Free Essay

Child Labor

In: Social Issues

Submitted By jinhun226
Words 4285
Pages 18
Role of States and IOs in Reduction of Child Labor: Analysis Based on Abolitionist and Protectionist Approaches

Jin Hun An
2013470001
International Organizations
18 June 2013

Child Labor – Overview and Definition
Overview
Globalization embodies a process of recurring interaction between diverse actors in pursuit of collective goals. With a rise of new technology, a concept of time and space has diminished, and 21st century has seen economic success and increasing numbers of transnational activities. Growing influence of global civil society and cross-border social movements demonstrate how people in the contemporary era seek ways to bring about mutual benefits in hopes of closing gaps between developed and developing countries. (Baylis, Smith, & Owens, 2011) Nevertheless, severe poverty, human rights violations, as well as child labor issues are still prevalent in many developing countries. Worst of all, women and children are victims of governmental apathy and corruption in most persecuted communities.
Children in developing countries with ill-constructed welfare system undergo extreme poverty and malnourishment. For their families’ survival, children under the age of fourteen work for the whole day, and they do not have any spare time to go to schools. Pakrashi (2009) has demonstrated a vicious cycle of child labor trap in Sub-Saharan Africa and Asia:
“Despite the high private rate of return to primary education, in Sub-Saharan Africa and Asia, many families are unable to afford their children’s education because of the prevalence of credit constraints. The inability of the parents to defray even a small amount of money may give rise to child labor.”

Poverty and child labor issues are not problems that have newly emerged in the contemporary era. Developed nations have experienced these issues during a process of their development in the 19th century. With successful economic growth, they have gradually eradicated them. Rampant poverty and child labor that we see today is considered as a historic recurrence, and they do not meet Westerners’ expectations of “sustainable improvements in the quality of life for all people” (Pakrashi, 2009). A process of elimination of child labor today has slowed down due to the global economic recession. International Labor Organization (ILO) urged more efforts to stimulate global campaign in order to end the practice. According to Global Report on child labor, “ child laborers had declined from 222 million to 215 million, or 3 per cent, over the period 2004 to 2008” (ILO, 1996). Thus, advocacy groups, Intergovernmental organizations, and social movements have called for global support for elimination (ILO, 1996). Definition Child labor that needs to be eradicated does not refer to all work done by children. When their work do not affect their “health and personal development or interfere with their schooling,” they do not fit the negative notion of child labor (ILO, 1996). Children sometimes assist their parents with housework and take a part in building family businesses without their working hours affecting primary education. This is indeed a beneficial experience for children, because they learn to be productive within their communities. On the other hand, ILO (1996) applies the term child labor when work “is mentally, physically, socially or morally dangerous and harmful to children; and interferes with their schooling by; depriving them of the opportunity to attend school; obliging them to leave school prematurely; or requiring them to attempt to combine school attendance with excessively long and heavy work.”
When child labor is engaged in enslavement, separation from families, and misplacement of children on the streets, ILO experts refer to it as the most extreme forms of child labor. “Article 3 of ILO Convention No. 182” has set the criteria that defines the worst forms of child labor. In such forms, conditions of working area of children are the most hazardous (Smolin, 2000).

History of Child Labor in the Western World Developed countries have successfully eliminated worst forms of child labor. Britain serves as a useful example to illustrate how they have carried out gradual eradication of child labor, because many other nations adopted their policies (Pierik and Houwezijl, 2006). In the early stage of industrialization, child labor played a critical role in large production of factory manufactures. Severe poverty at the time contributed to abundance of child labor. In fact, development of legal protection slowly took place: “although protective legislation on so-called pauper children was enacted in 1767, it took until 1833 before the working conditions of all children in the textile industry were regulated” (Pierik and Houwezijl, 2006). In 1867, medical inspection was set in place for children working in factories. From late 19th to early 20th century, the minimum age for child labor was gradually raised from ten to fifteen. In 1870, law enforced children between five and thirteen to receive proper education. In sum, legal protection of child labor gradually reduced working time and enabled children to work at improved conditions (Doepke and Zilibotti, 2005). Employers initially refused to accept legislative protection, because they believed that decline of child labor would eventually cause loss of competitive advantage in production of goods against foreign competitors. Nevertheless, government has successfully implemented legislation that protected children at the most dangerous working conditions. In 1914, the government enacted law that forbade children under twelve from working (Basu & Hoang Van, 1998). Child labor issues in the developed countries during the early period of industrialization manifest historical lessons. Even though economic, social, and political contexts at the time differ vastly from those of today, it is generally agreed that extreme poverty is a major cause of child labor. Poverty reduction is closely linked to decline in child labor, because “the main factors that facilitated the reduction in child labor were economic growth, technological and managerial changes, and the increase of adult earnings” (Pierik and Houwezijl, 2006). It is important to note that improvement of quality of lives did not come abruptly, but gradually. One of the reasons for slow mechanism was lack of political commitment of the governments. Thus, governmental support is essential in promoting effective prohibition of child labor (Smolin, 2000).

