Free Essay

Centrailia Mine

In: Business and Management

Submitted By paperhelp1
Words 1276
Pages 6
Public disasters often cause many questions to be raised and fingers to be pointed. This most certainly holds true for the catastrophic explosion of Centralia Mine No. 5 on the afternoon of March 25, 1947, and the violent and untimely deaths of the 111 Centralia Coal Company miners. While many played a role in the unfolding of this tragic disaster, focus is repeatedly brought back to Driscoll Scanlan, an Illinois mine state inspector. Were there other courses of action he could have pursued in the management and security of the mine, and what were the driving factors behind Scanlan’s decision concerning the law he was sworn to uphold and the interest of public good? Those are questions that if answered could help to uncover how this tragedy could have been prevented.
For a city of such humble beginnings, established by the railroad via a land grant in 1853, no one could have guessed that Centralia, Illinois, would face such devastation and tragedy less than a century later (Hartley and Kenney, 2006). The city of Centralia—throughout most of its history, experienced slow economic growth, progressed steadily and changed gradually, which provided a stable environment for the community and its growth. As any typical Midwestern town did, Centralia saw many highs and lows within the city’s primary business and industry. Those highs and lows of the coal mining, farming and railroad business helped Centralia become a balanced yet prosperous town and with the exception of the short lived oil boom during the late 1930’s, coal mining proved a primary source of employment for many city residence and immigrants (Hartley and Kenney, 2006).
The Centralia Coal Company, which was formed by Ferdinand Kohl and A.M. Warner in 1869, answered the growing need for coal. This demand was especially apparent in the railroad city of Centralia, and in 1907 the Centralia Mine No.5 was opened by Kohl and Warner (Hartley and Kenney, 2006). It proved to be one of the most resilient and prosperous mines of the area during that time. This fact, along with the personal devastation felt by the community, is what makes the explosion that much worse and causes us to examine the roles of those responsible for protecting the miners and securing the mine more closely.
As the primary individual responsible for policing the Centralia Mine No. 5, Scanlan failed to exercise and exhaust all of his resources and power in the prevention of this disastrous explosion (Stillman 2009). There is no doubt that Scanlan faced many obstacle or hurdles in his efforts to maintain a secure and safe working environment for the miners of the Centralia Coal Company, but it is also clear that his efforts—in some instances his lack of effort—were far from enough. Even with all of Scanlan’s challenges, there were still several alternate avenues in which he could have sought recourse, but did not. Among his options was the ability to close the mine himself. While this may have yielded a temporary solution, that quite possibly would have been shortly overturned, it was still an option that he had at his disposal, and at the very least may have drawn special attention to the terrible condition of the mine. Scanlan also could have supported the miners in their attempt to bring charges against the mine manager. This course of action would probably have garnered him an unfavorable response from the managers and the Department, but it would have demonstrated his conviction to the severity of his findings and to improving the mine conditions. Yet another option Scanlan had was to take his charges and concerns directly to the Governor Dwight Green, who had at least promised to uphold the mining laws during his campaign (Stillman 2009). Again this type of action would have infuriated, Robert Medill, the Director of Mines and Minerals, but could have gained the attention that was needed. Finally, Scanlan could have ignored the requests or mandates of Medill and continued to provide his full and detailed accounts of the dire situation at Centralia No. 5. Clearly his reports were striking a cord and raising some red flags, and it was not wise of him to discontinue his efforts in this regard. Scanlan’s beliefs and commitment to mining laws and bureaucracy were made null by his inability to enforce the laws and his strict adherence to the hierarchy of authority. This is made evident in his failure to close the mine when he noted on several occasions that direct laws were being broken, and his adherence to Medill’s orders to cease his detailed reporting and remove some of his recommendations following a disciplinary meeting (Stillman 2009). As a result of Scanlan’s departure from the true duties, responsibilities and purpose of his job lives were lost and a community was destroyed. Scanlan had the option to step up to the plate and take full action, or he should have stepped down from his position. If he was unable to handle the demands of the position it was only right for him to step aside and allow for someone else who could to step up.
We would like to believe that the devastation caused by disasters, such as the monstrous explosion at Centralia No. 5 were not in vain. That they may have aided or contributed in the passage of future legislation, like the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969—a far reaching document, signed by President Richard Nixon, that promised a new day for individuals in an industry that had claimed more than 100,000 lives since 1900 (Mining Disasters - An Exhibition, n.d.). This act—which would have greatly aided Scanlan and the miners of Centralia No. 5—required four annual inspections for each underground coal mine, eliminated exemptions for mines that were said to be absent of gas, broaden the power of the inspectors, gave miners the right to request Federal inspections, strengthened safety and health standards, and for the first time established mandatory fines for all violations and criminal penalties for knowing and willful violations (Mining Disasters - An Exhibition, n.d.).
It is possible that with the backing of legislation like the Act of 1969, Scanlan would have fully utilized his power and performed his required duties as a state inspector. With the backing of such a law and all of the liberties it afforded inspectors he may have been less incline to follow the orders of the Medill and the Department, or perhaps Scanlan would have exercised his ability to close the mine or even levied fines for any one of the many infractions he encountered and documented during his inspections. Unfortunately, these things did not occur, the mine did explode, and the lives of 111 men were lost. We may never know or understand all of the complexities that unfolded in this tragedy, and as we pick apart the layers only more questions arise, but the one thing that is clear is that through the actions of Driscoll Scanlan a dangerous fire was only fueled.

