Free Essay

Censorship of the Arts

In: English and Literature

Submitted By iamhated
Words 837
Pages 4
Abstract “Censorship of the arts” consists of a brief look into the art industry and how governments are attempting to control what artists release. There are several high profile cases referenced within this paper, one involving AMTRAK and a refused billboard. Also referenced is a situation which involves an artist painting abstract and grotesque pictures involving deformities. Closing out this paper is how art is able to bring people of different backgrounds and cultures together.

Censorship of the Arts Art is present in every aspect of modern life. It is there when we turn on the T.V. and watch our favorite program or see a commercial, when we drive past a billboard, and it’s even there when we make our morning breakfast. Art is a major part of our society, but it has been under attack by censorship since its first conception. Censorship of the arts is unconstitutional, limits creativity, and stifles diversity, but is sometimes needed. Censoring art is unconstitutional because art, at its core, is an expression of oneself or an idea, and in essence the same as a verbal statement. In the case Lebron v. National Railroad Passenger Corporation, AMTRAK refused to display a billboard ad by Michael Lebron in New York City’s Penn Station. The ad used Coors ad slogan “Right Beer” against it, asking the question “Is it the Right’s Beer Now?” The billboard pictures the usual, happy beer drinkers’ right next to a Nicaraguan village where villagers are being terrified by a can of Coors flying at them like a missile. Mr. Lebron designed this ad due to the Coors family support of right-wing causes, including the Contras in Nicaragua. In the end, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of Mr. Lebron because AMTRAK was partially run by the U.S. Government and subject to adhere to the constitution (“Art on Trial,” 2005). In the previously mentioned example, if the billboard in question had attempted to be placed in a privately owned train station, there would be nothing that could be done. The Constitution only limits government censorship, not private censorship. As in the previous example, art is capable of getting information out there that would otherwise go unnoticed. Limiting creativity is the creator’s worst enemy. In some senses, limiting a topic is like taking away the artists tools. In other cases, it may be welcome and needed to keep some perverse topics/art from being thrust upon the public. Artists like Jenny Saville can take creative freedom beyond what is normally considered acceptable with her works showing grotesque, deformed figures. Another example of going too far would be in Israel when photographs of Palestinians being interrogated were removed from an exhibit. The question there lies on “how far, is too far?” In a free society, that question can only be answered by the artist themselves and if they want to limit their piece, or the person buying or displaying the piece (Harrison, 2002; “Governments, Censorship,” 1989). Diversity is the key reason why free society is so grand and loved. No one’s views or opinions will the same as another’s. In the 50’s there were two major artists present, Pat Boone and Elvis Presley. They were both polar opposites in terms of their performances, lifestyles and personal beliefs, but art brought them together to share a bill at a 1955 sock hop in Cleveland OH.
In another instance involving Pat Boone, he did a tamer version of Ozzy Osbourne’s hit ‘Crazy Train’. Mr. Boone and Mr. Osbourne couldn’t be more different from one another. Pat Boone; a 1950’s musical icon from the sock hop era, and Ozzy Osbourne; a heavy metal shock-rocker, came together on common ground through this one song. Mr. Osbourne liked it so much that it was used for the opening credits in his reality T.V. show “The Osbourne’s” on MTV (“Censorship in arts ‘healthy’,” 2004).
Censorship of the arts can be harmful to a society; keeping ideas from circulating and taking root or dying out. The Constitution only protects free speech when the Government is directly involved. As a free society; with free speech, it is left to the artist or consumer themselves to decide what they deem is appropriate. At the end of the day, art is like T.V, there are plenty of channels to pick from.

References
Art on trial: Censoring artistic expression and the first amendment. (2005). The Thomas Jefferson Center. Retrieved June 26th, 2012, from http://www.tjcenter.org/ArtOnTrial/censor.html

Censorship in arts ‘healthy,’ Boone says. (April 20th, 2004). The Washington Times. Retrieved June 26th, 2012, from http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2004/apr/20/20040420-114829-2076r/print/ Governments, censorship and the arts. (August 13th, 1989). The New York Times. Retrieved June 26th, 2012, from http://www.nytimes.com/1989/08/13/arts/governments-censorship-and-the-arts.html

Harrison, S. (June 2002). Censorship and controversy in contemporary art.
Proquest. Retrieved June 26th, 2012, from http://www.csa.com/discoveryguides/art/overview.php

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Censorship and Its Affect on Art

