and women working in this country. Diff: 1 Page Ref: 544 Chapter: 15 Objective: 1 Skill: Concept 2) One of the earliest unions in the United States, the Knights of Labor, was formed by a group of ________. A) coal miners B) tailors C) carpenters D) railroad workers E) printers Answer: B Explanation: In 1869, a group of tailors met and formed the Knights of Labor. The Knights were interested in political reform. Diff: 2 Page Ref: 544 Chapter: 15 Objective: 1 Skill: Application 3) Who was responsible for forming the American Federation of Labor in 1886? A) Samuel Gompers B) Benjamin Franklin C) Frederick Taylor D) George Meany E) Alexander Hamilton Answer: A Explanation: In 1886, Samuel Gompers formed the American Federation of Labor (AFL). It consisted mostly of skilled workers and, unlike the Knights, focused on practical, bread-and-butter gains for its members. Diff: 2 Page Ref: 544 Chapter: 15 Objective: 1 Skill: Application 4) Which of the following was the primary goal of the American Federation of Labor? A) achieving political reform B) gaining a higher social status C) addressing immigrant labor D) improving work conditions E) creating labor legislation ...

Words: 11734 - Pages: 47

Premium Essay

Nike. Building a Global Brand

...developed strong brand equity in the United States due to its high level of brand awareness. Nike’s sources of brand equity in the US include; Brand Image, Price, Packaging, Brand Awareness and Positioning. These sources of brand equity have created unique, durable, and efficient products that are recognized worldwide leading to higher volume sales and higher profit margins against competing brands. Nike’s effort to become a global corporation has affected its sources of brand equity and brand image in the United States, Europe, and Asia positively. They achieved this by establishing their name in popular sports like soccer, track and field and tennis in Europe, basketball in America and cricket in Asia. According to the book, Best Practice Cases in Branding: Lessons from the World’s strongest brands, the author states that, “Given the company’s track and field heritage, Nike initially focused on developing links in track and field, whose sizable popularity in Europe was reflected by the fact that it was the second most televised sport (after soccer).” Sponsorships and...

Words: 1038 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Summary of Chapter 1 (Hrm, 12th Edition, Dessler)

...policies and practices involved in carrying out the people or the human resource aspects of a management position and are defined as the process of acquiring, training, appraising and compensating employees, and attending to their labor relations, health and safety, and fairness concerns. The components of Human Resource Management are Selection, Motivation, Productivity, Trade Unions, Training, Rewards System, Development, Discipline, Employment Legislation and Recruitment. Basic Human Resource concept states that HR creates value by engaging in activities that produce the employee behaviors that the company needs to achieve its strategic goals. The intensely competitive nature of business today means human resource managers must defend their plans and contributions in measurable terms. Current economic challenges require that HR managers develop new and better skills to effectively and efficiently deliver and manage HR services. The personnel aspects of a HR manager’s job include conducting job analysis, planning labor needs and recruiting job candidates, selecting job candidates, orienting and training new employees, managing wages and salaries, providing incentives and benefits, appraising performance, communicating, training and developing managers, and building employee commitment. Also, the HR manager’s today should also know and be concerned about notions such as equal opportunity and affirmative action, employee health and safety, handling grievances and labor relations...

Words: 1196 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Microecon Notes

...Chapter 6 Demand and Marginal Benefit Demand, Willingness to Pay, and Value • The value of one more unit of a good or service is its marginal benefit. Marginal benefit is the maximum price that people are willing to pay for another unit of a good or service. And the willingness to pay for a good or service determines the demand for it. So the demand curve for a good or service is also its marginal benefit curve. • The market demand curve is the horizontal sum of the individual demand curves and is formed by adding the quantities demanded by all the individuals at each price. • The demand curve in the figure shows that the maximum price a person is willing to pay for the 6 millionth gallon of milk per month is $3, so $3 is the marginal benefit of this gallon. • MSB curve: The market demand curve is also the economy’s marginal social benefit (MSB) curve. It reflects the number of dollars’ worth of other goods and services willingly given up to obtain one more unit of a good. • The figure shows that the maximum price a consumer is willing and able to pay for the 6 millionth gallon of milk is $3, so the marginal social benefit of the 6 millionth gallon of milk is $3. • Consumer surplus is the value (or marginal benefit) of the good minus the price paid for it, summed over the quantity bought. The figure illustrates the consumer surplus as the shaded triangle when the price is $3 per gallon. Supply and Marginal Cost Supply, Cost, and...

Words: 2450 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Social Media Policies: Are They Legal

...Case Study Week 2: Social Media Polices: Are They Legal? Keisha Rivera DeVry University MGMT 410 Professor Miller Case Study Week 2: Social Media Policies: Are They Legal? The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) is part of the United States government. It is an independent agency that is in charge of holding elections to represent the labor union, and also investigates and remedies the unfair labor practices (National Labors Relations Board, n.d.). Many companies have policies set into play regarding the restriction of social media usage while on company property. Many organizations are afraid that if an employee is utilizing social media accounts while at work that they may be posting negative comments about the organization. This will give the company a bad name. NLRB Facebook Firing An employee fro a Connecticut company had posted certain negative comments about a supervisor on their personal Facebook account. The employee was fired after posting about her supervisor, calling him a “scumbag”. Under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), employees are allowed to criticize the company as well as the leaders on social media. “Employers that set social media policies that prohibit or attempt to prohibit such activity can be in violation” (Northway, 2011, para. 6). Decision I agree with the decision of the NLRB to pursue this case. The company was clearly in the wrong by firing the employee for the remarks she made on her personal Facebook account. She...

Words: 889 - Pages: 4