References:
Mining Disasters - An Exhibition . (n.d.). United States Department of Labor. Retrieved from http://www.msha.gov/disaster/disaster.htm

Stillman, R. J. (2009). The Search for the Scope and Purpose of Public Administration'. In:
Maureen Staudt and Michael Stranz (ed), Public Administration Concepts and Cases. 9th ed. Mason, Ohio: Cengage Learning. pp.31-47.

Hartley, R. E and Kenney, David (2006). Death underground: The Centralia and West Frankfort mine disasters. Carbondale, IL: South Illinois University Press. pp. 23-50.

Martin, J. B. (1948). The blast in Centralia No. 5: A mine disaster no one stopped. Harper’s Magazine, March 1948.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Centralia No. 5

...woke up to attend their job at the coal mine just as any usual day. (Stillman, 2010) They had no idea they would never return home to their families. March 25, 1947 is the day 111 coal miners were killed during their routine daily duties at the Centralia Coal Mine. (Stillman, 2010) A massive explosion changed the city of Centralia forever. The cause of the massive explosion is due to a build up of coal dust. (Stillman, 2010) The explosion was 100% preventable if necessary actions were taken into affect. The conditions of the coal mine was deadly. There were reports of miners coughing up clumps of coal dust. There were also reports that cakes of coal dust were plastered to the walls of the mines. (Stillman, 2010) Identify and Explain Four Logistical Alternatives Scanlan Could Have Addressed. Governor Dwight Green appointed both Robert Medill and Driscoll Scanlan in the same year. Scanlan was recommended to Green by his state representative. There were several reports from Scanlan that the Centralia Mine No. 5 as highly explosive. ( U.S. Mine Rescue Association, 2012) The reason the mine was highly explosive is because of the coal dust buildup. Two year before the occurrence of the explosion, Frank Perez who was a mine inspector from the U.S. Bureau of Mines, conducted a federal inspection of Centralia Mine. ( U.S. Mine Rescue Association, 2012) Perez and Scalan reports of the Centralia mine were very similar. ( U.S. Mine Rescue Association, 2012) That......