Child Labor in developing countries today A core cause of child labor in the developing countries today is extreme poverty (ILO, 1996). A decrease in per capita GDP is correlated with increase in child labor. It is difficult for poor families to stop sending children to work, because alternatives are hunger and starvation of the whole families. Pierik and Houwezijl (2006) have put it,
“This is the main reason why targeted boycotts of the products of child labor turn out to be counterproductive (at least in the short term): they focus, in a limited geographical area, only on the effects of child labor—its products—but typically fail to investigate the structural reasons for the occurrence of child labor—namely, poverty.”
Thus, taking jobs away from these children without understanding fundamental principle of the child labor can only send them to worse and less-paid jobs. Prohibition on child labor works well when adult wages increase at the same time, and this would most likely happen if “all regulators, importers, and consumers of products in the world would be able to effectively support such a policy” (Pierik and Houwezijl, 2006). In this case, enforcement of legislative act on banning child labor will increase public welfare and improve quality of lives in the end. However, such adaptation will doubtfully take place in near future. Developing countries usually have weak central governments, and thus law enforcement cannot adequately be put in place. Another determinant of child labor is availability of education. Elimination of child labor has intention of returning children to schools from dangerous working factories. If education is not available in downtrodden communities, prohibition will not effectively improve their lives’ quality (ILO, 1996). Developing countries today have weak educational infrastructure to provide sufficient schooling to children when they are free from work. School fees are in most cases not affordable by the families residing in poor communities. Well-funded and qualified schools have not been built to provide high-valued education. Without fair and qualified education available to these children, sending children to schools is not a viable alternative. Therefore, poverty and lack of availability of education challenge Western advocacy groups or intergovernmental organizations and prevent them from effectively prohibiting child labor in the developing countries (ILO, 1996).

General Background on International Labor Organization (ILO) In 1919, the Treaty of Versailles formed the International Labor Organization (ILO). Since then, it has become a formal international organization that monitors and reports on child labor violations. The Conference, which is the major body of the organization, includes all the member states. Each member state in the Conference is consisted of two government representative, one employer representative, and one worker representative. “Since its creation, the ILO has always had a tripartite structure including governments, employers, and workers’ groups” (Ho, 2006). The Governing Body manages decision-making processes. A number of representatives for member states of the Governing Body equal those of the Conference (ILO, 1996). The tripartite structure of the ILO makes it particularly effective in monitoring and reporting on child rights violations. Each representative can raise complaints when another violates previously confirmed international labor conventions. Core principles of the organization includes “an extensive process for reporting labor violations, monitoring labor conditions, and issuing recommendations on ways to resolve violations and improve working environments” (Ho, 2006). Not only does it have reporting and monitoring power, it also enjoys enforcement powers under the Article 33 of the ILO’s Constitution (ILO, 1996). The organization’s core principle is abolishment of child labor across the borders. A system of conventions within ILO has traditionally set the international labor standards. Ratification by each member state is necessary in determining such criteria. However, in 1998, the ILO introduced fundamental labor rights regardless of convention ratification: “(1) freedom of association and free collective bargaining; (2) the elimination of forced or compulsory labor; (3) the abolition of child labor; and (4) the elimination of employment discrimination” (Ho, 2006). Furthermore, elimination of child labor has gained international support in late 20th century, and the contention on the Worst Forms of Child Labor was ratified by over 150 out of 178 member states. Article 3 of ILO Convention No. 182 defines the worst forms of child labors as: (a) “All forms of slavery or practices similar to slavery, such as the sale and trafficking of children, debt bondage and serfdom and forced or compulsory labour, including forced or compulsory recruitment of children for use in armed conflict; (b) the use, procuring or offering of a child for prostitution, for the production of pornography or for pornographic performances; (c) the use, procuring or offering of a child for illicit activities, in particular for the production and trafficking of drugs as defined in the relevant intnernational treaties; (d) work which, by its nature or the circumstances in which it is carried out, is likely to harm the health, safety or morals of children.” Worst form of child labor in India Bonded child labor in India is considered as the worst form of child labor, which is a phenomenon of children working in conditions of slavery in order to pay off their debts (Smolin, 2000). There are an estimated number of fifteen million bonded child laborers. The debt is usually passed on to children from their parents. The parents have taken loans from the creditors in order to “meet subsistence needs, pay for funeral or marriage costs, or replace income lost due to illness or death” (Tucker, 1997). Due to high rates of interest charged with the debts and low wages they gain, bonded child labor has persisted for a long time. Worst of all, the debt is passed on to one generation after another. In addition to poverty, there are many other factors that led to a phenomenon of bonded labor in India. Other elements include:
“an ancient tradition of slavery and debt bondage; the lack of a concerted social welfare scheme to safeguard against hunger and illness; a noncompulsory and grossly inadequate educational system; the lack of employment opportunities and living wages for adults; an ossified stratification of occupations, with little opportunity for upward mobility or intergenerational career changes within families; corruption and indifference among government officials; and endemic societal apathy” (Tucker, 1997).
For the purpose of this paper, association between child labor and education in India will be examined. In 1950, the Indian Constitution was formed, which proposed free education for children under the age of fourteen within ten years from the commencement of the Constitution. However, less than fifty percent of Indian children are going to schools, and literacy rate is lower than forty percent among agricultural workers (Tucker, 1997). The low rate of school attendance is deeply related to poor quality of public school system. The primary public schools are inadequately funded, and teachers are often unqualified. The classes are huge, and teaching materials are outmoded. Indian government chooses to spend their educational budget to subsidize secondary and university education, while disregarding primary education (Tucker, 1997). The government focuses on expanding the nonformal education system for working children. The system allows children to have a full-time job and provides three hours of education a day. Education children receive through this system is insufficient because it only provides basic and nonformal skills. The system that is deeply embedded in many villages exacerbates child rights violations in India (Tucker, 1997).

