Free Essay

Change of Management

In: Business and Management

Submitted By mum2myboyz
Words 1506
Pages 7
The Blast in Centralia No. 5 Megan Moore Mr. Joseph McCue Modern Public Administration October 23, 2011

The explosion at Centralia No 5 was a great tragedy in the State of Illinois that created over 90 widows and 70 fatherless children. Unfortunately, it was a tragedy that could have been avoided had action been taken sooner. Today it is easy to be shocked and appalled that this would have happened. However, looking at this from a worldview in the 21st Century is not the same as looking at the events in the worldview of someone in the 1940s. Coal production was once a big business producing thousands of tons of coal a week but at the time of the events in Centralia No 5 production had dropped due to advancement with oil and gas development. The war brought about increased demand for coal. It was in 1909 when a mine fire in Cherry Illinois killed 259 mineworkers that the call for safety and monitored regulations came to the forefront of coal production. (Fleege, A. 2009) Those involved in the coal mining industry knew of the hazards of the trade. Coal dust and gas were the main hazards in mining. In today’s industry these hazards are monitored by different agencies, both public and private, and as it the case in most industrial environments unions and Occupational Safety and Health Administration maintain strict reporting and monitoring procedures. (www.osha.com) Driscoll Scanlon, the inspector assigned to Centralia No 5, did not have the benefit of easy communication and the assistance of multiple agencies. There were procedures to follow and the Department of Mines and Minerals to report to. However, the system appeared to have flaws that cost 111 miners their lives. Few individuals held the position of mine inspector and Driscoll Scanlon was one of sixteen such inspectors. Scanlon spent the majority of his life, from the age of 16, inside a coalmine either as an employee or an inspector. It was well known that being a mine inspector was a position of political patronage. Scanlon studied engineering and was an inspector for a coal company before advancing to inspector. Given that he had risen to one of sixteen state inspectors it would have been well known to him the politics involved within the Department of Mines and Minerals and the way to make the system work to your advantage. He knew that this was not simply a job that he would go to, write a report and leave and that to take action would require more than just paperwork. Standard procedure was to inspect the property, type up a report containing an overview of the inspection and specifying violations in need of immediate or planned attention. The reports were sent to the Department of Mines and Minerals. Once checked typographical errors the report was forwarded, signed and sent to the mine stating that the DMM agreed with the recommendations and that violations should be fixed. The reports were not actually read by those who had the power to make a change and the company controlling the mine was expected to make the corrections without follow up. Scanlon followed the procedures to the letter and had faith that the appropriate action would be taken. He felt an obligation to the miners and to his position to see that the mine managers or those in upper levels of company did not sway his reports. He knew that other inspectors schmoozed with the miners but he had no intention of letting a relationship interfere with the integrity of his reports. He was known for writing long and in-depth reports. He didn’t fraternize with the managers or owners within the mines he was assigned. Scanlon took the words of Governor Dwight H. Green seriously. Green had stated that he would enforce mining regulations to “the letter of the law”. Unfortunately, his administration didn’t get the message. Driscoll Scanlon understood. He did his inspections and he sent his reports. In the case of Centralia No 5 Scanlon realized that there were major violations within the mine and action needed to be taken. However, after years of making the same report and no action being taken Scanlon still did nothing but file his reports. He followed the channels as was instructed and did not vary from it. He made an assumption that if he deviated from the standard procedure that he would either be fired or ignored. Scanlon failed to see that he was in a position to cross the boundaries of political lines. He had been given a position that was as powerful as he chose. He could shut a mine down if he felt passionately enough about it. The biggest mistake of Scanlon’s career would be to not take advantage of his position. He assumed that the system wouldn’t work. Perhaps if he had gone beyond the standard letter action would have been taken. Scanlon met with Local 52 about their concerns and assured them that he had passed along the reports and was as concerned as they were. He did what was expected but didn’t make it happen. He understood that the Governor wanted enforcement and did what he could to inform the department but the department failed to enforce. Scanlon was so aware of the bureaucracy involved in the mining community that he forgot that as one of only sixteen inspectors that enforcement was also his job. It would not have been a convenient trek for Scanlon but if he felt as passionate about the violations as his report seemed then they should have been walked through the agency. Sometimes a person needs to see your passion and not just read your words on paper. Another option would have been for Scanlon to used his power to its fullest. Instead of pushing and taking action he worried about overstepping. He wanted the process to work as it was designed to work. Unfortunately, the process was far from perfect. The question to be asked is; did Scanlon or the Department of Mines and Minerals know the process was flawed? Scanlon could have shut down the mine until the DMM could have inspected the mine personally and not sent another organization to do the job. Scanlon could have also taken advantage of the Unions. The UMWA was accused of not properly training the mineworkers. The UMWA denied that this was their responsibility and claimed it was the responsibility of the company itself. Scanlon could have encouraged the union to appeal to the Governor. The words he spoke were “to the letter of the law”. This obviously was not happening and he needed to be aware. Even in the 1940s unions were powerhouses when the need would arise. Miners in a small mining community did not have a loud voice and it was the responsibility of the union to give them volume. Another option would have been to close the mine. It was within his power to shut the mine down until the corrections had been made. Internal influences were stopping Scanlon from shutting down the mine. Even if shutting down the mine was a temporary solution it would have brought attention to the issues at hand. Today we have many watchdog organizations. They are waiting and watching for someone to not follow the rules and to let the world know that there is danger. However, in the 1940s the media outlets were nothing compared to what there is. There were newspapers and radio shows. It would have been beyond his scope and would most likely have gotten him in trouble with his superiors however the Department of Mines and Minerals and the Governor would have been forced to act upon the violations had the public known before the explosion. It was known that a mining inspector was a position of patronage and this could have been used to his advantage. This mine was located in a small community with limited ways to communicate. Scanlon could have taken advantage of the resources that he had. Driscoll Scanlon was not aggressive enough to tackle such serious violations within the mine. Had he stepped up and used the UMWA, the DMM, Local 52 and Governor Green action would have been taken. If it were possible to bring the leaders of each group together inside the mine and shown the violations first hand by an employee of Centralia No 5, or by Scanlon himself, action would have been taken. When it comes down to it Scanlon was afraid and simply not prepared for the job at hand. He was not responsible for the explosion but he could have stopped it had he confronted the procedure that was so obviously failing the men at Centralia No 5.