...Censorship and its affect on Art Regardless if you like art, music or just simply reading books, I am sure you have your favorites that have made a serious impact on your life, but what about all those works that you never got to see, read or feel? Maybe you never will, if they have fallen victim to the act of censoring. “Censorship is defined as the alteration or removal of works of art from public view” (Frank 92). Along with wars, conflicts, cultural influences, and evolution of societies, censorship has had an enormous effect on art of the past and will greatly alter the trajectory of art in the future for better or worse. The one who controls the ultimate decision whether to eliminate or support expression through art will be of the utmost importance in the growth and development of artistic expression. “The struggle for freedom of expression is as ancient as the history of censorship” (Newth). Everywhere free expression has been achieved, censorship follows, never too far behind. One of the more famous acts of censorship occurred when Socrates, a most influential philosopher of history was sentenced to drink poison for “corrupting” the youth with his ideals that varied from the current political and moral codes of his time. This happened in 399 BC. Gives you an idea of how long censorship has effected expression, and this is by no means the first time censorship took place in history. I personally never put too much thought into censorship and the severity of its faults...

Words: 2290 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Art Censorship Research Paper

...Censorship: What’s the fuss? When should censorship in art be put in place, and should it be put in place? Allowing art such as that of a very provocative taste will definitely cause a lot of noise. Noise like the standards needing to be invoked that deal with images of naked children in their works, as any work with naked person is pornography. For methods of censoring, would it be fair to retract any monetary gain if the art is “inappropriate” or “lewd,” or should the work be banned? Should Congress be able to step in and have a say in the censorship, or is messing around in federally funded art overstepping their boundaries? In the education field too, they have to try to make a decision to censor or allow provocative works of art. The...

Words: 1800 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Personal Narrative: Art Censorship

...The first thing I noticed was an inconsistency in spacing. This paper was hard for me. A lot of the evidence was stretched which I think led to my editorial not being as convincing. However, one evidence I like is in the beginning when I was deconstructing a quote. I said: “In basic terms, this means that art is created to address concerns, entertain, and express your being, so to censor it is to ruin it.” I’d say that this is my best evidence. It is clear, concise, and makes sense. Others, not as much. For one of my points I was addressing the effect of art on small children. I said: “While art is meant to cause reactions, the way it is shown may be inappropriate for children. When you are a child, though, stuff you don’t understand generally flies over your head.” This is bad evidence, and not entirely true. This speaks of a minority of children. Most of the time children are curious and inquisitive. If they hear a new word or see something they don’t understand they’ll be curious, especially if it is hidden from them. Like any paper, this one had strengths and weaknesses. I will improve from this by researching more, and finding better evidence to support my...

Words: 1014 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Censorship

...Courtney 24 March 2010 Art censorship and obscenity People in the United States of America are allowed to express themselves in many ways. One of these ways of expressing yourself is through art. Although we have this freedom, it is not completely accepted or viewed as right. What makes the many different forms or art acceptable or unacceptable with censorship? Why should creativity and artistic abilities be censored from other people or artists? “According to Plato, ‘because art has the power to intensify and not just purge emotions, a “dramatic censor” must control the content and form of all artistic expression’” (Hoffman). There are some people who just cannot accept or understand certain pieces of art, which leads them to find them inappropriate and misleading. Just because these people cannot handle certain works of art does not mean that the work should be hidden. Imagine painting a watercolor picture, which is very hard to work with, and working on it for months upon months. You strive to get it finished and once you do you feel very proud of what has been accomplished. Naturally, you would want to put your hard work on display to show it off to whoever you please. But right when you get the chance to do that, the watercolor that you painted for weeks and weeks is taken away from you by Nazi’s and banned from ever being seen. In 1940, this is exactly what happened to German painter, print maker, and watercolorist Emil Nolde. People come to the United States to...

Words: 1800 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Magdiel's Argumentative Essay

...Emmanuel who was Gaius Maecenas. This side argued that censorship of the arts is warranted. Most of their points were believable, however some were controversial. Each speech tied together a full understanding of why this group believed this. A main point included that Augustus has been a great ruler and the citizens of Rome should agree with his plans. Their organization of how each person went was good since it started with the Roman Senator and facts, then as the speeches went on there was more emotion involved. Brooke decided to rebuttal after the con side went. She made a good point on how the censors have been in public office they have been modeling how we should act. Her rebuttal had other respectable points that allowed for more discussion in the debate. Overall, I thought the...