Abolitionist Approach Major trends in international discourse on child labor include abolitionist perspective, which argues that elimination of child labor should be legally enforced in order to effectively end the practice. The abolitionists proclaim that states or external actors should directly impose policies that child labor. Bessel (1999) has referred abolitionist mechanism to the first wave of policies regarding child labor:
“The first wave has its origins in attempts to remove children from the workplace in the industrializing nations of Europe and the United States and was steadily exported around the world, particularly through the work of the International Labor Organization (ILO) since 1919.”
The ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work and its Follow-up (1998) added that,
“All members, even if they have not ratified the Conventions in question, have an obligation arising from the very fact of membership in the Organization to respect, to promote and to realize, in good faith and in accordance with the Constitution, the principles concerning the fundamental rights with are the subject of those Conventions, namely: freedom of association and the effective recognition of the right to collective bargaining, the elimination of all forms of forced or compulsory labor, the effective abolition of child labor, and the elimination of discrimination in respect of employment and occupation.”

The ILO has worked hard to implement effective prohibition on child labor; however, legal intervention sometimes does more harm than good. The abolitionist idea of eliminating child labor with legal forces benefits local families only if other sources of income are available. ILO Convention NO. 182 categorizes worst and other forms of child labor. The abolitionism suggests that the former should be abandoned if banning all forms of child labor is impossible. “The unequivocally worst form of child labor includes work that, by its nature or the circumstances in which it is carried out, hinders the physical, psychological, mental and social development of children, or is work in unhealthy and dangerous environments, or sequesters children from the society’s normal protection” (Pierik and Houwezijl, 2006). While other forms of child labor are tolerable to a certain degree, the worst form of child labor should immediately be abolished. In the document The State of the World’s Children, UNICEF (1997) noted that considering all forms of child labor as equally intolerable underplays the issue and makes the end of practice even harder to be achieved. In sum, the abolitionists believe in eradication of child labor with legal empowerment, but their approach does not apply to all forms of child labor.

Abolitionist approach in India Legislative enforcement against child labor came into action in 1993, when India was under British colonial power. The prohibition act was called the Children (Pledging of Labor) Act. Upon attaining independence, Indian government passed additional laws governing child laborers, including the Child Labor (Prohibition and Regulation) Act of 1986, which regulated work hours and working conditions. The most highlighted legal protection for children working in conditions of servitude was Bonded Labor System (Abolition) Act, which was passed in 1976 (Tucker, 1997). The Bonded Labor Act outlaws child labor system under any debt agreements. The act frees all bonded laborers, cancels any debts against them, and prohibits any new bondage agreements (Smolin, 2000). In spite of legal protections, bonded child labor is still prevalent, and prosecution is not yet strengthened. Punishments for violations against law are light and ineffective. Scarcity of legislative infrastructure is rooted in governmental apathy and corruption. Indian governments adopted abolitionist approach in a sense that they tried to abandon the worst form of child labor with legislative empowerment. Poverty and child labor are reduced to a certain extent, but prohibition policies have been less effective than they were expected (Tucker, 1997).

