Free Essay

Causes of Social Injustices and Inequalities in the South

In: Social Issues

Submitted By jcana
Words 1027
Pages 5
Jade Cana CNXJAD001
Tutorial 4

Week 3: In what ways have residents of Gwayi, Zimbabwe been disadvantaged by the protection of the forest reserve?

About 2.4% of Zimbabwe's land area is forested and managed by the Zimbabwean Forestry Commission (FC) on behalf of the state. Colonial and post-colonial state implemented practices to dispossess and alienate forest residents from protected forests to make way for commercial timber harvesting and wildlife hunting. Besides being a deliberate strategy to force local people to become part of the reserve labour pool to generate capital for developing settlers, Forestry conservation has greatly disadvantaged the communities that live within and around reserved forests in Zimbabwe such as the residents of Gwayi/mbembesi Forests. The forest has a long history of settlement by largely Ndebele speaking people, stretching way back before state dispossession during colonialization. It is important to note that the scaling back of the state is associated with neoliberalization that resulted in cutting back of state funding to conservation leading to the FC (as a state cooperation) to raise this funding gap from protection of the state forests. Marketing of forests for funding conservation has gained impetus, where state controlled territories are offered to investors through rents and concessions in the form of safari hunting and timber concessions allowing them to make private capital. There are many ways in which the residents of Gwayi are disadvantaged and it starts from the focus of revenue generation from the use of wildlife leading to the forced move of forest residents.

Matose (2014), speaks about the 'discursive blur' where he witnesses how the protection of forestry is being protected under the policy discourse of "biodiversity conservation" when it contradicts the realities and practices of local people and disadvantages them. Such relocations has been justified by authorities arguing that if people are allowed to stay, pressure will continue for others to settle and this will lead to the destruction of forests and that they are not able to provide the level of infrastructure available to those living in communal lands, thus by allowing them to stay in the forests they would be guilty of depriving forest occupants the right to development being enjoyed by those living in communal lands. There are also scientific arguments on the basis of environmental change such as deforestation were predicted if Gwayi settlers are allowed to stay.

The first relocation of residents from Insuzwa Wetland to western Gwayi in 1960 was to make way for wildlife habitat and increase capital made from that activity.. For example, people's resistance in the form of a policy of 'harassment' was initiated on grounds of the issue of water provision. They said animals got much better attention which is ridiculous. It was noted that in Hwange National Park there is a water point every 2km which runs all day to ensure water spills but the FC denies human beings access to water for drinking, limiting them to thrice a week. The success of the first Insuza Wetland displacement in 1960's led to FC wanting to create another wildlife habitat increasing the need to move residents from western Gwayi to eastern Gwayi. Concerning the issue of cultural identity, the fertile valleys of the Kalahari Sand Dunes have been the Ndebele resident’s home for many generations. This way of life came under increasing threat from the cumulative effects of the state's neoliberal conservation practices to 'protect forests', practices which threaten the Ndebele residents existence and culture. The Ndebele people's cultural identity also revolves around keeping large livestock herds which require access to good rangelands and western Gwayi provides that. Grazing is a highly valued resource for older Ndebele residents in both Gwayi sites, and if state regulation are highly enforced, these residents’ livelihoods are threatened.

Matose (2014) spoke with forest residents and many shared stories of them being denied access, permits and many indirectly disadvantaged in various ways. The residents say they cannot hunt to feed themselves whereas authorities of FC can kill animals at will and cut trees for pleasure on land that they found the forest residents living on. The revenue gained from timber concessions and wildlife safari hunting has significantly increased and brings in good capital to the FC, this has resulted in practices which disadvantages forest residents and adversely affected relationships with forest residents of Gwayi. Overt conflict emerged over the use of land in Gwayi west, there were increasing attempts to relocate all forest residents from the East to the west of gwayi but the people continued to resist and defy authorities covertly. Forest managers resorted to the prohibition of expansion of settlement and cultivation areas for all forest residents.

Mechanisms to achieve what they wanted were described by forest residents as warlike and harassment. Mechanisms included closure of water wells and dip tanks, leaving residents to rely on sand wells dug in a nearby forest river for their water needs and to buy chemicals for the water that was given to livestock, thereby cutting off of important sources of sustenance for livestock and forest residents. Other harassment included the prohibition of school reconstruction, undermining school operations. School buildings in Gwayi west were mostly brick under thatch for classrooms and teachers dwellings were constructed from mud and poles. Gwayi residents lived in fear and anxiety about their future especially given experiences in 1990 when some homes were burned and some people moved to distant communal lands. IN some parts of Gwayi west, grazing leases were granted by the FC in order to effectively reduce the amount of land available to local residents as a way to compel them t move to the east. Permits for construction material were denied, leaving residents unable to fix to their homes, when homes were in such a state of disrepair they went ahead and cut poles and thatch grass without permits and received regular fines. Fines were so high that residents couldn’t afford them and this was followed by the destruction of the newly established homes. People who owned cattle’s had to watch their main assets die and some cattle owners resisted and got in major trouble and were threatened with death.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Martin Luther King: A Hero Or Hero?