Words: 1084 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Media Censorship

...legislated just the same (McCormick). This case is the most recent of many that censorship has become a major battleground. Since first the shootings of April 1999 in Columbine Colorado, and most recently, the 2004 Super Bowl Halftime show in which singer Justin Timberlake exposed the breast of fellow singer Janet Jackson, the government has made it its priority to influence the entertainment industry to put into place new rules, such as the one in NASCAR, to regulate “inappropriate” material, therefore increasing censorship. On top of this, the industry itself has begun to attempt a type of self-censorship. Although censorship has been around for ages, what is it and why does it exist? Censorship in today’s era is a higher power attempting to prevent disturbing or painful sights, sounds, or any other information form from reaching the public in order to keep a feeling of well moral being. However, the main question in today’s times is whether or not censorship is necessary in today’s world, and if the government should be able to force censorship on the entertainment industry.      Though the case involving the NASCAR driver is the most recent ridiculous form of censorship, it has taken place throughout the history of entertainment itself. However, in the past ten years, after censorship laws had begun to loosen, the media and the government has once again begun to pull tighter on the censorship blindfold, covering...

Words: 1593 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Censorship: An Individual's Creativity

...Well, that world is called censorship. Censorship is basically a suppression of an individual's creativity. Many books by certain authors with strong themes and ideas are often censored. So are articles with strong opinions. Censorship doesn’t suppress anyone's creativity. It actually does. Many books written by authors like Judy Blume are often censored. Nowadays authors can’t really pour all of their creativity into a book without the fear of it being censored. “Censorship has imposed a serious limitation on a writers’ artistic creativity”(Pen America) The imagination that writers have is awesome, but they can’t express that without putting limits on their material....

Words: 349 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Censorship

...Censorship is a practice that restricts and music censorship is a very delicate matter. Music censorship is no new thing, it’s been going on regularly at least since the 1850s (Volz, 1991). Since music began, there is always someone trying to silence or censor something! Plato said “rhythm and harmony find their way into the inward places of the soul”. Music is art and art in all its forms has always been prone to censorship, usually because of the desire of artists to extend the boundaries of taste and challenge authority (2005) crystal ref encyclopedia Even though music censorship is no new thing and it has been around since the beginning of music, it is not right. I totally reject music censorship! The problem is always with the words. Words are lyrics and with those words artists creatively express their emotions, experiences, thoughts and feelings .Consequently creating an aesthetic quality, transforming words into lyrics. There is nothing more powerful than the written word. Talk is cheap but “words”- words are magic , words are deep. Words are the foundation of history, of feelings, of intrigue. Words teach, words punish. Words give you a release. Words are wonder. Words are weapons. Words can soothe and words can kill ! Words are the symbols that represent truth. Words bring accomplishment. Words bring things into being. Words are the written of what a person is seeing. Words create, they sedate, they equate, they elaborate and they dictate. Words instigate. Words...

Words: 856 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Music Censorship

...Music censorship began its journey in the early 1950’s with the “controversial” music of Blacks during the time period. It has then evolved from a form of racism to a method of suppression. It touches all major genres, but is most commonly issues with both rap and rock music. Major groups such as the Record Industry Association of America (RIAA) have been formed to try and monitor the lyrical messages that are expressed in songs. The RIAA is not out to completely censor music, but to advise buyers of the messages they may be listening to on a certain album. Then there is the party that feels censorship at any level shall not be present. It is suppressing one’s First Amendment rights in freedom of expression and also suppresses an artist abilities to fully paint a vivid picture with their lyrics to the audience. The last group believes that censorship is a must, and that any songs that carry the censored material shall be taken off of the shelves. That specific group believes that contaminating society with explicit lyrics should not reward artists. The side that believes censorship of music should not exist at all states that music is a form of art. Many tend to separate music from forms of art, such as paintings and poetry. However, the lyrics in the music are an art form as well, and they cannot restrict that due in part to the First Amendment. It is part of our Bill of Rights as American citizens, and no governing powers can take that away from us. Also, society favors contemporary...

Words: 720 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Dsskdfdfojrf Jff; Kdf; Jk; Jdj

...Censorship should not interfere with freedom of expression in the arts Whether in ancient Rome or in the modern United States, censorship has existed in every society at every age. Art that challenges the strongly held beliefs of any society – whether those be political, ideological, religious, or otherwise – causes offense and creates pressure for censorship. At the same time, almost every society has found value in the existence of visual art. What limitations on censorship should be made for the sake of artist value, or more broadly freedom of expression? “Artistic merit” and “offensiveness” are nebulous concepts lacking in objectivity, shifting with the tastes of society at any given time. Yet the value of art to society, both positive and negative, cannot be doubted. In modern American society, with its heterogeneous tastes, the tension between the two concepts becomes especially vivid. Given the divergent and unpredictable tastes of society, the fact that destroying a work permanently removes it from future generations, and considering censorship's dreadful history, the decision to censor is one appropriately made with caution. But neither can it be said that a work should never be censored, for art can and does cause offense, and even a society as diverse as ours will find consensus at the extremes. Rather, striking the appropriate balance calls ultimately for good judgment. In making this judgment, what is the appropriate role of the law and the courts? Those who think...