Fleege, A. (2009)1947 Centralia Mine Disaster, The. Journal of the Illinois State Historical Society

www.commerce.state.il.us

http://www.legendsofamerica.com/il-zeigler.html

www.osha.com

Stillman, R., (2009). Pubic Administration Concepts and Cases, Mason: Cenage Learning.

http://www.zeigleril.com/pages/zighist.htm

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Change Management

...Change management - the systems and tools for managing change Scope of change management This tutorial provides a summary of each of the main areas for change management based on Prosci's research with more than 900 organizations in the last 7 years. The purpose of defining these change management areas is to ensure that there is a common understanding among readers. Tools or components of change management include: Change management process Readiness assessments Communication and communication planning Coaching and manager training for change management Training and employee training development Sponsor activities and sponsor roadmaps Resistance management Data collection, feedback analysis and corrective action Celebrating and recognizing success Change management process The change management process is the sequence of steps or activities that a change management team or project leader would follow to apply change management to a project or change. Based on Prosci's research of the most effective and commonly applied change, most change management processes contain the following three phases: Phase 1 - Preparing for change (Preparation, assessment and strategy development) Phase 2 - Managing change (Detailed planning and change management implementation) Phase 3 - Reinforcing change (Data gathering, corrective action and recognition) These phases result in the following approach as shown below in Figure 1. Figure 1 - Change Management Process...

Words: 1289 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Change Management

...Change Management MGT 426 July 29, 2013 Change Management The roles of managers and individuals in change management are often intertwined; the organizational arrangement consistently seeks to engage both individual employees and his or her management teams in the course of organizational change. The goal of this is to engage employees and encourage them to adopt a new way of functioning in their careers, and it often falls to the management team specifically tasked with change management to make this process as painless as possible. The change management process usually consists of five parts: the change management team, executives, senior managers, middle managers, supervisors, the project teams, and the project support level (Change Management Learning Center, 2013). When each manages to fulfill their roles, healthy change occurs at the individual employee level, and the change is often successful. The change management team is responsible for developing the change management strategy and plans and is integral to the success of the change. The executives and senior managers launch the changes set forth by the change management team and are known as sponsors for the change. The middle managers and front-line supervisors coach their direct reports through the changes that will imprint on their day-to-day work. The project team manages the technical side of change, and integrates change management into the project plans. The project support functions support the different...