Protectionist Approach The second wave of policies regarding elimination of child labor is mainly characterized by intervention by external actors. In opposition to the abolitionism, the protectionists proclaim that emphasis should be focused on “efforts to improve working conditions, to protect working children from abuse and exploitation, and to provide services such as health and educational facilities” (Bessel, 1999). In the matter of providing services to working children and improving working conditions, NGOs are the major players. They do not disregard importance of legislative policies, but they maintain that prohibition policies should be enforced alongside stronger educational, service, and health infrastructure. The protectionist school is characterized by three arguments: (1) as long as extreme poverty is prevalent in a certain area, children often work out of necessity; (2) when working conditions are not harmful to children’s health and development, working experience can be beneficial to children; (3) children have a right to work. This rights-based approach suggests different strategic procedures in prohibiting child labor depending on the contexts (Bessel, 1999). Protectionist approach can be regarded as indirect policies against child labor. These policies not only address child labor itself, but they also emphasize issues connected to it. As poverty is the major determinant of child labor, policies aimed to reduce poverty are considered as the most effective in halting child labor in developing countries. As globalization introduced immense economic interdependence between developed and developing countries under the international institutions such as WTO, World Bank, and IMF, Western societies have duties to seek effective ways to end the global poverty. Therefore, it is argued that financial support to governments of the downtrodden states is one of the best policies to prevent children from going to work (Pierik and Houwerzijl, 2006) In addition, the protectionists put emphasis on building better educational infrastructure. Pierik and Houwerzijl (2006) have demonstrated negative correlation between availability of education and the occurrence of child labor, which implies that “the occurrence of child labor can be influenced indirectly by policies that reduce the costs of education, increase the accessibility of education, or increase the expected returns of education.” There are many ways to improve educational infrastructure in the peripheral states. Government or international institutions’ subsidies can reduce the cost of education. In fact, ILO and UNICEF have long been supporting education subsidies. School construction programs driven by the NGOs can also make education accessible to local children. Improvement in quality of teaching can further motivate children to return to school (Bessel, 1999). The Oportunidades program in Mexico is a good example that represents the protectionist approach. Under the program, local parents are rewarded when they send their children to schools:
“This program started in 1997 and pays parents if their children go to school; the stipend increases with the child’s age” (Pierik & Houwerzijl, 2006).
The education subsidies reach about two-thirds of what the students would make for full-time work. In addition, the families are granted additional costs for their nutrition and health. This policy is effective in preventing children from going to work, because it increases educational accessibility, and at the same time, it practically manages health and nutrition problems. The program is acclaimed for its tackling poverty, which is the root cause of child labor and educational problem. When the program raises family income, families’ dependence on children’s work is lowered. In the end, it can end the vicious cycle of poverty trap. After children receive proper education, they can enter the market as high-skilled laborers. High incomes they receive in the future gradually abolish child labor, because next generation will not face mandatory duty to work to support their families. Due to its effectiveness, many other developing countries tried to adopt similar program. However, without financial resources available to the governments, instituting the program is not feasible. In this context, cooperation between governments and NGOs is essential. After consultation with NGOs who are familiar with the local situation, governments can provide financial aid, which will effectively be put in use (Ho, 2006).

Protectionist Approach in India The program that follows the protectionist approach is called the Elimination of Child Labour Programme, which is designed for the purpose of sending working children to “special schools”, which provide nonformal education and vocational training. Families engaged in this program receive one hundred rupees and children have one daily free meal at schools:
“The one hundred rupee incentive was first initiated by the 1987 National Child Labour Policy. This policy, funded by international donor agencies (primariliy the International Programme on the Elimination of Child Labour (IPEC), of the International Labour Organization) and administered by local nongovernmental organizations, established the first special schools to provide nonformal education to working children” (Tucker, 1997).
Most often than not, external actors play significant roles in providing services or financial funds to local families. Thus, The protectionist school encourages the government to collaborate with the nongovernmental organizations. The government has resources and authority to implement the law, and the organizations facilitate implementation with trust from the grassroots. Moreover, NGOs can play a significant role as watchdog on governmental programs, and this is particularly important in India where there is a collapsed government or authority. The Elimination of Child Labour Programme is considered as a successful policy because the program served 7,000 children as of 1995 (ILO, 1996).

Conclusion The global civil society today has called for recognition of the expanding influence of the non-state actors. These actors are peoples-based institutions, which are important in providing expertise that states lack. The representatives of the grassroots mainly deal with environmental protection, gender equality, and human rights issues (Baylis, Smith, & Owens, (2011). In the case of a child labor issue, the abolitionist approach driven mainly by the governments has shown some limitations. In most cases, developing countries do not have well-constructed governmental infrastructure. Implementation of abolition act under such collapsed governments sometimes does more harm than good. Without sufficient services that lure children to go to schools, they often end up trapped in the vicious cycle of child labor. The protectionist approach is more plausible, because it seeks to reduce poverty, which is the core cause of the child labor. Even though child labor is still prevalent in India, protectionist mechanism has brought about effective reduction in numbers of child laborers. In particular, the protectionist school has addressed education, food, and family budgets as the major causes of child rights violations. As eradication of child labor in Western countries did not come in an abrupt fashion, developing countries today can gradually abolish child labor by reducing poverty and improving social welfare system (Pierik and Houwezijl, 2006). The governments and external actors such as ILO and NGOs need to collaborate. The governments have authority and resources to implement policies against child labor, and the external actors can facilitate implementation by monitoring the governmental programs (Tucker, 1997). The global campaign should be strengthened to motivate both the governments and international institutions to end the practice in collaboration. Sustainable development, which addresses fairness between developed and developing countries, can be accomplished when financial, technical, and political assistance are effectively put in place.