Words: 1717 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Virginia Class Submarine

...Navy). Although the Seawolf is thought to be better than the Virginia Class (The US Navy), the Virginia class is the best solution to the Navy’s needs at the lowest cost. Every vessel that the United States has ever created all have a common purpose, to complete a specific mission effectively. Whenever a new task or problem occurs, a need for a new vessel arises if no other vessel can complete the mission effectively. In the case of the Virginia Class, the mission of the 774 Class is to implement “open-ocean and littoral covert operations” through the execution of the following missions: Squadron and Expeditionary aid, Anti-Surface Warfare (ASUW), Anti-Submarine Warfare (ASW), Intelligence gathering and observation, and warfare such as mine, strike, special and electronic (US Navy, SSN 774). The necessity of the Virginia Class came about because of the retirement of the very old and technologically inferior Los Angeles Class. The Virginia Class Submarine is faster, quieter and more technologically advanced than the forty-four year old design of the SSN-688 Class. The Virginia Class is like no other submarine in the world, being built in sections and then being welded together (O'Rourke). With this new process of using standardized pieces, the SSN-774 Class uses about forty percent less parts than the Seawolf Class. With only 17,963 parts versus 45,000 parts, the Virginia Class is much easier to construct, as well as faster to build (U.S. Department of Defense). After the......

Words: 1352 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Audience Paper

...“Knowing your Audience” By: Nicholas Findlow August 16, 2013 When reading about an accident or and incident you have to think about everyone that is involved and how that may affect them. Whether it be towards the family or the company that it effects. It may be difficult to explain everything because when you do have to explain these things you will not have all the answers. When reading “Miners Trapped At Giant Freeport Mine in Papua” and “Over 30 Workers Trapped After Chilean Copper Mine” it was rather difficult for me to think of how I would personally address the family or the company about these situations. First off I think that I would speak with the families individually because I understand that each case would be different. Such as going to there homes, sitting them down and telling them that we are doing our best to get to the trapped miners and safely bring them home. The biggest thing that I feel we would offer to the families is support and up to day information on the process of rescuing these people. “ I am deeply saddened to have to come and speak with you today. At 1:00 p.m. this afternoon the eastern tunnel collapsed and your husband was one of the men trapped by the collapsed tunnel. We are doing everything we can to safely rescue him and the other men trapped. We completely understand your concern and are here to support you during this difficult time. If there is......

Words: 778 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Bristol Bay, Alaska - "Salmon or Gold"

...Bristol Bay, Alaska "Salmon or Gold" Can you imagine living in a geographical area in which traditions, language, rituals, and economic sustainability hasn't changed in over 1,000 years? A place inhabited by indigenous people that have lived in harmony with nature only taking what is needed to sustain their lifestyles and having the innate wisdom to keep this resource in balance to ensure continued prosperity? Did you realize that there are still people living in areas here on earth that live without the modern day conveniences such as fast food, malls, and outlet stores? People that rely on bartering and exporting their resource to trade for clothes, shoes, and other items to sustain their way of living and to ensure that their traditions and way of life will continue for generations to follow? As the world becomes smaller, even people that have remained unchanged for thousands of years are being forced to deal with changes that will alter their future and their traditions because of living near valuable resources that are in high demand in our modern day world. And, like so many indigenous people from history, they are desperately praying, advocating, and becoming very political with their fight so that their way of life can continue without disruption to their ecosystems. Native to the area of Bristol Bay, Alaska for thousands of years, the Yupik people have depended on salmon, along with pike, whitefish, beavers, caribou, moose, berries, and plants. Bristol Bay......

Words: 1107 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

The Choice

...The Choice A. The text is about a man called Michael Dillon and his wife Moira Dillon who are taken prisoner in their own home one night by IRA men. In the morning the captor tells Michael what to do: He is told to drive to the hotel which he’s the manager of, park the car in his reserved parking place and then leave the hotel again. Michael guesses that there’s a bomb in his car and he gets really nervous, but the captor threats him with killing his wife if he does anything wrong. He drives to the hotel and parks the car in his reserved parking place. Through the window he sees that a man called Pottinger is going to deliver his speak of religious hatred. He realizes that his car, with the bomb, is parked right under the head table where Pottinger is going to be and he understands that the whole plan is killing Pottinger. As he walks away he looks inside the hotel and sees a lot of innocent people who had families at home. He walks across the road till a wee shop and asks for a telephone. He rings the police who tell him to alarm the hotel and so he do. Then he drives home in a borrowed car to see if his wife is still alive. She is but she is not glad. B. Michael Dillon is in a huge dilemma. On the one hand he will not risk the life of his wife but on the other hand a lot of innocent people will die because of the lack of deed from his side, if he does not ring the police as soon as possible. I think he changed his mind and start to think about how he could ring......