...Martin Luther King Looking back to Martin Luther King’s life, we’ll see if he was really a hero or he was not. Martin Luther King was an African American. He fought for racial equality and social Justice. Martin Luther King was a hero because he lead the african-american civil rights movements. Then he died for it. He stands up african american, to get equality from the racist people to get equal rights. Martin Luther King was born in Atlanta, Georgia. He was the son of Michael and Alberta King. He grew up during the Great Depression. Martin witness not only the racism but the social injustice. He was a hero because he fought against racism and succeed. “...a direct witness not only racism in the south but to breadlines and social injustice....

Words: 408 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ethos In Letter From Birmingham Jail

...that Jesus himself would have likely participated in: “Jesus Christ, was an extremist for love, truth and goodness, and thereby rose above his environment. Perhaps the South, the nation and the world are in dire need of creative extremists” (King 4). Furthermore, King’s frequent reference to scripture and citation of the...

Words: 1144 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Rosewood, the Study, the Case, the Story

...African American colony annihilated in the course of a weeklong occurrences of violence in early January of 1923. This study will show the effects of segregation in the United States, which continued after laws were passed, but unfortunately ignored by people who wanted to continue to have power, social control, and inequality over an indigenous group of human being living within their community. Rosewood is a true, however historically-stifled chain of events that took place in small blooming town in Rosewood, Florida. Rosewood industry was cedar wood and mills, and a railroad station that transported products, communal relations between the towns of Rosewood and Sumner were one of tolerance. The African American community were aware of the inequality that was afforded to them, but also made every effort to build a culture of stability, and building a new cultural identity of freedom within an almost self-sufficient predominately African American community in spite of the power structure of its white neighbors and systematic racism (Dye, 1997). With the accusation of violence against a white women the mob viewed this act a direct threat to their social structure and the legacy. Social hierarchy played a major role in the mobs attitude, the violence was almost immediate, and within six days the accusation caused ominous consequences that affected the whole community of Rosewood and those that played a part in its destruction (Singleton, 1982). Historical Archaeologist Dr...

Words: 1827 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Higher Educatiom

... elitist and exclusively for men. Oxford and Cambridge admitted women several centuries after they were established. The establishment of the oldest universities was church based. However, the intellectual discourses at the universities revealed a need for qualitative change in their role. By early 19th century, the modern universities dropped their elitist attire and started getting inclusive, admitting both men and women from all strata of society. The modern universities paved the way for rapid social and cultural changes, becoming more secular and democratic. The changes gradually transformed the universities into cultural institutions that mold young minds. Andre Beteille says: "University education became socially significant because, as open and secular institutions, the universities served as examples and models of a new kind of social existence. The universities provided fertile breeding grounds for a new ideal of social life." This makes a university a social organisation. It deeply interacts with the society and provides "public services" outside the classrooms for the benefit of the society. With secular and democratic policy of enrolment,...

Words: 983 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Non Violence In The Civil Rights Movement

...does one need weapons? In the Civil Rights Movement there have been many views on how to change one issue, racial inequality. From groups like the Black Panthers who advocated for the rights to bare arms for self protection, to the Freedom Riders who did not believe violent retaliation in any form. Comparing figureheads such as Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X show the distinct differences between the two, what may seem like a radical idea to one may not seems so to the other. The contrasting ideas of both nonviolent activists and activists who believe violence is inevitable if not necessary in the Civil Rights Movement, emphasizes the idea that nonviolence is key to one understanding...

Words: 1274 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Paper

...their sons in South Africa in 1948. In his story, Alan Paton used the George Hegel's Dialect of thesis, antithesis, synthesis, in order to expose social injustices in a microcosm of South Africa that correlate to the macrocosm of the issues faced by the entire country and what must be done to fix these injustices. Paton subdivided his story into three books. The first of these books, depicts the Journey of Stephen Kumalo, to try and restore his family, is a cry against injustice. The second book focused mainly on James Jarvis’s plight to understand his deceased son, depicts the yearning for justice. While the final book displays the restoration and repair of the injustices derived from the yearning for justice. The society of the small urban town called Ndotsheni, from which both Stephan and Author come, is based largely on the native African tribal system. This town also suffers from a drought that drives away the young men to work in the mines of Johannesburg. Johannesburg directly contradicts Ndotsheni with no tribal system and the brake down of the moral fibers of its people. Yet in Johannesburg there is also hope for the future and ideas that help lead to the restoration of Ndotsheni. During the time the story is set in Johannesburg the reader is introduced to two exceptionally different characters. The first is John Kumalo, the brother of Stephen Kumalo. He is a corrupt politician with the voice of a “lion,” but a week hart, who spoke about the injustices of the whites...