References
Basu, K. & Hoang Van, P., (1998). The economics of child labor. The American Economic Review, 88(3), 412-427

Baylis, J., Smith, S., & Owens, P., (2011). The globalization of world politics: an introduction to international relations. New York, NY. Oxford University Press.

Bessel, S., (1999). The politics of child labour in Indonesia: global trends and domestic policy. Pacific Affairs, 72(3), 353-371

Doepke, M. & Zilibotti, F., (2005). The macroeconomics of child labor regulation. The American Economic Review, 95(5), 1492-1524

Ho, J., (2006). The international labour organization’s role in nationaliting the international movement to abolish child labor. Chicago Journal of International Law, 7(1), 337

International Labor Organization. (1996). Retrived June 5, 2013, from http://www.ilo.org

International Labor Conference. (1998). ILO declaration on fundamental principles and rights at work and its follow-up. Eighty-sixth Session, Geneva.

International Labor Conference. (2008). ILO declaration on social justice for a fail globalization. Ninety-Seventh Session, Geneva

Pakrashi, D., (2009). Does membership in international organizations affect incidence of child labor? ProQuest Dissertations and Theses.

Pierik, R. & Houwerzijl, M., (2006). Western policies on child labor abroad. Ethics & International Affairs, 20(2), 193

Smolin, D., (2000). Strategic choices in the international campaign against child labor. Human Rights Quarterly, 22(4), 942-987

Tucker, L., (1997). Child slaves in modern India: the bonded labor problem. Human Rights Quarterly, 19(3), 572-629

UNICEF, The State of the World’s Children (1997)

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Child Labor

...What causes child labor? The term “child labor” can be defined as work that deprives children of their childhood, their potential and their dignity, and that is destructive not only to their physical but also mental development. (ILO 1996) Child labor is a pervasive problem throughout the world, but it is more severe in developing countries. Furthermore, child labor is regarded as a curse on humanity due to its impact on the normal up bringing of a child and its influence on the development of a child as a normal human being. There are many organizations, (local and international) which are working towards eradicating child labor from global society. There are various factors that conspire to drive children into employment, none of which is unique to any one country or any one family's circumstances. It is therefore very important to understand what causes children to join the work force at a very young age and under such harsh conditions. Only when we fully understand these reasons can we begin to address the problems associated with child labor. In this essay I will try and show some of the main causes of child labor. One of the root causes of child labor is poverty. (Yasin, Qasim, Ahmad Faiz 2011) Parents of many children in developing countries are extremely poor and unable to support themselves with the basic necessities, they therefore send their children to hazardous jobs. Although they know it is wrong, they have no other alternative, as they need the money...

Words: 1083 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Child Labor

...What is Child Labor? Child labor is work that harms children or keeps them from attending school. Around the world , growing gaps between rich and poor in recent decades have forced millions of young children out of school and into work. The International Labor Organization estimates that 246 million children between the ages of 5 and 17 currently work under conditions that are considered illegal, hazardous, or extremely exploitative. Underage children work at all sorts of jobs around the world, usually because they and their families are extremely poor. Large numbers of children work in commercial agriculture, fishing, manufacturing, mining, and domestic service. Some children work in illicit activities like the drug trade and prostitution or other traumatic activities such as serving as soldiers. The child is the father of the man”. Children should be imparted noble values and virtues so that they can grow up as good and responsible citizen of the country. It is indeed unfortunately that we find children being forced to wok in order earn their livelihood. Thus the hand should be used for play or studies are used for hard manual work. Thus a childhood is wasted, which comes once in life of a man. Child labor in Bangladesh, it is a very sympathetic also a great sorrow for us we are really unable to take necessary action against them to remove elegy of child labor. Somebody say Bangladesh is a developing country but actually our country is poor. Economic problems are a most...