Words: 747 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

George Tate

...Abstract The Blast in Central No.5: A Mine Disaster, which No One Stopped, was a case that John B. Martin shared how this event made history and is known today as a very tragic event that occurred in the coal mine near the town of Centralia, Illinois. This tragic event bought the concern of mine safety and health concerns, which both were results in an explosion when an under burdened shot or blown-out shot ignited coal dust which 111 of the 142 men were killed. After the event many still question who could be blamed for this tragic event and how this tragic event could have been prevented. The Centralia Mine opened in 1907 and remained free of fatal accidents for decades (.www.city.centralia.il.us) This is the same mine that during World War II, provided coal to the war effort. By the 1940’s the mine that was once free of all issues began to have concerns surface. The mine inspectors began reporting excessive coal dust in the mines and also provided recommendations to rectify the issue. Driscoll Scanlan was the inspector of the district that included Centralia Mine No. 5 at this time. Scanlan was also familiar with the mine environment due to the fact that was a former miner. Scanlan inspected the mine every 3 months. Each time he reported the severity of the coal dust buildup in the mine. Although Scanlan inspected the mine several times in the years before the explosion and documentation that was made concerned many due to the issues that he found in his through......

Words: 1624 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

The End of Salt... or Not

...The end of Salt… or Not There were many aspects to our class that I found interested and engaging, even for one who has never been fond of history education. For so many years I have never been able to appreciate the founding of historical beings, artifacts, traditions, and even religion. I did enjoy our text that we were given this year; it was easy to read, didn’t bore me, gave illustrations that were factual but also entertaining, and also intrigued my mind. So many things in our age we take advantage of, we have no idea where things originated from, and in all honesty may be the wrong direction in which most of our generation and future generation are choosing to go in. Salt for example, I would have never thought to be such a significant mineral, or asset to a particular era or development of. I first have to address the way in which the author of our salt reading wrote. She was funny, educational, and I would think appealing to most readers. Maybe to some it seemed insignificant but to me it made me begin to look at the littlest of things and wonder where, when, and why did it originate. Salt was the beginning of something huge for this time. As we learned it was the most common commodity used in its times. As I spoke about in my first journal entry, the Egyptians using Nortran to preserve those that passed bodies, they also used it for fresh food so that it would not spoil.  Most importantly while reading I began to see how the importance of trade became....

Words: 1037 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Dead Men

...Sixteen Dead Men By William Butler Yeats O but we talked at large before The sixteen men were shot, But who can talk of give and take, What should be and what not While those dead men are loitering there To stir the boiling pot? You say that we should still the land Till Germany’s overcome; But who is there to argue that Now Pearse is deaf and dumb? And is their logic to outweigh MacDonagh’s bony thumb? How could you dream they’d listen That have an ear alone For those new comrades they have found, Lord Edward and Wolfe Tone, Or meddle with our give and take That converse bone to bone? “Man down, Man down”. A frightened voice screamed from miles away. Another hero gone, I thought silently. I glanced over at Gerry. He stood tall like a man of six foot height as he loaded up the truck ready for battle. His deep blue eyes had dark rings around them which extenuated when he is tired. “See you soon mate”, he limped into the truck drove off. That was the last time I ever saw Gerry again. The missiles struck, screaming in with pinpoint accuracy, bursting with blinding flashes, brighter than a thousand suns. Buildings disintegrated and vanished. Trees and houses exploded into flames. The flames were so fierce that they devoured all the oxygen around them suffocating those people who had sought refuge in deep shelters. The very ground trembled from the mighty screams of those who were attacked or injured. I stayed there in the same......