Words: 345 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Dictatorship in Brazil

...! ! Censorship in the Brazilian Military Dictatorship The Brazilian military dictatorship took place in Brazil between the years of 1964 and 1985. Known as the first South American bureaucratic regime, the dictatorship strived to develop the country’s economy, reform politics and attract foreign investors. As the name suggests, this governmental model used the military’s power in order to rule the country. For this reason, the system was known to be extremely repressive and censorial. Moreover, anyone who seemed to oppose to the Brazilian authorities were often subjected to strict trials and often torture. The main explanation behind these practices is that the military government wanted to prevent revolutionary ideas that may have put their power in jeopardy. The main targets of this radical censorship were journalists and musicians, many of whom were severely punished for “conspiring” against the country’s authorities. However, the latter were simply expressing facts and public opinions on the situation of the time. This intense oppression can be seen as a violation of human rights and freedom of speech. In this essay, the historical and political context of this period, the ways that the military tyranny has affected the lives of Brazilian journalists, writers and other artists as well as the effect on publication processes of their works will be outlined. Moreover, tactics used by journalists and musicians to avoid the common oppression will be surveyed. In order...

Words: 1999 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Free Speech

...March 1, 2012 Freedom of speech is the idea that people can speak freely without being stopped, or censored. The United States First Amendment states that people have the right for absolute freedom of speech, which raises concern for when freedom of speech should be limited. Being able to speak freely is important. It allows us to speak our minds without being punished for our ideas. Freedom of speech in relevance to our time is very crucial. More and more people are beginning to voice their opinions and the construction of free speech is one of great importance. When thinking of free speech many issues and topics come into play. Today it seems that free speech in social networking has become increasingly prevalent. Over four hundred million people across the world are involved in some sort of social network, thus the importance of their voice when dealing with free speech. People want their voice to be heard, especially using things such as Twitter and Facebook. The issue of this however concerns the creators and if they should monitor what is being said on these sites. If social networking sites were to monitor our every action and every word, would we feel as if they abide by the freedom of speech law? What if one day you logged onto Facebook and there was a notification telling you that you were being monitored and could no longer say whatever you wanted whenever you wanted? Most of us would be outraged and angry that we could not express our opinions. No one wants...

Words: 1269 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Censorship Essay: The Banning Of Books In Schools

...Vocally expressing one’s views cannot be repressed for once the words are spoken, they cannot be retracted. Books can be removed; music can be banned; movie production can be halted – but these art forms are in no way different from verbal expression. These forms of art are the author’s own way of bringing personal ideas and opinions to the public...

Words: 632 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Analyzing Victor Lombardi's Essay 'Music Censorship'

...In Victor Lombardi’s essay “Music And Censorship” he states his study that “using the value of art and the artist as a starting point, Lombardi shows how censorship is an attack against our right to pleasure-it is even an attack against truth: “a censored opinion, whether true or false, sidesteps conflicts and secures our distance in the truth” (201) My position is does the censorship to affect the art of musical artist and does it make it better than the mainstream music that isn’t? And what makes music so great? I interviewed an Alternative Rock fan named Samantha and asked what she thought made music good and her thoughts on music censorship. I interviewed Aaron who is a tremendous fan of hip-hop and his input as on why he thought censorship...

Words: 1560 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Digital Freedom Fighters

...Freedom Fighters: Defending Free Speech in the 21st Century Introduction Comic books have been published for over 75 years with a varied subject matter including superhumans, gods, soldiers, historical events and animals. Originally conceived as a child’s reading fodder, comics have evolved beyond the original audience. A recent study found that over 98% of comic book readers are over the age of 18. (Pantozzi, 2012) No longer an art form exclusively for children, comics have been the target of many censorship attacks. With the advent of 21st century technology, comic books have evolved and the criticisms have evolved with them. Newer challenges to this form of speech can sometimes be overwhelming, but there are many organizations which are focused on protecting these freedoms. These are the digital freedom fighters. They are a safeguard against the rising censorship and regulation of free speech. Banning books and other forms of media is a not a new practice, but digital media has changed the censorship methods. With new censorship, new bypasses have also been developed such as different means of disbution. The legal embattlements have also greatly shifted. Laptop, websites and other digital means are now central to the...

Words: 4276 - Pages: 18