Words: 2078 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Child Labor

...News Analysis In 2009, there was a piece of news reported by New Tang Dynasty Television informing the current situation of child labor in India. The news took advantage of real shooting on children’s working condition to indicate millions of children were deprived of childhood and engaged in detrimental jobs instead. It was acknowledged that the exploitation of child labor has been deemed as an accepted practice in India and child workers actually played an indispensable role in Indian workforce, but this would not raise public awareness and government attention. At the beginning, the TV news anchor briefly introduced the uncontrolled phenomenon of child labor in India by pointing out numerous children were compelled to work for little or no pay. Then the lens cut into the scene of an India child labor working on a variety of bangles while sitting on the shabby footstep, with the subtitle of “Child Labor Stile Rampant” on the screen. The news also provided a scope of the Indian northern state of Kolkata, which was famous for abundant bangles, depicting that a number of child workers were engaging in the bangle market under the jam-packed and disordered environment. Unexpectedly, a close shot of three smiling Indian kids with curious eyes appeared on the screen, which presented a conspicuous contrast with the subsequent interview of a slightly elder child work named Vikrantk. He worked for a bangle factory for 8 hours and only earned 35 rupees per day. He said he had no time to...

Words: 807 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Child Labor

...Playgrounds, laughter, joy, leisure and so on. Child labor is childhood destruction; children need to be children, they will have the rest of their lives as adults to work, so why rush that? Childhood is the most innocent stage in a human life. It is that phase of life where a child is nurturing, and is free from all the tensions, and health risks. Child labor existed in throughout the American and British history, as the industrial revolution moved workers from farms and home workshops into urban areas and factory work. Children were often preferred, because factory owners viewed them as more manageable, cheaper, and less likely to strike. But how did that end up? Many children died, many more were tortured and were forced to work, basically forced into slavery. So do we want that again? There is nothing wrong with children doing chores; not all work is bad for children. A child who delivers newspapers before school might actually benefit from learning how to work, gaining responsibility, and a bit of money. But what if the child is forced to work? Not paid or is poorly paid? Forced labor is any work performed against a person’s will under the threat of punishment. According to UNICEF, and Free the Child organizations, work that exceeds the min number of hours will deprive children from school, and is also physically, socially and mentally harmful for the child. Such work should therefore be eliminated.” Forced labor and child labor are closely linked. They happen in the...

Words: 595 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Child Labor

...Child labor was and is still an existing practice in the world today. Manuel, a five-year old worked at a seafood cannery in Biloxi, Mississippi, with a shrimp pail in each hand and a mountain of oyster shells behind his back. He is typical for thousands of working children in the years before the civil war, especially the turn of the century. America's army of child laborers had been growing steadily for the past century. The nation's economy was expanding. Factories, minds and mills needed plenty of cheap labor. Around 1911, more than two million American children under the age of 16 years of age were a regular part of the work force. Many of them worked twelve hours or more a day, six days a week, for pathetic wages under unhealthy and hazardous conditions. Thousands of young boys descended into dark and dangerous coal mines every day, or worked aboveground in the dust of coal breakers, picking slate from coal with torn and bleeding fingers. Small girls tended noisy machines in the spinning rooms of cotton mills, where the humid, lint-filled air made breathing difficult. They were actually kept awake by cold water being thrown in their faces. Three-year-olds could be found in the cotton fields, and twelve-year-olds on factor night shifts. Across the country, children who should have been in school or at play had to work for a living. By the early 1900's, many Americans were calling child labor "child slavery" and were demanding an end to it...

Words: 2327 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Child Labor

...Human beings have greed in their soul. They seek only profit in every work, no feeling of humanity in them for innocent face. No owner regret on their shameful act of child labor. Children who are small have no sense of “valuable papers”. Actually they don’t worth it they the necessary is education, they have hunger of fact. They have thirst of copy, pencil and bag. The parents, especially in south Asia, pretend as children are the gift of god we need to lose it else almighty will never forgive us and the same parent send their son to wash dishes of other, which is blindly correct. No, that is not blindness; money has covered their eyes and mouth, along with all sense organ that forbid them to understand their child’s pain. Making them work is largest sane in the entire universe. Children who have no knowledge of this cruel world are easily misused. They are forced to do lower class job, sometimes prostitution, which adult demand much higher cost. Child they work days and night to feed their family. They have to screw their entire childhood for their parent’s happiness. Children have sharp eyesight which is always beneficial of art work. It is less expensive to them; they have to give less food to them, they can also make children work overtime without any extra money. They can be easily frightened if they are taking rest instead of working. For instance, in a company if owner is providing food and wedge for daily. He will be benefited if he employs children; in compare to...