Words: 1328 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Combat Engineering

...around the battlefield. Combat engineers typically support this role through reduction of enemy obstacles which include point and row minefields, anti-tank ditches, wire obstacles, concrete and metal anti-vehicle barriers and wall and door breaching in urban terrain. Mechanized combat engineer units also have armored vehicles capable of laying short bridges for limited gap-crossing. * Clearing terrain obstacles * Overcoming trenches and ditches * Opening routes for armored fighting vehicles * Constructing roads and bridges Countermobility Building obstacles to prevent the enemy from moving around the battlefield. Destroying bridges, blocking roads, creating airstrips, digging trenches, etc. Can also include planting land mines and anti-handling devices when authorized and directed to do so. When the defender must retreat it is often desirable to destroy anything that may be of use to the enemy, particularly...

Words: 655 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Power Tower

...Power Tower in an Open Pit Mine: called a “Pit Power Tower” (PPT). | | By Jonathan Gwiazda and Francis A. DiBella | 1. Introduction1.2 Problem Statement The number of people and the amount of technology in the world are on the rise. People and technology both require energy. This rise in population and technology has led to a corresponding increase in energy demand. This trend is unlikely to change in the foreseeable future.The three primary methods of power production today are 1) fossil fuels, such as coal or natural gas, 2) hydroelectric dams, and 3) nuclear power. The undeveloped potential of each of these power methods is restricted by either the associated environmental impact or by the limits of the resource itself. Current methods of power production are in need of supplementation. An ideal source would be renewable and have minimal environmental impact. This paper presents one such method.1.3 Overview and Scope < A href="http://ljb.advertserve.com/servlet/click/zone?zid=29&pid=2&lookup=true&position=1" target="_top">< IMG src="http://ljb.advertserve.com/servlet/view/banner/image/zone?zid=29&pid=2&position=1" height="240" width="120" hspace="0" vspace="0" border="0" alt="Click Here!">< /A> | The paper begins with the background and description of the proposed power source, its advantages, and a tabular outline of three example sites. Concerns for each component of the system are briefly considered. The paper ends with......

Words: 4934 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Assignment

...BLAW 2006 Company Law BLAW 2006 COMPANY LAW FOR BUSINESS SUMMER SCHOOL – 2015 ASSIGNMENT In February, Butch made the decision that he was going to register a company to own and operate a diamond mine. He estimated that the company would need to raise $20M by way of a share issue and he planned to approach the members of his golf club, which has 100 wealthy members. Butch considered that the company would only need $10M of the $20M in the initial exploration phase but would require the further $10M in the critical operational phase that would follow. Butch was uncertain as to the type of company he should register. He planned to be the Managing Director of the company and to have his close friend Patsy as Chairman. Butch wanted to keep the affairs of the company confidential and retain control of its management but without the large amount of capital required, the company would not be able to undertake its objectives. In April, Butch contracted with some mining engineers to assist with the mining operations in October. Butch signed the contract with the mining engineers as “agent of Diamond Pty Ltd”. In June, Butch registered Diamond Pty Ltd with no constitution. Ralph is a shareholder in Diamond Pty Ltd. Ralph becomes aware that the directors of the company are considering the creation of a constitution with the following rules: i) that no director may be removed from office by the members; ii) that members may only appoint directors of the......

Words: 621 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Globla Ethics

...Since the publication of Kenneth Waltz’s Theory of International Politics in 1979, the classical school of realism, which suggests that state actions are driven by self-interest only, has been challenged by the school of “neoliberal institutionalism” and the idea that constructivism is a formidable school of thought in itself. This essay challenges the idea that “institutions” or “norms” guide the international system, rather arguing that classical realism, with elements of offensive realism, is what truly drives the international system, with states being the primary actors. While non-state actors (“NSA”) and transnational civil society is recognized as playing a part, it will be argued that it is ultimately the states that make the decisions. To this end the analysis will be from two different perspectives; the campaign against the anti-personnel landmines and the signing of the Ottawa treaty; and the rise of China despite ignoring “international norms” regarding human rights. Thus the analysis will be, first, an issue-based analysis and then an actor-based analysis. Landmines and the Ottawa Treaty Landmines have traditionally been used as an effective tool to prevent attacks by the enemy. Yet the downfall of having such a weapon in one’s arsenal is obvious, the weapon is indiscriminating; once set up it cannot and does not distinguish between soldier and civilian, thus leading to great civilian casualty and therefore seemingly going against the principles of just war ...