Words: 944 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Change Management

...The psychology of change: understanding the guiding principles of effective change management Most change management models in use today are in the form of a process or set of steps. In fact, the most effective processes or methodologies are based on research and the experiences of change management experts from years of trial and error in the field. However, the underlying lessons and principles that produced these change management processes and tools are not always clear to the practitioner (especially if you are new to the field of change management). In many cases, the guiding principles and lessons-learned are not even discussed as part of the model or tools. The result: you learn the how but not the why. The years of practical experience and knowledge that formed the basis for these processes are not readily available to a person trying to make them work in a specific situation. This new tutorial series goes beyond the activities and tasks of managing change for one simple reason: understanding the “why” makes you better at doing the “how.” Change management is not a matter of simply following steps. No two changes are exactly alike, nor are any two organizations. Following a recipe for change management is insufficient to drive business results. The right approach will be specific to the situation. If you do not understand the why behind your actions as a change management practitioner, changes can fail even when reputable change management processes are followed...

Words: 1907 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Change Management

...Change Management in British Airways Name Class Affiliation Instructor Date Table of Contents Introduction 3 Context of the change 3 Evaluation of the nature of such changes 4 The change management strategy 5 The challenges and difficulties in implementing such changes 6 Change management model 8 Stakeholders 10 Managerial challenges 11 Overcoming resistance to change 12 Managing change 12 Conclusion 14 Reference 16 Introduction UK largest international Airline, British Airways, is among the leading airlines in the world, with one of the most extensive route network, running internationally (British Airways, 2010). The income of the airline has been on the increase with the profits for the period between 2007 and 2008 being a total of £8,753, which translated to 3.1% more than the previous period. Throughout its operating years, British Airways has faced different challenges, as it is for all other companies in the industry. During the year 2007, the American economy experienced a crunch due to the bursting of the housing market. This was the beginning part of the 2008 economic crisis, or recession, which had global effects (Åslund, 2010). Like any other industry, the UK airline industry faced a major setback, British Airways being one of the companies and there was a need to implement changes for long company survival. This paper is an analysis of the changes implemented by the British Airways in the period between...

Words: 4043 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Change Management

...Change Management Brenda Macy American InterContinental University December 13, 2015 Abstract The world is an ever changing entity. As a business owner, you will need to keep up with those changes for success within your business. There are 3 areas of change to be considered when changing the organizational culture, the technology, the structure, and the people. Sometimes resistance is met when change is introduced in the workplace. To manage that change, models of change management are introduced to make the transition a smooth process. Two of those models are discussed here. Lewin’s Change Management Model, and Kotter’s 8 Step Change Model (Normandin, 2012). Change Management No matter the size of your business or what kind of business you are in, all businesses have the common element of change. Change can come from the introduction of new technology, new structure within the organization or by the people (Normandin, 2012). The world is changing on a fast track and to succeed in business, organizations must be on the fast track of change as well. Failing to implement a successful change within the organization can cause failure of the business (EditorialBoard, 2011). A psychologist name Kurt Lewin created a change model for understanding organizational change. It is the Unfreeze, Transition, Refreeze change model. In step one, the need for change is recognized and preparing the organization that the change is needed, and effective communication of the...

Words: 701 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Change Management

... Group 1 CHANGE MANAGEMENT INTRODUCTION In a world that is increasingly fast paced and ever changing, the change management process is an integral part of any organization and manager. Whether planning a large fundamental change or a smaller incremental one, change must be planned and executed correctly and the following change management process will give direction in terms of content needed for successful transformation. It is an organizational process aimed at helping change stakeholders to accept and embrace changes in their business environment. Change management has typically been defined as a process involving unfreezing, moving, and refreezing values, practices, and procedures within organizations. Unfreezing refers to the creation of a perceived discrepancy between the existing and ideal state of an organization that generates a desire for change and lowers people’s resistance to change. Moving refers to the various processes such as training, education, and restructuring that lead to the development of new behaviors, attitudes, and beliefs. Refreezing regards re-establishing a new state of equilibrium within the organization by stabilizing the new patterns through a variety of support mechanisms. OBJECTIVES • Review the basics of change management and how change affects us all. • Understand that change is a continuous process. • Focus on the Transformation programmers’ and identify what changes will occur and how they can be...