Words: 504 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Child Labor

...Assignment #6: Child Labor: Rights, Risks, and Realities Li-Chung Pan Boston University Metropolitan College AD746 Business Law & Regulation in a Global Environment Prof. Martin L. Saradjian February 20th, 2013 1. Child labor was used extensively before laws and legislations were enacted to abolish child labor. Nowadays, child labor is used in developing countries where child labor laws are not strictly enforced or there aren’t any child labor laws. Where child labor still exists is found in rural settings in developing countries where they are forced to work by their parents or their labor is used to repay debt incurred by their parents. Child labor is used in mostly unskilled labor and is much cheaper than adult workers. 2. Various cultural factors contribute to children working in hazardous conditions. According to “Child Labour: Rights, Risks & Realities” some ethnic and lower classes believe that some are born to rule and others are born to work. This includes children, where their lower caste excludes them from certain rights afforded to other children from a higher caste. If children from these castes drop out of school to work, it is seen as their destiny to do so. 3. The Rotary International is trying to change public attitudes of how some cultures perceive child labor. Rotary clubs around the world are trying to improve the conditions of children by fighting poverty and providing education. 4. The Convention on Rights of the Child is ratified...

Words: 275 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Child Labor

...In India, about 12% of all children between the age of 5 and 14 are engaged in child labor activities including carpet production2. They often are being trafficked from one form of labor into another, as with girls from rural Nepal, who are recruited to work in carpet factories but are then trafficked into the sex industry over the border in India3. What is child labor? Child labor is characterized as a regular use of children less than 14 years of age for hard manual labor. Usually hiring children is illegal, but that doesn’t stop a lot of factories, especially in third world countries, to hire them anyways. The worst form of child labor is the “bonded labor”. Bonded labor means that children give their children away (they bond them) because they owe people money. These children work to pay off their parents deeds and are being enslaved and forcibly recruited. Overall one in six children under the age of 14 (about 16% of all children in this age group) is involved in child labor in the world4. Discussing those numbers, we have to keep in mind that child labor is different from child work. According to UNICEF (United Nations Children’s fund), children that want to participate in work as an economic activity, and if it doesn’t negatively affect their health, development or education actually can do so. Light work is permitted from the age of 12 years under ILO Convention No.138. Child labor refers to children working in contravention of ILO standards contained in Conventions...

Words: 947 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Child Labor in Pakistan

...Sec 14 4th January 2012 Child Labor Is Child Labor Acceptable in Pakistan? Child labor is a global phenomenon that is defined as the children working under the age of 14 or 16 years. While most of the developed world has been able to overcome with this so-called social evil, child labor has been prevailing in almost all of the developing countries. The International Labor Organization (ILO) and Human Rights Organizations have been active in eliminating the practice of child labor through the agreement on the protection of the rights of children and the labor. The issue of child labor came into consideration in Pakistan when most of the European countries in 1990s declared a boycott on the goods exported by developing countries that involved child labor. As a result, child labor laws were passed in Pakistan in 1991 which banned child labor in certain manufacturing sectors. According to Federal Bureau of Statistics, a survey funded by IPEC (International Program on the Elimination of Child Labor) showed that in 2010, the working children in Pakistan numbered to 3.8 million (Arshad n.p). Although it is argued that child labor deprives children from education and leads to immoral acts such as exploitation and child abuse, it can be justified in Pakistan considering the current economic situation and educational infrastructure in the country and because it could give some economic and social benefits to the nation; therefore, the ban against child labor may have drastic effects...

Words: 3640 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Child Labor

...Child Labor: Stymieing a Global Pandemic Axia College Ericka Boice, Cherie Brown, and LaKeisha Wilkerson August 30, 2010 Child labor is a serious moral issue that illegally employs children below the age of 15, which means that one is not under the sole responsibility of parents or illegal guardians. Child labor has been an invasive problem throughout the global economy for a very long time. It first appeared with the development of domestic systems and this problem exists mostly in foreign and developing countries such as Mexico, Asia, India, and Africa. There is an estimated 250 million child workers, between ages 5 to 14. Some are working fulltime and some part-time. Child Labor has been one of the biggest issues around the world because it puts children in unfavorable danger. The awareness that globalization is leading towards child exploitation is a very serious matter for international businesses. This kind of labor is damaging and negative towards the health of children. You can very well say a child’s life in this matter is diminishing towards their future because it is impossible for children to receive enrichment towards an education or enjoy a proper childhood. Child Labor affects the global community because for one it is not an easy issue to resolve and it has been going on for a very long time in so many countries. It is found many issues involving child labor deals with children who are working because their families are very poor. The parent...

Words: 1527 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Child Labor

...Child Labor Today, Child Labor laws exist to ensure children are able to get an education and be employed under safe conditions. History tells a different story to the meaning of child labor. History explains how the industrial revolution changed the lives of young children during this time. Children as young as four years old were put to work, some worked under very hazardous conditions and were treated cruely. According to the Unicef website,” many children are put to work in ways that often interfere with their education, drains their childhood of joy, and crushes their right to normal physical and mental development”. This paper examines the history of child labor, the hazardous jobs these children endured, and the medical conditions resulting from such conditions. In addition, this paper examines meetings held within communities, and among organizational leaders on both the state at national levels addressing child labor issues and how to combat them.   In the United States company owners use to hire children to work in factories because they were not hard to work with.  The children would listen and do what they had to.  By 1900 the factories moved south.  Lots of children were hired in factories that dealt with textiles, agriculture and many others.  During the twentieth century the number of child labor increased.  The National Child Labor Organization worked to end child labor.  They also worked to get children free education.  In 1938 the government took control...