Words: 800 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Abcdef

...that for decrease the environmental damage caused by uranium mining, the rehabilitation method and strict regulation are should be carried out by every mine owners in Australia. One of the previous study also showed that the Ranger uranium mine has fulfilled the proper tailing control and has had great water management system for every Northern Territory’s mine companies to cover the tailings and waste rock produced by uranium grounds (Harries, et al, 1997). In addition, by this rehabilitation method it could modify the prior environment hazards, for instance it was found an uranium mines was reinstated under modern accurate environmental controls in Nabarlek, Northern Territory (Hancock, et al, 2006). Despite the fact that there is a rehabilitation method and strict regulation enforced by Australian Government with the aim to control the environmental damage, nevertheless nowadays the environmental problem from uranium grounds still exist, the improvement for reduce the damage was not completely success. It has been proofed that the water level to release the uranium wasted was 450 times higher than entire Australian drinking water level (Wu, et al, 2007). Furthermore, critics said the rehabilitation method was a successful story, where this statement could not be verified. For a case, the restoration of Radium Hill uranium mine in South of Australia still contaminated by soil which this caused hugely unpleasant effect on animals and the worst case it result in death of......

Words: 306 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Kakadu

...CHAPTER 2 Kakadu National Park – The Place and its People 2.1 Kakadu – The Place 2.2 Kakadu – The People 2.3 Inscription on the World Heritage List 2.4 Mission Visit Conclusion 13 Kakadu National Park – The Place and its People CHAPTER TWO: KAKADU NATIONAL PARK—THE PLACE AND ITS PEOPLE In this chapter the Australian Government gives an historical, social and cultural background to the Park. This context is necessary to be able to assess claims that the World Heritage area is under threat. The chapter describes: • • • • • • • The history of the Park The fact that from its beginnings the Park co-existed with Aboriginal land owning interests, mining interests, and tourism interests The history of the town of Jabiru and the mechanisms to ensure that it does not harm the values of the Park The history of the mining enclaves located in the region The management principles of Kakadu National Park The role of traditional owners in the Park Its inscription on the list of World Heritage Only with the full appreciation of the way in which Kakadu National Park came into existence and was entered onto the World Heritage listing in three stages, is it possible to assess the impact of the Jabiluka proposal on the overall values and attributes of Kakadu National Park. 2.1 2.1.1 KAKADU—THE PLACE History of the Park Aboriginal people have been associated with the area of land now known as Kakadu National Park for a very long time. Archaeological evidence suggests......

Words: 6408 - Pages: 26

Premium Essay

Pike River Case

...RIVER COAL MINE: THE DISASTER REPORT ON FAILURE OF THE PROJECT Prepared By: Atul Srivastava Stu ID- 14854045 05 Oct 2015 Table of Contents Executive Summery ………………………………………………………………………… 1. Introduction ………………………………………………………………………… 2. Methodology ………………………………………………………………………… 2.1 Factors contributed to project failure ………………………………………… 2.2 Failure of theories behind Pike tragedy ……………………………………… 3. Conclusion …………………………………………………………………………… References Executive Summery  Pike river coal mine was operated by Pike River Coal 46 km (29 mi) north-east of Greymouth in the West Coast Region of New Zealand's South Island.   Pike River Coal Company Ltd (Pike) was formed in 1982 and acquired by New Zealand Oil & Gas Ltd (NZOG) in 1998 as the major shareholder. It was initially expected to produce around one million tonnes of coal per year for around 20 years, making the mine the second-largest coal export mine in the country, as well as the largest underground coal mine of the country. Because of various technical glitch and poor forecasting of the management, the whole project was delayed. The Delayed timeframe, lower production rate of coal has increased the financial pressure as it was proven to be as over-promised and under-delivered. On Friday the 19th November 2010 an underground explosion occurred at the Pike River Mine that resulted in the deaths of twenty- nine men. Over the ensuing nine days, three more explosions propagated through the mine.......

Words: 3100 - Pages: 13