Words: 1012 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Janie Mae Overton Civil Rights Movement

...Civil Rights are defined by Merriam-Webster as the rights that every person should have regardless of his or her sex, race or religion. The fifties planted the seeds for the cultural conflict that traversed the nation in the sixties, a time when civil rights in inequality, an unfair situation in which some people have more rights or better opportunities than other people, created division and discord. Injustices such as the denial of full citizenship rights, equal opportunity in education, jobs, access to transportation and public facilities experienced by African Americans led to The Civil Rights Movement in the United States and a time of social unrest. The Civil Rights Movement was about the campaign of African Americans who had visions of equality and sought social change. Janie Mae Overton was an African American woman who, along with many others, was actively involved in the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960’s. Her involvement included participation in non-violent demonstrations, sit-ins and marches against inequality and social injustice which was the African American experience....

Words: 1935 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Too Young to Wed

...certain countries, even when the legal marriage age is 18, cultural traditions take priority over legislative law.[3] Child marriage affects both boys and girls, though the overwhelming majority of those affected are girls, most of whom are in poor socioeconomic situations. Child marriage is related to child betrothal, and it includes civil cohabitation and court approved early marriages after teenage pregnancy. In many cases, only one marriage-partner is a child, usually the female. Causes of child marriages include poverty, bride price, dowry, cultural traditions, laws that allow child marriages, religious and social pressures, regional customs, fear of remaining unmarried, illiteracy, and perceived inability of women to work for money. Child marriages were common throughout history for a variety of reasons, including poverty, insecurity, as well as for political and financial reasons. Today, child marriage is still fairly widespread in developing countries, such as parts of Africa, South Asia, Southeast Asia, West Asia, Latin America, and Oceania. The incidence of child marriage has been falling in most parts of the world. The countries with the highest observed rates of child marriages below the age of 18 are Niger, Chad, Mali, Bangladesh, Guinea and the Central African Republic, with a rate above 60%. Niger, Chad, Bangladesh, Mali and Ethiopia were the countries with child marriage rates greater than 20% below the age of 15, according to...

Words: 520 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Global Justice Essay

...countries. The problem in today’s society is there is a lack of global justice. According to Drydyk global justice means freedoms and opportunities to learn, work and feed and clothe people globally (Drydyk, 23). The importance of justice to business and society is to make the world just and bring equality for all. It is important for business and society to help other countries and treat them equally. It is important for business as well so that they can work fairly together to achieve the goal of global justice. Studying global justice allows people to become aware of the injustices that people around the globe face such as war, poverty, limited opportunities, etc. Moreover, global justice allows countries to be united under a legal system (Drydyk, 23). My research questions is what are the root causes of injustices in our world and how can they be solved? In this essay, I will demonstrate that the causes of injustices in our world stem from materialism (not helping the unfortunate nation because of selfishness and only caring about one countries profit), ignorance and capitalism where richer nations exploited poorer nations. First of all, I will discuss the issue of institutions of cosmopolitan failing to provide justice. Cosmopolitan principles urge for equality and moral worth of all humans and a shared economic system (Berry, 5). Similarly, Institutions of global justice fight to achieve moral equality and well being of people throughout the world (Kurasawa, 5). It is a process...

Words: 4052 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

An Analysis Of Dr. Martin Luther King's Letter From Birmingham Jail

...cities, such as Birmingham. After his famous march in Birmingham, white police officers arrested him and put him in the Birmingham Jail. While in jail, he read a public statement delivered by eight Alabama clergymen from local churches, claiming that King's demonstrations were unnecessary. King, responding by writing "Letter from Birmingham Jail," refutes all of the clergymen's claims. In paragraphs 12-14 of his letter, King attempts to persuade the clergymen as to why he must act now, rather than later, for social change, dismissing the claim that the march was "untimely." King raises the clergymen’s awareness of the situations affecting the...

Words: 1623 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

The 2011 London Riots: Expression of Urban Social Inequality

...major debate arose about the inner causes of the insurrections and the media and politicians promptly pointed out several hypothesis. The August 2011 events have been primarily interpreted, especially amongst the political class, through a lens that emphasises criminality. ,one prominent argument advocates that the cause of the unrest was the moral decay of ‘a feral underclass’ (Scrambler; Grover 2011) However, many of such explanations tend to be mostly speculative and they often fail to provide a consistent account of the causes of the riots based on solid evidence (the LSE/theguardian, 2011, Solomos, 2011). Against this background this essay attempts to disentangle the motives of the London 2011 riots, by focusing on the relations of causality between factors and events that led to the burst of the unrest. It argues that urban social inequalities as well as uneven processes of exclusion and inclusion of a marginalised class are the main factor underlying the disturbances. Yet this essay claims that these riots need also to be analysed in the very specific context in which they have arisen: the financial crisis, a society which is becoming increasingly consumerist in its orientation, the disputable role of the police, loss of faith in the political class and hopelessness towards the future amongst the urban youth. In the first part this essay analyses inequality indicators and trends embracing the multidimensional nature of social inequality (Bradley, 1996)....