Words: 3822 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Change Management

...ADKAR: Knowledge, Ability and Reinforcement making the change An overview of Prosci's ADKAR Model Prosci's ADKAR® Model is one of the most widely-requested and sought after models for change management. It is a simple but extraordinarily powerful model to help drive successful change in one's personal or professional life. Many attendees of Prosci's 3-day certification program call it "ADKAR training" - even though the majority of the program focuses on the organizational change management process - because ADKAR is what they remember and begin applying immediately. The first tutorial in this series provided five reasonswhy ADKAR "clicks" for change management practitioners. The second tutorial provided an overview of the first two building blocks -Awareness and Desire. This tutorial presents an in-depth discussion of the last three building blocks - Knowledge, Ability and Reinforcement.    Introduction Prosci's ADKAR Model is an individual change management model. It outlines the five building blocks of successful change, whether that change occurs at home, in the community or at work. The name "ADKAR" is an acronym based on the five building blocks: *   A   Awareness of the need for change *   D   Desire to participate and support the change *   K   Knowledge on how to change *   A   Ability to implement required skills and behaviors *   R   Reinforcement to sustain the change   The final three building blocks of Prosci's ADKAR Model are Knowledge...

Words: 1365 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Change Management

...and understanding of change management: Change management is a process of a continuous development of an organisations structure, capability and direction to serve the changing business environment as well as changing needs of customers (Moran & Brightmen, 2001). For both operational and strategically level of an organisation change is essential. There are number of change management model and theories have been evolved over time in order to successfully implement change in an organisation. The three step model of change is the considered as the first step of change. This three step model has three different components; 1. Unfreeze, 2. Freeze and 3. Refreeze. The unfreezing process model concentrates on breaking organisations current regulations so that changes can be brought. Moreover, the second step on the other hand is the implementation of the change and the third step explains the acceptance of change. The first step however, was taken into consideration so that employees are not resistant to change and make more acceptable way of doing things for the organisation. (Lewin, 1947). The third step on the other hand and the final step of the change which attempts the institutionalisation of new behaviour. However, the three step model thought to be too simple and has ignored many facts that impact change in an organisation. According to Lewis (2003), Kazmi (2013), the three step model of Lewin’s is the base of many later theories of change, but it’s too simplistic...

Words: 1322 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Change Management

...Contents Introduction Task 1 – Examine the past performance of your company to identify areas with the need for change. 2 3-4 Task 2 – Discuss any three models of change and evaluate their relevance of these models to contemporary organizations in Myanmar economy. Assess the value of using strategic intervention techniques in organizations. Determine the efficacy of applying these models to your organization. 5-7 Task 3 – Develop a change management strategy for your organization that involves stakeholders and a strategy for managing resistance to change. Formulate and evaluate a system to involve stakeholders in the planning of change. 8-9 Task 4 – Create an appropriate model for change in your organization and draw a plan to implement and develop measures to monitor it. 10-11 References 1|Page Delta Net Media Company is one of the largest and most innovative Media (Paid Satellite TV Network) & Internet Service Provider Company in Myanmar. Delta Net offer consumers in two different categories, DTH – Direct to Home satellite television network and MPS – Multi Play Services which adds satellite broadband internet to television network service. Delta Net is providing these services nationwide in Myanmar. It was launched in November 2010 and started with total 48 channels including sports, entertainment, news, movies, music so on and later expands to 83 channels as of 2013 and keep expanding the network to provide varieties of channels for consumers to...

Words: 3364 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Change Management

...Change ManageMent Defining Change Management Change management has typically been defined as a process involving unfreezing, moving, and refreezing values, practices, and procedures within organizations.1 Unfreezing refers to the creation of a perceived discrepancy between the existing and ideal state of an organization that generates a desire for change and lowers people’s resistance to change. Moving refers to the various processes mechanisms. Change and Resistance Change is often resisted by organizational members. The primary reason for resistance is that change requires employees to alter their existing individual and organizational identities. Changing one’s identity can be anxiety provoking and it is common for employees to use strategies such as denial, rationalization, idealization, fantasy, and symbolization to resist change.2 The Role of Communication in Change Initiatives Communication is key to developing change initiatives and implementing them. Communication can serve many functions during change initiatives.3 • Information sharing: Communication may be used to announce organizational changes and to provide stakeholders with information about the nature, timing, and significance of the change. • Participation: Change agents may create communication processes that actively involve lower-level employees in the planning and implementation of change initiatives or may construct communication processes that emphasize the role of upper-level management and limit...