Words: 1768 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Child Labor

...Child Labor Melinda Trevathan Global Business Management Dr. Wilson June 5, 2015 Abstract Generally, child labor is described as a broad term that covers a substantial mixture between and within countries in the nature of undertakings in which children play a part. More specifically, child labor is described as economic undertakings that may be harmful or lethal to the welfare of children. It may be difficult to imagine, where some children are chained to factory floors working in horrific conditions, forced into prostitution or even child-forced soldiers. Unfortunately, some countries do not hold the same values as developed or developing nations, where forced or voluntary child labor is regarded as a form of child abuse. It mostly depends on the type of work and what type of work environment that encircles the child or children (Edmonds & Pavcnik, 2005). Keywords: introduction, poverty, child labor statistics, globalization, conclusion Introduction Generally, child labor is described as a broad term that covers a substantial mixture between and within countries in the nature of undertakings in which children play a part. More specifically, child labor is described as economic undertakings that may be harmful or lethal to the welfare of children. It may be difficult to imagine, where some children are chained to factory floors working in horrific conditions, forced into prostitution or even child-forced soldiers. Unfortunately, some countries do not...

Words: 3975 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Child Labor

...Child Labor: Threatening the economy and well-being of children Child labor has existed throughout American history and throughout the world for many years. A quote from Lewis Hine in 1980 states: "There is work that profits children, and there is work that brings profits only to employers. The object of employing children is not to train them, but to get high profits from their work.” As factories started to assemble, most owners preferred children as their workers because the owners thought them as “more manageable, cheaper and less likely to strike.” The industries children usually worked for were mines, glass factories, textiles, agriculture, canneries, home industries, newsboys, messengers, bootblack and peddlers. During the Industrial Revolution, children at four years old were employed and dealing with dangerous and sometimes fatal working conditions. Now, because of new child labor laws in the United States, industries are going overseas to produce their product in countries that still use child labor. Developed countries consider these actions to be human rights violations and are illegal, while some undeveloped countries will allow or tolerate child labor. These children who are in these factories in different countries are costing the company less because of their wages, when they could have their factories in the States, producing jobs and cash flow in our economy. Child labor violates the common good by threatening the long-term growth of the economy and the well-being...

Words: 3347 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Child Labor

...Child Labor Today, Child Labor laws exist to ensure children are able to get an education and be employed under safe conditions. History tells a different story to the meaning of child labor. History explains how the industrial revolution changed the lives of young children during this time. Children as young as four years old were put to work, some worked under very hazardous conditions and were treated cruely. According to the Unicef website,” many children are put to work in ways that often interfere with their education, drains their childhood of joy, and crushes their right to normal physical and mental development”. This paper examines the history of child labor, the hazardous jobs these children endured, and the medical conditions resulting from such conditions. In addition, this paper examines meetings held within communities, and among organizational leaders on both the state at national levels addressing child labor issues and how to combat them.   In the United States company owners use to hire children to work in factories because they were not hard to work with.  The children would listen and do what they had to.  By 1900 the factories moved south.  Lots of children were hired in factories that dealt with textiles, agriculture and many others.  During the twentieth century the number of child labor increased.  The National Child Labor Organization worked to end child labor.  They also worked to get children free education.  In 1938 the government took control...

Words: 1769 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Child Labor

...There was a internal audit that was conducted on Apple, they found that 106 children were working at more than 10 factories creating Apple products in the past year alone according to The Guardian. (n.d.). Hiring children means that the child labor laws are being violated. Also this is morally wrong and not for the greater good of the people. Apple conducted an investigation on it's suppliers. The result of that investigation was unexpected. They found out that children were being recruited using fake identity papers. Child labor is obvious because of the harsh working conditions provided by Apple. Most of the children worked for Chinese companies that made supplies for apple. The children were under the age of 16; they employed about 74 children out of the 106 total according to The Guardian. (n.d.). Most of the cases are from 2013, and total there have been 70 companies in Apple's supply chain that have employed children according to The Guardian. (n.d.). There has been a host of other events happening when the whistle was blown so to speak. There have been cases of workers committing suicide, and also deadly explosions at some of the supply chains. This is relevant because workers slowly began to figure out that children were being used for labor, and these were some of the consequences. The children had to lift heavy equipment, and some of them were subject to pregnancy tests as well. If the children got into trouble while working they would be punished by having their pay...

Words: 4443 - Pages: 18