Words: 3372 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Equality

...Joshua Wu Equal in the Twentieth Century The late nineteenth century to the early twentieth century became the rising point of equality and social reform and protest. After many Nationalist movements of reform and revolts, this resulted in several unified countries. It then led to the next big social issue, equality. The female equality movement, especially the suffrage movement, gained traction throughout the world gaining massive support from many. Many female activists and authors were very vocal about the injustice they faced and how the societies they lived in needed to change. Some of these activists/authors were: Virginia Woolf, Alexandra Kollontai, Constance Markievicz, and Sylvia Pankhurst. Though in different forms and different pursuits these four authors pursued the same ultimate goal, equality. Virginia Woolf was an author during the turn of the century and in her piece, “A Room of One’s Own” she draws meaning from the injustice between the sexes in the time and in the industry of literature and art. In her piece, after referring to Shakespeare, she says, “A highly gifted girl who had tried to use her gift for poetry would have been so thwarted and hindered by other people…No girl could have walked to London and stood at a stage door and forced her way into the presence of actor-managers without doing herself a violence and suffering an anguish…for chastity may be a fetish invented…” (298). Prior to this quote Woolf spoke about the history of Shakespeare and how...

Words: 1458 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Environmental Inequality in the United States

...Environmental Inequality in the United States Introduction Minority and poor populations have been experiencing an unequal amount of exposure to various environmental hazards. The goal of this paper is investigate the situation at hand and provide an explanation to whether this treatment is ethical. Thus, in this paper, I will not only attempt to analyze reasons why these populations experience more pollution than other populations and the types of pollution that they experience, but I will also explore the solutions provided by other researchers on how to solve environmental inequalities. Previous research has been carried out to detect why most, if not all, of the polluting industries, such as power plants and waste facilities, tend to be located in minority and poor neighborhoods (Carter; Morello-Frosch; Pellow and Park; Bullard and Wright). Normally, people that live in low income neighborhoods will experience a disproportionately high amount of pollution compared to those living in high income neighborhoods (Morello-Frosch). Therefore, parks, trees, and outdoor recreational areas tend to be located in wealthy neighborhoods. Consequently, minority and poor neighborhoods tend to have the lowest ratios of parks-to-people (Carter). This means that there is a low amount of park space per 10,000 people. Other research shows that even if we ignore the level of income, minority neighborhoods, such as African American and Hispanic neighborhoods, will still experience higher levels...

Words: 3504 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

The Responsibility Act

...segregation laws in the south. This film showed two different organizational issues. The issues in the film are important, and as a result some of these issues affected the outcome of history. The social pressures of this film impacted the strength of the organized freedom riders and what they desired to accomplish. The outcome of what could happen to people if they participated in this movement affected the organization and their personal decision who got involved. The legal and ethical responsibility of police are both enforced and disregarded in this film. The two organizational issue facing this period were the freedom riders who opposed racism, and the police enforcing the Jim Crow laws and upholding racism. The two organizations had very different views during this movement. The freedom riders cause was clearly stated, and people defending desegregation and equality took action. Segregation during this period, in the south, was highly enforced. The freedom riders used song to communicate and strengthen their spirits. They received mistreatment from authorities because they would not allow their spirits to be broken. The police at this time felt the riders came down to cause trouble. Their organization issue was to stop the desegregation of blacks. They felt anyone who disregarded the Jim Crow laws was breaking the law; therefore, the police had a duty to arrest many of the freedom riders. The film is important because it gives insight to the injustice of those times. It shows...

Words: 752 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

A Connecticut Yankee In King Arthur's Court

...King's spirit is unfazed despite the suffering they are in. This event is what leads to Arthur announcing that at the end of this venture he will abolish slavery; a result that makes the matter meaningful for Hank. Being exposed to slavery first hand is what caused the King to see that the inequality that slaves were treated with was morally incorrect and he did not want any others to suffer the way that he did. It is implied that Twain experienced first-hand the harsh reality of slavery himself which is why he was so opposed to it. Twain experienced slavery in the South, which is very similar to the way Hank explains and compares the sixth century system. He uses this comparison when he explains that in the way individuals have to prove they are freemen to avoid being sold into slavery instead of making the sellers prove they are slaves before selling them. He makes the point that a unfair law seems to be much more when one finds it applied to themselves. Hank takes benefit of the common regard to nobles by claiming to be the property of one of them...

Words: 1164 - Pages: 5