Words: 732 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Change Management

...http://www.authenticityconsulting.com Requirements for Successful Organizational Change Cummings and Worley (Organization Development and Change, 1995) describe a comprehensive, five-phase, general process for managing change, including: 1) motivating change, 2) creating vision, 3) developing political support, 4) managing the transition and 5) sustaining momentum. That process seems suitable for organizing and describing general guidelines about managing change. Whatever model you choose to use when guiding organizational change, that model should include the priorities and areas of emphasis described in the following five phases of change. The collaborative consulting model described integrates highlights from all of the five phases. Motivating Change This phase includes creating a readiness for change in your client organization and developing approaches to overcome resistance to change. General guidelines for managing this phase include enlightening members of the organization about the need for change, expressing the current status of the organization and where it needs to be in the future, and developing realistic approaches about how change might be accomplished. Next, organization leaders need to recognize that people in the organization are likely to resist making major changes for a variety of reasons, including fear of the unknown, inadequacy to deal with the change and whether the change will result in an adverse effect on their jobs. People need to feel that their...

Words: 1177 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Change Management

...According to Leedy (2009), change management has been defined as an organized, systematic application of the knowledge, tools, and resources of change that provides organizations with a key process to achieve their business strategy. Nel et al (2004) says, change is an ever-present feature of organisational life, both at an operational and strategic level. Therefore, there should be no doubt regarding the importance to any organisation of its ability to identify where it needs to be in the future, and how to manage the changes required getting there. Organisation seeks for a change due to various reasons ranging from to earn the profit to make more benefit in a business. But due to various reasons they face problems of low level of success in their change efforts. Either from the point of view of employees or by the point of view of management. According to Daft (1994), organisations sense a need for change when they perceive a performance gap, that is, a disparity between existing and desired levels of performance. It seems a somewhat narrow definition in that it implies all change is planned and positive and seems to ignore the possibility of unplanned and potentially negative change - for example, unexpected budget cuts. This said, most change is planned, is intended to be positive and arises from the need to respond to new challenges and opportunities (Mullins, 1996). In response to, or in anticipation of such factors, organisations may initiate change. This can incorporate both...

Words: 2300 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Change Management

...MANAGEMENT OF CHANGE INTRODUCTION It is said that the only constant thing in life is change. This means that change is to be expected in all aspects of life yet most people find it difficult to adapt to change. Change is so fundamental to all things in the world that it is the most important obstacle to overcome in a game of survival of the fittest. It is constant for all times. Those who adapt to change evolve and become better like the butterfly while those who resist become extinct like the dinosaur. Bill Gates, the founder of Microsoft, believes that people who are reactive and let change overwhelm them or pass them by will perceive change negatively. But those who are proactive seek to understand change and embrace it; the idea of something new is positive, exciting and uplifting. Organisations that have realized the inevitability of change have accepted the onerous tasks of managing it. This unchallengeable fact may have been the reason behind the craving by many to understand change, as a phenomenon from wider and deeper perspectives. Consequently, this perhaps, has attracted to the field of management, a flood of change theories and practices. Peter Drucker defined Management as a multipurpose organ that manages a business, managers, workers and work, while Peterson and Plowman defined Management as the process by which purpose and objectives of a particular human group are determined, clarified and effectuated. According to Harold Koontz, "Management is the art...

Words: 5051 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Change Management

...Analyzing failures in change management According to me, Change is an inevitable part of any business. Successful change management is a key to success of any business. Over the years, companies have put their best efforts to manage change in the organization. Alongside organizations’ efforts, researches in the field have been extensive to ensure progress in this area. Despite of all these efforts, organizational change has not reached the success rate which is vital. Complex change processes and the most advanced technologies have shown very marginal improvement in change management. Failure of change leads to a number of factors. Out of all, few are found common and critical to most of the cases. They are discussed in this article. It is found that rather than technology and processes, commitment of the people involved and knowledge from experience plays more important role in change management. Organizational change covers most of the business functions in any organization. Change can be a little change in the system or a large scale change in the business environment which change the complete structure of the business (Allena et al., 2007). It is clear that larger the change, more the impact on business. Along with that there are more complications in the change as it gets bigger. Change management becomes more and more important with the increasing size of change (Weber et al., 2008). In the past, organizations have tried delivering change at their best. They have...

Words: 2972 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Change Management

...|Managing change | |Managing Change - McDonalds | |McDonalds | | | |By: Dangermin Field | |HR587 Managing Organizational Change | K Milburn 29 May 2011 |This document brings into picture the change that took place in McDonalds | Table of Contents Executive Summary Assessment/Diagnosis Analysis of the Change Strategy Results/Outcomes Evaluation of the Effort Discussion and Conclusion Works Cited Appendix Introduction: ‘You can change without improving, but you cannot improve without changing!’ In today’s fast growing and highly competitive environment everyone wants to stay...

Words: 1913 - Pages: 8